SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 17
Download to read offline
The Student Stressors and Assets
    Survey:
    An Assessment of the Developmental Assets™ of
    Students in the Bernards Township School District




Based on a Report Prepared By:
  Kirk C. Harlow, Dr.P.H.
  decisionstat@eartlink.net
Study Process
       Focus on assessing the presence among students of the Search
       Institute’s eight developmental assets

         Support—support from family, school, and community
         Empowerment—valuing of young people by the community
         Boundaries and expectations—clear expectations and limits
         Constructive use of time—enriching activities in which young
          people can participate
         Commitment to learning—lifelong commitment to learning
          and education
         Positive values—guiding values for choices
         Social competencies—Skills equipping young people to make
          effective choices
         Positive identity—Sense of purpose and worth.
Questionnaire Design

   25 questions drawn from
   Search Institute
   Remaining questions
   developed specifically for
   project
   Parental permission gotten
   for each student
   completing questionnaire
   Distributed in classrooms
   Distributed to all 6th, 8th,
   10th, and 12th graders
Response Rates


     Table 1. Response Rates by Grade and
                   Gender
        Grade      Males   Females   Total
         6th       56%      62%      59%
         8th       31%      33%      32%
         10th      77%      84%      80%
         12th      48%      63%      56%
        Total      53%      60%      56%
Demographic Characteristics of
Respondents
Respondent Class Grade by Gender

     Slightly more females than males responded,
     especially in the 12th grade
Student Age and Ethnicity
 Student ages corresponded   The majority of
 to the class grades         respondents were White
Other Demographic Information

   85% had grades of As
   and Bs or better
   84% lived with both
   parents
   70% lived in current
   household ten or
   more years
Survey Results
Summary Mean Scores for Seven
Developmental Asset Categories by
Grade
                                         Grade in School
                              6th  8th     10th      12th   Total
       Asset Categories      Mean Mean    Mean      Mean Mean
 Support summary              4.1    3.8      3.7       3.9   3.9
 Boundaries summary           3.8    3.7      3.6       3.4   3.6
 Commitment to learning
                              4.1     4.0     4.0      4.1    4.0
 summary
 Positive identity summary    4.1     3.8     3.4      3.6    3.7
 Social competency
                              3.7     3.8     3.7      3.7    3.7
 summary
 Positive values summary      4.0     3.7     3.7      3.7    3.8
 Empowerment summary          3.2     2.8     3.0      3.0    3.0

 Scores are based on a 1 to 5 point scale in which 5 is highest.
Athletic Involvement
            Asset 8-Constructive Use of Time through Activities
Have you participated in Athletics/Intramural sports?
                              Yes                 No
 Grade in School
                           Row N %             Row N %
          6th                    76.9%             23.1%
          8th                    80.2%             19.8%
         10th                    80.7%             19.3%
         12th                    74.9%             25.1%
         Total                   78.3%             21.7%

   If yes, how worthwhile do you think your participation was?
                                           Somewhat
                     Not worthwhile       worthwhile       Very worthwhile
  Grade in School         Row N %            Row N %            Row N %
           6th                   3.4%             22.7%             73.9%
           8th                 12.0%              32.6%             55.4%
          10th                   9.5%             29.7%             60.8%
          12th                   7.3%             33.0%             59.7%
         Total                   8.4%             30.1%             61.5%
Alcohol Use
                                                    Grade in School
                            6th           8th             10th            12th         Total
                       Column N %      Column N %     Column N %       Column N %   Column N %

In the past 3 months, have you drunk
beer, wine, or “hard” liquor, not
counting religious occasions?

  Never                      93.6%       82.0%         39.5%          19.8%            50.1%
  1 or 2 times                 5.3%      11.7%         27.9%          20.6%            19.4%
  3 or 4 times                 0.6%       3.1%         14.4%          18.6%            11.4%
  5 or more times              0.6%       3.1%         18.2%          41.1%            19.1%

In the past 3 months, how many times
have you gotten drunk?

  Never                      98.8%       92.1%         62.2%          40.0%            66.9%
  1 or 2 times                 0.0%       4.0%         18.9%          20.4%            13.8%
  3 or 4 times                 0.0%       1.6%         10.6%          15.7%              8.8%
  5 or more times              1.2%       2.4%          8.3%          23.9%            10.6%
Drug Use
                                             Grade in School
                            6th      8th          10th         12th    Total
                       Column N % Column N % Column N % Column N % Column N %




In the past year, how often used a
drug other than alcohol to get
high?


  Never                     98.3%    91.4%         74.2%       53.9%   73.4%

  1 or 2 times                1.7%    3.8%          8.1%       14.1%     8.5%

  3 or 4 times                0.0%    1.0%          4.2%        5.9%     3.7%

  5 or 6 times                0.0%    1.0%          1.7%        3.1%     1.8%
  More than 6 times           0.0%    2.9%         11.9%       23.0%   12.6%
Summary of Findings
  There is a cause for concern about alcohol use. The
  results indicated higher alcohol use among students in
  athletics compared to others. A similar result was found
  in the 2005 survey.
  There also was an indication that some students are
  riding in cars in which they perceive the driver as being
  drunk.
  While parental support was high, about one-fourth of all
  students indicated feeling too much pressure from
  parents to do well. Students who felt too much pressure
  also indicated feeling less support from parents.
  About half of the students indicated getting support from
  teachers, but only 30% of all students indicated feeling
  that teachers cared about them.
Summary of Findings
  Students indicated feeling that school rules were clear, but
  not necessarily family rules. In addition, it appeared that
  punishment for breaking family rules was not consistent.
  An inverse relationship between the clarity of family rules
  and involvement in risk behavior such as alcohol or drug
  use was found.
  Students indicated knowing how to set limits, but they also
  indicated acting without thinking. There is the potential for
  impulsive behavior to override self-regulatory behavior.
  By 10th grade over 25% of the students indicated cheating on
  a test two or more times in the past year. About two-thirds of
  10th and 12th graders indicated copying homework two or
  more times in the past year.
Implications of Findings

  The significant use of alcohol among students, especially
  among athletes, suggests that a concerted effort may be
  needed to address the risk associated with alcohol use
  among these students. The results indicate that some of
  the underlying factors may be related to social norms.
  The evidence that some students are riding in cars in
  which the driver is drunk suggests the need for increased
  efforts to prevent driving while drunk.
  There were clear, positive relationships between the
  Developmental Assets and lower involvement in risk
  behaviors. While many students have high scores for the
  assets, exploring measures that may strengthen the assets
  for at-risk students should be considered.
Implications of Findings
  Cheating in school has become a national problem, and the
  survey’s results indicate the problem is also present in these
  students. It may be useful to explore approaches to reduce
  cheating.
  There was an identified relationship between thrill seeking and
  impulse control, and high-risk behavior. Developing programs
  that focus not only on resistance, but impulse control, may be
  worthwhile. Targeting higher risk students, such as those with
  Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, may be of value.
  The results of the survey, in an appropriate format, should be
  made available not only to adults in the community, but also the
  students. Sharing the results is empowering, and an opportunity
  to open discussion about the issues examined in the survey.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Poster: International Students Strengths
Poster: International Students Strengths Poster: International Students Strengths
Poster: International Students Strengths vijayparalkar
 
Nostalgia and acculturation
Nostalgia and acculturationNostalgia and acculturation
Nostalgia and acculturationVeronika Kashkan
 
Cultural and linguistic discrimination of international students
Cultural and linguistic discrimination of international studentsCultural and linguistic discrimination of international students
Cultural and linguistic discrimination of international studentsElisabeth Chan
 
STRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTS
STRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTSSTRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTS
STRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTSAmlan Roychowdhury
 
Stress, Coping and Adjustment
Stress, Coping and AdjustmentStress, Coping and Adjustment
Stress, Coping and AdjustmentChristie Barakat
 
Acculturation And Mental Health In Latino Community
Acculturation And Mental Health In Latino CommunityAcculturation And Mental Health In Latino Community
Acculturation And Mental Health In Latino Communitysmallmandy
 
culture bound syndromes ppt
culture bound syndromes pptculture bound syndromes ppt
culture bound syndromes pptDeepika Singh
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Poster: International Students Strengths
Poster: International Students Strengths Poster: International Students Strengths
Poster: International Students Strengths
 
Nostalgia and acculturation
Nostalgia and acculturationNostalgia and acculturation
Nostalgia and acculturation
 
Mental Health Awareness (NAFSA Region I - 2015)
Mental Health Awareness (NAFSA Region I - 2015)Mental Health Awareness (NAFSA Region I - 2015)
Mental Health Awareness (NAFSA Region I - 2015)
 
Cultural and linguistic discrimination of international students
Cultural and linguistic discrimination of international studentsCultural and linguistic discrimination of international students
Cultural and linguistic discrimination of international students
 
Stress & Coping Framework
Stress & Coping FrameworkStress & Coping Framework
Stress & Coping Framework
 
Workshop-Acculturation-cfc
Workshop-Acculturation-cfcWorkshop-Acculturation-cfc
Workshop-Acculturation-cfc
 
STRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTS
STRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTSSTRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTS
STRESS MANAGEMENT. EMPHASIS ON CABIN CREW AND STUDENTS
 
MSCP THESIS, SEMINAR PPT
MSCP THESIS, SEMINAR PPTMSCP THESIS, SEMINAR PPT
MSCP THESIS, SEMINAR PPT
 
Stress, Coping and Adjustment
Stress, Coping and AdjustmentStress, Coping and Adjustment
Stress, Coping and Adjustment
 
Acculturation And Mental Health In Latino Community
Acculturation And Mental Health In Latino CommunityAcculturation And Mental Health In Latino Community
Acculturation And Mental Health In Latino Community
 
culture bound syndromes ppt
culture bound syndromes pptculture bound syndromes ppt
culture bound syndromes ppt
 

Similar to Student Stressors and Assets Survey Reveals Areas for Improvement

Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)
Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)
Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)Kaitlin V. Kordusky
 
Gentrification and belonging 431 final-3.ppt
Gentrification and belonging 431 final-3.pptGentrification and belonging 431 final-3.ppt
Gentrification and belonging 431 final-3.pptLuis Alejandro Molina
 
Student Feedback and Progressive Reporting
Student Feedback and Progressive ReportingStudent Feedback and Progressive Reporting
Student Feedback and Progressive ReportingHobsons APAC
 
Organizational Culture.pdf
Organizational Culture.pdfOrganizational Culture.pdf
Organizational Culture.pdfPatrick Curnyn
 
Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...
Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...
Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...suvozcuenta
 
GRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSE
GRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSEGRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSE
GRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSEYassiLim
 
OWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John Campbell
OWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John CampbellOWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John Campbell
OWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John CampbellSURF Events
 
PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017
PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017
PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017Gabriela Ramos
 
Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...
Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...
Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...husITa
 
Student Perception Surveys - Market Research Study
Student Perception Surveys - Market Research StudyStudent Perception Surveys - Market Research Study
Student Perception Surveys - Market Research Studymmumford
 
Education trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in Peru
Education trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in PeruEducation trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in Peru
Education trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in PeruNiños del Milenio - GRADE
 

Similar to Student Stressors and Assets Survey Reveals Areas for Improvement (20)

Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)
Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)
Executive summary an assessment of developmental assets bernard 2012 (2)
 
Gentrification and belonging 431 final-3.ppt
Gentrification and belonging 431 final-3.pptGentrification and belonging 431 final-3.ppt
Gentrification and belonging 431 final-3.ppt
 
October 2019 Directors Meeting
October 2019 Directors MeetingOctober 2019 Directors Meeting
October 2019 Directors Meeting
 
Student Feedback and Progressive Reporting
Student Feedback and Progressive ReportingStudent Feedback and Progressive Reporting
Student Feedback and Progressive Reporting
 
Organizational Culture.pdf
Organizational Culture.pdfOrganizational Culture.pdf
Organizational Culture.pdf
 
2015 Ottawa County Youth Assessment Survey
2015 Ottawa County Youth Assessment Survey2015 Ottawa County Youth Assessment Survey
2015 Ottawa County Youth Assessment Survey
 
Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...
Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...
Encuesta de newlink research us hispanics, political preference and immigrati...
 
GRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSE
GRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSEGRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSE
GRADE 11 RESEARCH FINAL DEFENSE
 
OWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John Campbell
OWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John CampbellOWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John Campbell
OWD 2012- 4 -Four years of learning analytics in practice- John Campbell
 
Tsirang 2011 GNH Results
Tsirang 2011 GNH ResultsTsirang 2011 GNH Results
Tsirang 2011 GNH Results
 
Sarpang GNH 2011 Results
Sarpang GNH 2011 ResultsSarpang GNH 2011 Results
Sarpang GNH 2011 Results
 
PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017
PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017
PISA 2015 Well Being Launch London 19 April 2017
 
Tsi1
Tsi1Tsi1
Tsi1
 
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mbCs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
Cs3 p8 dyck listenning to the voices of rural mb
 
Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...
Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...
Gender differences of internet use among young people in Hong Kong: Implicati...
 
Pemagatshel GNH 2011 Results
Pemagatshel GNH 2011 ResultsPemagatshel GNH 2011 Results
Pemagatshel GNH 2011 Results
 
Pem1
Pem1Pem1
Pem1
 
Student Perception Surveys - Market Research Study
Student Perception Surveys - Market Research StudyStudent Perception Surveys - Market Research Study
Student Perception Surveys - Market Research Study
 
Education trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in Peru
Education trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in PeruEducation trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in Peru
Education trajectories: From early childhoood to early aduldhood in Peru
 
MKTG 3222 Final
MKTG 3222 FinalMKTG 3222 Final
MKTG 3222 Final
 

Student Stressors and Assets Survey Reveals Areas for Improvement

  • 1. The Student Stressors and Assets Survey: An Assessment of the Developmental Assets™ of Students in the Bernards Township School District Based on a Report Prepared By: Kirk C. Harlow, Dr.P.H. decisionstat@eartlink.net
  • 2. Study Process Focus on assessing the presence among students of the Search Institute’s eight developmental assets  Support—support from family, school, and community  Empowerment—valuing of young people by the community  Boundaries and expectations—clear expectations and limits  Constructive use of time—enriching activities in which young people can participate  Commitment to learning—lifelong commitment to learning and education  Positive values—guiding values for choices  Social competencies—Skills equipping young people to make effective choices  Positive identity—Sense of purpose and worth.
  • 3. Questionnaire Design 25 questions drawn from Search Institute Remaining questions developed specifically for project Parental permission gotten for each student completing questionnaire Distributed in classrooms Distributed to all 6th, 8th, 10th, and 12th graders
  • 4. Response Rates Table 1. Response Rates by Grade and Gender Grade Males Females Total 6th 56% 62% 59% 8th 31% 33% 32% 10th 77% 84% 80% 12th 48% 63% 56% Total 53% 60% 56%
  • 6. Respondent Class Grade by Gender Slightly more females than males responded, especially in the 12th grade
  • 7. Student Age and Ethnicity Student ages corresponded The majority of to the class grades respondents were White
  • 8. Other Demographic Information 85% had grades of As and Bs or better 84% lived with both parents 70% lived in current household ten or more years
  • 10. Summary Mean Scores for Seven Developmental Asset Categories by Grade Grade in School 6th 8th 10th 12th Total Asset Categories Mean Mean Mean Mean Mean Support summary 4.1 3.8 3.7 3.9 3.9 Boundaries summary 3.8 3.7 3.6 3.4 3.6 Commitment to learning 4.1 4.0 4.0 4.1 4.0 summary Positive identity summary 4.1 3.8 3.4 3.6 3.7 Social competency 3.7 3.8 3.7 3.7 3.7 summary Positive values summary 4.0 3.7 3.7 3.7 3.8 Empowerment summary 3.2 2.8 3.0 3.0 3.0 Scores are based on a 1 to 5 point scale in which 5 is highest.
  • 11. Athletic Involvement Asset 8-Constructive Use of Time through Activities Have you participated in Athletics/Intramural sports? Yes No Grade in School Row N % Row N % 6th 76.9% 23.1% 8th 80.2% 19.8% 10th 80.7% 19.3% 12th 74.9% 25.1% Total 78.3% 21.7% If yes, how worthwhile do you think your participation was? Somewhat Not worthwhile worthwhile Very worthwhile Grade in School Row N % Row N % Row N % 6th 3.4% 22.7% 73.9% 8th 12.0% 32.6% 55.4% 10th 9.5% 29.7% 60.8% 12th 7.3% 33.0% 59.7% Total 8.4% 30.1% 61.5%
  • 12. Alcohol Use Grade in School 6th 8th 10th 12th Total Column N % Column N % Column N % Column N % Column N % In the past 3 months, have you drunk beer, wine, or “hard” liquor, not counting religious occasions? Never 93.6% 82.0% 39.5% 19.8% 50.1% 1 or 2 times 5.3% 11.7% 27.9% 20.6% 19.4% 3 or 4 times 0.6% 3.1% 14.4% 18.6% 11.4% 5 or more times 0.6% 3.1% 18.2% 41.1% 19.1% In the past 3 months, how many times have you gotten drunk? Never 98.8% 92.1% 62.2% 40.0% 66.9% 1 or 2 times 0.0% 4.0% 18.9% 20.4% 13.8% 3 or 4 times 0.0% 1.6% 10.6% 15.7% 8.8% 5 or more times 1.2% 2.4% 8.3% 23.9% 10.6%
  • 13. Drug Use Grade in School 6th 8th 10th 12th Total Column N % Column N % Column N % Column N % Column N % In the past year, how often used a drug other than alcohol to get high? Never 98.3% 91.4% 74.2% 53.9% 73.4% 1 or 2 times 1.7% 3.8% 8.1% 14.1% 8.5% 3 or 4 times 0.0% 1.0% 4.2% 5.9% 3.7% 5 or 6 times 0.0% 1.0% 1.7% 3.1% 1.8% More than 6 times 0.0% 2.9% 11.9% 23.0% 12.6%
  • 14. Summary of Findings There is a cause for concern about alcohol use. The results indicated higher alcohol use among students in athletics compared to others. A similar result was found in the 2005 survey. There also was an indication that some students are riding in cars in which they perceive the driver as being drunk. While parental support was high, about one-fourth of all students indicated feeling too much pressure from parents to do well. Students who felt too much pressure also indicated feeling less support from parents. About half of the students indicated getting support from teachers, but only 30% of all students indicated feeling that teachers cared about them.
  • 15. Summary of Findings Students indicated feeling that school rules were clear, but not necessarily family rules. In addition, it appeared that punishment for breaking family rules was not consistent. An inverse relationship between the clarity of family rules and involvement in risk behavior such as alcohol or drug use was found. Students indicated knowing how to set limits, but they also indicated acting without thinking. There is the potential for impulsive behavior to override self-regulatory behavior. By 10th grade over 25% of the students indicated cheating on a test two or more times in the past year. About two-thirds of 10th and 12th graders indicated copying homework two or more times in the past year.
  • 16. Implications of Findings The significant use of alcohol among students, especially among athletes, suggests that a concerted effort may be needed to address the risk associated with alcohol use among these students. The results indicate that some of the underlying factors may be related to social norms. The evidence that some students are riding in cars in which the driver is drunk suggests the need for increased efforts to prevent driving while drunk. There were clear, positive relationships between the Developmental Assets and lower involvement in risk behaviors. While many students have high scores for the assets, exploring measures that may strengthen the assets for at-risk students should be considered.
  • 17. Implications of Findings Cheating in school has become a national problem, and the survey’s results indicate the problem is also present in these students. It may be useful to explore approaches to reduce cheating. There was an identified relationship between thrill seeking and impulse control, and high-risk behavior. Developing programs that focus not only on resistance, but impulse control, may be worthwhile. Targeting higher risk students, such as those with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, may be of value. The results of the survey, in an appropriate format, should be made available not only to adults in the community, but also the students. Sharing the results is empowering, and an opportunity to open discussion about the issues examined in the survey.