An Introduction to the Contradictions Between
was equally dismayed to see first-hand            deaths, and several times that number of
the prevalence of physicians wh...
no such cycles). When you factor in un-           SIDS and vaccines; one such study
der-reporting, the vaccine may be 100 ...
approximately 20% of these). This con-           unethical; they force an uninformed
cern is underscored by a study reveal...
cluded, “The apparent paradox is that as        “Vaccines are the reason for low disease
measles immunization rates rise t...
neously over a period of several decades          U.S. Division of Biological Standards,
between the 1870’s and the beginn...
Research also indicates that vac-         developed symptoms if he or she had not
cination commits immune cells to the    ...
where stepped-up immunization cam-
paigns in native aborigines resulted in an               Most childhood infectious dis-...
tection for less than six months.50 Some
healthcare professionals are concerned           ...or was it?
that the virus fro...
agnosed and recorded as polio before the          higher than that cited by the CDC. No-
vaccine, but were distinguished a...
(commonly known as antifreeze). Some                is thus not only known, but relied upon
of these ingredients are gastr...
linked to immunisation.”56 The diabetes          otherwise explain the dramatic rise in
findings may be only the tip of th...
tions with which allopathic medicine has           more required vaccines. In general,
had little success.                ...
state to state) may be all that it takes to                Conflicts of interest are the norm
get a copy mailed to you. Or...
government's immunization policies…               the safety and effectiveness of any phar-
are driven by politics and not...
radical positions, but they are not un-              out their lives, and every healthcare sys-
founded. The continued den...
208-361-8889, email: patterpub@ya-                4. birth issues, fall 1999. Canadian magazine of
         hoo. com, or u...
                                                         Am J Epidemiol 1994 Jan 15;139(2):229-30. Di-
Dept. of Internal Medicine, Mayo Vaccine Re-             48
   Fishkin v. Yonkers Public Schools, 710 F.
Supp. 506 (S.D.N.Y. 1989).
   Berg v. Glen Cove City School District, 8...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

MSWord version of this document to Download and Print.doc


Published on

Published in: Health & Medicine
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Total Views
On Slideshare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

MSWord version of this document to Download and Print.doc

  1. 1. DISPELLING VACCINATION MYTHS: An Introduction to the Contradictions Between Medical Science and Immunization Policy Alan Phillips, Director Citizens for Healthcare Freedom Last Revision: May 2001 INTRODUCTION dozens of chronic immunological and neurological diseases that have risen dra- When my son was set to begin matically in recent decades to mass im- his routine vaccination series at age 2 munization campaigns. months, I didn’t know there were any risks associated with immunizations. But Decades of studies published in the clinic's flyer contained a contradic- the world’s leading medical journals tion: my child’s chances of a serious ad- have documented vaccine failure and se- verse reaction to the DPT vaccine were rious adverse vaccine events, including one in 1750, while his chances of dying death. Dozens of books written by doc- from pertussis were one in several mil- tors, researchers, and independent inves- lion. When I pointed this out to the tigators reveal serious flaws in immu- physician, he angrily disagreed, and nization theory and practice. Yet, incred- stormed out of the room mumbling, “I ibly, most pediatricians and parents are guess I should read that [flyer] some- unaware of these findings. This has be- time...” Soon thereafter I learned of a gun to change in recent years, however, child who had been permanently dis- as a growing number of parents and abled by a vaccine, so I decided to inves- healthcare providers around the world tigate for myself. My findings have so are becoming aware of the problems and alarmed me that I feel compelled to questioning mass mandatory immuniza- share them; hence, this report. tion. There is a growing international movement away from mass mandatory Health authorities credit vaccines immunization. This report introduces for disease declines, and assure us of some of the information that provides their safety and effectiveness. Yet these the basis for the movement. assumptions are directly contradicted by government statistics, published medical My point is not to tell anyone studies, Food and Drug Administration whether or not to vaccinate, but rather, (FDA) and Centers for Disease Control with the utmost urgency, to point out (CDC) reports, and the opinions of credi- some very good reasons why everyone ble research scientists from around the should examine the facts before deciding world. In fact, infectious diseases de- whether or not to submit to the proce- clined steadily for decades prior to mass dure. As a new parent, I was shocked to immunizations, doctors in the U.S. re- discover the absence of a legal mandate port thousands of serious vaccine reac- or professional ethic requiring pediatri- tions each year including hundreds of cians to be fully informed of the risks of deaths and permanent disabilities, fully vaccination, let alone to inform parents vaccinated populations have experienced that their children risk death or perma- epidemics, and researchers attribute nent disability upon being vaccinated. I
  2. 2. was equally dismayed to see first-hand deaths, and several times that number of the prevalence of physicians who are, if permanent disabilities.1 VAERS officials with the best of intentions, applying report that 15% of adverse events are practices based on incomplete—and in “serious” (emergency room trip, hospi- some cases, outright mis—information. talization, life-threatening episode, per- manent disability, death). Independent This report is only a brief intro- analysis of VAERS reports has revealed duction; your own further investigation that up to 50% of reported adverse is warranted and strongly recommended. events for the Hepatitis B vaccine are You may discover that this is the only “serious.”2 While these figures are way to get an objective view, as the con- alarming, they are only the tip of the ice- troversy is a highly emotional one. berg. The FDA estimates that as few as 1% of serious adverse reactions to vac- A word of caution: Many have cines are reported,3,4 and the CDC ad- found pediatricians unwilling or unable mits that only about 10% of such events to discuss this subject calmly with an are reported.5 In fact, Congress has heard open mind. Perhaps this is because they testimony that medical students are told have staked their personal identities and not to report suspected adverse events.6 professional reputations on the presumed safety and effectiveness of vaccines, and The National Vaccine Informa- because they are required by their pro- tion Center (NVIC, a grassroots organi- fession to promote vaccination. But in zation founded by parents of vaccine-in- any event, anecdotal reports suggest that jured and killed children) has conducted most doctors have great difficulty ac- its own investigations.7 It reported: “In knowledging evidence of problems with New York, only one out of 40 doctor's vaccines. The first pediatrician I attempt- offices confirmed that they report a ed to share my findings with yelled an- death or injury following vaccination.” grily at me when I calmly brought up the In other words, 97.5% of vaccine related subject. The misconceptions have very deaths and disabilities go unreported deep roots. there. Implications about medical ethics aside (federal law directs doctors to re- port serious adverse events8), these find- VACCINATION MYTH #1: ings suggest that vaccine deaths and seri- ous injuries actually occurring may be “Vaccines are safe...” from 10 to 100 times greater than the number reported. ...or are they? With pertussis (often referred to The Federal government VAERS as “whooping cough”), the number of (Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting Sys- vaccine-related deaths dwarfs the num- tem) was established by Congress under ber of disease deaths, which have been the National Childhood Vaccine Injury about 10 annually for many years ac- Compensation Act of 1986. It receives cording to the CDC, and only 8 in 1993, about 11,000 reports of serious adverse one of the last peak-incidence years (per- reactions to vaccinations annually, which tussis runs in 3-4 year cycles; no none include as many as one to two hundred knows why, but vaccination rates have 2
  3. 3. no such cycles). When you factor in un- SIDS and vaccines; one such study der-reporting, the vaccine may be 100 claimed that there was a slightly lower times more deadly than the disease. incidence of SIDS in vaccinees. Howev- Some argue that this is a necessary cost er, many of these studies were called to prevent the return of a disease that into question by yet another study that would be more deadly than the vaccine. found “confounding” had erroneously But when you consider the fact that the skewed the results of these studies in fa- vast majority of disease decline this cen- vor of the vaccine.13 At best, there is tury preceded the widespread use of vac- conflicting evidence. But shouldn't we cinations (pertussis mortality declined err on the side of caution? Shouldn't any 79% prior to vaccines), and the fact that credible correlation between vaccines rates of disease declines remained virtu- and infant deaths be just cause for metic- ally unchanged following the introduc- ulous, widespread monitoring of the vac- tion of mass immunization, present day cination status of all SIDS cases? Health vaccine casualties cannot reasonably be authorities have chosen to err on the side explained away as a necessary sacrifice of denial rather than caution. for the benefit of a disease-free society. In the mid 1970's Japan raised Unfortunately, the vaccine-relat- their vaccination age from two months to ed-deaths story doesn’t end here. Studies two years; their incidence of SIDS internationally have shown vaccination dropped dramatically;14 they went from to be a cause of SIDS9,10 (SIDS, Sudden an infant mortality ranking of 17 to first Infant Death Syndrome, is a “catch-all” in the world (i.e., Japan had the lowest diagnosis given when the specific cause infant death rate when infants were not of death is unknown; estimates range being immunized). England’s vaccina- from 5,000 to 10,000 cases each year in tion rate temporarily dropped to about the US). One study found the peak inci- 30% at about the same time following dence of SIDS occurred at the ages of 2 media reports of vaccine-related brain and 4 months in the U.S., precisely when damage. Infant mortality dropped sub- the first two routine immunizations are stantially for about 2 years, then rose given,11 while another found a clear pat- again in close correlation to rising im- tern of correlation extending three weeks munization rates in the late 1970’s. De- after immunization. Another study found spite these experiences, the medical that 3,000 children die within 4 days of community maintains a posture of de- vaccination each year in the U.S. (amaz- nial. Coroners don’t check the vaccina- ingly, the authors reported no SIDS/vac- tion status of SIDS victims, and unsus- cine relationship), while yet another re- pecting families continue to pay the searcher’s studies led to the conclusion price, unaware of the dangers and denied that at least half of SIDS cases are the right to make an informed choice. caused by vaccines.12 FDA and CDC admissions about Initial studies suggesting a causal the lack of adverse event reporting sug- relationship between SIDS and vaccines gests that the total number of adverse re- were quickly followed by vaccine-manu- actions actually occurring each year may facturer-sponsored studies concluding actually fall within a range of 100,000 to that there is no relationship between a million (with “serious” events being 3
  4. 4. approximately 20% of these). This con- unethical; they force an uninformed cern is underscored by a study revealing American public to pay for vaccine man- that 1 in 175 children who completed the ufacturer's liabilities, while ensuring that full DPT series suffered “severe reac- this same public will remain ignorant of tions,”15 and a Dr.'s report for attorneys the dangers of their products. This ar- stating that one in 300 DPT immuniza- rangement also diminishes any incentive tions resulted in seizures.16 that manufacturers might have to pro- duce safer vaccines. England actually saw a drop in pertussis deaths when vaccination rates It is important to note that insur- dropped to 30% in the mid 70's. Swedish ance companies, who do the best liability epidemiologist B. Trollfors’ study of studies, refuse to cover vaccine reac- pertussis vaccine efficacy and toxicity tions. Each industry’s respective profit around the world found that “pertussis- motives have generated these contradic- associated mortality is currently very tory positions. low in industrialised countries and no difference can be discerned when coun- VACCINATION TRUTH #1: tries with high, low, and zero immunisa- tion rates were compared.” He also “Vaccination causes significant death found that England, Wales, and West and disability at an astounding personal Germany had more pertussis fatalities in and financial cost to uninformed families 1970 when the immunization rate was and society.” high than during the last half of 1980, when rates had fallen.17 VACCINATION MYTH #2: Vaccinations cost us more than just the lives and health of our children. “Vaccines are very effective...” The U.S. Federal Government's National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program ...or are they? (NVICP) has paid out over $1.2 billion since 1988 to the families of children in- The medical literature has a sur- jured and killed by vaccines,18 with mon- prising number of studies documenting ey that comes from a tax on vaccines vaccine failure. Measles, mumps, small that vaccine recipients pay. Meanwhile, pox, pertussis, polio and Hib outbreaks pharmaceutical companies have a cap- have all occurred in vaccinated popula- tive market; vaccines are legally mandat- tions.19,20,21,22,23 In 1989 the CDC report- ed in all 50 U.S. states (though legally ed: “Among school-aged children, avoidable in most; see Myth #9), yet [measles] outbreaks have occurred in these same companies are “immune” schools with vaccination levels of from accountability for the consequences greater than 98 percent.24 [They] have of their products. Furthermore, they have occurred in all parts of the country, in- been allowed to use “gag orders” as a cluding areas that had not reported leverage tool in vaccine damage legal measles for years.”25 The CDC even re- settlements to prevent disclosure of in- ported a measles outbreak in a docu- formation to the public about vaccination mented 100% vaccinated population.26 A dangers. Such arrangements are clearly study examining this phenomenon con- 4
  5. 5. cluded, “The apparent paradox is that as “Vaccines are the reason for low disease measles immunization rates rise to high rates in the U.S. today...” levels in a population, measles becomes a disease of immunized persons.”27 A ...or are they? more recent study found that measles vaccination “produces immune suppres- According to the British Associa- sion which contributes to an increased tion for the Advancement of Science, susceptibility to other infections.”28 childhood diseases decreased 90% be- These studies suggest that the goal of twee</p>n 1850 and 1940, paralleling complete “immunization” may actually improved sanitation and hygienic prac- be counter-productive, a notion under- tices, well before mandatory vaccination scored by instances in which epidemics programs. The Medical Sentinel recently followed complete immunization of en- reported, “from 1911 to 1935, the four tire countries. Japan experienced yearly leading causes of childhood deaths from increases in small pox following the in- infectious diseases in the U.S. were troduction of compulsory vaccines in diphtheria, pertussis, scarlet fever, and 1872. By 1892, there were 29,979 measles. However, by 1945 the com- deaths, and all had been vaccinated.29 In bined death rates from these causes had the early 1900’s, the Philippines experi- declined by 95 percent, before the imple- enced their worst smallpox epidemic mentation of mass immunization pro- ever after 8 million people received 24.5 grams.”35 million vaccine doses (achieving a vacci- nation rate of 95%); the death rate Thus, at best, vaccinations can be quadrupled as a result.30 Before Eng- examined only for their relationship to land’s first compulsory vaccination law the small, remaining portion of disease in 1853, the largest two-year smallpox declines that occurred after their intro- death rate was about 2,000; in 1870-71, duction. Yet even this role is question- England and Wales had over 23,000 able, as pre-vaccine rates of disease mor- smallpox deaths.31 In 1989, the country tality decline remained virtually the of Oman experienced a widespread polio same after vaccines were introduced. outbreak six months after achieving Furthermore, European countries that re- complete vaccination.32 In the U.S. in fused immunization for small pox and 1986, 90% of 1300 pertussis cases in polio saw the epidemics end along with Kansas were “adequately vaccinated.”33 those countries that mandated it; vac- 72% of pertussis cases in the 1993 cines were clearly not the sole determin- Chicago outbreak were fully up to date ing factor. In fact, both small pox and with their vaccinations.34 polio immunization campaigns were fol- lowed by significant disease incidence VACCINATION TRUTH #2: increases. After smallpox vaccination “Evidence suggests that vaccination is an was being mandated, smallpox remained unreliable means of preventing disease.” a prevalent disease with some substantial increases, while other infectious diseases simultaneously continued their declines VACCINATION MYTH #3: in the absence of vaccines. In England and Wales, smallpox disease and vacci- nation rates eventually declined simulta- 5
  6. 6. neously over a period of several decades U.S. Division of Biological Standards, between the 1870’s and the beginning of Dr. J. Anthony Morris, analyzed the 41 World War II.36 It is thus impossible to cases, he confirmed only 5, and all had say whether or not vaccinations con- been vaccinated.40 Such instances as tributed to the continuing declines in dis- these demonstrate the fallacy of inci- ease death rates, or if the declines con- dence figures, yet vaccine advocates tinued unabated simply due to the same tend to rely on them forces which likely brought about the indiscriminatel</p>y. initial declines—improvements in sanita- tion, hygiene and diet; better housing, VACCINATION TRUTH #3 transportation and infrastructure; better food preservation techniques and tech- “It is unclear what impact, if any, that nology; and possibly natural disease cy- vaccines had on 19th and 20th century in- cles. Underscoring this conclusion was a fectious disease declines.” recent World Health Organization report which found that the disease and mortal- ity rates in third world countries have no VACCINATION MYTH #4: direct correlation with immunization procedures or medical treatment, but are “Vaccination is based on sound immu- closely related to the standard of hygiene nization theory and practice...” and diet.37 Credit given to vaccinations for our current disease incidence has ...or is it? simply been grossly exaggerated, if not outright misplaced. The</p> clinical evidence for vaccines is their ability to stimulate anti- Vaccine advocates point to inci- body production in the recipient. What is dence rather than mortality statistics as not clear, however, is whether or not an- evidence of vaccine effectiveness. How- tibody production constitutes immunity. ever, statisticians tell us that mortality For example, agamma globulin-anemic statistics are a better measure of disease children are incapable of producing anti- than incidence figures, for the simple bodies, yet they recover from infectious reason that the quality of reporting and diseases almost as quickly as other chil- record keeping is much higher on fatali- dren.41 Furthermore, a study published ties.38 For instance, a survey in New by the British Medical Council in 1950 York City revealed that only 3.2% of pe- during a diphtheria epidemic concluded diatricians were actually reporting that there was no relationship between measles cases to the health department. antibody count and disease incidence; re- In 1974, the CDC determined that there searchers found resistant people with ex- were 36 cases of measles in Georgia, tremely low antibody counts and sick while the Georgia State Surveillance people with high counts.42 Natural im- System reported 660 cases.39 In 1982, munization is a complex interactive pro- Maryland state health officials blamed a cess involving many bodily organs and pertussis epidemic on a television pro- systems; it cannot be replicated merely gram, “D.P.T.—Vaccine Roulette,” by the artificial stimulation of antibod- which warned of the dangers of DPT, ies. but when former top virologist for the 6
  7. 7. Research also indicates that vac- developed symptoms if he or she had not cination commits immune cells to the been vaccinated. It is also worth noting specific antigens in a vaccine, rendering that outbreaks in recent years have them incapable of reacting to other in- recorded more disease cases in vaccinat- fections. Immunological reserves may ed children than in unvaccinated chil- thus actually be reduced, causing a gen- dren. erally lowered resistance. 43 Yet another surprising aspect of Another component of immu- immunization practice is the “one size nization theory is “herd immunity,” the fits all” aspect. An 8-pound 2-month-old notion that when enough people in a baby receives the same dosage as a 40 community are immunized, all are pro- pound five year old. Infants with imma- tected. As Myth #2 showed, there are ture, undeveloped immune systems may many documented instances showing receive five or more times the dosage, just the opposite—fully vaccinated pop- relative to body weight, as older chil- ulations have experienced epidemics. dren. Furthermore, the number of “units” With measles, this actually seems to be within doses has been found in random the direct result of high vaccination testing to range from ½ to 3 times what rates.44 In Minnesota, a state epidemiolo- the label indicates; manufacturing quali- gist concluded that the Hib vaccine in- ty controls appear to tolerate a rather creases the risk of illness when a study large margin of error. “Hot Lots”—vac- revealed that vaccinated children were cine lots associated with disproportion- five times more likely to contract menin- ately high death and disability rates— gitis than unvaccinated children.45 have been repeatedly identified by the NVIC, but the FDA consistently refuses Surprisingly, vaccination has to intervene to prevent further unneces- never actually been clinically proven to sary injury and deaths. In fact, individual be effective in preventing disease, for the vaccine lots have never been recalled simple reason that no researcher has di- due to their greater incidence of adverse rectly exposed test subjects to diseases reactions. However, the rotavirus vac- (nor may they ethically do so). The med- cine was taken off the market a few ical community’s gold standard, the dou- months after being introduced when it ble blind, placebo-controlled study, has caused bowel obstructions in many re- not been used to compare vaccinated and cipients. Incredibly, the FDA and CDC unvaccinated people, and so the practice knew about this problem prior to licens- remains scientifically unproven. Further- ing the vaccine, but both organizations more, it is important to recognize that still gave their unanimous approval.46 not everyone exposed to a disease devel- ops symptoms (indeed, only a tiny per- Finally, vaccines are adminis- centage of a population need develop tered with the assumption that all recipi- symptoms for an epidemic to be de- ents—regardless of race, culture, diet, clared). Thus, if a vaccinated individual genetic makeup, geographic location, or is exposed to a disease and doesn’t get any other characteristic—will respond sick, it is impossible to know whether the same. This was perhaps never more the vaccine worked, because there is no dramatically disproved than in Australi- way to know if that person would have a's Northern Territory a few years ago, 7
  8. 8. where stepped-up immunization cam- paigns in native aborigines resulted in an Most childhood infectious dis- incredible 50% infant mortality rate.47 eases have few serious consequences in One must wonder about the lives of the today's modern world. Even conserva- survivors, too; if half died, surely the tive CDC statistics for pertussis during other half did not escape unaffected. 1992-94 indicate a 99.8% recovery rate. In fact, when hundreds of pertussis cases Almost as troubling was a recent occurred in Ohio and Chicago in the fall study in the New England Journal of 1993 outbreak, an infectious disease ex- Medicine reporting that a substantial pert from Cincinnati Children's Hospital number of Romanian children were con- said, “The disease was very mild, no one tracting polio from the vaccine. Re- died, and no one went to the intensive searchers found a correlation with injec- care unit.” tions of antibiotics. A single injection within one month of vaccination raised The vast majority of the time, the risk of polio eight times, two to nine childhood infectious diseases are benign injections raised the risk 27-fold, and 10 and self-limiting. They usually impart or more injections raised the risk 182 lifelong immunity, whereas vaccine-in- times.48 duced immunity is only temporary. In fact, the temporary nature of vaccine im- What other factors not accounted munity can create a more dangerous situ- for in vaccination theory will surface un- ation in a child’s future. For example, expectedly to reveal unforeseen or previ- the new chicken pox vaccine has an ef- ously overlooked consequences? We fectiveness estimated at 6 - 10 years. If cannot begin to fully comprehend the effective, it will postpone the child's vul- scope and degree of the danger until nerability until adulthood, when death public health officials begin looking and from the disease, while still rare, is 20 reporting in earnest. In the meantime, times more likely than in childhood. entire countries’ populations are unwit- “Measles parties” used to be common in ting gamblers in a game that many might Britain; if a child got measles, other par- very well choose not to play if they were ents in the neighborhood would rush given all the rules in advance. their kids over to play with the infected child, to deliberately contract the disease VACCINATION TRUTH #4: and develop natural lifetime immunity. This avoids the risk of infection in adult- “Many of the assumptions upon which hood that comes with artificial immuni- immunization theory and practice are un- ty, when the disease is more dangerous, proven or have been proven false in their and provides the benefits of an immune application.” system strengthened by the natural dis- ease process. VACCINATION MYTH #5: About half of measles cases in “Childhood diseases are extremely dan- the late 1980's resurgence were in ado- gerous...” lescents and adults, most of whom were vaccinated as children,49 and the recom- ...or are they, really? mended booster shots may provide pro- 8
  9. 9. tection for less than six months.50 Some healthcare professionals are concerned ...or was it? that the virus from the chicken pox vac- cine may “reactivate later in life in the Six New England states reported form of herpes zoster (shingles) or other increases in polio one year after the Salk immune system disorders.”51 Dr. A. vaccine was introduced, ranging from Lavin of the Dept. of Pediatrics, St. more than doubling in Vermont to Mas- Luke's Medical Center in Cleveland, sachusetts’ astounding increase of 642%; Ohio, strongly opposed licensing the other states reported increases as well. new vaccine, “until we actually The incidence in Wisconsin increased by know...the risks involved in injecting a factor of five. Idaho and Utah actually mutated DNA [the vaccine herpes virus] halted vaccination due to the increased into the host genome [children].”52 The incidence and death rate. In 1959, 77.5% truth is, no one knows, but the vaccine is of Massachusetts’ paralytic cases had re- now licensed, recommended by health ceived 3 doses of IPV (injected polio authorities, and quickly becoming man- vaccine). During 1962 U.S. Congres- dated throughout the country. sional hearings, Dr. Bernard Greenberg, head of the Dept. of Biostatistics for the Not only are most infectious dis- University of North Carolina School of eases rarely dangerous, they can actually Public Health, testified that not only did play a vital role in the developing a the cases of polio increase substantially strong, healthy immune system. Persons after mandatory vaccinations—a 50% in- who have not had measles have a higher crease from 1957 to 1958, and an 80% incidence of certain skin diseases, de- increase from 1958 to 1959—but that the generative diseases of bone and carti- statistics were deliberately manipulated lage, and certain tumors, while absence by the Public Health Service to give the of mumps has been linked to higher risks opposite impression.53 It is important to of ovarian cancer. Anthroposophical understand that the polio vaccine was medical doctors recommend only the not universally accepted, at least initial- tetanus and polio vaccines; they believe ly. Despite this, polio declined both in contracting other childhood infectious European countries that refused mass diseases is beneficial in that it matures vaccination as well as in those that em- and strengthens the immune system. ployed it. VACCINATION TRUTH #5: According to Australian re- searcher-author Dr. Viera Scheibner, “Dangers of childhood diseases are 90% of polio cases were eliminated from greatly exaggerated in order to scare par- statistics by health authorities’ redefini- ents into compliance with a questionable tion of the disease when the vaccine was but highly profitable procedure.” introduced, while in reality the Salk vac- cine was continuing to cause paralytic polio in several countries amidst an ab- VACCINATION MYTH #6: sence of epidemics caused by the wild virus. For example, cases of viral and “Polio was one of the clearly great vacci- aseptic meningitis, which have symp- nation success stories...” toms similar to polio, were routinely di- 9
  10. 10. agnosed and recorded as polio before the higher than that cited by the CDC. No- vaccine, but were distinguished and re- tably, the live poliovirus is no longer in moved from polio statistics after the vac- widespread use. cine. Also, the number of cases needed to declare an epidemic was raised from To be sure, polio as it was known 20 to 35, and the requirement for inclu- in the first half of the 20th century does sion in paralysis statistics was changed not exist today. However, declines fol- from symptoms that lasted for 24 hours lowing polio peaks in the late 1940’s and to symptoms lasting 60 days (many polio early 1950’s had been underway for a victims’ paralyses were temporary). It is period of years by the time the vaccine no wonder that polio decreased radically was introduced. after vaccines—at least on paper. In 1985, the CDC reported that 87% of the VACCINATION TRUTH #6: cases of polio in the U.S. between 1973 and 1983 were caused by the vaccine, “The polio vaccine temporarily reversed and later declared that all but a few im- disease declines that were underway be- ported cases since were caused by the fore the vaccine was introduced; this fact vaccine—and most of the imported cases was deliberately covered up by health occurred in fully vaccinated individuals. authorities. In Europe, polio declined in countries that both embraced and reject- Jonas Salk, inventor of the IPV, ed the vaccine.” testified before a Senate subcommittee that nearly all polio outbreaks since 1961 were caused by the oral polio vaccine. VACCINATION MYTH #7: At a workshop on polio vaccines spon- sored by the Institute of Medicine and “My child had no reaction to the vac- the Centers for Disease Control and Pre- cines, so there is nothing to worry vention, Dr. Samuel Katz of Duke Uni- about...” versity cited the estimated 8-10 annual U.S. cases of vaccine-associated paralyt- ...or is there? ic polio (VAPP) in people who have tak- en the oral polio vaccine, and the [then The documented long term ad- four year] absence of wild polio from the verse effects of vaccines include chronic western hemisphere. Jessica Scheer of immunological and neurological disor- the National Rehabilitation Hospital Re- ders such as autism, hyperactivity, atten- search Center in Washington, D.C., tion deficit disorders, dyslexia, allergies, pointed out that most parents are un- cancer, and other conditions, many of aware that polio vaccination in this which barely existed before mass vacci- country entails “a small number of hu- nation programs. Vaccine ingredients in- man sacrifices each year.” Compounding clude known toxicants and carcinogens this contradiction are low adverse event such as thimersol (a mercury derivative), reporting and the NVIC’s experiences aluminum phosphate, formaldehyde (for with confirming and correcting misdiag- which the Poisons Information Centre in noses of vaccine reactions, which sug- Australia claims there is no acceptable gest that the actual number of VAPP safe amount that can be injected into a “sacrifices” may be 10 to 100 times living human body), and phenoxyethanol 10
  11. 11. (commonly known as antifreeze). Some is thus not only known, but relied upon of these ingredients are gastrointestinal by clinical researchers studying brain toxicants, liver toxicants, respiratory tox- disorders. icants, neurotoxicants, cardiovascular and blood toxicants, reproductive toxi- A German study found correla- cants, and developmental toxicants, to tions between vaccinations and 22 neu- name a few of the known dangers. rological conditions including attention Chemical ranking systems rate many deficit and epilepsy. Another dilemma is vaccine ingredients among the most haz- that viral elements in vaccines may per- ardous substances, and they are heavily sist and mutate in the human body for regulated. Even microscopic doses of years, with unknown consequences. Mil- some of these ingredients are known to lions of children are partaking in an be able to cause serious injury. In addi- enormous, crude experiment, and no sin- tion, some vaccine mediums used in the cere, organized effort is being made to production of vaccines contain human track the negative side effects or to de- diploid cells originating from human termine the long-term consequences. aborted fetal tissue, a fact that might af- Since long-term studies on the adverse fect many people’s vaccination choices effects of vaccines are virtually non-ex- —if they only knew this was the case. istent, their widespread use in the ab- sence of informed consent and adequate Medical historian, researcher and safety testing constitutes medical experi- author Harris Coulter, Ph.D. explained mentation. As the American Association that his extensive research revealed of Physicians and Surgeons and the Na- childhood immunization to be “causing a tional Vaccine Information Center have low-grade encephalitis in infants on a pointed out, this is a violation of the first much wider scale than public health au- principle of the Nuremberg Code, “the thorities were willing to admit, about centerpiece of modern bioethics.”54,55 15-20% of all children.” He points out that the sequelae [conditions known to Bart Classen, MD, PhD, founder result from a disease] of encephalitis [in- of Classen Immunotherapies and devel- flammation of the brain, a documented oper of vaccine technologies, conducted adverse effect of vaccination]: autism, epidemiological studies around the learning disabilities, minimal and not-so- world and found vaccines to be the cause minimal brain damage, seizures, epilep- of 79% of insulin type I diabetes in chil- sy, sleeping and eating disorders, sexual dren under 10. The increase risk ranged disorders, asthma, crib death, diabetes, from 9% with the diphtheria vaccine to obesity, and impulsive violence are pre- 50% with the Hepatitis B vaccine. Ac- cisely the disorders which afflict con- cording to Classen, CDC data confirms temporary society. Many of these condi- his findings. However, the implications tions were formerly relatively rare, but of Classen’s findings go well beyond di- they have become more common as abetes, as his comment in a 1999 issue of childhood vaccination programs have the British Medical Journal points out: expanded. Coulter also points out that “The incidence of many other chronic pertussis toxoid is used to induce en- immunological diseases, including asth- cephalitis in lab animals. The pertussis ma, allergies, and immune mediated can- vaccine’s ability to cause brain damage cers, has risen rapidly and may also be 11
  12. 12. linked to immunisation.”56 The diabetes otherwise explain the dramatic rise in findings may be only the tip of the ice- many of these diseases.” berg. Recent studies in the U.S. and VACCINATION MYTH #8: England suggest that vaccines cause autism.57,58,59 Mercury poisoning and “Vaccines are the only disease preven- autism have nearly identical symptoms,60 tion option available...” and a single day’s vaccination regimen may inject 41 times the level of mercury ...or are they? known to cause harm.61 California’s autism rate has mushroomed 1000% Most parents feel compelled to over the past 20 years, with dramatic in- take some disease-preventing action for creases following the introduction of the their children. While there is no 100% MMR vaccine in the early 1980’s. Eng- guarantee anywhere, there are viable al- land had dramatic autism increases be- ternatives. Historically, homeopathy has ginning in the 1990’s, following the in- proven many times to be more effective troduction of the MMR vaccine there. than allopathic medicine in the treatment Some infants receive 100 times the and prevention of disease. In a U.S. EPA’s maximum allowable amount of cholera outbreak in 1849, allopathic mercury through vaccines. In January, medicine saw a 48-60% death rate, while 2000, the Journal of Adverse Drug Reac- homeopathic hospitals had a documented tions reported that the MMR vaccine death rate of only 3%.63 Roughly similar was not adequately tested and should not statistics still hold true for cholera to- have been licensed. Further reinforcing day.64 Recent epidemiological studies the suspected vaccine-autism connection show homeopathic remedies as equaling is the fact that many physicians using a or surpassing standard vaccinations in systematic mercury-detoxification regi- preventing disease. There are reports in men with autistic patients have seen dra- which populations that were treated matic improvements in the health and homeopathically after exposure had a behavior of their patients.62 Today, one 100% success rate—none of the treated out of every 150 children are affected by caught the disease.65 autism, according to the National Vac- cine Information Center. In the early There are homeopathic kits avail- 1940’s, prior to the introduction of most able for disease prevention.66 Homeo- vaccines in current use, it was consid- pathic remedies can also be taken only ered a rare condition that few doctors during times of increased risk (out- would ever encounter in their practice. breaks, traveling, etc.), and have proven highly effective in such instances. And VACCINATION TRUTH #7: since these remedies have no toxic com- ponents, they have virtually no side ef- “The long term adverse effects of vacci- fects. In addition, homeopathy has been nations have been ignored in spite of effective in reversing some of the dis- compelling correlations with many seri- ability caused by vaccine reactions, not ous chronic conditions. Doctors can’t to mention many other chronic condi- 12
  13. 13. tions with which allopathic medicine has more required vaccines. In general, had little success. though, medical exemptions are difficult to get, may be available only to those VACCINATION TRUTH #8: who have already had a serious vaccine reaction or who have a family history of “Documented safe and effective alterna- serious vaccine reactions, may be grant- tives to vaccination have been available ed only for the specific vaccine believed for decades. However, they have been to have caused a previous reaction, and systematically attacked and suppressed may be valid only as long as the condi- by the medical establishment.” tion giving rise to the exemption persists (i.e., may be temporary). VACCINATION MYTH #9: 2) Religious Exemption: 48 states allow “Vaccinations are legally mandated and for a religious exemption (all but MS unavoidable...” and WV). A state’s laws may state that membership in an established religious ...or are they? organization is required. However, this requirement has been held unconstitu- In the U.S., vaccine laws vary tional in New York federal courts; per- from state to state. While every state sonal religious beliefs are sufficient for a legally requires vaccines, every state religious exemption, regardless of which also has one or more legal exemptions religious organization you belong to, or from vaccines. School and health offi- whether or not you belong to an orga- cials will seldom volunteer exemption nized religion at all.67,68,69,70 In one case, information, and are sometimes misin- the plaintiffs were awarded money dam- formed about legal exemptions, so it is ages when the court found that the state important to check the laws in your state had violated their civil rights by denying to find out exactly what the requirements them a religious exemption. are. Each state offers one or more of the following three kinds of exemptions: 3) Philosophical or Personal Exemption: Approximately 17 states allow parents to 1) Medical Exemption: All 50 states in refuse vaccination for personal or philo- the U.S. allow for a medical exemption. sophical reasons. However, few pediatricians check for in- dications of increased risk before admin- It is worth noting that exempted istering vaccines, so it is advisable for children may be banned from attending parents to research this matter for them- schools during local outbreaks. But all selves if they have reason to believe that schools, public or private, must comply their child may be predisposed to vac- with state vaccination laws and honor le- cine reactions. Epilepsy, severe allergies, gal exemptions. and a previous adverse reaction in a child or sibling are but a few of the many The best source for a copy of conditions in child or family history your state's vaccination laws is state which may increase the chances of an health officials. A phone call to the state adverse reaction, and thus may qualify Department of Epidemiology or Immu- for a medical exemption from one or nization (the specific name varies from 13
  14. 14. state to state) may be all that it takes to Conflicts of interest are the norm get a copy mailed to you. Or, for a small in the vaccine industry. Members and fee, the NVIC and New Atlantean Press Chairs of the FDA and CDC vaccine ad- will sell you a copy of your state’s im- visory committees own stock in drug munization laws (see contact informa- companies that make vaccines; individu- tion at the end of this article). Statutes als on both advisory committees own can be searched on the internet (for ex- patents for vaccines under consideration ample, see www.findlaw.com), but these or affected by the decisions these com- sources may not reflect very recent mittees make. The CDC grants conflict- changes in the law, if there have been of-interest waivers to every member of any. Law libraries and lawyers are, of their advisory committee a year at a course, a good source as well. time, allowing full participation in the discussions leading up to a vote by every VACCINATION TRUTH #9: member whether or not they have a fi- nancial stake in the decision.71 “Legal exemptions from vaccinations are available for many—but not all—U.S. Concerns over vaccine adverse citizens.” effects and conflicts of interest led the American Society of Physicians and Sur- geons to issue a Resolution to Congress VACCINATION MYTH #10: calling for a “moratorium on vaccine mandates and for physicians to insist “Public health officials always place the upon truly informed consent for the use public’s health above all other of vaccines.” Approved by unanimous concerns...” vote at the AAPS October 2000 annual meeting, the resolution made references ...or do they? to the “increasing numbers of mandatory childhood vaccines, to which children Vaccination history is riddled are…subjected without …information with documented instances of deceit por- about potential adverse side effects”; the traying vaccines as mighty disease con- fact that “safety testing of many vaccines querors, when in fact vaccines have had is limited and the data are unavailable little or no discernable impact on—or for independent scrutiny, so that mass have even delayed or reversed—pre-ex- vaccination is equivalent to human ex- isting disease declines. The United King- perimentation and subject to the Nurem- dom's Department of Health admitted berg Code, which requires voluntary in- that vaccination status determined the di- formed consent”; and the fact that “the agnosis of subsequent diseases: Those process of approving and ‘recommend- found in vaccinated patients received al- ing’ vaccines is tainted with conflicts of ternate diagnoses; hospital records and interest.”72 death certificates were falsified. Today, many doctors still refuse to diagnose dis- In an October 1999 statement to eases in vaccinated children, and so the Congress, Bart Classen, M.D., M.B.A., “Myth” about vaccine success persists. founder and CEO of Classen Im- munotherapies and developer of vaccine technologies, stated, “It is clear…that the 14
  15. 15. government's immunization policies… the safety and effectiveness of any phar- are driven by politics and not by science. maceutical product. Military personnel I can give numerous examples where have been, and continue to be, unwitting employees of the US Public Health Ser- subjects in unethical experiments. vice…appear to be furthering their ca- reers by acting as propaganda officers to VACCINATION TRUTH #10: support political agendas. In one case… employees of a foreign government, who “Many of the public health officials who were funded and working closely with determine vaccine policy profit substan- the US Public Health Service, submitted tially from their policy decisions.” false data to a major medical journal. The true data indicated the vaccine was dangerous however the false data that SOME CLOSING REMARKS was submitted indicated there was no risk. An employee of the NIH who man- In the December 1994 Medical ages large vaccine grants jointly pub- Post, Canadian author of the best-seller lished a misleading letter about the sub- Medical Mafia, Guylaine Lanctot, M.D., ject with one of these foreign civil ser- stated, “The medical authorities keep ly- vants. As you are aware it is illegal to ing. Vaccination has been a disaster on falsify data from research funded by the the immune system. It actually causes a US government.” Dr. Classen recom- lot of illnesses. We are actually changing mended that Congress hire a special our genetic code through prosecutor “to determine if public health vaccination...100 years from now we officials are following the laws enacted will know that the biggest crime against to ensure vaccines are safe” and to deter- humanity was vaccines.” After critically mine “if public health officials along analyzing literally ten’s of thousands of with manufacturers are misleading the pages of the vaccine medical literature, public about the safety of these prod- Dr. Viera Scheibner concluded that ucts.”73 “there is no evidence whatsoever of the ability of vaccines to prevent any dis- In France, 15,000 French citizens eases. To the contrary, there is a great have sued their government over adverse wealth of evidence that they cause seri- Hepatitis B vaccine reactions.74 Former ous side effects.”76 Dr. Classen has stat- public health officials there are serving ed, “My data proves that the studies used prison sentences following findings that to support immunization are so flawed they did not follow the law to ensure the that it is impossible to say if immuniza- safety of the vaccine, and school-age tion provides a net benefit to anyone or Hep B vaccination has been discontin- to society in general. This question can ued. U.S. military personnel may be only be determined by proper studies even worse off: “…four letters from the that have never been performed. The FDA/Public Health Service…clearly re- flaw of previous studies is that there was veal that the anthrax vaccine was ap- no long-term follow up and chronic toxi- proved for marketing without the manu- city was not looked at. The American facturer performing a single controlled Society of Microbiology has promoted clinical trial.”75 Clinical trials are, of my research...and thus acknowledges the course, absolutely critical to determining need for proper studies.”77 These may be 15
  16. 16. radical positions, but they are not un- out their lives, and every healthcare sys- founded. The continued denial and sup- tem and government a potential buyer, it pression of the evidence against vaccines is little wonder that countless millions of only perpetuates the “Myths” of their dollars are spent nurturing the growing “success” and, more importantly, their multi-billion dollar vaccine industry. negative consequences on our children Without public outcry, we will see more and society. Aggressive and comprehen- and more new vaccines required of us sive scientific investigation into adverse all. And while profits are readily calcula- vaccine events is clearly warranted, yet ble, the real human costs are ignored or immunization programs continue to ex- suppressed. pand in the absence of such research. Manufacturer profits are enormous, Whatever your personal vaccina- while accountability for the negative ef- tion decision, make it an informed one; fects is conspicuously absent. This is es- you have that right and responsibility. It pecially sad given the readily available is a difficult issue, but there is more than safe and effective alternatives. enough at stake to justify whatever time and energy it takes. The positions asserted above are not coming from a handful of fringe lu- natics; entire professional organizations are speaking out. Criticisms of vaccines FOR MORE INFORMATION: are being sounded by an increasing num- 1. National Vaccine Information Center, ber of credible and reputable scientists, 512 Maple Avenue West #206, Vienna, researchers, investigators, and self-edu- VA 22180. 703-938-DPT3; 800-909- cated parents from around the world. In- SHOT (7468). stead, it is public health officials and die- Email: info@909shot.com hard vaccine advocates (many of whom Website: http://www.909shot.com have a financial stake in the outcome of 2. Vaccine Information & Awareness the debate) who are beginning to lose (VIA), Karin Schumacher, J.D., Direc- tor. 792 Pineview Drive San Jose, CA credibility by refusing to acknowledge 95117. 408-397-4192 (voice mail/pag- the growing body of evidence and to ad- er) 408-554-9053 (phone/fax). Email: dress the very real, serious, documented via@access1.net. For information on all problems. sides of the issue, go to VIA’s Website: http://www.access1.net/via Meanwhile, the race is on. There 3. Vaccine Policy Institute, 251 Ridgeway are over 200 new vaccines being devel- Dr., Dayton, OH 45459, Krystine Sev- oped for everything from birth control to eryn, R.Ph., Ph.D., ph/fax: 513-435-4750. Quarterly Newsletter. cocaine addition.78 Some 100 of these Information from a highly credentialed, are already in clinical trials. Researchers highly informed expert on vaccines. are working on vaccine delivery through 4. New Atlantean Press P.O. Box 9638 nasal sprays, mosquitoes (yes, Santa Fe, NM 87504 505-983-1856. mosquitoes), and the fruits of “trans- Books, tapes, videos, write for catalog. genic” plants in which vaccine viruses are grown. With every adult and child on 5. Diane Rozario, Immunization Resource Guide, 4th Edition, Patter Publications, the planet a potential recipient of vac- P.O. Box 204, Burlington, IA 52601. cines administered periodically through- 319-752-0039, 888-513-7770, fax 16
  17. 17. 208-361-8889, email: patterpub@ya- 4. birth issues, fall 1999. Canadian magazine of hoo. com, or use a standard Internet the Association for Safe Alternatives in Child- search engine to find any of the many birth (ASAC). sellers online. This guide has it all, pro 5. The Home-Grown Family, spring, fall, winter and con, and is reasonably priced. 1998-99. Christian home-schooling magazine. 6. The Immune Manual, Life and Health Re- search Group, CA, 1997. ABOUT THE AUTHOR 7. Hindustan Times and other Indian newspa- pers; two Indian homeopathic journals, 1997 (ac- Alan Phillips is an attorney in Chapel cording to Sai Sanjeevini Foundation, New Del- Hill, NC, and a co-founder and director of Citi- hi, India). zens for Healthcare Freedom (CHF), a nonprofit 8. NEXUS Magazine, October-November 1997. corporation dedicated to raising vaccine aware- Multinational magazine. ness and advocating informed choice. Alan has a 9. Wildfire, spring 1996. US Native American background in technical writing, writing assess- magazine. ment, children’s elementary education, freelance 10. Numerous grass-roots organizations’ writing and investigative research on alternative newsletters around the world. health issues, and is known internationally for professional music performance and production. Unsolicited Distributors: 1. Sai Sanjeevini Foundation, New Delhi, India. INTRODUCTORY VACCINE PRESENTA- 2. HealthAction Network, UK. TIONS 3. Vaccine Information Network, New Zealand. 4. Prometheus (publisher), UK. Citizens for Healthcare Freedom Director Alan 5. Medical Missionary Press, NC, USA. Phillips, Esq., conducts introductory lectures on 6. Asian Pacific Homeopathic Association, Hong the vaccine controversy. Presentations are de- Kong. signed to complement and supplement the infor- mation in this article. To sponsor a presentation Request for classroom use by: in your home, office, local library, or other suit- 1. Sheffield Homeopathic College, UK. able location, write to CHF Lectures, P.O. Box 2. A neurologist in Italy. 3473, Chapel Hill, NC 27515-3473, or email 3. A medical school professor in NC. lawpapa@nc.rr.com. Internet Postings: There are many; solicitations RELATED ARTICLES: are ongoing. Alan has researched and written on several vac- cine legal issues, including vaccine exemptions (with a focus on religious exemption federal case law), the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, and the shaken-baby-syndrome/vaccine injury connection: the documented instances in which parents and caretakers are convicted of child abuse, but later the damage is shown to have been caused by a vaccine injury. UNSOLICITED PUBLISHINGS: 1. parenteacher magazine, summer 2000. 2. Claudia’s Abundant Life Health Food Market, 09/1999 – 02/2000. 3. Epidemics, Opposing Viewpoints, Greenhaven Press, 1999. 17
  18. 18. ENDNOTES Am J Epidemiol 1994 Jan 15;139(2):229-30. Di- 1 Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System vision of Immunization, Centers for Disease (VAERS); National Technical Information Ser- Control, Atlanta, GA 30333. 14 vice, Springfield, VA 22161, 703-487-4650, See Viera Scheibner, supra note 12. 15 703-487-4600; see also NVIC, infra note 7; and Nature and Rates of Adverse Reactions Asso- the VAERS website at http://www.fda.gov/cber/ ciated with DTP and DT Immunizations in In- vaers/vaers.htm. fants and Children (Pediatrics, Nov. 1981, Vol. 2 Statement of the National Vaccine Information 68, No. 5) 16 Center (NVIC), Hearing of the House Subcom- DPT Report, The Fresno Bee, Community Re- mittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy and Hu- lations, 1626 E. Street, Fresno, CA 93786, De- man Resources, "Compensating Vaccine In- cember 5, 1984. 17 juries: Are Reforms Needed?" September 28, Trollfors B, Rabo, E. 1981. Whooping cough 1999. in adults. British Medical Journal (September 3 Less than 1%, according to Barbara Fisher, cit- 12), 696-97. 18 ing former FDA Commissioner David Kessler, National Vaccine Injury Compensation Pro- 1993, JAMA, in the Statement of the NVIC, gram (NVICP) http://bhpr.hrsa.gov/vicp/. 19 supra note 2. Measles vaccine failures: lack of sustained 4 Less than 10%, according to KM Severyn, measles specific immunoglobulin G responses in R.Ph., Ph.D. in the Dayton Daily News, May 28, revaccinated adolescents and young adults. De- 1993. (Vaccine Policy Institute, 251 Ridgeway partment of Pediatrics, Georgetown University Dr., Dayton, OH 45459) Medical Center, Washington, DC 20007. Pedi- 5 American Association of Physicians and Sur- atric Infectious Disease Journal. 13(1):34-8, geons, Fact Sheet on Mandatory Vaccines at 1994 Jan. 20 http://www.aapsonline.org/. Measles outbreak in 31 schools: risk factors for 6 Jane Orient, M.D., Director of the American vaccine failure and evaluation of a selective re- Association of Physicians and Surgeons, “Man- vaccination strategy. Department of Preventive dating Vaccines: Government Practicing Medicine and Biostatistics, University of Toron- Medicine Without a License?” 1999. to, Ont. Canadian Medical Association Journal. 7 National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), 150(7):1093-8, 1994 Apr 1. 21 512 Maple Ave. W. #206, Vienna, VA 22180, Haemophilus b disease after vaccination with 703-938-0342; "Investigative Report on the Vac- Haemophilus b polysaccharide or conjugate vac- cine Adverse Event Reporting System." cine. Institution Division of Bacterial Products, 8 42 U.S.C.S. § 300aa-25(b)(1)(A),(B). Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research, 9 Karlsson L. Scheibner V. Association between Food and Drug Administration, Bethesda, Md non-specific stress syndrome, DPT injections 20892. American Journal of Diseases of Chil- and cot death. Paper presented to the 2nd immu- dren. 145(12):1379-82, 1991 Dec. 22 nization conference, Canberra, Australia, May Sustained transmission of mumps in a highly 27-29, 1992. See also Viera Schiebner, Ph.D., vaccinated population: assessment of primary Vaccination: 100 Years of Orthodox Research vaccine failure and waning vaccine-induced im- Shows that Vaccines Represent a Medical As- munity. Division of Field Epidemiology, Centers sault on the Immune System for discussion and for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, references. Georgia. Journal of Infectious Diseases. 10 W.C. Torch, "Diptheria-pertussis-tetanus 169(1):77-82, 1994 Jan. 1. 23 (DPT) immunization: A potential cause of the Secondary measles vaccine failure in health- sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS)," (Amer. care workers exposed to infected patients. De- Academy of Neurology, 34th Annual Meeting, partment of Pediatrics, Children's Hospital of Apr 25 - May 1, 1982), Neurology 32(4), pt. 2. Philadelphia, PA 19104. Infection Control & 11 Id. Hospital Epidemiology. 14(2):81-6, 1993 Feb. 12 24 Viera Schiebner, Ph.D., Vaccination: 100 MMWR (Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Re- Years of Orthodox Research Shows that Vac- port) 38 (8-9), 12/29/89. 25 cines Represent a Medical Assault on the Im- MMWR "Measles." 1989; 38:329-330. 26 mune System, 1993. MMWR. 33(24),6/22/84. 13 27 Confounding in studies of adverse reactions to Failure to reach the goal of measles elimina- vaccines [see comments]. Fine PE, Chen RT, tion. Apparent paradox of measles infections in REVIEW ARTICLE: 38 REFS. Comment in: immunized persons. Review article: 50 REFS. 18
  19. 19. Dept. of Internal Medicine, Mayo Vaccine Re- 48 Washington Post, February 22, 1995. search Group, Mayo Clinic and Foundation, 49 Reported by KM Severyn, R.Ph, Ph.D. in the Rochester, MN. Archives of Internal Medicine. Dayton Daily News, June 3, 1995. 154(16):1815-20, 1994 Aug 22. 50 Vaccine Information and Awareness (VIA), 28 Clinical Immunology and Immunopathology, "Measles and Antibody Titre Levels," from Vac- May 1996; 79(2): 163-170. cine Weekly, January 1996. 29 Trevor Gunn, Mass Immunization, A Point in 51 NVIC Press Release, "Consumer Group Warns Question, at 15 (citing E.D. Hume, Pasteur Ex- use of New Chicken Pox Vaccine in all Healthy posed-The False Foundations of Modern Children May Cause More Serious Disease". Medicine, Bookreal, Australia, 1989.) 52 Id. [Reported by KM Severyn, R.Ph., Ph.D.] 30 Physician William Howard Hay's address of 53 Hearings before the Committee on Interstate June 25, 1937; printed in the Congressional and Foreign Commerce, House of Representa- Record. tives, 87th Congress, Second Session on H.R. 31 Eleanor McBean, The Poisoned Needle, Health 10541, May 1962, at 94. Research, 1956. 54 NVIC Vaccine Conference Program Guide, 32 Outbreak of paralytic poliomyelitis in Oman; 1997. evidence for widespread transmission among ful- 55 Unanimous resolution of the AAPS, 57th Annu- ly vaccinated children. Lancet vol 338: Sept 21, al Meeting, St. Louis, MO, October, 2000; see 1991; 715-720. http://www.aapsonline.org/. 33 Neil Miller, Vaccines: Are They Really Safe 56 British Medical Journal, 1999, 318:193, 16 and Effective? Fifth Printing, 1994, at 33. (January). 34 Chicago Dept. of Health. 57 35 Harold Buttram, M.D., “Vaccine Scene 2000, Singh V, Yang V. Serological association of Review and Update,” Medical Sentinel, Vol.5 measles virus and human herpes virus-6 with No. 2, March/April 2000. brain autoantibodies in autism. Clinical Im- 36 Neil Miller, supra note 33 at 45 [NVIC News, munology and Immunopathology April 92 at 12]. 1998;88(l):105-108. 58 37 S. Curtis, A Handbook of Homeopathic Alter- Wakefield AJ, et al. Ileal-lymphoid-nodular natives to Immunization. hyperplasia, non-specific colitis, and pervasive 38 Darrell Huff, How to Lie With Statistics, W.W. developmental disorder in children. Lancet Norton & Co., Inc., 1954 at 84. 1998;351:637-641. 59 39 Quoted from the internet, credited to Keith Wakefield AJ, Anthony A, Murch SH, Thom- Block, M.D., a family physician from Evanston, son M, Montgomery SM, et al. Enterocolitis in Illinois, who has spent years collecting data in Children With Developmental Disorders. Am the medical literature on immunizations. JGastroenterol September; 95:2285-2295. 60 40 See Trevor Gunn, supra, note 29, at 15. Stephanie Cave, MD, NVIC Vaccine Confer- 41 Id. at 21. ence, September, 2000; see http://www.909shot.- 42 Id. at 21 (British Medical Council Publication com for conference transcripts and information. 61 272, May 1950). Congressman Dan Burton, House Committee 43 See Trevor Gunn, supra, note 29, at 21; see on Government Reform, Hearing on Mercury also Neil Miller, supra note 33 at 47 (Buttram, and Medicine, 6/18/2000. 62 MD, Hoffman, Mothering Magazine, Winter Press Release, Feb. 12, 2001; see 1985 at 30; Kalokerinos and Dettman, MDs, http://www.autism.com/ari/press1.html 63 "The Dangers of Immunization," Biological Re- Dana Ullman, Discovering Homeopathy, at 42 search Inst. [Australia], 1979, at 49). (Thomas L. Bradford, Logic Figures, p68, 44 See Mayo Vaccine Research Group, supra note 113-146; Coulter, Divided Legacy, Vol 3, p268). 64 27. See S. Curtis, supra note 34. 65 45 See Neil Miller, supra note 33 at 34. See S. Curtis, supra note 34. 66 46 Chairman/Congressman Dan Burton, Commit- Isaac Golden, Vaccination? A Review of Risks tee of Government Reform, Opening Statement, and Alternatives, 5th Edition, 1994. (Australia). 67 “FACA: Conflicts of Interest and Vaccine De- Allanson v. Clinton Central School District, velopment, Preserving the Integrity of the Pro- No. CV 84-174, slip op. at 5 (N.D.N.Y. 1984). 68 cess,” June 2000. Sherr and Levy vs. Northport East-Northport 47 Archie Kalolerinos, MD, Every Second Child, Union Free School District, 672 F. Supp. 81 Keats Publishing, Inc. 1981. (E.D.N.Y. 1987). 19
  20. 20. 69 Fishkin v. Yonkers Public Schools, 710 F. Supp. 506 (S.D.N.Y. 1989). 70 Berg v. Glen Cove City School District, 853 F. Supp. 651 (E.D.N.Y. 1994). 71 Congressman Dan Burton, Committee on Gov- ernment Reform, “FACA: Conflicts of Interest and Vaccine Development: Preserving the In- tegrity of the Process,” June 15, 2000. 72 “AAPS Resolution Concerning Mandatory Vaccines” at http://www.aapsonline.org/aaps/. 73 J. Barthelow Classen, M.D., M.B.A. President and CEO, Classen Im- munotherapies, Inc., 6517 Montrose Ave, Balti- more, MD 21212 Tel: (410) 377-4549 Fax: (410) 377-8526 E-mail: Classen@vaccines.net, letter to The Honorable Dan Burton, Chairman U.S. House of Representatives, Committee on Gov- ernment Reform, Washington, DC 20515, Octo- ber 12th, 1999, at http://vaccines.net. 74 “Show us the Science,” Mothering Magazine, March/April 2001, Report on the Sept. 2000 NVIC Vaccine Conference. 75 See J. Barthelow Classen, MD, MBA, supra note 73. 76 Viera Scheibner, PhD, 178 Govetts Leap Road, Blackheath, NSW 2785, Australia; phone +61 (0)2 4787 8203, Fax +61 (0)2 4787 8988 77 See J. Barthelow Classen, MD, MBA, supra note 73. 78 Statement of the National Vaccine Information Center, Hearing of the House Subcommittee on Criminal Justice, Drug Policy and Human Re- sources, "Compensating Vaccine Injuries: Are Reforms Needed?" September 28, 1999. 20