This lecture was presented to the Duke Talent Identification Program (https://tip.duke.edu/node/334) at the Pisgah Astronomical Research Institute (http://www.pari.edu/).
4. History
1960: NASA Exobiology Program
1976: Viking missions to Mars
1995: Extrasolar planet orbiting a sun-like star
1996: Controversial Martian Meteorite
Today: Exoplanets, Mars, Titan, and
Europa
Source: http://www.nasa.gov/50th/50th_magazine/astrobiology.html
5. Key Questions
How does life originate?
How does life evolve?
What kind of environment is necessary for life to survive?
What are the environmental limits or “extremes” under which life can survive?
What might life look like on another world?
Is there or has there been life elsewhere in our solar system?
How can we observe and identify a habitable – or even inhabited – world?
What is humanity’s future on Earth and beyond?
7. Hierarchical View
• Universe (one or many)
Galaxies (~150 Billion Galaxies)
Milky Way (~100 Billion Stars)
Solar System (Sun, planets..)
Earth
Life
Source: Margaret Race, NASA, 2010 Teachers Workshop
8.
9. Early Conditions
• Liquid water
• Energy source
• UV (sun), Electrical
(lightning), chemical
(hydrothermal vents)
Source: theecolologist.tumblr.com
10. The Origin of Life
Exogenesis / Panspermia
Life came to earth from elsewhere in the universe
Autotrophic
Hydrothermal vents
Heterotrophic
‘RNA-World’ Theory
RNA self-replicating
Miller-Urey Experiment
Source: http://www.ib.bioninja.com.au/options/option-d-evolution-2/d1-origins-of-life-on-earth.html
13. Common chemical
model?
Fitness
Weak A:T and strong C:G
is optimal
Chance
Random & conserved
Past selective pressure
Adenine’s precursor used
to be more abundant /
favorable
Adenine
-weaker bond
Amino-Adenine
-stronger bond
Source: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1367593104001358
17. Handle Information
Metabolize resources in environment to construct
parts
Carry out self-replication
Display some sort of evolution
Necessary
Characteristics of Early
Life?
18. Alternative Life Forms
Carbon based life
Silicon?
Germanium?
Metal Oxides?
Heteropoly acids
Polyoxometalates
Source: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1367593104001358
19. Polyoxometalates
Source: Lee Cronin http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20906-lifelike-cells-are-made-of-metal.html
https://youtu.be/unNRCSj0igI?t=10m5s
20. Non-Water Solvents
Hydrocarbons, ammonia (NH3), sulfuric acid, liquid N
/ H
Why water?
Wide liquid phase (T)
High heat capacity (heat per degree)
Large heat of vaporization ( L G)
Amphoteric (Acid & Base)
Density: S < L
38. Mars: H2O
Gale Crater
Salt Brines in a daily
water cycle
Recurring slope lineae
Source:
http://www.nature.com/nge
o/journal/v8/n5/full/ngeo2
412.html
Glacial features
49. Terraforming Mars
Introduce greenhouse gases
raised temperature
vaporized CO2 in the south polar cap
Melting ice
increased atmospheric pressure
suitable for trees
51. Sample Topics
Physics of light, gravity, matter,
energy, magnetism, radioactivity,
nuclear energy and relativity
Evolution of life on Earth
Biochemical machinery of all living
organisms
Uniqueness of the organisms on
Earth inhabiting very extreme
environments (extremophiles)
Geology of volcanism, plate
tectonics, atmosphere, and erosion
as applied to all planets
Chemical composition of space
H-R diagram and its role in
understanding the evolution of all
stars
Physics, chemistry and biology of
space exploration and habitation
Suitability of life on comets
Origin of the Universe
Origin of our solar system and the
planetary systems
Birth and death of stars and
galaxies
Does life require a dynamic
environment?
52. One last thing….
Source: http://tierra.rediris.es/Geoethics_Planetary_Protection/geoethics_JMF_AGID.jpg
53. Policy & Ethics
Ethical Concerns
Colonization
Monuments
Terraforming
Resource use
Environmental Concerns
Space junk
Forward contamination
Back contamination
Regulatory Concerns
Regulation (private vs.
government vs. UN vs.
world democracy)
Tourism
Sacred celestial bodies
54. Works Cited*
https://depts.washington.edu/astr
obio/drupal/content/what-
astrobiology
Dr. Margaret S Race, NASA
Astrobiology Teachers workshop
2010
http://www.space.com/15498-
europa-sdcmp.html
http://www.ucl.ac.uk/~ucbpmbo/
something.html/Work_files/Case
%20Presentation%203.pdf
http://www.powershow.com/view
/242d5-
YmFhY/Astrobiology_an_Introduc
tion_powerpoint_ppt_presentation
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tar
digrade
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gia
nt_tube_worm
http://www.astronomynotes.com/
starprop/s3.htm
http://www.hou.usra.edu/meeting
s/abscicon2015/program/topics/
*: resources directly cited in presentation not included here
Editor's Notes
Introduction
What I want them to get out of talk
explain their presentations
think about topics for their presentations
this is a broad overview and is certainly not exhaustive
Goal: give you a broad overview of the topic & some areas of current research and controversy
1959 = first project
1976 – viking missions had 3 biology experiments to look for microbial life – some unexpected chemical activity but no clear evidence
1996 – alan hills 84001 metoerite, found in antartica, left mars 17 million years ago, earth for 13,000
And then one more bullet point for now
How does life begin and evolve?
Is there life beyond Earth and, if so, how can we detect it?
What is the future of life on Earth and in the universe?
Universe been around for 14billion years. Earth for 4.5 billion years.
Humans as a genus, only a few million years old
Homo sapiens, 200,000 years old
If earth history was a year long video, humans would not appear until the last hours of Dec 31st.
How did we start?
Synthesize more complex organic compounds from simple building blocks
i’m only giving a quick summary, but these are all really interesting topics which a lot of research is focusing on:panspermia – comets or meteorites
Autrophic – means it can produce its own energy – simple organisms got energy source from pyrite on hydrothermal vents
Heterotrophic – consumes other things (ie all the stuff floating in the prebiotic soup). Complex molecules formed in soup that could store information and do enzyme like activity
Stanley miller and harold urey
The experiment used water (H2O), methane (CH4), ammonia (NH3), and hydrogen (H2). The chemicals were all sealed inside a sterile 5-liter glass flask connected to a 500 ml flask half-full of liquid water. The liquid water in the smaller flask was heated to induce evaporation, and the water vapour was allowed to enter the larger flask. Continuous electrical sparks were fired between the electrodes to simulate lightning in the water vapour and gaseous mixture, and then the simulated atmosphere was cooled again so that the water condensed and trickled into a U-shaped trap at the bottom of the apparatus.
To skip past 100’s of millions of years, get to where we are now. Much of astrobio about this process, so why is this important for studying space? Why does what happens here matter for other life? Ask them.
Have all of you studied evolution? Raise you hand if so.
Why ribose (for RNA) and deoxyribose (for DNA)?
Is the DNA-RNA-Protein essential?
Past selective pressures may no longer exist, or they may
So what? Examining the reasons and path that life has taken on earth can offer clues into what earth may look like elsewhere
Liquid solvent
generally regarded as necesarry: Solute, temperature, polarity
What do you t
Energy,respond to enviroment, grow, reproduce, adapt, cells, levels of organication
Carbon is much more abundant in the cosmos and is more versatile (t can bond with more different types of atoms)
The Cronin group at Glasgow University reported self-assembly of tungsten polyoxometalates into cell-like spheres
Heteropoly acid - class of acid made up of a particular combination of hydrogen and oxygen with certain metals and non-metals.
By modifying their metal oxide content, he can give the spheres a hole as part of its structure and become a porous membrane, selectively allowing chemicals in and out of the sphere according to size.
The purple thing is them creating a membrane inside the cell to mimic the nucleus/ now this is old, and wasn’t ultimately successful but it gives you an idea of the types of work you can do.
So weve now looked at the chemical bassis for life.
Subsurface liquid water is considered likely or possible on several of the outer moons: Enceladus (where geysers have been observed), Europa, Titan.
To compare this to ammonia, it’s abundant, can donate/accept proton ( not as well as water) BUT weaker h-bonds so
heat of vaporization less, its surface tension to be a third, and reducing its ability to isolate non-polar molecules through a hydrophobic effect
Energy source - anything
Chlorphyll degrade @ 75 C
Organic molecules decompose @ 150 C
Can reanimate organisms at -200 C, but hard for them to be active, partly because enzyme are so slow & ice crystals can rupture cells
Radiation increased during solar flares
Halophile – typically have high concentration of chemicals so that water from the internal cytoplasm doesn’t want to escape into the salty environment outside, or they accumulate more salt in the cell
Psychrophiles have more flexible bonds so they don’t rupture, antifreeez proteins that lower the freezing points of other biomolecules
Thermophiles have stronger bonds
Temp, acidity, salinity
Defines a region of possible life. Not a cuboid structure, it is dented in corners and extends at the bottom level
What do you think this means? One conclusion: dealing with one extreme can hurt it’s ability to deal with another aspect
Up to a mile deep near hydrothermal vents
How can they survive without oxygen? Usually needed by mitochindria for aerobic respiration
Use a different process involving hydrogenosomes
Swedish university: 10 days in space
Survived space vacuum, UV radiation, cosmic rays
They can dessicate and then rehydrate when water is available again
Also: heat (300 degrees F -, cold (almost to absolute zero), pressure
Not technically extremophiles, because are not adapted to live in this conditions, and more will die longer they are out there.
What I want to stress about this research into extremophiles is that there is no one form of life. When looking outwards, know types of conditions that life has adapted to on earth can offer clues as to what to look for.
Additionally, we must consider forward contamination, there are overlaps between conditions on earth and in our solar system, notably Mars.
Cannot be directly imaged – any ideas why not?
A star with a planet has its own small orbit because of the gravity of a planet. Then you measure these variations regularly you can measure the gravitational impact & mass of a planet
the displacement of the spectral lines due to the doppler effect
towards you: blue shift – higher frequency & smaller wavelength
away: red shift – lower frequency and bigger wavelength
Planet crosses in front of parent star. Gets you the planet size, and later (with the radial velocity method as well) its density and mass.
Hard because have to be perfectly positioned, gotten over this by massive scans of 100,000’s of stars.
Green shades – habitable zone / goldilocks zone (within a stars habitable zone)
Size of the circles – radius of planets (estimated from mass when not known directly)
amount of energy reaching each square centimeter of a detector (eg., your eye, CCD, piece of the sphere) per unit time (gets smaller as you get farther away) . Related to the inverse square laq
amount of energy reaching each square centimeter of a detector (eg., your eye, CCD, piece of the sphere) per unit time (gets smaller as you get farther away) . Related to the inverse square laq
Passing Galileo spacecraft shows the little moon has a dense core and a rocky mantle. It appears that it has a liquid water ocean beneath the ice crust.
Heat may be provided by the decaying elements in this core
Chemical base for creation of complex molecules
Liquid Solvent
Energy Source
Very cold, liquid hydrocarbon lakes, thick atmosphere with carbon rich compounds but mostly composed of nitrogen
left: array in chile, shows the spacial maps of gaseous chemicalls: hydrogen isocyanide , cyano-acetylene
east-west zone formation: saturns magnetic field, unknown atmospheric circulation patterns, or thermal effects
Chemical base for creation of complex molecules
Liquid Solvent
Energy Source
Brine streaks caused by seeping water
Chemical base for creation of complex molecules
Liquid Solvent
Energy Source
So what? Methane can be part of biological activity and this methane is both created and used up in a very rapid seasonal cycle
Bit of controversy about the source
Type I civilization: can use all the energy on their planet (we are .7)
Type II civilization: can use all the energy on their host star
Type III civilization: can harness all the power comparable to that of the milky way galaxy
Filter: life to start,
prokaryote eukaryote
The universe has only recently calmed down enough, used to be gamma ray bursts that would kill everything
Hasn’t been this much time for life to form
What I think – we have only been listening for 50 years in the universe that is around for 14 billion years.
This is a bit advanced, so I’m only going to touch on most of these subjects. Try to not get overwhelmed, instead just think of the big topics.
Two types of objects – chiral and achiral (or not chiral)
Chira (shoes)l vs achiral (baseball bat, pen)
R & S enantiomers (or versions, of the same molecule)
Racemic mixture
In pharmcuedical industry, all drugs have to be either the R or S enantiomer, because they can have different properties
So why is this important? b/c All amino acids in proteins are ‘left-handed’, while all sugars in DNA and RNA, and in the metabolic pathways, are ‘right-handed’
Typically, it was thought you cannot get a mix of R and S in what is called achiral conditions (baseball bat). An interesting debate,
the chiral product precipitates from the solution
I show this example to get you thinking about all the different disciplines that get involved here. Chemists, geologists, astronomers, engineers, all together in this field
Stress: this is not likely, but an interesting topic
Greenhouse effect – thermal radiation from a planet surface is absorbed & re-radiated back by atmospheric gasses, so average temp increases
In this context, a runaway greenhouse gas trigger can cause the boil off of a planets oceans
Broad range of topics
When you choose what you want to present on, think about the range of things
Start from earth and move outward
origin of life, evolution, habitable planets,