. When we say product we usually mean physical goods, but services are also included in them; yet to clarify we can say product and services; also called offering . Ideally a manager does not do anything individually; rather uses resources like human, material, and financial to achieve the objectives of the firm; in practice there is a balance between coordination and hands-on work, which will vary from firm to firm and within the same firm based on the leadership style of the manager
. Perceived need – may occur when an ad or a sales representative makes a convincing pitch . May be both non-durable and durable
. The advertising manager is responsible for all promotion activities except sales . In some companies the ad manager has the title of Marketing Communications Manager . Classic brand management structure developed by P&G in 1930s . Commonly used where different products use the same channels of distribution
. Product or brand champion
. Narrow – inability to step back and ask more fundamental questions about customer needs . Centralized – may lose geographic/regional focus on product benefits to target customers . Short-term – due to this there has been a dramatic increase in the use of short-term marketing tools such as sales promotions for consumer packaged goods, may stifle innovation . Several salespersons – particularly for industrial products, overload marketing data information . Managers will have individual budgets, ad agencies, media channels partners
. The advertising manager is responsible for all promotions activities except sales . In some companies the ad manager has the title of Marketing Communications Manager
. Segments - may be industry, channel, region of the country or world, or customer size . Differences – lead to differences in the marketing strategies and tactics used to appeal to the customers in the segments
. The advertising manager is responsible for all promotional activities except sales . In some companies the ad manager has the title of Marketing Communications Manager
. Embedded – it is common for sales and marketing research to be separate functions in most organizations
. The Web is a new channel of distribution - early 1990s, communication medium, way of creating a community around a brand; can be used for both customer acquisition and retention, and brand building; the Web needs to be integrated into the marketing and communication plan . IS – better and more timely information on market share, sales and distribution ; scanners, database marketing, data mining . A major trend started in the 1990s was the realization that one of the greatest assets a company has is its set of brands and the image and confidence the consumers have in them, brand equity – the value of the brand name, not just descriptive labels but are product attributes that require consistent investment for maintenance and enhancement . Balance of power has shifted from manufacturer to retailer . Lifetime value of a customer concept, stream of income from future purchases . Worldwide competition; need for international experience and knowledge of marketing in different cultures and regions; formation of trading blocks, NAFTA, EU, MERCOSUR .
. At the center is the core or physical product, distinctiveness or differentiation is based on the outer layers which are subjective, and the service factors are on the outermost, especially if the physical product features have low differentiation
. 6 major market factors impact market attractiveness . PLC – product life cycle
. Is an important piece of data about any market . It is clearly an important determinant of the likelihood that a product will generate revenues to support a given investment . Both large firms and entrepreneurial firms might find large markets attractive . Large markets tend to draw competitors with considerable resources making it unattractive for small firms . Thus, absolute size by itself is not sufficient to warrant new or continued investment
. P&G developed the US market for disposable diapers, but the high growth rate supported the entry of other firms such as J&J and Kimberly Clark . In technology firms fast-growth means dramatic shift in market share and virtual disappearance of rival products . In the Internet browser market, Netscape had 13% of the market and Mosaic 60%; by 2002 Netscape had 8%, Mosaic had disappeared, and Microsoft’s Internet Explorer held 91% . Thus, growth brings the prospects of increasing revenues but also dynamic market structures in terms of competitors
. In the introduction and growth stages the sales grow rapidly, in maturity it levels off, in decline it drops steadily . In maturity the sales volume is high, growth rate is low, market is at its peak – large Rs volume with slow growth – like in the consumer packaged goods – classic patern for soft drinks, fast food . Not always clear – introduction and growth may be attractive to pioneers from a long-run market share perspective . Product in the growth phase are not ensured success – failures of Osborne and Commodore personal computers, and AT&T and HP in the home PC market
. Inter-year – like ice cream, woolen clothes, rain gear, agriculture is affected by climate . High capital intensive businesses such as automobiles, steel, machine tools are often affected by . Businesses tied to interest rates such as real estate, financial services are also susceptible to cycles general business conditions . Many firms attempt to develop products and acquire other businesses to eliminate or offset inter-year sales cyclicity
. Differences in profitability across industries is due to a variety of underlying factors like factors of production (capital, labor, raw materials), manufacturing technology, and competitive rivalry . Profitability varies with time, variance in profitability is often used as a measure of industry risk . Semiconductors offer abnormally high returns when demand is good but poor returns when it slumps . Food related industry on the other hand produce relatively steady, if unspectacular, profits . Product managers must make a risk-return trade off, evaluating expected returns against the variability in those returns
. + is positive, desirable, - is negative, undesirable
. How are barriers to entry set up?
. Scale – barrier in the automobile industry, Ferrari is content to serve the high priced market segment; in non-manufacturing – hospital supplies – profit margins are better for larger orders; in service industry – it costs about the same to set up for a few customers or retailers as for many, large advertisers usually get quantity discounts when buying block media time on TV, radio, others, so it is hard for a new entrant to compete . Large capita – for manufacturing, chain of stores, or marketing programs . Switching – cost of switching form one supplier to another, high in the computer industry, FedEx has given its corporate customers software with they can track their own packages, so it is difficult for another delivery company to make the FedEx corporate customer switch; airline industry offers mileage program so customers get a free trip after a certain number of miles; it is hard to create switching barriers in the consumer products industry, consumer change brands frequently . Distribution – new entrants can find it difficult to obtain shelf space to compete with multinationals; supermarkets may charge slotting fee; CP and P&G copied Minnetonka, Inc’s innovative pump for hand soap; barriers change over time due to expiration of patent; lock up distribution and supply arrangements . A product manager can ask: is there anything I can to make it more difficult for a new entrant or a current competitor to compete against me legally?
. Low profits means supplier cannot charge more . Backward integration – if computer manufacturers make their own chips, forward if they open their own retail stores . Buyers – say customer – has detailed pricing information on cars can negotiate the sticker price by choosing the right manufacturers options available . The product manager’s objective is to decrease buyer power by increasing product diff., helping customers become more profitable through services such as technology assistance or manufacturing/product dev./marketing related consulting, and building switching costs . Buying power of individual consumers in not substantial, but as a group or co-operative it can be high; industrial businesses can have high buying power . High buying power is not attractive if you are or want to be one of the competitors in the markets because buyers can force down prices, and play competitors against one another . Governments have high buyers power generally
. High supplier power is not attractive as they can dictate price, delivery conditions to the buying category . Concentrated – dominated by a few firms, few microprocessor manuf. - like Intel, AMD; few supercomputer manuf. – like IBM, Cray, NEC . No substitutes – OPEC power increases and decreases, is now on the rise, they produce oil and natural gas, and the global requirements for energy is such that coal and other sources are not strong substitutes . Differentiation – AK Steel supplier to GM – offers delayed payment plan, guarantee of no work stoppages, a demonstration of cheaper steel can be used in certain areas, extra services such as supplying steel with adhesives for certain applications . Supply limited – demand is high, buyer has little option to extract special terms . To counter it – product managers can look for new sources of supply, substitute materials, other strategies
. Rivalry – Compaq – Dell in the PC business, Intel – AMD in the microprocessor business, Disney – Six Flags in amusement parks, Sony – Matsushita in consumer electronics . Many or balanced – fast-food, automobiles, PCs; Boeing and Airbus (EU) became balanced by Boeings acquisition of McDonnell Douglas . Slow growth – in a mature market slow growth can come only from a competitor . High FC – pressure to run at full capacity to reduce unit costs – so capital-intensive industries like paper and chemicals are highly competitive . Lack of differentiation – product looks like a commodity . Personal – Sun’s Scott McNealey and Microsoft’s Bill Gates; Oracle’s Larry Ellison and Siebel’s Tom Siebel, even thoguh Siebel woked for Oracle
. Soft drinks high – more generic, broadcast media, tractors few
. Travel industry – during recession resorts are empty, rates drop
. (+) is positive, desirable, (-) is negative, undesirable . Helps to decide whether firm should be or continue to be in the category, product manager can compete better in the particular product category
. These factors are outside the control of both the firm and the industry, though the industry may have some leverage – external . External factors are unrelated to the product’s customers and the competitors that affect marketing strategies . Vulnerability of a product category to changes in the environment is an unattractive characteristic, to be dealt with . Changes in the environment can be opportunities to gain competitive advantage
. High-tech – computers, technology changes in 18 months . Home banking has not become very popular – customers have a desire for customer service . Packaged goods industry – although packaging technology improves – the sales are driven by marketing programs
. Alcohol, tobacco . Pharmaceutical . Intervention – helpful to the industry, auto and textile dumping, agro restrictions helps
. Trends – important to consumer product companies . Derived demand – generated by the consumer for B2B . Young adults – affluence – furniture, electronics, appliances, upscale fast-food, clothing, financial services, travel services . Mature adults – want to reduce their psychological age – sports cars, clothing, financial services, travel services, over 40 years . Children – indirect purchasers . It is said that – today customers can pretty much have what they want when they want it and at the price they wish to pay – airline ticket booking via Internet, due to information . Socio-economic trends
. Commercial data services, standard industrial classification, SIC code, used by the US Govt. . Managerial judgment – using primary data – talking to distributors; using secondary data – salespersons reports . Behavioral data – secondary data from commercial firms – A. C. Nielsen or Information Resources, Inc.; households are enrolled with the firms and their scanning data at the store is analyzed by them . Customer judgments – primary data
. Generic category of deserts; developed through focus group research that identifies products satisfying a given need . Product brands are placed near the vectors; then a judgment can be made as to what the competitor set might be . 1) judged overall similarity – for a pair of products . 2) similarity within consideration set – large set of products divided into groups in which each is a substitute for another . 3) product deletion – in a group that are substitutes for each other, if one is deleted or not available, which one would the customer select from the choice set or . 4) substitution in use . Perceptual mapping – is part of using customer judgment – judged overall similarity measure
. C I gathering is for large as well as small firms . Microsoft deployed a team of engineers and marketers specifically to track Linux, the fast-growing, free operating system that had become popular . The team has attempted to convince potential corporate users that Linux is nota real competitor to windows . Frontier Airlines hired former United Airlines planning executive and its planning director to get ‘ inside’ United’s corporate head; instead of scheduling more flights Frontier learned that if it flew only twice a day to a city, United was not likely to increase its capacity on that route . Tom Sternburg, founder and CEO of Staples, the office supply superstore, drops by one of his stores and a competitor’s; focuses on what the competitor is doing well – customer service, store visibility, displays, how easily the prices can be read
. Product managers should always begin a competitor analysis with a search of secondary sources of information . Internal sources – information about competing products already exists within the company or division in past marketing plans, special strategic studies, lying around in someone’s office . Audits – for publicly held companies – stock market companies . Government – regulated industries like power, insurance, infrastructure development have to reveal a lot of information to the govt. like pricing, or to obtain contracts and bids, which are public information
. Most underutilized source, interact with the customer on a regular basis, are in an excellent position to find out about sales pitches, pricing, delivery schedules on a routine basis, merely by observing, can send information to corporate wirelessly with a notebook or laptop, sales report sheets can have a competitor tracking section for intelligence gathering . Suppliers – are willing to give information about competitors to impress potential buyers and high volume clients, carton manufacturers name and address is on the carton – calling them can provide information on the volumes on account of the number of cartons purchased by the customer . Customers – may feel it is not ethical or in their interest of time and effort, but some may give their opinion about the product they have used or someone they know has used . Employee can observe changes in packaging, price, shelf display at the supermarket or store . Firms develop reports, forecasts – as part of their business – e.g. media spending by brands, advertiser spending in the various media . Consultants – can be hired to develop special reports, as opposed to generic reports used in secondary data . Investment bankers – develop detail analysis of prospects, they can provide information to a potential new client, can be part of secondary data as well
. Reverse – purchase the product and take it apart, or try it, or taste it; one can purchase and use the software, open a bank account; the information can be used as bench-marking for quality and cost of manufacturing or assembly; Xerox benchmarked Canon copiers and tried to beat each component of the latter’s machines on cost and quality; in designing the Lexus, Toyota bought competitor’s cars, including 4 Mercedes, a Jaguar XJ6, and 2 BMW’s, put them through performace tests, and then them apart . Test markets – some companies test market products in limited areas of the country or the world to better understand decisions about pricing, advertising, and distribution . Hiring – when hired new employees are required to sign a non-disclosure agreement, so when they leave they cannot reveal any company information; HP does it with a training program, video, that defines how HP interprets ‘trade secrets’; knowledge on marketing strategies and plans may help a newly hired senior manager in competitor analysis for the new employer
. Primary – collected directly . Secondary – collected by someone else, library, internet, published information
. Relative importance of the attribute is indicated by weights – an index can be computed which can give a good idea of strength and weakness of your own product
. Capabilities – dose the competitor have the resources to pursue such an objective
. These are at product level; at corporate level they may be return on investment or others . In 1998 Boeing announced in a business publication that it was going to emphasize profits over market share – who is the competition – this was good news for Airbus, can focus on global market share
. A product manager can monitor these actions by rival brand managers
. Can be interpreted as a retreat, perhaps only temporarily, from active and aggressive competition in the market
. Companies from Japan, Korea, Singapore have done that – in the US
. Leveraged buyout . Federal Express bought its own planes in mid-1970’s – Emery Air Freight was slow to respond
. The key is to find which customer groups the competitors have targeted; can avoid segments in which there is intense competition and one can determine under-targeted or non-targeted segments that may represent opportunities . Core – is the basis on which the rival is competing, its key claimed differential advantage, which is a critical component of strategy because it forms the basic selling proposition around which the brand’s communication are formed; also called the brands positioning or value proposition . Two types of differential advantage: based on price/cost or on product features; products are usually positioned on price and quality dimensions, although some choose a value positioning with midrange price and quality; price differences – Boston Consulting Group – cost goes down with volume so price can be lowered and margins can be maintained; quality difference – real pr psychological or perceptual difference – such as service, packaging, delivery as well as material – IBM’s core strategy since its inception has been service based – Reebok’s ‘U B U’ campaign stresses individuality . Physical product differences stressed in industrial, durable, or new frequently purchased product; mature products or products with similar physical attributes or commodities often emphasize perceptual differences
. Customers see these decisions in the marketplace, but they are neither exposed to nor do they particularly care about a product’s marketing strategy; customers are exposed to price, advertising, and other marketing mix elements
. Product – a major determinant of a firm’s capabilities, at least in the short run; less easily changed than price or advertising , . Is price uniform in all markets, is there a quality price differential the competitor has, are discounts being offered . Are sales people aggressive in obtaining ne accounts, what are their commission rates?, what media are being used for ad . Have channels of distribution shifted? – is competitor changing the entire system – opening its own retail, direct marketing
. Internet, brochures, provides information on the brands major strengths , positioning information – provides information on core strategy . Sales force – informal contacts, trade shows . Trade ad – reveals the segments being targeted (location and media used) and the differential advantage (from ad copy) being touted . Tracking services or yourself, TV ad messages (differential advantage) and programs they appear in (target segments) – TV ad good for determining core strategy because the nature of the medium prohibits communicating all but the most important messages – print may deliver more core information . Implementing strategy information – distributors, salespeople, customers, ad agencies, company’s own employees, stockholder mailings, use of the product; it takes market sensitivity, sophisticated management information systems can also be used
. Michael Porter – Competitive Advantage – developed (1985) a concept called value chain that can be used to compare a brand or company’s strengths and weakness against another . An important point made by the value chain is that differentiation can be obtained through efforts of the whole corporation, not just through marketing . One way to differentiate is through inbound logistics, that is, through the selection of the highest-quality raw materials and other inputs including technology – Cray in supercomputers . Second – through operations advantages – McDonald’s has been the fast food market leader throughout the world due to its significant investments in training programs that produce consistency in service and product quality . Outbound – third basis – speedy and on-time delivery such as FedEx ‘absolutely and positively overnight’, Premier Industrial Corporation distributes nuts and bolts, seemingly a commodity, but differentiates by agreeing to ship in any quantity desired by the customer, and has higher margins . Marketing – also serve to differentiate – IBM sales are able to satisfy the customer better than competitors . Service – is an important differentiator – as has retailer Nordstrom found . The product manager can use the value chain concept to check at each step of the process if and how a competitor is gaining competitive advantage in the category
. Blank audio cassette market – early 1970 – early stage of the PLC; Gillette’s Safety Razor Division was considering entering the market, as was Memorex, a manufacturer of computer tape and related products; G had competitive advantage over M in marketing finance, but at a disadvantage in terms of R&D, manuf., and the apparent match of skills and image to the cassette category, in the minds of the customer; M succeeded and G failed in test marketing
. 1) quality, value chain, benefits who, where, when, why . 2) retail, to trade . 3) total effort in Rs., methods strategy/copy, media, timing, total effort in Rs. . 4) distribution method/coverage . 5) entry stage in PLC . While doing the Competitor Analysis the product manager should not lose focus on the customer; it may be better to concentrate directly on the customer instead or ignoring them; if a balance is desired – concentrate 70/30 on customer/competitor, or at the most 50/50
. Technology, scientists/engineers, funding; quality of competitor’s new product development efforts, a long-term threat in a product category – total quality management improves this capability . Manufacturing, skilled employees: physical, human resources; for a service firm it is the ability to deliver the service . Sales force, distribution, advertising, funding; how aggressive, inventive . Debt, liquidity, cash flow, budgeting system; limited financial resources hamper effective competition – how the limited or sufficient resources is allocated among the product categories is critical . Profile of key people, decision process, planning, staffing, organizational structure; P&G replaced the manager for its coffee business in the US with a coffee general manager from the UK with a reputation for developing new products – he launched 4 new products in 15 months
. The factors are listed descriptively; a rating is given say from 1-10 for each factor; the manager is forced to evaluate own product honestly on a factor-by-factor basis; the overall rating gives a more global feel for the toughest competitors in the market, especially for the future, which may not necessarily be reflected in the current market shares or profits
. To unseat a market leader by frontal attack in its primary market segment is to provoke violent reactions; whereas a strategy that nibbles away at secondary markets (niche) is more likely to go unmatched. eBay’s key product is online auctions – attempts by Amazon.com and others to enter online auctions are considered to be a strong threat to eBay’s viability and are met with increased promotions and advertising and expansion in the number of auction categories . Coca-Cola launched new coke which failed on the basis of taste – the original coke was reintroduced as coke classic – Coca-Cola held on to new coke and repositioned it several times even though it did not sell well after its introduction
. Trend continue – high-quality, high-price; appealing to mature consumers . Link - Bethlehem steel spent billions to upgrade its manufacturing; competitors could forecast that B would be able to simultaneously cut price and protect margins . Simulate – Corning Glass – Corning Ware line was coming off patent – used role-play by own managers as to how Libby-Owens-Ford and Anchor Hocking would enter the business to preempt their entry strategy; Charles Schwab and Company – brokerage – eSchwab online business – Merrill Lynch’s interest in entering the Web business Schwab managers – role-play
. Customer relationship management – CRM – systems that emphasize IT apparently have not paid off, with a $100 M investment in recent years . Relationship marketing is important with a focus on understanding customers rather than data collection and warehousing
. These are descriptive variables: . Not clearly differentiated in terms of their behavior to the product . Relationship between these variables and purchase behavior can be weak . Even less useful than the above two . Widely used as a basis for segmentation and advertising themes; values and lifestyle – VALS typology
. The topologies are often related to purchasing patterns and afford the product manager the opportunity to match potential buyers with the appropriate media and message to communicate with them
. These are descriptive variables: . Use – light, medium, heavy . Service – more or less . Purchasing – quality, price, service . Many of the same variable sare used to segment for consumer and industrial goods in global markets
. Company may not have dreamed of the use; customer may have purchased the product for a different reason – backing soda for backing, not leaving in the refrigerator or putting in the drain to deodorize . Used at home, office, outdoors – where; how
. For rational decisions, customers essentially compare alternatives on features via a multi-attribute model
. Done by using focus groups . Done by direct questioning . Done by direct questioning
. Two Dimensional Map for a Bank . Any two attributes or dimensions can be looked at . For example – brands of cars – a map may be created based on quality and performance . Another two attributes may be – safety and performance . A – market leader . F – bank . Firms product, car, it may have high quality and high performance but may be less than the market leader A, or the quality may be better but not performance, or performance may be better but not the quality, the firm must objectively determine this before positioning the product . One can have low performance and high quality if the product is launched but not ready for the market . One can have low quality and low performance if the product is not formulate or designed well and the materials or components and finish are not of high quality . One can have low quality and high performance if the components are substandard but the technology is new, innovative, and leading-edge
. While the actual analysis and design of conjoint studies are more complicated than this, the basic ideas are the same
. Routine – if a product has little market share and the objective is to increase it, the product manager must ‘shock’ the customer into considering the product to break the routine; promotions, significant price breaks, and free samples are useful shock devices
. Essentially it is the net financial benefit to the customer from using one product versus another . Value is provided by the performance features of a product, and the before, during, and after-sales service . Source of value is basically the image of the product, including how the product ‘feels’ – sporty, luxurious, high-tech – and whether that feeling matches the image the customer wants to project; price is a part of product image, some prefer high-price – sign of quality or status, others low-price
. If sales are constant with increase in price - is generally of greater value than one for which demand slumps . Difficult to track compared to directly spoken and written comments
. New-products – indicate that the total gap between customer value and company costs is sufficiently large to allow for profits even when more companies divide the market
. Importance – this estimate could focus on individual customers or market segments and may simply be projected sales to the segment . The main value of this exercise is to generate broad indicators towards which particular uses of the product could be targeted, since relative effectiveness is hard to quantify
. How good is brand A compared to brand B, rate from 1-5 . Please rate the following brands dividing 10 points among them . Requires customers to indicate which of a pair of products they prefer and by how much – in terms of Rs . Customer ratings of products described in terms of attributes including price and brand name; through this analysis, regression analysis, the relative importance of the attributes, as well as the values of different levels of these attributes, are determined
. These are fundamental aspects of marketing
. Direct questioning – how important is …..? . Controlled settings – shopping malls, in-store, conference rooms . Individual records - scanner data, credit card purchases; such analysis often use regression analysis to predict sales as a function of mix elements or logit analysis – a type of regression – to assess the impact of mix elements on market share or individual choice probabilities . Assessing sensitivity to elements of the marketing mix is a large, ongoing task; output of this assessment has implications primarily for the tactical/programmatic elements of marketing – how much to spend on advertising
. Quality helps to create and maintain a customer – basic principle of marketing . Long-term – single transaction – sale – is not the ultimate goal . Quality is ultimately measured in terms of customer satisfaction
. Repeat – perhaps most important
. Hence, measures of intended or actual repeat purchasing provide a useful way to simultaneously measure satisfaction and its impact . Intentions are an imprecise predictors of future purchase and a staple input to sales forecasts
. Mass customization – one-to-one marketing – Levis custom tailored jeans for women; Dell – customer configured PCs by direct marketing, Internet – businesses offer customization . Segmentation is a compromise between treating each customer as unique and assuming all customers are the same – mass marketing . Provides insights about different kinds of customer behavior and make marketing programs more efficient
. Segments must be of sufficient size in terms of potential sales . Identity provides an aid to strategic and tactical decisions, name rather than Segment A . For purposes of planning the marketing mix, e.g. advertising, it is useful to be able to target efforts on a segment; sports-minded segments can be reached by specific media – sports magazine, sports games on TV . Segments should respond differently to at least some of the elements of the offering; if all the segments respond the same, then there is no segmentation – some customers may be sensitive to price and unaffected by advertising, others may be unconcerned about the price but may be sensitive to ads; this forms a useful basis for both describing the overall market and defining the segment . It is assumed that all members of the segment are homogeneous – but actually not true; however, it is important that the average member be reasonably close to the rest of the members; within- segment variation in behavior is small compared to between-segment variation . Fairly stable over time since future plans are based on past data
. Product manager has customer data form surveys or other sources measuring both descriptive information and information about behavior towards the product; customer – former, potential, current
. Each cluster, a, b, c represents a combination of factors – age and purchase quantity; a product manager can conclude form this analysis that the young customers purchase the most, the oldest second most, and the middle-aged the least . Cluster analysis programs are widely available in commercial computer software packages such as SAS and SPSS, however, such clear clusters rarely emerge
. Company collected information on descriptors, attitudes, and behavior – as usage measured in $
. Do not consider the product important . Loyal to supplier . The product is important . Bargain for both price and service
. Chi-square test to determine statistically significant relationship the independent variable – attitude and the dependent variable – usage quantity is used; and SAS; results presented in the form of a table . Also called cross-tabular analysis
. The broadest and most abstract of external factors that influence consumer behavior . Culture is the complexity of learned meanings, values, norms, and customs shared by members of a society .Cultural norms offer direction and guidance to members of a society in all aspects of their lives, including their consumption behavior . Increasingly important in international marketing efforts . Sub-culture – within a given culture, smaller groups or segments whose beliefs, values, norms, and patterns of behavior set them apart from mainstream Sub-cultures many be based on age, geography, religious, racial and/or ethnic differences . Social Class – societies exhibit stratification, individuals assigned to a special social category on the basis of criteria important to members of that society, refers to relative homogeneous divisions, people sharing similar lifestyles, values, norms, interests, and behavior can be grouped . Class structures can be based on occupational status, educational attainment, and income . Sociologists – in US, 3 broad levels, upper (14%), middle (70%), lower (16%) Important to marketers – in each class, similar values, lifestyles, buying behavior Social Class groups provide a natural basis for market segmentation . A Reference Group is a group whose presumed perspectives or values are being used by an individual as the basis for his or her judgments, opinions, and actions . A guide to individual behavior even when the group is not present – party group, classmates, family, and co-workers, or a group to which an individual aspires . Situational Determinants – specific situations in which a consumers plan to use the product or brand which directly affects their perceptions, preferences, and purchasing behaviors . 3 situations – the specific usage situation (private, public, commercial), the purchase situation (environment at the time of purchase, and the communication situation (condition in which an advertising exposure occurs, TV, car radio, friends)
. Which need would you place Development in ? . Accomplishment, respect . Affection . Safety . Clothing . Abraham Maslow, 1948
. Attainment of a more positive situation, when a consumer has a felt-need it creates a want . To make a purchase decision, internal – routine purchase base on memory, external – personal sources (friends, coworkers, relatives, etc.), commercial sources (ad, point-of-sale, Internet, etc), public sources (newspapers, magazines, news on TV, etc.), personal experience (examining, handling, testing a product) . Comparison of various brands or products and services . Making the purchase based on intention to purchase or predisposition to buy a certain brand . How the consume feels about the purchase after using it for a little while, evaluates performance, is satisfied or dissatisfied
. Motivation to solve the problem – then need or want . Process of how the consumer receives, selects, organizes, and interprets information to create a meaning, perceptions can be subliminal – unconsciously aware . Attitudes are learned predispositions towards anything – issues, products, services – overall feelings towards and evaluation of the situation - . The way knowledge, meaning, and beliefs are combined to evaluate two or more alternatives . The process by which the knowledge gained and experience obtained is applied to future related decisions
. The purchase decisions are such that for many products fewer than 50% of consumers are loyal to one brand
. Quantity demand varies with price – the product manager would like to know what is the effective demand for the product at any given price . May b thought of as that part of the total market or effective demand for an existing product which a firm might anticipate securing through the introduction of a new competitive product . Related to available disposable income, lack of availability reflects marketing opportunity for a product manager
. Simple demand curve, for an undifferentiated product
. Out of these assumptions only 2 and 3 seem likely to be true with any frequency in the real world . Consumer demand is fickle and changes frequently . Total knowledge may be possible about prices or many not . May spend money as resource permit and desired . Consumer will try to maximize satisfaction – objectively and subjectively (which is not rational)
. Demand is direct – consumption by individuals or derived – when crating final consumption goods . Effective demand is related to the population, can be forecasted with forecast in population . For latent demand to become effective, other factors come into play, less easy to predict; Maslow’s hierarchy of Human Needs – basic understanding of tastes; Engels laws – guidance on how . Needs – transportation, energy, entertainments; specific wants – cars, solar power, satellite TV . The remaining factors which influence demand – price, distribution, stocks – really have more to do with achieving some kind if equilibrium between demand and supply than in shaping long-term demand changes people’s expenditure will change as their income rises
. Product modification – can occur not just in the physical product but in any aspect of the offering – changing distribution channels, lowering the price, changing the ad focus, changing the service experience – an ordinary flower becomes special when it is delivered personally door-to-door
. New Coke – loyal coke buyers did not even try it . It is possible that though the original concept is faulty, a better one is found through the concept tests; it would reenter the development process at the screening stage - 4 . Ideas generated have to be managed – 1 . Ideas screened turn into a more clearly specified concept – 2 . Initial assessment of the extent of demand for the idea – 3 . Prototypes are physically made – 5 . Tested with potential customers to assess the overall impression of the test product – 6 . Penultimate stage in the development cycle – small-scale tests with customers in the market, the real world – 7 . Last stage - commercialization stage – very costly – decisions when to launch, where to launch, how and to whom to launch have to be made – 8
. The usefulness of the process models, such as the BAH, lies in the way in which they provide an indication of the magnitude of the project required in order to develop and launch a new product . For a slightly, versus, new, versus really new product the complexity, risk and uncertainty, and the budget will increase . A roadmap is used by the best performers, about 40%, more often than the worst, about 20% . A product manager will walk the path of the model which will be different from firm to firm
. The sources of information for this stage are both internal and external, incorporating any market or technical research carried out thus far . The output of this stage will be a development plan with budget and an initial marketing plan
. These decisions are based on information collected throughout the development process
. How many different Honda Civics should there be to capitalize on the original brand’s equity; Toyota introduced Lexus to sell a luxury-prices Toyota
. How many different Honda Civics should there be to capitalize on the original brand’s equity; Toyota introduced Lexus to sell a luxury-prices Toyota
. Companies maintain facilities where customers are less obtrusively observed using company products; Sony – Michigan Ave in Chicago, Whirlpool – at its HQ . RC Cola first introduced diet cola – not Coke or Pepsi
. Non-rep customers – customers in a different market segment or purchasing a different category of products . The style is different – new products – emphasis is fixing or improving existing products; for really new – taking an outsider’s view, doing things differently, disrupting current behavior, and using different or new technologies, process reengineering, discovery by scientists and engineers
. Surveys – large samples can be obtained . Focus – as predictors of actual sales, they are fairly inaccurate due to their small size . Demo – ask questions after the ‘story’
. Eliminate serious problems . Customers given products to use . May last for two months – advantage is that the results allow both for the initial expectations to wear out and for problems thatmanifest themdelves only over time to develop
. This precludes test marketing products with high initial fixed cost or investment requirements – in this case a prototype is tested in collaboration with a potential customer, especially for industrial products . Projections are typically made for both share and actual sales, approximately adjusted to national levels
. This precludes test marketing products with high initial fixed cost or investment requirements – in this case a prototype is tested in collaboration with a potential customer, especially for industrial products . Projections are typically made for both share and actual sales, approximately adjusted to national levels
. Standards for evaluating the tests should be set up in advance, including when to stop the test, continue the test, revamp the product, go national . Is a serious problem – for consumer products tests are done in 2 to 3 cities, areas that are self-contained in terms of media are preferred; basis is representing market segment, ability to gain distribution channels and media exposure, availability of good research suppliers . Effort should be to simulate a national or regional launch – in terms of dist. Channels, trade discounts, price breaks to the customer . Not easily answered – cost consideration, competitor counter is quick if long . Ad and promotions account for 65-75 % of the test marketing budget . A variety of information is gathered – 1) actual sales – typically from 40 stores, plus dist., promotion; 2) surveys that measure awareness, attitude; 3) panels that report actual purchase and allow monitoring of trial and repeat rates
. Silk and Urban’s (1978) – assessor – currently the most prominent – uses a simulated shopping trip following ad exposure and an in-home use period, bases . Blackburn and Clancy’s (1980) – litmus – uses pretest market data plus a large database of past new products to calibrate the results; movement from awareness to trial and trial to repeat is estimated based on a laboratory experiment . Less expensive but less reliable than actual market test
. All stages of the process are to be managed . To combine technical and marketing expertise a number of company functions have to be involved : R&D, manufacturing, engineering, marketing, sales . Technical and market information provided to the development team appropriately and timely . Quick enough to capitalize on new product opportunity before the competitors do . Facilitates efficiency and cooperation . So people stay focused
. In other words, the structures, culture, and even strategies of Sony have remained locked to the formulae of the successes of the 1970s – 1980s, rather than moving on to understand what the changing market and technologies demand for the 21 st -century innovative organization
. It can be a name, trademark, logo, or other symbol . Under trademark law the seller is granted exclusive rights to the use of the brand name in perpetuity . Brand is an asset, like other assets like patents and copyrights . Like a patent, brand does not expire
. One of the most important function a company does is market its products or services . If not a marketing-oriented company, a company ought to be a market oriented company . Everything starts with the market, the consumer, especially for consumer oriented products . The reason for innovation comes from the market . Focusing on product innovation and quality is a great way for a brand to start, or extend the PLC . Focus on brand identity – Nike brand – to represent sports and fitness activities, misjudged the aerobics market to Reebok, outgrew its own capacity to manage at the $1B revenue mark, and made a disastrous move into casual shoes . Nike created a whole new segment within – basketball shoes – Air Jordan, still requires performance which is Nike’s core competency with the running shoes, further Nike created two segments in the basketball segment – Force – for an aggressive and muscular player and Flight – for a more flexible, quick, high-flying style, and light weight player . Create a new umbrella of products by acquiring like Nike did – Cole-Hann, a maker of dress shoes, the Nike name is not involved, save time to create the product and ad expense by acquiring a company with growth potential in the market . Emotional ties with the customer, long-term relationship, loyalty
. 6 levels of meaning that can be used for positioning – brand can have a deep meaning or a shallow meaning . Japanese corporate culture of quality . Hero Honda – motorcycles, swift and agile like a cheetah . The 4 p’s of marketing lend themselves to brand positioning . Brand Personality – consumers may select brands due to congruity between their self-image and the brand’s personality, this self-definition rational would be stronger in some product categories than in others . Consumers are more likely invest their sense of self in product categories such as cars and clothing than in paper towels . Image congruency is specially important in those situations in which the product is socially conspicuous, our sense of self is supposed to grow due to reactions of others important to us . Psychologists call people who are constantly modifying their own personalities to appear more likeable to others high self-monitors – are more sensitive to imagery ad appeals than are low self-monitors . Endorsers and celebrities (user imagery), execution elements (media), symbols (McDonald’s golden arches, Merrill Lynch’s bull, Prudential’s rock), consistency (over time), and marketing elements (pricing, promotions, distribution, and line extensions are important to create brand personality associations and to to support and reinforce a brands basic personality
. The challenge for a brand manager is to deeply anchor the brand identity
. CDI of 100 or less suggests that the category potential is low . BDI of greater than 100 suggests that the brand potential is good relative to other brands . One can determine what media weight (quantity of ad) to apply to the product category and the brand in terms of the advertising budget to gain additional market share
. CDI of 100 or less suggests that the category potential is low . BDI of greater than 100 suggests that the brand potential is good relative to other brands . One can determine what media weight (quantity of ad) to apply to the product category and the brand in terms of the advertising budget to gain additional market share
. Emotional Bonding . How consumers think about brands in respect to product benefits, through a rational learning process, can be measured, consumers are not very loyal and brand switching is common . A brand may be thought of as self-assured, aggressive, adventurous, as opposed to compliant and timid, the consumer’s judgment of the brand has moved beyond its attributes or delivery of product/service benefits, consumer judges the personality of a brand on the basis of an assessment of overt or covert cues found in its advertising . Master Card – priceless, L’Oreal – I am worth it . Reminder Advertising can be in any type – rational, emotional, rational and emotional
. Difficult to find a major selling idea . Image advertising – major selling idea – soft drinks, beer, cars, airlines, financial services, perfumes/colognes, clothing
. There is reduced risk associated with a familiar brand for the customer . Overall quality, specific product attributes, user characteristics – young, hip – impact the reaction to a brand . Inclusion in the consideration set is a critical part of brand equity – willingness to consider buying the brand, similar to being on an approved supplier list in B2B marketing . Is the strongest type of brand equity and the most beneficial for sellers; may pass from one generation to the next . Advocacy the strongest fans of a brand become advocates, word of mouth, encouraging channels to stock the brand
. If sales are constant with increase in price - is generally of greater value than one for which demand slumps . Difficult to track compared to directly spoken and written comments
. New-products – indicate that the total gap between customer value and company costs is sufficiently large to allow for profits even when more companies divide the market
. 2008 – source Interbrand Corp., $ figures rounded . 1994 – Coca-Cola brand value was 35 $B, doubled in 10 years, reason the brand equity is high is its efficient worldwide distribution, the company says that it wants to be an ‘ within an arm’s reach of desire’
. David A Aaker, Managing Brand Equity, a brand can have high equity or value as a tradable asset for many reasons: high awareness, many loyal customers, a high reputation for perceived quality, proprietary brand assets such as access to scarce distribution channels or to patents, or brand association such as personality associations . The equity is captured in the name and symbol of the brand
. Positioning by: . Using product characteristics or customer benefits – Colgate – cavity fighter . Price and quality – Hipercity is a value store . Use or application - DeCold is for cough and fever . Product user – Maruti is for the common man . Product class – 7-Up is a soft drink like the colas, but not a cola or a mixer . Cultural symbols – IPL cricket league . Competitor - Pepsi positions itself against Coke . Identifying the competitor – not as simple as it might seem . Pepsi might define its competitors as follows: 1) other cola drinks 2) non- diet soft drinks 3) all soft drinks 4) non-alcoholic beverages 5) all beverages except water, may be even including water
. Other pain relievers – Balms for headaches, Tiger . Postal Services, other couriers . Dettol – antiseptic but stings, children (major customers) don’t like it . Mercedes – offering mostly luxury in 1974, BMW has sold bullet proof sedans for the Indian Govt.
. Two Dimensional Map . Any two attributes or dimensions can be looked at . For example – brands of cars – a map may be created based on quality and performance . Another two attributes may be – safety and performance . A – market leader . F – firms product, car, it may have high quality and high performance but may be less than the market leader A, or the quality may be better but not performance, or performance may be better but not the quality, the firm must objectively determine this before positioning the product . One can have low performance and high quality if the product is launched but not ready for the market . One can have low quality and low performance if the product is not formulate or designed well and the materials or components and finish are not of high quality . One can have low quality and high performance if the components are substandard but the technology is new, innovative, and leading-edge
. The basic tools of the marketing-mix are the same in rural and urban markets, but the rural challenges are unique . HL – the first multinational to enter the rural market – Lifebuoy 50g, Rs 2 . Coca-Cola – returnable 200ml glass bottle, Rs 5, 80% of new customers from rural; Sunfill – powdered soft-drink concentrate, instant ready-to-mix single-serve sachet 25g, Rs 2 . Videocon – washing machine, Rs 3,000 . Godrej – Cinthol, Fair Glow and Godrej soap, 50g, Rs 5
. Mkt. mix – 4Ps and 4Cs . IMC promotional mix – broader perspective . Advertising means paid and non-personal (mass media) . Sales promo. – consumer-oriented includes couponing, sampling, rebates, contests, sweepstakes, point-of-sale materials – trade-oriented targets intermediaries such as wholesalers, distributors, and retailer and includes promotional and merchandising allowances, price deals, sales contests, and trade shows to encourage trade to stock and promote company’s products . Publicity refers to non-personal communications regarding an organization, product, service, or ides not directly paid for or run under identified sponsorship and includes new story, editorial, or announcement about company, products, services . Attempts media to cover or run a favorable story to affect awareness, knowledge, opinions, and/or behavior . Techniques used to gain publicity include news releases, press conferences, feature articles, photographs, films, and videos . Pub. Relations is defined as the management function which evaluates public attitudes, identifies the policies and procedures of an individual or organization with the public interest, and executes a program of action to earn public understanding and acceptance, tools include special publications, participation in community activities, fund-raising, sponsorship fo special events, and various public affairs activities, als advertising as a PR tool . A form of person-to-person communication in which a seller attempts to assist and/or persuade prospective buyers to purchase the company’s product or service or to act on an idea Direct contact between buyer and seller, face-to-face or telecommunications . DM not traditionally considered part of the mix But had become important and involves separate objectives, budgets, and strategies Direct mail and mail-order catalogs, database management, direst selling, telemarketing, direct response ads through direct mail, the Internet, various broadcast and print media – Amway, Tupperware, L.L. Bean, Dell . Internet – is interactive, real time exchange – other than www interactive includes CD-ROMs, kiosks, interactive TV
. The advertising manager is responsible for all promotions activities except sales . In some companies the ad manager has the title of Marketing Communications Manager
Brand managers may choose different ad agencies. Ad Dept. would be involved in sales promo, package design, and merchandizing. Brand managers will work directly with the Ad Dept. P&G, Gillette Co., Nestle assign each product ot brand to a brand manager.
. Different brand managers many have their own ad agency . Tide and ERA, P&G, compete with each other for a share of the laundry detergent market – why? . The ad dept. is part of marketing services and supports the brand manager . P&G – decentralized system, generally referred to as a Category Management System, includes category managers, brand managers, and ad managers . Category manager oversees the entire product category . The ad manager many, advise and consult with the brand manager, and may have the authority to override the brand managers decision on advertising . Advantage – each brand receives concentrated managerial attention, resulting in faster response to both threats and opportunities, flexible system – easier to adjust various aspects of the ad and promotional program, such as creative platforms and media and sales promotion schedules . GM uses the brand manager system – 40-plus models or cars, trucks, minivans, and sports utility vehicles, brand manager is responsible for marketing the brand, identifying the target market, developing integrated communications programs that will differentiate the brand . Disadvantages – brand managers lack training and experience, may develop short-term programs, may not understand the advertising aspect or sales promotion, competing for top management attention and resources, potential rivalry and misallocation of funds . For this reason P&G switched to category management system – ad and sales promotion decision making involves the ad and/or sales promotion manager, the brand manager, and the marketing director
. Tools used by Foster’s included billboards, videos, point-of-sale promotions, TV spots . DAGMAR objectives must be measurable like Midwest Airline asked passengers if their airfares were higher than those of compet
. Any of these can spark a major selling idea . Pennzoil and Quaker State merger – the company now creates separate ads, Pennzoil positioned for protection – we’re driving protection; Quaker State for performance – stay tuned . The USP, brand image, inherent-drama, and positioning approaches are often used as the basis of the creative strategy for ad campaigns . Today’s creative kings don’t write books, rarely give interviews, or lay out their theories on advertising, they’ve endorsed no set of rules, professed no simple maxims, what’s replaced them is a conscious desire to lift the intelligence level of advertising, today’s leaders see advertising as an uplifting social force, as a way to inspire and entertain . Advertising works best when it speaks into people’s lives, when it doesn’t look or feel like advertising, treating people best, not common denominator to make money, that at the same time has a sales pitch, understand the sociocultural realities of people and how they interact with the media, messages that connect with people or that people can connect with . If the major selling idea is some other approach – use it as a guide in developing an effective creative strategy
. Selected by Advertising Age . Ad campaign plans are short-term, like IMC is annual . Campaign themes – usually intention of being used for a longer time, unfortunately last for a short time ineffective or market conditions and/or competitive developments in the marketplace change . Some marketers change theme often, a successful theme may last for years . Philip Morris – Marlboro country – 40 years . General Mills – Breakfast of Champions – decades . BMW – Ultimate driving machine – since 1774, changed agencies several times in the past 3 decades, the classic tag line has been retained
New Product Development – Process and Role of Product Manager
Brand vs. Product, Brand Elements
Dr. A. Kaul Take Notes
Brand Extension/Brand Relationships Spectrum
Brand Identity
Brand Equity
Brand Building Strategies
Dr. A. Kaul Syllabus Take Notes
Reference Texts
Product Management – Lehmann
Strategic Brand Management – David Aaker
Strategic Brand Management – Noel Kapferer
Building Strong Brands - Keller
Dr. A. Kaul Take Notes
Introduction to Product Management
What is a Product?
A product is anything that can be offered to a market to satisfy a want or a need
What is Management?
Management is coordination of the resources of the firm to produce goods and services
1 Dr. A. Kaul
What type of Products are Marketed?
Physical Goods – Cars, Shampoos
Services – Financial, Repair
Persons – Movie Stars, Political Leaders
Places – Switzerland, Nanital
Organizations – Girl Scouts, Political Parties
Ideas – Family Planning, Driving in Single Lanes
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Product Classification
Products are classified into 3 groups according to their durability and tangibility
Non-Durable – Few uses – soaps, salt
Durable – Many uses – clothing, cooking range
Services – Intangibles – banking, brokerage
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Consumer Goods
Convenience Goods
Frequently used, purchased with minimum effort – bread, cooking oil
Shopping Goods
Purchased less often, comparison on price, quality, and style – TV, Mobile Phone
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Specialty Goods
Purchased as desired, branded products –
anti-aging cream, shampoos
Unsought Goods
Purchased on perceived need, can do without – food processor, water filter
Dr. A. Kaul 1 Consumer Goods
FMCG
Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG)
Groceries
Snacks
Detergent
Hair Oil
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Industrial Goods
Capital Goods
Plant Equipment, Computers
Materials and Parts
Plastics, Auto Parts
Supplies
Paper, Toner
Business Services
Market Research, Patent Services
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Product-Focused Organization Head of Company/ Division Manufacturing Marketing Finance Corporate Communications Product Management Marketing Research Support Manager Product B Manager Product A Manager Product C Dr. A. Kaul 1
Characteristics
Classic brand management structure developed by P&G in 1930s
Commonly used where different products use the same channels of distribution
Product Manager acts as a ‘Mini-CEO’
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Product Manager has the ultimate responsibility for the brand
Associate Product Manager develops brand extensions or manages a small brand
Assistant Product Manager is responsible for market and share forecasting, budgeting, coordinating with production, executing promotions, and packaging
Dr. A. Kaul 1 Characteristics
Advantages
Center of responsibility is clear
Clear who to turn to for information on the product
Product has an advocate with training, experience, persuasion, and communication skills
Breeding ground for senior executives
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Disadvantages
Narrow focus on one product
Induces a centralized structure
Quest for quarterly or short-term sales and market share goals
Several salespeople representing different products calling on the same customer
Inefficient use of marketing funds to build brand name
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Examples
P&G
General Foods
Adobe
Ford
Mitsubishi
GM (adopted – 1995, dropped – 2002)
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Market-Focused Organization Head of Company/ Division Manufacturing Marketing Finance Corporate Communications Manager Market B Manager Market A Manager Market C Dr. A. Kaul 1
Characteristics
Marketing authority by market segment
Useful when there are significant differences in buyer behavior in the market segments
Does not give managers full responsibility for the services or products delivered
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Advantages
Focus on the customer as an asset
Easier to justify product modification or elimination
Useful when bundling different products or when consumer purchases many different products form the same company
Enhances product manager interactions due to specific knowledge in the particular segment
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Disadvantages
Possible conflict with the product management structure that may lie below
‘ Mini-CEO’ training and experience of traditional product managers may be lost
Most product management skills need to be
sustained
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Examples
Levi
Bell
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Function-Focused Organization Head of Company/ Division Manufacturing Marketing Finance Corporate Communications Advertising Product Planning Sales Promotion Marketing Research Dr. A. Kaul 1
Characteristics
Aligned by marketing functions
Product and market-focused organizations have aspect of this structure embedded in their organizations
A single manager is not responsible for day-to-day marketing activities of the product
Marketing strategies are designed and implemented through coordinated efforts
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Advantages
Administratively simple
Useful if company has few products
The structure is logical with normal marketing activities
Functional training is easier to deliver
Managers become functional experts
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Disadvantages
Product responsibility is shared so no one down the line can be held accountable
Requires substantial time in cross-functional meetings
Training is limited to function
Marketing VP or head needs to do much of the planning
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Examples
Intel
Apple
HP
Dr. A. Kaul 1
Dr. A. Kaul
Role and Operation of Product Management in Marketing 2 Dr. A. Kaul
Factors Influencing Competitive Success Environmental Factors Rate of Technology Change Nature of Competition Intensity of Competition Organizational Factors Size Structure Culture Manufacturing Capability Marketing Factors Product Quality Customer Service Market Research Managerial Factors Leadership Style Communication Attitude Strategic Factors Long-term Objectives Strategic Time Horizon Product-Market Strategy Product or Business Performance Dr. A. Kaul 2
Changes Affecting Product Management
The Web
IS Database Management
Increased Emphasis on Brands
Shift in Balance of Channel Power
Increased Importance of Customer Retention
Increased Global Competition
Dr. A. Kaul 2
Potential Interactions of a Product Manager Product Manager Advertising Agency Media Promotion Services Packaging Purchasing Sales Market Research Manuf. and Distrib. Research and Dev. Fiscal Legal Publicity Dr. A. Kaul 2
Three Levels of a Product Dr. A. Kaul 2 Core Benefit or Service Brand Name Quality Styling Features Packaging Warranty After-Sales Service Delivery And Credit Installation Augmented Product Tangible Product Core Product
Dr. A. Kaul
Product Analysis
Category
Competitor
Customer
Demand
3 Dr. A. Kaul
1. Category Attractiveness Analysis
Aggregate Category Factors
Category Factors
Environmental Factors
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Aggregate Category Factors
Category Size
Category Growth
Stage in the PLC
Sales Cyclicity
Seasonality
Profits
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Category Size
Measured in units and monetary value
Will revenues support investment?
Large markets are better
Large categories offer more opportunities for segmentation
Large size tends to draw competitors
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Category Growth
Current growth are important
Growth projections are crucial
Fast-growing support high margins and sustain future profits
Attract competitors
Cause dramatic shift in market share
survivability of product
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Stage in the PLC
The introduction stage is unattractive for new entrants
The growth stage is attractive
The maturity stage may be attractive for
some categories
The decline is unattractive to new entrants and low market share holders may exit
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Category Attractiveness over the PLC
Sales
Stage Intro. Growth Maturity Decline Years
Size Small Moderate Large Moderate
Growth Low High Low Negative
Attract - Low High Low/ Low
ivenes High
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Sales Cyclicity
Due to inter-year variation in demand
General Economic conditions introduce peaks and valleys in sales as GDP varies
Swing in sales, profits, employment, cash available for new product development
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Seasonality
Intra-year cycles in sales
Clothes, sweets, fire-crackers, and toy sales during festivals
Generates price wars
Many products are seasonal like cold remedies, skin creams, ice cream
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Profits
Vary across products or brands in a category, and over time
Inter-industry differences also exist
Average profit margins for footwear is about 6%, personal care 20%, and biotechnology 50%
Chronic low profitability is less attractive
Variation used as industry risk
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Attractiveness of Market Factors
Attractiveness
Factor High Low
Category Size + -
Category Growth + -
Sales Cyclicity - +
Seasonality - +
Profit + -
Profit Variability - +
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Aggregate Category Factors
Category Factors
Threat of New Entrants
Bargaining Power of Buyers
Bargaining Power of Suppliers
Amount of Intra-category Rivalry
Threat of Substitute Products or Services
Category Capacity
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Threat of New Entrants
If high, attractiveness diminishes
In early stages of market development it can help a market to expand
Usually it heightens competitiveness and reduces profit margins
Offset by setting up barriers to entry
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Potential Barriers to Entry
Economies of Scale
Product Differentiation
Capital Requirements
Switching Costs
Distribution
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Bargaining Power of Buyers
Distributors, original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) or end users
High if – product bought is a large % of buyer’s cost, product is undifferentiated, buyers earn low profits, buyer can backward integrate, buyer has full information, when substitutes exist
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Bargaining Power of Suppliers
Is a mirror image of buyer power
High if – suppliers are concentrated, no substitutes, differentiated product, built in switching costs, supply is limited
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Amount of Intra-category Rivalry
Intense category competition is not attractive
Escalates marketing expenditures, price,
employee switch
High if – many or balanced competitors, slow growth, high fixed costs, lack of differentiation, personal rivalry
Difficult for a product manager to have an impact on category rivalry
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Threat of Substitute Products or Services
Large number is less attractive
Threat from generics
Threat generally in all categories
High rates of returns when few
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Category Capacity
Chronic overcapacity is not a positive sign for long-term profitability
Operating at capacity – costs stay low, supplier bargaining power high
Indicates health of category
Recession may lead to overcapacity
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Porter’s Five Forces Model Amount of Intra-Category Rivalry Bargaining Power of Supplier Threat of Substitute Products or Services Bargaining Power of Buyer Threat of New Entrants – Barriers to Entry Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Attractiveness of Category Factors
Attractiveness
Factor High Low
Threat of New Entrants - +
Bargaining Power of Buyers - +
Bargaining Power of Suppliers - +
Amount of Intra-Category Rivalry - +
Threat of Substitute Products or - +
Services
Unused Capacity - +
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Category Factors
Environmental Factors
Technological
Political
Economic
Regulatory
Social
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Technology
If weak – vulnerable to new product and global competition
If well positioned – firm can take advantage of change
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Environmental Factors
Political
Affects products with global sales
Product manager must assess political risk
Free market – affected by political party in power
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Environmental Factors
Economic
Interest rate fluctuations – short-term financing
Currency exchange rates – global markets
Employment conditions – availability of skilled labor
Recession – sales, GDP growth declines
Inflation rates – consumer buying power diminishes
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Environmental Factors
Regulatory
Restrict industry from specific media use
Stringent testing requirements
Air, water, soil pollution
Intervene in global competition - dumping
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Environmental Factors
Social
Trends in demographics, lifestyles, attitudes, and personal values
Trends affect B2B due to derived demand
Young adults
Mature consumers
Children as consumers
Shift of power from seller to consumer
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Environmental Factors
2. Competitor Analysis
To analyze competitors, a commitment to developing a competitive strategy that includes a willingness to expend resources on collecting data is necessary
Judged Overall Similarity – for a pair of products
Similarity within Consideration Set – large set of products divided into groups in which each is a substitute for another
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Product Deletion – in a group that are substitutes for each other, if one is deleted or not available, which one would the customer select from the choice set or the rest
Substitution in Use – judged similarities in usage context, use and substitutes are indicated for the target product
Dr. A. Kaul Using Customer Judgments 3
Defining Competitive Set with Perceptual Mapping Dr. A. Kaul Moist Needs Refrigeration Between Meal Snack Easy to Carry At School/Work Tea/Coffee Break Long Time to Prepare Formal Desert 3
Corporate Intelligence
Rank US Company
1 Microsoft
2 Motorola
3 IBM
4 P&G
5 GE, HP
6 Coca-Cola, Intel
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Competitor Analysis Steps
Data Collection
Data Analysis
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Secondary Sources of Information Secondary Data Internal Sources Newspapers Annual Reports Patent Filings Financial Audit Filings Business Press Government Computer Databases Internet News Releases Trade Associations Promotional Literature Trade Press Consultants Customer Communications Dr. A. Kaul 3 Data Collection
Primary Sources of Information Primary Data Investment Bankers Sales Force Suppliers Customers Employees Specialized Firms Consultants Dr. A. Kaul 3 Data Collection
Other Sources of Information
Classified Ads
Trade Shows
Plant Tours
Reverse Engineering
Monitoring test Markets
Hiring Senior Employees
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Data Collection
Competitor Analysis Model Primary Data Secondary Data Key Questions Who are they? What are the competing product features? What do they want? What is their current strategy? Differential Competitor Advantage Analysis Who has the competitive product advantage? Competitor Marketing Plan What are they going to do? Dr. A. Kaul 3 Data Analysis
Data Analysis Questions
Who are the major competitors?
How do the competing products or services stack up against each other?
What are the objectives of the major competitor products?
What is the current strategy being employed to achieve the objectives?
Who has the competitive edge?
What are they likely to do in the future?
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Data Analysis
Product Features/Attribute Matrix
Competitor Features/Attributes
Memory Price Processor
A
B
C
D
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Assessing Competitors’ Current Objectives
Is a critical first step in a competitor analysis for major competitor products
Gives valuable information on intended aggressiveness of the competitors in the future
Helps to assess the capabilities of the competitors
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Define the Terms
Growth Objective – increase unit sales or market share
Hold Objective – brand losing market share, stop the slide
Harvest Objective – profit is paramount relative to market share
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Determining the Objectives
Growth Objective
Improve market share at the expense of short-term profits
The following will occur:
A cut in price
Increase in advertising expenditures
Increase in promotions to consumers and distributors
Increase in distribution expenses
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Harvest Objective
Focus on profitability – brand marketed in the opposite way
The following will occur:
Increase in price
Decrease in marketing budgets
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Determining the Objectives
Examples of Objectives
Global Competitor
May be interested in establishing market position even with short-term losses
Private Firm on Stock Exchange – long-term profits
Private Family Owned – short-term profits
Public Firm– foreign exchange, employment, providing services
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Mergers, Acquisitions, LBO
Retain market share
Firms Operating Philosophy
Minimize capital investment
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Assessing the Competitors’ Current Strategies
The important second step in competitor analysis is to determine how competitors are attempting to achieve their objectives
Marketing Strategy
Differential Advantage Analysis
Competitor’s Will
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Marketing Strategy
Three Major Components:
Target Market Selection
Core Strategy
Positioning, Differentiating
Implementation
Supporting Marketing Mix
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Marketing Mix
The mix provides insight into the basic strategy of the competitor and special tactical decisions
4P’s
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Product
Physical product or service and how it is sold
Price
Highly visible
Promotion
Which type and how often
Place
Which channels are being emphasized?
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Marketing Mix
Tracking Competitors’ Strategies
Industrial Products
Product sales literature
The company’s own sales force
Trade advertising
Consumer Products
Tracking Ads
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Comparing Value Chains Firms Infrastructure Inbound Logistics Human Resources Management Technology Development Procurement Operations Outbound Logistics Marketing And Sales Service Support Activities Primary Activities M A R G I N Dr. A. Kaul 3
Technology Strategy
Framework of Six Criteria
Technology Specialization
Level of Competence
Sources of Capability – Internal/External
R&D Investment Level
Competitive Timing – Initiate/Respond
R&D Organization and Policies
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Product Entry Decisions
Decision R&D Marketing Timing
First State-of-the- Stimulating Early-entry
To Market art Primary Demand in the PLC
Second Advanced, Differentiating Entry Early in
To Market Responsive the Product PLC Growth
Next Ability in Market Entry During
to Market Applications Segmentation PLC Growth
Late Skill in Process Minimizing Selling Entry Late in
What we need to know about current and potential customers:
1. Who – buys and uses the product?
2. What – customers buy and how they use it?
3. Where – customers buy?
4. When – customers buy?
5. How – customers choose?
6. Why – customers prefer a product?
7. How – customers respond to marketing programs?
8. Will – customers buy it (again)?
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Segmentation Variables for Consumer Markets
Demographics
Age, gender, geographic location
Socio-graphics
Income, education, occupation, social class
Personality
traits – ambitious, extrovert
Psychographics and Value
lifestyle – activities, interests, opinions
1. Who Buys and Uses? Dr. A. Kaul 3
Lifestyle Topology
Strivers
Achievers
Pressured
Adapters
Traditionalists
Dr. A. Kaul 3 1. Who Buys and Uses?
Value Topology
Self-respect
Security
Warm relationship with others
Sense of accomplishment
Self-fulfillment
Sense of belonging
Respect for others
Fun and enjoyment
Excitement
Dr. A. Kaul 3 1. Who Buys and Uses?
Segmentation Variables for Business Markets
Demographics
Industry, company size, location
Operating Variables
Customer technology, use status, service
Purchasing Approaches
Structure, power, purchasing criteria
Situational Factors
Size of order, just-in-time delivery
Personal Characteristics
Attitude to risk, loyalty to supplier
Dr. A. Kaul 3 1. Who Buys and Uses?
Benefits
The Firm Produces Features
The Customer Purchases Benefits
Technology Firms – User friendly
Drill Manufacturer – Sells holes, not drills
Product Manager – Understand the benefits customers are seeking in the market segment
2. What Customers Buy and Use? Dr. A. Kaul 3
Distinction Between Features and Benefits - Cadillac
Features Benefits
300-HP Engine Ability to pull away safely
Northstar Engine Smooth-running engine
Adjustable Seats Stay fit, alert, comfortable
ABS Brakes Wheels won’t lock and skid
Dr. A. Kaul 3 2. What Customers Buy and Use?
Purchase Pattern
Database Marketers use three criteria for evaluating and segmenting customers in their databases
Recency – how recently has the customer bought brand?
Frequency – How many different products does the customer buy, and what are the time intervals?
Monetary Value – What is the value of the customer’s purchases in terms of profits?
Dr. A. Kaul 3 2. What Customers Buy and Use?
Potential Customers
Continuum Relating to the Product
Unaware
Aware
Accepting – Willing to use the product
Attracted – Positive towards the product
Active – Buy and/or plan to buy
Advocates - Encourage others to buy
Dr. A. Kaul 3 2. What Customers Buy and Use?
Product Assortment
Different Brands Purchased by the Customers for the category in the Segments
Create Switching Tables
Different Vendors used by Businesses – Industrial products
Dr. A. Kaul 3 2. What Customers Buy and Use?
Use
Sweets – Festivals
Rainwear – Rainy season
Sunscreen – Summer
Customer Suggestions – Baking soda to deodorize drains
– Lime juice to clean cooking range
Dr. A. Kaul 3 2. What Customers Buy and Use?
Channels of Distribution
Customers Migrate to Other Channels
Specialty retailer to Discount
Discount to Department Store
Neighborhood to Superstore
Small Retailer to Large-Volume retailer
Brick-and-Mortar to Internet
3. Where Customers Buy? Dr. A. Kaul 3
Timing Issue
Sales or Price Breaks and Rebates
Fast-Food – Breakfast, lunch, snack, dinner
Woolens – Winter
Capital Equipment – Near fiscal year end
Cold Remedies – Before and during winter
4. When Customers Buy? Dr. A. Kaul 3
Customers Compare Alternatives
Information
Media Advertisements
In-store personnel
Word-of-Mouth
Internet
Decision Process
Emotional
Impulse
Rational
5. How Customers Choose? Dr. A. Kaul 3
Multi-attribute Model
The process of how customers make decisions
Attributes – used by customer to define the product
Perceptions – amount of attributes possessed by each brand or product in the category
Importance Weights – weights given by customer for each attribute
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Attributes
Identifying the relevant set is not easy
Managerial judgment alone can cause misestimates
Collect information:
Focus-Groups
Survey/Questionnaire – Open-ended or close-ended
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Perceptual or Positioning Map – Bank
Courteous Personnel
F A
D
Inconvenient Convenient
C B ATM
Locations
Un-courteous
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Importance Weights
Direct Questioning
On a scale of 1-to-7 with 7 being very important and 1 not important, how important is ‘the attribute …..’ in your
purchase decision
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Decision Making by Manager for Each Brand
Segment 1 Segment 2
Attribute A Weight x Rating = Score
Attribute B
Attribute C
Attribute D
Segment Score ∑
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Rules Available to the Product Manager
Compensatory Rule – Multivariate Model
All attributes are considered and weakness in one can be compensated for by strength in another
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Lexicographic Rule
Compares the products on the most important attributes alone and eliminates those which are not at the top
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Conjunctive Rule
Assumes the customer sets minimum cutoffs on each dimension and rejects a product if it has any attributes below the cutoff
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Conjoint Analysis
An alternative to weights, conjoint analysis permits the product manager to infer the importance of different product attributes in terms of importance
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Conjoint Analysis – Laptops Computers
Three Attributes
Weight – 1 kg or 2 kg
Battery Life – 2 hr or 4 hr
Brand – HP or LG
Task:
Rank in order the following combinations from 1 = most preferred to 8 = least preferred
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Customer Response – Laptop Computers
Combination Rank
1 kg, 2 hr, HP 4
1 kg, 2 hr, LG 2
1 kg, 4 hr, HP 3
1 kg, 4 hr, LG 1
2 kg, 2 hr, HP 8
2 kg, 2 hr, LG 6
2 kg, 4 hr, HP 7
2 kg, 4 hr, LG 5
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Analysis – Laptop Computers
Preference
1 kg, 4 hr, LG with rank 1 – most
2 kg, 2 hr, HP with rank 8 – least
Average Ranking:
1 kg option = 2.5 = (1 + 2 + 3 + 4)/4
2 kg option = 6.5 = (5 + 6 + 7 + 8)/4
2 hr option = 5.0
4 hr option = 4.0
HP = 5.5
LG = 3.5
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Difference in the Average Ranks:
Weight = 4.0 (6.5 – 2.5)
Battery Life = 1.0 (5 – 4)
Brand = 2.0 = (5.5 – 3.5)
The most important attributes to this customer is weight, followed by brand, and then battery life
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Customer as Problem Solver
Extensive Problem Solving – First-time buyers or high-technology products
Limited Problem Solving – Customer understands functioning and competitors, evaluates on small number of attributes
Routine Response Behavior – routine purchases with low or high price tag
Dr. A. Kaul 3 5. How Customers Choose?
Customer Value
Critical Component of Customer Analysis
Benefit – Customer’s perspective
Cost – price, maintenance
Sources of Customer Value
Economic
Functional
Psychological
Dr. A. Kaul 6. Why Customers Prefer a Product? 3
Manifestation of Customer Value
Price – firm’s assessment of the product’s value
Price Sensitivity – sales change with price
Satisfaction – Indicated in surveys used as standard practice
Complaints and Compliments – Number
Word-of-Mouth – Difficult to track
Dr. A. Kaul 3 6. Why Customers Prefer a Product?
Margin/Profit Contribution – Higher margins
Sales – Value assessed by the market
Competitive Activity – New-product introductions
Repeat Purchase Rate – High loyalty indicates high brand value
Dr. A. Kaul 3 6. Why Customers Prefer a Product?
Assessing Value of the Product Category
Determine the uses of the product
Estimate the importance of the uses
List competing products for the uses
Determine the relative effectiveness of the product category in each usage situation
Dr. A. Kaul 3 6. Why Customers Prefer a Product?
Assessing the Value of he Brand/Product/Service
Assessing the total value of a brand can be done indirectly
A high-value brand has:
High Market Share
High Repeat Purchase Rate
Low Elasticity with respect to Price
Limited Competitive Brand Shopping
Dr. A. Kaul 3 6. Why Customers Prefer a Product?
Using customer responses to estimate the value of a brand directly:
Ratings for competing products
Constant sum ratings across brands
Graded paired comparisons
Conjoint analysis
Dr. A. Kaul 3 6. Why Customers Prefer a Product?
Customer Response
Sensitivity and Preference Varies by Customer:
To Price – and to means of payment
Distribution and Availability – including the effect of direct marketing
Advertising
Promotion
Service
Dr. A. Kaul 7. How Customers Respond to Marketing Programs? 3
Assessing Sensitivity
Expert Judgment – using knowledge of managers, sales-force
Customer Survey – including both direct questioning and more subtle approaches as conjoint analysis
Experiments – both controlled settings and actual market segments
Analyses of Past Data – across market segments or individual customer records
Dr. A. Kaul 3 7. How Customers Respond to Marketing Programs?
Decision to Purchase
Critical Issue – whether new or current customer will purchase the product in the future
Quality Program – satisfy and retain customers
Relationship Marketing – long-term, lifetime, value of a customer
Dr. A. Kaul 8. Why Customers Buy It (Again?) 3
Quality - Satisfaction
Quality is ultimately measure in terms of customer satisfaction
Satisfaction has a strong relative component to quality
Are customers of the product category more or less satisfied than those of a different but potentially substitutable one?
Are customers of the company’s product more or less satisfied than customers of a competitor’s?
Dr. A. Kaul 3 8. Why Customers Buy It (Again?)
Measurement of Satisfaction
Three Key Aspects
Expectations of Performance/Quality
Perceived Performance/Quality
The Gap between Expectations and Performance
Dr. A. Kaul 3 8. Why Customers Buy It (Again?)
Indirect Measures
Word-of-Mouth Comments
Complaints
Compliments
Repeat purchase – or lack thereof
Dr. A. Kaul 3 8. Why Customers Buy It (Again?)
Why Satisfaction?
Leads to Loyalty
Customer Retention
Intention to Purchase
Dr. A. Kaul 3 8. Why Customers Buy It (Again?)
Satisfied but No Repurchase
Due to Poor Product Supply
Variety Seeking or Multiple Sourcing
Large Promotional Deals
Unsatisfied but Continue to Purchase
Monopoly
Convenience
Dr. A. Kaul 3 8. Why Customers Buy It (Again?)
Segmentation
Each Customer is Unique
Mass Marketing is Generic
Each Customer Strategy
Time-Consuming
Not Very Profitable
Group Customers into Segments
A Compromise
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Insights into Different Kinds of Customer Behavior
Makes Marketing Programs more Efficient
With IT one-to-one Marketing is Viable
But Segmentation is the Norm
Dr. A. Kaul Segmentation 3
Criteria for Segmentation
Sizeable
Identifiable
Reachable
Respond Differently
Coherent
Stable
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Methods for Market Segmentation
Simple to Apply, Easy-to-Use software, and require Descriptive and Behavioral Data
Cluster Analysis
Tabular Analysis
Regression Analysis
Latent Class Analysis
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Cluster Analysis
Examines the values of the variables for each respondent , from a sample of customers, and then groups the respondents with similar values
Purchase
Quantity
Age
Dr. A. Kaul A B C Cluster Cluster Cluster 3
Phone company employed Cluster Analysis to understand its regional customers
Six segments based on clustering households
Low Income/Blue Collar – Fledglings
Frugal/Retired – Thrifties
Contended Middle Class – Contenteds
Aspiring M-C Status Seekers – Climbers
Technology –Driven Strivers – Techies
Contended Upper Middle-Class - Executives
Dr. A. Kaul Cluster Analysis 3
Industrial-products company segmented its national accounts based on trade-offs between price and service to form four segments
Programmed Buyers – small customer, routine purchases
Relationship Buyers – small buyers, loyal, pay low prices and obtain high service levels
Transaction Buyers – large buyers, obtain price discounts, expect high service levels, switch suppliers
Bargain Hunters – large buyers, lowest prices, highest service levels
Dr. A. Kaul Cluster Analysis 3
Tabular Analysis
This analysis uses categorical variables based on customer responses
Descriptor Variables – related to attitude, independent variables
Convenience Oriented
Enthusiastic
Disinterested
Behavioral Variables – dependent variables
Small/Light, Medium, Large/Heavy
Dr. A. Kaul Also Called Cross-Tabular Analysis 3
Regression Analysis
Is used when the product manager can specify an explicit relationship between behavioral, dependent variable, and one or more descriptor, independent variable
However, unlike tabular analysis it assumes a continuously measured dependent variable, quantity rather than category of usage
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Usage = f (price, convenience oriented, enthusiastic, disinterested, low, medium, high income)
Regression performed using regression coefficients to represent the regression model in an equation form
U = aP + bC + cE + eD + fL + gM + hH
Dr. A. Kaul Regression Analysis 3
Results may suggest:
Price sensitivity depends on various service characteristics – quality, support
Price responsiveness exists across counties and continents – segmentation based n responsiveness rather than country boundaries are useful for global marketing
Dr. A. Kaul 3 Regression Analysis
Latent Class Segmentation
Begins with the market as a whole and then determines what segmentation pattern best trades off few segments and the ability to explain behavior
The previous methods begin with individuals and then aggregate them
Is recent, intriguing, requires sophistication –
not widely used
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Judgment-Based Segmentation
Useful because segments are readily identifiable and reachable
Heavy, Light, Non-Users
Can be used as a basis for comparison with results of computer-based analysis
Segments based on intuition may exist only in the mind of a manager and not in the market
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Environmental Influences On Consumer Behavior 3 Dr. A. Kaul
Consumer Motivation - Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs 3 Dr. A. Kaul
Consumer Decision-Making Process Problem Recognition Information Search Alternative Evaluation Purchase Decision Post-Purchase Evaluation 3 Dr. A. Kaul
Consumer’s Internal Psychological Processes Motivation Perception Attitude Formation Integration Learning 3 Dr. A. Kaul
Percentage of Users Loyal to One Brand in the Category
Product %
Toothpaste 61
Automobile 47
Perfume/After Shave 46
Shampoo 44
Soft Drink 44
Athletic Shoes 27
3 Dr. A. Kaul
Consumer Attitude
Important to Marketers
Summarize a Consumer’s Evaluation of a Brand or Company
Represent Positive or Negative Feelings
Are Related to Consumer’s Purchase Behavior
3 Dr. A. Kaul
Demand Analysis
Three Broad Categories of Demand
Effective – demand backed by purchasing power
Potential – customer possesses purchasing power but is not currently buying
Latent – one which the customer is unable to satisfy, usually for lack of purchasing power, or availability
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Classic Demand Curve
Price
Quantity
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Economic Assumptions of Consumer Demand
The Consumer wants remain unchanged
Has a fixed amount of money available
Is one of many buyers
Knows the price of all good, which are homogeneous
If wishes, spends money in very small amounts
Acts rationally
Dr. A. Kaul 3
General Demand Influencers
Three broad Factors
Demographics – effective demand is related population
Buyer Behavior – demand reflects the aggregate needs and wants of individuals in the population
Availability – supply and channels of distribution
Price
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Decline in Demand
The reduction in promotional support will often lead to contraction in overall demand as the product loses the front-of-mind awareness, stimulated by advertising, so that usage will gradually decline
Dr. A. Kaul 3
Dr. A. Kaul
New Product Development
Slightly New Products - Modification
Change of Ingredients
Adding Features
Resembling Competitor Products
New Products
Offensive – gain sales or share
Defensive – match or block competitors
Really New Products
Create/Expand a New Category
4 Dr. A. Kaul
Development Stages
Idea Generation
Concept Development
Feasibility Screening
Concept Testing
Product Development
Product Testing
Market Testing
Go-No Go Decision
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Model for New Product Development Dr. A. Kaul Company Objective Exploration Product Success Screening Business Analysis Development Testing Commercialization The Booz, Allen and Hamilton Model 1,2 3,4 5 6,7 8 4
Business Analysis
First Major Decision Stage
Is venture potentially worthwhile, since expenditures will increase dramatically after this stage?
Market Analysis
Explicit Statement
Explanation
Dr. A. Kaul Model for New Product Development 4
Market Analysis
Detailing potential total market
Estimated market share with specific time horizon
Competing products if any
Likely price, break-even volume
Identification of early adopters, specific market segments
Dr. A. Kaul Business Analysis 4
Explicit Statement
Technical Aspects
Costs
Production Implications
Supplier Management
Further R&D
Dr. A. Kaul Business Analysis 4
Explanation
How the Project Fits with Corporate Objectives?
Dr. A. Kaul Business Analysis 4
Commercialization
The Second Major Decision Stage is the Commercialization Stage – Launch Stage
Last Stage in the Development Cycle
Decisions to be made:
When to launch the product?
Where to launch it?
How and to whom to launch it?
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Important Considerations
Seasonality of the product
Whether the launch should fit any trade or commercialization event
Whether the new product is a replacement for the old one
Whether it is advantageous to be first to market
Launch location
Launch strategy
Dr. A. Kaul Commercialization 4
Line Extension
Line Extension
Product variant in the same category using the existing brand name
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Line Extension
Allow Full Line of Products
Appeal to Multiple Segments
Increase Potential Sales – customer base
Allow Price Discrimination – among users with different needs and preferences
Can Confuse Customers
Can Dilute/Weaken Brand Equity
Dr. A. Kaul Line Extension 4
Brand Extension
Brand Extension
Product in a different category using the existing brand name
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Brand Extension
Riskier than Line Extensions
Brand must Fit in the New Category
Image Match
Dr. A. Kaul Brand Extension 4
Brand Risk/Fit/Image
Pepsi Tofu – artificial drink doesn’t go with natural food
IBM Pens – why would they bother?; what do know about making pens?
Minute Maid Cranberry Juice – don’t they make this already?
Dr. A. Kaul Brand Extension 4
Tide Facial Cleanser – makes me think of sandpaper rubbing on my skin
McDonald’s Film Processing – I see chemicals in my food
Dr. A. Kaul Brand Extension 4
Really New Products
Create or Expand a New Category
Are New to Customers
Raise Issues of Channels of Distribution and Organizational Responsibility
May Create a Need for Infrastructure
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Examples of Really New Products
Consumer Goods
Packaged Goods – bottled tea, frozen vegetables
Durable Goods – microwave ovens, rooms air conditioners
Industrial Products – microprocessor chips, mobile phones
Services – ATM’s, credit cards, Internet
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Getting Ideas for New Products
Customer Analysis – surveys of attitudes and attribute importance – unstructured (focus groups) – structured (conjoint analysis)
Competitor Analysis – most new products are copies of competitors’ products
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Active Search – new products and processes in other areas
Category Analysis –examining social trends, technologies
Brainstorming – generating ideas for new products can be difficult
Dr. A. Kaul Getting Ideas for New Products 4
Brainstorming
New Market/Customer Acquisition – who else can we sell it to?
Customer Expansion – what else can we sell them?
Dr. A. Kaul 4 Getting Ideas for New Products
Product Variants/Line extensions – what different features can we add or replace
Value Chain Changes – how else can we get it to the customer?
Dr. A. Kaul Brainstorming 4
Getting Ideas for Really New Products
Similar to New Products but with a certain radical quality
Asking or listening to dissatisfied customers
Asking non-representative customers
Open-ended qualitative surveys
Involving customers as co-developers
Listening to newcomers and non-experts
Scanning the literature
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Testing New Products
Concept Testing
Surveys – useful for forecasting
Focus Groups – detailed diagnosis
Demonstrations – present the concept
Product Testing
Market Testing
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Product Testing
1. Product Tests
Uncover product shortcomings
Evaluate commercial prospects
Evaluate alternative formulations
Uncover the appeal
Gain ideas for marketing-mix
Dr. A. Kaul Testing New Products 4
Types of Product Tests
Small Samples – employees
Limited-Time Horizon – forced-trial
Placement of Product in Homes - elaborate
Dr. A. Kaul Product Testing 4
2. Discrimination and Preference Testing
Discrimination is the ability to correctly identify differences from the product alone, without cues such as brand name and ingredients
Preference can be the result of true discrimination or of random guessing
Dr. A. Kaul 4
3. Market Testing
The purpose of such tests is to predict sales and profits from a major product launch
Dr. A. Kaul 4
‘ Practice’ so that marketing, distribution, and production skills are developed before entering full-scale operations
Projections are made for both share and actual sales
Dr. A. Kaul Market Testing 4
Test Design Requirements
Action Standards
Where to Test
What to Do
How Long
Cost
Information Gathering
Dr. A. Kaul Market Testing 4
4. Quasi-Market Tests
Market tests tend to be expensive
They take time and tip off competitors
Simulated Test Methods
ASSESOR
BASES
LITMUS
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Evaluation Criteria for Really New Products
Customer Level
Do customers like it?
Is it unique?
Will they buy it?
How soon/fast will they buy it?
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Firm Level
1. Does it add to our customer base through
Acquisition?
Expansion
Loyalty/retention?
Enhanced brand equity?
Dr. A. Kaul Evaluation Criteria for Really New Products 4
2. Does it detract from our customer base through
Cannibalization?
Customer defections?
Lowered brand equity?
Dr. A. Kaul Evaluation Criteria for Really New Products 4
3. Do we have the capabilities to
Develop it?
Produce it?
Distribute and sell it?
Buy or partner to do the above?
Dr. A. Kaul Evaluation Criteria for Really New Products 4
4. Will it be profitable
On a stand-alone basis?
Long-run impact on product line?
5. Are there other benefits associated with it
Learning/capability enhancement?
PR?
Dr. A. Kaul Evaluation Criteria for Really New Products 4
6. Are there other costs associated with it?
Legal liability?
PR?
7. Can we control the market in the short and long-run
Against the new entrants?
Against the entire competition?
Dr. A. Kaul Evaluation Criteria for Really New Products 4
Typical Penetration For New Brand Over Time
Penetration, %
Time
Dr. A. Kaul Ultimate Penetration Level – 45% 4
Typical Repeat Rate For New Brand Over Time
Repurchase, %
Time
Dr. A. Kaul Ultimate Repeat Rate – 15% 4
Role of Product Development Manager
Manages the entre process
Need for interdisciplinary inputs
Need to develop product advantage
Need for speed in the process
Need to manage the information flow
Need to manage the people
Dr. A. Kaul 4
Factors Affecting Success Dr. A. Kaul Successful New Product Process Timing Pre-Development Activities Development Activities Marketing Activities Launch Activities People Multifunctional Coordination Product Champion Communication Strategy Clear Objectives Innovation Culture Technology/Marketing Synergy/Risk Information Marketing External Communication Technical Management Top Commitment Set Cultural Climate Technology Support Inter-Level Communication Organizational Structure Flexible Participative Interdisciplinary Teams Face-to-Face Communications Non-Hierarchical 4
Sony
Has lost its leading-edge in new product development ,and in bringing new products to market
What are the reasons?
Dr. A. Kaul
Apple’s iPod
Samsung’s flat screen TV’s
Korean digital cameras
Chinese pen drives and multimedia players
These companies and sources continue to push Sony out of its core consumer electronics market
Dr. A. Kaul Sony
This problem is partly due to Sony’s corporate culture,
where business units are run separately, discouraging
agility, cross fertilization, and anticipation of consumer needs
Dr. A. Kaul
Dr. A. Kaul
Brand vs. Product, Brand Elements 5 Dr. A. Kaul
What is a Brand?
A brand is a name, terms, sign, symbol, design, or a combination intended to identify goods or services of a firm and differentiate them from the competitors
Using BDI and CDI Indexes 5 Dr. A. Kaul BDI CDI HIGH LOW HIGH High Market Share Good Market Potential Low Market Share Good Market Potential LOW High Market Share Monitor for Sales Decline Low Market Share Poor Market Potential
Using BDI and CDI Indexes 5 Dr. A. Kaul BDI CDI HIGH LOW HIGH Good Sales Potential for both Product Category and the Brand Category shows High Potential but Brand is not doing well, the Reasons should be Determined LOW The Category is not selling well, but Brand is, good market to advertise but Monitor for Sales Decline Both Category and Brand are doing Poorly, not a good area for Advertising
Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Extension/ Brand Relationships Spectrum 6 Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Relationships Spectrum 6 Dr. A. Kaul
Levels of Relationships with Brands 6 Dr. A. Kaul
Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Identity 7 Dr. A. Kaul
Creating a Brand Image
Competing Brands are Similar
Difficult to Find a Unique Attribute or Benefit
Differentiation on Functional or Performance Basis not Easy
7 Dr. A. Kaul
Creating a Brand Image
Develop Strong, Memorable Identity for the Brand through Image Advertising
Image or Personality of the Brand is Particularly Important when the Brands are Similar
7 Dr. A. Kaul
Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Equity
Brand Equity is the value of a product beyond that explainable by economic and functional attributes
Brand equity represents value to the manufacturer and is represented by the premium a customers would pay for one product over another when economic and functional attributes are identical
8 Dr. A. Kaul
Measuring Brand Equity
At the Customer Level:
Awareness – Necessary for purchase
Associations – Reactions to the brand
Attitude – Favorability, acceptability
Attachment – Loyalty to the brand
Activity – Spreading positive word
Dr. A. Kaul 8
Manifestation of Customer Value
Price – firm’s assessment of the product’s value
Price Sensitivity – sales change with price
Satisfaction – Indicated in surveys used as standard practice
Complaints and Compliments – Number
Word-of-Mouth – Difficult to track
Dr. A. Kaul 8
Margin/Profit Contribution – Higher margins
Sales – Value assessed by the market
Competitive Activity – New-product introductions
Repeat Purchase Rate – High loyalty indicates high brand value
Dr. A. Kaul 8
India’s Trusted Brands
Colgate
Lux
Dettol
Pond’s
Tata Salt
LIC
Vicks
Britannia
Rin
Bata
8 Dr. A. Kaul
The World’s Most Valuable Brands
Rank Brand Brand Value, $B
Coca-Cola 67
IBM 59
Microsoft 59
GE 53
Nokia 36
Toyota 34
Intel 31
McDonald’s 31
Disney 29
Google 26
8 Dr. A. Kaul
Top 20 Brands
Rank Brand Brand Value, $B
Mercedes Benz 26
HP 23
BMW 23
Gillette 23
American Express 22
Louis Vuitton 22
Cisco 21
Marlboro 21
Citi 20
Honda 19
8 Dr. A. Kaul
Coca-Cola Brands 8 Dr. A. Kaul
Factors Affecting Brand Equity BRAND EQUITY Name Symbol BRAND LOYALTY NAME AWARENESS BRAND ASSOCIATIONS PERCEIVED QUALITY BRAND ASSETS VALUE TO CUSTOMER Easier to Interpret Benefits Feel Confident in the Purchase Decision Get more Satisfaction in Use Value to Firm BRAND LOYALTY Efficient and Effective Marketing Programs Price/Margins Brand Extensions Trade Leverage Competitive Advantage 8 Dr. A. Kaul
Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Building Strategies 10 Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Positioning
Is the act of designing the company’s offering and image to occupy a distinctive place in the mind of the target market
9 Dr. A. Kaul
Positioning Strategy
Competitive Frame of Reference
MOOV, back pain for women
Points–of–Difference
FedEx, overnight delivery nationally
Points–of–Parity
Savlon, antiseptic no sting
Redefining Category
BMW, both luxury and performance
9 Dr. A. Kaul
Introductory Branding Strategy 9 Dr. A. Kaul PROMOTION PRICE HIGH LOW HIGH Rapid Skimming (Profits) Slow Skimming (Profits) LOW Rapid Penetration (Profits in Short-Term) Slow Penetration (Profits in Long-Term)
Perceptual or Positioning Map
High Quality
F A
D
Low High
Performance C B Performance
Low Quality
9 Dr. A. Kaul
4P Marketing Mix – 4A Rural Challenges
4Ps 4As
Product Acceptability
Price Affordability
Place Availability
Promotion Awareness
9 Dr. A. Kaul
Elements of Promotional Mix
Advertising
Sales Promotion
Publicity and Public Relations
Personal Selling
Direct Marketing
Internet Marketing
9 Dr. A. Kaul
Corp. Marketing Dept. – Centralized Marketing Product Planning Advertising Sales Promotion Marketing Research 9 Dr. A. Kaul
Corp. Marketing Dept. – Decentralized Marketing Services Marketing Sales Product Management Brand Manager Brand Manager Advertising Department Marketing Research Marketing Services 9 Dr. A. Kaul
Brand Manager
Responsible for Ad and Promotions
Works closely with Outside Ad Agency and other Marketing Communication Specialists
May have own Ad Agency
May Compete with other, even in the same Product Category
9 Dr. A. Kaul
Concrete Objectives – Foster’s Beer
Strengthen the Brands Image
Maximize Brand Presence
Broaden the Market Base Beyond Traditional Import Beer Drinkers
Increase Sales
9 Dr. A. Kaul
Positioning
In the Minds of the Consumer
For Companies as well as Brands
Distinctive Attribute
Price/Quality
Usage/Application
Product Users/Class
Creative Strategy for Multiple Brands in the same Market Segment
0 comments
Post a comment