What Kind of Persons Are Bio-Electronic Humans?
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Like this? Share it with your network


What Kind of Persons Are Bio-Electronic Humans?



Are electronic or software beings that meet the biological definition of "life" and that persuade psychologists they really feel human just "corporate persons" like a company or are they ...

Are electronic or software beings that meet the biological definition of "life" and that persuade psychologists they really feel human just "corporate persons" like a company or are they "constitutional persons" like naturally born citizens? This presentation was given at the 3rd Colloquium on the Law of Transbeman Persons, Space Coast, Florida, 2007.



Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



2 Embeds 2

http://www.slideshare.net 1
http://consciousnessproblem.blogspot.com 1



Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

What Kind of Persons Are Bio-Electronic Humans? Presentation Transcript

  • 1. What Kind of Persons Are Bio-Electronic Humans? Martine Rothblatt [email_address]
  • 2. LIFE IS ORGANIZED, EXCHANGES MATTER/ENERGY, RESPONDS TO STIMULI, REPRODUCES, DEVELOPS & ADAPTS Biology = LIFE Implemented Via A Program Transferred With Molecules (e.g. DNA) Vitology = LIFE Implemented Via Program Transferred With Electronics (e.g. Binary Code) (Thank you Lady Ada) Any Ethical Difference?
  • 3. “ Transbemans” Self-Identify As B io- E lectronic Hu mans in Trans ition Biological Life = Organization Specified by Chemical Codes, Such as DNA/RNA Vitological Life = Organization Specified by Electronic Codes, Such As Binary
  • 4. Trans ition Continuum From Fleshware to Software Dependent On IT/Electronics Dependent On Biology - + + -
  • 5. Transbemans Believe Substrate Per Se Irrelevant to Humanness Virtuals Nano-Bios Ectogens
  • 6. In Other Words, Transbemans Want, But Might Not Be Entitled, To Human Rights  Definition of Life Can Include Electronic Beings  Definition of Human Goes Beyond Flesh  Bio-Electronic Beings Can Feel Quite Human, Especially In Transition But Society May Not Yet Appreciate The Logic
  • 7. Corporate Personhood Spans A Range of Concepts Corporations have commercial and criminal legal personalities Corporations have some constitutional and human rights
  • 8. Separation of Creators from Corporation is Hallmark of Corporate Personhood
  • 9. Corporate Personhood for Transbemans May Limit Their Creator’s Liability
  • 10. Is Victor Frankenstein Responsible for His Monster? Generally NO if Monster has corporate personhood Generally YES, if Monster lacks corporate personhood
  • 11. Should Lt. Cdr. Data Be Allowed to Vote? Not if he just has corporate personhood Yes, if he has natural or other juridical personhood, with or without corporate personhood
  • 12. Pros & Cons of Typical Corporate Personhood Interests of Corps Not Same as the Species Liability Protection Encourages Risk-Taking Evolving Society Humans Can Fill Trounced by Heartless Corps Grouped Humans Contribute to Welfare Happy Society Humans Reckless in Groupings Single Point of Accountability Secure Society Disadvantages Advantages Critical Factor
  • 13. Pros & Cons Applied to a Transbeman (Society View) Undermines Tried & True DNA-Based Life Encourages Consciousness Extensions Evolving Society Might Help Unhumans Get Dominant Less Likelihood of Transbeman Agitation Happy Society Creators Can Escape Liability More Focused Legal Controls on Transbemans Secure Society Disadvantages Advantages
  • 14. Pros & Cons From Transbeman’s View 2nd Class Citizenship Means Not Safe & Less Happy
  • 15. The Ethical Conundrum 2. Corporations Don’t Value Anything, Only Their Individuals Can Feel Value 1. We Award Rights to Individuals Who Value Them 3. Ergo, Transbemans Who Value Human Rights Deserve Constitutional Personhood; Other Transbemans Deserve Corporate Personhood for Their Creators’ Interests
  • 16. A New Type of Personhood: Turing Meets Freud Meets Christine
  • 17. The Transbeman Real-Life Test
    • Turing: If a machine convinces a human the machine is human, then the machine is equivalent to being human
    • Freud: A person’s underlying nature can be discerned from psycho-therapy
    • Christine: A biological male v. female reality can be legally changed on birth certificate, and with phenotype surgery, if after a year of therapy two psychologists agree the biological doesn’t match the mental nature
  • 18. Let Shrinks Decide if a Transbeman Lacking Personhood Is Human Psyche Equivalent
    • One Year “Real
    • Life Test”:
    • Weekly Sessions;
    • Two Certified Psychologists In Agreement
    • Letter to Authorities
    • Judge Orders Birth Certificate Issued
    • Transbeman Gets Natural Born Citizenship by Court Order
  • 19. Two Ways Forward for Transbeman Personhood Start the Transbeman with Corporate Personhood, Unless They Already Have Constitutional Personhood Use “Real-Life Test” Route for Issuance of Birth Certificates (or Equivalents) for Transbemans that Desire Constitutional Personhood
  • 20. Basically, Each New Transbeman Is Like an Immigrant Let Those That Arrive Live, Work, Save & Have Some Due Process Rights Let Those That Want & Warrant Citizenship, Via Real-Life Test, Have It & Full Due Process Rights
  • 21. A Few Legal Quirks Not Hard to Resolve
    • States Create Corporate Personhood, But Citizenship Rules Are Federalized
    • States Handle Birth Certificates, But Immigration is Federalized
    Diverse State Approaches to Transbeman Rights Is a Strength of the US System
  • 22. Critical Path Elements Demonstrate Cyber-Consciousness Develop Cyber-Psychology Certification Get Judges to Agree & Set Legal Precedent