travel to obtain service : travel to benefit from a particular service or activity that is unavailable at home ( usually used in combination )
health tourism
3. travel business : the business of arranging travel and travel services for people 2. travel for pleasure : the activity of traveling for pleasure 1.
www.yellowpages-cambodia.com/images/maps/Southeastasia PHILIPPINES THAILAND INDIA SINGAPORE MALAYSIA The Booming MEDICAL TOURISM In ASIA
Medical tourism in Asia is relatively new brought on in the aftermath of the Asian Financial Crisis that led first private hospitals in some Asian countries to seek alternative revenue sources…
KAZEMI Dec. 2007 Lulea University of Technology
Asia represents the most potential medical tourism market in the world. In 2007, the region generated revenues worth US$ 3.4 Billion, accounting for nearly 12.7% of the global market
“ Asian Medical Tourism Analysis (2008-2012)” Bharatbook June 2008
MEDICAL TOURISM, Defined
Popular mass culture where people travel often long distances to overseas destinations to obtain medical, dental and surgical care while simultaneously being holiday makers in a more conventional sense
Connell 2006
MEDICAL TOURISM, Defined
Provision of cost-effective private medical care in collaboration with the tourism industry for patients needing surgical and other forms of specialized treatment.
India Medical Care, 2007
Medical Treatment Alternative & Complimentary Medicine Medical Tourism Wellness Tourism MEDICAL TOURISM, Structure Jabarri, 2007 Health Tourism
Any help and treatment that is beyond the usage of Western Medicine (Avijgan, 2007)
Dietary supplements, mega dose vitamins, herbal preparations, massage therapy, magnet therapy, spiritual healing and meditation
Complimentary medicine- used together with conventional
Alternative medicine- used in place of conventional
COMPLIMENTARY & ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE
Medical Surgical (Cosmetic, Non-Cosmetic) Dental Reproductive: (Fertility, Birth, Sex Change) Medical Treatment Medical Tourism Wellness Tourism Alternative & Complimentary Medicine MEDICAL TOURISM, Structure Jabarri, 2007 Health Tourism
MEDICAL TOURISM, Defined MEDICAL TOURISM Consumer Benifit Social Issues Branding Product Infrastructure Communication Channel Legal Framework Operators Caballero, Danell & Mugomba, 2006
MEDICAL TOURISM, What’s at stake? Medical Tourism A business that: – creates value within the tourism and healthcare – attracts foreign exchange and investment capital – creates supply and demand for high skilled labor pool – generates the highest revenue per visit of any tourist category
Initially, medical tourists were composed of only the affluent and well-to-do people from all over the world, who could afford to travel abroad to receive the best medical attention.
medical tourists now also consist of average earning individuals.
Who are medical tourists ? Asian Medical & Hospital Center
Why would someone travel halfway across the world to a foreign country for these health care?
Even if these procedures are available in the home country. What are the significant reasons?….
Earliest medical tourism centers
2000 BC – (Bronze Age) hill tribes near present day St. Moritz, Switzerland gathered around to drink & bathe in the iron rich mineral springs of the region
4000 BC – Sumerians constructed the earliest known health complexes alongside mineral water springs that included elevated temples and flowing pools
GREEKS – first laid the foundation for a comprehensive health tourism system
Health Medical Tourism, 2005 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
The rise of Greek medical tourism
Asclepia temples – earliest healing centers, where patients from around the region congregated for therapeutic purposes
Greek mythology – Asclepius, the God of Medicine, mentored by Chiron, the master of Medicine
4 th Century BC – Asclepian healing temples had been constructed throughout the length and breadth of the Grecian world.
Wikipeda, 2007 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
The rise of Greek medical tourism
Epidaurus Asclepia Temple Complex flourished well until 4 th century AD
Included:
Bathing springs
Dream temple
Gymnasiun
Palaestra (exercise area)
Snake farm
Health Medical Tourism, 2007 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
Ancient Roman medical tourism
Thermae (hot water baths) – not only used for obvious medicinal purposes but served as important social networking venues for some of the Europe’s most privileged elite ( Health Medical Tourism, 2005)
Because of active trade, Thermae expansion included the following:
Ayurvedic massage
Chinese medicine
Aspects of Buddhist spiritual healing ( Health Medical Industry, 2005)
MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
Early Islamic civilization
Mansuri Hospital in Cairo (erected 1210 AD)
In patient capacity 8000 people
Largest hospital of the time
Most advanced health care facility
Health Medical Tourism, 2007 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
Medieval Japan
Onsen – hot mineral springs with healing properties enriched by the surrounding volcanic soil.
- discovered later by elderly farmers and hunters to be effective treatment for arthritic aches, and by warriors to alleviate pain, heal wounds and recuperate
Health Medical Tourism, 2007 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
Indian Medical Tourism
India’s alternative medicine and yoga (5000 yrs ago) – made India the epicenter of Eastern cultural, spiritual, and medicinal progress
Remained to be a veritable Mecca for all practitioners of alternative medicine
The world’s oldest medical tourism destination and now, one of the world’s popular ones
Connel, 2006 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
European Medical Tourism
16 th Century –Europeans discovered the Roman baths
Spa towns sprung up, notably, Bath or Aquae Sulis (Sulis Minerva-water Goddess)
Bath- became anointed as fashionable wellness and recreation playground for the rich and the famous.
Health Medical Tourism, 2005 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
Health Tourism in the new world
1600s – English and Dutch colonists in the newly discovered America constructed log cabins near mineral springs that were rich in medicinal properties.
Health Medical Tourism, 2007 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
The Rise of Medical Tourism in Asia
Asian countries can now attract a combined 1.3 million medical tourists per year and is increasing annually.
Asia alone will be projected to generate more than USD4 billion by 2012
Gupta 2007 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
The Rise of Medical Tourism in Asia
1970’s- Thailand became known as a destination for medical tourism because of sex change operations, and later, cosmetic surgery
After 1998 in the wake of Asian economic crisis and the need for economic diversification , Malaysia entered medical tourism
Connel, 2006 MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
The Rise of Medical Tourism in Asia
Mid 1990’s – India, regarded as contemporary global center for medical tourism advertises itself as offering everything from alternative Ayurvedic therapy to coronary bypasses and cosmetic surgery
MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY Connel, 2006
The Rise of Medical Tourism in Asia
2001 – successful separation of 10 mo. old Nepalese conjoined twins put Singapore ’s medical expertise into headlines around the world. (Wikipeda, 2007)
2006 – Joint Commission International (JCI) set up its Asia Pacific office in Singapore. The country has 9 hospitals & 2 medical centers accredited by the said commission . ( Connel, 2006)
MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
The Rise of Medical Tourism in Asia
October 2004 – Philippine Medical Tourism Program (PMTP) was created through Executive Order No. 372 by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo
Nov., 2006 -"Only in the Philippines: Tender Loving (Health)Care ," the very first Philippine Medical Tourism Congress, Expo and Launch
MEDICAL TOURISM, HISTORY
History of Curative & Wellness Tourism Which are Used & Named to Each Decade Jabbari, 2007 Hospitals are more like spas & Spas are more like hospitals TODAY - Formation of International Spa Association 1991 - Health Farms & Fat Farms 20 th Century - Sea & Mountain Air (TB sanitarium) 19 th Century - Spa 17 th , 18 th century - Fountain of Youth 16 th century - Springs Middle Ages - Mineral & Hot Springs Visits Neolithic & Bronze Age-
The shifting in consumer values
Increased stress & workload
Older population
Health care costs are escalating
New attitude towards mental & spiritual activities
The emergence of environmentalists
Why would someone travel halfway across the world to a foreign country for wellness? Jabbari, 2007
Exhorbitant cost of treatment in the home country
Treatment or surgeries not covered by health insurance in home country
Long waiting periods ( in “rationed” health care in home country)
No or minimal insurance coverage
Privacy (Anonymity)
Lack of facilities in the home country
Possibility of a holiday with health care
Why would someone travel halfway across the world to a foreign country for treatment? Jabbari, 2007
MEDICAL TOURISM, Today… In the past, health travel was restricted either to the wealthy or truly desperate. Today, with flattening global economy, international travel, mass communication and more lenient trade policies make it possible for those with modest means to enjoy the benefits of world-class health care in the form of medical tourism. KAZEMI, 2007
Objectives of Medical Travel KAZEMI Dec. 2007 vs
Elective procedures: they are wait-listed in home country: UK & Canada
Opportunity for high quality interventions
Competitive prices
Desirable environment
Combination of treatment and tour.
Self-paying client from the Middle East, Asia or Latin America seeking care in the USA or Western Europe.
Specialists Targeted: quality care not available in home countries i.e. cardiac or plastic surgeries
Need for emergency care not available in home countries.
Health Medical Tourism (Present) Industrial Medical Tourism (Past)
Jabarri, 2007 Trend of Medical Tourism Concept (1 st International Conference of Health Tourism in Iran) 1997 Health Tourism 1997- 2001 Transition 2001- 2007 Medical Tourism 2006- 2007 Medical Outsourcing
Sociological Aspects of Medical Outsourcing to Asia Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006 Monetary benefit to nation Savings passed on to other needs Additional income revenue Lower Costs Country Receiving Patients Country Sending Patients ECONOMIC
Sociological Aspects of Medical Outsourcing Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006 More tourism promotion in effect Opportunity for family to visit abroad Increased cultural exchanges Greater respect to host nationals Opportunity to encounter others Appreciation given host nation Country Receiving Patients Country Sending Patients SOCIAL
Sociological Aspects of Medical Outsourcing Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006 Internationalization of practices Potential for redefining of malpractice suits Greater international legal ties Promote development of agreements Country Receiving Patients Country Sending Patients LEGAL
Sociological Aspects of Medical Outsourcing Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006 Inspections by international medical regulatory boards Concerns for medical standards Reputation importance Questions of safety in follow up Raise issues of international medical ethics Less control of medical practices Increased prestige in medicine for host nation Increased contacts in exchange of people and information Country Receiving Patients Country Sending Patients MEDICAL
ADVERTISEMENT Technology Quality Reliability Overseas Training KAZEMI, 2007
THAILAND
Inter-sectoral coordination
Effective marketing
Focus on hospitality
Building Infrastructure
PROMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES OF ASIAN COUNTRIES KAZEMI, 2007
INDIA
Low-cost treatment
Effective marketing
Indian companies having negotiation with National Health Service (NHS) about out-sourcing the treatment of British patients to India
PROMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES OF ASIAN COUNTRIES KAZEMI, 2007
MALAYSIA
Government effort to promote medical tourism promotional plans.
Tax incentives
Lessening import duty on medical equipment
Enabling supporting infrastructure
Set up 5 Committees to promote health tourism
PROMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES OF ASIAN COUNTRIES KAZEMI, 2007
SINGAPORE
High level of cleanliness
World best standard training and professionalism
PROMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES OF ASIAN COUNTRIES KAZEMI, 2007
PHILIPPINES
3 BUSINESS MODELS FOR HEALTH
Creation of an international zone of health for wellness combining medical tourism , spa, health, eco-tourism and retirement villages
Health human resources development network with the top nursing and medical schools/hospitals in the Philippines.
Health crewing for specific health services, including Tele-health, medical transcription
PROMOTIONAL EXPERIENCES OF ASIAN COUNTRIES KAZEMI, 2007
MEDICINE WELLNESS TOURISM
PROCESS Wikipeda, 2008 PATIENT Medical Tourism Provider Certified Medical Doctors or Consultants Discussion of The Package Signing of Consent Bonds & Agreements Recommendation letters for medical visa From the Embassy TRAVEL Medical Tourist is assigned to a Case Executive who takes care of everything for the tourist
STANDARDS Wikipeda, 2008 International Health Care Accreditation Evidence- based Medicine Quality Assurance
Joint Commission International (JCI)
USA
International Health Care Accreditation
International Health Care Accreditation Wikipeda, 2008
Trent International Accreditation Scheme
United Kingdom
HongKong
International Health Care Accreditation Wikipeda, 2008
The Society for International Health Care Accreditation (SOFIHA)
Promotion of safe hospital environment for patients
Health Care Tourism International
Accreditation for all major groups involved in the health tourism industry:
HOTELS
RECOVERY FACILITIES
MEDICAL TOURIST BOOKING AGENCIES
Quality of Care Issues Health care errors seriously harm 1 in every 10 patients around the world. Source: World Health Organization (WHO) Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006
Quality of Care Issues International Patient Safety Goals Goal 1 – Identify Patients Correctly Goal 2 – Improve Effective Communication Goal 3 – Improve the Safety of High-Alert Medications Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006
Goal 4 – Eliminate Wrong-Site, Wrong-Patient, Wrong-Procedure Surgery Goal 5 – Reduce the risk of health care-acquired infections. Goal 6 – Reduce the risk of patient harm resulting from falls. Quality of Care Issues International Patient Safety Goals Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006
The Outsourcing of Surgical Procedures to Asia: Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006 Note: Angioplasty in Malaysia averages $4,000 - $6,000 $13,000 $10,000- $11,000 $9,000- $10,000 $160,000 – $281,000 Heart Valve (single) $20,000 $12,000 $4,000-$10,000 $100,000 –$123,000 Coronary Artery Bypass $13,000 $13,000 $4,000-$11,000 $35,000 –$83,000 Coronary Angioplasty Singapore Thailand India USA Procedures& Services
www.pcij.org The Outsourcing of Surgical Procedures to Asia: 1,400 1,365 1,711 3,221 2,800-5,700 Liposuction 5,639 5,500 4,342 6,207 5,000 Total knee replacement 1,424 950 1,014 1,749 2,500-3,000 Cataract surgery PHILIPPINES In US$ THAILAND In US$ MALAYSIA In US$ SINGAPORE In US$ USA $ TREATMENT Table 1: Comparative Cost of Treatments (in US$) Source: PIDS
The Outsourcing of Surgical Procedures to Asia: Langham, Richmond, Rubin, 2006 $10,000 $90,000 Spinal Disc $9,000 $7,000 $5,000-$6,000 $63,000-$91,000 Spinal Fusion $8,000 $7,000-$8,000 $4,000-$6,000 $17,000-$20,000 Knee (ACL) Repair $8,000 $8,000 $4,000-$7,000 $40,000-$60,000 Rotator Cuff $13,000 $10,000 $8,000-$9,000 $40,000-$61,000 Knee Replacement $12,000 $12,000 $9,000 $44,000-$64,000 Hip Replacement Singapore Thailand India USA Procedures & Services
RISKS Wikipeda, 2008
DIFFERENCE IN DISEASE-RELATED EPIDEMIOLOGY BETWEEN HOME COUNTRY & COUNTRY OF DESTINATION
Hepatitis A
Amoebic Dysentery
Mosquito-transmitted diseases
TB
DIFFERENCE IN HEALTHCARE PROVIDER STANDARDS AROUND THE WORLD
World Alliance for Patient Safety
Assists hospitals and government around the world in setting patient safety policy and practices relevant when providing medical tourism services
QUALITY OF POST-OP CARE
Role of Accreditation
Long flights maybe worse for some cases.
LEGAL & ETHICAL ISSUES Wikipeda, 2008
Medical Malpractice Lawsuits
Illegal purchase of organs and tissues for transplantations
Inequities in health care system
GROWTH OF MEDICAL TOURISM IN THE WORLD Google Trends 2004 2005 2006 2007 0 Search Volume
More than 2.9 Million patients visited Thailand, India, Singapore, Malaysia and the Philippines for medical tourism in 2007.
Thailand’s low cost and scenic beaches have enabled it to become the largest medical tourism market in Asia; however, an unstable political environment and occurrence of another epidemic such as bird flu can restrain its growth.
Asian Medical Tourism Analysis (2008-2012) Bharatbook, June 2008
Asian Medical Tourism HOSPITALS Samitivej Hospital, Thailand
Asian Medical Tourism HOSPITALS
Healthcare costs are considerably high in Singapore as compared to other Asian destinations. The country, however, boasts of an infrastructure and resources that in some cases are even better than those in the west.
Asian Medical Tourism Analysis (2008-2012) Bharatbook, June 2008
Asian Medical Tourism HOSPITALS Singapore National Eye Centre (SNEC)
India, with its low cost advantage and emergence of several private players, represents the fastest growing market. The country’s questionable sanitary perceptions in the west are, however, a major roadblock for growth.
Asian Medical Tourism Analysis (2008-2012) Bharatbook, June 2008
Asian Medical Tourism HOSPITALS LAKESHORE HOSPITAL, INDIA
Malaysia and Philippines , both relatively new players in the medical tourism market, are expected to grow strongly in the next five years.
Asian Medical Tourism Analysis (2008-2012) Bharatbook, June 2008
Asian Medical Tourism HOSPITALS ST. LUKES, MEDICAL CENTER, Philippines
Asian Medical Tourism HOSPITALS Gleneagles Medical Centre Penang, Malaysia .
A number of employers and health insurance firms in developed countries have now started looking at medical tourism to reduce their surging healthcare expenditure.
The Asian medical tourism market is expected to grow at a CAGR of 17.6% between 2007 and 2012
Asian Medical Tourism Analysis (2008-2012) Bharatbook, June 2008
Challenges for Health Care Providers in the Promising Industry of Medical Tourism HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS Medical Quality of Services Importance of Non-medical Services for Patient Access Marketing Options
0 comments
Post a comment