Veteran Patient Agency


Published on

Published in: Health & Medicine, Business
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Veteran Patient Agency

  1. 1. Research Proposal in Economic Outcomes David Paschane, Ph.D. Veteran Patient-Agency The purpose of this research initiative is to prepare VA for effectively adopting transformations in service delivery strategies, especially those that focus on post-military transitions. Although the initiative emphasizes healthcare, the same model is appropriate in all VA-managed services. Increasingly, healthcare providers are designing services that adapt to patients’ roles in managing chronic and behavior-based conditions, adapting to home-based and spouse-based services, and controlling processes through technological advancements. The underlining driver in these transformations is patient-agency, which is the degree to which patients can and are willing to manage their healthcare processes. VA is not well-prepared for this transformation because it uses institution-based management structures. Although VA is serving veterans with unique transitioning risks, the VA emphasis is not on the veteran as the manager of these experiences. A lack of reinforcing patient-agency can lead to unsuccessful restoration efforts by VA, including unwanted consequences, such as diminishing a veteran’s agency development. Therefore, it is necessary for VA to develop an expertise in understanding, responding to, and protecting patient-agency and its role in restoring physical, psychological, and economic capacity in veterans. Definition: Patient-agency is the ability of a patient to evaluate, decide, and act according to personal preferences. Its potential scope includes all the functions that are relevant to healthcare management, and that can be transferred to the patient. These include control over (1) visible and understandable information, (2) flexible and efficacious processes, and (3) effective and authoritative decision-making. Successful treatment and prevention of the most prevalent health problems, chronic diseases and behavior-driven conditions, is dependent on patient-agency. Target: Two groups of veterans are at high-risk because of diminished patient-agency. First, service members returning from OIF/OEF face a combined set of stressors that include combat traumas and transition anxieties, which can undermine patient-agency sustainment. Second, veterans with diagnosed or latent service-connected mental health problems can have underdeveloped patient- agency because of restoration difficulties. Purpose: The purpose of this initiative is to fund a targeted research agenda that includes three interconnected foci. First, produce a standardized method for measuring patient-agency in rehabilitation, medical, and processing settings, in terms of its development and sustainment. Dr. David Paschane, VA 008A, Page 1
  2. 2. Second, explain the short-term and long-term impact of stressors on patient-agency change, in terms of psycho-physiological differences between women and men, intensity and duration of stressors, and the mediation of innovative communication and control devices. Third, construct a streamline evaluation of VA programs that determines how each interacts with veterans and affects the overall physical, psychological, and economic restoration goals, in terms of changing patient-agency. Benefits: A patient-agency protection initiative can help guarantee that VA is appropriate, effective, and efficient. First, a patient-agency expertise in VA can ensure that veterans are fully supported throughout their life course, especially as they transition from military to civilian life. As VA supports veterans overcoming physical, psychological, and economic hardships, it must guarantee that its processes enable rather than diminish patient-agency. This is a crucial objective, as patient-agency can affect veterans’ successful utilization of transition counseling, retraining assistance, employment assistance, and physical and psychological treatments. Second, patient-agency protection provides a unique research framework that is appropriate for addressing the complex needs of veterans. Such a framework can help VA target a hierarchy of research and reform goals, so as to ensure that VA resources are effectively responding to changes in veterans. Third, VA will benefit from the efficiency and consistency it can build into its programs, by tailoring best practices in terms of how VA affects patient-agency and at what costs. These insights can become standards for consistent and adaptable operations. Background: A breadth of research illustrates that patient-agency is a primary driver of demand and outcomes in healthcare. It is the patient who presents the illness, requests assistance, weighs the risks and benefits, consents to care, and continues the process through changing health status, treatment, and health-related behaviors. The following citations identify evidence that speaks to the critical role of patient-agency in healthcare: Healthcare Outcomes • Greater sense of control enhances patient’s resiliency (Diesnstbier, 1989; Herbert and Cohen, 1993; Sieber et al., 1992; Wiedenfeld et al., 1990). • Disengaged cancer patients tend to have unfavorable outcomes (DiClemente and Temoshok, 1985; Greer, Morris, and Pettingale, 1979; Pettingale et al., 1985). • Pain control training produces better dosage schedules and less pain at follow-up (Rimer, Levy, and Keintz, 1987). • Cardiac patients who can control visits and their timing demonstrated lower mean heart rate and diastolic blood pressure (Lazure and Baun, 1995). Utilization Management Dr. David Paschane, VA 008A, Page 2
  3. 3. • Preparatory information is associated with shorter hospital stays, reduced morbidity, and reduced need for analgesics (Eisendrath, 1987). • Video presentations on back surgery improved patients’ knowledge about options and reduced the demand for surgery (Deyo et al., 2000; Phelan, 2001). • Under severe conditions (ovarian cancer), greater understanding of information is a strong determinant of treatment choices (Elit, Levine, and Gafni, 1996). • Patient-controlled analgesia devices maintain effective concentrations (Hull and Sibbald, 1981) while keeping constant rates (Austin, Stapleton, and Mather, 1980). Medical Communication • Patients’ medical comprehension is dependent on clarity and specificity of the content (Hall, Roter, and Katz, 1988), and manner of delivery (Larsen and Smith, 1981). • Patient’s medical objectivity is appropriate, given age (Stiggelbout et al., 1996; Yellen, Cella, and Leslie, 1994) and responsibilities (Yellen and Cella, 1995). • Patients are consistent in medical decisions (Cassileth, Seidman, and Soloway, 1989; Danis et al., 1994; Everhart and Pearlman, 1990; Slevin, Stubbs, and Plat, 1990). • Patient’s can communicate preferences when multiple trade-offs characterize complicated treatment decisions (Brundage et al., 1998). Twenty years ago, researchers experimented with how VA could affect patient-agency through innovative techniques (Greenfield et al., 1985). They found that both veterans and programs could benefit significantly from designs that reinforce patient-agency development. The examination was of a 20-minute pre-visit coaching program. The study demonstrated sustained and significant benefits in patient-agency and physical health, without additional clinical time. In their conclusions, they contended that without well-developed patient-agency, veterans “may not acquire the knowledge, skill, and more importantly the confidence and sense of control they need in the management of chronic disease” (p. 456). The study also illustrated that reinforced patient- agency could help mange unnecessary use of healthcare services and improve veterans’ ability to prevent acute health problems. Dr. David Paschane, VA 008A, Page 3