• Share
  • Email
  • Embed
  • Like
  • Save
  • Private Content
Local Undocumented Migration Policy in the Municipality of Utrecht

Local Undocumented Migration Policy in the Municipality of Utrecht






Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



2 Embeds 209

http://www.integratingcities.eu 192
http://www.eurocities.eu 17



Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

    Local Undocumented Migration Policy in the Municipality of Utrecht Local Undocumented Migration Policy in the Municipality of Utrecht Presentation Transcript

    • 1 Jan Braat Niene Oepkes Local Undocumented Migration Policy in the Municipality of Utrecht, The Netherlands Tampere september 10, 2013
    • 2 Situation Utrecht in the winter • Sleeping rough in the Utrecht forest area
    • 3 Basic Legal Principles Local Policy • Human Rights Treaties: a. European Convention on Human Rights (art 3) b. International Convention on the Rights of the Child c. EU Return Directive • European Committee of Social Rights: • Shelter for families with children, based on a ruling European Committee of Social Rights (2008) and of the High Court of the Netherlands (2012). First case was won in Utrecht. • Complaint by European Conference of Churches against the Dutch State 2013 (European Committee of Social Rights to Shelter undocumented migrants)
    • 4 Policy Objectives Utrecht Migrant Policy • Dutch municipalities are obliged to give shelter to vulnerable undocumented migrants by Dutch court decisions • Public Order competence Mayor Objective: To prevent and reduce illegal stay in the Netherlands The result is: • either a residence permit with coaching to education and work • or “reconnection” to the country of origin • Homelessness and rough sleeping on the street is not the solution, but part of the problem
    • 5 Utrecht Comprehensive Policy Undocumented Migrants Solution oriented and pragmatic coaching: 1. Support Centre Perspective former Unaccompanied Minors (18+) and Support centre Undocumented Migrants 2. Emergency shelter rejected asylum seekers 3. Medical shelter Undocumented Migrants 4. EU migrants successful approach Polish organization Barka reconnection and work
    • 6 How to handle the politics? • Successfactors: • Combine the solution for social problems and public order • An effective policy is as much non-political as possible • Create a network of simular Cities • Human Rights principles and EU directives are more important then national policies • Needs local politicians with backbone • Use media exposure to influence national policies. • Leaflet “ basic rights for undocumented migrants” in Utrecht • More cooperation of best practices by municipalities on successful local irregular migration policies
    • 7 Appendix results Utrecht migration policy Support Centre Perspective: • Award most successful social project in Utrecht 2004 • Public Order Award, City of Utrecht 2005 • Nomination Eurocities Award, Gdansk Poland 2007 • Results better then national policy • Experiment 20 municipalities 2009 - 2011 Successfactors of one-stop-shop support centre: 1. Respectful coaching based on trust in a homelike environment 2. Estimating chances on residence permit through excellent legal counselling 3. Increasing perspective of a future in countries of origin
    • 8 Results outflow national 16% 10% 74% Repatriation Status Unknown destination
    • 9 Total results Utrecht Perspective Approach (outflow) 19% 53% 9% 19% Repatriation Status Unknown destination Unknown destination after Plexa
    • 10 Barka-approach homeless EU migrants: • Successfactors local approach: • “leaders” who experienced and overcame homelessness and addiction • Assistant is social worker / psychologist who is the connection to Dutch society • Shelter and/or communities in country of origin • Results • 2012 in 6 Dutch cities (Utrecht, Amsterdam, The Hague, Rotterdam, Eindhoven Arnhem) 325 reconnections • Utrecht 85% less criminal offences concerning Eastern EU migrants. No rough sleeping in the forests around Utrecht anymore • Barka is also working in London (2500 reconnections), Edinburgh, Dublin, Hamburg, Kopenhagen
    • 11 Barka “Communities“ in Poland