Cloud hosting survey

Survey of Cloud Hosting Providers Michael Peters PlusThree, LP YAPC::NA 2010

What is "the cloud"? The definition we'll use for a cloud hosting provider is a hosting provider that abstracts away the hardware details and lets you scale your usage on-demand.

Why "the cloud"? ✔Minimal initial capital for a new startup or project ✔Easily make duplicates of servers to scale out ✔Easily add resources to scale up ✔Reduce costs for temporary environments ✔QA, experimentation, etc ✔Resources are guaranteed (vs shared hosting) ✔Reduced system administration ✔Easier and cheaper to migrate to different OS or software stack ✔Easily clone existing machines

Why not "the cloud"? ✔Extra strict security requirements (HIPAA, some PCI Levels) ✔Your application needs access to the hardware ✔Need "appliances" in your clust ✔High speed mailers ✔Search appliances ✔Really high performance hardware

Oodles and Oodles ✔AppEngine (Google) ✔AWS (Amazon) ✔Azure (Microsoft) ✔Rackspace Cloud ✔Linode ✔Engine Yard ✔Prgmr ✔... and lots more ✔Terremark, Go Grid, Joyent, 3Tera, Cloud BG, Carinet, SymteriQ, Etelos, Elastic Hosts, Jungle Disk, etc.

Why not...? Google's AppEngine ✔Python and Java (JVM) only ✔Very different architecture ✔Your application must be written from scratch only using the provided API ✔Ultimate Vendor Lock-In ✔well, you can use AppScale ✔ Very strict limits on computing time and resources

Why not...? Microsoft's Azure ✔Fairly New ✔Windows only ✔some kind of special windows variant ✔Not a lot of choices in language or software ✔some kind of IIS like thing ✔.Net (CLR) languages ✔some scripting languages ✔no binaries, no compilation, no install

Why not...? Engine Yard ✔Ruby on Rails only

Why not...? Prgmr ✔Extremely small "slices" ✔starts at 64MB RAM, 1.5G storage ✔biggest is 4GB RAM, 96G storage

Reference Setup

AWS http://aws.amazon.com Composed of lots of different services that can be combined in different ways. EC2, S3, EBS, SQS, RDS, Elastic MapReduce, Cloud Front, SimpleDB, VPC, FWS, FPS, Cloud Watch and many more.

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Basically their version of virtual hosts (using the Xen hypervisor). Most applications won't need to be re-written and can run as-is. Your infrastructure will most likely need to be different, system administration will most likely be different.

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Operating Systems ✔Windows ✔Server 2003 and 2008 ✔Linux ✔RHEL, Fedora, OEL, OpenSUSE, Ubuntu, Debian, Gentoo ✔OpenSolaris Supports both 32bit and 64bit (with restrictions)

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Sizes ✔8 Different sizes in 3 different groups ✔standard ✔high-memory ✔high-cpu ✔Smallest: 1.7G RAM, 160G Storage ✔Largest: 68G RAM, 1T Storage ✔Network usage is billed separately ✔Measures CPU in "compute units"

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Pricing Model ✔On Demand ✔Not sure how long you'll need it ✔Reserved ✔Can save up to 35% ✔"Spot" ✔Bid for unused capacity ✔Can be really cheap ✔Can lose it at any time ✔Windows is more expensive than Linux

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Locations ✔Mutiple datacenters in multiple locations ✔Northern Virginia ✔Northern California ✔Ireland ✔Singapore ✔You have full control over which location is used.

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) IP Addresses ✔Instances are limited to 1 (private) IP Address which is NAT'd to provide public access. ✔You can augment that with Elastic IPs which are associated with an account. ✔Limited to 1 Elastic IP per instance. ✔Quickly remap to a different server for changes or failover

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Elastic Load Balancing ✔Load balance HTTP traffic between EC2 instances. ✔Automatically detects unhealthy nodes ✔Can span multiple zones ✔Works via DNS CNAMEs and can't be attached to non-root domain names.

AWS EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud) Storage ✔Completely ephemeral ✔Plan for failure ✔Not usable for services like a Database or a file server ✔For permanent storage you need EBS

AWS EBS (Elastic Block Storage) Block level storage volumes that can be mounted to EC2 instances. Behave like RAW unformatted disks. Need to build your own filesystem on top of an EBS volume.

AWS EBS (Elastic Block Storage) ✔Volume sizes from 1G to 1T ✔Volumes can be moved around EC2 hosts ✔Can't be shared at the same time ✔Automatic replication across zones ✔Saved snapshots of volumes ✔Clone snapshots to create volume copies

AWS EBS (Elastic Block Storage) Not locally attached, which means every IO operation is a network operation. Can be mitigated somewhat by using multiple EBS volumes attached to an EC2 host in a RAID 0 software array. Larger EC2 instances have better network performance, so the larger the instance the better EBS will perform.

AWS SimpleDB Non-relational data store (NoSQL). Automatic scaling, geographically distributed, zero maintenance, key-value store. Vendor lock-in is high, but since there are lots of other distributed key-value stores around it shouldn't be too bad to abstract away.

AWS S3 (Simple Storage Service) Storage of files that are available anywhere via a URL. Usable outside of EC2. Pseudo CDN that can be promoted to full CDN (CloudFront). Supports both public and private files

AWS SQS (Simple Queue Service) Messaging system that can be used by EC2 instances even across zones. Redundant storage of messages (arcoss locations) Unlimited number of readers and writers

AWS Cloud Watch Monitor your EC2 instances to see how they perform and what resources they are using. Also allows monitoring of EBS volumes and Elastic Load Balancing. Charged per-instance but also includes Auto Scaling Almost a necessity with EC2 impermanence

AWS - Basic Setup

AWS - Adv Setup

Linode http://linode.com Been around since 2003 providing VPS hosting. One main product: their virtual hosts ("linodes") using the Xen hypervisor. Like AWS's EC2, most applications won't need to be re-written. Not as many additional services as AWS. Your infrastructure and system administration will probably not change much.

Linode Operating Systems ✔Just Linux ✔Arch, RHEL, Fedora, CentOS, OEL, OpenSUSE, Ubuntu, Debian, Gentoo, Slackware Supports both 32bit and 64bit on all instances

Linode Sizes ✔10 Different sizes ✔Smallest: 512M RAM, 16G Storage ✔Largest: 20G RAM, 640G Storage ✔Network usage is built-in ✔Larger instances have more built-in bandwidth ✔Bandwidth is pooled across all your instances ✔Extra network usage can be purchased

Linode Pricing Model ✔On Demand ✔Not sure how long you'll need it ✔Reserved ✔Can save up to 15%

Linode Locations ✔Mutiple datacenters in multiple locations ✔Newark, NJ ✔Atlanta, GA ✔Dallax, TX ✔Fremont, CA ✔London, UK ✔You have full control over which location is used.

Linode IP Addresses ✔Instances start out with 2 IP Addresses (1 private, 1 public) ✔Additional IPs can be purchased ✔irc support said there were no limits ✔IP Addresses can be configured for failover ✔Can swap between instances at any time

Linode Storage ✔Permanent ✔All disks are local with RAID mirroring ✔No need for anything like EBS ✔Since total storage on any single node is limited to 640G you'll need to handle larger sizes on your own ✔MogileFS ✔Ceph

Linode Misc ✔Free DNS hosting ✔Support for Reverse DNS ✔Customize Installs with "Stack Scripts" ✔Lish web-based console for emergencies ✔OS Lovers (YAPC sponsors) ✔Just gave all their existing customers 40% more RAM for free :)

Linode Setup

Rackspace Cloud http://rackspacecloud.com Formerley Mosso and then bought Slicehost in 2008 and rebranded. Halfway between AWS and Linode but competing more with AWS. ✔Cloud Servers ✔Cloud Files ✔Cloud Sites

Rackspace Cloud Operating Systems ✔Windows ✔Server 2003 and 2008 (beta) ✔Linux ✔Arch, RHEL, Fedora, OEL, OpenSUSE, Ubuntu, Debian, Gentoo 64bit on all instances

Rackspace Cloud Sizes ✔7 Different sizes ✔Smallest: 256M RAM, 10G Storage ✔Largest: 16G RAM, 620G Storage ✔Network usage is extra

Rackspace Cloud Pricing Model ✔On Demand Only ✔Windows is more expensive than Linux

Rackspace Cloud Locations ✔Mutiple datacenters in multiple locations ✔Dallas, TX ✔San Antonio, TX ✔Chicago, IL ✔Planning something for the UK ✔You don't have control over which location is used, at least as far as I could tell.

Rackspace Cloud IP Addresses ✔Instances start out with 2 IP Addresses (1 private, 1 public) ✔Additional IPs can be purchased ✔A limit of 5 public IPs per instance ✔Can only be used for SSL

Rackspace Cloud Storage ✔Permanent ✔All disks are local with RAID mirroring ✔No need for anything like EBS ✔Since total storage on any single node is limited to 620G you'll need to handle larger sizes on your own ✔MogileFS ✔Ceph

Rackspace Cloud Misc ✔Free DNS Hosting ✔Support for Reverse DNS ✔Can mix dedicated and cloud servers on the same network

Rackspace Cloud Cloud Files ✔Similar to AWS ES3 ✔Store individual files accessible via URL ✔Can easily upgrade those files to their CDN ✔Supports public and private files

Rackspace Cloud Cloud Sites ✔Basic site hosting with automatic failover, load balancing and storage redundancy. ✔No root access ✔Supports Perl, PHP, Apache, mod_rewrite, MySQL, FTP and that's about it ✔Control panel to manage DNS and crons ✔Can't really install your own software ✔Competes well against traditional shared hosting

Rackspace Setup

Feature Comparison Feature AWS Linode Rackspace Linux Yes Yes Yes Windows Yes No Yes BSDs No No No Solaris Yes No No Multiple IPs No Yes Yes(*) On Demand Pricing Yes Yes Yes Reserved Pricing Yes Yes No "Tiny" sizes No Yes Yes "Huge" sizes Yes No No Dedicated Servers No No Yes Permanent Local Storage No Yes Yes

Feature Comparison Feature AWS Linode Rackspace Auto Scaling Yes No No Cloud File Storage Yes No Yes Multiple Data Centers Yes Yes Yes Automatic Backups No(*) Yes(*) Yes(*) Add Extra Memory No Yes No Add Extra Local Storage No Yes No Free Non-Peak Resources No Yes Yes API (w/ Perl modules) Yes Yes Yes Command Line Yes No No SLA 99.95% 99.9% 100%(*) Shareable Images Yes No(*) No

Price Comparison Feature AWS Linode Rackspace 256M RAM $11 1.5¢ 512M RAM $20 2.7¢ $22 3¢ 1G RAM $40 5.6¢ $44 6¢ 2G RAM (1.7G AWS) $61 8.5¢ $80 11¢ $88 12¢ 8G RAM (7.5G AWS) $244 34¢ $320 44¢ $350 49¢ 16G RAM (15G AWS) $490 68¢ $640 89¢ $700 97¢ 34G RAM $864 $1.20 64G RAM $1728 $2.40 Permanent Storage 10¢ G 10¢ MIO Free Free Bandwidth In Free* Free $.08/G Bandwidth Out $.15/G* Free $.22/G File Storage $.15/G* $.15/G File Bandwidth In Free* $.08/G File Bandwidth Out $.15* $.22/G

Performance Comparison I haven't done a comparison myself, but others have: http://www.thebitsource.com/featured- posts/rackspace-cloud-servers-versus- amazon-ec2-performance-analysis/ http://journal.uggedal.com/vps-performance- comparison

Performance Comparison 5 different benchmarks were carried out every 3 hours over a week, leading to 56 runs each. The slowest system used up to 3 hours to complete all 5 benchmarks. Weeklong benchmarking was used to account for variance in host load during the day/night and week. - Eivind Uggedal

Performance Comparison Single Processor Unixbench

Performance Comparison Multiple Processor Unixbench

Performance Comparison SQLBench on PostgreSQL

Performance Comparison Summarizing the benchmarks gives us one clear winner: Linode. 32-bit gave the best results on the Unixbench runs while 64-bit was fastest on the Django and database tests. Since Linode also has the highest included bandwidth I have a hard time recommending any of the other providers if performance and price is most important for you. - Eivind Uggedal

Conclusions My personal opinion: Go with Linode unless you have a good reason not to. Unless you need: ✔Mixed dedicated and virtual ✔Windows or Solaris ✔Bells and whistles (SQS, RDS, etc) ✔Huge RAM needs

Cloud hosting survey

by Michael Peters on Jun 22, 2010

Accessibility

Categories

Tags

Upload Details

Usage Rights

Statistics

Cloud hosting survey — Presentation Transcript