Insert Coin To Play

3,956
-1

Published on

In my presentation for State Of The Map 2011 in Denver, I loosely connect three topics: the Warm Geography (expressed by Data Temperature) that makes OpenStreetMap unique; the challenge of converting sign-ups to contributors in what I call the First Mile, and finally how ideas from gaming can help meeting that challenge and preparing OpenStreetMap for 4 million contributors.

0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
3,956
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
7
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Introduce the topic. This talk was going to be about game concepts in OSM
  • I want to talk about three topics today. First, I want to talk about what makes OSM unique: its contributors and local communities sharing their local knowledge. The people and the community are what define OSM. Then, I want to go into one of the main challenges for OpenstreetMap, which is not in attracting those people, but in guiding them from sign-up to full contributors – what I call the first mile. To conclude I want to propose some ideas borrowed from gaming that I believe may help in that process, and also help scaling the community up.
  • OpenStreetMap has one defining quality: it's warm geography. People sharing their knowledge about their own neighborhoods.
  • First I plan to go into what motivates people in general - as defined in the classic Maslov hierarchy of human needs. The dimensions particularly interesting for OSM are a the ones higher up in the hierarchy: sense of belonging, esteem and self-actualization. I am not an expert on this so I'm just going to go into this briefly. I then plan to connect this to gaming and how playing (certain kinds of) games taps into these needs.
  • Initial idea was about badges. Has drawbacks – people just in it for the badges, It should be about more that just quantitative achievements
  • Introduce the topic. Gaming and quality Create tension – how could gaming help OSM?
  • Insert Coin To Play

    1. 1. Insert Coin To Play Can gaming concepts help make OpenStreetMap better? Martijn van Exel For SOTM11 9/11/11
    2. 2. Topics <ul><li>Warm versus Cold Geography
    3. 3. The first mile
    4. 4. OpenStreetMap as a game – kind of. </li></ul>
    5. 5. <ul><li>Free form
    6. 6. Driven by personal needs and interests
    7. 7. Organic
    8. 8. Bottom-up
    9. 9. Continuous </li></ul><ul><li>Commissioned
    10. 10. Driven by abstracted use cases
    11. 11. Pre-defined
    12. 12. Top-down
    13. 13. Discrete </li></ul>VS. COLD WARM GEOGRAPHY
    14. 14. bestofosm.org
    15. 15. bestofosm.org
    16. 16. HOT – grassroots mapping in Haiti
    17. 17. Warm geography requires local communities OpenStreetMap requires local communities. Ortigas/Mandaluyong (Phillipines) mapping party Photo from http://bit.ly/oJ3fKZ
    18. 18. Mapquest TIGER viewer
    19. 19. osmium fast and flexible C++ and Javascript toolkit and framework for working with OSM data
    20. 20. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 12 % of users
    21. 21. 9 % untouched TIGER
    22. 22. 4.8 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    23. 23. 8 % of features touched in last 3 months, 40 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 77°
    24. 24. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 5 % of users
    25. 25. 32 % untouched TIGER
    26. 26. 1.4 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    27. 27. 14 % of features touched in last 3 months, 52 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 59°
    28. 28. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 13 % of users
    29. 29. 4 % untouched TIGER
    30. 30. 4.2 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    31. 31. 2 % of features touched in last 3 months, 7 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 59°
    32. 32. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 27 % of users
    33. 33. 13 % untouched TIGER
    34. 34. 2.6 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    35. 35. 26 % of features touched in last 3 months, 62 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 87°
    36. 36. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 6 % of users
    37. 37. 24 % untouched TIGER
    38. 38. 1.5 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    39. 39. 3 % of features touched in last 3 months, 5 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 38°
    40. 40. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 8 % of users
    41. 41. 40 % untouched TIGER
    42. 42. 0.9 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    43. 43. 4 % of features touched in last 3 months, 12 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 34°
    44. 44. <ul><li>95% of edits done by 26 % of users
    45. 45. 80 % untouched TIGER
    46. 46. 0.4 avg version increase of TIGER roads
    47. 47. 1 % of features touched in last 3 months, 7 % in last year </li></ul>Community score card 20°
    48. 48. What Do We See <ul><li>Data turns cold when there's no local community to tend to it.
    49. 49. OpenStreetMap becomes Just Another Dataset </li></ul>
    50. 51. SIGN-UP CONTRIBUTE COLLABORATE OWN
    51. 52. The First Mile
    52. 55. The 'MVP OSM' concept
    53. 56. Ideas Worth Pondering Over <ul><li>Tiered editing capabilities: you 'earn' the right to make more complicated edits
    54. 57. Local OSMasters who watch over newcomers through an auto-OWL
    55. 58. New contributors are introduced to their OSMaster(s) </li></ul>
    56. 59. How This Would Help <ul><li>A smoother First Mile
    57. 60. OSMastery is acknowledged and leveraged
    58. 61. Helps make community growth more scalable </li></ul>
    59. 62. Thank you Martijn van Exel [email_address]
    1. A particular slide catching your eye?

      Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

    ×