Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. See our User Agreement and Privacy Policy.

Slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. See our Privacy Policy and User Agreement for details.

Like this presentation? Why not share!

- The dual self model in economics: M... by Russell James 6902 views
- Diversification Bias by Russell James 3350 views
- Hyperbolic Discounting & Projection... by Russell James 7256 views
- Introduction to Decision-Making & E... by Russell James 7662 views
- Pre-Commitment Strategies in Behavi... by Russell James 2098 views
- The dual self model of choice in no... by Russell James 2207 views

3,459 views

3,246 views

3,246 views

Published on

An introduction to the economic concept of the dual self-consumer

License: CC Attribution-ShareAlike License

No Downloads

Total views

3,459

On SlideShare

0

From Embeds

0

Number of Embeds

11

Shares

0

Downloads

186

Comments

0

Likes

3

No embeds

No notes for slide

- 1. Introduction to the dual-self model of choice<br />Dr. Russell James III<br />Texas Tech University<br />
- 2. An alternative model<br />Previous discussion shows that the rational, utility-maximizing assumption for consumers is not always true.<br />So, now what?<br />Throw it out the door?<br />But, it often makes accurate predictions<br />A modification from behavioral economics<br />
- 3. “Our theory proposes that many sorts of decision problems should be viewed as a game between a sequence of short-run impulsive selves and a long-run patient self.”<br />Drew Fudenburg (Harvard U.) and David K. Levine (Washington U.), 2006, A dual-self model of impulse control. American Economic Review, 96(5), 1449-1476.<br />
- 4. Fudenberg & Levine (2006)<br />Long-run (patient) self<br /><ul><li>This side tries to maximize utility across time</li></ul>Short-run (impulsive) selves<br /><ul><li>Sequential selves that exist only for a brief time
- 5. Each cares only about immediate experience</li></li></ul><li>Experiment Time!<br />This is real. One of you will be picked to receive one of the choices you selected.<br />
- 6. Choice One<br />Pick one<br />You can receive $1.00 (cash) on the second to last day of this class.<br />You can receive $1.05 (cash) on the last day of this class.<br />
- 7. Choice Two<br />Pick one. One week prior to the last day of class, you can have during class either<br />Tangerine<br />Chocolate Bar<br />The dollar value of both is identical. (Of course, the tangerine is a healthier choice.)<br />
- 8. It’s now time!<br />Get ready, someone is about to get a nice giveaway!<br />
- 9. Choice Three<br />Pick one. Right now, you can have either<br />Tangerine<br />Chocolate Bar<br />The dollar value of both is identical. (Of course, the tangerine is a healthier choice.)<br />
- 10. Choice Four<br />Pick one<br />You can receive $1.00 (cash) right now.<br />You can receive $1.05 (cash) during the next meeting of this class.<br />
- 11. Research Results<br />Read & van Leeuwen (1998). 200 participants. People who were not hungry, chose the unhealthy snack for delivery in one week<br /> 26% of the time<br />They chose the unhealthy snack for immediate consumption<br /> 70% of the time<br />←Next Week<br />Right Now -> <br />26%<br />70%<br />
- 12. Dual-self<br />Long-run (patient) self<br /><ul><li>This side tries to maximize utility across time</li></ul>Short-run (impulsive) selves<br /><ul><li>Sequential selves that exist only for a brief time
- 13. Each cares only about immediate experience</li></li></ul><li>Discussion<br />Short-run (impulsive) selves<br />Does the short-run self care about<br /><ul><li>Future consumption next week?
- 14. Future health consequences?
- 15. Immediate consumption choice?</li></ul>←Next Week<br />Right Now -> <br />26%<br />70%<br />
- 16. Discussion<br />Discuss with a neighbor and vote in a moment.<br />Does this result fit better with simple rational decision-making or a two-system approach? <br />Simple rational decision making<br />Two system “dual-self” decision making <br /> (long-run/patient self and short-run/impulsive selves)<br />←Next Week<br />Right Now -> <br />26%<br />70%<br />
- 17. Class vote comparison<br />How many voted for chocolate at the end of the semester?<br />Fall 2009 – 62.7% (n=86)<br />How many voted for chocolate right now?<br />Fall 2009 – 64.8% (n=74)<br />
- 18. Hyperbolic discounting<br />Would you rather receive $100 right now or $101 in a week? Most people choose $100 right now. <br />But when the choice is between $100 a year from now and $101 in a year and a week from now, most people choose $101 in a year and a week. <br />This is time inconsistent, as both choices involve delaying by one week for $1.<br />Note also that choosing $100 right now implies an interest rate charge of 1% per week or APR of 52%<br />
- 19. Discussion<br />Short-run (impulsive) selves<br />Does the short-run self care about<br /><ul><li>Immediate money?
- 20. Two different future money options? </li></ul>Now <br />v. later<br />Later v. <br />much later<br />
- 21. Class vote comparison<br />How many voted to take the $1 on the second to last day of the class (instead of $1.05 on the last day)?<br />Fall ‘09: 32.2% (n=87)<br />How many voted to take the $1 right now (instead of $1.05 in the next class meeting)?<br />Fall ‘09: 66.3% (n=86)<br />What is the implied interest rate being charged to those who chose the immediate $1?<br />Next class in 2 days. 5% difference. APR = (365/2) X 5% ≈912%<br />
- 22. Thoughts to ponder<br />Could the willingness of some to ignore a 920% interest rate for immediate reward have implications for consumer use of credit?<br />Could the variations in the healthiness of food choices have implications for consumer food choices?<br />More later…<br />
- 23. Slides by: <br />Russell James III, J.D., Ph.D., CFP®<br />Associate Professor <br />Division of Personal Financial Planning <br />Texas Tech University<br />russell.james@ttu.edu<br />Please use these slides! <br />If you think you might use anything here in a classroom, please CLICK HEREto let me know. Thanks!<br />The outline for this behavioral economics series is at <br />http://www.slideshare.net/rnja8c/outline-for-behavioral-economics-course-component <br />

No public clipboards found for this slide

Be the first to comment