Ingilab Ahmadov - PWYP Montreal Conference 2009
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Ingilab Ahmadov - PWYP Montreal Conference 2009



Civil Society Successes and Challenges: Stories from the Ground

Civil Society Successes and Challenges: Stories from the Ground

Ingilab Ahmadov, Public Finance Monitoring Centre, Azerbaijan



Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



0 Embeds 0

No embeds



Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

Ingilab Ahmadov - PWYP Montreal Conference 2009 Ingilab Ahmadov - PWYP Montreal Conference 2009 Presentation Transcript

  • Azerbaijani EITI : thorny path towards transparency Dr. Ingilab Ahmadov Public Finance Monitoring Center (Baku) Montreal, 16 th November 2009
  • Background
    • Azerbaijan is the first EITI pilot country ( 2003 )
    • Azerbaijan is the most reporting country ( 11reports )
    • Azerbaijan is the first compliant status country ( 2009 )
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • But Azerbaijan EITI reporting is pretty modest… Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov But Azerbaijan EITI reporting is pretty modest…
  • What is next?
    • Short term target:
    • Company to Company reporting
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • What is next?
    • Long term target:
    • Expanding to :
    • transportation
    • refinery processing
    • license acquisition and contract
    • state expenditures
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • Advantages
    • Covering totally oil & gas companies and successfully shifting to gold sector payment
    • No denial on information to audit company from any extractive companies so far
    • Most regular payment for audit company fee by government and companies
    • Absence of any unexplained discrepancy between government and companies’ reports
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • Disadvantages
    • Reporting successfully develops in breadth, rather than in deepness
    • It’s impossible to promulgate name of the company, even, who made mistakes in reporting templates filling (due to MoU term)
    • Absence of gladly willingness of Companies on CSO cooperation within EITI
    • Government can not impact on Companies in moving to individual reporting
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • What does report afford?
    • Publicly availability of full info related to oil & gas companies’ payment to Government within PSA contracts, a bit fewer SOCAR payment within local fields
    • Availability of independent comparative analysis, EITI reporting outcomes with other statistics, even with Government expenditures
    • Observing more carefully “Azeri-Cirag-Guneshli” PSA contract’s cash flow and Government sharing of benefit
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • What doesn’t report afford ?
    • Making sure on reliability and the reporting info verification. CSO has to satisfy just with audit company clarification
    • Calculation of each Company’s contribution
    • Access to Government expenditures info
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • Questions …
    • What is preferable; Liberian discrepancy or Azerbaijani complete correspondence?
    • What is preferable; Government sympathy or real movement on transparency, but with official’s irritability?
    • What is preferable; country substantial transparency achievement, or geographical expansion?
    • What is benchmark?
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • Lessons
    • EITI is a process, rather than achieving a result
    • EITI is a consensus among parties, rather than dominancy of the stakeholder
    • EITI mission is very specific and we shouldn’t expect any full country transparency and good governance, thanks just to EITI development
    • EITI current agenda is very narrow and we have to think of expanding of this
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • So,
    • Azerbaijani EITI looks like… a half filled glass of water
    • Government : “We have half filled glass of water”
    • CSO : “ We have half empty glass of water”
    Dr.Ingilab Ahmadov
  • Thank you!