SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
WHAT IS RESEARCH IN THE VIRTUAL
WORLD?
Madelyne Oliver
THE LITERATURE: PREFERENCES TO WEB-BASED
  TOOLS OR NON-WEB-BASED TOOLS AMONG
           SCHOLARS IN THE VISUAL ARTS
•Catherine Larkin, (2010) “Looking to the Future While Learning from
the Past: Information Seeking in the Visual Arts” Art Documentation,
vol 29, n. 1.




                                                               Photo
                                                               courtesy of
                                                               Catherine
                                                               Larkin
                                                               ©2010
Photo
courtesy of
Catherine
Larkin ©2010
Photo
courtesy of
Catherine
Larkin ©2010
LITERATURE REVIEW CONTINUED…
Jennifer Mayer and Cheryl Goldenstein (2009), “Academic libraries
Supporting Visual Culture: A Survey of Image Access and Use,” Art
Documentation, vol 28, N. 1.




                                                              Photo
                                                              courtesy of
                                                              Catherine
                                                              Larkin ©2010
Photo courtesy of
Catherine Larkin ©2010
Photo
courtesy of
Catherine
Larkin ©2010
PREDICTIONS

 Visual scholars are becoming more adaptive to technological
resources because web-based tools are used increasingly more
often than non-web-based tools for seeking information and
collecting research, most especially images.

The authority of online resources and web-based tools are still
heavily questioned by scholars and not seen as reliable as print or
physical resources and tools.
OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study is to push the boundaries between two
disciplinary fields: anthropology and art history (Social Sciences and the
Humanities) through personal observation and interactions with the
virtual space of the online archive and labeling digital images for
submission to SAHARA.

In essence, I will explore how these web-based tools and online spaces
channel the exchange of methods, resources, and data from both
academic disciplines and if the increasing interaction with the virtual
world encourages an intimate relationship between the researcher and
the researched subject.
TAGGING AND CATEGORIZING…..
EXCHANGE OF VISUAL INFORMATION: DIGITAL
         TOOLS AND METADATA
COMMON WEB-BASED IMAGE RESOURCES: ONLINE
  IMAGE ARCHIVES ARTSTOR AND SAHARA
WEB-BASED TOOLS/ONLINE INTERFACES
           EXPLORED:
Zotero
SAHARA
Society of Architectural Historians (www.sah.org)
ARTstor
JSTOR
Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians Online www.jsah.org
Cataloging Cultural Objects (CCO
ALNA (Association of Librarians of North America)
The Dictionary of Art
Grove Art Online
Full Text
Anthropology Plus
Anthropology Index
AnthroSource
Humanities and Social Sciences Index Retrosprective
ISI Citation Databases:
          Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) (1900-       present)
          Arts and Humanities Citation Index (AHCI) (1975- present)
TESTING SCHOLARS’ ONLINE INFORMATION
         SEEKING BEHAVORS FOR THE YEAR 2011…

How often do you use a computer and online tools for research?

                       Frequency              Percent
Always                             4                    57.1
Sometimes                          2                    28.6
None                               1                    14.3
Total                              7                    100%
What web-based tool do you utilize the most for
  research?
  Google                      3              42.9
  Youtube.com                 3              42.9
  Google Scholar              1              14.3
  Total                       7             100%

How do you search for images?
Databases (ARTstor,       5                 56%
SAHARA, AP images)

General search            5                 44%
engines or image
search engines
(Google, yahoo, flickr)
Library’s                 0                 0
collection/prind index
Total                     9                 100%
Electronic and digital images facilitate and inspire my work.
Strongly Agree                         2                    29%
Agree                                  5                    71%
Neutral                                0                    0%
Disagree                               0                    0%
Strongly Disagree                      0                    0%
Total                                  7                   100%


        If you believe web-based tools serve as authoritative
        sources, please rate the level of authority accordingly.
        Excellent                  0                 0%
        Good                       3                 43%
        Neutral                    3                 43%
        Fair                       1                 14%
        Poor                       0                 0%
        Total                      7                100%
WHAT DOES THE RESEARCH SAY ABOUT
           RESEARCH?

                        Such web-based tools for cataloging
                        images and articles facilitated close
                        observations of art historians’ use of the
                        virtual space for personal research and
                        the public exchange of visual data.

                        Anthropological training in participant
                        observation aided the exploration of
                        these web-based tools, revealing an
                        encouraging intimate relationship between
                        the researcher and his or her subject matter.

                        Related literature indicated that academics
                        frequently use web-based tools for
                        information-collecting purposes, in which
                        disciplinary fields overlap.

More Related Content

Similar to What is research in the virtual world?

Library, what's Library? Creative Library Assessment
Library, what's Library? Creative Library AssessmentLibrary, what's Library? Creative Library Assessment
Library, what's Library? Creative Library AssessmentOlga Koz, DM, MLS
 
Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba...
 Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba... Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba...
Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba...Lynn Connaway
 
Chandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior Review
Chandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior ReviewChandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior Review
Chandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior ReviewKim Arcand
 
Libraries Case Study
Libraries Case StudyLibraries Case Study
Libraries Case StudyConduit
 
Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...
Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...
Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...Filipe MS Bento
 
Nitle 2013 presentation
Nitle 2013 presentationNitle 2013 presentation
Nitle 2013 presentationNITLE
 
Social information Access2012
Social information Access2012Social information Access2012
Social information Access2012Peter Brusilovsky
 
The Internet, Science, and Transformations of Knowledge
The Internet, Science, and Transformations of KnowledgeThe Internet, Science, and Transformations of Knowledge
The Internet, Science, and Transformations of KnowledgeEric Meyer
 
Can't Get No Satisfaction
Can't Get No SatisfactionCan't Get No Satisfaction
Can't Get No SatisfactionJohn Pell
 
Bridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and Technologies
Bridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and TechnologiesBridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and Technologies
Bridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and TechnologiesTed Lin (林泰宏)
 
Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...
Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...
Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...IL Group (CILIP Information Literacy Group)
 
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...Guus van den Brekel
 
Online Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen ScienceOnline Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen ScienceAndrea Wiggins
 
Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)
Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)
Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)Maura A. Smale
 
How students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession Booth
How students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession BoothHow students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession Booth
How students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession BoothEmily Singley
 
Cst 2018 037
Cst 2018 037Cst 2018 037
Cst 2018 037asafe2012
 
Researching Researchers: Avalon's Repository Usage
Researching Researchers: Avalon's Repository UsageResearching Researchers: Avalon's Repository Usage
Researching Researchers: Avalon's Repository UsageAvalon Media System
 
Public data archiving: Who does? Who doesn't? What can we do about it?
Public data archiving: Who does?  Who doesn't?  What can we do about it?Public data archiving: Who does?  Who doesn't?  What can we do about it?
Public data archiving: Who does? Who doesn't? What can we do about it?Heather Piwowar
 

Similar to What is research in the virtual world? (20)

Teens and Libraries
Teens and LibrariesTeens and Libraries
Teens and Libraries
 
Library, what's Library? Creative Library Assessment
Library, what's Library? Creative Library AssessmentLibrary, what's Library? Creative Library Assessment
Library, what's Library? Creative Library Assessment
 
Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba...
 Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba... Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba...
Beyond the survey: Using qualitative research methods to support evidence-ba...
 
Chandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior Review
Chandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior ReviewChandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior Review
Chandra & Public Science, Presentation for Senior Review
 
Libraries Case Study
Libraries Case StudyLibraries Case Study
Libraries Case Study
 
Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...
Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...
Scientific Information Integration & Discovery Service: Getting the most rele...
 
Nitle 2013 presentation
Nitle 2013 presentationNitle 2013 presentation
Nitle 2013 presentation
 
Social information Access2012
Social information Access2012Social information Access2012
Social information Access2012
 
0900 0930-uksg connaway 08 april 2013
0900 0930-uksg connaway 08 april 20130900 0930-uksg connaway 08 april 2013
0900 0930-uksg connaway 08 april 2013
 
The Internet, Science, and Transformations of Knowledge
The Internet, Science, and Transformations of KnowledgeThe Internet, Science, and Transformations of Knowledge
The Internet, Science, and Transformations of Knowledge
 
Can't Get No Satisfaction
Can't Get No SatisfactionCan't Get No Satisfaction
Can't Get No Satisfaction
 
Bridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and Technologies
Bridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and TechnologiesBridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and Technologies
Bridging the Gap: Encouraging Engagement with Library Services and Technologies
 
Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...
Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...
Process drawing: a tool to promote reflective practice in information literac...
 
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...
 
Online Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen ScienceOnline Communities in Citizen Science
Online Communities in Citizen Science
 
Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)
Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)
Some Observations on Qualitative Research (in Libraries)
 
How students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession Booth
How students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession BoothHow students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession Booth
How students *really* do research - Findings from the Research Confession Booth
 
Cst 2018 037
Cst 2018 037Cst 2018 037
Cst 2018 037
 
Researching Researchers: Avalon's Repository Usage
Researching Researchers: Avalon's Repository UsageResearching Researchers: Avalon's Repository Usage
Researching Researchers: Avalon's Repository Usage
 
Public data archiving: Who does? Who doesn't? What can we do about it?
Public data archiving: Who does?  Who doesn't?  What can we do about it?Public data archiving: Who does?  Who doesn't?  What can we do about it?
Public data archiving: Who does? Who doesn't? What can we do about it?
 

What is research in the virtual world?

  • 1. WHAT IS RESEARCH IN THE VIRTUAL WORLD? Madelyne Oliver
  • 2. THE LITERATURE: PREFERENCES TO WEB-BASED TOOLS OR NON-WEB-BASED TOOLS AMONG SCHOLARS IN THE VISUAL ARTS •Catherine Larkin, (2010) “Looking to the Future While Learning from the Past: Information Seeking in the Visual Arts” Art Documentation, vol 29, n. 1. Photo courtesy of Catherine Larkin ©2010
  • 5. LITERATURE REVIEW CONTINUED… Jennifer Mayer and Cheryl Goldenstein (2009), “Academic libraries Supporting Visual Culture: A Survey of Image Access and Use,” Art Documentation, vol 28, N. 1. Photo courtesy of Catherine Larkin ©2010
  • 8. PREDICTIONS  Visual scholars are becoming more adaptive to technological resources because web-based tools are used increasingly more often than non-web-based tools for seeking information and collecting research, most especially images. The authority of online resources and web-based tools are still heavily questioned by scholars and not seen as reliable as print or physical resources and tools.
  • 9. OBJECTIVE The purpose of this study is to push the boundaries between two disciplinary fields: anthropology and art history (Social Sciences and the Humanities) through personal observation and interactions with the virtual space of the online archive and labeling digital images for submission to SAHARA. In essence, I will explore how these web-based tools and online spaces channel the exchange of methods, resources, and data from both academic disciplines and if the increasing interaction with the virtual world encourages an intimate relationship between the researcher and the researched subject.
  • 10.
  • 12. EXCHANGE OF VISUAL INFORMATION: DIGITAL TOOLS AND METADATA
  • 13. COMMON WEB-BASED IMAGE RESOURCES: ONLINE IMAGE ARCHIVES ARTSTOR AND SAHARA
  • 14. WEB-BASED TOOLS/ONLINE INTERFACES EXPLORED: Zotero SAHARA Society of Architectural Historians (www.sah.org) ARTstor JSTOR Journal of the Society of Architectural Historians Online www.jsah.org Cataloging Cultural Objects (CCO ALNA (Association of Librarians of North America) The Dictionary of Art Grove Art Online Full Text Anthropology Plus Anthropology Index AnthroSource Humanities and Social Sciences Index Retrosprective ISI Citation Databases:  Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI) (1900- present)  Arts and Humanities Citation Index (AHCI) (1975- present)
  • 15. TESTING SCHOLARS’ ONLINE INFORMATION SEEKING BEHAVORS FOR THE YEAR 2011… How often do you use a computer and online tools for research? Frequency Percent Always 4 57.1 Sometimes 2 28.6 None 1 14.3 Total 7 100%
  • 16. What web-based tool do you utilize the most for research? Google 3 42.9 Youtube.com 3 42.9 Google Scholar 1 14.3 Total 7 100% How do you search for images? Databases (ARTstor, 5 56% SAHARA, AP images) General search 5 44% engines or image search engines (Google, yahoo, flickr) Library’s 0 0 collection/prind index Total 9 100%
  • 17. Electronic and digital images facilitate and inspire my work. Strongly Agree 2 29% Agree 5 71% Neutral 0 0% Disagree 0 0% Strongly Disagree 0 0% Total 7 100% If you believe web-based tools serve as authoritative sources, please rate the level of authority accordingly. Excellent 0 0% Good 3 43% Neutral 3 43% Fair 1 14% Poor 0 0% Total 7 100%
  • 18. WHAT DOES THE RESEARCH SAY ABOUT RESEARCH? Such web-based tools for cataloging images and articles facilitated close observations of art historians’ use of the virtual space for personal research and the public exchange of visual data. Anthropological training in participant observation aided the exploration of these web-based tools, revealing an encouraging intimate relationship between the researcher and his or her subject matter. Related literature indicated that academics frequently use web-based tools for information-collecting purposes, in which disciplinary fields overlap.