Regulating the network   Mathias Klang   @klang67
Regulation of technology is the regulationof democracy
It cannot be helped, it is as it should be, thatthe law is behind the times. Oliver Wendell Holmes
Rights of citizen & Man (1789)
Killer app 1789
Universal declaration of human rights (1948)
Killer app 1948
Laying out theconflict
Law and Borders - The Rise of Law inCyberspace                     Johnson & Post (1996)
Governments of the Industrial World, youweary giants of flesh and steel, I comefrom Cyberspace, the new home of Mind.On be...
Law is a system ofrules and guidelineswhich are enforced…to govern behavior,wherever possible. Itshapes … and servesas a s...
Technologychanging society,but social rulesslow to evolve…
Cyberlawyers argue: New technology,new rules & New field
Law of the horseFrank H. Easterbrook (1996)
Cyberlaw = establishment
Lessig (1999)Code is law
Nothing new under the sun?
Does technology influence law?
Only technology(spot the ethical dilemma?)
Control in                      digital world       Law   Contextual &programmed social       rules   Architecture        ...
How is social media         different?
Blogger 1999Google 1999               End of communications monopoly
Theoretical rightsbecome inevitable    practice
We have moved on
We the people…
Goodbye SisterMaría Jesús Galán
Marketplace of ideas: free or racistspeech?
"Crap! Robin Hood airport is closed. Youvegot a week and a bit to get your shit togetherotherwise Im blowing the airport s...
Uni student bomb threat
Post, like, share?
Norwegian politician
Medical staff
Patient and other privacy
Parents!
Why?
Eula trumps rightsIs a defense…
You know you want to…The design effect
Thenetworkeffect
If you’re not the customer you’re the                product
Why no action?  Protect us from ourselves
Neutral tools…Its only technology…
Free will  we are supposed to know stuff…           autonomy
Being stupid is not illegal
Unpopular decisions requirecourage…
Courage is a mean with regard to fear andconfidence                    Aristotle in Nicomachean Ethics
Controversial only means this will lose youvotes, courageous means this will lose you               the election.         ...
Law pushes on technology- the return of law?
Europe asks facebook questions
“Starting today, we give ourselves the ability to reactively withholdcontent from users in a specific country”            ...
(1) we will attempt to let the user    know,(2) we will clearly mark when the    content has been withheld.(3) As part of ...
Regulation by proxy
Did you read before you agreed?
Morosov is critical to the “technology bringsdemocracy” approach and is concerned that we are“amusing ourselves to death” ...
Social media creates silos & do not allowusers to port data from one site to another.
Where to now… ?   Seduction of technology
Control in                      digital world       Law   Contextual &programmed social       rules   Architecture        ...
Academia   is needed
Thank you.
Mathias Klang     klang@ituniv.se or @klang67           www.digital-rights.netImage & licensing info in the notes         ...
Regulating the Network
Regulating the Network
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Regulating the Network

531 views
450 views

Published on

Published in: Technology, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
531
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
5
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Not only our island nation that is... from nattu cc by
  • iphone Dead End from magic_quote cc by
  • Written in Gold by Anonymous Account cc by
  • Eleanor Roosevelt and United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Spanish text. Work in the public domain.
  • Lost by Stéfan cc by nc sa
  • Malcom X from Keoki Seu cc by nc sa David R. Johnson & David G. Post. Law and Borders - The Rise of Law in Cyberspace. Stanford Law Review, Vol. 48, p. 1367, 1996
  • http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law Halloween From fabbio cc by sa
  • Eden WEEE man statue by Ruth Flickr cc by nc sa
  • Came hame háááá! from R'eyes cc by
  • Horse racing event from tpower1978 cc by ...the best way to learn the law applicable to specialized endeavors is to study general rules. Lots of cases deal with sales of horses; others deal with people kicked by horses; still more deal with the licensing and racing of horses, or with the care veterinarians give to horses, or with prizes at horse shows. Any effort to collect these strands into a course on 'The Law of the Horse' is doomed to be shallow and to miss unifying principles. Frank H. Easterbrook (Cyberspace and the Law of the Horse, 1996)
  • Anarchy In The UK from an untrained eye cc by nc
  • red light... From Kıvanç Niş cc by
  • design cctv by wrote cc by nc
  • image from Yumiko Hayakawa essay Public Benches Turn ‘ Anti-Homeless ’ (also recommend Design with Intent ) Source http://architectures.danlockton.co.uk/2006/10/05/anti-homeless-benches-in-tokyo/
  • Two of a Kind by Ali A cc by nc sa
  • 2001 Wikipedia, Tripadvisor 2002 Linkedin 2003 Pirate Bay, MySpace, Second Life, Wordfeud 2004 Facebook, digg 2005 Youtube 2006 Twitter, Spotify, Slideshare 2007 iPhone 2009 Klout, Farmville, Quora, Foursquare, Kickstarter 2010 Wordfeud, Instagram 2011 Google+
  • CSA-2006-08-10-093402 By The U.S. Army cc by
  • iPhone by wiennat cc by sa
  • goldfish from a_trotskyite cc by nc sa
  • Get thee to a nunnery from kevindooley cc by María Jesús Galán, dubbed 'Sister Internet', had almost 600 Facebook 'friends'at the time of her eviction  Photo: FACEBOOK The Telegraph http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/facebook/8333810/Spanish-nun-expelled-from-order-over-Facebook-usage.html
  • My tweet was silly, but the police reaction was absurd For one joke on Twitter I've had my civil liberties trampled on, and have now got a criminal record “ Unfortunately,yesterday I was found guilty and ordered to pay £1,000 in fines and legal costs, which I have to find along with my own legal costs of another £1,000. I am considering an appeal, though I have no means, having left my job due to the circumstances. ” http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/libertycentral/2010/may/11/tweet-joke-criminal-record-airport
  • workstation by striatic cc by Tentaångest. Man sitter i salen och skriver. Ingen är lycklig, flera är stressade. Men det kan bli värre… Mitt under en tenta kom två civilklädda poliser in och grep en av studenterna. Hans brott? Natten innan, under febril tentapluggande skrev han på sin Facebook statusrad att han skulle bomba skrivsalen ( Spionen ) sedan gick han och la sig, vaknade och gick till tentasalen. Han satt en timme och skrev på tentan innan polisen kom och hämtade honom. På något vis hade hans status­uppdatering nått polisen, som tog hotet på allvar. I stället för tenta blev det förhör på Mölndals polisstation. - Efter många timmar blev jag frisläppt. Jag åkte in till stan och åt lunch med några kursare. Sedan gick jag direkt till tentasalen och pratade med en av vakterna, förklarade situationen och bad om ursäkt, berättar studenten som säger att han inte hade en tanke på att någon skulle kunna uppfatta hans uppdatering som ett seriöst hot. ( Spionen ) http://www.spionen.se/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=154&Itemid=3
  • Stella Mwangi Rita Ormbostad, deputy mayor of Aure County on Norway’s west coast, wrote that she would rather have “Sami, polar bears and muskox” as winners and that “that’s what we should sell, not that we are open to asylum seekers!” Ormbostad later added that she had “sharpened a spear and bought bongo drums” in anticipation of the Eurovision finals where Mwangi will represent Norway. “Maybe I’ll travel to Africa and watch from there, where I can eat wildebeest!” Ormbostad tried to brush off her comments as merely a joke, but also told local newspaper Tidens Krav that “I believe something originally Norwegian sells more and is more suitable for the Norwegian Grand Prix than a song that has African tendencies.”
  • the doctor will see you now from CmdrCord cc by nc sa
  • En anställd vid Karolinska universitetssjukhuset riskerar avsked sedan personen lagt ut bilder från kirurgiska ingrepp på internetnätverket Facebook.
  • I'm working.(1) by purprin cc by nc sa
  • Why do you do this every day? from edmittance cc by nc sa
  • Untitled from Kennedy Garrett cc by
  • Prego from marcodede cc by
  • Forest For The Nails from Brandon Heyer cc by nc sa
  • [ قطرة تفاؤل ] from [ALHanouf _ Photography's]²º¹¹ cc by
  • Howl from CaptPiper cc by
  • Seamour Sheep + MacBook from Andy Woo cc by nc sa
  • if it makes you fly... from notsogoodphotography cc by
  • Spot from Daniele Pesaresi cc by sa
  • jamie cullum-it's about time from visualpanic cc by
  • OK, who gave the monkey a ray gun_! by Don Solo cc by nc sa
  • Pressed into Service from horizontal.integration cc by nc sa
  • A hard days work by Kalexandersson cc by nc sa
  • A little photoshop By psiaki cc by
  • Lotta By Cristma cc by nc nd http://blog.twitter.com/2012/01/tweets-still-must-flow.html
  • Lost by Stéfan cc by nc sa
  • the same horizon by Norma Desmond cc by nc sa
  • Flamingos Partying from szeke cc by
  • A5 #3 OBSESSION ISSUE - #18 Yara... from A5 Magazine cc by nc sa Tim Berners Lee: “Long Live the Web: A Call for Continued Open Standards and Neutrality”, Scientific American Magazine (2010)
  • The shark By Miguel Pires da Rosa cc by sa
  • October 2010, Reykjavik, Iceland by loranger CC BY
  • Heroes from Gastev cc by
  • Eyes ! (Youth from Antikythera!) by agelakis cc by nc sa
  • Regulating the Network

    1. 1. Regulating the network Mathias Klang @klang67
    2. 2. Regulation of technology is the regulationof democracy
    3. 3. It cannot be helped, it is as it should be, thatthe law is behind the times. Oliver Wendell Holmes
    4. 4. Rights of citizen & Man (1789)
    5. 5. Killer app 1789
    6. 6. Universal declaration of human rights (1948)
    7. 7. Killer app 1948
    8. 8. Laying out theconflict
    9. 9. Law and Borders - The Rise of Law inCyberspace Johnson & Post (1996)
    10. 10. Governments of the Industrial World, youweary giants of flesh and steel, I comefrom Cyberspace, the new home of Mind.On behalf of the future, I ask you of thepast to leave us alone. You are notwelcome among us. You have nosovereignty where we gather. Barlow (1996)
    11. 11. Law is a system ofrules and guidelineswhich are enforced…to govern behavior,wherever possible. Itshapes … and servesas a social mediatorof relationsbetween people.
    12. 12. Technologychanging society,but social rulesslow to evolve…
    13. 13. Cyberlawyers argue: New technology,new rules & New field
    14. 14. Law of the horseFrank H. Easterbrook (1996)
    15. 15. Cyberlaw = establishment
    16. 16. Lessig (1999)Code is law
    17. 17. Nothing new under the sun?
    18. 18. Does technology influence law?
    19. 19. Only technology(spot the ethical dilemma?)
    20. 20. Control in digital world Law Contextual &programmed social rules Architecture Control in analogue world
    21. 21. How is social media different?
    22. 22. Blogger 1999Google 1999 End of communications monopoly
    23. 23. Theoretical rightsbecome inevitable practice
    24. 24. We have moved on
    25. 25. We the people…
    26. 26. Goodbye SisterMaría Jesús Galán
    27. 27. Marketplace of ideas: free or racistspeech?
    28. 28. "Crap! Robin Hood airport is closed. Youvegot a week and a bit to get your shit togetherotherwise Im blowing the airport sky high!"
    29. 29. Uni student bomb threat
    30. 30. Post, like, share?
    31. 31. Norwegian politician
    32. 32. Medical staff
    33. 33. Patient and other privacy
    34. 34. Parents!
    35. 35. Why?
    36. 36. Eula trumps rightsIs a defense…
    37. 37. You know you want to…The design effect
    38. 38. Thenetworkeffect
    39. 39. If you’re not the customer you’re the product
    40. 40. Why no action? Protect us from ourselves
    41. 41. Neutral tools…Its only technology…
    42. 42. Free will  we are supposed to know stuff… autonomy
    43. 43. Being stupid is not illegal
    44. 44. Unpopular decisions requirecourage…
    45. 45. Courage is a mean with regard to fear andconfidence Aristotle in Nicomachean Ethics
    46. 46. Controversial only means this will lose youvotes, courageous means this will lose you the election. Sir Humphrey in Yes Minister
    47. 47. Law pushes on technology- the return of law?
    48. 48. Europe asks facebook questions
    49. 49. “Starting today, we give ourselves the ability to reactively withholdcontent from users in a specific country” Twitter
    50. 50. (1) we will attempt to let the user know,(2) we will clearly mark when the content has been withheld.(3) As part of that transparency, we’ve expanded our partnership with Chilling Effects when we are required to withhold a Tweet in a specific country
    51. 51. Regulation by proxy
    52. 52. Did you read before you agreed?
    53. 53. Morosov is critical to the “technology bringsdemocracy” approach and is concerned that we are“amusing ourselves to death” (Postman 1985)
    54. 54. Social media creates silos & do not allowusers to port data from one site to another.
    55. 55. Where to now… ? Seduction of technology
    56. 56. Control in digital world Law Contextual &programmed social rules Architecture Control in analogue world
    57. 57. Academia is needed
    58. 58. Thank you.
    59. 59. Mathias Klang klang@ituniv.se or @klang67 www.digital-rights.netImage & licensing info in the notes section of slides. Images at www.flickr.com (or specifically stated). This ppt licensed: Creative Commons BY-NC-SA Download presentation www.slideshare.net/klang

    ×