Community antipatterns

Uploaded on


More in: Technology
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads


Total Views
On Slideshare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds



Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

    No notes for slide


  • 1. CommunityAnti-patternsDave NearyNeary
  • 2. “Good artists copy, great artists steal” Pablo Picasso
  • 3. Cargo cults
  • 4. Community anti-patterns: Best Practices Run Amok
  • 5. Cookie licker
  • 6. Symptoms● Community member volunteers for tasks● Progress reports are infrequent & vague ● “Im working on a draft” ● “Its nearly ready to go”● When its suggested someone takes over, the task owner resists ● “Ill make time next week” ● “Ive almost finished”
  • 7. Causes● Desire to have things done well● Best community members always over-commit● Truly believes they can make time● Once committed, handing off task is admitting failure
  • 8. Treatment● Set deadlines on tasks, and reassign when they run over● Make failure OK
  • 9. HelpVampire
  • 10. TreatmentGood newbie docsEncourage recent newbies to answernewbie questionsTeach newcomers how to search foranswers
  • 11. See also: RTFM
  • 12. Command and Control
  • 13. Symptoms● Joint Copyright Assignment● All committers from one company● No public roadmap, unannounced features arrive regularly
  • 14. Justification● Have a company to run● We need to own the code for our business model● The company paid for it, we should be special● Community contributions are small anyway
  • 15. Treatment● Define policies for community access to project resources● Public roadmap process● Exchange influence for control
  • 16. Headless chicken
  • 17. Bikeshed
  • 18. Leadership
  • 19. Mob rule
  • 20. Beware Dunbars Number
  • 21. How do your communitymembers self-identify?
  • 22. Culture of Doing
  • 23. AvoidSmokeFilledRooms
  • 24. TheWaterCooler
  • 25. Fear ofcommunity
  • 26. Work in a glasshouse
  • 27. Open Design !=Design by Committee
  • 28. Black Hole
  • 29. “Ironically, since I started working onSyncEvolution full-time beginning of thisyear, I seem to have *less* time leftcompared to the previous years when Idid it in my spare time" Patrick Ohly“Im too busy to spend time answeringquestions on the mailing list” OpenWengo developer
  • 30. Treatment● Ensure “doing things in the open” is part of the job description● Train managers & engineers in community development● Document who is doing what publicly – and explicitly leave some thing on the roadmap clearly marked “Not us”
  • 31. Broken window
  • 32. Symptoms● Off-topic/bikeshed threads on mailing list● Wiki vandalism/decreased article quality● IRC Signal to Noise ratio decreases
  • 33. Treatment● Document Best Practices● Remind offenders early● Spread policing load around
  • 34. Broken record
  • 35. “Im the bad guy??? How did thathappen? I did everything theytold me to.” Michael Douglas, Falling Down
  • 36. Treatment: Dont be that guy! (A gentle reminder is usually enough)
  • 37. Final thought:Communities are emotional places
  • 38. Community goal:Create a fun, friendly environment where people feel safe sharing
  • 39. Thank you! Dave Neary