Philippine Dental Association HOUSE OF DELEGATES MINUTES OF THE MEETING FIRST PLENARY SESSION September 27, 2012 Waterfront Hotel & Casino Lahug, Cebu City1 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:2 Ladies and gentlemen, the processional. Please rise for the entrance of the MACE held by3 Dr. Mari Jennifer Yalung, HOD Peace Officer.4 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:5 The MACE is the symbol of Authority and Legislative Power vested upon the House of6 Delegates. It signifies that the House is now in session. The MACE will be put on its pedestal.7 It consists of three (3) chambers that represent the delegates from Luzon, Visayas and8 Mindanao who express their minds towards the improvement of our association, while the9 light rays it emits, work towards improvement. It also magnifies the MACE which is the10 symbols of the House of Delegates; the four (4) corners of its pedestal representing North,11 East, West and South.12 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:13 Ladies and gentlemen, let us all welcome the PDA Regional Coordinators, the PDA Past14 Presidents, the PDA House of Delegates Past Speakers, the PDA Officers, the PDA Floor15 Leader Dr. Raymundo Lope, the PDA Speaker Protempore, Dr. Joan Carbonell, Mr. Alex16 Chua, CME Officer, Westmont, Mr. Carlo Estanislao, Marketing Manager, Biomedis, Mr.17 Ramoncito Sta. Maria, VP, PRMD, Unilab, Ms. Joy Ong, Assistant Manager, Mr. Raffy Castro,18 Biomedis. Ladies and gentlemen, the PDA President Dean Arturo de Leon together with the19 House of Delegates Speaker Dr. Clarissa Jane Pe and representing our Keynote Speaker Hon.20 Sergio Restauro. Please remain standing for the Entrance of Colors!21 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:22 Please remain standing for the Doxology to be rendered by Dr. James Flores, Mandaue23 Dental Chapter.24 Please join us in the singing of the PDA Hymn.25 Thank you very much! You may now take your seats. And maayong hapon sa inyong tanan.26 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:27 In English that is good afternoon to everybody.28 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:29 Yes, and welcome to the Mid-Year Session of the House of Delegates here in C-E-B-U,30 captivating, exciting, beautiful and unique Cebu. Ok ba Mr. President na mamana lang sa31 inyo?
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (2) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:2 Ang galing, galing talaga sa harmonics ni Sir, e!3 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:4 So nahahawa lang kami. Ok, Dr. Bimbo?5 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:6 Ok, so we go to program proper. Are you all ok? Feeling good? After that very (-----------------7 ---)sarap no.8 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:9 And a very healthy travel from your different provinces. Thank you very much!10 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:11 Sino yung bagyo?12 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:13 Si Lawin, limilipad lipad si Lawin.14 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:15 Ang lakas ng hangin ni Lawin.16 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:17 Binugaw namin si Lawin, bawal siya dito sa Cebu kasi it is exciting, captivating, and beautiful18 unique Cebu.19 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:20 To welcome all and acknowledge our guests, May I call on the House of Delegates Speaker21 Protempore, Dr. Joan Carbonell.22 DR. JOAN CARBONELL (HOD Speaker Protempore):23 Maayong hapon sa inyong tanan. Maimbag malay ating hapon, may aga------------- (greetings24 in Visayas dialect.) Magandang hapon po sa inyong lahat. To our Guest Speaker Dr. Sergio25 Restauro, our energetic Dean Arturo de Leon, PDA President, our dynamic Speaker of the26 House, Dr. Clarissa Jane Pe, the very handsome and very helpful Vice President of Unilab,27 Mr. Ramoncito Sta. Maria, still handsome and very brilliant, our Parliamentarian, Dr. Luis28 Uy, all the Executive Officers who are here this afternoon, and of course all the House of29 Delegates Officers: Dr. Mari Jennifer Yalung, our Peace Officer, Dr. Rey Lope, our Floor30 Leader, HOD Administrator, Dr. Delia Castillo, our HOD Secretaries, Dr. Army Jane Chavez31 and Dr. Renzy Viloria, our Finance Officer, Dr. Maria Cecilia Diego, our 2 advisers, Dr. Maria32 Arlissa Aguiluz and Dr. Ramon Hebron, All the Past PDA Presidents, all the Past Speakers of33 the House, and of course our dear friend from Unilab, Ms. Joy Ong, the debonair Mr. Alex34 Chua of Westmont, our dear friends from Biomedis Mr. Carlo Estanislao and Mr. Rafael
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (3) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 Castro, all the delegates from different Chapters and Affiliates, all the Regional2 Coordinators, the host Chapter, Mandaue and Cebu Dental Chapter, and of course all the3 HOD organizing committee members who had been very helpful with their undying support4 to make this HOD Mid-Year Session possible, ladies and gentlemen, good afternoon.5 It is my pleasure to welcome you all in our 50 th Mid-Year Session and it is worth mentioning6 that we have 213 delegates that will mark the historic task of addressing different, but7 relevant issues that our association is facing right now. In behalf of all the HOD Officers, we8 welcome you all and we hope and pray that we all join hands to address all the problems,9 and we will have our new PDA and this Mid-Year Session will be fruitful & successful. Thank10 you and magandang hapon uli.11 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:12 Thank you very much Dr. Joan Carbonell, and now may we call on Mr. Ramoncito Sta. Maria,13 Vice President of the Professional Relations Management Division of United Laboratories14 for his cordial greetings. A round of applause, please!15 MR. RAMONCITO STA. MARIA (VP-PRMD, United Laboratories, Inc.):16 Speaker of the House, Dr. Clarissa Pe, PDA President Dean Arturo De Leon, the Hon. Dr.17 Sergio Restauro, representing good governor, Hon. Gwendolyn Garcia, all the officers,18 members, Past Presidents, Past Speakers, and delegates to this year’s convention,19 magandang tangali po sa inyong lahat! Welcome to Cebu!20 As I was talking to your Speaker, nabanggit niya 50 years na, actually this is the 51st because21 again since the early 60’s, 1961 to be exact, the first By-laws, set of By-laws were filled up22 and crafted, the policy making and legislative work were actively pursued by the leadership23 of the Philippine Dental Association in more than half a century. Later today, the House of24 Delegates will make a regulatory work even stronger and more attuned to present times. It25 was also around this time for us in Unilab, that Unilab really started working very closely26 with the Filipino dentist, practically in all its 67 years of existence in pharmaceutical27 industry. Well, I am proud again to be standing here once again before you, marching with28 the dignitaries with all the special people of the HOD and the PDA during the entrance29 ceremony, and sitting alongside with these people, and of course we miss the good30 governor.31 This gives me an opportunity once again to force another year of tight partnership with the32 Philippine Dental Association specifically the House of Delegates and if I may just call on the33 people behind this or the people behind me in trying to trim up this activity before you, I34 would like the people to please stand up to be recognized, Mr. Alex Chua, Mon de Castro35 and Carlo of Biomedis, Chona, Leo, Vangie and of course Ms. Joy Ong. Sila po ang katuwang36 natin kaya andito tayong maghapon, hanggang bukas, hanggang Sabado making sure37 everything goes well in the Mid-year Session. And for as long as infections are arrested by38 Amox Dofenal, well of course matutuwa si Alex dito and for as long as bleeding is arrested39 by Hemostan ---- and ----- Happy as we keep our breath always with Swish. Unilab will be by40 HOD’s side through thick and thin ho ito and we certainly recognize the efforts the41 judicious, consciencous and productive policy making activity of the body, for indeed the42 House of Delegates of the Philippine Dental Association is the future of Philippine Dentistry.43 Maraming salamat po! Congratulations on your 51st at magandang hapon po ulit!
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (4) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:2 Thank you very much, Mr. Chito Sta. Maria, United Laboratory for your ever support to3 almost all the activities of the House of Delegates and that of the Philippine Dental4 Association. And may we request Mr. Chito Sta. Maria to please stay on the center stage5 together with our HOD Speaker, Dr. Clarissa Pe and Pres. Dr. Arturo De Leon. (Read the6 Plaque of Appreciation). Thank you very much, Mr. Chito Sta. Maria of Unilab!7 And now, we would like to call on our favourite, Ms. Jocelyn Ong on the center stage please.8 (Read the Plaque of Appreciation). Thank you, Ms. Jocelyn Ong, love you from the HOD and9 the PDA!10 We would like to call on Mr. Alex Chua of Westmont to receive the Plaque of Appreciation11 for Westmont Pharmaceutical Incorporated. (Read the Plaque of Appreciation). Salamat,12 Westmon and Mr. Alex Chua! Huwag sana kayong magsasawa sa pagtulong sa amin!13 And now, I would like to call on the Marketing Manager of Biomedes, Mr. Carlo Estanislao14 to receive the Plaque of Appreciation for Biomedes. (Read the Plaque of Appreciation).15 Thank you very much Mr. Carlo Estanislao. Huwag ninyo po kaming iiwan hanggang Sabado,16 dere-derecho na po ang tulong ng Biomedes, Salamat sa Hemonstan!17 We also would like to present a Plaque of Appreciation to Innovitelle but we will be18 awarding that tomorrow during Fellowship Night kasi sila po yung ating sponsor for the19 Fellowship Night.20 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:21 Ok, congratulations and thank you for all the support that you have given us through the22 years!23 With your kind indulgence, allow me to try my Tagalog for this next portion of our program.24 Ang susunod na magtatalumpati sa harap nating lahat ay isang ginoo na sa wari ko ay tuwid,25 uliran, responsable, inteligente, natural at siyempre guapo, Turing for short. Ladies and26 gentlemen, let us all welcome our vagrant PDA President, Dean Arturo “Turing” de Leon.27 DEAN ARTURO DE LEON (PDA President):28 Thank you very much Dr. Cabahug for being truthful, except for the last one. Of course I would like to acknowledge the dignitaries in the table headed by our Hon. Sergio Restauro,29 Executive Governor, our House Speaker, who is very much behind this preparation and30 design for this session together with the organizing committee of this Mid-Year House31 Session, Dr. Clarissa Pe, to our Parliamentarian, Past President, and Past Speaker, Dr. Luis32 Uy, to our corporate partner, Unilab represented by Dr. Chito Sta. Maria, and members of33 PMRD and subsidiary companies, to the Officers of the House of Delegates, to the member34 of the Executive Board, to the men and women of this PDA House of Delegates, to the35 Affiliate Societies Presidents, to the Council of Past Presidents, to the Council of Past36 Speakers, friends, ladies and gentlemen, a pleasant good afternoon to all of you.37 Magandang hapon po sa inyong lahat!38 I prepared 101 slides for this talumpati, however, due to the essence of time, I just reduced39 this one piece speech into 4 demonics. The first one tells about what you have? HOD, House40 of Delegates, now representing it the way you feel for our profession, the way you feel, for41 our association. As I see it right now and as we feel, everyone feels right now HOD would
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (5) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 mean, ”Heavy on Dedication”. To me, everyone, every member of this institution deserves2 the acronyms of all the men and women of Philippine Dentistry. You will not be here if you3 do not have that dedication. In fact, you will use that dedication to share your prospective4 as you define the 4 documents that will depict the collection of Philippine Dentistry.5 Without such dedication, you cannot contribute to this outmost success. Tunay ng inyong6 pakikipagpunyagi ay masasalamin sa dedikasyon. Sa inyong walang sawang7 pakikipagpunyagi sa ating samahan ng mga dentista, HOD, Heavy on Dedication. This again8 is an opportunity to show it, to underscore such feeling towards to our profession, and you9 can only do that if you are going to put the name of this institution again to its highest10 ultimate level. For this institution represents the very essence of what we have and what11 we are enjoying right now, this is the essence of democracy.12 Yes my colleagues the second demonic is HOD, House of Democracy. Democracy would13 actually tell us that everyone who has all equal rights and all privileges, here walang Past14 Presidents, walang Past Speakers, walang President, walang ordinaryong member, lahat15 tayo ay pantay, pantay. Bawat opinion ay mahalaga, bawat pananaw ay isang kontribusyon16 para bumuo ng isang magandang pananaw para sa ating samahan, para sa ating Inang17 Bayan. This democratic process is the penultimate to what has been prepared for you to be18 processed through the efforts of the technical working group and its members headed by19 Dr. Arlissa Aguiluz. What you are going to have right now is the product of their labours,20 their timeless dedication in making sure that everything pertains to the 4 documents that21 we are going to post right now with you and possibly amend, would have its right22 ingredients, right components. We feel that without your approval, everything might not be23 in its proper prospective. The Executive board requirements the process of exercising its24 policy making mandates, it is you the men and women of the House of Delegates which25 should finally put a seal of approval on these 4 documents, and we cannot do this one not26 unless we are united. Yes, we can agree, we can disagree, but once we agree on one thing,27 let us be one to see that same picture in going towards that goal. Magiging maaring28 emotional, maaring maging unheated argumentations, but at the end of the day we all29 belong to one association, we need to define one direction that leads to the third demonic30 HOD, you will be given that lead opportunity to shout to the board that here we are HOD,31 Having one Direction. It is very important for us to see the same picture as we move as to32 unity towards that goal, but we can only do that one if we first have the panoramic view on33 everything and of course with due respect to everyone. Walang mali o walang tamang34 pananaw. Ito po ay isang kusang pagbibigay ng pahalaga sa ating mga ginagawa bilang35 dentista at bilang kasapi ng samahan. Bigyan po natin ng paggalang ang bawat pananalita36 ng ating kasamahan. In the end we will be going home with the thought that we37 contributed towards a meaningful journey of our association.38 Tita Precy, you gave a very nice demonic of Cebu I would like to use that one Cebu demonic39 to put everything in its prospective in abbreviation C-E-B-U, Come Everyone Be United.40 Good afternoon to all of you. Marami pong salamat!41 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:42 Maraming salamat po, Dean Arturo De Leon! And now we would like to call on our Speaker43 of the House of Delegates to give her own message for all of us, a round of applause for Dr.44 Clarissa Jane Pe.45 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):46 It’s been going over and over my head the many things that I want to say today and in the47 end I can only say a few words. First of all, I would like to acknowledge our partner who has
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (6) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 been there through thick and thin. Thank you from the bottom of our heart, Mr. Chito Sta.2 Maria and United Laboratories! To our Dean, to our President for his support, his push for3 positive change, his inspiring criticism for things that you have yet to accomplish, we thank4 you for that, Sir! To our Parliamentary, Dr. Luis Uy, for bringing us back to the right road, we5 still have a long way to go, but yet we will not be alone, we will all be together. And for our6 Keynote Speaker, a doctor in profession, a DMD specialist, the Chair of Provincial Board of7 the province of Cebu, Dr. Sergio Restauro, and to all the men and women of the Executive8 Board, you will be acknowledged individually later in the roll call, to the Past President and9 Past Speakers, I am humbled by your presence because in the 50 years of existence of the10 House of Delegates we haven’t had this number of Past Speakers and Past Presidents in one11 mid-year session. Thank you very much! To the delegates who are called here today, we12 thank you from the bottom of our heart for responding to our invitation! A few months ago13 during the annual session in November 2011, there was a strong clamour for mid-year14 session to be held in Cebu, it was a big challenge, and it is a big challenge to bring you here.15 We beg your kind indulgence, our apologies for whatever little inconveniences that you may16 have experienced! There are things that are beyond our control, we can ask only for kind17 understanding with that. We are all here called for a mission. 50 years of existence of House18 of Delegates is something that we owe to our Past Speakers, Past Presidents, all the men19 and women who had been here also like us today seated with one goal to make the20 Philippine Dental Association achieve its goal in proving dental help to the nation through21 our respective practices, through our individual Chapters where we come from. There is so22 much in the history of the House of Delegates, today, we start another 50 years. By then,23 most of us may not be here anymore, but let us leave a legacy. I am challenging you. Let us24 leave a legacy that will guide those who will come after us, after all this is our house. Let us25 put it in order so that those who will follow our footsteps will find it in order. Let us be26 united in our direction, let us all understand that we can all be one in the achievement of27 our goals that we have set. It is not an easy task to amend, to change the 4 documents: the28 Constitution and By-laws, the Code of Dental Ethics, the Republic Act 9484, and the29 establishment of the Standard of Care. It is a challenge to all of us. It is not just a challenge30 to the House of Delegates Officers but for each and every one of us who are here today. We31 have prepared our committees; our Technical Working Group has laboured. I urge you to32 keep an open mind, think not of your own personal interest, but for the good of the33 Philippine Dental Association.34 Tomorrow, we will break the whole group into 3 clusters. Here, we’ll be able to find a35 cluster for you to go. It doesn’t mean that you will only stay with one cluster. We have set36 aside 2 hours per cluster and we will rotate. The documents have been sent to you37 electronically, it was “kinda” ambitious on our part to go electronic, but nowadays we38 cannot afford to spend on paper printing and shipping these documents and it will be too39 heavy for you to carry over here in Cebu in that way, long after you go back to your own40 respective Chapters you will still have a copy and it can be forwarded to your respective41 members.42 Tomorrow, we will have an open meeting. That is why we invited you to bring your laptops,43 your PD and we would just like to encourage everyone to refrain from going into social44 networking. The PDA spent so much money to bring you here, if you have other business45 we will understand but kindly step out from the session hall. We are here to legislate and46 this is serious matter. Do not be offended if we find that you are working other ways and47 you are using the networking instrument, we will kindly ask you to step out of the Session48 Hall. It is not a joke, the committee have laboured so hard and with that I would like to49 acknowledge our Technical Working Group, as well as the Officers, the appointed and50 elected Officers of the House of Delegates to please rise. Those who have laboured to make51 this, without you, thank you very much! Without the dedication of these men and women
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (7) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 who are here as your servant leaders, please let us treat each other the respect that we all2 deserve. They are not your personal servants. We are one. We have the same calling and I3 urge you if you have any concerns, let us not make a big fun out of it. You know things are4 not perfect all the time as much as we are not also perfect.5 And tomorrow on the very first hour, you will be broken into clusters. We will have one6 cluster outside this hall, one cluster will stay here and the other cluster will stay in the7 Mediterranean room. We have our Chairs; we have our facilitators, our consultants, and the8 technical committee. During the plenary at the end of 6 hours you will convene, whatever9 will be the output of the clusters we will present it in the plenary for the approval of the10 body. So we urge you tonight if you have a chance to go over the documents that we have11 e-mailed to you please find time to study them. We will ask you to put your opinion on12 certain provisions of the Constitution that needs amendments. To save time, we will only13 have limited discussions in the clusters to a few people. Everybody is welcome to put in14 their contributions by writing your opinion or recommendation in the beta cards that you15 will find in the cluster. Then the committees, the Technical Working Group will then16 summarize it and present it in the plenary. If you have recommendations that were not17 identified by the cluster, please you are still welcome to make your revision, but we also ask18 you to respect the decision of the committee Chair if they think that your recommendations19 are not as urgent as they would mean then, we thank you in advance for your kind20 understanding!21 And with that I would like to personally thank Ms. Joy Ong for the sacrifice, for quite22 understanding, for the patience that she has extended to the working committees, and also23 to different partners, Unilab, Westmont, Biomedis, Innovitelle, these are sponsors on24 tomorrows Fellowship.25 Tomorrow at the end of a long day, we will also party hard and enjoy with our Luau Retro26 theme and with that ladies and gentlemen as I have said there is so much to say, but there27 is not much time to say. Thank you and have a pleasant afternoon!28 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:29 Thank you very much Madam Speaker. May we request to please remain on the center30 stage and may we invite our PDA Dean Arturo De Leon to join the Speaker to award the31 plaque to the PDA-HOD life members.32 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:33 Our first awardee is the Immediate Past President of the PDA, Dr. Roberto M. Tajonera, Life34 time member.35 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:37 (Read the Plaque of the life time member to Dr. Roberto M. Tajonera). Congratulations, Dr.38 Tajonera!39 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:40 Our next awardee for Life Time Member is no other than our Immediate Past Speaker of the41 House of Delegates, ladies and gentlemen, Col. Ramon Hebron.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (8) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:2 (Read the Plaque of the life time member to Col. Ramon Hebron). Thank you and3 congratulations again to Col. Ramon Hebron!4 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:5 Our third award the Honorary Speaker Award, ladies and gentlemen, let us call in Dr. Primo6 Gonzales to receive the award.7 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:8 (Read the Plaque of the life time member to Dr. Primo Gonzales). We would like to call all9 the Past Speakers of the House of Delegates to have a photo off with the new Honorary10 Speaker of the House of Delegates. We thank once again Dr. Primo Gonzales, Honorary11 Speaker of the House of Delegates.12 Ok, as we now move on to the most important part of our Opening ceremony, may we call13 on HOD Past Speaker, who incidentally is the first woman HOD Speaker, a round of14 applause, ladies and gentlemen to Dr. Libertad Nolido who will do the honor of introducing15 our Keynote Speaker.16 DR. LIBERTAD NOLIDO:17 Thank you, Dr. Precy! Good looking gentlemen and beautiful women dignitaries at the18 presidential table and sub-presidential table. Past and Present Officers of both branches the19 executive and the legislative of the Philippine Dental Association, fellow dentists, good20 afternoon.21 We request that today, we will have with us Cebu’s pride itself, the first woman governor22 with 443 year history of the province of Cebu, Gov. Gwendolyn Garcia. She is in Manila with23 some business, urgent business. However, she sent a representative who is equally as24 dedicated government service worker as she is. He is a medical doctor, specializing in Ears,25 Eyes, Nose and Throat, and likewise serving as a Board Member of the first district of the26 province of Cebu, and who knows he might also become the governor himself? Only God27 knows. Let’s put our hands together for Doctor, the Honorable Board Member, Dr. Sergio28 Bacus Restauro.29 HON. SERGIO B. RESTAURO:30 Please sit down! To Dr. Libertad Nolido, thank you for that wonderful introduction. I31 appreciate it very much. To Dr. Clarissa Jane Pe, and to Mr. Ramoncito O. Sta. Maria of the32 United Laboratories, to incumbent PDA President of 2012, Dean Arturo De Leon, and to the33 active officers and members of the House of Delegates, our participating dental34 practitioners who came from the different provinces and cities, welcome and to other35 friends, guests. Maayong hapon, sa inyong tanan!36 At this very moment I am very thankful and flattered to have been asked to speak in this37 momentous gathering in lieu of our beloved Governor, the Honorable Gwen F. Garcia, who38 is currently undertaking a number of previous commitments, in line with her local functions39 as responsible Chief Executive of the province of Cebu. Nevertheless, she is conveying her40 great pride and honor for the reason that your prestigious organization chose to hold the
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (9) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 51st Philippine Dental Association, House of Delegates Mid-Year Session in our beloved2 province. Remember, it is more fun in Cebu.3 First of all, she wants to express her full support in this event and granted me this unique4 opportunity to speak before you in her behalf. I would gladly say that I am overwhelmed5 with so much joy and pleasure for I am speaking in front of very noble professionals, who6 are very vigilant and have great concern in maintaining the present high professional7 standard of dental profession, and it is always a practice that leadership will always be in8 harmony with the persons concerned: the dental health providers both here and abroad.9 Again I truly realize the fact that each one of you has temporarily left your family and work.10 For some of you came here from very distant places. You came here not just because you11 want to find or rekindle friendships, which for me is also a good intent, however, if you have12 come for more noble cause that is to share each other experiences and expertise in order to13 cope with the dental health care services in this country in a higher, if not in a highest level14 of standard. I would also like to humbly state that I have also done my part as member of15 the Sanguniang Panglalawigan in the province of Cebu concerning improvement and16 upliftment of health care by passing legislations that I would someday listen to our people17 particularly in maintaining good health services and facilities. Moreover, I continuously18 advocate and fully support all the provisions and guidelines set forth by the Department of19 Health in providing quality health care services for our fellow constituents. Incidentally,20 aside from being member of the provincial board, this representation, also served as a21 community Chairman of public health and social services in the province of Cebu. My22 fervent wish is that due to our continuing efforts, the government and private sector will23 come up with a long term plan, strategy and system that would create and join impact that24 would deem not only the entire health provider but also its recipients as well. To all our25 dear delegates and participants may you fully achieve what you have been expecting for26 these three (3) days activities and I expect camaraderie within you to continue to flourish27 and to reach for the highest standard in serving our people. All these will remain in your28 hearts evermore. Lastly, I would like to commend all the men and women who have29 contributed so much of their time and efforts in order to make this event possible and30 successful one. I hope your stay in Cebu will be productive, pleasant and favourable one.31 God bless us all, daghang salamat sa inyong tanan.32 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:33 Thank you very much, Honourable Sergio Restauro for relating the message of the Governor34 to all of us here today! Now we would like to request you to please occupy the center stage35 and we would like to call our Speaker of the House of Delegates, as well as our PDA36 President to award the Token of Appreciation for our Keynote Speaker. Thank you very37 much, Hon. Sergio Restauro!38 We would like to call the President of Mandaue Dental Chapter, Dr. Gina Amador to receive39 the Plaque of Appreciation from the House of Delegates to Mandaue Dental Chapter. (Read40 the Plaque of Appreciation)41 DR. GERARDO CABAHUG:41 Short reminders for tonight’s activity. After this, we will have a roll call and for tonight the42 government of Cebu prepared a dinner for us at the Capitol Social Hall. So, please be ready!43 We will leave at 6:30. Also on Saturday morning, 2 days from now, the Governor herself44 approved a special show to be performed by the dancing inmates, the world renowned45 dancing inmates. The special show will be at 9:30 in the morning.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (10) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 Now, we would like to request the personalities in the presidential table to please go down2 for the recessional. Thank you everybody, we really enjoyed this afternoon with you! Have a3 great, great plenary!4 DR. PRECIOSA TANAGON:5 Marami pong salamat sa inyong lahat!6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 Its 3:49, I now call the house into order. Mr. Floor Leader, what is the next order of8 business.9 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):10 Good afternoon Madam Speaker, the first order of business is the roll call by our HOD First11 Secretary, Dr. Army Jane Chavez.12 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):13 Dr. Amry, please proceeds with the roll call!14 DR. AMRY JANE CHAVEZ (HOD 1st Secretary):15 Good afternoon colleagues. Honourable Delegates of the House of Delegates, we will start16 with Northern Luzon.17 AFP DENTAL CHAPTER DR. ANDREW REGACHO - Chief Delegate18 DR. RENATO GRACILLA - Alternate Delegate19 ANTIPOLO CITY CHAPTER DR. MARIA JAMILA DEL PILAR - Chief Delegate20 DR. ENRICO DOLATRE - Official Delegate21 KALOOKAN CITY CHAPTER DR. MA. CIELO CAJIUAT - Chief Delegate22 DR. ARIEL GO - Official Delegate23 I would like to ask for your understanding if I have mispronounced your name, ngayon24 palang po ako dito, salamat po!25 MALABON-NAVOTAS CHAPTER DR. MA. ISABEL GUTIERREZ - Chief Delegate26 DR. JACINTA BERNARDO - Official Delegate27 MANDALUYONG CITY CHAPTER DR. ROBELYN REYES - Chief Delegate28 DR. MARI JENIFFER YALUNG - Official Delegate29 MARIKINA CHAPTER DR. LIBRADA ALCANTARA - Chief Delegate30 DR. GISELA ORTIZ - Alternate Delegate31 PHILIPPINE NATIONAL POLICE CHAPTER DR. HELEN GRACE PILON - Chief Delegate32 DR. MARIA SUSANA PASCUAL- Official Delegate33 QUEZON CITY CHAPTER DR. MANUEL LUKBAN - Chief Delegate34 DR. LILLIAN EBUEN - Alternate Delegate35 SAN JUAN CITY CHAPTER DR. CRISTINA LACANILAO - Chief Delegate36 DR. ALVIN LAXAMANA - Official Delegate37 VALENZUELA CHAPTER DR. DONISIO CASIMIRO - Official Delegate38 SOURTHERN LUZON:39 LAS PIÑAS CHAPTER DR. MELECIO OSIAS - Chief Delegate
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (11) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. MARIA ROSARIO MATNOG- Official Delegate2 MAKATI CHAPTER DR. REY VICTOR ESTRELLA - Chief Delegate3 DR. ALMA SOLIMAN - Official Delegate4 MANILA CHAPTER DR. ANNA LEONORA CAMUS - Chief Delegate5 DR. DELIA CORAZON BARBA - Official Delegate6 MUNTINLUPA CHAPTER INC. DR. DONNA VASQUEZ - Chief Delegate7 DR. JOAN CARBONELL - Official Delegate8 PARAÑAQUE CHAPTER DR. RENOIR AMBA - Chief Delegate9 DR. ALEXANDER NIEVES - Official Delegate10 PASAY CITY CHAPTER DR. OSCAR DELOS TRINOS - Chief Delegate11 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE- Official Delegate12 I would like to go back to the City of Valenzuela Dental Chapter Dr. Helen Polloso. We will13 proceed to:14 PASIG-PATEROS-TAGUIG CHAPTER DR. SHEILA COBCOBO - Chief Delegate15 DR. ARLEEN REYES - Official Delegate16 REGION I - NORTH WESTERN LUZON:17 BAGUIO CITY CHAPTER DR. TERESITA VELASCO - Chief Delegate18 DR. RUTHGAR TECSON - Official Delegate19 BENGUET CHAPTER DR. IRENE CAYABYAB - Chief Delegate20 DR. FREDDIE SAYUCOP - Official Delegate21 ILOCOS NORTE CHAPTER DR. LIEZEL GAJETON-RAMOS - Chief Delegate22 DR. FRANCISCA CALUYA - Official Delegate23 ILOCOS SUR CHAPTER DR. GRACE INGUSAN - Official Delegate24 LA UNION CHAPTER DR. ARTEMIO LICOS, JR. - Chief Delegate25 DR. LAGRIMAS C. VALDEZ - Official Delegate26 PANGASINAN CHAPTER DR. EVANGELINE PADLAN - Chief Delegate27 DR. ARNEL BAGASAN - Official Delegate28 REGION II - NORTHEASTERN LUZON:29 TUGUEGARAO CITY/CAGAYAN DR. RYAN PACQUING - Chief Delegate30 CHAPTER DR. VICTOR TALLUD - Official Delegate31 ISABELA-QUIRINO CHAPTER DR. MA. LUZVIMINDA GARCIA- Official Delegate32 DR. CRESENCIA PALAGUD - Alternate Delegate33 NUEVA VISCAYA- IFUGAO CHAPTER DR. LARRY CABASAL - Chief Delegate34 DR. SHARON JOY MANALANG - Official Delegate35 KALINGA CHAPTER DR. JOCEL LANGCAUON - Chief Delegate36 DR. NICOLAS BALAIS -Alternate Delegate37 REGION III -NCENTRAL LUZON:38 ANGELES CITY CHAPTER DR. MARIA TERESA HENSON - Chief Delegate39 DR. LUIS MARIANO UY - Official Delegate40 BATAAN CHAPTER DR. MARDEM ARELLANO - Chief Delegate41 DR. ALLAN EUSEBIO ARELLANO- Official Delegate42 BULACAN CHAPTER DR. CHARLIE ANTONIO - Chief Delegate43 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ - Official Delegate44 NUEVA ECIJA CHAPTER DR. CYNTHIA REYES - Chief Delegate45 DR. MARIA CECILIA DIEGO - Official Delegate46 OLONGAPO CITY CHAPTER DR. MARILYN MARPURI - Chief Delegate47 DR. BERNABE FABIAN - Official Delegate48 PAMPANGA CHAPTER DR. JOSE MARI SANDIKO - Chief Delegate
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (12) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. JOCELYN MANABAT - Official Delegate2 TARLAC CHAPTER DR. MARIA FELICITAS SEVERINO - Chief Delegate3 DR. MAYLA SIENNA TIONGQUICO - Official Delegate4 ZAMBALES CHAPTER DR. JOSEPHINE ESCAÑO - Chief Delegate DR. MARIE JANE SORIA - Official Delegate56 REGION IV – SOUTHERN TAGALOG:7 BATANGAS PROVINCE CHAPTER DR. CRISTOFER TAGLE - Chief Delegate8 DR. ASUNCION SAMANIEGO - Official Delegate9 BATANGAS CITY CHAPTER DR. BENILDA ANASTACIA AMBIDA - Chief Delegate10 DR. ERLINDA ATIENZA - Official Delegate11 CAVITE CHAPTER DR. APOLONIA JOVELLANO - Chief Delegate12 DR. CHERYL DEL ROSARIO - Official Delegate13 LAGUNA CHAPTER DR. JONATHAN VITERBO - Chief Delegate14 DR. CORAZON FLORES - Official Delegate15 LIPA CITY CHAPTER DR. NESLYN TORRES - Chief Delegate16 DR. NIÑA ILAGAN - Official Delegate17 MARINDUQUE CHAPTER DR. CORAZON JOSUE - Chief Delegate18 DR. GILDA CALACHAN - Official Delegate19 OCCIDENTAL MINDORO CHAPTER DR. ROBELYN AGUILA - Chief Delegate20 DR. CIELO CAJAYON - Official Delegate21 ORIENTAL MINDORO CHAPTER DR. MERCYFE MANGAHAS ACEBILLO - Chief Delegate22 DR. CRISANTA CORALES - Official Delegate23 PALAWAN CHAPTER DR. CALYN VENTURA - Chief Delegate24 DR. KWARIZMAE KUHUTAN - Official Delegate25 QUEZON PROVINCE CHAPTER DR. VIRGINIA CHUA - Chief Delegate26 DR. ANTONIO LEON VALENCIA - Official Delegate27 RIZAL CHAPTER DR. MARLIN FRANCISCO - Chief Delegate28 DR. CYNTHIA TIANGCO-BALITE - Official Delegate29 ROMBLON CHAPTER DR. NICOLAE GADAONI - Chief Delegate30 DR. SUSAN FAJILAN - Official Delegate31 SAN PABLO CHAPTER DR. RICO CALINGASAN - Chief Delegate32 DR. FERNANDO SEE - Official Delegate33 REGION V – BICOL REGION34 ALBAY CHAPTER DR. ROMEL DE GUZMAN - Chief Delegate35 DR. GLORIA CRISTINA R. LLENO - Official Delegate36 CAMARINES NORTE CHAPTER DR. DOLORES LAVARRO - Chief Delegate37 DR. CECILIA JOY MANSILUNGAN - Official Delegate38 CAMARINES SUR CHAPTER DR. JESSIE ALBEUS - Chief Delegate39 DR. ROMMEL FAJARDO - Official Delegate40 CATANDUANES CHAPTER DR. HIDELITA G. POSADA - Chief Delegate41 DR. DAISY MAITA OSIDA-MANCITA- Alternate Delegate42 REGION VI – WESTERN VISAYAS:43 AKLAN CHAPTER DR. LUCY SALIDO - Chief Delegate44 DR. KAY DELA CRUZ - Official Delegate45 ANTIQUE CHAPTER DR. LUCILLE ANG - Chief Delegate46 DR. NOEMI ACUB - Official Delegate47 NEGROS OCCIDENTAL CHAPTER DR. MARISSA ARGEL - Chief Delegate48 DR. MARIE RITA ARANETA - Official Delegate
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (13) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 REGION VII – CENTRAL VISAYAS:2 BOHOL CHAPTER DR. MA. RAINELDA L. BARIMBAO - Chief Delegate3 DR. JOSEPHINE TAGO-YAP - Official Delegate4 CEBU CHAPTER DR. EDUARDO BERNADOS - Chief Delegate5 DR. LUCILO NIÑAL, JR. - Official Delegate6 MANDAUE CITY CHAPTER DR. GINA YUAMADOR - Chief Delegate7 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE - Official Delegate8 NEGROS ORIENTAL CHAPTER DR. LUIS LESTOR - Chief Delegate9 DR. MINDA REGALADO - Official Delegate10 REGION VIII – EASTERN SAMAR11 BILIRAN CHAPTER DR. FELICHITA BORNILLO - Official Delegate12 DR. FE SACLOLO - Alternate Delegate13 EASTERN SAMAR CHAPTER DR. GIL MAXIMO BEJAR - Chief Delegate14 DR. ROSARIO ARANAS - Official Delegate15 LEYTE CHAPTER DR. RAYMUNDO ESPOS - Chief Delegate16 DR. ROSARIO GEONZON - Official Delegate17 ORMOC CITY CHAPTER DR. ROMUALDO MOVILLA III - Chief Delegate18 DR. ERWIN INTO - Official Delegate19 REGION IX – WESTERN MINDANAO:20 DIPOLOG CITY CHAPTER DR. EPHRAIM HAYAG - Chief Delegate21 OZAMIS CITY CHAPTER DR. ERNESTO ANTEOLA, JR. - Chief Delegate22 DR. MARVIN LUZA - Official Delegate23 SULU CHAPTER DR. CHARINA ISAHAC - Chief Delegate24 DR. ADZJIRA ALLAMA - Official Delegate25 ZAMBOANGA CITY CHAPTER DR. MARY JOY ROXAS-FELICIANO - Chief Delegate26 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ - Official Delegate27 ZAMBOANGA DEL NORTE CHAPTER DR. MA. NEONIDA SY - Chief Delegate28 DR. CONCEPCION NAYRE - Official Delegate29 ZAMBOANGA DEL SUR CHAPTER DR. CORAZON PUNZALAN - Chief Delegate30 DR. APRYL DARLENE YAMBA - Official Delegate31 REGION X – NORTHER MINDANAO32 BUKIDNON CHAPTER DR. HELEN DAMASCO - Chief Delegate33 DR. ABELARDO RODRIGO - Official Delegate34 CAGAYAN DE ORO/MISAMIS ORIENTAL CHAPTER DR. LUIS BORJA III - Chief Delegate35 CAMIGUIN CHAPTER DR. JULIET JUNI-REYES - Chief Delegate36 DR. JULIET MONTALBA - Official Delegate37 ILIGAN CITY CHAPTER DR. AGNES SUOBIRON - Chief Delegate38 DR. GIUSSEPE MARTIN MICHAEL TIANCO - Official Delegate39 LANAO DEL NORTE CHAPTER DR. MARKQUITO NERI - Chief Delegate40 LANAO DEL SUR/MARAWI CHAPTER DR. SAMSIDA RAKIM-GANDAMRA - Official Delegate41 DR. NORHATA DATU-BEDAR - Alternate Delegate42 MISAMIS OCCIDENTAL DENTAL CHAPTER DR. ARTHUR ENANORIA - Chief Delegate43 DR. MARIA ANTONIA ENANORIA - Official Delegate44 REGION XI – SOUTHERN MINDANAO:45 DAVAO CHAPTER DR. SUSAN MALAGA - Chief Delegate46 DR. ALBERT DE GUZMAN - Official Delegate47 DAVAO DEL SUR CHAPTER DR. NORLYN BAJENTING - Chief Delegate48 DR. SARAH JANE RUIZ - Official Delegate
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (14) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 NORTH DAVAO CHAPTER DR. ELJEAN BENOLOGA - Chief Delegate2 DR. DAHLIA CANETE - Official Delegate3 REGION XII - CENTRAL MINDANAO:4 COTABATO CITY CHAPTER DR. TERESA MARIE USON - Chief Delegate5 DR. WILHELMINA MARQUEZ - Official Delegate6 NORTH COTABATO CITY CHAPTER DR. MARIA OLIVA DAMASCO - Chief Delegate7 DR. JOEL EDROSO - Official Delegate8 GENERAL SANTOS CHAPTER DR. LORA PAZ ARCAMO - Chief Delegate9 DR. FLORO FRANCISCO - Official Delegate10 KIDAPAWAN CITY CHAPTER DR. ALMA LUZ BANAWIS - Chief Delegate11 DR. FE DORCAS RUIZO - Official Delegate12 SOUTH COTABATO CHAPTER DR. MA. CARMEN SALCEDO - Chief Delegate13 DR. SHEILA MARIE TUAZON - Official Delegate14 SULTAN KUDARAT CHAPTER DR. MA. JOSELA DEFENSOR - Chief Delegate15 DR. HERTER INDANAO - Official Delegate16 REGION XIII – EASTERN MINDANAO:17 AGUSAN DEL NORTE CHAPTER DR. EMILIANO YUMANG - Official Delegate18 AGUSAN DEL SUR CHAPTER DR. DEWELL HIJOSA, SR. - Chief Delegate19 DR. LIZA BATUMALAKE - Official Delegate20 SURIGAO DEL NORTE CHAPTER DR. MARIA RODENA MADRIA - Chief Delegate21 DR. ANNA LIZA LERIO - Official Delegate22 SURIGAO DEL SUR CHAPTER DR. PABLO CHICANO - Chief Delegate23 DR. JUNETO MANIGO - Official Delegate24 Let us go to the affiliates:25 ASSOCIATION OF PHIL. ORTHODONTICS, INC. DR. MA. LAARNI SERAON - Chief Delegate26 DEPT. OF EDUCATION DENTISTS ASSOC. DR. JAY PEREY - Chief Delegate DR. MADELEINE OBIENA - Official Delegate27 DEPT. OF HEALTH NATIONAL ASSOC. DR. EDGARDO GAMAYO - Official Delegate28 OF DENTISTS29 ENDODONTICS SOCIETY OF THE PHILS. DR. ISABEL CAMPOS-BUSTOS - Chief Delegate30 DR. ROLANDO GONZALEZ - Official Delegate31 FILIPINO-CHINESE DENTAL FOUNDATION INC. DR. SUSAN CO-SABANDAL - Official Delegate32 OCCUPATIONAL DENTIST ASSOC. OF THE PHILS. DR. MA. MIRASOL CABAL - Chief Delegate33 DR. TERESITA CATAPANG - Official Delegate34 PHIL. ACADEMY OF GENERAL DENTISTRY DR. ALICE VILLADOS - Chief Delegate35 DR. MELINDA GONZALEZ - Official Delegate36 PHIL. ASSOC. OF PRIVATE SCHOOL DENTISTS DR. ROSANNA CORNEJO - Chief Delegate37 DR. BERNADETTE PALACOL - Official Delegate38 PHIL. COLLEGE OF ORAL MAXILLO-FACIAL DR. ROBERTO TAJONERA - Official Delegate39 SURGEONS DR. ROLANDO JAIME ALDECOA -Alternate Delegate40 PHIL. PROSTHODONTICS SOCIETY DR. MERLIN GO - Chief Delegate41 DR. VICTOR FRANCIS GREGORIO - Official Delegate42 PHIL. ACADEMY OF IMPLANT DENTISTRY DR. LEO GERALD DE CASTRO - Chief Delegate43 DR. PERCY BENITO - Official Delegate44 PHIL. WOMEN DENTAL FOUNDATION INC. DR. EDITHA MARALIT - Chief Delegate45 DR. EMMA BRIOSO - Official Delegate46 WOMEN DENTIST ASSO. OF THE PHILS. DR. ASTERIA CAMPANERO - Chief Delegate47 DR. MARIA BUENSUCESO GIMENA-Official Delegate
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (15) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 INTERNATIONAL ASSOC. OF ORTHODONTICS DR. DOMINADOR DACANAY - Chief Delegate2 DR. ALFREDO VALERA - Official Delegate3 PHIL. PEDIATRIC DENTAL SOCIETY, INC. DR. MARITESS VILLARICO - Chief Delegate4 DR. FENELLA ISABEL G. GALVAN -Alternate Delegate5 PHIL. SOCIETY OF ORTHODONTICS, INC. DR. FEDERICO NADELA - Chief Delegate6 DR. BEN RAMON ESPIRITU - Official Delegate7 PHIL. ACADEMY OF ESTHETIC DENTISTRY DR. MARYLOU FERNANDEZ - Chief Delegate8 DR. VICTOR TORRES - Official Delegate9 PHIL. ASSO. OF FUNCTIONAL JAW DR. APOLINARIO ALZONA - Chief Delegate10 ORTHOPEDICS, TMJ INC. DR. MARIA LOURDES CORONACION-Official Delegate11 NOVALICHES DENTAL PROFESSIONALS DR. DULCE AMOR JOSON - Chief Delegate12 DR. ISMAEL VINOYA - Official Delegate13 ALPHA-PHI OMEGA DENTAL ASSOC. DR. JOSELITO MILLONADO - Chief Delegate14 OF THE PHILS. DR. RONALDO NUÑEZ - Official Delegate15 Also present today we would like to acknowledge the 2 representatives from NADTI16 National Association of Dental Technologists, may I recognize Dr. Makoto Kobayashi and17 Mr. Bienvenido Nacorda. Once again I would like to sincerely apologize for Valenzuela18 Dental Chapter that I missed calling your name during the roll call, but I was able to call it19 back and I hope you understand for our shortcomings. And again thank you very much! We20 are now done with the roll call, Madam Speaker.21 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):22 Thank you very much, Dr. Amry! Mr. Floor Leader, what is the next item in the order of23 business?24 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):25 The next order of business is the report of the Committee on Accreditation and the26 determination of quorum by yours truly. As of 3:10 p.m., out of 227 accredited delegates27 we have 209 present, therefore Madam Speaker, we have a quorum.28 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):29 Thank you very much, Mr. Floor Leader! With 227 accredited delegates, 209 are present. It30 is my understanding that some of the delegates called to inform that there is poor weather31 condition in their area which is preventing them from coming over while others have very32 urgent personal reasons, so they will not be able to come. Mr. Floor Leader, what is the33 next order of business?34 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):35 The next order of business is the reading and approval of the minutes of the previous36 session.37 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):38 Dr. Amry Chavez, HOD First Secretary you are now directed to please read the minutes of39 the previous session. Yes, Dr. Caluya of Ilocos Norte.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (16) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. FRANCISCA CALUYA (OD Ilocos Norte):2 Madam Speaker, I move to dispense with the reading of the previous minutes considering3 the fact that everybody has been sent a copy and presumably everybody has peruse the4 minutes.5 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):6 Motion to dispense the reading of the minutes presented by our delegate from Ilocos7 Norte, duly seconded by Kalookan, Pampanga, Rizal, Malabon, Endodontics, General8 Dentistry, Angeles, Camarines Norte, Albay, Antipolo, Bulacan, Camarines Sur, Ilocos Sur,9 Mandaluyong seconded. Any discussion? Any objection, there being none, the reading of10 the minutes of the annual session is hereby dispensed. Any motion to approve the minutes11 of the Annual Session that has been dispensed with the reading. Lady from Bulacan.12 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):13 Madam Speaker, I move to accept the minutes of the previous meeting.14 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):15 Any second to the motion? Duly seconded. Any discussion? Objection? Hearing none, the16 minutes of the Annual Session is hereby accepted and approved. Mr. Floor Leader, what is17 the next order of business?18 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):19 May we request the technicals to please flash the agenda for today and for remainder of20 the Mid-year Session. Please show the summary of the agenda? Madam Secretary, can you21 please read the agenda for the Mid-year Session?22 DR. AMRY JANE CHAVEZ (HOD 1st Secretary):23 Madam Speaker, the agenda, Order business for today:24 1) Call to Order by Dr. Clarissa Jane Pe, HOD Speaker25 2) Call the Roll by Dr. Army Jane Chavez, HOD Secretary26 3) The report of the Committee on Accreditation and determination of quorum by Dr.27 Raymundo Lope, HOD Coordinator28 4) Reading and Approval of the Minutes of the previous session29 5) Approval of the Agenda30 6) Adoption of the House Rules31 7) Calendar of Business32 A. Business of the Day33 a.1 Presentation of Technical Working Group Chair34 a.2 Confirmation of the Comelec, Third member35 B. Clustering36 b.1 Presentation for Cluster37 b.1.1 Standard of Care Guidelines38 b.1.2 Group 2 – Constitutions and By-laws39 b.1.3 Group 3 – Code of Ethics and Republic Act 9484
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (17) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 8) Unfinished Business2 A. Treasurer’s Report3 B. Amalgam Phase Out4 C. New Business Arising5 c.1 PDA President Budget Presentation6 c.2 PDA Board Resolution No. 13, Series of 20127 c.3 PDA Board Resolution No. 14, APD Series of 20128 c.4 PDA Board Resolution No. 15, Series of 20129 c.5 PDA Board Resolution No. 16, Series of 201210 c.6 La Union Resolution No. 2, Series 201211 c.7 La Union Resolution No. 3, Series 201212 c.8 La Union Resolution No. 4, Series 201213 c.9 La Union Resolution No. 5, Series 201214 c.10 Las Pinas Resolution No. 1, Series 201215 c.11 Iloilo Resolution16 c.12 Ilocos Norte Resolution17 c.13 Philippine Academy of Prosthetic Dentistry 118 c.14 Philippine Academy of Prosthetic Dentistry 219 c.15 Kapisanan ng mga Dentista sa Bulacan KADEBU20 9) Other Matters21 10) Adjournment22 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):23 Thank you very much, Dr. Amry! The Chair will now call for, yes, Dr. Yumang.24 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):25 Question of Privilege.26 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):27 What is your question of privilege?28 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):29 We cannot memorize all those business for today, Madam Speaker, is it possible that we30 have a copy so that we can follow up the sequence of the proceedings.31 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):32 Your privilege motion Dr. Yumang is noted and we will direct now the Secretariat to please33 furnish all the delegates with a copy of the agenda for the Mid-year Session. The Chair34 would like to apologize for the late printing because there were last minute submissions of35 resolutions; in fact the last resolution was dated only this morning, so we have to edit them.36 So however, the Secretariat will provide everybody with the agenda in a few minutes. In the37 meantime (interrupted by Dr. Arlissa Aguiluz)38 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):39 Madam Chair, point of order.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (18) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 Yes, delegate from Bulacan.3 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):4 May we just furnish the Chapters and Affiliates who specifically request it, Madam Speaker5 to save money on printing and other cost, Madam Speaker?6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 So noted delegate from Bulacan. The Chair now calls for a raise of hands who among our8 delegates would like a printed copy of the Agenda. Just to remind you that the agenda was9 actually e-mailed to you and also in the USB that will be distributed to you together with the10 actual printed version. Sir, the Committee is distributing the USB, so because of these11 changes in the agenda there is a slight delay in the distribution of the USB. Anyway, po the12 purpose really is to approve the agenda for today, everything in the agenda is in the USB, it13 is more of the general program. So shall we still have printed copy, kindly raise your14 placards? Ok, so may I direct the Secretary to please prepare at least 20 and distribute or15 claim. The Secretariat is directed to print and distribute to the delegates who wants to have16 a printed copy of the agenda. In the meantime the Chair calls for the approval of the agenda17 as presented. Yes, Endodontic Society.18 DR. ROLANDO GONZALEZ (OD ESP):19 I move for the approval of the agenda.20 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):21 Motion presented to approve? Any second? Seconded General Dentistry, overwhelmingly22 seconded. Thank you.23 DR. ROLANDO GONZALEZ (OD ESP):24 One more thing?25 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):26 The Chair will have to rule before there will be any discussion. Ok duly seconded. Any27 discussion on the approval of the agenda? Any objection? There being none, the agenda28 presented is hereby approved. Delegate from Endodontic Society is that a privilege motion?29 What is your motion, Sir?30 DR. ROLANDO GONZALES (ENDODONTICS SOCIETY):31 Since we have 6:00 o’clock dinner at the provincial hall, I move for adjournment at 5:00 or32 5:30?33 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):34 So there is a privilege motion to adjourn, the motion presented by our gentleman from35 Endodontic is 5:00, I need to have a second to the motion so that we can discuss. Any
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (19) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 second? Seconded by Kaloocan and General Dentistry. Discussion? Motion to amend the2 one that is being discussed, the time, yes delegate from Laguna.3 DR. CORAZON FLORES (PDA VP Luzon-South/OD Laguna Chapter):4 I would like to manifest my observation that PDA has given so much money to have this5 session, can we please half of the resolution be discussed before adjournment. Is it possible6 Madam Chair to please move the appointment at the provincial hall, the dinner; is it7 possible, Madam Chair?8 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):9 Thank you, delegate from Laguna, our invitation for dinner at the capitol social hall is at 7:0010 o’clock, so we have to travel by bus, it is about 20 to 30 minutes given the traffic situation.11 So if we move fast and shorten our interpolation then we can for sure cover a lot within one12 hour, but that may mean that the delegates could not have to change to their casual attire13 and as you are we will proceed to the capitol social hall. So shall we set the time? Can14 anyone set a motion for amendment for the time that we can go on recess? Yes, delegate15 from Bulacan.16 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):17 Madam Speaker, I move to amend the time of recess up to around 6:15.18 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):19 Any second to the motion as amended? Duly seconded. Any discussion? Objection? Hearing20 none, the motion to have a recess at 6:15 is hereby approved. Mr. Floor Leader, what is the21 next order of business?22 The next order of business is the Adoption of House Rules by our HOD Secretariat, Dr. Amry23 Jane Chavez.24 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):25 Can we request the technicals to please flash the Adoption of House Rules and Madam26 Secretary, you are directed to please read.27 DR. AMRY JANE CHAVEZ (HOD 1st Secretary):28 House of Delegates Mid-Year Session 2012 Internal House Rules:29 (a) Seek recognition from the Presiding Officer by raising your place card before30 speaking. Upon recognition state your Name, & Chapter/Affiliate for record31 purposes. Always address the Presiding Officer. Speak clearly.32 (b) Quorum: A quorum is determined by the Constitution and By-laws the policy manual33 of an organization. A simple majority, which is 50% plus is the basic rule to be34 served.35 (c) No substitution of Chief and Official delegates shall be allowed for the Mid-year and36 Annual Session after the check deadline of HOD Accreditation Committee prior to37 the Mid-year Session.38 (d) Presenting a Resolution. Only duly accredited CD and OD of Chapter or Affiliate will39 be recognized to present a resolution.4041424344454647
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (20) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 (e) Debate: Discussant is given a maximum of five (5) minutes debate. A green light will2 turn on indicating the start of the debate. One (1) minute before the end of the3 allotted time, a yellow light will turn on. At the end of the 5 minutes debate, a red4 light will turn on and a buzzer will sound off signalling that your time is up and you5 have to go back to your seat.6 (f) Proponent of resolution is given ample opportunity to explain or to answer queries7 or any clarification.8 (g) All delegates shall observe proper decorum, including Dress Code.9 (h) All delegates are not allowed to engage in any form of social media when the House10 is in session.11 (i) All delegates are required to sign-in & sign-out every session.12 (j) ID must be worn throughout the session.13 (k) Chapter Chief Delegates and Official Delegates are allowed to vote. Affiliates are14 only entitled to one vote. Alternate delegates are not entitled to vote but may15 participate in the discussion.16 (l) Past HOD Speakers and Past PDA President and incumbent Board of Trustees may17 participate during the discussion but not allowed to vote or present a floor18 resolution.19 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):20 Thank you, Madam Secretary! The Chair now calls for the Adoption of the Internal House21 Rules. Delegate from Camarines Sur.22 DR. ROMMEL FAJARDO (OD Camarines Sur Chapter):23 I move that the House rules and regulations of the Mid-year Session be approved.24 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):25 Any second to the motion? Endodontics, PAFJO, AFP, IAO, Las Piñas, Negros Occidental,26 Manila, Cebu, Negros Oriental, Mandaue, Pasig-Pateros, Antique, Parañaque, Biliran, Ilocos27 Sur, Zamboanga and the rest. Any discussion to the motion to adopt the Internal House28 Rules as presented? Any objection? Hearing none, the House hereby adopts the House29 Rules. Mr. Floor Leader, what is the next order of business?30 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):31 The next order of business is the Calendar of Business, (A) Business of the day, (a.1)32 Presentation of TWG or Technical Working Group Chair.33 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):34 Ok the first business of today (a.1) Presentation of Technical Working Group Chair. May I35 now request our Technical Working Group Chair, Dr. Arlissa Aguiluz to present the output of36 the Technical Working Group that would be the need for the clusters for tomorrow?37 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):38 Thank you, Madam Speaker and a pleasant good afternoon to all my fellow delegates here39 in the HOD Mid-Year Session. I am very pleased and proud to be with you once again where40 I really and truly believe I belong. I am extremely pleased to present to you the mechanism41 behind the Technical Working Group. If I may familiarize you and go you through the
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (21) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 process by which we arrived at the TWG as it is properly called or as we are called by our2 leader who actually envisioned and planned all of these thinkers with guts.3 So the Technical Working Group was presented and approved as an AD hoc committee to4 the Executive Board on January early this year. It is actually envisioned and a project of our5 incumbent PDA President, Dr. Arturo De Leon, and his vision is to document and amend all6 four (4) documents effective in our practice of profession and our PDA in general. Apat po7 ang dokumento na kailangan natin na sunud-sunod at sabay-sabay na talakayin, sana ang8 natirang mga oras at araw ay ating harapin kasama po dito ang Code of Ethics, ang Republic9 Act 9484, ang ating PDA Constitution and By-laws, at ang hindi pa successful na natalakay na10 Standard of Care and Guidelines to put into practice in dentistry.11 Yours truly was very generously approved by the Executive Board as Chair of the TWG in12 March of 2012. Among the objectives of our Technical Working Group Clusters as we call13 them is to formulate the Standard of Practice or put into practice in dentistry or then we14 call it the TGCD. This is headed by someone whom I am proud to admit as one of the rising15 stars and icons of Philippine Dentistry particularly in the field of academe, my very own16 dean at the UP College of Dentistry, Dean Vicente Medina III, Sir, please stand up to be17 recognized.18 Hindi ho naging madali ang pagtalakay ni Dean Medina sa Standard of Care. Alam naman19 natin na ang SOC or Standard ay siyang pinakamabilis na pamantayan at pamamaraan para20 tayo ay husgahan kung tayo man ay nasasakdal sa isang husgado, and yet noon ako po ay21 inutusan ng ating President, Dr. Arturo De Leon na umattend ng Department of Health22 meeting, ang unang una pong hiningi sa akin ng DOH ay nasaan na ang Standard of Care ng23 Dentistry. Ako po ay halos manliit sa aking upuan noong meeting na iyon kaharap po ang24 mga fields of medicine, nursing, pharmacy, public health, veterinary med. At iba pang mga25 allied na professions, lahat po sila ay may sinusundan na Standard of Care maliban po sa26 ating propesyon. We claim to already to be in 100 years of dentistry in the Philippines ay27 walang maipakita ni isang pahina kung ano ba ang ating mga pamantayan at parang bang28 sinasabi ikaw ay isang magaling na dentista na tuloy na sumusunod sa mga serbisyo ng isang29 mahusay na dentista, wala po tayo nito. Pinaki-usapan po natin si Dr. Vicente Medina30 upang bumuo sa pamamagitan ng inyong tulong ng Standard of Care. Remember, the SOC31 will not cater to the specialist, iyan po ang aking pinakadiin-diin ngayon pa lamang. Ang32 ating SOC complete with guidelines in the practice of dentistry ay kailangan ng magtugon sa33 mga pangangailangan ng general dentists. Ano ang dapat gawin ng isang general dentist34 para masabi na safe ang kanyang practice of dentistry, iyon po ang tatalakayin niya sa35 kanyang cluster.36 Aside from our objectives to correct the provision of RA 9484 that are particularly37 erroneous katulad ng mga term of office na hindi akma sa limang examiner, mga definition38 of terms na kung titingnan natin ay hindi naman talaga tumutugon sa dapat na talakayin at39 iba pa. Naiintindihan ko noon, noong ako ay naging Speaker of the House limang taon na po40 ang nakalilipas na itong Dental Law ng 2007 ay biglang binagsak sa atin ng ating PRC at41 humihingi ng Implementing Rules and Regulations. Wala naman po tayong nagawa noong42 mga panahon na yon kung hind gumawa ng IFR sa pinakamainit at pinakamahusay na43 paraan ng ating nakayanan, pero limang taon na po yon, that was five (5) long years ago and44 who were our legal advisers then? One of them is, Sen. Joey Lina. Limang taon is limang45 taon. We are now entitled to agitate as professional organization to change and amend RA46 9484 and the Code of Ethics that includes if it no longer serves our needs particularly on the47 issue of integration. Every single day that we are here, existing as accredited professional
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (22) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 organization we are not actually able to implement the full measure of the law to the intent2 that is indebted. Bakit po? Hindi ho tayo talaga integrated number 1.3 (2) Kaya ba natin to integrate di ba? So andito po ang ating mga kasamahan mula sa hanay4 ng dental technologist pinangungunahan ni Dr. Makoto Obayashi. Sir, I wish to recognize5 your group, can you please all stand up they are here as observers and participants. Ang6 dami po nila sariling gastos po nila yan. Sila ay nandidito bilang commitment nila na7 makipagisa, tagapagsundo sa ating mga dentist. Nangluluklok din ako at the same time,8 Madam Speaker, kasi nadidiyan po tayong mga dentist at kahit andidiyan po ang grupo ng9 dental technologist ay hindi pa din natin maiimplement ang RA 9484 in terms of integration10 dahil wala ang mga dental hygienist. Dapat ho nating isipin mga kasama ko dito sa House11 dapat talaga tayong mag-integrate? That question I will leave up to you. Remember, kami12 pong mga cluster leaders ninyo ay hindi nandito para pilitin kayo na sumangayon sa ano13 mang legend na aming ihaharap rather, we are your voice to the PDA and to the14 government. You in turn as CD and OD should be voices of your Chapters and Affiliates15 society. Do not take this task that we are about to do tomorrow very likely. If you do, I really16 want tayo pa rin sa pancitan pag ito ay hindi natin naayos sa ating kagustuhan. This is our17 chance now five (5) years otherwise, we will continue all in all that we are not implementing18 the full measure of the law and PRC is already looking at us at why we are not able to do so.19 We are not accepting any excuses or alibis for that matter.20 Another objective is to add provisions that would benefit both public and accredited21 profession organization of dentists. Ito yung tungkol sa mga new provisions, so kung wala22 doon sa ihaharap namin sa inyo yung nasa isipan ninyo at nasa konsiyensya ninyo ay maaari23 kayong magsalita, di ba? Sabi nga nung teacher at yung ating mga lecturers hindi kayo24 nandito para mag-init ang inyong mga upuan, you are not bench warmers here. I wish that25 you will open up your mind, your heart and your mouth in order to speak otherwise we26 would not hear what you have to say. Wala namang maling opinion, ok lang ho kung hindi27 kayo makapag English ng tama, who cares, it is the thought and the concept and the28 substance and the thought that counts not the actual words that you use, but rather the29 thought that you’ve said with sincerity, honesty and above all with integrity. Kalimutan30 natin ang mga personal na motibo pagtayo ay nahahanap ng resolution kung maaari lang po31 ito ang aking pakiusap.32 To revise the Code of Ethics, yan din po ang kailangan nating harapin. Ano ba ang inyong33 panukala tungkol sa advertising na yan. Sino naman ang nagsabi na ikaw ay nagte-34 testimonial para sa isang dental product. Pag ikaw ba ay nanggamot at may nirecommend35 sa inyo na brand na toothpaste na ito dahil sa inyong masugit na paniniwala ito ang the36 best, yaon ho ba ay nagco-constitute ng testimonial and are you in fact being unethical?37 Yaon po ang aking ibig sabihin na dapat siguro tingnan hindi lang naayon sa current 201238 definition of terms, kung ano ang ethical and kung ano ang unethical? Keep an open mind39 about this.40 Ito po ang sulyap kung papaano natin io-organisa ang ating Technical Working Group,41 dalawa po ang aking hinahawakan diyan dahil iisa lang naman ho yung dokumentong yon.42 Ang akin hong cluster is Standard of Care and Good Clinical Practice of Dentistry, na aking43 nabanggit ay pinangungunahan ng aking dekanong UP College of Dentistry Dr. Vicente44 Medina III, kung walang the Third hindi daw siya yon kaya kailangan bangitin yung the Third45 and of course the Cluster PDA Constitutions and By-laws headed by an icon and a personal46 idol of mine in Philippine Dentistry, Dr. Diampo Lim, please stand up. Kasama po ni Dean47 Lim ang isang pang napakatunay nagtamo ng karangalan para sa ating Philippine Dental48 Association ang unang PDA President na nakakamit ng Accredited Professional Organization
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (23) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 best award ang ating Dr. Jess Tumaneng. We are very honoured to be with us, Sir. Salamat2 po sa inyo!3 Ano ho ba ang ating mga stratehiya upang tayo ay makabuo ng ating dokumentong ito? 3C4 ang ating gagawin (1) we must consult the proper stakeholders and that means identify who5 the stakeholders are? Kasama at kabilang kayo diyan, kayong mga PDA members, you6 represent your members from your Chapter from your area of practice, kasama ng ating7 mga Affiliates dami, daming Affiliates. Ano ba ang inyong mga concerns? Try to voice out,8 auxiliary, hygienist, and technologist and in my case in the Republic Act 9484, yes, I have to9 consult the unlicensed dental graduates. Dahil sa kanilang hindi matapos tapos na hinagpis10 tungkol sa refresher course na yan, so kasama po sila sa stakeholders for the Republic Act11 9484.12 The second scene, concur or not concur with the proposed amendments offered by each13 participants. Ang bilin pong maigi ng ating Speaker of the House, do it with courtesy, hindi14 po tayo kailangang magbastusan dito sa House of Delegates para lang maipadinig or para15 lang maiparating ang inyong nais maparating, you can do so calmly, gently, using the right16 words. Please let us observe professional courtesy with each other at all times.17 And lastly, the House of Delegates must concur with all the amendments. This is the18 particular power that is given to us by our Constitution and By-laws; no one can take it away19 from us, tayo lang po ang pu-pwedeng magpalit ng Constitution and By-laws at pag nabuo20 po natin ang SOC at saka ang amended RA 9484 tayo po ang magfo-forward nito sa ating21 PRC. The Mid-year Session is only but one venue wherein we can do this. Sabi nga ng ating22 Speaker matapos nating magcomment lahat ito ay ating iipunin at bubuuin at ilalagay sa23 tamang anyo at ito ay ating isusumite sa ating Executive Board na siya namang maghahatid24 sa PRC sa DOH at saka sa kinauukulang pang ahensiya ng gobyerno. Ang mga accredited25 Affiliates natin, I asked you if you have time tonight please consult your members regarding26 your declaration. If you want a particular concern especially in the Standard of Care, I27 understand na kayo ay mga dalubhasa sa inyong mga siyensa, pero tandaan po natin yung28 mga dental practitioners na hindi kasing dalubhasa ninyo, does not necessarily make them29 bad dentists if they did not do the techniques that you do? If they did not use the same30 equipment that you do, are they necessarily doing bad dentistry? So although almost all of31 you are specialists, keep in mind, the Standard of Care is for the general practitioner. Diyan32 ho natin aasahan ang ating mga ODs and CDs ng mga GT and if I present the PDA RGTs,33 insist and demand for your rights and privilege. Magbaliktaktakan tayo dito malinaw at34 maliwanag para sa ikabubuti ng lahat, and this will always subject, as the Speaker said, to35 the usual debate and discussion during the House of Delegates. All our concerns will also be36 published in our PDA website headed by our PDA Website Master Dr. Charlie Atienza. I37 wonder if he has arrived here in Cebu City. He will be available as a reference person to our38 Chapter and Affiliates ODs and CDs should we have any concern about posting on the PDA39 website. Ok and that is it, that is all my report, Madam Speaker. Where is Madam Speaker?40 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):41 Will the Speaker or the Deputy Protempore entertain? Speaker Protempore must entertain42 my interpolation supposedly.43 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):44 Thank you, Madam Speaker Protempore that ends my report.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (24) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. JOAN CARBONELL (HOD Speaker Protempore/OD Muntinlupa City):2 Dr. Yumang?3 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):4 My interpolation Madam Speaker Protempore, the Chairman just made mention at5 tinanong kung payag ba tayong mag-integrate itong prinesenta kanina. I would just like to6 ask the said Officer, the Chairperson, the approved resolution is way back in Fontana, May7 29, 2011. Approved Resolution No. 8, Resolution bringing the Philippine Dental Association8 to perform its insurgents, to perform its ministerial duty to integrate the National9 Integrated Association of the duly licensed of the member of the Dental Technology and10 Dental Hygienist Profession as mandated in Sec. 30 Republic Act 9484. That is why I don’t11 know why the Chairperson is asking payag ba kayong i-integrate? It is mandated in that12 Board Resolution, Madam Speaker Protempore.13 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):14 May I answer the question Madam Speaker?15 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):16 Yes, Madam Chair, please answer!17 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):18 I think the question of the Former Speaker strikes the very core of why we are doing this at19 all when he gently reminded me that there was indeed an approved resolution in the House20 way back last year, exactly the concerns, Sir. It is time now to review, are we really able to21 integrate? Because it is now time to take a look inside you and mentally exercise if we were22 able to interpret the law or should the law be interpreted to serve us. Iyon lang po ang ating23 question na itinatapon. I do not need to question the men of the House, the will of the24 House has already been expressed, what I am saying this is our chance to amend the Dental25 law. We do not have to sit still for another 5 years or 6 years before we agitate and move as26 a body in order to demand the changes due to us as a professional. I hope I am quite clear.27 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):28 Thank you, Madam Chair! Dr. Yumang?29 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):30 Yes, to rebut.31 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):32 Please proceed!33 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):34 As I have said, it is mandated, ministerial duty, it is a notification for the PDA per the PRC’s35 order and this has been right or wrong for us to do this, but the House or in Congress about36 this. That is all Madam Speaker.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (25) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 Thank you, Dr. Yumang! I think our Chair understands the point that is being raised by our3 Past Speaker. Madam Chair, could you please continue the presentation or?4 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):5 Madam Chair, I am done with the presentation.6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 Ok, Dr. Lim?8 DR. DIAMPO LIM (PDA Past President/HOD Past Speaker):9 Thank you, Madam Speaker. Just to answer the question of our good friend, Past Speaker,10 Dr. Yumang. That is the reason why we are going to have a cluster for tomorrow. It is11 because of the fact that we cannot do anything for the reason that the law states clearly12 that the dental technologist and dental hygienist will be integrated with the Philippine13 Dental Association, and so therefore, the reason why we are here is to find out how we will14 be able to integrate them? The solution that we are going to find out, how to integrate15 them? Are we going to integrate them in the same manner with that of the dental16 profession or whatever it is? That is now the role of the clustering of the committee that is17 initiated by the President of the Philippine Dental Association. Thank you, Madam18 Chairman!19 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):20 Thank you very much, Dr. Lim! Now that the Chair has presented how the Technical21 Working Group was created and what it aim to achieve during this Mid-year Session, I22 would like to solicit for the acceptance of the presentation of our Technical Working Group23 Chair. Yes, General Dentistry.24 DR. MELINDA GONZALEZ (OD PAGD):25 I move for the acceptance of the report of our Chairman. Thank you!26 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):27 Motion to accept the report of the Chairman. Any second? Seconded by ODAP, PAFJO,28 Endodontic, PPS, Cavite, Private School Dentists, Antipolo, Benguet, Lipa, Ilocos Norte,29 Camarines Sur, Ilocos Sur, Occidental Mindoro, Bulacan, Palawan, La Union, Pangasinan,30 Marikina, Malabon-Navotas, PNP, Kalinga, Romblon, Rizal, Zambales, Tarlac, Camarines31 Norte, Bataan, Anitque, IAO, Ormoc City, Fil-Chi, PSO, Women Dentist, Philippine Women,32 Las Piñas, Negros Occidental, Bohol, Cebu, Manila, Muntinlupa, Parañaque, Aklan, Pasay,33 Leyte, Biliran, Bukidnon, North Davao, Davao del Sur, Davao City, Misamis Occidental, Lanao34 del Norte, Sultan Kudarat, Agusan del Sur and Isabela. Any discussion on the report as35 presented by our Technical Working Group Chair? Yes Kalookan City.36 DR. ARIEL GO (OD Kalookan City Chapter):37 Madam Chair, point of information lang, can I address to the Former Speaker?
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (26) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 Please proceed!3 DR. ARIEL GO (OD Kalookan City Chapter):4 Ma’am, you mentioned a while ago regarding the implementing rules and regulations the5 House did sometime in 2007. Could there be a possibility na maretrieve natin yung file na6 yon? Kasi, I think we’ve worked for that for 3 to 4 days. The implementing rules that was7 not accepted by the PRC. I think during that time, ma’am, we imposed on it how to accredit8 and how to integrate the 2 other organizations in our organization.9 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):10 May I answer Madam Speaker the delegate?11 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):12 Yes, Madam Chair you may.13 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):14 Yes, I remember the IRR and I remember that both of us worked very hard on it. Thank you,15 Sir! I still have to thank you after all these years. I would try my best to look for my files, Sir16 or the then House Secretary, Thea Peralta, but please be informed that since 2007 I have17 undergone several floodings already in Bulacan particularly Ondoy and Habagat. I will do my18 best to retrieve the file. I hope you can try to retrieve yours and perhaps we can sit together19 and try to work out, but that is a pleasant problem Mr. Delegate, our task really is to go20 through the entire Republic Act, the existing law as is, correct what is needed to be21 corrected and you know that there are a lot to be corrected. Yung mga nanggagalaiti sa22 inis, sa kamalian ng dental law na ito, now is your chance, speak out please and we will all23 do our best.24 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):25 Thank you, Madam Chair! Any objection to the report of the Technical Working Group as26 presented? Hearing none, the report of the Technical Working Group Chair is hereby27 approved. Mr. Floor Leader, what is the next business of the day?28 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):29 The next order of business is A.2 Confirmation of the Third Member of the Comelec.30 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):31 Madam Secretary, please read the Executive Board Resolution, rather, Mr. Floor Leader32 proceed with the reading of the Executive Board Resolution on the confirmation of the33 Third Member.34 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):35 Philippine Dental Association Inc. Series of 2012-2013. Board Resolution Approving the36 Nomination and Appointment of Dr. Ramon Hebron as Third Member of the Comelec.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (27) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 Whereas, as enunciated in Art. 19 of the PDA By-laws, the PDA Commission on Election is2 composed of a chairman and 2 members;3 Whereas, Dr. Florata C. Villacorte, who served last administrative year 2011 as the Second4 Member is currently now the Chairman;5 Whereas, this above and called for an existing vacancy in the Comelec;6 Whereas, the PDA Board of Trustees during its 8th Regular Meeting held on August 10,7 2012 has accepted the nomination of Dr. Ramon M. Hebron;8 Whereas, having met all the necessary qualifications as define in the rules and regulations9 of the PDA -----, the Board approved the nomination of said Dr. Ramon M. Hebron as10 Third Member of the PDA Comelec;11 Now, therefore, be resolved as it is hereby resolved that Dr. Ramon Hebron’s12 appointment as Third Member of the Comelec is hereby approved by the Board.13 Signed Dean Arturo De Leon, DMD14 President15 Board Resolution approving the nomination/appointment of Dr. Ramon N. Hebron as16 Third Member of the Comelec, we the undersigned officers and members of the Board of17 Trustees of the Philippine Dental Association has approved this resolution this 10th day of18 August 2012.19 Signed:20 Dr. Arleen Reyes, EVP, Dr. Emmanuel Centeno VP Luzon North, Dr. Corazon S. Flores VP21 Luzon South, Dr. Elmer Cuevas VP Visayas, Dr. Jay Perey VP Mindanao, Dr. Fernando22 Fernandez President Elect.23 Board of Trustees Dr. Gary Brillo, Dr. Ma. Mirasol Cabal, Dr. Cheryl del Rosario, Dr. Asteria24 Campanero, Dr. Joven Javier, Dr. Gil Joseph Octaviano III, Dr. Maria Lourdes M.25 Coronacion, Dr.Erwin Into, Dr. Jocelyn Manabat, Dr. Rosalinda A. Acharon, Dr. Joel C.26 Edroso, also signed by the Ex-Oficio Dr. Roberto Tajonera, Treasurer Dr. Iraida De Leon,27 Auditor Dr. Nelson Magnaye.28 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):29 Thank you, Mr. Floor Leader! The Chair now calls for any objection to the appointment of30 the Third Member of the Comelec Dr. Ramon M. Hebron. Objection? It should be31 discussion. The Chair calls for a discussion? Kalookan City.32 DR. ARIEL GO (OD Kalookan City Chapter):33 Ma’am, I am not against the appointment of Dr. Ramon Hebron, but my question with34 regards to the customary of the appointment. As we all know Dr. Ramon Hebron is the35 Immediate Past Speaker, and eventual Immediate Adviser of the Speaker of the House,36 come April he will seat as Third Member of the Comelec and at the same time Advisory37 Board of the House. Second, he is going to be a member of the Council of Past Speakers38 may be in 3 years’ time, he is going to be the Chairman of the Comelec and at the same39 time Chairman of Council of Past Speakers just probably, so where will Dr. Ramon Hebron
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (28) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 stand? Is he going to be an administrative interpreter or Comelec member? That is all2 Madam Speaker.3 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):4 Thank you very much, Dr. Ariel Go! The Chair would like to seek the opinion of the5 Parliamentarian of this issue that has just been raised.6 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):7 Thank you, Madam Speaker! I think there is no problem being an adviser, he can always ask8 somebody to do the job, Dr. Hebron and we do not even know that Dr. Ramon Hebron9 would be the Chairman of the Council of Past Speakers. I think there is no problem with10 that.11 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):12 May I remind the body that Dr. Hebron’s position as Adviser is appointive in nature and not13 elective position. So, thank you very much for that concern. Any more discussion on the14 conferment of the position as Third Member of the Comelec, Dr. Yumang?15 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):16 As to my desire to make it clear for our young delegates it is not appointed, it is embodied17 in the Constitution that automatically the Speaker becomes the Adviser of the House18 particularly these people, so you need not appoint him, but it is embodied to make it clear19 for everybody especially the young delegates that it is embodied in the Constitution and By-20 laws House of Delegates that the immediate Past Speaker automatically will be the Adviser21 of the House of Delegates.22 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):23 Thank you very much, Dr. Yumang! I stand corrected on that matter. So any more24 discussion, last discussant? The Chair now calls for any objection to the conferment of Dr.25 Ramon Hebron as Third Member? Hearing none, Dr. Ramon N. Hebron is hereby appointed26 as Third Member of the Comelec. May we request Dr. Hebron to please come forward? May27 we call on our President Dean Turing to please come forward for the induction of our Third28 Member of the Comelec?29 DR. ARTURO DE LEON (PDA President):30 Madam Speaker, before the august body of the House of Delegate, as part of my ministerial31 duty I would like to officially administer the oath of office. May we request the member of32 the House to please rise as we administer the Oath of Office for Dr . Ramon Hebron? Please33 raise your right hand and repeat after me. (Citing the Oath of Office).34 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):35 Thank you very much, Mr. President and again congratulations to our new Third Member of36 the Comelec Dr. Ramon N. Hebron. Mr. Floor Leader, what is the next calendar of business?37 Ok, can we ask our Third Member Dr. Ramon Hebron to please come forward and say a few38 words?
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (29) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 COL RAMON N HEBRON:2 Madam Speaker of the House of Delegates, our parliamentarian, all members of the House3 of Delegates, magandang hapon po sa inyong lahat. Wala po akong masasabi kung hindi4 maraming salamat sa inyong pagtitiwala pagkat ito po ang ating tahanan na aking pong5 iniwanang salita, ang salitang integridad or integrity, service, teamwork, excellence and6 professionalism which will serves as my battle ground in every move. With this as Third7 Member I would say Ito rin po ang aking gagawin para sa kaunlaran ng Philippine Dental8 Association. Maraming salamat po at mabuhay House of Delegates.9 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):10 Thank you very much, Dr. Hebron! Mr. Floor Leader, what is the next calendar of business?11 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):12 The next calendar of business is B-Clustering. So this will be for tomorrow.13 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):14 Mr. Floor Leader, we still have 45 minutes, so we cover as much as we can until the15 designated time to go for dinner. We have deferred the clustering for tomorrow morning,16 so we will skip Letter B calendar of business, but we will proceed to the next order of17 business? Unfinished business, so what is the next order of business, Mr. Floor Leader?18 DR. RAYMUNDO EDESIO LOPE (Floor Leader/OD Pasay City Chapter):19 The next order of business is unfinished business, Treasurer’s report of the PDA Treasurer20 Dr. Iraida de Leon.21 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):22 May the Chair asks our Treasurer if she is ready to present her report as requested? May I23 remind the delegates that in the minutes of the Annual Session, page 36, line 1 to 10,24 Annual Session First Plenary, the report of the Treasurer from January up to September of25 2011 was accepted and approved, however, she was directed to present the last quarter of26 the report covering the period October to December of 2011. So, we would like to call on27 our Treasurer, Dr. Iraida. In the meantime, the Chair would like to call for a 5 minutes break28 to give time for our Treasurer to prepare her report.29 5 MINUTES RECESS30 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):31 The Treasurer is now ready to present the last quarter report. The Chair would like to32 acknowledge the fact that our Treasurer made a sacrifice to be here for this. She was33 supposed to stay behind because her daughter is in the hospital with dengue, but because34 of her obligation and duty, dental duty our Treasurer is here to present her report and with35 that I would like to say thank you very much, Dr. Iraida! So we will now proceed with the36 last quarter report.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (30) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):2 In accordance with Article 18, Sec. 8, Letter C of the Philippine Constitutions and By-laws,3 one of the duties of the elective Treasurer is to submit the Financial Annual Report to the4 members of the Board of Trustees. I will now present Financial Statement ending December5 31, 2011, audited by our elected Auditor Ma. Evelyn A. Gaytano.6 I suppose you have already a copy of my report. Please turn to page one on the last column7 po ending December 31, 2011. Our Assets for trust and short term investments:8 Unrestricted Funds P 808,264.339 Restricted special and fiduciary funds 8,232,784.2310 Total cash in short term investment (details on page 6 ) 29,041,048.5411 Ito po yung cash natin sa banko. Ito po yung naiwan na cash ng last administration. The P2112 million is deposited in different accounts.13 Page 6, The P21 million po is deposited in different branches and in different accounts14 although it was already approved na we will consolidate all accounts into 4 accounts. From15 Security Bank, we have 5 accounts, yung account No. 1877704 nasa page 6 po tayo, ang16 cash in bank po natin is P116,080.83. Eto po yung passbook, P116,000.00. Next po yung17 current account sa Security Bank Account No. 18777005 P 187,922.99, eto po yung18 passbook, eto yung amount. Mayroon po tayong time deposit same bank Security Bank ang19 total po na cash na andoon is P 6,400,395.41, another time deposit US dollar account po20 natin same bank Security Bank $133,649.88 dollars po ito kinonvert po namin sa peso nasa21 P5,746,936.24. May mga MayBank account po natin under Account No. 5000631 ang cash22 po na nakadeposit doon is P1,434,161.72, another account in MayBank with Account No.23 5000595 ang cash po nating nakadeposit don is P114,758.84. Next account, Account No.24 135000409 cash deposit P281,460.57, another MayBank Account with Account No.25 13500096-8 P213,535.31. Time deposit in MayBank P3,838,996.34, another Time Deposit in26 Account No. 13500904-3 P3,164,095.86. Mayroon po tayong dollar account in MayBank27 $274.06 US Dollars equivalent po sa Peso P11,784.58, another dollar account $227.10 US28 Dollars ang equivalent po sa Peso P 9,765.30, another dollar account $1,881.23 converted29 po sa Peso P80,892.89. Ang APDC Account po natin deposited sa RCBC Malayan30 P3,263,053.89, PBCom Alabang Branch P3,134,132.17, and dollar account po sa PBCom31 Alabang Branch $36,516.33 converted po P1,533,685.86, another dollar account at32 MayBank Parañaque Branch $1,646,11 converted to Peso P69,136.62. So yon po yung pera33 natin sa banko cash.34 Kindly refer again to page 1:35 Accounts Receivables po natin details po on page 4 P 58,000.0036 Loan Receivables 1,400.0037 Advances for Liquidation details on page 5 460,480.5338 Yung sa last column po liquidated na po ito Dr. Jonathan Acosta eto po kasi is for the39 printing of the Special ID for the Life Member for the Past Presidents and Past Speakers.40 Back to page 1 po ulit:41 Office Facilities and Equipment details on page 8 P 21,384,609.7742 Accumulated Depreciation (4,905,887.07)
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (31) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 Nasa Page 8, these are the nagpurchase po for this year One (1) Unit Server for Membership2 Database System P 305,500.00, andiyan pa po yung iba nating napurchase ang total po ng3 purchases natin P885,753.00.4 Under Liabilities and Fund Balance po natin nasa page 1 po ito, lower part.5 Under General Fund P 22,325,866.066 Special and Fiduciary Funds7 Welfare and Trust Fund 2,538,380.218 Publication fund 150,412.509 House of Delegates Fund (1,184,312.25)10 Legal Affairs Fund (161,695.50)11 Continuing Education Fund (2,879,410.89)12 Council on Dental Products 9,543,991.5213 PDA/APDC Fund (293,579.86)14 Building and Trust Fund 16,000,00.0015 TOTAL FUND BALANCE 46,039,651.7916 Kindly refer to Page 2 sa last column po for:17 Membership Income details on page 9 for 12,731 members at P500.00 ang total is18 P 6,365,500.0019 Membership allocation for the General Fund at 32.5%20 2,068,787.5021 Legal Affairs Fund at 5%22 318,275.5023 Chapter Rebates at 7.5%24 477,412.5025 Comelec Fund at 2.5%26 159,137.5027 House of Delegates Fund at 10%28 636,550.0029 Publication Fund at 12.5%30 795,687.5031 Continuing Education Fund at 12.5%32 795,687.5033 Welfare and Trust Fund at 17.5%34 1,113,982.5035 TOTAL OF 6,365,500.0036 Please refer on Page 2 Convention Proceeds37 15,073,784.5138 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):39 Excuse me Madam Treasurer, mahirap po talaga basahin yung nakasulat don in fact may40 medyo sumakit na yung mata namin doon. Since you submitted a report here, can you not41 just go over this report if and when you have any question then you can ask Madam42 Chairman para madali rather than going through with this and then babalik ulit sa atin for43 the question para mas mabilis. Is that possible?
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (32) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):2 Sir, konti na lang po I think the problem is the projector.3 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):4 Kasi I am sure that people at the back cannot even read or identify.5 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):6 They have naman a copy.7 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):8 That is why since all of us have a copy, let us just go over this and then if you have any9 question then address ok.10 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):11 I’ll just give the total for Publication, Sponsorship P230,000.00, Building and Trust Fund P812 million, Total Sponsorship donation of P19,690,000.00, Total of Other Income nasa13 P3,296,114.97, Total Expenses P32,791,667.07. Prepared by our Accountant Ms. Marilyn14 Ang, Checked by Yours Truly and Approved by Dr. Robert Tajonera.15 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):16 Thank you very much, Madam Treasurer! The Chair now calls for the acceptance of the17 report of Treasurer for the administrative year 2011. Yes APODAP?18 DR. RONNIE NUÑEZ (OD APODAP):19 Madam Chair, I move for the acceptance of the Treasurer’s Report.20 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):21 Motion to accept the report of Treasurer as presented. Any second to the motion? San22 Pablo, Camarines Norte, Cavite, Antipolo, Baguio, Private School, majority. Thank you! Any23 discussion on the report of the Treasurer for the administrative year 2011? Zamboanga24 City?25 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ (OD Zamboanga City Chapter):26 Just point of observation to our Treasurer. I’ve noticed that our dollar account has 327 deposits on different banks of which MayBank has a bigger deposits in dollar account, may28 we know for what reason Madam Treasurer, is it because of the interest rate or what?29 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):30 Yes Madam Chair, please answer the query of our delegate from Zamboanga.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (33) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):2 That is the interest rate, Sir, but the bank ito kasi medyo kilala na natin yung banko at3 madali tayong magtransact sa kanila although, last Board meeting we have already4 approved na all those accounts will be consolidated po, we are just waiting for the maturity5 of the dollar of the time deposit.6 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ (OD Zamboanga City Chapter):7 So the plan Madam Chair is to consolidate all the accounts into just one bank?8 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):9 Please address the Chair?10 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ (OD Zamboanga City Chapter):11 Yes, Madam Chair, may I know if the intention is to consolidate the whole account into one12 bank deposit?13 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):14 Madam Treasurer, please answer the query?15 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):16 Not in one account, but the Board approved to have it at 4 accounts, for Fiduciary Fund and17 for General Fund.18 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):19 Does that answer your query delegate from Zamboanga?20 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ (OD Zamboanga City Chapter):21 I am not well clarified with the answer, Madam Chair.22 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):23 As you can see po with the report, ang apat na account na ire-retain kasi po yung sa24 Fiduciary Fund, as approved by the Board, hindi po ako ang nagdesisyon ang Board po, yung25 Welfare and Trust Fund, makikita po natin on page 1 yung pong may malalaking amount po26 natin na sa Welfare and Trust Fund po, Continuing Education Fund, and Council on Dental27 Products po, so yon po ang nadesisyonan ng Board na ise-separate po yung account and the28 General Fund. Yung ibang hindi na ise-separate kasi laging negative tayo doon kasi ang ibig29 sabihin po ng negative mayroon po sa report na may mga allotment po tayo for the30 membership, so pag-negative po ibig sabihin po hindi po enough yung fund na naka-allot so31 kukuha po tayo sa General Fund. So yung bank account yung Fiduciary Fund io-one account32 na lang sa General Fund siya isasama.32 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):33 Does that answer your query gentleman from Zamboanga?34
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (34) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ (OD Zamboanga City Chapter):2 Still malabo, Madam Speaker. I’m sorry.3 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):4 Ok, can you please expound?5 DR. DIAMPO LIM (PDA Past President/HOD Past Speaker):6 Point of observation Madam Speaker.7 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):8 Yes. Dr. Lim?9 DR. DIAMPO LIM (PDA Past President/HOD Past Speaker):10 I think the gentleman from Zamboanga is asking are all our money deposited in one bank or11 several banks not the account that is what he is asking.12 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):13 I think that is not the gist of the query from the gentleman? Can you please restate your14 query?15 DR. ROMEO DELA CRUZ (OD Zamboanga City Chapter):16 Madam Speaker, my point of observation was that we have 3 different dollar accounts of17 which MayBank has a bigger dollar account, for what reason, kung bakit malaki yung dollar18 account sa MayBank compared to the 2 banks Security Bank and the other one.19 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):20 Ok, Madam Treasurer please answer the query?21 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):22 Yung iba pong kasi account na ito existing pa from the Past President, so naging choice po23 ng mga dating President kung aling account io-open po yon so dati nga po masyadong24 marami yung account diniside po ng Board na iconsolidate na lang sila, so naging choice po25 ng mga dating President nagpasok po noon month na yon kung ano po yung bank na26 pagdedepositohan noon pera.27 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):28 Ok, thank you very much! I think I can expound a little bit more. I was with the Board last29 night. For the information of everybody, the Board noticed the same query of the30 gentleman and it was decided that upon maturity of said accounts, it will be consolidated,31 but not into one single account po, it will be transferred to another bank but it will be32 consolidated upon the maturity. Hindi siya sabay-sabay kasi po may mga charges32 pagwinidraw natin before the maturity date. So the Treasurer will advice the Board when33 each of these accounts are due to mature saka lang po ita-transfer, in the meantime, we3334
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (35) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 can already open another account to transfer it. Di po ba ang nangyari kagabi sa Board2 meeting. So, does that answer the query of the gentleman? Ok, the Parliamentarian has an3 opinion.4 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):5 This is not an opinion but I want to ask the Madam Treasurer.6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 Wala pa po tayo sa discussion. So we are in the period of discussion, we just finished8 answering the query of the gentleman from Zamboanga. You have a query to the Treasurer.9 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):10 Madam Treasurer, last year kayo yung Treasurer di ba? This year kayo rin ang Treasurer.11 Now was there a formal turnover of all the records of the PDA from one administration to12 the other?13 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):14 Yes, Sir!15 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):16 You know on the first Board meeting, there is a portion there wherein the previous17 administration will turn over all the records of the PDA including the payables, receivables18 and everything, this is a turnover to the new administration, was there such an event that19 happened?20 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):21 Such an event happened, Sir.22 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):23 What is the response of Madam Treasurer? Was there a formal turnover?24 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):25 Yes.26 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):27 Considering that you are still the incumbent Treasurer of the previous administration you28 were the Treasurer also. So the query of the Parliamentarian was, was there a turnover of29 all the properties, money, receivables and obligations of the previous administration to the30 incumbent administration?31 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):32 During the first Board meeting there was a turnover.33
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (36) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 Ok.3 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):4 Just a follow up question. I understand, I just heard this that yung previous administration5 nag-iisue pa ng payables even after their term? I heard that mayroon payment issued by the6 previous administration way past your administrative year?7 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):8 Mayroon pong isang transaction yung payment po sa ating auditor.9 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):10 What is the date of the payment? The query is about whether there was a transaction from11 the previous administration after the turnover of the money and properties to the12 incumbent?13 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):14 Yes, ma’am.15 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):16 The Treasurer is answering in a positive response that means that there was one17 transaction of which it involves the payment for the Auditor po. Ok.18 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):19 Now since it is already being turned over, so the signatory now will be the incumbent20 President, how come you still issue payment to that effect, because the turnover you have21 to turn over to the new administration all the payables, receivables, and everything, so the22 previous administration will just inform the incumbent administration that there is such23 payment to be paid, so it will now be the incumbent president that will now issue the24 payment, why is it that you still issued even after the term?25 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):26 Ms. Marilyn told me that by phone lang November Ms. Marilyn? November, kaya lang po sa27 dami po niyang ginagawa namiss niyan yung for payment and then pinagawa po niya ng28 letter yung auditor para support po for whatever disbursement na ilalabas, so nagawa po29 yata ng payment ni Ms. Marilyn ng after January. I asked Ms. Marilyn, sa accounting daw po30 kasi expense po iyon ng past administration, so para po makita kung magkano talaga yung31 naiwan ng past administration since expense siya ng past administration. Ang accounting32 principle daw po mayroong 6 months na para iclose yung book.33 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):33 Ok, I would like to acknowledge the PCOMS delegate and the Immediate Past President Dr.34 Robert Tajonera to expound on the issue.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (37) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. ROBERT TAJONERA (PDA Immediate Past President/OD PCOMS):2 Thank you, Madam Chair! Privilege Madam Chair as Immediate Past President. It is true that3 there was a payment of a certain expenses that occurred during our last part of my4 administration because it is tradition that the external auditor be paid on the last usually on5 December or January or February of the previous administration and has been the pattern,6 but that payment is the payment of the auditing of the 3 previous administration. Ang7 nangyayari po parating huli talaga binabayaran, in fact on this year ang payment po niyan ay8 sa sususnod na taon kay Dr. Andy Fernandez. But the fact is the billing was given on9 November to our Treasurer and the payment was done a little bit late. There was a formal10 turnover, yes during the first board meeting but the payment was given December or11 February or January. Ang ibig ko pong sabihin the actual expense was due because of the12 past years ------------------13 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):14 Does that answer your query Dr. Parliamentarian.15 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):16 Sabi po ninyo kanina there is a grace period parang ganyan 6 months wherein the past17 administration or the Past President can still sign check, ano ba yon? what is that?18 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):19 Can sign check, Sir.20 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):21 What is this 6 months?22 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):23 Para i-close po yung book, to end all the transaction para maclose, kasi minsan po kasi24 paghindi nacheche-check hindi pa po nadedeposit ng ibang isuhan, so mayroon daw po na 625 months na period pa.26 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):27 Does that answer your query? We will entertain 2 more discussant and then the Chair will28 rule because it is already 6:18, we are are supposed to adjourn as 6:30. So just 2 discussant29 and then the Chair will proceed with the ruling. Yes IAO and then Ilocos Norte.30 DR. ALFREDO VALERA (OD IAO):31 Madam Chair, this question is with regards to the report, IAO donated P50,000.00 for the---,32 (sorry po, I do not know what is being said ABT THIS. they have raise the reward money for33 the acclamation of the hold upper and the money went through with 2:20:25------- but I34 could not find it? The list of our donation.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (38) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 Thank you delegate from IAO! May we inquire from the Treasurer where the donation of3 the IAO for the acclamation of the hold upper intended?4 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):5 Sir, nareport ko na po last session, it is included in the last session.6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 May I remind our delegates that the Treasurer is reporting for the last quarter of the year,8 so perhaps the query was covered already in the first 3 quarters of the year last November.9 So, may I advise our delegate from IAO to please review and sit down with the Treasurer10 where that part of the donation is reflected in the Treasurer’s report. So Dr. Caluya of Ilocos11 Norte last discussant.12 DR. FRANCISCA CALUYA (OD Ilocos Norte Chapter):13 Madam Speaker, may the Treasurer subject to a question?14 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):15 Please proceed.16 DR. FRANCISCA CALUYA (OD Ilocos Norte Chapter):17 I would just like to know Madam Treasurer, why Madam Speaker, why the Treasurer does18 not intend to put all the dollar accounts into one so that it will earn a higher interest. I know19 they may not mature all at the same time, but even as early part of the year they must have20 made a plan to the effect that they should put that all together so that it will earn higher21 interest.22 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):23 Thank you delegate Caluya, Madam Treasurer please answer the query of the delegate from24 Ilocos Norte!25 DR. IRAIDA DE LEON (PDA Treasurer):26 As I have mentioned a while ago that during the last Board meeting we already planned to27 consolidate all the accounts so we are just waiting for the maturity of the dollar accounts28 and we will transfer it into one account.29 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):30 Ok, I think that sufficiently answers the query of our delegate. Ok, one last discussion from31 our Speaker Libertad Nolido.32 DR. LIBERTAD NOLIDO (HOD Past Speaker):33 Madam Speaker, I feel that we -----miss straighten -----our procedures in our financial34 aspect. At the end of each term, all assets, liabilities including accounts payable and account
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (39) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 receivables should be turned over to the next administration and it now becomes the2 responsibility of the new signatories to disburse the money for accounts payables, there3 should be a cut off, it cannot be just because there are accounts payable the old4 administration after its term will still continue to disburse that is a big no, no, I think. That is5 all Madam Speaker.6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 Thank you very much, Past Speaker Nolido. So, after a period of discussion the Chair now8 calls if there are any objections to the acceptance of the report of the Treasurer? We have9 an objection from the delegate from Bulacan. The Chair now rules that we will divide the10 house rather to approve the Treasurer’s report or not. May I request our secretariat Dr.11 Amry, Dr. Renzy, Dr. Jen Yalung, to please do the head counts? The objection is against the12 approval of the Treasurer’s Report.13 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):14 Point of Inquiry, Madam?15 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):16 Yes, delegate from Bulacan.17 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):18 Would the approval, point of inquiry po ito Madam Speaker, would the term approval of the19 Treasurer’s Report mean that there will be an end to inquiry and that report is immediately20 accepted as factual and realistic? Would that encompass the term approving the report?21 We would no longer be able to ask the Treasurer certain relevant questions regarding the22 conduct of disrespect.23 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):24 Yes, that is correct delegate from Bulacan. When the Treasurer’s Report is approved,25 therefore all queries will not be entertained anymore and that means it is accepted en toto.26 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):27 May I continue with due respect with my fellow delegates. May I continue with another28 clarification?29 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):30 Yes proceed.31 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):32 Would such an approval by the House, of the Treasurer’s report accept certain parties from33 further action by the House of Delegates in the future, Madam Speaker?
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (40) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 May I be clarified on what certain actions in the future are you saying Madam Delegate3 from Bulacan in particular? Or what kind of action in the future because acceptance of the4 report means that, the approval of the report means that the report are factual and has5 been accepted and approved by the delegates, and therefore, it doesn’t mean that you6 cannot make inquiries, but that the House has accepted the report as factual report.7 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):8 Madam, I beg your indulgence! By means of making further inquiries would that mean that9 on the next session of the House, the Treasurer will still be available to continue answering10 certain questions that are still very much in our minds or will that close the window and11 would mean to seek another systems by which we can address our query?12 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):13 Madam Speaker, point of inquiry.14 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):15 Delegate from Agusan please, I would like to yield first for the Parliamentarian before I16 acknowledge you.17 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):18 This is point of information. This needs to be attended to as protocol procedure.19 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):20 Yes proceed.21 DR. EMILIANO YUMANG (HOD Past Speaker/OD Agusan del Norte Chapter):22 I would just like to remind the Chair whatever will be the ruling of the Chair can be appealed23 whatever the result so we can go on with the decision.24 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):25 So noted. Thank you very much, Delegate from Agusan! Ok I would like first to yield to our26 Parliamentarian before the Chair will proceed with the division of the House.27 DR. LUIS UY (HOD Parliamentarian):28 Madam Speaker if only we have enough time sana we can discuss this we cannot close case29 in this report yaon ang dapat nating gawin, but if you have objection to this report and we30 have to divide the house.31 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):32 The Chair rules that we will proceed with the division of the House.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (41) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):2 Madam Speaker, excuse me but I am still on the floor and I have not received an answer to3 my query.4 DR. RONNIE NUÑEZ (OD APODAP):5 Madam Speaker point of order?6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 What is the point of order?8 DR. RONNIE NUÑEZ (OD APODAP):9 Just a while ago Madam Speaker, I moved for the acceptance of the Treasurer’s Report for10 2011, is there any motion for the approval? Because we are in the process of acceptance of11 the report, we are not yet the fact that we have not received any motion for the approval of12 the Treasurer’s Report Madam Speaker?13 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):14 We already accepted earlier and there was already a motion for approval, we were in the15 period of discussion.16 DR. RONNIE NUÑEZ (OD APODAP):17 Madam Chair, may I know then who moved the motion for approval? It must be on the18 report.19 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):20 May I request our Secretary Dr. Bem?21 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):22 Madam Chair, point of order. We would have not gone in the period of asking if there is an23 objection if there is no motion for approval, and so I objected.24 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):25 Let us clarify from our Recording Secretary to set the records straight. Delegate from26 APODAP is asking if we already finished the acceptance and we are now on the process of27 approval.28 DR. RONNIE NUÑEZ (OD APODAP):29 Madam Speaker, if I remember it right we are in the process of questioning the Treasurer30 and then suddenly there was a division of the house, I would just like to have a query on the31 motion for the approval.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (42) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. MARIA ARLISSA AGUILUZ (HOD Past Speaker/OD Bulacan Chapter):2 Madam Speaker, may I with your kind approval?3 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):4 Hold on please we are in the process of reviewing. Ok, based on the report of our Recording5 Secretary, Dr. Bem we are still in the period of acceptance and discussion and I called for an6 objection therefore it was not an approval that we are in, so that was only for the period of7 acceptance. So the Chair stands corrected. So, in as much as there is an objection in the8 acceptance of the report, the Chair now calls for the division of the house whether the9 report of the Treasurer is accepted. If the report is accepted, if there is no objection sana10 we will go to approval but we have to back track we are still in the period of acceptance and11 there is an objection, now the house will go into division whether to accept the report of12 the Treasurer or not, malinaw po ba? I will now direct our officers, 2 Secretaries and our13 Floor Leader and our Peace Officer, only the Chapter CD and OD will get one vote each,14 Affiliates will only be entitled to one vote. Look at your ID only those with stickers.15 DR. ---------:16 Madam Speaker, Point of clarification.17 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):18 Sir, we are in the point of division of the house.19 DR. ---------: (?)20 I would just like to inquire Madam Speaker, acceptance po ba or approval?21 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):22 Acceptance, Sir. Thank you!23 R. CHERYL DEL ROSARIO (PDA Board of Trustee/OD Cavite Chapter):24 Privilege motion, Madam?25 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):26 What is your privilege motion?27 DR. CHERYL DEL ROSARIO (PDA Board of Trustee/OD Cavite Chapter):28 Where are the white and black voting cards?29 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):30 We will not use that, in your ID there is a cover, Madam Secretary, what is the color of the31 voting delegates? Yellow sticker on your ID po, iyon po ang gagamitin to signify yong yellow32 iyon po ang bibilangin natin. Only delegates with yellow sticker are allowed to vote on the33 motion. Ok may I repeat the motion that we are dividing the house for? To accept or not to34 accept the report of the Treasurer. Those who are in favor, please raise your ID with a
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (43) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 yellow sticker? Acceptance po, those who are in favor of the acceptance of the Treasurer’s2 Report? May I remind the delegates after the Chair has ruled on this we will have to go on3 recess.4 DR. CHERYL DEL ROSARIO (PDA Board of Trustee/OD Cavite Chapter):5 Privilege motion Madam Chair?6 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):7 We are in the period of division? What is your privilege motion?8 DR. CHERYL DEL ROSARIO (PDA Board of Trustee/OD Cavite Chapter):9 Madam Chair just to remind the Secretary or those who counts, Madam Chair sa Affiliates10 dalawa din ang sticker.11 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):12 Isa lang po yung yellow.13 DR. CHERYL DEL ROSARIO (PDA Board of Trustee/OD Cavite Chapter):14 Dito po dalawa po silang may sticker na yellow, so ang ibig sabihin puwede silang mag-vote15 pero isa lang dapat.16 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):17 Isa lang for the Affiliates. Yes, only one will be counted.18 DR. MARI JENNIFER YALUNG (HOD Peace Officer/OD Mandaluyong Chapter):19 Madam Speaker 90 voted to accept the Treasurer’s Report.20 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):21 For those who are against please count record purpose, those who are against the22 acceptance of the Treasurer’s Report?23 DR. MARI JENNIFER YALUNG (HOD Peace Officer/OD Mandaluyong Chapter):24 50 are against.25 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):26 So out of 209 accredited and delegates present 90 voted for the acceptance of the27 Treasurer’s Report, 50 are against so I presume that 69 have abstained in the votation.28 DR. JOAN CARBONELL (HOD Speaker Protempore/OD Muntinlupa Chapter):29 Point of inquiry.
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (44) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):2 Yes.3 DR. JOAN CARBONELL (HOD Speaker Protempore/OD Muntinlupa Chapter):4 Can we count the abstained?5 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):6 The abstention?7 DR. JOAN CARBONELL (HOD Speaker Protempore/OD Muntinlupa Chapter):8 E kasi parang hindi na interesado yung iba e?9 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):10 Hindi po with 209 present delegates.11 DR. ---------: (?)12 Madam Chair we have to deduct the number of Affiliates.13 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):14 Yes, we will deduct the number of Affiliates present. Can we have the number of the15 Affiliates present? Dr. Del Castillo, how many Affiliates are present?16 DR. ROLANDO JAIME ALDECOA (Alternate PCOMS):17 Madam Chair, can I make a point of order please?18 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):19 What is your point of order?20 DR. ROLANDO JAIME ALDECOA (Alternate PCOMS):21 I think we should respect the result of the votation, to those who have abstained to vote. I22 think that is out of order because they made a decision not to vote, I think we have to23 respect their decision.24 DR. CLARISSA JANE PE (HOD Speaker):25 We are not forcing them to vote we are just getting the numbers right. It is just to get it26 right. We are not forcing them to vote because we have to deduct the number of Affiliates,27 so do we have the number Dr. Del? How many Affiliates present? For the record 90 voted28 for the acceptance of the Treasurer’s Report and 50 voted against and counting only one29 per Affiliate Chapter, those that abstained, so 53 abstained, therefore, the report is30 accepted. Now since we have gone past the time for recess, the Chair rules that the motion31 to approve will be postponed until tomorrow. We will reconvene at 8:00 a.m. May I urge
Minutes of the Meeting PDA-HOD Midyear (1st Plenary Session) PAGE (45) OF Waterfront Hotel & Casino, Lahug, Cebu City September 27, 20121 our delegates to please review if you have any questions because that will be your2 opportunity to ask the Treasurer’s Report if it is approved.3 Ok, instructions to all our delegates please proceed to the check in area, the buses that will4 be carrying everybody to the Provincial Capitol Social Hall is already there. We are expected5 at the Capitol by 7:00 p.m. We project that the program, the dinner will be finished not later6 than 10:00 o’clock, so we expect that the delegates will avail of our buses. There are 6 buses7 awaiting our delegates at the lower ground floor of the check-in area. That is all! Have a8 pleasant evening at the Capitol Social Hall and see you tomorrow at 8:00 a.m. Breakfast will9 start at 5:30 in the morning at Café Uno.10 RECESS