Wikipedia and
Higher Education
Dr. Robert E. Cummings
Associate Professor of English, University of Mississippi
SLAM Fello...
Two Parts to This Presentation
Part One:
The Role of Wikipedia in
Higher Education
Part Two:
Some examples of
successful a...
Part One: The Four Phases of Higher
Education’s Engagement with
Wikipedia
1. Understanding Wikipedia as a source (2001 – p...
1. Higher Education
Understanding Wikipedia
as a Source
Wikipedia first appears on
15 January, 2001, as an
alternative to ...
1. Higher Education
Understanding Wikipedia
as a Source
Higher Education begins
to take notice of
Wikipedia.
“First” examp...
1. Higher Education
Understanding Wikipedia
as a Source
Which is soon followed by
its banishment:
February 2007: Middlebur...
2. Wikipedia as a teaching tool
List of Institutions Currently Registered as Teaching with
Wikipedia:
https://en.wikipedia...
3. Wikipedia as the public face
of research
At its 2011 meeting, the
Association for
Psychological Science
urged its membe...
3. Wikipedia as the public face
of research
After reading articles on psychology on Wikipedia, Banaji
observed that “They ...
3. Wikipedia as the public face
of research
Disciplines -- even in “high
stakes” areas – start to
realize through their
Wi...
4. Wikipedia as identity site for
disciplines ?
As the academy begins to understand the expanding role
for Wikipedia and t...
Getting Started:
A Model for Teaching
with Wikipedia
Consider
your
Course
Learning
Objectives
Determine
Course
Topic to
Ta...
Step 1 of 7
Consider Your Course Learning
Objectives or Outcomes
How will teaching with Wikipedia support your course
lear...
Step 1 of 7
Consider Your Course Learning
Objectives or Outcomes
Example:
In my first-year writing course, my course outco...
Step 2 of 7
Consider The Course Content You Would
Like Students to Engage on Wikipedia
How will teaching with Wikipedia su...
Step 2 of 7
Consider The Course Content You Would
Like Students to Engage on Wikipedia
Example:
In my WRIT 101 course, I c...
Step 3 of 7
Introduce Students to
the Wikipedia Environment
Give students an opportunity to express their experience,
atti...
Step 3 of 7
Introduce Students to
the Wikipedia Environment
Review the Five Pillars of Wikipedia:
1. Wikipedia is an encyc...
Step 3 of 7
Introduce Students to
the Wikipedia Environment
Examples:
Students writing essays, and simultaneously violatin...
Step 4 of 7
Register Your Course with the Wikipedia
Education Program
Visit the Wikipedia Education Program Page.
Benefits...
Step 5 of 7
Decide How Your Class Project Will
Contribute to Wikipedia
Determine the overall framework of your Wikipedia
a...
Step 6 of 7
Locate the content on Wikipedia and propose
improvements in class, and online
In the assignment, design a meth...
Step 7 of 7
Design Reflection
In my Wikipedia assignments, I include reflection at the
end of the sequence.
Reflection all...
Some Questions . . .
Why not Wikiversity?
Whither OER? Why won’t Wikipedia replace all classroom
content? (cf. university ...
Some Resources . . .
Wiki Ed Foundation
Teaching with Wikipedia Listserv
http://outreach.wikimedia.org/wiki/Using_Wikipedi...
Closing Thought
It is not an easy task to overcome the prejudices against Wikipedia
in academic circles, but accomplishing...
Works Cited
Banaji, Mahzarin. Photo. From The Project on Law and Mind Sciences. 2008.
Web. 14 Feb. 2104.
--.
http://www.ps...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Wikipedia and Higher Education: Teaching with Wikipedia

848

Published on

Presentation on Wikipedi and Higher Education given at University of Sydney Writing Hub during symposium on teaching with Wikipedia.

Published in: Education, Technology
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
848
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
5
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
14
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Wikipedia and Higher Education: Teaching with Wikipedia

  1. 1. Wikipedia and Higher Education Dr. Robert E. Cummings Associate Professor of English, University of Mississippi SLAM Fellow, University of Sydney US Fulbright Senior Specialist in OER
  2. 2. Two Parts to This Presentation Part One: The Role of Wikipedia in Higher Education Part Two: Some examples of successful assignments teaching with Wikipedia from students and teachers around the world
  3. 3. Part One: The Four Phases of Higher Education’s Engagement with Wikipedia 1. Understanding Wikipedia as a source (2001 – present) 2. Wikipedia as a teaching tool (2003-present) 3. Wikipedia as the public face of research (2011 – present) 4. Wikipedia as identity site for disciplines (?)
  4. 4. 1. Higher Education Understanding Wikipedia as a Source Wikipedia first appears on 15 January, 2001, as an alternative to Nupedia. Nupedia had been an online, peer-reviewed encyclopedia project which suffered from lack of contributions. With little to lose, Jimmy Wales, et al., decided to open the gates and allow anyone to contribute to the encyclopedia. And content exploded.
  5. 5. 1. Higher Education Understanding Wikipedia as a Source Higher Education begins to take notice of Wikipedia. “First” example of higher education engagement with Wikipedia: 11 July 2003. Andrew Lih (“Fuzzheado”) teaches a course “You’ve Got Mail: Interactive Media, News, and Communication” at University of Hong Kong.
  6. 6. 1. Higher Education Understanding Wikipedia as a Source Which is soon followed by its banishment: February 2007: Middlebury History Department bans Wikipedia citations in student papers.
  7. 7. 2. Wikipedia as a teaching tool List of Institutions Currently Registered as Teaching with Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Institutions
  8. 8. 3. Wikipedia as the public face of research At its 2011 meeting, the Association for Psychological Science urged its members to begin editing Wikipedia to ensure “represents psychology fully and accurately.” Mahzarin R. Banaji, a psychology professor at Harvard University, stated that she knows it will be difficult to engage academics in editing Wikipedia. Photo. From The Project on Law and Mind Sciences. 2008.
  9. 9. 3. Wikipedia as the public face of research After reading articles on psychology on Wikipedia, Banaji observed that “They were really old, out-of-date stuff.” But Wikipedia gets 13 million visitors a day, so these inaccuracies, she realized, were the public face of Psychology, far more than any professional journal. Of 5,500 psychology articles in the online reference, only nine have been rated as good by Wikipedia’s peer- assessment process, according to the psychology association.
  10. 10. 3. Wikipedia as the public face of research Disciplines -- even in “high stakes” areas – start to realize through their Wikipedia pedagogy that public access to information is vital to their professions. Professor Arnin Azzam’s course teaches future medical professionals how to edit Wikipedia. “As these students are going to become the next generation of health care providers we need them to be able to communicate in language that the general population understands”
  11. 11. 4. Wikipedia as identity site for disciplines ? As the academy begins to understand the expanding role for Wikipedia and the face of public knowledge, I predict that disciplines will become more organized in engaging editors. As the public’s expectation and appetite for authority – bolstered by academic presence – grows within Wikipedia, I predict that disciplines will begin to compare their presences on Wikipedia. Disciplines which are more oriented to providing accurate public knowledge will move first. As their awareness of their relative successes grows, they will compete amongst themselves to achieve the best presence.
  12. 12. Getting Started: A Model for Teaching with Wikipedia Consider your Course Learning Objectives Determine Course Topic to Take to Wikipedia Teach Students the Wikipedia Context through Five Pillars: * Encyclopedia * NPOV *CC-BY-SA * Civility and Community *Be Bold Register your class with Education Program Locate the content on Wikipedia and propose improvements in class, and online: copy edit? Extend a stub? Take an article to the next level? Translate? Write a requested article? Practice making those improvements in your sandbox while awaiting feedback Make those improvement s Reflect on the lessons learned, as they relate to to . . .
  13. 13. Step 1 of 7 Consider Your Course Learning Objectives or Outcomes How will teaching with Wikipedia support your course learning outcomes? Almost all Wikipedia assignments are keyed off of student “mastery” of your course content in some way. Once students are on the way toward achieving a course outcome, their experience in Wikipedia can reinforce their progress. Activity: Step 1 on your worksheet
  14. 14. Step 1 of 7 Consider Your Course Learning Objectives or Outcomes Example: In my first-year writing course, my course outcomes are: Writing Process: Students will demonstrate writing as a process that requires brainstorming, drafting, revising, editing, and proofreading. Exploration and Argument: Students will use writing to respond to readings, explore unfamiliar ideas, question thinking different from their own, reflect on personal experiences, and develop sound arguments. Purposes and Audience: Students will produce writing suitable for a variety of purposes, with an emphasis on academic purposes. Research: Students will integrate primary sources with their own ideas through summary, paraphrase, and quotation, and document those sources properly. Conventions and Mechanics: Students will produce writing that is free of serious grammatical and mechanical errors.
  15. 15. Step 2 of 7 Consider The Course Content You Would Like Students to Engage on Wikipedia How will teaching with Wikipedia support your course learning outcomes? At some point in your learning outcomes, students will have obtained a level of working engagement with your course content. They will not be experts, but they will know more than most of the public. All teaching with Wikipedia works by reinforcing a student’s developing expertise with your course content. There are several types of Wikipedia assignments, but all rely on a student’s comparative knowledge advantage in you course content. Activity: Step 2 on your worksheet
  16. 16. Step 2 of 7 Consider The Course Content You Would Like Students to Engage on Wikipedia Example: In my WRIT 101 course, I chose for my students to work with film pages on Wikipedia. They were allowed to choose a film that interested them, and they could work in groups, or as individuals. Students were not experts in film. However, after some research in to the film of their choosing, they knew more about their chosen film than most of the public.
  17. 17. Step 3 of 7 Introduce Students to the Wikipedia Environment Give students an opportunity to express their experience, attitudes, and background with Wikipedia, both inside and outside the classroom. Remind students that the purpose of a university education is to move them from being “information consumers” to “information producers” and that writing in Wikipedia is an opportunity to try their hand at producing information which the public will find valuable. Assure students that you (and Wiki Ed ambassadors) are there to help and support them throughout the project. Activity: Step 3a on your worksheet
  18. 18. Step 3 of 7 Introduce Students to the Wikipedia Environment Review the Five Pillars of Wikipedia: 1. Wikipedia is an encyclopedia. 2. Wikipedia is written from a neutral point of view. 3. Wikipedia is free content that anyone can edit, use, modify, and distribute. 4. Editors should treat each other with respect and civility. 5. Wikipedia does not have firm rules. Activity: Step 3b on your worksheet
  19. 19. Step 3 of 7 Introduce Students to the Wikipedia Environment Examples: Students writing essays, and simultaneously violating (1) no original research, (2) NPOV and (3) purpose of an encyclopedia. Students failing to accord due weight. Students not offering sufficient citations. Students plagiarizing. Biting the newcomers.
  20. 20. Step 4 of 7 Register Your Course with the Wikipedia Education Program Visit the Wikipedia Education Program Page. Benefits include online ambassadors for your course interaction with Wikipedia, and more structure for your course page. Or, alternatively, post a notice of your course on the School and University Projects page.
  21. 21. Step 5 of 7 Decide How Your Class Project Will Contribute to Wikipedia Determine the overall framework of your Wikipedia assignment. Here are a few common types (cf. Case Studies pamphlet): copy edit? Extend a stub? Take an article to the next level? Translate? Write a requested article?
  22. 22. Step 6 of 7 Locate the content on Wikipedia and propose improvements in class, and online In the assignment, design a method for students to practice and propose their edits. The process is generally: 1. Identify and evaluate the article 2. Propose the edits to the class 3. Propose the edits to the Wikipedia editing community via the article’s talk page 4. Practice the edits in a sandbox (attached to the user page) 5. Make the edits!
  23. 23. Step 7 of 7 Design Reflection In my Wikipedia assignments, I include reflection at the end of the sequence. Reflection allows students to express their opinions about any aspect of the assignment, but, more meaningfully, it allows them to make connections between their editing experience and the value it provides them, sometimes in terms of SLOs, but other times more broadly. Students’ unit grades are calculated based on their participation in the overall process – NOT whether or not their proposed edits were retained by Wikipedia.
  24. 24. Some Questions . . . Why not Wikiversity? Whither OER? Why won’t Wikipedia replace all classroom content? (cf. university model from Israel of simply challenge testing students who read and review Wikipedia articles.)
  25. 25. Some Resources . . . Wiki Ed Foundation Teaching with Wikipedia Listserv http://outreach.wikimedia.org/wiki/Using_Wikipedia_as_a_teaching_tool_in_higher_education_% 28Bookshelf%29/Introduction:_Using_Wikipedia_as_a_teaching_tool_in_higher_education Wikipedia Education Program: http://outreach.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_Education_Program Logan, Sandal, Gardner, Manske and Bateman. “Ten Simple Rules for Editing Wikipedia.” Plos Computational Biology 6(9). (2010). http://www.ploscompbiol.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pcbi.1000941 Wikipedia Education Program Newsletter http://outreach.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_Education_Program/News
  26. 26. Closing Thought It is not an easy task to overcome the prejudices against Wikipedia in academic circles, but accomplishing that will serve us all and solidify an important new layer of knowledge in the online- information ecosystem. Wikipedia's first decade was marked by its meteoric rise. Let's mark its second decade by its integration into the formal research process. --Casper Grathwohl Vice President and Publisher of Digital and Reference Content Oxford University Press “Wikipedia Comes of Age.” Chronicle of Higher Education 7 January 2011
  27. 27. Works Cited Banaji, Mahzarin. Photo. From The Project on Law and Mind Sciences. 2008. Web. 14 Feb. 2104. --. http://www.psychologicalscience.org/index.php/publications/observer/2010/dec ember-10/anyone-can-edit-wikipedia-have-you.html Cohen, Norm. “A History Department Bans Citing Wikipedia as a Research Source.” The New York Times. 21 Feb. 2007.Web. 14 Feb. 2014. Fischman, Josh. “Academics, in New Move, Begin to Work with Wikipedia.” Chronicle of Higher Education. Wired Campus Blog. 28 May 2011. Web. 14 Feb. 2014. Lih, Andrew, Deryck Chan, and Emily Temple-Wood. “Ten years of Wikipedia outreach in Hong Kong.” Wikimania 2013 , The Free Encyclopedia. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 11 Feb. 2014. Web. 14 Feb. 2014.
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×