SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 22
Download to read offline
mesopartner working paper
                  No. 05




          The Hexagon of
          Local Economic
         Development and
       LED in South Africa
          Jörg Meyer-Stamer




    www.mesopartner.com
This paper has been an outcome of intense interaction between
   the author and GTZ’’s LED Programme in South Africa, in
particular with Shawn Cunningham. The usual disclaimers apply.




                        © by the author
           Jörg Meyer-Stamer, jms@mesopartner.com
                Revised Version, Duisburg 2006

mesopartner papers are a product of mesopartner, a consultancy
 partnership specialised in local economic development. For more
              information, see www.mesopartner.com

                        ISSN 1613-298X
Overview:
What is the Hexagon?




Local economic development (LED) has been implemented in industrialised
countries for decades. Since the 1990s, many developing countries have
seen the launch of LED activities. But despite the pervasiveness of the prac-
tice, there is no academic discipline which lays the conceptual foundations.
LED thinkers and practitioners rather borrow elements from a variety of
disciplines such as economic geography, urban planning, economic sociol-
ogy, and regional economics. What does not seem to exist is a conceptual
framework for LED which integrates the main elements in a way which
makes it easy for practitioners to organise their thinking, planning and prac-
tice. The Hexagon of LED provides this framework.

The Hexagon of Local Economic Development emerged as a didactical tool.
Its purpose is to organise the key issues in local economic development in a
way which makes it easy for LED practitioners to memorise them and to
explain LED to newcomers. Behind this is the thinking that it is possible to
organise the main concepts and instruments of local economic development
(LED) along a number of triangles. Altogether there are six triangles, and
adding them graphically creates the Hexagon.

The Hexagon is useful in introducing practitioners and stakeholders to the
main concepts and instruments of LED. It helps widen the perspective, un-
derstand the complexity of LED and appreciate the trade-offs and conflicts
involved in doing LED. It is useful to subsume the triangles under three
main headers:

   The first and second triangles are about the hard core of conventional lo-
   cal economic development, i.e. the key categories and instruments.
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


    The third and fourth triangles are very useful in adding an innovative
    twist, a wider perspective and a broader scope to LED. They explore the
    connections between LED and other approaches to local development.

    The fifth and sixth triangle are about practical issues in implementing an
    LED initiative. They look at governance and process management.


Local Economic Development in South Africa

South Africa is a special case when it comes to Local Economic Develop-
ment. Whereas in other countries LED tends to be a voluntary activity of lo-
cal government, often born our of necessity or desperation, in South Africa
it is a statutory activity. The South African constitution establishes “devel-
opmental local government”, and this includes the responsibility for eco-
nomic development.

In recent years, the main vehicle for the developmental task of local gov-
ernment has been the IDP process. IDP stands for integrated development
plan (for details see www.pimss.net), a five-year-plan which looks mainly at
infrastructure development but also includes LED activities. The preparation
of IDP includes comprehensive consultation exercises with local communi-
ties, albeit it appears that local business communities are not very present in
these exercises. LED in IDP more often than not relates to infrastructure and
buildings, not to other typical LED interventions like business networking
or business development service programmes.

Until about 2003, the conceptual discussion around LED in South Africa
primarily focused the issues of poverty alleviation, upliftment of the previ-
ously disadvantaged persons (black empowerment) and infrastructure de-
velopment.1 LED used to be conceptualised as part of a social policy and an
affirmative action agenda. LED was often identified with small projects
with an extremely limited impact which addressed marginalised groups of
persons. Evaluations found that the impact of such interventions was very
limited. At the same time, it became obvious that there needs to be a
stronger effort to enhance the job creation capacity of the established formal
economy. Thus, creation of location-based competitive advantage is a theme
has been introduced into the LED policy.




1     Tomlinson, Richard (2003): The Local Economic Development mirage in South
      Africa. Geoforum, Vol. 34, pp. 113-122. See also http://www.led-sa.co.za/ .




mesopartner                                                                         2
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development




   The First Triangle


  (Hard core LED #1)




Economic development is based on the efforts of companies – some of them
government-owned, but most of them private. The main target group of lo-
cal economic development (LED) are thus companies, in particular the pri-
vate sector. Further target groups include the workers and the public sector;
we will come to them when we discuss locational factors.

What kind of companies make up the main target group? LED efforts are
often primarily directed at attracting companies. The main goal of tradi-
tional LED efforts (i.e. in industrialised countries: from the 1960s to the
1980s) was to attract new investors. It is much too narrow, however, to limit
LED in this way. There are three types of companies which can be the tar-
geted in LED: Local companies, external investors and start-up companies.

It depends on the features of a given location which of these three types is
the priority target. Locations with a weak local company base and little en-
trepreneurial dynamism will often try to attract external investors. In loca-
tions with a strong local economic base, promoting the competitiveness of
existing companies is often much more relevant than attracting companies.

Yet the main message is: Do not conceptualise the three target groups in an
either/or manner. Instead, try to realise the synergies between them:

   Do not try to attract external investors in a random manner. Try to attract
   companies that strengthen the profile and competitive advantage of the
   local economy. Try to build clusters or sub-sectors that can benefit from
   shared suppliers or infrastructure.




mesopartner                                                                 3
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


   When you go for start-up promotion, look at the opportunities which are
   created through outsourcing, subcontracting and spin-offs. Also look at
   the succession issue in established companies. For a longer-term per-
   spective, introduce enterpreneurship as a topic in primary and secondary
   education.

   Assess the opportunities which franchising creates for potential entre-
   preneurs in your location.


The relevance of the first triangle for South Africa

LED in South Africa primarily targets new start-ups, mostly under the
headings of "emerging entrepreneurs" or “self-employed persons” as well as
"black economic empowerment" (BEE). This reflects the fact that the vast
majority of the population was seriously restricted in its business options be-
fore 1994, and that massive support for emerging entrepreneurs is crucial in
an economy which is highly concentrated, i.e. where most sectors are run by
monopolies or oligopolies.

The political rationale for this focus of LED is obvious and necessary. Yet it
is advisable to widen the scope of LED, without losing the original focus:

   Ironically, LED activities tend to ignore existing black businesses. Yet
   improving the environment for existing businesses might also lead to
   strong job creation effects, over and above the promotion of new BEE
   entrepreneurship, especially if the latter is not done competently and
   does not lead to sustainable businesses.

   LED activities around outsourcing and subcontracting activities of es-
   tablished big corporations, parastatals and even government, create a
   potential for existing and start-up businesses which so far has not been
   sufficiently explored. Too much emphasis is on the tendering process for
   big deliveries, and the small purchases are lost in the process. Small
   scale supplying is often the gateway for very small business to get into
   this lucrative market.

   National LED policy explicitly and quite rightly argues against "smoke-
   stack chasing", i.e. attracting external investors through subsidies and
   fiscal incentives. Unfortunately, this leads to a constellation where in-
   vestment promotion – which should not be based primarily on financial
   incentives anyway – escapes the attention of LED stakeholders alto-
   gether. Attracting investments from outside can strengthen the local
   economy and create jobs, thus being in line with established focus areas.




mesopartner                                                                  4
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


   South Africa has a very high density of franchises. However, the fran-
   chise principle so far has not been properly applied to the business de-
   velopment service (BDS) industry. There are examples of commercially
   successful local business services centres. But the opportunity that rests
   in turning this business into a proper franchise has not been realised so
   far. The concept of Social Franchising could be explored, where the
   Franchisor is a not-for-profit entity, whilst all the Franchisee outlets are
   profit driven.

Reconsidering and reconceptualising LED from the perspective of this tri-
angle may lead to an improved and more effective LED practice in South
Africa. It would entail the practical operationalisation of the revised Na-
tional Policy on LED.




mesopartner                                                                  5
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development



The Second Triangle


(Hard core LED #2)




          Locational factors are those features which determine whether a given town,
          city or region qualifies as a favourable setting for doing business. There are
          three types of locational factors:

          1. Tangible locational factors, which are mostly "hard" criteria and which
             can often be quantified

          2. Intangible factors relevant for companies, which are "soft" factors and
             not easily quantifiable

          3. Intangible factors relevant for professionals, which are basically those
             factors that define the quality of life in a given location

          There is a clear hierarchy between the three types of locational factors. Most
          relevant are tangible factors. It is only after tangible factors become in-
          creasingly similar across locations that intangible factors become relevant as
          a distinguishing feature. To put it differently: If your location, unlike other
          locations which are nearby, suffers from unreliable electricity supply, water
          scarcity, and dreadful roads, even excellent supporting institutions and the
          most effective business network program will have only a limited effect.

          Regarding intangible factors, the focus for good practice has changed from
          specific business promotion activities to the overall local business environ-
          ment. In the past, government often tried to promote business even though it
          itself was the most important obstacle for business – due to high taxes,
          complex and excessive regulations, and complicated, protracted and unpre-
          dictable permit processes. A key objective of local governments these days
          is to remove unnecessary obstacles to business activities.



          mesopartner                                                                  6
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development




The relevance of the second triangle for South Africa

The triangle of locational factors is at the very core of LED thinking and
practice in many parts of the world, but not necessarily in South Africa.

   LED interventions in South Africa address certain tangible locational
   factors, in particular infrastructure development (including the IDP pro-
   cess) and skills development.

   In recent years, in many countries the main focus of LED has been to
   remove government-created obstacles for business. Typical examples
   are

   –     the removal of decade-old regulations which are no longer relevant
         but still could stand in the way of businesses; in many cases the
         authorities are not even aware of these regulations, and should con-
         sider a comprehensive audit of them (e.g. regulations that limit small
         business to operate from a residential premise could be revisited),

   –      the speeding-up and simplification of permit processes, so that busi-
         nesses can invest and create jobs quicker; in some cases a simple
         transaction is being stretched to a month-long process through bu-
         reaucratic procedures, negligence or avoidance of decision-making,

   –     regular meetings between top officials in local government and busi-
         nesspeople to find practical ways of improving the business environ-
         ment; this simple, obvious exercise has the potential of improving the
         business environment in a speedy and effective way

   –     the reorganisation of interaction between businesses and local gov-
         ernment offices, for instance through the creation of Internet gate-
         ways, the set-up of first-stop agencies (which competently inform
         businesses about permit procedures and regulations) and the set-up of
         one-stop agencies (so that businesses must no longer interact with a
         multitude of government agencies, which sometimes even contra-
         dicted each other).

   It holds big potential to implement such activities in South Africa.

   Another main LED activity in many countries is the promotion and fa-
   cilitation of business networking. Typical examples are

   –     the organisation of informal get-togethers for businesspeople,




mesopartner                                                                  7
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


   –     the creation of mentorship schemes where experienced businesspeo-
         ple dedicate some time to mentoring young businesspeople,

   –      cluster initiatives to promote closer interaction between businesses,
         in order to improve competitiveness and stimulate innovation.

This also holds big potential for South Africa.




mesopartner                                                                  8
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development




   The Third Triangle


  (Innovative LED #1)




Local economic development is not just about things like business promo-
tion, SME support and micro enterprise promotion.

   The overarching goal of LED is to create jobs and income, and therefore
   it is crucial to involve employment promotion measures and organiza-
   tions in a given LED effort. Employment creation and poverty allevia-
   tion, however, is also a distinct activity with its own delivery structure,
   and it is usually addressed as part of social policy. This, in turn, leads to
   something which is often a major confusion in LED: the distinction be-
   tween economic development (business promotion) and community de-
   velopment (employment creation, poverty alleviation). Sometimes these
   activities get mixed up, and as a result usually neither economic nor so-
   cial objectives are achieved.

   One of the key issues of LED is to enhance the locational quality of a
   given place. If you look at the tangible and intangible locational factors,
   you find that some of them are closely related to business promotion,
   whereas many other have to do with issues which are usually addressed
   under the heading of Urban Development, which has its own concepts
   and approaches – and often a much longer time horizon than LED.

From the perspective of a business promotion agency /actor, in order to de-
sign and implement an adequate LED effort, it is crucial to understand what
is going on in these two neighbouring fields: What are the main concepts
and instruments used there? And what are the synergies which can be real-
ised by connecting concepts, measures and actors from these different
fields?




mesopartner                                                                   9
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development




The relevance of the third triangle for South Africa

In South Africa, LED is being approached from all the three different angles
involved in this triangle.

First, there is the poverty alleviation angle. In the past, the majority of "LED
projects" were not intended to create sustainable businesses or to improve
the environment of existing businesses. They rather addressed the immedi-
ate problems of marginalised persons who have little or no income and op-
portunities. These projects often went wrong; evaluators found quite a num-
ber of failed poultry, brick making, bakery, and vegetable garden projects.
The failure of these projects was primarily due to the basic design and sup-
port problems. Often funders demanded that such projects were driven by a
group of people, not by an individual, and that they made no profit (but also
no loss). This lead to unclear governance structures inside the project – no-
body was really in charge, and as soon as anything went wrong everybody
blamed everybody else. Also, what is the incentive to put in hard work if
you can't make a profit anyway?

The solution is not to stop projects which benefit the really poor, but rather
expand and manage them in a professional way. Poor people with little or
no education need and deserve the support of the society. But it is wrong to
call activities which are supposed to benefit them "LED projects", or even
worse, “businesses”. These projects are an outcome of social policy. They
do not primarily have an economic rationale. They do not aim at stimulating
business and economic growth. They rather help those people who would



mesopartner                                                                  10
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


continue to be poor and marginalised even if there was economic growth.
These projects are poverty alleviation projects that are supposed to stimulate
self-help, and they should be named accordingly. In South Africa’s situa-
tion, it is certainly justified that Government encourages and supports such
projects, especially as it is moving rapidly to genuine local economic devel-
opment.

Second, there is the urban planning angle. This includes infrastructure de-
velopment and, most of all, the IDP process. This approach to LED is plan-
ning-driven, which effectively means that there is a long period of time be-
tween conceiving a project and observing an impact on the ground. Planning
and proper LED are closely related, but it is fatal to assume that planning is
the same as LED. An urban planner is perfectly happy if something he is
planning today has a practical impact three years from now. From a business
perspective, this is unattractive. A given business doesn't even know
whether it will still exist three years from now. For a business, LED is only
attractive if it leads to visible improvements within a short period of time.

This takes us to the third angle, namely business-oriented LED. This is a
rare phenomenon in South Africa, especially outside the big metros. The
business sector is only occasionally involved in LED – and often drops out
if LED is much talk and little action.




mesopartner                                                                11
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development



The Fourth Triangle


(Innovative LED #2)




           Sustainable development often appears as a somewhat abstract concept.
           However, it becomes much less abstract if is being conceptualised at the lo-
           cal level. A good example is vegetable oil. For instance, have you ever con-
           sidered how much vegetable oil restaurants and industrial kitchens in your
           city are consuming? And have you ever considered that much of it is actu-
           ally not consumed but rather disposed of after some period of use? If you
           start to ask around, you may come to figures which amount to several tons
           of vegetable oil which is monthly poured into sewers or local rivers. This is
           not only creating environmental problems. It is also a big waste. Used
           vegetable oil still has a high energy content, and after a process of refining it
           can be used, for instance, to run internal combustion engines. Why not run
           local buses on recycled vegetable oil? If you think about it, it quickly be-
           comes obvious that this is an excellent manifestation of the concept of sus-
           tainable development:

              it solves several environmental problems (pollution of rivers, air pollu-
              tion from conventional petrol),

              it creates an economic opportunity, since the collection and refinery op-
              eration ought to be run as a private enterprise (probably with some pub-
              lic seed money),

              it makes a contribution to social development, in particular in terms of
              creating low-skilled jobs in the oil collection business.

           This example shows two things. First, sustainable development can be a
           very concrete concept. Second, thinking about issues from this perspective




           mesopartner                                                                   12
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


opens the mind to note potentials which otherwise go unnoticed. In this
sense, sustainable development can play the role of giving orientation in
terms of strategic orientation. It can also contribute to motivate local actors
for a LED effort. There are many places, including in poor regions, where
environmental problems such as waste disposal are pressing. Many such
problems indeed are business opportunities, and conceptualising them in
this way can pave the way for an effective LED initiative.


The relevance of the fourth triangle for South Africa

The triangle of sustainable development is an outcome of the discussion on
ecological aspects of development. The idea is to reconcile economic, social
and ecological / environmental development, i.e. to make sure that devel-
opment is not following an exclusively economic rationale but also leads to
social development while not destroying the environment. Connecting these
three points as part of local development initiatives is a relatively new ap-
proach in industrialised countries. As yet, it is only starting to make its way
to South Africa.

In fact, a foreign observer in South Africa might get the impression that en-
ergy is for free. The degree of inefficiency in the use of resources, in par-
ticular energy, is stunning. The negligence of biomass as a source of energy
is as stunning as the absence of proper systems for the recycling of materi-
als. While on the one hand this is a very serious problem which is reinforc-
ing problems of poverty and marginalisation, on the other hand it is also a
big opportunity since it creates the possibility of quick gains for local-level
activities which address energy efficiency and recycling.

At the local level, activities such as recycling tend to cover all three corners
of the triangle of sustainable development at the same time. They are creat-
ing a business opportunity. They are creating jobs and income, often for
low-skilled persons. And they solve environmental problems.




mesopartner                                                                  13
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development



 The Fifth Triangle


(Organising LED #1)




           Any local development effort involves the public and private sectors, and
           probably also other actors. The basic pattern of a successful LED effort in-
           volves a network, not an organization. LED is based on a policy-network,
           i.e. a set of different actors, governmental as well as non-governmental. The
           reason is that each actor contributes specific resources – legislative power,
           money, information and knowledge, credibility and prestige, and others.

           On the public side, the legislative and several branches of the local or re-
           gional executive have to play a role. On the private side, chambers and other
           business associations have to participate. But there may also be active in-
           volvement of companies, most obviously real estate and development firms
           and utilities, but also other companies, such as large firms involved in sup-
           plier development or community development activities. NGOs also may
           play a role, as may local universities or other organisations.

           In many developing countries, it is still common to find not particularly
           strong actors on either side. Public agencies are under financed, lack highly
           skilled staff, are excessively bureaucratic, have no idea what a business
           mindset is like, etc. Private organizations, in particularly chambers and as-
           sociation, are understaffed, not very professional, highly politicised, offer
           little services to their members, lack a clear mission, etc.

           In a setting like this, it is tricky to launch a LED initiative. At the same time,
           it will often be unlikely that these problems get sorted out for some reason
           in the medium term. Therefore, stakeholders who want to launch a LED ini-
           tiative have work with the institutions which are there. Rather than waiting
           for public sector reform to happen and organizational development in cham-
           bers and associations to fall from heaven, a LED initiative creates an op-




           mesopartner                                                                    14
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


portunity, and possibly a motivation, for these things to occur. Successful
LED is based on a constructive relationship between local government, the
private sector and possibly other stakeholders. Practical LED interventions
which look at quick gains are a possible way to create a constructive rela-
tionship.


The relevance of the fifth triangle for South Africa

Successful LED is based on the interaction between an efficient govern-
ment, which understands business principles and economic development,
and an effectively organised private sector which can voice the interests of
private business but also assure compliance with agreements. Both condi-
tions apply to South Africa only to a limited extent.

   Local government is often not strong enough. As staff frequently
   changes, and as departments go through repeated rounds of restructur-
   ing, the effectiveness of local government suffers.

   Even though some local business chambers are very strong and effec-
   tive, most are not. It is not even rare to find locations without any effec-
   tive organisation of the private sector.

Moreover, both sides are often hesitant to co-operate, since both sides look
at the other side with scepticism and suspicion. Under these circumstances
LED gains an additional dimension. It is not just about practical interven-
tions to make a location a better place to do business. It is also about learn-
ing and organisational development processes both in local government and
in the private sector. For both sides, this involves an important learning op-
portunity. In the recent past, LED often involved public sector employees
trying to run quasi-businesses, sometimes well, often not. At the same time,
individuals who are running successful businesses are often not successful
at all when it comes to running a business association.

In practice, LED tends to be based on a local "LED Forum". In fact, there is
an opinion that the best way to start LED is by creating an LED Forum. But
some observers would argue that this is the best way to assure that LED is
stillborn. When an LED process reaches some maturity, an LED Forum can
serve as an information platform for coordination, leveraging resources and
know-how, and troubleshooting. However, if an LED Forum is created at
the outset, this usually means that representatives from all sorts of sectors –
business, health, social, education, security – spend a lot of time figuring out
how to approach and implement LED. As there are no consistent guidelines
on how to organise an LED Forum, bewilderment may quickly turn into




mesopartner                                                                  15
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


frustration, as the Forum cannot agree on its purpose. Stakeholders start
dropping out, first of all business representatives, who are under serious
time constraints. In the absence of the business perspective, however, the
Forum then easily wanders into the social policy / poverty alleviation field
and is soon afflicted by Projectitis, i.e. the proliferation of little projects
which draw heavily on the capacity of local government but have little im-
pact.




mesopartner                                                                 16
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development




   The Sixth Triangle


 (Organising LED #2)




Local economic may have a beginning, but it never ends. It may start with
central government delegating economic development responsibilities to lo-
cal authorities, or with local stakeholders deciding to take things in their
own hands because problems of unemployment and poverty become un-
bearable. But once you have started with LED, you will find out that you are
dealing with a moving target: as soon as have solved the easy problems,
such as particularly clumsy licensing processes, you are identifying more
tricky problems which take longer to sort out. And it goes on like that.

The best way of conceptualising LED is as a permanent cycle, which in
terms of learning involves three cornerstones:

   participatory diagnostic

   participatory planning

   participatory monitoring, evaluation and benchmarking

These learning- and knowledge-oriented points lead to three more practical
activities:

   motivation, mobilisation and prioritisation

   implementation

   reflection and adjustment




mesopartner                                                              17
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development


LED is an iterative process which runs around this triangle over and again.
LED is also a learning process. It is desirable that LED starts with simple
activities which lead to quick successes. But over time LED may become
more ambitious and more sophisticated.


The relevance of the sixth triangle for South Africa

The basic idea of the triangle of process management is that LED is an it-
erative process. The metaphor of the triangle also indicates that iterations
should be visible as such; the opposite is a process which runs endlessly, or
collapses and has to be restarted. Perceiving the process as a sequence of it-
erations also is a constant reminder that one should not get lost in the details
of managing the current stage, thus losing sight of the other steps. In par-
ticular, this refers to the later steps of the process, in particular evaluation,
benchmarking and learning, which should not be introduced as an after-
thought.

The practice of the LED process in South Africa so far looks not so much
like a triangle but rather like a funnel. There is a big mobilisation effort, but
then the process gets narrower and narrower, and in the end very little
comes out. This probably has a lot to do with confusion about how to start
LED in the first place. What is missing is a clear concept for the early steps,
i.e. the identification of opportunities to create growth and scrapping bottle-
necks which limit economic growth. This early stage is either driven by dis-
cussions in an LED Forum or by IDP-like planning processes with limited
practical results on the ground. This is why we suggest to employ the PACA
methodology at an early stage, in order to move quickly into action. With
PACA, an LED process will look like a funnel which stands on top: Ini-
tially, there are only a couple of activities going on. But over time, as
stakeholders learn LED and get empowered, the number, size and scope of
interventions widens significantly.




mesopartner                                                                   18
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development




Conclusion

LED is a long-term activity which is mostly based on short- and medium-
term projects. Over time, LED tends to go through a life cycle with three
typical phases, which are summarised in the following table.

                  Kick-off phase               Lasso phase                    Network phase
Focus             Get LED projects moving      Get LED projects under con-    Segment activities (sector
                                               trol                           initiatives, landmark projects)
                                               formulate a strategy           delegate responsibilities
                                                                              pro-forma strategy
Governance        Informal                     Clear distribution of tasks    Central information-
pattern                                        and responsibilities           exchange, decentralised re-
                                               Possibly creation of central   sponsibilities
                                               LED agency
M+E pattern       None                         Informal                       Emerging formalization
Reward system     Excitement                   Discipline and suffering       Identification with project
                  personal motivation          Salary                         objectives
                                                                              Latitude of decision-making
Crisis            Fragmentation, lack of co-   Exploding co-ordination effort Network failure
                  ordination                   Increasing number of LED
                                               professionals = rising fixed
                                               cost
                                               Time- and energy-consuming
                                               strategizing effort
                                               De-motivation of volunteers


It is not useful to try to leapfrog any of these phases. It is rather important to
be aware of the existence of this life-cycle, and to reflect occasionally on
which phase you are in – and whether it might be advisable to move to the
next stage.

In South Africa, localities tend jump into the second phase before
completing, or even initiating, the first one. It is not rare to find localities
where the LED officer’s shelves are overflowing with consultants’ project
feasibility reports, but where very few LED activities are actually going on.
One of the reasons is the legal mandate mentioned above: Many local
governments think that, because they have mandate for LED, they must and
can do on their own, without involving other actors in the delivery. The
results are very disappointing. South African localities will only get a
significant outcome from LED if they address it in a more comprehensive,
balanced way – as indicated by the Hexagon.




mesopartner                                                                         19
Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development



mesopartner is a consultancy partnership which specialises in
local and regional economic development. It was founded in De-
cember 2002 and registered in April 2003 by Dr Ulrich Harmes-
Liedtke, Dr Jörg Meyer-Stamer and Christian Schoen.

Currently, the main product of mesopartner is PACA. This is a
methodology to kick-start or refocus local economic development
initiatives which has been developed by Jörg Meyer-Stamer. It
has been successfully applied in a number of developing and
transformation countries. The main objectives of mesopartner
are

   to train PACA practitioners in various countries,

   to develop more specific PACA instruments, for instance for
   cluster analysis, value chain analysis and analysis of govern-
   ment-created obstacles to business,

   to develop and disseminate further methodologies and tools
   for local and regional economic development initiatives,

   to develop innovative concepts and tools to train practitioners
   in local and regional economic development.

Another mesopartner product is RALIS (Rapid Appraisal of Local
Innovation Systems). As technology and innovation continue to be
major preoccupations of local actors who want to create a local-
ised advantage in a globalised world, we expect that there is a lot
of potential demand for a tool like RALIS which addresses the
most important obstacle for the leveraging of local innovation
systems: fragmentation between local companies, agencies and
organisations.

Further mesopartner products are

   the Compass of Local Competitiveness, a balanced scorecard-
   based approach to performance management of territorial de-
   velopment initiatives,

   GENESIS, a methodology for the rapid and participatory
   elaboration of strategic interventions for a local or regional
   economy.

You find more information at our website, www.mesopartner.com




mesopartner                                                       20

More Related Content

What's hot

Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016
Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016
Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016Volition Properties
 
Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...
Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...
Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...OECD Governance
 
National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...
National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...
National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...OECD Governance
 
Launch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised world
Launch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised worldLaunch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised world
Launch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised worldOECDregions
 
Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016
Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016
Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016Volition Properties
 
Fostering a Startup and Innovation Ecosystem
Fostering a Startup and Innovation EcosystemFostering a Startup and Innovation Ecosystem
Fostering a Startup and Innovation EcosystemTechstars
 
Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?
Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?
Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?Terry Flew
 
Well Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being for policymaking
Well Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being  for policymakingWell Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being  for policymaking
Well Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being for policymakingOECD Governance
 
맥킨지 보고서 영문
맥킨지 보고서 영문맥킨지 보고서 영문
맥킨지 보고서 영문renee7337
 
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...Structuralpolicyanalysis
 
Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...
Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...
Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...Alexander Decker
 
OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016
OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016
OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016OECD Governance
 
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economiesIntangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economiesABACO
 
Resilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECD
Resilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECDResilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECD
Resilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECDOECD Governance
 
C4 c tech sector final to clerk
C4 c tech sector   final to clerkC4 c tech sector   final to clerk
C4 c tech sector final to clerkjoemazzei
 
[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend
[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend
[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-TrendChallenge:Future
 
Recent trends in global business .ppt
Recent trends in global business .pptRecent trends in global business .ppt
Recent trends in global business .pptKannan Vijayan
 

What's hot (20)

Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016
Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016
Structuring Your Real Estate like a Business - Mar 31, 2016
 
Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...
Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...
Northern Sparsely Populated Areas - Launch of OECD report, Brussels, 13 March...
 
National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...
National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...
National Prosperity Through Modern Rural Policy- 10th OECD Rural Conference, ...
 
Launch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised world
Launch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised worldLaunch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised world
Launch OECD report on Productivity and jobs in a globalised world
 
Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016
Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016
Top 5 Factors When Investing In Toronto - May 19, 2016
 
Fostering a Startup and Innovation Ecosystem
Fostering a Startup and Innovation EcosystemFostering a Startup and Innovation Ecosystem
Fostering a Startup and Innovation Ecosystem
 
What got us here will not get us there! (Updated 30 March 2013)
What got us here will not get us there!  (Updated 30 March 2013)What got us here will not get us there!  (Updated 30 March 2013)
What got us here will not get us there! (Updated 30 March 2013)
 
Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?
Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?
Cultural Economic Geography: A New Paradigm for Global Communication Studies?
 
Well Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being for policymaking
Well Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being  for policymakingWell Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being  for policymaking
Well Being in Danish cities - measuring local well-being for policymaking
 
맥킨지 보고서 영문
맥킨지 보고서 영문맥킨지 보고서 영문
맥킨지 보고서 영문
 
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
The Role of Production Factor Quality and Technology Diffusion in 20th Centur...
 
Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...
Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...
Exploring the link between foreign direct investment and multinational enterp...
 
OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016
OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016
OECD Regional Outlook 2016 - Presentation, Brussels, Belgium 11 October 2016
 
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economiesIntangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
Intangibles and industry productivity growth: the EU economies
 
Resilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECD
Resilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECDResilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECD
Resilient Cities, Policy Highlights - OECD
 
C4 c tech sector final to clerk
C4 c tech sector   final to clerkC4 c tech sector   final to clerk
C4 c tech sector final to clerk
 
[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend
[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend
[Challenge:Future] IQ: Anti-Trend
 
Newsletter on the Special high-level meeting of ECOSOC with BWIs, WTO and UNC...
Newsletter on the Special high-level meeting of ECOSOC with BWIs, WTO and UNC...Newsletter on the Special high-level meeting of ECOSOC with BWIs, WTO and UNC...
Newsletter on the Special high-level meeting of ECOSOC with BWIs, WTO and UNC...
 
Next economy by leed for san diego csl net conference
Next economy by leed  for san diego csl net conferenceNext economy by leed  for san diego csl net conference
Next economy by leed for san diego csl net conference
 
Recent trends in global business .ppt
Recent trends in global business .pptRecent trends in global business .ppt
Recent trends in global business .ppt
 

Viewers also liked

Industrial activity and geographic location
Industrial activity and geographic locationIndustrial activity and geographic location
Industrial activity and geographic locationDr.Rajesh Patel
 
Weber notes 2013
Weber notes 2013Weber notes 2013
Weber notes 2013cindipatten
 
Economic theory of industrial location
Economic theory of industrial locationEconomic theory of industrial location
Economic theory of industrial locationParth Maru
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Industrial activity and geographic location
Industrial activity and geographic locationIndustrial activity and geographic location
Industrial activity and geographic location
 
Weber notes 2013
Weber notes 2013Weber notes 2013
Weber notes 2013
 
Weber 1
Weber 1Weber 1
Weber 1
 
Economic theory of industrial location
Economic theory of industrial locationEconomic theory of industrial location
Economic theory of industrial location
 
Industrial theory
Industrial theoryIndustrial theory
Industrial theory
 
Fourie&krugell the spatial persistence of south africa
Fourie&krugell the spatial persistence of south africaFourie&krugell the spatial persistence of south africa
Fourie&krugell the spatial persistence of south africa
 

Similar to The Hexagon of Local Economic Development and LED in South Africa

Durban Chamber Blueprint execsummary
Durban Chamber Blueprint execsummaryDurban Chamber Blueprint execsummary
Durban Chamber Blueprint execsummaryAkash Singh
 
808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0
808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0
808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0Richard Florizone
 
Small And Medium Enterprise In Bangladesh
Small And Medium Enterprise In BangladeshSmall And Medium Enterprise In Bangladesh
Small And Medium Enterprise In BangladeshSheri Elliott
 
Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...
Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...
Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...led4lgus
 
Toolkit on LRED
Toolkit on LREDToolkit on LRED
Toolkit on LREDled4lgus
 
Preconditions for the social entrepreneurship developments
Preconditions for the social entrepreneurship developmentsPreconditions for the social entrepreneurship developments
Preconditions for the social entrepreneurship developmentsAlianta INFONET
 
Funding of small scale development agencies in nigeria
Funding of small scale development agencies in nigeriaFunding of small scale development agencies in nigeria
Funding of small scale development agencies in nigeriaAlexander Decker
 
Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...
Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...
Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...ConectaDEL
 
incubation center
incubation centerincubation center
incubation centerArfatSyed1
 
BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...
BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF  BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF  BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...
BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...Vasily Ryzhonkov
 
DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...
DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...
DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...Sheikh Shahnawaz
 
ECDPM Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector
ECDPM  Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector ECDPM  Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector
ECDPM Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector Annarosengren321
 
The Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth Entrepreneurship
The Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth EntrepreneurshipThe Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth Entrepreneurship
The Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth Entrepreneurshipijtsrd
 
SGB_Impact-Report_2015_digit
SGB_Impact-Report_2015_digitSGB_Impact-Report_2015_digit
SGB_Impact-Report_2015_digitDavid Zhou
 
LEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCE
LEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCELEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCE
LEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCEIDIS Viitorul
 

Similar to The Hexagon of Local Economic Development and LED in South Africa (20)

2090740
20907402090740
2090740
 
Durban Chamber Blueprint execsummary
Durban Chamber Blueprint execsummaryDurban Chamber Blueprint execsummary
Durban Chamber Blueprint execsummary
 
Blueprint executive summary
Blueprint executive summaryBlueprint executive summary
Blueprint executive summary
 
808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0
808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0
808960BRI0Winn00Box379814B00PUBLIC0
 
Small And Medium Enterprise In Bangladesh
Small And Medium Enterprise In BangladeshSmall And Medium Enterprise In Bangladesh
Small And Medium Enterprise In Bangladesh
 
Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...
Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...
Why is Local Economic Development so difficult, and what can we do to make it...
 
Toolkit on LRED
Toolkit on LREDToolkit on LRED
Toolkit on LRED
 
Preconditions for the social entrepreneurship developments
Preconditions for the social entrepreneurship developmentsPreconditions for the social entrepreneurship developments
Preconditions for the social entrepreneurship developments
 
Funding of small scale development agencies in nigeria
Funding of small scale development agencies in nigeriaFunding of small scale development agencies in nigeria
Funding of small scale development agencies in nigeria
 
Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...
Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...
Clusters and the Coordination of Private Sector Development Policies-Carlo Pi...
 
incubation center
incubation centerincubation center
incubation center
 
BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...
BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF  BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF  BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...
BUSINESS INCUBATION AS ELEMENT OF BUSINESS SERVICE INSTITUTION AND SME DEVEL...
 
DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...
DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...
DEVELOPMENT OF ENTREPRENEURIAL STRATEGIES FOR SMALL SCALE INDUSTRIES ENTREPRE...
 
ECDPM Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector
ECDPM  Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector ECDPM  Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector
ECDPM Economic Transformation and the role of the Private Sector
 
India MSME Communication Programme,An Introduction.PDF
India MSME Communication Programme,An Introduction.PDFIndia MSME Communication Programme,An Introduction.PDF
India MSME Communication Programme,An Introduction.PDF
 
Enterpreneuership
EnterpreneuershipEnterpreneuership
Enterpreneuership
 
The Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth Entrepreneurship
The Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth EntrepreneurshipThe Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth Entrepreneurship
The Role of IT in Supporting Vietnam Youth Entrepreneurship
 
SGB_Impact-Report_2015_digit
SGB_Impact-Report_2015_digitSGB_Impact-Report_2015_digit
SGB_Impact-Report_2015_digit
 
Corporate Social Responsibility’s New Role in the Middle East
Corporate Social Responsibility’s New Role in the Middle EastCorporate Social Responsibility’s New Role in the Middle East
Corporate Social Responsibility’s New Role in the Middle East
 
LEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCE
LEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCELEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCE
LEGITIMACY, EFFICIENCY AND INTEGRITY OF ADVOCACY: MOLDOVA’S EXPERIENCE
 

More from led4lgus

Proceedings of the LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSE
Proceedings of the  LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSEProceedings of the  LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSE
Proceedings of the LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSEled4lgus
 
Subnational Full Toolkit
Subnational Full ToolkitSubnational Full Toolkit
Subnational Full Toolkitled4lgus
 
SMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RP
SMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RPSMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RP
SMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RPled4lgus
 
Strategy Mapping
Strategy MappingStrategy Mapping
Strategy Mappingled4lgus
 
Public Private Partnership Handbook
Public Private Partnership HandbookPublic Private Partnership Handbook
Public Private Partnership Handbookled4lgus
 
SMEDSED Organizational Review Project
SMEDSED Organizational Review ProjectSMEDSED Organizational Review Project
SMEDSED Organizational Review Projectled4lgus
 
Performance mgt using balanced scorecard
Performance mgt using balanced scorecard Performance mgt using balanced scorecard
Performance mgt using balanced scorecard led4lgus
 
Negros Tourism Marketing Agency
Negros Tourism Marketing AgencyNegros Tourism Marketing Agency
Negros Tourism Marketing Agencyled4lgus
 
Appropriate Coordinating Structures Chapter 2
Appropriate  Coordinating Structures Chapter 2Appropriate  Coordinating Structures Chapter 2
Appropriate Coordinating Structures Chapter 2led4lgus
 
Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3
Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3
Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3led4lgus
 
The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9
The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9
The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9led4lgus
 
Financial Challenges Chapter 5
Financial Challenges Chapter 5Financial Challenges Chapter 5
Financial Challenges Chapter 5led4lgus
 
Managing Cities as Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2
Managing Cities as  Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2Managing Cities as  Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2
Managing Cities as Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2led4lgus
 
Assessing City Competitiveness Frameworks
Assessing City Competitiveness FrameworksAssessing City Competitiveness Frameworks
Assessing City Competitiveness Frameworksled4lgus
 
Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009
Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009
Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009led4lgus
 
Local and Regional Economic Development in Leyte Province
Local and Regional Economic Development in Leyte ProvinceLocal and Regional Economic Development in Leyte Province
Local and Regional Economic Development in Leyte Provinceled4lgus
 
Strategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local Governments
Strategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local GovernmentsStrategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local Governments
Strategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local Governmentsled4lgus
 
Making Local Economic Development Strategies: A Trainer’s Manual
Making Local Economic Development  Strategies: A Trainer’s ManualMaking Local Economic Development  Strategies: A Trainer’s Manual
Making Local Economic Development Strategies: A Trainer’s Manualled4lgus
 
Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009
Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009
Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009led4lgus
 
Promoting Local Economic Development through Strategic Planning
Promoting Local Economic Development through Strategic PlanningPromoting Local Economic Development through Strategic Planning
Promoting Local Economic Development through Strategic Planningled4lgus
 

More from led4lgus (20)

Proceedings of the LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSE
Proceedings of the  LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSEProceedings of the  LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSE
Proceedings of the LED FUNDAMENTALS COURSE
 
Subnational Full Toolkit
Subnational Full ToolkitSubnational Full Toolkit
Subnational Full Toolkit
 
SMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RP
SMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RPSMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RP
SMEDSEP Business Reg Licensing in RP
 
Strategy Mapping
Strategy MappingStrategy Mapping
Strategy Mapping
 
Public Private Partnership Handbook
Public Private Partnership HandbookPublic Private Partnership Handbook
Public Private Partnership Handbook
 
SMEDSED Organizational Review Project
SMEDSED Organizational Review ProjectSMEDSED Organizational Review Project
SMEDSED Organizational Review Project
 
Performance mgt using balanced scorecard
Performance mgt using balanced scorecard Performance mgt using balanced scorecard
Performance mgt using balanced scorecard
 
Negros Tourism Marketing Agency
Negros Tourism Marketing AgencyNegros Tourism Marketing Agency
Negros Tourism Marketing Agency
 
Appropriate Coordinating Structures Chapter 2
Appropriate  Coordinating Structures Chapter 2Appropriate  Coordinating Structures Chapter 2
Appropriate Coordinating Structures Chapter 2
 
Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3
Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3
Effective Financing Responses Chapter 3
 
The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9
The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9
The Compass of Local Competitiveness v0.9
 
Financial Challenges Chapter 5
Financial Challenges Chapter 5Financial Challenges Chapter 5
Financial Challenges Chapter 5
 
Managing Cities as Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2
Managing Cities as  Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2Managing Cities as  Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2
Managing Cities as Drivers of the Economy Chapter 2
 
Assessing City Competitiveness Frameworks
Assessing City Competitiveness FrameworksAssessing City Competitiveness Frameworks
Assessing City Competitiveness Frameworks
 
Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009
Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009
Project Programming & Prioritisation Toolkit September 2009
 
Local and Regional Economic Development in Leyte Province
Local and Regional Economic Development in Leyte ProvinceLocal and Regional Economic Development in Leyte Province
Local and Regional Economic Development in Leyte Province
 
Strategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local Governments
Strategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local GovernmentsStrategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local Governments
Strategic Local Economic Development: A Guide for Local Governments
 
Making Local Economic Development Strategies: A Trainer’s Manual
Making Local Economic Development  Strategies: A Trainer’s ManualMaking Local Economic Development  Strategies: A Trainer’s Manual
Making Local Economic Development Strategies: A Trainer’s Manual
 
Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009
Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009
Pre-Feasibility Study Guideline September 2009
 
Promoting Local Economic Development through Strategic Planning
Promoting Local Economic Development through Strategic PlanningPromoting Local Economic Development through Strategic Planning
Promoting Local Economic Development through Strategic Planning
 

Recently uploaded

Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in LifePlanetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in LifeBhavana Pujan Kendra
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxRakhi Bazaar
 
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...SOFTTECHHUB
 
Lessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in Entrepreneurship
Lessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in EntrepreneurshipLessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in Entrepreneurship
Lessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in EntrepreneurshipDoge Mining Website
 
Features of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdf
Features of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdfFeatures of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdf
Features of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdfOne Monitar
 
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare NewsletterHealthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare NewsletterJamesConcepcion7
 
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan DynamicsWelding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan DynamicsIndiaMART InterMESH Limited
 
Darshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdf
Darshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdfDarshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdf
Darshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdfShashank Mehta
 
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdftrending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdfMintel Group
 
How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...
How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...
How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...Hector Del Castillo, CPM, CPMM
 
14680-51-4.pdf Good quality CAS Good quality CAS
14680-51-4.pdf  Good  quality CAS Good  quality CAS14680-51-4.pdf  Good  quality CAS Good  quality CAS
14680-51-4.pdf Good quality CAS Good quality CAScathy664059
 
MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024
MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024
MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024Chandresh Chudasama
 
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataNAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataExhibitors Data
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024Adnet Communications
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Jiastral oracle
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxappkodes
 
How do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdf
How do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdfHow do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdf
How do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdfshubhamaapkikismat
 
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applicationsIntroducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applicationsKnowledgeSeed
 
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptxImplementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptxRich Reba
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in LifePlanetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
Planetary and Vedic Yagyas Bring Positive Impacts in Life
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
 
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
 
Lessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in Entrepreneurship
Lessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in EntrepreneurshipLessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in Entrepreneurship
Lessons from Shanavas M.P. (AKA SHAN) For The Mastering in Entrepreneurship
 
Features of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdf
Features of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdfFeatures of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdf
Features of a Call Recorder Spy App for Android.pdf
 
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare NewsletterHealthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
 
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdfWAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
 
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan DynamicsWelding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
 
Darshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdf
Darshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdfDarshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdf
Darshan Hiranandani (Son of Niranjan Hiranandani).pdf
 
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdftrending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
 
How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...
How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...
How Generative AI Is Transforming Your Business | Byond Growth Insights | Apr...
 
14680-51-4.pdf Good quality CAS Good quality CAS
14680-51-4.pdf  Good  quality CAS Good  quality CAS14680-51-4.pdf  Good  quality CAS Good  quality CAS
14680-51-4.pdf Good quality CAS Good quality CAS
 
MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024
MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024
MEP Plans in Construction of Building and Industrial Projects 2024
 
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors DataNAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
NAB Show Exhibitor List 2024 - Exhibitors Data
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
 
How do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdf
How do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdfHow do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdf
How do I Check My Health Issues in Astrology.pdf
 
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applicationsIntroducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
Introducing the Analogic framework for business planning applications
 
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptxImplementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
Implementing Exponential Accelerators.pptx
 

The Hexagon of Local Economic Development and LED in South Africa

  • 1. mesopartner working paper No. 05 The Hexagon of Local Economic Development and LED in South Africa Jörg Meyer-Stamer www.mesopartner.com
  • 2. This paper has been an outcome of intense interaction between the author and GTZ’’s LED Programme in South Africa, in particular with Shawn Cunningham. The usual disclaimers apply. © by the author Jörg Meyer-Stamer, jms@mesopartner.com Revised Version, Duisburg 2006 mesopartner papers are a product of mesopartner, a consultancy partnership specialised in local economic development. For more information, see www.mesopartner.com ISSN 1613-298X
  • 3. Overview: What is the Hexagon? Local economic development (LED) has been implemented in industrialised countries for decades. Since the 1990s, many developing countries have seen the launch of LED activities. But despite the pervasiveness of the prac- tice, there is no academic discipline which lays the conceptual foundations. LED thinkers and practitioners rather borrow elements from a variety of disciplines such as economic geography, urban planning, economic sociol- ogy, and regional economics. What does not seem to exist is a conceptual framework for LED which integrates the main elements in a way which makes it easy for practitioners to organise their thinking, planning and prac- tice. The Hexagon of LED provides this framework. The Hexagon of Local Economic Development emerged as a didactical tool. Its purpose is to organise the key issues in local economic development in a way which makes it easy for LED practitioners to memorise them and to explain LED to newcomers. Behind this is the thinking that it is possible to organise the main concepts and instruments of local economic development (LED) along a number of triangles. Altogether there are six triangles, and adding them graphically creates the Hexagon. The Hexagon is useful in introducing practitioners and stakeholders to the main concepts and instruments of LED. It helps widen the perspective, un- derstand the complexity of LED and appreciate the trade-offs and conflicts involved in doing LED. It is useful to subsume the triangles under three main headers: The first and second triangles are about the hard core of conventional lo- cal economic development, i.e. the key categories and instruments.
  • 4. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The third and fourth triangles are very useful in adding an innovative twist, a wider perspective and a broader scope to LED. They explore the connections between LED and other approaches to local development. The fifth and sixth triangle are about practical issues in implementing an LED initiative. They look at governance and process management. Local Economic Development in South Africa South Africa is a special case when it comes to Local Economic Develop- ment. Whereas in other countries LED tends to be a voluntary activity of lo- cal government, often born our of necessity or desperation, in South Africa it is a statutory activity. The South African constitution establishes “devel- opmental local government”, and this includes the responsibility for eco- nomic development. In recent years, the main vehicle for the developmental task of local gov- ernment has been the IDP process. IDP stands for integrated development plan (for details see www.pimss.net), a five-year-plan which looks mainly at infrastructure development but also includes LED activities. The preparation of IDP includes comprehensive consultation exercises with local communi- ties, albeit it appears that local business communities are not very present in these exercises. LED in IDP more often than not relates to infrastructure and buildings, not to other typical LED interventions like business networking or business development service programmes. Until about 2003, the conceptual discussion around LED in South Africa primarily focused the issues of poverty alleviation, upliftment of the previ- ously disadvantaged persons (black empowerment) and infrastructure de- velopment.1 LED used to be conceptualised as part of a social policy and an affirmative action agenda. LED was often identified with small projects with an extremely limited impact which addressed marginalised groups of persons. Evaluations found that the impact of such interventions was very limited. At the same time, it became obvious that there needs to be a stronger effort to enhance the job creation capacity of the established formal economy. Thus, creation of location-based competitive advantage is a theme has been introduced into the LED policy. 1 Tomlinson, Richard (2003): The Local Economic Development mirage in South Africa. Geoforum, Vol. 34, pp. 113-122. See also http://www.led-sa.co.za/ . mesopartner 2
  • 5. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The First Triangle (Hard core LED #1) Economic development is based on the efforts of companies – some of them government-owned, but most of them private. The main target group of lo- cal economic development (LED) are thus companies, in particular the pri- vate sector. Further target groups include the workers and the public sector; we will come to them when we discuss locational factors. What kind of companies make up the main target group? LED efforts are often primarily directed at attracting companies. The main goal of tradi- tional LED efforts (i.e. in industrialised countries: from the 1960s to the 1980s) was to attract new investors. It is much too narrow, however, to limit LED in this way. There are three types of companies which can be the tar- geted in LED: Local companies, external investors and start-up companies. It depends on the features of a given location which of these three types is the priority target. Locations with a weak local company base and little en- trepreneurial dynamism will often try to attract external investors. In loca- tions with a strong local economic base, promoting the competitiveness of existing companies is often much more relevant than attracting companies. Yet the main message is: Do not conceptualise the three target groups in an either/or manner. Instead, try to realise the synergies between them: Do not try to attract external investors in a random manner. Try to attract companies that strengthen the profile and competitive advantage of the local economy. Try to build clusters or sub-sectors that can benefit from shared suppliers or infrastructure. mesopartner 3
  • 6. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development When you go for start-up promotion, look at the opportunities which are created through outsourcing, subcontracting and spin-offs. Also look at the succession issue in established companies. For a longer-term per- spective, introduce enterpreneurship as a topic in primary and secondary education. Assess the opportunities which franchising creates for potential entre- preneurs in your location. The relevance of the first triangle for South Africa LED in South Africa primarily targets new start-ups, mostly under the headings of "emerging entrepreneurs" or “self-employed persons” as well as "black economic empowerment" (BEE). This reflects the fact that the vast majority of the population was seriously restricted in its business options be- fore 1994, and that massive support for emerging entrepreneurs is crucial in an economy which is highly concentrated, i.e. where most sectors are run by monopolies or oligopolies. The political rationale for this focus of LED is obvious and necessary. Yet it is advisable to widen the scope of LED, without losing the original focus: Ironically, LED activities tend to ignore existing black businesses. Yet improving the environment for existing businesses might also lead to strong job creation effects, over and above the promotion of new BEE entrepreneurship, especially if the latter is not done competently and does not lead to sustainable businesses. LED activities around outsourcing and subcontracting activities of es- tablished big corporations, parastatals and even government, create a potential for existing and start-up businesses which so far has not been sufficiently explored. Too much emphasis is on the tendering process for big deliveries, and the small purchases are lost in the process. Small scale supplying is often the gateway for very small business to get into this lucrative market. National LED policy explicitly and quite rightly argues against "smoke- stack chasing", i.e. attracting external investors through subsidies and fiscal incentives. Unfortunately, this leads to a constellation where in- vestment promotion – which should not be based primarily on financial incentives anyway – escapes the attention of LED stakeholders alto- gether. Attracting investments from outside can strengthen the local economy and create jobs, thus being in line with established focus areas. mesopartner 4
  • 7. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development South Africa has a very high density of franchises. However, the fran- chise principle so far has not been properly applied to the business de- velopment service (BDS) industry. There are examples of commercially successful local business services centres. But the opportunity that rests in turning this business into a proper franchise has not been realised so far. The concept of Social Franchising could be explored, where the Franchisor is a not-for-profit entity, whilst all the Franchisee outlets are profit driven. Reconsidering and reconceptualising LED from the perspective of this tri- angle may lead to an improved and more effective LED practice in South Africa. It would entail the practical operationalisation of the revised Na- tional Policy on LED. mesopartner 5
  • 8. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The Second Triangle (Hard core LED #2) Locational factors are those features which determine whether a given town, city or region qualifies as a favourable setting for doing business. There are three types of locational factors: 1. Tangible locational factors, which are mostly "hard" criteria and which can often be quantified 2. Intangible factors relevant for companies, which are "soft" factors and not easily quantifiable 3. Intangible factors relevant for professionals, which are basically those factors that define the quality of life in a given location There is a clear hierarchy between the three types of locational factors. Most relevant are tangible factors. It is only after tangible factors become in- creasingly similar across locations that intangible factors become relevant as a distinguishing feature. To put it differently: If your location, unlike other locations which are nearby, suffers from unreliable electricity supply, water scarcity, and dreadful roads, even excellent supporting institutions and the most effective business network program will have only a limited effect. Regarding intangible factors, the focus for good practice has changed from specific business promotion activities to the overall local business environ- ment. In the past, government often tried to promote business even though it itself was the most important obstacle for business – due to high taxes, complex and excessive regulations, and complicated, protracted and unpre- dictable permit processes. A key objective of local governments these days is to remove unnecessary obstacles to business activities. mesopartner 6
  • 9. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The relevance of the second triangle for South Africa The triangle of locational factors is at the very core of LED thinking and practice in many parts of the world, but not necessarily in South Africa. LED interventions in South Africa address certain tangible locational factors, in particular infrastructure development (including the IDP pro- cess) and skills development. In recent years, in many countries the main focus of LED has been to remove government-created obstacles for business. Typical examples are – the removal of decade-old regulations which are no longer relevant but still could stand in the way of businesses; in many cases the authorities are not even aware of these regulations, and should con- sider a comprehensive audit of them (e.g. regulations that limit small business to operate from a residential premise could be revisited), – the speeding-up and simplification of permit processes, so that busi- nesses can invest and create jobs quicker; in some cases a simple transaction is being stretched to a month-long process through bu- reaucratic procedures, negligence or avoidance of decision-making, – regular meetings between top officials in local government and busi- nesspeople to find practical ways of improving the business environ- ment; this simple, obvious exercise has the potential of improving the business environment in a speedy and effective way – the reorganisation of interaction between businesses and local gov- ernment offices, for instance through the creation of Internet gate- ways, the set-up of first-stop agencies (which competently inform businesses about permit procedures and regulations) and the set-up of one-stop agencies (so that businesses must no longer interact with a multitude of government agencies, which sometimes even contra- dicted each other). It holds big potential to implement such activities in South Africa. Another main LED activity in many countries is the promotion and fa- cilitation of business networking. Typical examples are – the organisation of informal get-togethers for businesspeople, mesopartner 7
  • 10. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development – the creation of mentorship schemes where experienced businesspeo- ple dedicate some time to mentoring young businesspeople, – cluster initiatives to promote closer interaction between businesses, in order to improve competitiveness and stimulate innovation. This also holds big potential for South Africa. mesopartner 8
  • 11. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The Third Triangle (Innovative LED #1) Local economic development is not just about things like business promo- tion, SME support and micro enterprise promotion. The overarching goal of LED is to create jobs and income, and therefore it is crucial to involve employment promotion measures and organiza- tions in a given LED effort. Employment creation and poverty allevia- tion, however, is also a distinct activity with its own delivery structure, and it is usually addressed as part of social policy. This, in turn, leads to something which is often a major confusion in LED: the distinction be- tween economic development (business promotion) and community de- velopment (employment creation, poverty alleviation). Sometimes these activities get mixed up, and as a result usually neither economic nor so- cial objectives are achieved. One of the key issues of LED is to enhance the locational quality of a given place. If you look at the tangible and intangible locational factors, you find that some of them are closely related to business promotion, whereas many other have to do with issues which are usually addressed under the heading of Urban Development, which has its own concepts and approaches – and often a much longer time horizon than LED. From the perspective of a business promotion agency /actor, in order to de- sign and implement an adequate LED effort, it is crucial to understand what is going on in these two neighbouring fields: What are the main concepts and instruments used there? And what are the synergies which can be real- ised by connecting concepts, measures and actors from these different fields? mesopartner 9
  • 12. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The relevance of the third triangle for South Africa In South Africa, LED is being approached from all the three different angles involved in this triangle. First, there is the poverty alleviation angle. In the past, the majority of "LED projects" were not intended to create sustainable businesses or to improve the environment of existing businesses. They rather addressed the immedi- ate problems of marginalised persons who have little or no income and op- portunities. These projects often went wrong; evaluators found quite a num- ber of failed poultry, brick making, bakery, and vegetable garden projects. The failure of these projects was primarily due to the basic design and sup- port problems. Often funders demanded that such projects were driven by a group of people, not by an individual, and that they made no profit (but also no loss). This lead to unclear governance structures inside the project – no- body was really in charge, and as soon as anything went wrong everybody blamed everybody else. Also, what is the incentive to put in hard work if you can't make a profit anyway? The solution is not to stop projects which benefit the really poor, but rather expand and manage them in a professional way. Poor people with little or no education need and deserve the support of the society. But it is wrong to call activities which are supposed to benefit them "LED projects", or even worse, “businesses”. These projects are an outcome of social policy. They do not primarily have an economic rationale. They do not aim at stimulating business and economic growth. They rather help those people who would mesopartner 10
  • 13. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development continue to be poor and marginalised even if there was economic growth. These projects are poverty alleviation projects that are supposed to stimulate self-help, and they should be named accordingly. In South Africa’s situa- tion, it is certainly justified that Government encourages and supports such projects, especially as it is moving rapidly to genuine local economic devel- opment. Second, there is the urban planning angle. This includes infrastructure de- velopment and, most of all, the IDP process. This approach to LED is plan- ning-driven, which effectively means that there is a long period of time be- tween conceiving a project and observing an impact on the ground. Planning and proper LED are closely related, but it is fatal to assume that planning is the same as LED. An urban planner is perfectly happy if something he is planning today has a practical impact three years from now. From a business perspective, this is unattractive. A given business doesn't even know whether it will still exist three years from now. For a business, LED is only attractive if it leads to visible improvements within a short period of time. This takes us to the third angle, namely business-oriented LED. This is a rare phenomenon in South Africa, especially outside the big metros. The business sector is only occasionally involved in LED – and often drops out if LED is much talk and little action. mesopartner 11
  • 14. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The Fourth Triangle (Innovative LED #2) Sustainable development often appears as a somewhat abstract concept. However, it becomes much less abstract if is being conceptualised at the lo- cal level. A good example is vegetable oil. For instance, have you ever con- sidered how much vegetable oil restaurants and industrial kitchens in your city are consuming? And have you ever considered that much of it is actu- ally not consumed but rather disposed of after some period of use? If you start to ask around, you may come to figures which amount to several tons of vegetable oil which is monthly poured into sewers or local rivers. This is not only creating environmental problems. It is also a big waste. Used vegetable oil still has a high energy content, and after a process of refining it can be used, for instance, to run internal combustion engines. Why not run local buses on recycled vegetable oil? If you think about it, it quickly be- comes obvious that this is an excellent manifestation of the concept of sus- tainable development: it solves several environmental problems (pollution of rivers, air pollu- tion from conventional petrol), it creates an economic opportunity, since the collection and refinery op- eration ought to be run as a private enterprise (probably with some pub- lic seed money), it makes a contribution to social development, in particular in terms of creating low-skilled jobs in the oil collection business. This example shows two things. First, sustainable development can be a very concrete concept. Second, thinking about issues from this perspective mesopartner 12
  • 15. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development opens the mind to note potentials which otherwise go unnoticed. In this sense, sustainable development can play the role of giving orientation in terms of strategic orientation. It can also contribute to motivate local actors for a LED effort. There are many places, including in poor regions, where environmental problems such as waste disposal are pressing. Many such problems indeed are business opportunities, and conceptualising them in this way can pave the way for an effective LED initiative. The relevance of the fourth triangle for South Africa The triangle of sustainable development is an outcome of the discussion on ecological aspects of development. The idea is to reconcile economic, social and ecological / environmental development, i.e. to make sure that devel- opment is not following an exclusively economic rationale but also leads to social development while not destroying the environment. Connecting these three points as part of local development initiatives is a relatively new ap- proach in industrialised countries. As yet, it is only starting to make its way to South Africa. In fact, a foreign observer in South Africa might get the impression that en- ergy is for free. The degree of inefficiency in the use of resources, in par- ticular energy, is stunning. The negligence of biomass as a source of energy is as stunning as the absence of proper systems for the recycling of materi- als. While on the one hand this is a very serious problem which is reinforc- ing problems of poverty and marginalisation, on the other hand it is also a big opportunity since it creates the possibility of quick gains for local-level activities which address energy efficiency and recycling. At the local level, activities such as recycling tend to cover all three corners of the triangle of sustainable development at the same time. They are creat- ing a business opportunity. They are creating jobs and income, often for low-skilled persons. And they solve environmental problems. mesopartner 13
  • 16. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The Fifth Triangle (Organising LED #1) Any local development effort involves the public and private sectors, and probably also other actors. The basic pattern of a successful LED effort in- volves a network, not an organization. LED is based on a policy-network, i.e. a set of different actors, governmental as well as non-governmental. The reason is that each actor contributes specific resources – legislative power, money, information and knowledge, credibility and prestige, and others. On the public side, the legislative and several branches of the local or re- gional executive have to play a role. On the private side, chambers and other business associations have to participate. But there may also be active in- volvement of companies, most obviously real estate and development firms and utilities, but also other companies, such as large firms involved in sup- plier development or community development activities. NGOs also may play a role, as may local universities or other organisations. In many developing countries, it is still common to find not particularly strong actors on either side. Public agencies are under financed, lack highly skilled staff, are excessively bureaucratic, have no idea what a business mindset is like, etc. Private organizations, in particularly chambers and as- sociation, are understaffed, not very professional, highly politicised, offer little services to their members, lack a clear mission, etc. In a setting like this, it is tricky to launch a LED initiative. At the same time, it will often be unlikely that these problems get sorted out for some reason in the medium term. Therefore, stakeholders who want to launch a LED ini- tiative have work with the institutions which are there. Rather than waiting for public sector reform to happen and organizational development in cham- bers and associations to fall from heaven, a LED initiative creates an op- mesopartner 14
  • 17. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development portunity, and possibly a motivation, for these things to occur. Successful LED is based on a constructive relationship between local government, the private sector and possibly other stakeholders. Practical LED interventions which look at quick gains are a possible way to create a constructive rela- tionship. The relevance of the fifth triangle for South Africa Successful LED is based on the interaction between an efficient govern- ment, which understands business principles and economic development, and an effectively organised private sector which can voice the interests of private business but also assure compliance with agreements. Both condi- tions apply to South Africa only to a limited extent. Local government is often not strong enough. As staff frequently changes, and as departments go through repeated rounds of restructur- ing, the effectiveness of local government suffers. Even though some local business chambers are very strong and effec- tive, most are not. It is not even rare to find locations without any effec- tive organisation of the private sector. Moreover, both sides are often hesitant to co-operate, since both sides look at the other side with scepticism and suspicion. Under these circumstances LED gains an additional dimension. It is not just about practical interven- tions to make a location a better place to do business. It is also about learn- ing and organisational development processes both in local government and in the private sector. For both sides, this involves an important learning op- portunity. In the recent past, LED often involved public sector employees trying to run quasi-businesses, sometimes well, often not. At the same time, individuals who are running successful businesses are often not successful at all when it comes to running a business association. In practice, LED tends to be based on a local "LED Forum". In fact, there is an opinion that the best way to start LED is by creating an LED Forum. But some observers would argue that this is the best way to assure that LED is stillborn. When an LED process reaches some maturity, an LED Forum can serve as an information platform for coordination, leveraging resources and know-how, and troubleshooting. However, if an LED Forum is created at the outset, this usually means that representatives from all sorts of sectors – business, health, social, education, security – spend a lot of time figuring out how to approach and implement LED. As there are no consistent guidelines on how to organise an LED Forum, bewilderment may quickly turn into mesopartner 15
  • 18. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development frustration, as the Forum cannot agree on its purpose. Stakeholders start dropping out, first of all business representatives, who are under serious time constraints. In the absence of the business perspective, however, the Forum then easily wanders into the social policy / poverty alleviation field and is soon afflicted by Projectitis, i.e. the proliferation of little projects which draw heavily on the capacity of local government but have little im- pact. mesopartner 16
  • 19. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development The Sixth Triangle (Organising LED #2) Local economic may have a beginning, but it never ends. It may start with central government delegating economic development responsibilities to lo- cal authorities, or with local stakeholders deciding to take things in their own hands because problems of unemployment and poverty become un- bearable. But once you have started with LED, you will find out that you are dealing with a moving target: as soon as have solved the easy problems, such as particularly clumsy licensing processes, you are identifying more tricky problems which take longer to sort out. And it goes on like that. The best way of conceptualising LED is as a permanent cycle, which in terms of learning involves three cornerstones: participatory diagnostic participatory planning participatory monitoring, evaluation and benchmarking These learning- and knowledge-oriented points lead to three more practical activities: motivation, mobilisation and prioritisation implementation reflection and adjustment mesopartner 17
  • 20. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development LED is an iterative process which runs around this triangle over and again. LED is also a learning process. It is desirable that LED starts with simple activities which lead to quick successes. But over time LED may become more ambitious and more sophisticated. The relevance of the sixth triangle for South Africa The basic idea of the triangle of process management is that LED is an it- erative process. The metaphor of the triangle also indicates that iterations should be visible as such; the opposite is a process which runs endlessly, or collapses and has to be restarted. Perceiving the process as a sequence of it- erations also is a constant reminder that one should not get lost in the details of managing the current stage, thus losing sight of the other steps. In par- ticular, this refers to the later steps of the process, in particular evaluation, benchmarking and learning, which should not be introduced as an after- thought. The practice of the LED process in South Africa so far looks not so much like a triangle but rather like a funnel. There is a big mobilisation effort, but then the process gets narrower and narrower, and in the end very little comes out. This probably has a lot to do with confusion about how to start LED in the first place. What is missing is a clear concept for the early steps, i.e. the identification of opportunities to create growth and scrapping bottle- necks which limit economic growth. This early stage is either driven by dis- cussions in an LED Forum or by IDP-like planning processes with limited practical results on the ground. This is why we suggest to employ the PACA methodology at an early stage, in order to move quickly into action. With PACA, an LED process will look like a funnel which stands on top: Ini- tially, there are only a couple of activities going on. But over time, as stakeholders learn LED and get empowered, the number, size and scope of interventions widens significantly. mesopartner 18
  • 21. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development Conclusion LED is a long-term activity which is mostly based on short- and medium- term projects. Over time, LED tends to go through a life cycle with three typical phases, which are summarised in the following table. Kick-off phase Lasso phase Network phase Focus Get LED projects moving Get LED projects under con- Segment activities (sector trol initiatives, landmark projects) formulate a strategy delegate responsibilities pro-forma strategy Governance Informal Clear distribution of tasks Central information- pattern and responsibilities exchange, decentralised re- Possibly creation of central sponsibilities LED agency M+E pattern None Informal Emerging formalization Reward system Excitement Discipline and suffering Identification with project personal motivation Salary objectives Latitude of decision-making Crisis Fragmentation, lack of co- Exploding co-ordination effort Network failure ordination Increasing number of LED professionals = rising fixed cost Time- and energy-consuming strategizing effort De-motivation of volunteers It is not useful to try to leapfrog any of these phases. It is rather important to be aware of the existence of this life-cycle, and to reflect occasionally on which phase you are in – and whether it might be advisable to move to the next stage. In South Africa, localities tend jump into the second phase before completing, or even initiating, the first one. It is not rare to find localities where the LED officer’s shelves are overflowing with consultants’ project feasibility reports, but where very few LED activities are actually going on. One of the reasons is the legal mandate mentioned above: Many local governments think that, because they have mandate for LED, they must and can do on their own, without involving other actors in the delivery. The results are very disappointing. South African localities will only get a significant outcome from LED if they address it in a more comprehensive, balanced way – as indicated by the Hexagon. mesopartner 19
  • 22. Jörg Meyer-Stamer, The Hexagon of Local Economic Development mesopartner is a consultancy partnership which specialises in local and regional economic development. It was founded in De- cember 2002 and registered in April 2003 by Dr Ulrich Harmes- Liedtke, Dr Jörg Meyer-Stamer and Christian Schoen. Currently, the main product of mesopartner is PACA. This is a methodology to kick-start or refocus local economic development initiatives which has been developed by Jörg Meyer-Stamer. It has been successfully applied in a number of developing and transformation countries. The main objectives of mesopartner are to train PACA practitioners in various countries, to develop more specific PACA instruments, for instance for cluster analysis, value chain analysis and analysis of govern- ment-created obstacles to business, to develop and disseminate further methodologies and tools for local and regional economic development initiatives, to develop innovative concepts and tools to train practitioners in local and regional economic development. Another mesopartner product is RALIS (Rapid Appraisal of Local Innovation Systems). As technology and innovation continue to be major preoccupations of local actors who want to create a local- ised advantage in a globalised world, we expect that there is a lot of potential demand for a tool like RALIS which addresses the most important obstacle for the leveraging of local innovation systems: fragmentation between local companies, agencies and organisations. Further mesopartner products are the Compass of Local Competitiveness, a balanced scorecard- based approach to performance management of territorial de- velopment initiatives, GENESIS, a methodology for the rapid and participatory elaboration of strategic interventions for a local or regional economy. You find more information at our website, www.mesopartner.com mesopartner 20