Hydrocracked vs. mineral oil


Published on

Published in: Business
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Hydrocracked vs. mineral oil

  1. 1. Printed in U.S.A., Copyright © 2000. PentonMedia, Inc. All rights reserved. Machine De-sign (ISSN 0024-9114) is published semi-monthly by Penton Media, Inc., 1100 Supe-rior Ave., Cleveland, OH 44114-2543. Copiesnot qualified for domestic requester circula-tion: one year, $105; two years, $165. Permis-sion to photocopy is granted for users regis-tered with the Copyright Clearance Center(CCC) Inc. to photocopy any article, with theexception of those for which separate owner-ship is indicated on the first page of the arti-cle, provided that the base fee of $1.25 percopy of the article, plus $.60 per page is paidto CCC, 222 Rosewood Dr., Danvers, MA01923 (Code No. 0024-9114/00 $1.25 + .60). Permission to reprint: Barbara LoSchi-avo; Purchased reprints: Judy Dustman(216-696-7000, ext. 9607); Advertising Ma-terials: Advertising Dept., Machine Design,1100 Superior Ave., Cleveland, OH 44114-2543, 216-696-7000. Inserts should be sentto Machine Design, Penton Press, 680 N.Rocky River Dr., Berea, OH 44017-1691.
  2. 2. Fluid power Edited by Lawrence Kren Automobiles that never need oil changes? How about doubling, even tripling, the time between service for turbines, rotary compressors, gear units, and other high-speed machinery? Severe-hydrocracked lubricating oils could make all this possible — at about half the cost of synthetic oils. The push toward lifetime lubesE. R. BooserConsulting EngineerNiskayuna, N.Y.M akers of most Euro- pean cars to- daysuggest changing oilevery 6,500 to 9,500miles. Volkswagen andPeugeot plan to extendthat figure to 18,000miles or 24 months forits passenger cars, andDaimler-Benz may de- Conoco’s recent $500 million hydrocracking plant turns petroleumbut a “fill-for-life” vehi- crude into Group II and Group III lube oil base stocks.cle by 2010. Key to the success ofsuch initiatives is better quality motor oils. process largely unchanged since the earlyCurrent synthetic oils let automobiles run 1900s. Here, distillation separates hydro-25,000 miles between oil changes or about carbon molecules by boiling point and theirfive times longer than most conventional respective molecular size and viscosity.types. Despite the advantage, their rela- Added solvents selectively extract aromat-tively high cost has limited market share ics and other impurities such as sulfur, ni-to about 3%. But emerging severe hydroc- trogen, and oxygen compounds. These ex-racked oils cost about half as much as syn- tracts are an environmental concern andthetics and last just as long. This has ma- are often burned as fuel.jor oil companies scurrying to supply the Hydrocracking instead treats base oilsexpected boon. What’s in it for them: with hydrogen rather than solvents. Itgreater efficiencies and a more environ- yields more useful products while elimi-mentally friendly, adaptable process. nating the environmental problems. More- Traditional refineries distill petroleum over, hydrocrackers can use less-expensivecrude into mineral lubricating oils using a petroleum crude which helps refineries re- MACHINE DESIGN MAY 17, 2001 www.machinedesign.com 77
  3. 3. Fluid power Flow diagrams for solvent refining and hydrocracking. A catalytic dewaxing step follows hydrocracking to convert waxy, straight-chain paraffins to branched-chain paraffins with lower pour points. (1) Remove sulfur, nitrogen, and oxygen impurities from crude oil. (2) Convert aromatic hydrocarbons to cycloparaffins that remain in Group II base stocks. (3) Open ring structure to paraffinic chains in Group III base stocks. Only the carbon atom skeletons are shown — the rest of the four valence bonds of each carbon atom are filled with hydrogen atoms. coup installation costs. Production can modern hydrocracker — a small 1,000 bar- readily shift from lubricants to automotive rel-per-day unit — was activated by Stan- and diesel fuels that meet more demand- dard Oil of Calif. in 1959 to produce im- ing emissions regulations. And by-prod- proved transportation fuels. By 1972, Gulf ucts from lube-oil production serve as Oil had built three severe hydrocrackers high-end fuels for transportation vehicles. for lubricant production, but further instal- Although hydrocracking may seem re- lations by Gulf and others got sidetracked cent, it dates back to the 1930s. The first as production focused on environmentally78 MACHINE DESIGN MAY 17, 2001 www.machinedesign.com
  4. 4. Fluid power Characteristics of hydrocarbon types PARAFFIN CHAIN CYCLOPARAFFIN AROMATIC No deposits Very little deposits, some varnish Black sludge Clear, colorless Slight color Dark color High viscosity index (VI) Intermediate VI Lower VI Branched chain: low pour point Low pour point Poor at low temperatures Straight chain: wax Intermediate additive solvency Good additive solvency Poor additive solvency Higher viscosity for same volatility Higher viscosity Low viscosity and volatility Some medicinal and cosmetic uses Aromatic portion is carcinogenic Nontoxic improved gasolines and diesel fuels. most conventional additives. Group III base More recently, Chevron has become a stocks undergo even more severe hydroc- major developer and operator of high-pres- racking, nearly completing the conversion sure hydroprocessors and has licensed the to branched-chain paraffins. Group III oils technology to Petro-Canada and Conoco. provides longer service life and a viscosity These large-scale installations cost about a less sensitive to temperature changes as in- half-billion dollars each and pose daunting dicated by a very high viscosity index engineering challenges. For example, cat- (VHVI – above 120). alytic reactors and some support hardware run at temperatures to 900°F and pres- Oil’s worst enemy sures to 3,000 psi. Steady improvements to Over time, oil reacts with dissolved at- piston pumps, catalysts, and other compo- mospheric oxygen and breaks down or oxi- nents exposed to the severe conditions help dizes. Oxidation starts a chain reaction make the operations more reliable. that first forms hydroperoxides then pro- gresses to other oxidation products, all of The hydrocracking process which increase acidity, viscosity, darken Mineral oils derived from petroleum have color, and leave surface deposits. Internal three basic hydrocarbon structures: paraf- combustion engines that leak combustion fins, cycloparaffins, and aromatics. Most de- gases into the oil (blow-by) accelerate the sirable are paraffins in which hydrogen process. Oxidation-inhibiting additives atoms completely saturate carbon-atom slow the deterioration over a hundred-fold chains. These hydrogen-saturated paraffin by eliminating the initial hydroperoxides chains can also form ring structures or cy- and by interrupting the chain sequence. cloparaffins. The third type has a six-mem- Useful life continues through an induc- ber aromatic ring structure with an unsatu- tion period as the oxidation inhibitor is rated carbon-atom skeleton. slowly consumed. Oxidation depends The high temperatures and pressures of strongly on temperature as life generally the hydrocracking process destabilize hy- halves for every 10°C (18°F) above normal drocarbon structures in crude petroleum. operating temperatures. Although addi- This leads first to hydrogen saturation of tional inhibitor delays life-ending oil aromatic rings to form cy- cloparaffins, and finally to New refineries producing both API Group II opening of cycloparaffin rings to give chain-structured hy- and Group III hydrocracked base stocks drocarbons. Start-up year: 1997 1998 2000 So-called Group II base Petro-Canada Chevron Equilon (Texaco-Shell) stocks are processed only to Conoco-Pennzoil Ergon where most aromatic hydro- Modrica (Yugoslavia) ExxonMobil carbons are eliminated along Imperial Oil (Canada) with sulfur, nitrogen, and Motiva (Aramco) oxygen impurities. The re- Sunoco maining cycloparaffins pro- vide sufficient solubility for80 MACHINE DESIGN MAY 17, 2001 www.machinedesign.com
  5. 5. Fluid power American Petroleum Institute (API) base oil categories Group Saturates,% Aromatics,% Sulfur,% Viscosity index Capacity, barrels/day I. Solvent-refined mineral oil <90 >10 >0.03 80 to <120 96,000 II. Hydroprocessed >90 <10 <0.03 80 to <120 86,000 III. Hydrocracked (VHVI) >90 <10 <0.03 120+ 7000 IV. PAO polyalphaolefins (100) (0) (0) 3000 (such as Mobil 1) V. All other synthetics such as esters for jet engine oils and for compounding some automotive and industrial oils. Lubricant production and relative costs last about three times longer than tradi- % of total Relative production cost tional solvent-refined oils at a given operat- ing temperature. One reason is the absence Mineral oil 97 1 of aromatics. While traditional solvent-re- SYNTHETIC OILS fined base stocks contain up to 35% aro- PAO synthetic hydrocarbons 1.4 3 matic hydrocarbons, severely hydrocracked Glycols 0.7 4 oils are often clear and colorless with less Polyol esters 0.5 7 than 0.5% aromatics. This helps minimize Diesters 0.2 5 varnish, dark deposits, insoluble sludge, Phosphate esters 0.15 8 and other problems that shorten oil life. The composition works in a variety of applica- tions including premium turbine oils (used breakdown, slow accumulation of oxida- in gas and steam turbines, electric motors, tion products and contaminants such as compressors, and a wide variety of rotating wear particles and soot eventually signal machinery), high-pressure hydraulic oils, an oil change. and extreme-pressure gear oils. The good news is, oils with a paraffinic molecular structure stave off oxidation. Hy- Measuring oil life drocracked oils have such a structure and Laboratory bench tests are the tradi- tional method to evaluate oxidation Expected oil life life. For example, the Turbine Oil Stability Test (TOST - ASTM D943) Year 1990 2010 bubbles oxygen through an oil sam- Automobile engines 3,000 to 4,000 mile 20,000 to 40,000 mile ple raised to 95°C and in contact Railroad diesels 3 month 1 yr with water and metal catalysts. But Steam turbines 10 yr 25 yr TOSTs can take several thousand Gas turbines 5 yr 10 yr hours to complete because of better Electric motors 2 yr 5 yr base oils and additives. A more ag- Gear sets, EP oil 0.5 yr 1 yr gressive Rotary Bomb Oxidation Test (RBOT - ASTM D2272) boosts pressure to 100 psi and tempera- tures to 150°C. Both tests Typical test life measure the initial induc- tion period involving only Solvent refined Hydrocracked slow oxidation. This in- TURBINE OIL duction period typically precedes much more TOST life, hr 4,000 18,000 rapid oxidation as meas- RBOT life, min 500 1800 ured by elevated oil acid- HYDRAULIC OIL ity (TOST) or drop in oxy- TOST life, hr 2,000 6,000 gen pressure (RBOT). Turbine Oil Stability Test (TOST - ASTM D943). Rotary Bomb Oxidation Test (RBOT - ASTM In addition to these D2272). These are typical results for premium turbine grade and hydraulic mineral oils tests, automotive engine commonly used in steam and gas turbines, compressors, electric motors and generators, and a oils are put through accel- wide range of industrial applications. erated wear and life eval- uations in test engines.82 MACHINE DESIGN MAY 17, 2001 www.machinedesign.com
  6. 6. Fluid power Key benefits of hydrocracked lubricants • Improves action of antioxidant additives. • Lets some applications run at higher temperatures. • Less carbon formation and fewer deposits. • Improved low temperature fluidity. • Separates water and releases foam more efficiently. • Lower oil volatility for reduced emissions. • Biodegrades faster. • Lower impurities and toxicity make them suitable for use in some cosmetics and pharmaceuticals. From here come standards including the Paraffinic-hydrocracked oils also have new GF-3 motor oil classification. GF-3 is different solvent properties that may com- scheduled for adoption by the International promise some gaskets, seals, and non- Lubricant Standardization and Approval metallic components. For instance, such Committee, and then by the API as Service oils can displace plasticizers in elastomers Classification SL. Oils meeting the new and plastic parts, possibly changing their standard (Group II hydrocracked oils for dimensions and mechanical properties. instance) are less volatile which helps cut Although compatible replacements are airborne components. They also have a rel- typically available for new designs, exist- atively lower viscosity to improve gas ing diesel engines, automotive compo- mileage and cold-weather starting. Best of nents, gear units, and other machines can all, Group II oils extend time between oil encounter problems. The new oils also sep- changes and reduce wear of engine valve arate water more rapidly which may re- train and piston ring surfaces. Diesel en- quire modified lubrication systems. Im- gines get the new PC-9 classification which proved filtration may also be needed to also relies heavily on hydrocracked base avoid build-up of contaminants and wear stocks. particles between longer oil-change inter- Several lubricant suppliers in North vals. All these issues need addressing if America and Europe are marketing “syn- hydrocracked oils are to deliver on their thetic” engine oils compounded with even promise of longer life at a lower cost. s more severely hydrocracked Group III base stocks. These oils are said to be equivalent Background information for this article to polyalphaolefin synthetics such as Mobil comes from Conoco, ExxonMobil, General 1. VHVI oils should make major inroads as Electric, and Petro-Canada. A source of automakers push for reduced maintenance further information on lubricant properties and longer oil-change intervals. and performance in bearings is a new book by M. M. Khonsari and E. R. Booser, Limitations and fixes Applied Tribology: Bearing Design and The new Group II and Group III oils Lubrication, John Wiley & Sons, New York. aren’t without problems, however. One It’s available at www.amazon.com drawback is a lower solubility to additives. Automotive engine oils are particularly challenging because they contain a rela- tively large amount of oxidation inhibitors, antiwear additives, and detergents. Additive separation can be a problem in some high-speed compressors. Centrifug- ing action in bearings slings additives out- We want your feedback. ward, likely because of incomplete solubil- Did you find this material interesting? Circle 785 ity in the base oil. One way to boost addi- Do you want more information of this type? Circle 786 tive solubility is to blend Group III base stocks with synthetic ester fluid. Similar Comment via e-mail to mdeditor@penton.com results are possible by adding Group I sol- What related topics would you like to see covered? What additional vent-refined oils to Group II hydrocracked information on this topic would you find useful? base stocks, but at the expense of potential longer life.84 MACHINE DESIGN MAY 17, 2001 www.machinedesign.com