Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×
 

Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh

on

  • 250 views

Accompanying a paper

Accompanying a paper

Statistics

Views

Total Views
250
Views on SlideShare
249
Embed Views
1

Actions

Likes
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0

1 Embed 1

https://www.linkedin.com 1

Accessibility

Categories

Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Processing…
Post Comment
Edit your comment

Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh Systems Dynamics in boundaries @ HaCIRIC 2010 conference Edinburgh Presentation Transcript

  • HaCIRIC 2010
    The simulation model as an object between boundaries
    M.Kapsali, T. Bolt, S. Bayer, S. Brailsford
  • Outline
    - Stakeholder interaction - The boundary roles of technology - What do models do - Simulation as a social object - Ideal Types - 2 case studies - Results - Questions
  • Stakeholder interaction
    Different diverse communities, Healthcare complexity, cognitive distance – various backgrounds, professions, roles, levels etc. + Different interests, viewpoints and background - communication patterns = Different forms of collaboration
  • The boundary roles of technology
    Communication and translation artefacts between several intersecting social worlds - multi-dimensional nature - satisfy their information requirements - explore perceptions and attitudes - convey meaning and create understanding used to manipulate meaning or assert status ambiguous role since they are used subjectively
  • What do models do?
    (Zagonel, 2002)
    (Zagonel, 2002)
  • Simulation as a social object
    1. facilitate interdisciplinarity2. used to make predictions 3. shape the conversation 4. conceptual modelling as representing reality 5. negotiating a social order
  • Simulation as a social object
    (Ewenstein & Whyte, 2009)
  • Ideal Types
  • Ideal Types
  • Ideal Types
    Easily changeable, (visually) making systemic mechanisms easily accessible
    Fixed, (visually) making systems outcomes attractive
  • Case studies
    • Two System Dynamics modelling projects tackling the same problem from a local and national perspective
    • Work carried out by consultants in collaboration with expert group for health care client
    • Similar group model building approach
    • Different composition of expert group
    • Local project aims to inform commissioning
    • National project aims to develop tool for commissioners nationwide
  • national vs. a local SD modelling projects
    National
    Cohesive group
    Community of practice
    Common understanding of the goal knowledge about the model and the technology, common knowledge of the system
    Produce a predictive tool
    Local
    Diverse group
    Community of interest
    Different backgrounds, different understandings of the system, different knowledge of the processes, variable understanding of the model as a technology
    Learning about the system
  • case studies cont....
    National
    The goal was clear and shared
    Codifying the already shared knowledge
    The common understanding combined with the tool building focus resulted in limited use of the model as a boundary object.
    Local
    The model used to provide to stakeholders a shared imagery of the system through its RO function
    workshops spent time at creating the shared understanding of the problem
  • National: producing a generic tool for all PCTs
    Goal: "influence policy" and "make a difference“, "reflect the work we had done in this“, "Provide a tool for local authorities to make a robust business case."  
    Group composition: "it is a reasonably small field" and so "we all knew each other"
    Some said model building made them "look at everything“ while others don’t see difference to other policy discussions
    Welcome broad participation in group (different disciplines)
    Model is ("looking at full spectrum of interventions") – model can communicate this to others
    Model can also distract because some find it difficult to understand
  • Local: producing a specific tool for one PCT
    Data clashed with perception of participants – learning about wider system, finding about the performance of the solutions, attention directed by modeller towards solutions
    Iterative process where the boundaries of the model are negotiated with participants depending on changing perceptions of the system
    “Three key points to help the participants use the model constructively: a well defined issue, people who have the power to make changes to take part in the process and the simplest model to address the issue.”
     “ ..... it is a group learning process – if you present it cold through a model without the learning process it is very difficult to own the results ......”
    “the model works best with those (participants) who have a whole systems view and can articulate what they see ....”
  • Results
    The ability of the model to serve as a boundary/epistemic object was limited by the perceived complexity of its visual representation.
    The role taken by the model at various points seemed to be linked to the project process- the process had an effect.
    Tied to the project process are the issues of consistency in participation and learning elements. Therefore it is a matter of project management handling the project group.
  • Results
    The less diverse and distant the group the more the representative role was successful- because the group had a common understanding of the reality of the system and common goal, did not need to negotiate it and created successfully fixed representational and technical elements in the model
  • Dominant role in case studies
    Local
    National
  • Questions
    Thank you