SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 1
Download to read offline
Judging Rubric

Team/Project Name:

 Gameplay
 How good was the game concept/story? Was the gameplay                 1   2   3   4   5
 intuitive? Enjoyable? Were the game mechanics well designed and
 implemented?


 How engaging was the game? Is it likely to keep players interested,   1   2   3   4   5
 as well as attract new players?



 Aesthetics
 Graphic design                                                        1   2   3   4   5


 Sound design                                                          1   2   3   4   5



 Social Change
 How relevant is this game to its chosen social cause?                 1   2   3   4   5


 How effectively does this game support or communicate this cause?     1   2   3   4   5



 Complexity and Future
 How much progress was made during the event? How creative was
 the solution presented? Is the solution complete, or is there still   1   2   3   4   5
 much work to be done?


 How prepared, and how likely, is this team to further develop this    1   2   3   4   5
 project after the event?



Total Score (sum):

Notes:

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (6)

Gameplay Concept Tool
Gameplay Concept ToolGameplay Concept Tool
Gameplay Concept Tool
 
Building Gameplay
Building GameplayBuilding Gameplay
Building Gameplay
 
How it's made: Online Games
How it's made: Online GamesHow it's made: Online Games
How it's made: Online Games
 
Communities: Bridging the Gap
Communities: Bridging the GapCommunities: Bridging the Gap
Communities: Bridging the Gap
 
Go for Engagement by David Vermeir
Go for Engagement by David VermeirGo for Engagement by David Vermeir
Go for Engagement by David Vermeir
 
Pleasure, Flow, and Meaning in Design
Pleasure, Flow, and Meaning in DesignPleasure, Flow, and Meaning in Design
Pleasure, Flow, and Meaning in Design
 

Similar to Judging criteria_2012

ATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game Design
ATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game DesignATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game Design
ATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game DesignSharon Boller
 
Play to Learn Workshop Slides
Play to Learn Workshop SlidesPlay to Learn Workshop Slides
Play to Learn Workshop SlidesKarl Kapp
 
Playtesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An Coppens
Playtesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An CoppensPlaytesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An Coppens
Playtesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An CoppensAn Coppens
 
Play to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get Results
Play to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get ResultsPlay to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get Results
Play to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get ResultsHRDQ-U
 
Board Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century Learner
Board Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century LearnerBoard Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century Learner
Board Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century LearnerBecky Palgi
 
A Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and Results
A Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and ResultsA Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and Results
A Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and ResultsSharon Boller
 
Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)
Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)
Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)David Farrell
 
LAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and Analysis
LAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and AnalysisLAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and Analysis
LAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and AnalysisDavid Mullich
 
LTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a Time
LTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a TimeLTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a Time
LTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a TimeAndy Petroski
 
Gamification and Usability
Gamification and UsabilityGamification and Usability
Gamification and UsabilityDudi Peles
 
UPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi Peles
UPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi PelesUPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi Peles
UPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi PelesOhad Inbar
 
Games design notes
Games design notesGames design notes
Games design notesamme77
 
Monkeytalk spring 2015 - Gamification
Monkeytalk spring 2015 - GamificationMonkeytalk spring 2015 - Gamification
Monkeytalk spring 2015 - GamificationChristophe Benoit
 
5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business
5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business
5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Businessollisotamaa
 
Game Design Workshop @ Naresuan University
Game Design Workshop @ Naresuan UniversityGame Design Workshop @ Naresuan University
Game Design Workshop @ Naresuan UniversityCarolina Islas Sedano
 
Coursera Reflections on Gamification
Coursera Reflections on GamificationCoursera Reflections on Gamification
Coursera Reflections on Gamificationanitadeciannibrown
 
"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland
"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland
"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions PortlandCarolyn Chandler
 
Games for Change Methodology
Games for Change MethodologyGames for Change Methodology
Games for Change MethodologyGames for Change
 

Similar to Judging criteria_2012 (20)

ATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game Design
ATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game DesignATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game Design
ATD 2017 Play Games to Learn Game Design
 
Play to Learn Workshop Slides
Play to Learn Workshop SlidesPlay to Learn Workshop Slides
Play to Learn Workshop Slides
 
Playtesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An Coppens
Playtesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An CoppensPlaytesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An Coppens
Playtesting presentation for Gamification Europe by An Coppens
 
Play to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get Results
Play to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get ResultsPlay to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get Results
Play to Learn: Learning Games and Gamification that Get Results
 
Board Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century Learner
Board Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century LearnerBoard Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century Learner
Board Game Questions Based on AASL Standards for the 21st Century Learner
 
A Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and Results
A Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and ResultsA Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and Results
A Primer On Play: How to use Games for Learning and Results
 
Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)
Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)
Educational Games Design (STEG10 Keynote)
 
LAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and Analysis
LAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and AnalysisLAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and Analysis
LAFS SVI Level 3 - Game Design and Analysis
 
LTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a Time
LTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a TimeLTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a Time
LTMS 531 Week 4: Once Upon a Time
 
Gamification and Usability
Gamification and UsabilityGamification and Usability
Gamification and Usability
 
UPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi Peles
UPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi PelesUPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi Peles
UPA Israel event 2011 – Dudi Peles
 
Games design notes
Games design notesGames design notes
Games design notes
 
Monkeytalk spring 2015 - Gamification
Monkeytalk spring 2015 - GamificationMonkeytalk spring 2015 - Gamification
Monkeytalk spring 2015 - Gamification
 
5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business
5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business
5 Questions To Ask About Your Games Business
 
Game Design Workshop @ Naresuan University
Game Design Workshop @ Naresuan UniversityGame Design Workshop @ Naresuan University
Game Design Workshop @ Naresuan University
 
2019 dhdownunder game prototyping workshop
2019 dhdownunder game prototyping workshop2019 dhdownunder game prototyping workshop
2019 dhdownunder game prototyping workshop
 
Coursera Reflections on Gamification
Coursera Reflections on GamificationCoursera Reflections on Gamification
Coursera Reflections on Gamification
 
Collaborative Games
Collaborative GamesCollaborative Games
Collaborative Games
 
"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland
"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland
"Play to Change" Workshop - WebVisions Portland
 
Games for Change Methodology
Games for Change MethodologyGames for Change Methodology
Games for Change Methodology
 

Judging criteria_2012

  • 1. Judging Rubric Team/Project Name: Gameplay How good was the game concept/story? Was the gameplay 1 2 3 4 5 intuitive? Enjoyable? Were the game mechanics well designed and implemented? How engaging was the game? Is it likely to keep players interested, 1 2 3 4 5 as well as attract new players? Aesthetics Graphic design 1 2 3 4 5 Sound design 1 2 3 4 5 Social Change How relevant is this game to its chosen social cause? 1 2 3 4 5 How effectively does this game support or communicate this cause? 1 2 3 4 5 Complexity and Future How much progress was made during the event? How creative was the solution presented? Is the solution complete, or is there still 1 2 3 4 5 much work to be done? How prepared, and how likely, is this team to further develop this 1 2 3 4 5 project after the event? Total Score (sum): Notes: