2. 2
Mark Fanner
Product Group Manager, NPD
“National Newspapers made a significant contribution
to the successful launch of Oats & More. We had
clear proof that the newspaper campaign drove a
good level of sales in its own right.
Together, TV and newspapers effectively built
awareness and trial, and newspapers developed the
more emotional elements of the new brand.
Pre-testing helped evolve our understanding of how
readers consume newspaper advertising. By taking
into account what stands out and engages people,
we could really maximise effectiveness and appeal.
And by using several executions we could underline
several important communication points, which had a
big impact on people’s willingness to try the brand.”
Oats & More
The client’s view
3. 3
Newspapers caused extra 8.3% sales uplift
TV + Newspapers drove more than double the increase in
brand familiarity
TV + Newspapers doubled increase in trial
Brand involvement 80% higher with Newspapers
Adding National Newspapers improved response to the TV
ad, making it more engaging, significantly better branded,
and enhancing communication
Oats & More
Headline results
4. 4
Oats & More
Test Hypothesis: Newspapers are perfect partners to TV
TV and national newspapers are the perfect partnership
They are processed in different but complementary ways: TV
is more passive, newspapers involve active processing
Both media are heavily consumed in the evening
Media profiles are complementary
Together, the brand impact should be stronger than either
medium separately
6. 6
Oats & More
Test detail
Media Plan
Feb Mar Apr May £m
Media
Target audience:
ABC1 Adults 25-
54
TV – 30 sec 1.2
Newspapers 0.7
Research Dates
Millward Brown
Pre-wave
Post wave
Research sample: 711 Women 25-55, regular cereal buyers
Media Source: NMR/BARB/NRS
342
TVRs
Campaign objectives
To launch Oats & More as the irresistibly tasty way to get the goodness of oats.
336
GRPs
8. 8
During
Oats & More
National newspapers drive sales
Source: dunnhumby
Newspaper Advertising effect on Sales
% increase
8.3
9. 9
Oats & More
National newspapers double the increase in familiarity
Brand Familiarity
Tried/heard a lot about Oats & More
Pre to Post % points increase – Top 2 Box %
Pre-wave
15
30
Post-wave Pre-wave Post-wave
30
63
TV solus TV + NP
+15 +33
10. 10
Oats & More
National newspapers double the increase in trial
Brand Trial
Tried Oats & More %
Pre to Post % points increase
Pre-wave
5
11
Post-wave Pre-wave Post-wave
16
28
TV solus TV + NP
+6 +12
11. 11
Oats & More
National newspapers double brand commitment
Brand Commitment
Likelihood to choose*
Pre to Post % points increase – Top 3 Box %
Pre-wave
11
22
Post-wave Pre-wave Post-wave
22
41
TV solus TV + NP
+11 +19
12. 12
Oats & More
80% higher emotional involvement with national newspapers
Brand Involvement
Someone I like*
Pre to Post % points increase – Top 3 Box %
Pre-wave
20
34
Post-wave
36
61
TV solus TV + NP
+14 +22
42
64
Any NP
+25
Pre-wave Post-wave Pre-wave Post-wave
13. 13
Oats & More
Pre-testing aids higher recognition
Recognition – Newspaper ads
% recognising
Oats & More
20
31
Millward Brown
Print Norm
(326 ads)
14. 14
Oats & More
Visual standout is vital
Newspaper ads - % agreeing
Very eye-catching I’d stop and look at rather
than turn the page
65
60
44
80
MB UK NormOats & More
15. 15
Oats & More
Newspaper ads engage more strongly
Pleasant
GentleIrritating
Soothing
Unpleasant
Disturbing
Millward Brown –
Media Involvement
Diagnostics
Millward Brown Norm
(Base: 698 TV ads)
-+ Difference between
NP and TV
+14
+21
+19
-12
-9
Recognise TV ad
Distinctive
Interesting
Weak
Dull
Boring
Involving
Recognise Any NP ad
-18
16. 16
Oats & More
Adding newspapers makes TV work harder
Pleasant
GentleIrritating
Soothing
Unpleasant
Disturbing
Millward Brown Norm
(Base: 698 TV ads)
-+ Added effect of NP
+18
+13
+16
-8
-9
Recognise TV only
Distinctive
Interesting
Weak
Dull
Boring
Involving
Recognise TV + NP
Millward Brown –
TV Involvement
Diagnostics
17. 17
Oats & More
National newspapers enhance TV ad branding
Branding
Definitely remember ad was for Oats & More
% agreeing
TV solus
60
68
66
40
TV + NP Any NP TV + NP
TV ad Newspaper Ads
+28 +6
18. 18
Oats & More
Newspaper ads enhance TV communication
TV Advertising
Strongly suggests
% answering Added effect
of NP
TV + NPTV solus
Tastes great
Is irresistible
Contains wholesome
goodness
Good for you as well
as being delicious
58
31
+8
+17
+21
+20
For people like me +27
60
40
85
44
81
64
80
72
19. 19
Oats & More
Multiple executions communicate powerfully
Newspaper Advertising
Strongly suggests
% answering
67
57
64
61
44
Tastes great
Is irresistible
Contains wholesome
goodness
Good for you as well
as being delicious
For people like me
20. 20
Oats & More
Newspaper ads more persuasive
Response to TV ads
% agreeing
29
65
39
62
44
71
57
80
68
TV + NPTV solus
Tastes great
Is irresistible
Contains wholesome
goodness
Good for you as well
as being delicious
For people like me
47
21. 21
Oats & More
Multiple executions boost call to action by 76%
Advertising measures – Call to Action
Gives me a reason to go out and buy*
Top 2 Box %
TV solus
62
75
TV + 1
NP ad
46
81
TV + 2 or 3
NP ads
TV + all 4
NP ads
22. 22
Oats & More
Multiple executions more than double emotional connection
Advertising measures – Brand Values
Helps me to connect and identify more strongly*
Top 2 Box %
TV solus
54
73
TV + 1
NP ad
40
85
TV + 2 or 3
NP ads
TV + all 4
NP ads
23. 23
Oats & More
Adding newspapers boosts re-appraisal by 97%
Advertising measures – Re-appraisal
Surprising and gets me to think differently*
Top 2 Box %
TV solus
59
71
TV + 1
NP ad
41
81
TV + 2 or 3
NP ads
TV + all 4
NP ads
Editor's Notes
Combining National Newspapers with TV delivered a highly effective launch campaign for Nestlé Oats & More:Newspapers alone were responsible for an 8.3% incremental sales uplift for Oats & More during the campaignThe powerful combination of TV and newspapers drove more than double the increase in brand familiarity than TV solusThe TV and newspaper combination doubled the increase in trial compared with TV solusNewspapers’ impact on brand involvement was 80% higher than TV solusAdding National Newspapers improved response to the TV ad, making it more engaging, significantly better branded, and enhancing communication
The research methodology used was pre-post tracking by Millward Brown among the same respondents (brand/category interest disguised at pre-stage), to measure changes among people seeing different media and account for any existing predispositions of any media group.
dunnhumby analysis of Tesco Clubcard data during the campaign showed that newspapers caused a 8.3% sales uplift for Oats & More, over and above any increases due to TV and promotions.Sales analysis was conducted by dunnhumby using anonymisedClubcard data. Two samples were matched on a range of criteria – including demographics, frequency of shopping and spend in Tesco, sector buying patterns, brand buying patterns pre-test period. The only difference between the Control sample and the newspaper sample was that the Newspaper sample had bought a newspaper carrying the relevant ad in Tesco. Estimates are conservative, as women in the Control sample may have bought newspapers outside Tesco and been exposed to the ads.
With their large circulations and sense of newsworthiness, NationalNewspapers are a great medium for driving awareness. This is clearly crucial for a new brand. In combination with TV, the effect is really powerful – TV and newspapers together increased familiarity with Oats & More by 33% points, more than double the increase achieved by TV solus.
Newspapers also provide a sense of immediacy, encouraging swift consumer response. Claimed trial among women seeing both TV and newspaper advertising increased by 12% points following the campaign – once again, double the increase achieved among women seeing TV only.
Likelihood to choose Oats & More at the next cereal buying occasion was almost doubled by the launch campaign, from 14% to 25%. Again, TV and National Newspapers outperformed TV solus, with an additional 8% points increase in brand commitment. With Oats & More, as with many other brands tested, we see that the TV + Newspaper group has a stronger brand relationship at the pre-stage of tracking. Nevertheless, we still see that the uplifts are greater for TV and newspapers together than for TV on its own.
Newspapers are an emotionally involving medium. Neuroscience and tracking evidence for 2006 effectiveness tests demonstrated the power of newspapers to drive emotional brand response. This ability was again demonstrated for Oats & More. Newspapers were around 80% more effective at increasing emotional brand involvement than TV solus. The highest overall levels of emotional connection were for people seeing both media.
The newspaper ads achieved high recognition. Qualitative creative development research identified the route as visually appealing, with an upbeat tone that reflected the product offer (whereas an alternative route with more factual information was perceived as dictatorial and dull on the one hand, and over-emphasising taste to the detriment of health credentials on the other) . Executional modifications helped ensure that branding, appeal and standout were maximised – all of which contribute to improved recognition
Tracking confirmed the ads’ visual stopping power. This is vital, as a newspaper ad has just 1-2 seconds to capture initial attention and encourage people to read on.
Millward Brown’s involvement diagnosis ‘wheel’ shows how actively engaging ads are perceived to be by consumers. The preferred territory for most ads is the top of the wheel, where descriptors are both active and positive. The worst position for standout and involvement is the passive negative area at the bottom of the wheel. The grey shaded area represents the norm for TV ads (Newspaper ads have only been measured on this scale this year so no norms are yet available).Newspaper ads for Oats & More were highly iinvolving, distinctive and interesting.
Seeing newspaper ads as well as TV invariably makes the TV work harder in all Newsworks effectiveness tests to date. The Oats & More TV ad performed close to average engagement levels when viewed solus. However, people who also saw the newspaper campaign found the TV ad much more involving, interesting and distinctive.
Newspapers also enhance branding of TV ads. The branding score for the TV ad was increased by 28% points among people who had also seen the newspaper campaign. TV’s impact on newspaper ad branding was considerably lower.
Similarly, TV communication was significantly improved if people had also seen the newspaper ads. In particular, seeing newspaper ads alerted people to the implicit nutritional message inherent in oat-based cereal.
Take-out from Oats & More newspaper ads was strong and well-balanced between taste and nutrition messages. A key advantage of newspapers is the flexibility to use multiple executions to build a brand story. Newspaper readers are highly loyal and fresh ways of delivering the message are noticed better than repeats of the same execution, which readers screen out as ‘old news’.
As a result of the balance between taste and nutrition communication across the executions, the newspaper ads were collectively more emotionally appealing, relevant and rationally persuasive than the TV ad.
Further strong evidence of the build effect of multiple newspaper executions in addition to TV is seen in the call to action metric. On its own, TV delivers a reason to go out and buy to 46% of women. Simply adding one newspaper execution increases the call to action to 62%. Seeing TV plus 2 or 3 newspaper ads builds call to action again to 75%. Seeing all four newspaper ads plus TV increases propensity to go out and buy to 81% - a massive 76% higher than for TV alone.
There is also clear evidence that adding multiple newspaper executions builds emotional brand response. The power of newspapers to foster emotional brand bonds is vividly demonstrated by the doubling of the brand values measure among those seeing TV plus all 4 newspaper ads, compared with those seeing TV alone.
Newspapers are a fantastic medium for making people re-think their perceptions, providing daily evidence and insights to their attentive readers. This benefit extends to the ads – for Oats & More the cumulative effect of adding four surprising and engaging newspaper ads was to almost double brand re-appraisal versus TV solus.