Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting

  • 225 views
Uploaded on

 

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads

Views

Total Views
225
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0

Actions

Shares
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0

Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
    No notes for slide

Transcript

  •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
  • 2. IURPWKHLUSURSHUWLQRUGHUWRSXULIDQGVDQFWLIWKHP>DW7DXEDK@7KDWLVZKWKLVNLQGRIVDGDTDKLVFDOOHG]DNDKIRUESDLQJLWRQHLVDVSLULQJWRDWWDLQEOHVVLQJ SXULILFDWLRQDQGWKHFXOWLYDWLRQRIJRRGGHHGV7DNLQJ LQWR DFFRXQW LWV YHU QDWXUH LW LV QR ZRQGHU WKDW ]DNDK FRQVWLWXWHV RQH RI WKH ILYH SLOODUV RI,VODP ,W LV DVVRFLDWHG ZLWK SUDHU VDODK
  • 3.  LQ HLJKWWZR 4XUDQLF YHUVHV $OODK WKH ([DOWHG 2QHSUHVFULEHG LW LQ +LV %RRN 7KH 4XUDQ
  • 4.  +LV 0HVVHQJHU FRUURERUDWHG LW E KLV VXQQDK
  • 5.  DQG WKHFRPPXQLW XPPDK
  • 6. EFRQVHQVXVXSKHOGLW,EQ$EEDVUHSRUWHGWKDWZKHQWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVHQW0XD]KLEQ-DEDOWR<HPHQ DVLWVJRYHUQRU
  • 7. KHVDLGWRKLP<RXDUHJRLQJWRDSHRSOHZKRDUH3HRSOHRIWKH6FULSWXUH,QYLWHWKHPWRDFFHSWWKHVKDKDGDKWKDWWKHUHLVQRJRGEXW$OODKDQG, DP +LV 0HVVHQJHU ,I WKH DFFHSW DQG DIILUP WKLV WHOO WKHP WKDW $OODK WKH *ORULRXV 2QH KDVHQMRLQHGILYHSUDHUVXSRQWKHPGXULQJWKHGDDQGQLJKW,IWKHDFFHSWWKDWWHOOWKHPDOVRWKDW+HKDVHQMRLQHGVDGDTDKXSRQWKHLUDVVHWVZKLFKZLOOEHWDNHQIURPWKHULFKRIWKH 0XVOLP
  •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
  • 9. ,QWKLVDDKSXULIPHDQVWRSXULIWKHPIURPVWLQJLQHVVJUHHGDQGPHDQQHVVDQGDODFNRIUHPRUVHWRZDUGWKHSRRUDQGWKHZUHWFKHG7RVDQFWLIWKHPLVWRUDLVHWKHPLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 11. DQGDVNRXWRPHPRUL]HPZRUGV6DGDTDKWDNHQIURPDSURSHUWQHYHUGHFUHDVHVLWDPDQZKRVXIIHUVLQMXVWLFHDQGLVSDWLHQWZLWKLW$OODKZLOOJUDQWKLPVWUHQJWKDPDQZKRVWDUWVEHJJLQJ$OODKZLOOFDXVHKLPWREHSRRU$KPDGDQGDW7LUPL]KLUHODWH DQGWKHODWWHUJUDGHGLWVDKLK
  • 12. IURP$EX+XUDLUDKWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG$OODKUHFHLYHVFKDULWE+LVULJKWKDQGDQGWKHQ+HFDXVHVLWWRJURZ IRU HDFK RI RX -XVW DV RX UDLVH D KRUVH FROW IRDO RU RXQJ ZHDQHG FDPHO VR WKDW PRUVHOEHFRPHVDVODUJHDVWKH0RXQWRI8KXG2I WKLV KDGLWKV FRQWHQW :DNL VDV 7KLV LV VDQFWLRQHG EWKH 4XUDQ R WKH QRW NQRZ WKDW LW LV$OODK DORQH ZKR FDQ DFFHSW WKH UHSHQWDQFH RI +LV VHUYDQWV DQGLVWKH WUXH
  •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
  • 14. DQG]DNDKDQG,ZLOOJLYHDGYLFHWRHYHU0XVOLPLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 16. +HZLOOODIODWRQDVDQGVRIWSODLQDQGWKHZLOOUXQRYHU KLP KHDYLO RQH DIWHU DQRWKHU XQWLO $OODK SURQRXQFHV MXGJPHQW RQ +LV VHUYDQWV GXULQJ D GDODVWLQJ ILIW WKRXVDQGV HDUV >7KH LQGLYLGXDO LQ TXHVWLRQ@ ZLOO WKHQ EH VKRZQ KLV SDWK OHDGLQJ KLPHLWKHUWR3DUDGLVHRUWR+HOO(TXDOOQRRZQHURIJRDWVZKRGRHVQRWSD]DNDK ZLOOEHVSDUHG
  •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
  •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
  • 19. WKHZLOOEHRYHUFRPHESRYHUWWKHLUSURYLVLRQVZLOOGHFUHDVHDQGWKHLUUXOHUZLOOEHXQMXVW,IWKHUHIUDLQIURPSDLQJWKH]DNDKGXHRQWKHLUSURSHUWLHVWKHZLOOEHGHSULYHGRIUDLQXQOHVVWKHJHWLWRQOIRUWKHVDNHRIWKHLULVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 20. FDWWOH ,I WKH UHQRXQFH WKHLU FRPPLWPHQW WR $OODK DQG +LV 0HVVHQJHU WKH ZLOO EH JRYHUQHG E DQHQHPZKRLVDVWUDQJHUWRWKHPDQGZKRZLOOWDNHDZDVRPHRIZKDWWKHSRVVHVV,IWKHLUUXOHUVGRQRWUXOHDFFRUGLQJWR$OODKV%RRNWKHZLOOEHDIIOLFWHG EFLYLOZDU$OODKIRUELGWKDWWKHVHVKRXOGKDSSHQWRRX$O%XNKDUL DQG 0XVOLP UHODWH IURP DO$KQDI LEQ 4DVWKDWKHVDLG,ZDVLQWKHFRPSDQRIVRPHPHQRI4XUDLVKZKHQDPDQ $EX=KDUUDO*KDIDULDFRPSDQLRQRIWKH3URSKHW
  • 21. FDPHZLWKFRDUVHKDLUFORWKHVDQGDSSHDUDQFH+HVWRRGXSJUHHWHGWKHPDQGVDLG,QIRUPWKRVHZKRKRDUGSURSHUWWKDWDVWRQHZLOOEHKHDWHGLQWKH)LUHVRI+HOODQGWKHQSODFHGRQWKHQLSSOHVRIWKHLUEUHDVWVXQWLOLWFRPHVRXWIURPWKHWRSRIWKHLUVKRXOGHUV,WZLOOWKHQEHSODFHGRQWKHWRSRIWKHLUVKRXOGHUVXQWLOLWFRPHVRXWDJDLQIURPWKHQLSSOHRIWKHLUEUHDVWVDQGWKHZLOOEHVKDNHQ7KHQKHOHIW,IROORZHGKLPDQGVDWQHDUKLPQRWNQRZLQJZKRKHZDV,VDLG7KHVHSHRSOHGLVOLNHGZKDWRXVDLGWRWKHP+HREVHUYHG7KHGRQRWXQGHUVWDQGDQWKLQJWKDWPIULHQGVDLGWRPH,DVNHG:KRLVRXUIULHQG"+H UHSOLHG 7KH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH >2QH GD KH DVNHG PH@ R RX VHH WKH 0RXQW RI8KXG" , ORRNHG DW WKH VXQ WR VHH KRZ PXFK RI WKH GDZDVOHIWDV,WKRXJKWWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHZDQWHGWRVHQGPHRQDQHUUDQGIRUKLP,VDLG<HV8SRQWKLVKHVDLG1RWKLQJZRXOGGHOLJKWPHPRUHWKDQKDYLQJJROGHTXDOWRWKHEXONRI8KXGDQGVSHQGLQJDOORILW LQ$OODKVZD
  •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
  • 23. WKHUXOHUFRXOGWDNHKDOI RI WKH GHIDXOWHUV PRQH LQ DGGLWLRQ WR WKH FDOFXODWHG DPRXQW RI ]DNDK DV D SXQLVKPHQW 7KLVYLHZLVEDVHGRQZKDW$KPDGDQ1DVDL$EXDZXGDO+DNLPDQGDO%DLKDTLKDYHUHFRUGHGIURP%DK]LEQ+DNLPDOOWKHZDEDFNWRKLVJUDQGIDWKHUZKRVDLG,KHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVD:KHWKHUWKHFDPHOVRIWKH]DNDKSDHUDUH JURZQRUEDEFDPHOVLWPDNHVQRGLIIHUHQFHLQKLVUHZDUGLIKHJDYHWKHPZLOOLQJO +RZHYHU
  • 24. LIVRPHRQHUHIUDLQVIURPSDLQJLWLWZLOOEHWDNHQIURPKLPDORQJZLWKKDOIKLVSURSHUWIRULWLVDULJKWRIRXU/RUGWKH%OHVVHGDQGWKH([DOWHGQRWDULJKWRIWKHKRXVHRI0XKDPPDG$VNHG DERXW LWV FKDLQ $KPDG UXOHG LW JRRG KDVVDQ
  •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
  • 26. WKDWWKHXVHGWRSDDWWKHWLPHRI$OODKV0HVVHQJHULVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 28. WKHHDUFRXQW KDZO
  • 29. VWDUWVIURPWKHGDRIWKHQLVDEFRPSOHWLRQ&RPPHQWLQJ RQ WKH LVVXH DQ1DZDZL VDLG ,Q RXU YLHZ DQG WKH YLHZV RI 0DOLN $KPDG DQG WKHPDMRULWRIVFKRODUVWKHDPRXQWRISURSHUWOLDEOHIRUSDPHQWRI]DNDKVXFKDVJROGVLOYHURUFDWWOHLVWLHGWRWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIQLVDEWKURXJKWKH WXUQRIDZKROHHDU,IWKHQLVDEGHFUHDVHVLQDQWLPHRIWKHHDU>WKHFRXQWLQJRI@WKHHDUGLVFRQWLQXHV/DWHULIWKHQLVDELVFRPSOHWHGWKHHDUFRXQWLVUHVXPHGIURPWKHWLPHRILWVFRPSOHWLRQ2Q WKH VDPH VXEMHFW $EX +DQLIDK KROGV :KDW PDWWHUV LVWKH DYDLODELOLW RI QLVDE DW WKH EHJLQQLQJDQGHQGRIWKHHDU,WVGHFUHDVHDWDQWLPHLQEHWZHHQGRHVQRWPDWWHUHYHQWKRXJKWKH]DNDKSDHUKDGWZRKXQGUHGGLUKDPVDQGKHORVWDOOEXWRQHGLUKDPGXULQJWKHHDURULIKHKDGIRUWVKHHSDOORIZKLFKGLHGH[FHSWIRURQHGXULQJWKHHDU,IDWWKHHQGRIWKHHDUKHKDGWZRKXQGUHGGLUKDPVRUIRUW VKHHS WKHQ KH PXVW SD ]DNDK RQ DOO RI WKDW 7KLV FRQGLWLRQ LV QRW DSSOLFDEOH WR WKH ]DNDK RISODQWDWLRQVDQGIUXLWVIRUWKHLU]DNDKVKRXOGEHSDLGRQWKHKDUYHVWGD$OODKWKH([DOWHG2QHVDV$QGSDWKHGXHWKHUHRIXSRQWKHKDUYHVWGD>DO$UDI@$O$EGDULHODERUDWHGWKDW7KHKROGLQJVVXEMHFWWR]DNDKDUHRIWZRNLQGV7KHILUVWNLQGJURZVELWVHOIFURSVDQGIUXLWV7KHVHFRQGNLQGLVXVHGIRUJURZLQJDQGSURGXFWLRQPRQHPHUFKDQGLVHDQGFDWWOH,QWKHIRUPHUFDVH]DNDKVKRXOGEHSDLGDWWKHWLPHRIKDUYHVW,QWKHODWWHUFDVHLWVKRXOGEHSDLGDWWKHHQGRIWKHKDXO7KLVZDVWKHRSLQLRQRIDOOMXULVWVDVUHSRUWHGLQDQ1DZDZLVDO0DMUQX)LTK=DNDKRQWKH+ROGLQJVRI,QIDQWVDQG0HQWDOO5HWDUGHG3HRSOH7KH JXDUGLDQ RI D FKLOG RU RI D PHQWDOO UHWDUGHG SHUVRQ PXVW SD ]DNDK RQ KLV EHKDOI IURP KLVSURSHUWLILWFRQVWLWXWHVDQLVDE$PULEQ6KXDLEUHSRUWHGIURPKLVIDWKHUEDFNHGXSEDFKDLQRIVRXUFHVJRLQJEDFNWR$EGXOODKLEQ$PUWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG2QHZKREHFRPHVWKHJXDUGLDQRIDQRUSKDQZLWKSURSHUWPXVWWUDGHRQKLVEHKDOIDQGQRWOHDYHLWSDVVLYHLQRUGHUWRDYRLGGHSOHWLRQRIWKHSURSHUWEVDGDTDK+RZHYHU WKLV KDGLWK KDV D ZHDN OLQN 6WLOO DO+DIL] DIILUPV WKDW 7KHUH LV D VLPLODU KDGLWK RI WKHPXUVDOWSHLQWKHFRPSLODWLRQRIDVK6KDILZKRFRQILUPHGWKDWLWLVFRQVLGHUHGDVRXQGRQH$LVKDKXVHGWRVHWDVLGH]DNDKIRUWKHRUSKDQVZKRZHUHXQGHUKHUSURWHFWLRQ$W7LUPL]KL FRQFOXGHV WKDW -XULVWV GLIIHU RQ WKLV LVVXH 0RUH WKDQ RQH FRPSDQLRQ RI WKH 3URSKHWXSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG WKDW ]DNDK PD EH WDNHQ IURP DQ RUSKDQV SURSHUW $PRQJ WKHVH DUH8PDU $OL $LVKDK DQG ,EQ 8PDU 7KLV YLHZ LV DOVR VXSSRUWHG E 0DOLN DVK6KDIL $KPDG DQG,VKDT$QRWKHUJURXSLQFOXGLQJ6XIDQDQG,EQDO0XEDUDNKROGWKDW=DNDKVKRXOGQRWEHWDNHQRXWRIDQRUSKDQVSURSHUW)LTKD7KH,QVROYHQWHEWRU:KRHYHUKDVSURSHUWPXVWSDLWVSURSHU]DNDK,IWKHSURSHUWLVLQGHEWHGKHPDILUVWSDRIIKLVGHEWWKHQLQFDVHWKHUHPDLQGHULVHQRXJKWRFRQVWLWXWHDQLVDEKHPXVWSD]DNDK,IKHGRHVQRWKROGWKHQLVDEKHGRHVQRWKDYHWRSDLWVLQFHKHLVSRRU 7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG2QOWKHZHDOWKDUHUHTXLUHGWRJLYHFKDULW7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDQGDO%XNKDUL7KHODWWHUUHFRUGVLWLQPXDOODTIRUP7KH3URSKHWDOVRVDLG=DNDKLVOHYLHGRQWKHULFKDQGSDLGWRWKH SRRU ,W LV DOO WKH VDPH ZKHWKHU KH LV LQGHEWHG WR $OODK RU WR PDQ EHFDXVH RQH KDGLWK VWDWHV$OODKVGHEWLVPRUHGHVHUYLQJRIIXOILOOPHQW)LTK=DNDK2ZHGEDHFHDVHG3HUVRQLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 34.  GRHV QRW DJUHH WKDW LW VKRXOG EH SDLG EHIRUH LWV WLPH 2Q WKH RWKHU KDQG WKH JURXSZKLFK YLHZV LW DV VLPLODU WR WKH FDVH RI GHIHUUHG REOLJDWRU GXHV DSSURYHV LWV YROXQWDU SDPHQW LQDGYDQFH,QVXSSRUWRIKLVYLHZDVK6KDILUHODWHVDKDGLWKIURP$OLWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDVNHGIRUDO$EEDVVDGDTDKEHIRUHLWVGXHGDWHLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 36. FRLQVLIWKHDWWDLQDQLVDE$OLUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG,H[HPSWRXIURPSDLQJ]DNDKRQKRUVHVDQGVODYHV3DWKHQ]DNDKRQVLOYHURQHGLUKDPIRUHDFKIRUWGLUKDPV=DNDKLVQRWGXHRQQLQHWRURQHKXQGUHGGLUKDPVRIVLOYHU,ILWUHDFKHVWZRKXQGUHGGLUKDPVILYHGLUKDPVDUHWREHSDLG7KLVZDVUHODWHGEWKHDXWKRUVRIDV6XQQDQ 7KH7UDGLWLRQV
  • 37. $W7LUPL]KLUHODWHV,DVNHGDO%XNKDULLIKH FRQILUPV WKLV KDGLWK +H VDLG ,W LV DXWKHQWLF  $W7LUPL]KL DOVR VDV -XULVWV UHFRJQL]H WKDWVDGDTDKVKRXOGEHWDNHQRXWRIDQDPRXQWOHVVWKDQILYHRXQFHV DZDT
  • 38. 2QHRXQFH XTLDK
  • 39. HTXDOVIRUW GLUKDPV )LYH DZDT HTXDO  GLUKDPV 7ZR KXQGUHG GLUKDPV HTXDO WZHQWVHYHQ ULDOV HTXDO(JSWLDQSLDVWHUV)LTKD&RPELQLQJ*ROGDQG6LOYHU,I D SHUVRQ RZQV JROG DQG VLOYHU EXW QHLWKHU RI WKHP RQ LWV RZQ FRQVWLWXWHV D QLVDE KH VKRXOG QRWFRPELQHWKHWZRLQRUGHUWRREWDLQDQLVDE7KLVLVEHFDXVHWKHDUHQRWRIWKHVDPHNLQG7KHEDVLFLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 43.  VKH VKRXOG SD]DNDKRQORQWKHUHFHLYHGKDOI+RZHYHULIDOORIWKHGRZULVFDQFHOOHGEHIRUHVKHUHFHLYHVLW LQWKHFDVHRIQXOOLILQJWKHPDUULDJHRQKHUEHKDOI
  •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
  •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
  • 46. 7KHUHIRUHLWLVQRWUHDVRQDEOHWRH[HPSWEXVLQHVVPHQIURPWKHLUVRFLHWDOREOLJDWLRQVZKHQWKHSRVVHVVPRVWRIWKHQDWLRQVZHDOWK)LTK:KHQ*RRGVFDQEH-XGJHGDV7UDGLQJ*RRGV7KH DXWKRU RI DO0XJKP VWDWHV WKDW 0HUFKDQGLVH FDQ RQO EH FRQVLGHUHG DV WUDGLQJ JRRGV IRU WZRUHDVRQV 7KH DFWXDO SRVVHVVLRQ RI PHUFKDQGLVH LV DFTXLUHG E DQ DFW VXFK DV D FRPPHUFLDO WUDQVDFWLRQPDUULDJHGLYRUFHGHPDQGHGEWKHZLIH NKXO
  • 47. DFFHSWDQFHRIDJLIWEHTXHVWERRWDQGRWKHUODZIXODFTXLVLWLRQ7KLVLVEHFDXVHWKDWZKLFKLVQRWVXEMHFWWR]DNDKFDQQRWEHFRQVLGHUHGDVVRVXEVHTXHQWWRLWVSRVVHVVLRQRQWKHEDVLVRIQLDK LQWHQWLRQ
  • 48. RQODVIRUH[DPSOHLQWKHFDVHRIIDVWLQJ,WGRHVQRWPDNHDQGLIIHUHQFHZKHWKHUDSHUVRQFDPHWRSRVVHVVVXFKLWHPVEEXLQJWKHPRUQRWEHFDXVHKLVSRVVHVVLRQLVEDQDFWVLPLODUWRLQKHULWDQFH 7KH JRRGV DUH LQWHQGHG DW WKH WLPH RI SRVVHVVLRQ IRU WUDGH 7KHVH DUH FRQVLGHUHG DV QRQWUDGHJRRGVHYHQWKRXJKWKHSHUVRQLQWHQGVWRXVHWKHPODWHUIRUWUDGH+RZHYHU LI KH SRVVHVVHV WKHVH JRRGV WKURXJK LQKHULWDQFH DQG LQWHQGV WKHP IRU WUDGH WKH DUH QRWFRQVLGHUHGDVWUDGHJRRGVEHFDXVHWKHGHWHUPLQLQJIDFWRULQVXFKFDVHVLVWKHVWDWXVRIDFTXLVLWLRQQRWWKH WHPSRUDU VWDWH RI WUDGH 0HUH LQWHQWLRQ ZLOO QRW SURYLGHDYDOLGUHDVRQWRFKDQJHLWVVWDWXV)RUH[DPSOH LI D SHUVRQ LQWHQGV WR WUDYHO ZLWKRXW HPEDUNLQJ XSRQ LW WKHQ WKH PHUH H[SUHVVLRQ RI KLVLQWHQWLRQ ZLOO QRW FRQVWLWXWH WKH DFW RI WUDYHOLQJ /LNHZLVH LI D SHUVRQ ERXJKW PHUFKDQGLVH IRU WUDGHDQGWKHQLQWHQGHGLWIRUSRVVHVVLRQLWZRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGDVVXFKDQG]DNDKZLOOQRWEHSDLGRQLW)LTK+RZLV=DNDKRQ7UDGH0RQHWREH3DLG2QHZKRSRVVHVVHVPHUFKDQGLVHZLWKDQLVDEIRUDHDUVKRXOGSD]DNDKRQLWWKHDPRXQWRIZKLFKLVD TXDUWHU RI D WHQWK RI LWV YDOXH 7KLV VKRXOG EH GRQH E D EXVLQHVVPDQ HYHU HDU +RZHYHU WKHSHULRGRIDHDUGRHVQRWFRPHLQWRHIIHFWXQOHVVKLVLQYHQWRUFRQVWLWXWHVDQLVDE$VVXPLQJ D EXVLQHVVPDQ SRVVHVVHV PHUFKDQGLVH VKRUW RI D QLVDE DQG SDUW RI D HDU KDV SDVVHG KLVLQYHQWRUVXEVHTXHQWOLQFUHDVHVWKURXJKDQXQXVXDOULVHLQYDOXH EHFDXVHRIVXSSODQGGHPDQGRUWKURXJKSULFHIOXFWXDWLRQ
  • 49. VRWKDWLWFRQVWLWXWHVDQLVDERUKHVROGPHUFKDQGLVHIRUWKHSULFHRIDQLVDERU GXULQJ WKH FRXUVH RI WKH HDU KH FRPHV WR SRVVHVV RWKHU PHUFKDQGLVH ZKLFK WRJHWKHU ZLWK KLVSUHYLRXVDPRXQWFRPSOHWHVDQLVDEWKHQWKHKDZO IRUWKHSXUSRVHRI]DNDK
  • 50. VWDUWVDWWKDWWLPHDQGWKH WLPH HODSVHG LV QRW WDNHQ LQWR FRQVLGHUDWLRQ 7KLV LV WKH YLHZ RI WKH +DQDILDK DWK7KDXULDVK6KDIL,VKDT$EX8EDLG$EX7KDXUDQG,EQDO0XQ]KLU$FFRUGLQJWR$EX+DQLIDKLIWKHPHUFKDQGLVHLQSRVVHVVLRQFRQVWLWXWHVDQLVDEDWWKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHHDU DQG DOVR DW WKH HQG ]DNDK ZLOO VWLOO EH DSSOLFDEOH HYHQ WKRXJK WKH QLVDE PLJKW KDYH GHFUHDVHGZLWKLQ WKDW WLPH 7KH UHDVRQ LV WKDW LW LV GLIILFXOW WR DVFHUWDLQ LWV FRPSOHWHQHVV LQ WKH LQWHUYHQLQJSHULRGLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 51. 7KH +DQEDOLDK KROG WKDW LI WKH PHUFKDQGLVH GHFUHDVHV GXULQJ WKH FRXUVH RI WKH HDU DQG LQFUHDVHVDJDLQ XQWLO LW FRQVWLWXWHV D QLVDE WKH UHTXLVLWH
  • 52.  SHULRG RI D HDU VWDUWV DOO RYHU DJDLQ EHFDXVH LW KDVEHHQLQWHUUXSWHGLQLWVFRXUVHEWKHGHFUHDVH)LTK=DNDKRQSODQWVDQGIUXLW$OODKKDVPDGH]DNDKREOLJDWRURQSODQWVDQGIUXLWIRU+HVDV2RXZKREHOLHYH6SHQGRIWKHJRRG WKLQJV ZKLFK RX KDYH HDUQHG DQG RI WKDW ZKLFK :H EULQJ IRUWK IURP WKH HDUWK >DO%DTDUDK@ =DNDK LV FDOOHG H[SHQGLWXUH QDIDTDK
  • 53.  *LYLQJ WKH MXVWLILFDWLRQ IRU SDLQJ ]DNDK RQ SURGXFH$OODKVDV+HLWLVZKRSURGXFHVJDUGHQVWUHOOLVHGDQGXQWUHOOLVHGDQGWKHGDWHSDOPDQGWKHFURSVRIGLYHUVH IODYRUV DQG WKH ROLYH DQG WKH SRPHJUDQDWH OLNH DQG XQOLNH (DW RI WKHIUXLWWKHUHRIZKHQLWSURGXFHV IUXLW DQG SD LWV GXH XSRQ WKH KDUYHVWGD>DO$QDP@,QKLVH[SODQDWLRQRIWKHZRUGKDTT GXH
  • 54. LQWKHSUHFHGLQJDDK,EQ$EEDVVDVWKDWEKDTTLVPHDQWERWKWKHREOLJDWRU]DNDKDQGWKHXVKU WLWKH
  • 55. DQGWKHKDOIWLWKH)LTKD=DNDKRQ3ODQWVDQG)UXLWVDWWKH7LPHRIWKH3URSKHWXULQJWKHWLPHRIWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH]DNDKZDVOHYLHGRQZKHDWEDUOHGDWHVDQGUDLVLQV$EX %XUGDK UHODWHG IURP $EX 0XVD DQG 0XD]K WKDW ZKHQ WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH VHQW WKH ODWWHU WZR
  • 56.  WR <HPHQ WR WHDFK LWV LQKDELWDQWV ,VODP KH FRPPDQGHG WKHP WR OHYVDGDTDKRQORQZKHDWEDUOHGDWHVDQGUDLVLQV7KLVKDGLWKLVUHODWHGEDGDUDTXWQLDO+DNLPDW7DEDUDQLDQGDO%DLKDTL&RPPHQWLQJRQWKHVWDWXVRIWKHUHSRUWDO%DLKDTLVDVWKDWLWVFKDLQLVPXWWDVLO XQLQWHUUXSWHG
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 60. E FDSDFLW 7KH RQO H[FHSWLRQV ZHUH JUDSHV DQG IUHVK GDWHV 2Q WKH ODWWHU WZR NLQGV ]DNDK ZDVOHYLHGDVDZKROHZLWKRXWGLIIHUHQWLDWLRQZKHWKHURUQRWWKHZHUHGU)LTK7KH2SLQLRQRI-XULVWV7KHUH LV QR GLIIHUHQFH RI RSLQLRQ DPRQJ MXULVWV FRQFHUQLQJ WKH REOLJDWRU QDWXUH RI ]DNDK RQ SODQWVDQGIUXLWV7KHGRKRZHYHUGLIIHURQWKHNLQGVRISODQWVDQGIUXLWVZKLFKVKRXOGEHVXEMHFWWR]DNDK+HUHLVWKHEURDGVSHFWUXPRIRSLQLRQVRQWKHVXEMHFW$O+DVDQ DO%DVUL DQG DVK6KXDEL KROG WKDW ]DNDK LV RQO RQ WKH VSHFLILHG LWHPV LQ WKH 4XUDQ DQGVXQQDK
  •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
  • 62. $EX<XVXIDQG0XKDPPDGKROGWKDW]DNDKLVSDDEOHRQHYHUSURGXFWRIWKHODQGSURYLGHGLWODVWVWKHZKROHHDUZLWKRXWWRRPXFKFDUHRUWUHDWPHQW7KLVLQFOXGHVSURGXFHPHDVXUHGEFDSDFLWVXFKDVJUDLQVRUEPDVVVXFKDVFRWWRQDQGVXJDU,IWKHSURGXFHGRHVQRWODVWDZKROHHDUVXFKDVWKHWZRNLQGVRIFXFXPEHU TXWKWKDDQGNKLDU
  • 63. ZDWHUPHORQVDQGRWKHUVRIWKHLUNLQGWKHUHLVQR]DNDKRQWKHP0DOLN KROGV WKDW ]DNDK LV SDDEOH RQ WKDW ZKLFK LV SURGXFHG RQ WKH ODQG DQG ZKLFK VWDV EHFRPHVGUDQGLVSODQWHGEKXPDQEHLQJV7KLVLQFOXGHVODQGSURGXFHXVHGDVQRQSHULVKDEOHIRRG PXTWDW
  •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
  • 65. RUVSLFHVDQGKHUEV DKDUL]
  • 66. VXFKDVFRULDQGHUFDUDZDVHHGV RUVHHGVVXFKDVOLQVHHGRIWKHIOX]SODQW NLWWDQVHHGV
  • 67. WKHVHHGVRIWKHWZRNLQGVRIFXFXPEHU TXWKWKDDQGNKLDU
  • 68. RUVDIIORZHUDQGVHVDPHVHHGV$FFRUGLQJWR$KPDG]DNDKLVDOVRSDDEOHRQGUIUXLWVVXFKDVGDWHVUDLVLQVDSULFRWVILJVDOPRQGVKD]HOQXWVDQGSLVWDFKLRQXWVLIWKHSUHFHGLQJVSHFLILFDWLRQVDSSOWRWKHP7KHUHLVQR]DNDKRQIUHVKIUXLW VXFK DV SHDFKHV SHDUV DSSOHV DSULFRWV DQG ILJV ,Q WKH VDPH ZD LW LV QRW GXH RQ YHJHWDEOHVVXFKDVWKHWZRNLQGVRIFXFXPEHUZDWHUPHORQVHJJSODQWVWXUQLSVDQGFDUURWV)LTK=DNDKRQ2OLYHV$Q1DZDZLVDV$VIRUROLYHVRXU>6KDILDK@YLHZLVWKDWWKHUHLVQR]DNDKRQWKHP7KLVLVDOVRWKHRSLQLRQRI+DVDQLEQ6DOLK,EQ$EX/DODDQG$EX8EDLG6FKRODUV VXFK DV DV=XKUL DO$X]DL DO/DWK 0DOLN DWK7KDXUL $EX +DQLIDK DQG $EX 7KDXUPDLQWDLQWKDWWKHUHLV]DNDKRQROLYHV$]=XKULDO/DWKDQGDO$X]DLKROGHWHUPLQHLWVTXDQWLWEFRQMHFWXUH XNKDUUDV
  • 69. DQGWKHQWDNHLWV]DNDKLQWKHIRUPRIROLYHRLOZKLOH0DOLNVDV7KHUHLV QR QHHG WR FRPSXWH LWV TXDQWLW E FRQMHFWXUH XNKDUUDV
  •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
  •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
  • 72. RQWKDWZKLFKLVOHVVWKDQILYHDZVXT,WLVDOVRQDUUDWHGE$KPDGDQGDO%DLKDTLZLWKDJRRGFKDLQ$EX 6DLG DO.KXGUL UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG 7KHUH LV QR VDGDTDK RQDQDPRXQWRIGDWHVRUJUDLQVOHVVWKDQILYHDZVXT$ZXVXTEFRQVHQVXVRIRSLQLRQLVVL[WVDDV DFXELF PHDVXUH RI YDULQJ PDJQLWXGH
  •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
  •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
  • 75. RQHRQZKLFKDWLWKHLVGXHDQG WKH RWKHU RQ ZKLFK RQO KDOI RI WKH WLWKH LV GXH +H WKHUHIRUH GLVWLQJXLVKHG EHWZHHQ WKH WZRFDWHJRULHV RQO LQ UHVSHFW WR WKH DPRXQW GXH 7KHUH LV QR PHQWLRQ RI DQ DPRXQW RI QLVDE LQ WKLVKDGLWK+RZHYHUKHPHQWLRQHGLWH[SOLFLWOLQDQRWKHUKDGLWKZKLFKFDQQRWEHLJQRUHGDVVRPHWKLQJLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 77. 7KXVDQLVDELVILIWNDODK NDODKLVDGUPHDVXUHRIZHLJKWLQ(JSWLWLVHTXDOWR /
  • 78.  $V WR WKH SURGXFH ZKLFK FDQQRW EH PHDVXUHG ,EQ 4XDGDPDK VDV 7KH QLVDE RI VDIIURQFRWWRQDQGVXFKLWHPVLVWREHZHLJKHGDW,UDTLSRXQGV UDWODQ,UDTLUDWOHTXDOVDSSUR[LPDWHOGLUKDPV
  •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
  •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
  • 81. $OORIWKHFRVWVLQYROYHGLQKDUYHVWLQJWUDQVSRUWDWLRQWKUHVKLQJFOHDQLQJVWRULQJDQGRWKHUVDUHWREHERUQHEWKHRZQHUIURPKLVSURSHUWDQGVKRXOGQRWEHDFFRXQWHGIRUDJDLQVWWKH]DNDKWREHSDLG,EQ $EEDV DQG ,EQ 8PDU KROG WKDW ZKDWHYHU LV ERUURZHG IRU WKH SXUSRVH RI WLOOLQJ SODQWLQJ DQGKDUYHVWLQJVKRXOGILUVWEHWDNHQRXW7KLV LV HYLGHQW IURP WKHLU IROORZLQJ VWDWHPHQWV UHSRUWHG E -DELU LEQ =DLG WKDW ,EQ $EEDV DQG ,EQ8PDU VDLG WKDW D PDQ ZKR ERUURZV LQ RUGHU WR VSHQG LW HLWKHURQFXOWLYDWLRQ RIKLVODQG
  • 82. RURQKLVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 83. IDPLOPXVWILUVWSDRIIKLVGHEWWKHQSD]DNDKRQ WKHUHVW,EQ$EEDVVDLG)LUVWKHPXVWSDRIIZKDW KH VSHQW RQ FXOWLYDWLRQ DQG WKHQ SD ]DNDK RQ WKH UHVW <DKD LEQ $GDP UHODWHG WKLV LQ DO.KDUDM,EQ +D]P UHODWHV IURP $WD WKDW DOO H[SHQVHV DUH WR EH GHGXFWHG ILUVW ,I ]DNDK LV DSSOLFDEOH WR WKHUHPDLQLQJDPRXQWRQOWKHQZLOOLWEHSDLG)LTK=DNDKRQ.KDUDMLDK/DQG/DQGVXEMHFWWRWD[LVGLYLGHGLQWRWZRFDWHJRUHV XVKULDK ODQG WLWKH ODQG
  • 84.  ODQG RZQHG E SHRSOH ZKR DFFHSWHG ,VODP ZLOOLQJO RU ZKR ZHUHFRQTXHUHGEIRUFHDQGKDGWKHLUODQGGLYLGHGDPRQJWKHFRQTXHURUVRUODQGUHYLYHGDQGFXOWLYDWHGE0XVOLPVDQG NKDUDMLDK ODQG WD[DEOH ODQG
  •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
  • 86.  ERWK ]DNDK DQG NKDUDM DUH D NLQG RI REOLJDWLRQV KDJT
  • 87.  HDFKEDVHGRQDGLIIHUHQWUHDVRQDQGRQHGRHVQRWQXOOLIWKHRWKHU,WLVVLPLODUWRWKHFDVHZKHQDSHUVRQZKRLVLQWKHVWDWHRILKUDPNLOOVSULYDWHORZQHGJDPH IRUHDWLQJ
  • 88. 6LQFHWKHWLWKHLVSDDEOHEWKHIRUFHRIWKHWH[WLWFDQQRWEHQHJDWHGENKDUDMZKLFKEHFRPHVSDDEOHEWKHIRUFHRILMWLKDG$EX+DQLIDK KROGV WKDW WKHUH LV QR WLWKH RQ NKDUDM ODQG .KDUDM KH VDV LV GXH RQO ZKHQ WKH ODQG LVFRQTXHUHG ZKHUHDV
  • 89. RQHRIWKHFRQGLWLRQVJRYHUQLQJWKHREOLJDWRUQDWXUHRIWKHWLWKHLVWKDWWKHODQGVKRXOGQRWEHNKDUDMLDK7KH9DOLGLWRI$EX+DQLIDKV9LHZ,PDP $EX +DQLIDK SURYLGHV WKH IROORZLQJ HYLGHQFH IRU KLV YLHZ $FFRUGLQJ WR ,EQ 0DVXG WKH3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG 1HLWKHU NKDUDM QRU WLWKH >XVKU@ DUH SDDEOH VLPXOWDQHRXVO RQWKHODQGRID0XVOLP7KHSUHFHGLQJKDGLWKLVEFRQVHQVXVKHOGWREHZHDN GDLI
  • 90. <DKDLEQ$QEDVDKUHSRUWHGLWRQWKHDXWKRULW RI $EX +DQLIDK IURP +DPPDG IURP ,EUDKLP DQ1DNKDL IURP $OTDPDK IURP ,EQ 0DVXGIURPWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH$O%DLKDTLSUREHVLWVFKDLQDQGVDVLQDO0DULIDKDV6XQDQZDDO$WKDU7KHSUHFHGLQJKDGLWKLVQDUUDWHGE$EX+DQLIDKIURP+DPPDGIURP,EUDKLPRQKLVRZQDXWKRULW7KXV<DKDUHSRUWHGLQVXVSHQGHG PDUIX
  •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
  • 92. $Q1DZDZL VDV ,I WKLV KDGLWK PHDQV ZKDW WKH >WKH +DQDILDK@ FODLP WKHQ LW PHDQV WKDW ]DNDKFRXOGQRWEHHQMRLQHGRQGLUKDPVGLQDUVDQGPHUFKDQGLVH,IWKLVLVVRWKHQQRERGVXEVFULEHVWRLW,W ZDV UHSRUWHG WKDW ZKHQ WKH GDKTDQ JUDQGHH
  •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
  • 94. GLGQRWSRVVHVVDQWKLQJZKLFKUHTXLUHGWKHOHYRIDWLWKHRQLW,W LV VDLG WKDW WKH SUDFWLFH RI WKH UXOHUV DQG LPDPV ZDV QRW WR FRPELQH WKH XVKU DQG NKDUDM ,EQ DO0XQ]KLUGLVDSSURYHVRIVXFKDSUDFWLFHEHFDXVH8PDULEQ$EGXOD]L]GLGFRPELQHWKHWZR,WLVDOVRVDLGWKDWNKDUDMLVWKHRSSRVLWHRIXVKU7KLVPHDQVWKDWNKDUDMLVDFRQVHTXHQFHRIFRQTXHVWZKHUHDVXVKULVDQDFWRIZRUVKLS7KHUHIRUHWKHWZR FDQQRWEHFRPELQHG DWRQHWLPH
  • 95. DQGREWDLQHGVLPXOWDQHRXVOIURPWKHVDPHSHUVRQ7KLVKHOGWUXHLQWKHEHJLQQLQJ ZKHQODQGVZHUHFRQTXHUHG
  • 96. EXW LW LV QRW WHQDEOH LQ WKH ORQJ UXQ 1HYHUWKHOHVV QRW DOO IRUPV RI NKDUDM DUH EDVHG RQ IRUFH DQGFRQTXHVW VLQFH VRPH RI LWV IRUPV DUH LQVWLWXWHG ZLWKRXW IRUFH DV IRU H[DPSOH LQ WKH FDVH RI ODQGVDGMRLQLQJDNKDUDMODQGRULQWKHFDVHRIDFTXLUHGDQGUHYLYHGODQGZDWHUHGZLWKVWUHDPV,WLVDOVRVDLGWKDWWKHUHDVRQEHKLQGWKHLPSRVLWLRQRINKDUDMDQGXVKULVRQHWKDWLVDQDFWXDOORUSRWHQWLDOO LHOGLQJ ODQG 7KLV FDQ EH H[SODLQHG E UHFDOOLQJ WKDW LI LW LV PDUVK ODQG RI QR EHQHILW VDENKDK
  • 97.  WKHUH LV QR NKDUDM RU XVKU RQ LW 7KDW LV RQH FDXVH FDQQRWGHPDQGWZRGXHVRIWKHVDPHNLQG 7KLV LV VLPLODU WR WKH FDVH RI DQ LQGLYLGXDO ZKR IRU D HDU SRVVHVVHV IUHHJUD]LQJ FDPHOV VDLPDK
  • 98. LQWHQGHGIRUVDOHIRUVXFKDSHUVRQLVQRWUHTXLUHGWRSDWZRNLQGVRI]DNDKWKDWLVRQHIRUSRVVHVVLRQDQGRQHIRUWUDGH7KLVLVQRWWKHFDVHEHFDXVHWKHXVKU WLWKH
  •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
  • 100. $EX+DQLIDKKROGVWKDWWKHHVVHQFHRIREOLJDWLRQUHVWVZLWKWKHODQG,EQ4XGDPDKLQFOLQHVWRZDUGWKHPDMRULWVYLHZDQGVDV7KHREOLJDWLRQOLHVRQWKHSURGXFHDQGLVSDDEOHELWVRZQHUDVLQWKHFDVHRI]DNDKRQWKHYDOXH>RIDSURSHUW@LQWHQGHGIRUWUDGH$OVRLWLVVLPLODUWRWKHWLWKHSDDEOHRQWKHSURGXFHRIWKHODQGRZQHG7KHLU WKH+DQDILDK
  • 101. YLHZLVQRWDXWKHQWLFIRULI]DNDKZHUHWREHOHYLHGRQWKHYDOXHRIWKHODQGWKHQLWZRXOGKDYHEHHQREOLJDWRUHYHQLIWKHODQGZDVQRWFXOWLYDWHGDVLVWKHFDVHZLWKWKHODQGWD[DQGHYHQQRQ0XVOLUQVZRXOGQRWEHH[FOXGHGIURPLWVDSSOLFDWLRQ%HWKDWWKHFDVHNKDUDMZRXOGKDYHWREHHVWLPDWHGRQWKHODQGLWVHOIQRWRQWKHYDOXHRISURGXFHWKDWLVLWZRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHGSDUWRIWKHH[SHQGLWXUHRIIDQRWWKHH[SHQGLWXUHRI]DNDK)LTK7KH(VWLPDWLRQRI1LVDERQ3DOP7UHHVDQG*UDSHYLQHV7KURXJK.KDUV1RWE0HDVXUH .DO
  •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
  • 103. HVWLPDWH >KHU ]DNDK@ 7KHQ WKH0HVVHQJHUXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHHVWLPDWHGWHQDZVXTDQGWROGKHU>7KH DPRXQW RI ]DNDK@ KDV EHHQ FDOFXODWHG RQ RXU >RUFKDUGV@ SURGXFH  7KLV LV QDUUDWHG EDO%XNKDUL7KLV LV WKH SUDFWLFH RI WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH DQG KLV FRPSDQLRQV DQG WKHVFKRODUVREVHUYHGLW7KH+DQDILDKKDYHGLIIHUHQWYLHZVEHFDXVHWKHFRQVLGHUFRQMHFWXUHWREHXQFHUWDLQDQGWKHUHIRUHRI QR XVH LQ GHWHUPLQLQJ WKH DPRXQW RZHG 6WLOO WKH WUDGLWLRQ RI WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK LV D EHWWHUJXLGH D]KD
  • 104. EHFDXVHFRQMHFWXUHLVQRWJXHVVLQJLWLVDGLOLJHQWDWWHPSWWRHVWLPDWHWKHDPRXQWRIWKHSURGXFH ,W LV WKH VDPH DV HVWLPDWLQJ WKH DPRXQW RI WKH SURGXFH ORVW EHFDXVH RI LWV EHLQJ URWWHQ RUPRWKULGGHQ
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 111. IRUGRLQJVR7KXVLWZDVH[HPSWHG,EQDO0XQ]KLUDIILUPV7KHUHLVQRWUDGLWLRQ NKDEDU
  • 112. ZKLFKVWDWHVWKDW]DNDKPXVWEHSDLGRQKRQHQRULVWKHUHDFRQVHQVXV7KHUHIRUHWKHUHLVQR]DNDKRQKRQH7KLVLVWKHRSLQLRQRIPRVWVFKRODUV7KH+DQDILDKDQG$KPDGDUHRIWKHRSLQLRQWKDWKRQHLVVXEMHFWWR]DNDKHYHQWKRXJKWKHUHLVQRHYLGHQFH IRU WKLV YLHZ LQDQWUDGLWLRQH[FHSWIRUVRPHWUDGLWLRQV DWKDU
  • 113. ZKLFKVXSSRUWHDFKRWKHU7KHLUUHDVRQLVWKDWVLQFHLWLVSURGXFHGIURPEORVVRPVWUHHVDQGIORZHUVDQGZHLJKHGDQGVWRUHGOLNHRWKHU WSHV RI SURGXFH ]DNDK LV GXH RQ LW 7KH DOVR VD LW LV VXEMHFW WR ]DNDK EHFDXVH WKH FRVW RISURGXFLQJLWLVOHVVWKDQWKHFRVWRIJURZLQJIUXLWVDQGSODQWV$EX+DQLIDKPDGHLWDFRQGLWLRQWKDWLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 115. :KHQWKHDUHWHQWKHLU]DNDKLVWZRVKHHS7KXVHYHUWLPHWKHLQFUHDVHEILYHWKH]DNDKGXHRQWKHP LV RQH PRUH VKHHS +RZHYHU ZKHQ WKH UHDFK WZHQWILYHWKH GXH ]DNDK LV D VKHFDPHO ELQWPDNKDGRUELQWODEXQ
  • 116. ZKLFKLVDHDUROGDQGVWDUWLQJWKHVHFRQGRUDRXQJPDOHFDPHOZKLFKLVWZRHDUVDQGDOUHDGVWDUWLQJWKHWKLUGHDU:KHQWKHUHDFKWKLUWVL[WKH]DNDKGXHRQWKHPLVDRXQJVKHFDPHO ELQW ODEXQ
  • 117.  :KHQ WKH UHDFK IRUWVL[ WKH GXH ]DNDK LV D VKHFDPHO KXTTDK
  • 118.  ZKLFK LVDOUHDGWKUHHHDUVROGDQGVWDUWLQJWKHIRXUWK:KHQWKHUHDFKVL[WRQHWKHGXH]DNDKLVDIRXUHDUROGFDPHODOUHDGVWDUWLQJLWVILIWKHDU MD]KDK
  • 119. :KHQWKHUHDFK VHYHQWVL[WZRRXQJVKHFDPHOV ELQWODEXQ
  • 120. DUHGXH:KHQWKHDUHLQWKHUDQJHRIQLQHWRQHWRWKH]DNDKLVWZRRXQJFDPHOV KXTTDWDQ
  • 121.  :KHQ WKH QXPEHU RI FDPHOV LV DERYH  RQ HYHU IRUW RXQJ VKHFDPHOV RQH ELQWODEXQLVGXH$QGRQHYHU ILIWDERYHDRXQJVKHFDPHO KXTTDK
  •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
  • 123. &DWWOHDUHVXEMHFWWR]DNDKSURYLGHGWKHDUHDIUHHOJUD]LQJKHUGDQGQXPEHUWKLUWDWWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIWKHKDZO$WWKDWSRLQWWKH]DNDKGXHLVDRXQJEXOORUDRXQJFRZ WDELRUWDELDK
  • 124. :KHQWKHUHDFKIRUWWKH]DNDKLVDRXQJFRZWZRHDUVROG PXVLQQDK
  • 125. ZKHQVL[WWZRRXQJFRZVRUWZRRQHHDUROGV WDELDKV
  • 126. ZKHQVHYHQWWKH]DNDKGXHLVRQHPXVLQQDKDQGRQHWDELZKHQHLJKWWZRPXVLQQDKVZKHQQLQHWWKUHHWDELVZKHQRQHKXQGUHGRQHPXVLQQDKDQGWZRWDELVZKHQWZRPXVLQQDKVDQGWZRWDELVDQGZKHQWKUHHPXVLQQDKVRUIRXUWDELV7KLVVVWHPLVIROORZHGRQDOODGGLWLRQDOFDWWOHRQHWDELDQGRQHYHUIRUWRQHPXVLQQDK)LTKD=DNDKRQ6KHHS ,QFOXGLQJ*RDWV
  • 127. 6KHHS DUH VXEMHFW WR ]DNDK ZKHQ WKHLU QXPEHU UHDFKHV IRUW :KHQ WKH KHUG FRXQWV IRUW IUHHOJUD]LQJKHDGVDWWKHHQGRIWKHHDULWV]DNDKLVRQHVKHHS7KLVLVDSSOLFDEOHXQWLOWKHQXPEHUUHDFKHVDWZKLFKSRLQWXSXQWLOWKH]DNDKLVWZRVKHHS)URPWRWKHLU]DNDKLVWKUHHVKHHS:KHQ WKH QXPEHU LV DERYH  RQH DGGLWLRQDO VKHHS LV DGGHG IRU HDFK LQFUHPHQW RI RQH KXQGUHG<RXQJVKHHS MD]K
  • 128. DUHOHYLHGLQWKHFDVHRIVKHHSDQGRXQJJRDWV WKDQ
  •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
  • 130. ZKHQWKHUHDFKWKLUWVL[WRIRUWILYHWKHQWKH]DNDKGXHRQWKHPLVDRXQJVKHFDPHOWZRHDUVROGDQGDOUHDGVWDUWLQJWKHWKLUG ELQWODEXQ
  • 131. &RQFHUQLQJWKHVDGDTDKRIFDWWOHKHVDLG:KHQFDWWOHQXPEHUEHWZHHQWKLUWDQG IRUW WKH ]DNDK LV D RXQJ FDOI RI RQH HDU ROG WDEL
  • 132.  RU D EXOO RU FRZ RI RQH HDU DQG DOUHDGVWDUWLQJWKHVHFRQG MD]KRUMD]KDK
  • 133. ZKHQWKHUHDFKIRUWDRXQJFRZRIWZRHDUVROGDQGDOUHDGVWDUWLQJ WKH WKLUG UQXVLQQDK
  • 134.  &RQFHUQLQJ VDGDTDK RQ VKHHS KH VDLG :KHQ WKH QXPEHU RI IUHHOJUD]LQJVKHHSLVEHWZHHQIRUWWZRDQGWKHLU]DNDKLVRQHHZH7KXVZKDWOLHVEHWZHHQWZHQWILYHDQGWKLUWVL[FDPHOVLVFRQVLGHUHGZDTVWKDWLVWKHUH LVQR]DNDKRQWKHP/LNHZLVHZKDWOLHVEHWZHHQWKLUWDQGIRUWFDWWOHLVFRQVLGHUHGZDTV7KLVLVDOVRDSSOLHVWRVKHHS)LTK:KDW6KRXOG1RW%H,QFOXGHGLQ=DNDK7KH ULJKWV RI SURSHUW RZQHUVPXVWEHFRQVLGHUHGZKHQWKHLUSURSHUWLHVDUHVXEMHFWHGWR]DNDK7KHEHVWLWHPVDUHQRWWREHWDNHQDV]DNDKXQOHVVWKHRZQHUVIUHHOSHUPLWLW/LNHZLVHWKHULJKWVRIWKHSRRU VKRXOG EH FRQVLGHUHG $ GHIHFWLYH DQLPDO VKRXOG QRW EH WDNHQ DV ]DNDK XQOHVV DOO RI WKH RWKHUDQLPDOV DUH GHIHFWLYH ,Q VXFK D FDVH]DNDKLVGXHRQWKHDYHUDJHRIWKDWSURSHUW6RPHSURRIVIRUWKLVYLHZDUH ,QWKHOHWWHURI$EX%DNU1HLWKHUDQROGRUDGHIHFWLYHDQLPDOQRUDELOOJRDWPDEHWDNHQDV]DNDK 6XIDQLEQ$EGXOODKDWK7KDTDILUHSRUWHG8PDUIRUEDGHWKH]DNDKFROOHFWRUWROHY]DNDKRQWKHIROORZLQJ EDUUHQ HZHV DODNXODK
  • 135.  D VKHHS NHSW DW KRPH IRU PLON DUUDK
  • 136.  D SUHJQDQW HZH DOUQDNKLG
  • 137. RUDUDPXVHGIRUEUHHGLQJ IDKODOJKDQDP
  • 138.  $EGXOODK LEQ 0XDZLDK DO*KDGLUL UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG:KRHYHUSHUIRUPVWKHVHWKUHHDFWVZLOOKDYHKDG VDYRUHG
  • 139. DWDVWHRIEHOLHI LUQDQ
  • 140. +HZKRZRUVKLSV$OODKDORQHDQG>EHOLHYHV@WKDWWKHUHLVQRJRGEXW+LPKHZKRJRRGKHDUWHGORIIHUVWKH]DNDKRQKLVSURSHUWZKLFKZLOOUHSDKLPHYHUHDUDQGKHZKRGRHVQRWRIIHUDYHUROGVKHHSDPDQJVKHHS D VLFN VKHHS D PHDQ DQG ORZ VKHHS RU D HZH ZKLFK SURGXFHV RQO D VPDOO DPRXQW RI PLON<RXVKRXOGRIIHURQHIURPWKHDYHUDJH9HULO$OODKDVNVRXWRRIIHUQHLWKHUWKHEHVW QRUWKHZRUVW,WZDVUHODWHGE$EXDZXGDQGDW7DEDUDQLZLWKDJRRGWUDQVPLVVLRQ)LTKD=DNDKRQ$QLPDOV2WKHU7KDQ&DWWOH DO$QDP
  • 141. =DNDK LV QRW DSSOLFDEOH WR DQLPDOV RWKHU WKDQ FDWWOH 7KXV WKHUH LV QR ]DNDK RQ KRUVHV PXOHV RUGRQNHV XQOHVV WKH DUH XVHG IRU WKH SXUSRVH RI WUDGH 2Q WKH DXWKRULW RI $OL LW LV UHODWHG WKDW WKHLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 144. FDUULHGEWKHVKHSKHUGDUHQRWWREHWDNHQDV]DNDK/LNHZLVHDEDUUHQVKHHS DODNXODK
  • 145.  D HZH NHSW IRU PLON DUUDE
  • 146.  D SUHJQDQW HZH DOPDNKLG
  • 147.  DQG D UDP XVHG IRUEUHHGLQJ IDKODOJKDQDP
  •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
  • 149. WKHQ WKH FRXOG DOVR EH FRQVLGHUHG RQ WKHLU RZQ $VK6KDIL DQG $EX <XVXI KROG WKDW DW OHDVW RQHRXQJ DQLPDO
  • 150. LVREOLJDWRU DV]DNDK
  • 151. IURPWKHRXQJDQLPDOV)LTK2Q&RPELQLQJ<RXQJDQG2OG $QLPDOV
  • 152. RU6HSDUDWLQJ7KHP 6XZDLGLEQ*KDIODKVDLG7KH]DNDKFROOHFWRURIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHFDPH WR XV DQG , KHDUG KLP VD :H GR QRW FROOHFW ]DNDK RQ VXFNOLQJ DQLPDOV QRU GR ZH VHSDUDWHEHWZHHQWKHP>RXQJDQG ROG@QRUFRPELQHWKHPWRJHWKHU$PDQFDPHZLWKDJUHDWKXPSHGFDPHO NDZPD
  • 153. EXWKHGLGQRWDFFHSWLWDV]DNDK,WZDVUHSRUWHGE$KPDG$EXDZXGDQGDQ1DVDL $QDV UHSRUWHG WKDW $EX %DNU ZURWH WR KLP 7KHVH DUH WKH VDGDTDK VWLSXODWLRQV ZKLFK WKH0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH PDGH REOLJDWRU WR WKH 0XVOLPV >$QG RI LW@ GR QRWFRPELQH7KHUHLVQRQHHGWRJDWKHU>RXQJDQGROG@DQLPDOVQRUWRVHSDUDWHWKHPWRREWDLQWKHFRUUHFWVDGDTDK DPRXQW :KDW KDSSHQV WR D PL[WXUH RI RXQJ DQG ROG" :KHQ ]DNDK LV DVVHVVHG RQ WZRDVVRFLDWHVWKHQWKHKDYHWRILJXUHLWRXWHTXDOODPRQJWKHP$O%XNKDULUHODWHVWKLVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 156. +DYHDQ(IIHFW"7KH+DQDILDKKROGWKDWDVIDUDVWKHGHWHUPLQDWLRQRI]DNDKLVFRQFHPHGFRPELQLQJ DQLPDOV
  •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
  • 158. ,WPHDQVWREHKLGGHQ$OODKWKH([DOWHG2QHVDV2UKHDUIURPWKHPWKHVOLJKWHVWVRXQG>0DUDP@WKDWLVULN]PHDQVDVOLJKWVRXQGLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 159. ,QWKHSUHVHQWFRQWH[WWKLVUHIHUVWRZKDWZDVEXULHGDWWKHWLPHRIMDKLOLDK WKHSUH,VODPLFSHULRG
  • 160. 0DOLN DQG PDQ RWKHU VFKRODUV DUH RI WKH RSLQLRQ WKDW ULND] PHDQV REMHFWV EXULHG EHIRUH WKH $UDEVHPEUDFHG ,VODP DQG ZKLFK ZHUH GXJ XS ZLWKRXW DQ H[SHQVLYH HIIRUW RU PRQH ,I WKHVH FRQGLWLRQVFDQQRWEHPHWWKHQLWLVQRWFRQVLGHUHGULND]$EX+DQLIDKKROGVWKDWLWLVDQDPHRIDQHQWLWKLGGHQHLWKHUEWKH&UHDWRURUEWKHFUHDWHGRQH PDQ
  • 161. )LTKD7KH0HDQLQJRI0LQHUDOVDQG7KHLU&RQGLWLRQVIRU=DNDK7KH WHUP PDGLQ PLQHUDOV
  • 162.  LV GHULYHG IURP WKH YHUE DGDQD WR UHVLGH
  • 163.  DV LQ WKH SKUDVH DGDQD ILDOPDNDQ ZKLFK PHDQV VRPHRQH UHVLGHG LQ VRPH SODFH $OODK WKH ([DOWHG 2QH VDV $OODK KDVSURPLVHG WR WKH EHOLHYLQJ PHQ DQG EHOLHYLQJ ZRPHQ JDUGHQV RI (GHQ >DW7DXEDK@VLQFHLWLVDQDERGHIRUHWHUQLW6FKRODUVGLIIHUDERXWPLQHUDOV PDGLQ
  • 164. ZKLFKDUHVXEMHFWWR]DNDK$KPDGKROGVWKDWHYHUWKLQJGXJIURPWKHJURXQGZKHWKHUFUHDWHG LQLWRUEXULHGEPDQDQGZKLFKKDVDYDOXH VXFKDVJROGVLOYHULURQ FRSSHU OHDG VDSSKLUHV FKUVROLWH HPHUDOGV WXUTXRLVH FUVWDO DJDWH NRKO DQWLPRQ VXOILGH
  • 165. DUVHQLF WDU SHWUROHXP VXOSKXU ]DM
  •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
  • 167.  DQG WKH VLOYHU DW OHDVW GLUKDPV7KHDJUHH ZLWKWKH+DQDILDK
  • 168. WKDWWKHVHPHWDOV GRQRWUHTXLUHFRPSOHWLRQRIDHDUWREHVXEMHFWHGWR]DNDKZKLFKEHFRPHVGXHDQWLPHLWLVDYDLODEOH$FFRUGLQJWRWKHSUHFHGLQJVFKRODUVWKH DPRXQW VKRXOG EH RQHIRUWLHWK DQG LWV GLVWULEXWLRQ VKRXOG EH OLNH WKDW RI WKH UHJXODU ]DNDK )RU$EX+DQLIDKLWVGLVWULEXWLRQLVVLPLODUWRERRW ID
  • 169. )LTK7KH/HJLWLPDFRI=DNDKRQ5LND]DQG0DGLQ7KDW]DNDKRIULND]DQGPDGLQLVREOLJDWRULVVKRZQEDVWDWHPHQWDWWULEXWHGWR$EX+XUDLUDK7KH3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG 7KHUH LV QR FRPSHQVDWLRQ IRU RQH NLOOHG RU ZRXQGHG E DQDQLPDO IDOOLQJ LQ D ZHOO RU EHFDXVH RI ZRUNLQJ LQ PLQHV EXW RQHILIWK NKXPV
  • 170.  LV FRPSXOVRU RQULND],EQDO0XQ]KLUFRQIHVVHVWKDWKHGRHVQRWNQRZDQRQHZKRFRQWUDGLFWHGWKLVKDGLWKH[FHSWDO+DVDQ ZKR GLIIHUHQWLDWHV EHWZHHQ ZKDW H[LVWV LQ WKH ODQG RI ZDU DQG WKH ,VODPLF ODQG 7KHODWWHUKROGVWKDWLIULND]LVIRXQGLQWKHODQGRIZDURQHILIWK NKXPV
  • 171. LVGXHEXWLILWLVIRXQGLQWKH,VODPLFODQGLWZLOOEHVXEMHFWWRWKHUHJXODU]DNDK([SODLQLQJLW,EQDO4DLPVDVWKDWWKHUHDUHWZRLQWHUSUHWDWLRQVRIWKLVVWDWHPHQW7KHILUVWLQWHUSUHWDWLRQLVWKDWZKHQHYHUVRPHRQHKLUHVVRPHRQHHOVHWRGLJDPLQHIRUKLPDQGWKHQKHIDOOV LQWR LW DQG LV NLOOHG WKHUH LV QR FRPSHQVDWLRQ IRU KLP 7KLV YLHZLVVXSSRUWHGEWKH3URSKHWVVDLQJ7KHUHLVQRFRPSHQVDWLRQIRURQHZKRIDOOVLQWRDZHOORUZKRLVNLOOHGEDQDQLPDO DOELUMXEDUZDDODMPDMXEDU
  • 172. 7KHVHFRQGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQLVWKDWWKHUHLVQR]DNDKRQPLQHUDOV7KLVYLHZLVVXSSRUWHGEWKH3URSKHWVVDLQJ  EXW RQHILIWK LV FRPSXVORU RQ WUHDVXUH ZD IL D]]DNDK DONKXPV
  • 173.  7KXV KHGLIIHUHQWLDWHG EHWZHHQ PLQHUDO PDGLQ
  • 174.  DQG WUHDVXUH ULND]
  • 175.  +H PDGH ]DNDK RQ ULND] FRPSXOVRUEHFDXVHLWLVDZHDOWKREWDLQHGZLWKRXWDQFRVWRUHIIRUW+HH[HPSWHGPLQHUDOV PDGLQ
  • 176. IURP]DNDKEHFDXVHWKHUHTXLUHERWKFRVWDQGHIIRUWIRUWKHLUPLQLQJ)LTK5LND]8SRQ:KLFK=DNDKLV3DLG7KHULND]DUHDOOWKRVHVXEVWDQFHVXSRQZKLFKRQHILIWK NKXPV
  • 177. LVSDDEOHVXFKDVJROGVLOYHULURQOHDG EUDVV DQG WKH OLNH 7KLV LV WKH RSLQLRQ RI WKH +DQDILDK WKH +DQEDOLDK ,VKDT DQG ,EQ DO0XQ]KLU$UHSRUWIURP0DOLNDQGRQHRIWKHWZRRSLQLRQVRIDVK6KDILDOVRFRUURERUDWHLW$VK6KDILDOVRKROGVWKDWRQOJROGDQGVLOYHUDUHVXEMHFWWRNKXPV)LTKD7KH/RFDWLRQRI5LND]5LND]PLJKWEHIRXQGLQWKHIROORZLQJSODFHV ,QDEDUUHQODQGDODQGRIXQNQRZQRZQHUVKLSRULQDQLQWUDFWLEOHURDGRUUXLQHGYLOODJH,QWKDWFDVHNKXPVKDVWREHSDLGDQGWKHRQHZKRIRXQGLWPDNHHSWKHRWKHUIRXUILIWKVIRUKLPVHOI7KLVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 178. LVEDVHGRQDUHSRUWIURPDQ1DVDLRQWKHDXWKRULWRI$PULEQ6KXDLEIURPKLVIDWKHUDQGIURPKLVJUDQGIDWKHU ZKR VDLG WKDW ZKHQ WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH ZDV DVNHG DERXW DOXFNILQG DOOXTDWDK
  • 179. KHUHVSRQGHG)RUDQWKLQJDORQJDWUDFWDEOHURDGRULQDQLQKDELWHGYLOODJHLWVRZQHUVKLSLVGHWHUPLQHGEHVWDEOLVKHGFXVWRP,IWKHRZQHUFODLPVLWLWLVKLV+RZHYHUZKHQDQLWHPLVIRXQGLQDQLQWUDFWDEOHURDGRULQDQXQLQKDELWHGYLOODJHWKHQRQLWDQGWKHUHVWRIWKHILQGRQHILIWK NKXPV
  •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
  •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
  • 182. WKHQLWEHORQJVWRWKHRZQHU RI WKH ODQG DFFRUGLQJ WR $EX +DQLIDK 0XKDPPDG DQG $KPDG ,W LV DOVR UHSRUWHG IURP$KPDGWKDWLWEHORQJVWRWKHRQHZKRIRXQGLW ULND]
  •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
  • 184. DOOVFKRODUVDJUHHWKDWLWKDVQRWEHHQVWLSXODWHGDVDFRQGLWRQ)LTKD:KR0XVW3DWKH.KXPV 2QH)LIWK
  • 185. 0RVW VFKRODUV DUH RI WKH RSLQLRQ WKDW NKXPV LV GXH RQ DQRQH ZKR ILQGV D WUHDVXUH ZKHWKHU KHKDSSHQVWREHD0XVOLPDIUHHQRQ0XVOLPVXEMHFW ]KLPPL
  • 186. ROGRXQJVDQHRULQVDQH+RZHYHUWKHJXDUGLDQVRIWKHRXQJDQGLQVDQHPXVWSDLWRQWKHLUEHKDOI,EQDO0XQ]KLUFRPPHQWVWKDWDOOOHDUQHGSHUVRQVDJUHHWKDWD]KLPPLZKRILQGVULND]KDVWRSDLWVNKXPV7KLVLVDOVRWKHRSLQLRQRI0DOLN WKH VFKRODUV RI 0DGLQDK DWK7KDXUL DO$X]DL WKH VFKRODUV RI ,UDT WKRVH ZKR XVH DQDORJ DVKDEDUUD
  • 187. DQGRWKHUV$VK6KDILVWDWHGWKDWNKXPVLVRQOGXHXSRQWKRVHZKRPXVWSD]DNDK)LTKLVWULEXWLRQRI.KXPV$FFRUGLQJWRDVK6KDILWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRINKXPVLVVLPLODUWRWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRI]DNDK$KPDGDQGDO%DLKDTL QDUUDWH IURP %LVKU DO.KDWKDPL WKDW D PDQ IURP KLV WULEH VDLG :KLOH,ZDVLQ.XIDK,UHFHLYHG D MDU IURP DQ ROG PRQDVWHU DW WKH ]DNDK GLVWULFW MLEDDK
  • 188.  RI %LVKU 7KHUH ZHUH GLUKDPVLQLW,WRRNLWWR$OLZKRWROGPHWRGLYLGHLWLQWRILYHSDUWVZKLFK,GLG7KHQ$OLWRRNRQHILIWK DQG JDYH PH IRXUILIWKV :KHQ , GHSDUWHG KH FDOOHG PH DQG DVNHG LI WKHUH ZHUH VRPH QHHGSHRSOHOLYLQJQHDUPH,UHSOLHGWKDWWKHUHZHUHDQGKHDVNHGPHWRGLYLGHWKHRQHILIWKDPRQJWKHP$EX+DQLIDK0DOLNDQG$KPDGDUHRIWKHRSLQLRQWKDWLWVGLVWULEXWLRQLVVLPLODUWRWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIERRW ID
  • 189. $VK6KXELQDUUDWHVWKDWDPDQZKLOHKHZDVRXWRI0DGLQDKIRXQGGLQDUVLQWKHJURXQG+HEURXJKWWKHPWR8PDULEQDO.KDWWDEZKRWRRNWKH NKXPVRIGLQDUVDQGJDYHWKHPDQWKHUHVW8PDUVWDUWHGWRGLVWULEXWHWKHGLQDUVDPRQJWKH0XVOLPVZKRZHUHSUHVHQW6LQFHDOLWWOHELWZDVOHIWRYHUKHWKHQDVNHG:KHUHLVWKHRZQHURIWKHGLQDUV":KHQWKHPDQUHVSRQGHG8PDUVDLGWRKLP7DNHWKHVHGLQDUVIRUWKHDUHRXUV,QDO0XJKQLLWVDVWKDWLILWZHUHOLNH]DNDKKHZRXOGLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 193. RHV1RW9RLGLWLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 196. VDGDTDK7KH0HVVHQJHUUHSOLHG$OODKGLGQRWOHDYHWKHPDWWHURIVDGDTDWWREHGHFLGHGEDSURSKHWQRUWRRWKHUV+H+LPVHOIFODVVLILHGLWLQWRHLJKWFDWHJRULHV,IRXILWLQWRDQRIWKHVHFDWHJRULHV,ZLOOJLYHRXRXUGXH,WZDVQDUUDWHGE$EXDZXGDOWKRXJKLQLWVFKDLQRIWUDQVPLVVLRQWKHUHLV$EGXUUDKPDQDO$IULTLZKRLVRITXHVWLRQDEOHPHULWV7KHIROORZLQJLVDQHODERUDWLRQXSRQWKHSUHFHGLQJHLJKWFDWHJRULHV 7KH3RRU DO)XTDUD
  • 197.  7KH1HHG DO0DVDNLQ
  • 198. 7KHQHHGDORQJZLWKWKHSRRUPHQWLRQHGDERYHDUHWKRVHZKRGRQRWHYHQ KDYH EDVLF QHHGV IXOILOOHG 7KLV FDWHJUR SDUDOOHOV WKH FDWHJRU RI WKH ULFK ZKR KDYH DOO WKHQHHG $V PHQWLRQHG HOVHZKHUH D SHUVRQ LV FRQVLGHUHG ULFK LI KH SRVVHVVHV WKH QLVDEWKDW LV DQDUQRXQWLQH[FHVVRIKLVHVVHQWLDOQHHGVRUWKRVHRIKLVFKLOGUHQZLWKUHJDUGWRIRRGGULQNFORWKLQJKRXVLQJ DQLPDOV WRROV RI KLV WUDGH DQG VLPLODU RWKHU QHFHVVLWLHV 7KXV RQH ZKR ODFNV DOO WKHVH LVFRQVLGHUHGSRRU IXTXUD
  • 199. DQGTXDOLILHVIRU]DNDK$KDGLWKDWWULEXWHGWR0XD]KLQVWUXFWV7DNHIURPWKHULFK>WKDWLVWKRVHZKRDUHVHOIVXIILFLHQW@DQGJLYH WR WKHLU SRRU 7KXV ]DNDK VKRXOG EH WDNHQ IURP WKH ULFK ZKR RZQ D QLVDE DQG JLYHQ WR WKRVHZKRDUHQRWVRIRUWXQDWH1RGLIIHUHQFHKDVEHHQPDGHKHUHEHWZHHQWKHSRRU IXTXUD
  • 200. DQGWKHQHHG QDVDNLQ
  •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
  •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
  • 203. $SHUVRQUHFHLYLQJLW VDGDTDK
  • 204. ZLOOEHFRQVXPLQJIRUELGGHQKROGLQJV7KLVLVQDUUDWHGE$KPDG0XVOLP$EXDZXGDQGDQ1DVDL)LTK,V]DKDKJLYHQWRDSHUVRQZKRFDQZRUN",QGLYLGXDOVVWURQJLQERGDQGHDUQLQJWKHLUOLYLQJDUHQRWHQWLWOHGWR]DNDK7KHLUSRVLWLRQLVVLPLODUWRWKDWRIWKHULFKLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 205.  8EDLGXOODKLEQ$GLDO.KLDUUHSRUWHG7ZRPHQWROGPHWKDWWKHZHQWWRWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHGXULQJWKH)DUHZHOO3LOJULPDJHZKLOHKHZDVGLVWULEXWLQJFKDULW7KHDVNHGKLPIRUKHOS+HJDYHWKHPDORRNIURPWKHKHDGGRZQDQGWKHQIRXQGWKHPWREHVWXUGDQGVWURQJ7KHQKHVDLG,IRXGHVLUH,VKDOOJLYHLWWRRX%XWWKHUHLVQR]DNDKIRURQHZKRLVULFKQHLWKHUIRUWKHRQHZKRLVVWURQJDQGHDUQLQJ7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EXDZXGDQGDQ1DVDL&RQFHUQLQJWKHPHULWVRIWKLVKDGLWKDO.KDWWDELVDVWKDWLWSURYLGHVWKHFULWHULRQWKDWLIDSHUVRQLVQRWNQRZQWRKDYHPHDQVLWZLOOEHSUHVXPHGWKDWKHKDVQRQH7KHKDGLWKDOVRSURYLGHVWKHUXOHWKDWRQH ZKR DSSHDUV WR EH VWXUG LV QRW H[FOXGHG IURP UHFHLYLQJ WKH ]DNDK XQOHVV KLV LQFRPH LVGHWHUPLQHGIRUWKHUHDUHVRPHSHRSOHZKRDUHVWURQJLQERGEXWIRURQHUHDVRQRUDQRWKHUDUHXQDEOHWRZRUN6XFKSHRSOHPDUHFHLYHFKDULWDFFRUGLQJWRWKLVKDGLWK ,W LV UHODWHG IURP 5DKDQ LEQ <D]LG IURP $EGXOODK LEQ $PU WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EHSHDFH VDLG 6DGDTDK LV QHLWKHU SHUPLVVLEOH IRU WKH ULFK QRU IRU WKH RQH ZKR LV RI HQHUJHWLFGLVSRVLWLRQVRXQGERGDQGKHDOWKOLPEV7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EXDZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KL7KHODWWHUJUDGHVLWDVVRXQG VDKLK
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 209. ZDUULRULQWKHFDXVHRI$OODKRUDSHUVRQZKRLVJLYHQDSUHVHQWEWKHQHHG PLVNHHQ
  •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
  •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
  • 212. KHDUWVDUHWREHUHFRQFLOHGWR,VODP2QWKHFRQWUDUDVK6KDILPDLQWDLQVWKDWVXFKHQGRZPHQWVDUHQRWIRUXQEHOLHYHUV$VIRUWKHVLQQHU IDV]T
  •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
  • 214. DVWKHFDOLSKVGLGLQWKRVHPDWWHUVWKDW UHTXLUHG LMWLKDG :KHWKHU D OHDGHU FDQ IRUFH WKHP LQWR REHGLHQFH E FRHUFLYH DFWLRQ EHIRUHUHVRUWLQJWRWKHXVHRIWKHHQGRZPHQWLVDQXQVHWWOHGLVVXH1HYHUWKHOHVVWKLVFDQQRWEHIROORZHGDVDUXOH EXW UDWKHU DV WKH SULQFLSOH RI LQFOLQLQJ WR WKH OHVVHU RI WZR HYLOV DQG WR WKH EHVW EHQHILW RI WKHVRFLHW)LTK)UHHLQJ&DSWLYHV7KLV FDWHJRU LQFOXGHV WZR NLQGV RI VODYHV FRQWUDFWHG VODYHV UQXND]DEXQ
  •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
  • 216. ZKRILJKWVIRU$OODKWKHFRQWUDFWHGVODYHZKRORQJVWREXKLVIUHHGRPDQGRQHZKRZLVKHVWRJHWPDUULHGIRUWKHVDNHRIFKDVWLW7KLVLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDQGWKHDVKDEDV6XQDQ$W7LUPL]KLJUDGHVWKLVUHSRUWDVJRRGDQGVRXQG$VWRWKHPHDQLQJRIIUHHFDSWLYHV ZD ILDUULTDE
  • 217. DVK6KDXNDQLVDVWKDWVFKRODUVGLIIHURYHULW$OLLEQ$EX7DOLE6DLGLEQ-XEDLUDO/DWKDWK7KDXULDO,WUDKWKH+DQDILDKWKH6KDILDKDQGWKHPDMRULW RI VFKRODUV DUH UHSRUWHG WR EHOLHYH WKDW LW UHIHUV WR FRQWUDFWHG VODYHV UQXNDWDEGQ
  • 218.  ZKRVHIUHHGRPLVVHFXUHGWKURXJKSDPHQWIURP]DNDK$FFRUGLQJWR,EQ$EEDVDO+DVDQDO%DVUL0DOLN$KUQDGLEQ+DQEDO$EX7KDXUDQG$EX8EDLGLWPHDQVXVLQJ]DNDKLQWKHUHOHDVHRIDQNLQGRIVODYH $O%XNKDUL DQG ,EQ DO0XQ]KLU DUH DOVR VXSSRUWLYH RI WKLV YLHZ 7KHLU UDWLRQDOH LV WKDW WKHH[SUHVVLRQZDILDUULTDEFDQQRWEHFRQILQHGWRWKHNLQGRIVODYHUDULVLQJIURPDFRQWUDFWEHFDXVHLIWKDW KDG EHHQ WKH FDVH WKHQ LWZRXOGKDYHIDOOHQXQGHUWKHFDWHJRURIWKRVHLQGHEW JKDULPOQ
  • 219. IRUWKHLUV LV DQ REYLRXV FDVH RI GHEW $V VXFK IUHHLQJ D VODYH IURP ERQGDJH LV EHWWHU WKDQ KHOSLQJ DFRQWUDFWHGVODYH+HFRXOGEHDLGHGRUKHOSHGEXWQRWIUHHGIRUWKHFRQWUDFWHGVODYHLVDVODYHDVORQJDVKHRZHVHYHQRQHGLUKDP$WWKHVDPHWLPHIUHHLQJDVODYHLVSRVVLEOHDWDQWLPHLQFRQWUDVWWRWKHVLWXDWLRQRIDFRQWUDFWHGVODYH&RPPHQWLQJ RQ WKH VXEMHFW D]=XKUL VDV WKDW WKH SUHFHGLQJ SRVLWLRQ HQWDLOV WZR SRVVLELOLWLHV 7KH4XUDQLF DDK RQ WKH VXEMHFW DOOXGHV WR WKHVH WZR SRVVLELOLWLHV ZKLFK KDYH EHHQ SRLQWHG RXW EDVK6KDXNDQL LQ KLV 0XQWDTD DO$NKEDU ,Q WKH KDGLWK QDUUDWHG E DO%DUD HYLGHQFH VXJJHVWV WKDWUHGHHPLQJQHFNVLVQRWWKHVDPHDVIUHHLQJWKHP1RULVWKHGHHGRIIUHHLQJVODYHVWKHVDPHDVKHOSLQJFRQWUDFWHG RQHV ZLWK PRQH WR SD RII WKH FRQWUDFW %RWK RI WKHVH EULQJ WKH LQGLYLGXDO FORVHU WR+HDYHQDQGGLVWDQFHKLPIURP+HOO)LTKHEWRUV3HRSOH EXUGHQHG E GHEWV DQG XQDEOH WR SD WKHP DUH RI VHYHUDO NLQGV WKRVH ZKR WRRN XSRQWKHPVHOYHV UHVSRQVLELOLW WR GLVFKDUJH D GHEW WKRVH ZKR JXDUDQWHHG GHEWV RI RWKHUV DQG WKHUHIRUHXSRQ GHIDXOW WKH GHEWV KDYH EHFRPH WKHLU REOLJDWLRQ WKRVH ZKR PLVPDQDJHG WKHLU ILQDQFHV WKRVHLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 223. UDLOZDOLQHVDQG WKH EXLOGLQJ RI FUXLVHUV ZDUSODQHV IRUWUHVVHV DQG WUHQFKHV $Q LPSRUWDQW LWHP LQ WKLV FDWHJRUFRXOGEHWKHSUHSDUDWLRQRI0XVOLPPLVVLRQDULHVDQGVHQGLQJWKHPWR QRQ0XVOLPFRXQWULHVWRVSUHDG,VODP MXVW DV QRQ0XVOLP PLVVLRQDULHV DUH QRZ VSUHDGLQJ WKHLU UHOLJLRQV LQ ,VODPLF FRXQWULHV $OVRIDOOLQJXQGHUWKLVKHDGLQJZRXOGEHVFKRROH[SHQVHVWRSUHSDUHDGHTXDWHFRXUVHVLQUHOLJLRXVVFLHQFHVDQGLQRWKHUDUHDVRISXEOLFLQWHUHVW7HDFKHUVLQYROYHGLQVXFKSURJUDPVVKRXOGEHJLYHQVDGDTDKDVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 226.  WKH QHHG UQDVDNP
  • 227.  WKHDGPLQLVWUDWRUVRI]DNDK DPLOGQDDODLKD
  • 228. WKRVHZKRVHKHDUWV DUH WR EH ZRQ RYHU PXDOODIDWX TXOXEXKXP
  • 229.  VODYHV DUULTDE
  • 230.  WKRVH LQ GHEW JKDULPXQ
  • 231.  WKHZDIDUHUV DEQDDV6DELO
  • 232. WKHZDUULRUV UQXMDKLGOQ
  • 233. 7KHMXULVWVGLIIHURYHUWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRI]DNDKDPRQJWKHSUHFHGLQJHLJKWJURXSVRISHRSOH$VK6KDILDQGKLVIROORZHUVKROGWKDWLIDGLVWULEXWRURI]DNDKKDSSHQVWREHWKHRZQHURIWKHSURSHUW RU WKH DJHQW
  • 234.  WKHQ WKHUH LV QR VKDUH RI WKH FROOHFWRUV LQ LW ,Q WKDW FDVH LW EHFRPHV REOLJDWRU WRGLVWULEXWH WKH VXP FROOHFWHG DPRQJ WKH UHPDLQLQJ VHYHQ FDWHJRULHV ,I RWKHU FDWHJRULHV DUH IRU VRPHUHDVRQLQHOLJLEOHIRUWKHLUVKDUHLWZLOOEHGLVWULEXWHGDPRQJWKRVHVWLOOHOLJLEOH,WLVQRWSHUPLVVLEOHWRGLVUHJDUG DQ FDWHJRU LI LW PHHWV WKH FRQGLWLRQV IRU HOLJLELOLW ,EUDKLP DQ1DNKDL VDV WKDW LI WKHDPRXQW RI ]DNDK UHFHLYHG LV ODUJH WKHQ LW LV SRVVLEOH WR GLYLGH LW DPRQJ WKH GLIIHUHQW FDWHJRULHV+RZHYHULILWLVVPDOOLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRSODFHLWLQWRRQHFDWHJRU$KPDGLEQ+DQEDOKROGVWKDWWKHGLYLVLRQRI]DNDKKDVDSULRULWEXWWKDWLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRJLYHLWDOOWRRQHFDWHJRU0DOLNPDLQWDLQVWKDW WKH GLVWULEXWRU RI ]DNDK VKRXOG PDNH DQ HIIRUW WR LQYHVWLJDWH WKRVH ZKR DUH LQ QHHG +H VKRXOGGLVWULEXWH LW DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH LPPHGLDWH FRQGLWLRQ RI WKH QHHG DQG SRRU SHRSOH 7KXV LI KH VHHV LQFHUWDLQHDUVWKDWWKHSRRUQHHGPRUHWKHVKRXOGEHJLYHQSULRULW,IKHVHHVLQDQRWKHUHDUWKDWWKHZDIDUHUV DUH PRUH QHHG KH VKRXOG GLVWULEXWH LW DPRQJ WKH WUDYHOHUV 7KH +DQDILDK DQG 6XIDQDWK7KDXULWKRXJKWWKDWWKH]DNDKSDHUFDQFKRRVHWKHFDWHJRULHVKHZLVKHGWRGLVWULEXWHWKH]DNDKWR7KLV LV UHODWHG E +X]KDLIDK DQG ,EQ $EEDV $O+DVDQ DO%DVUL DQG $WD LEQ $EL 5DEDK EDVH WKHLURSLQLRQVRQLW$EX+DQLIDKKROGVWKDWWKHGLVWULEXWRUVRI]DNDKPDJLYHLWWRRQHSHUVRQXQGHUDQRIWKHHLJKWFDWHJRULHV)LTK:KWKH6FKRODUVLIIHU$FFRUGLQJ WR ,EQ 5XVKG 7KH FDXVH RI WKHLU GLIIHUHQFHV OLHV EHWZHHQ WKH OLWHUDO DQG WKH LQWHQGHGPHDQLQJ 7KH OLWHUDO PHDQLQJ GHWHUPLQHV WKH FODVVLILFDWLRQV EXW WKH LQWHQGHG PHDQLQJ VKRZV WKDWSULRULWVKRXOGEHJLYHQWRWKHQHHGDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLPPHGLDFRIWKHLUQHHGVVLQFHWKHDLP>RIWKHLQVWLWXWLRQ RI ]DNDK@ LV WR HOLPLQDWH SRYHUW 7KH HQXPHUDWLRQ >RI WKH FDWHJRULHV@ LQ WKH 4XUDQ LVPHDQWWRGLVWLQJXLVKWKHGLIIHUHQWNLQGVWKDWLVWKHSHRSOHHOLJLEOHIRU]DNDKDQGQRWQHFHVVDULOWKHLUJURXSLQJ 7KH ILUVW LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ LV WKH OLWHUDO RQH ZKLOH WKH VHFRQG LV WKH LQWHQGHG LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ$VK6KDILEXLOGVKLVFDVHRQWKHKDGLWKRIDV6XGDLZKLFKLVUHODWHGE$EXDZXG$PDQFDPHWRWKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH DQG DVNHG IRU ]DNDK 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EHSHDFHVDLG$OODKKDVQRWOHIWWKHPDWWHUWRWKHMXGJPHQWRIDSURSKHWQRUWRRWKHUV+HKDVODLGWKHUXOHV IRU LWWKDW LV +H KDV FODVVLILHG >WKH EHQHILFLDULHV@ LQWR HLJKW FDWHJRULHV ,I RX ILW LQWR DQ RIWKHVH,ZLOOJLYHRXRXUGXH)LTKD7KH3UHIHUHQFHRIWKH0DMRULW2SLQLRQ2YHU7KDWRIDVK6KDILLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 237.  LV QRW HQWLWOHG WR ]DNDK ([FHSWLRQV WR WKH UXOH DUH WKRVH SHRSOH ZKRVH KHDUWV DUHOHDQLQJ WRZDUG ,VODP +RZHYHU LW LV SHUPLVVLEOH WR JLYH D ]KLPPL IURP WKH QRQREOLJDWRU FKDULW WDWDZZX
  • 238.  $OOXGLQJ WR WKH FKDUDFWHULVWLFV RI WKH EHOLYHUV WKH 4XUDQ VDV $QG IRU +LV ORYH WKHIHHG WKH LQGLJHQW RUSKDQ DQG FDSWLYH DGDKU  7KLV LVDOVRVXSSRUWHGEWKHIROORZLQJKDGLWK%HNLQGWRRXUPRWKHU7KHZRPDQLQWKLVFDVHZDVDQXQEHOLHYHU)LTKE%DQX+DVKLPLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 239. 7KLVLQFOXGHVWKHIDPLOLHVRI$OL-DIDUDO$EEDVDQGDO+DULWK,EQ4XGDPDKVDVWKHUHDUHQRWZRRSLQLRQV RQ WKH LQHOLJLELOLW RI %DQX +DVKLP WR UHFHLYH ]DNDK 7KH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFHGHFODUHG,QGHHGVDGDTDKRXJKWQRWWREHJLYHQWRWKHIDPLORI0XKDPPDG0XVOLPUHODWHGLW$EX +XUDLUDK UHSRUWHG WKDW ZKHQ DO+DVDQ WRRN RQH GDWH IURPWKHVDGDTDKGDWHVWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG WR KLP 1D VSLW LW RXW RQW RX NQRZ WKDW ZH FDQQRW HDW IURP FKDULW"6FKRODUVDJUHHRQWKHDXWKHQWLFLWRIWKLVKDGLWK$VWRWKHHOLJLELOLWRI%DQXDO0XWWDOLEIRU]DNDKWKHVFKRODUVGLIIHU$VK6KDILKROGVWKDWOLNH%DQX+DVKLPWKHDUHGLVDOORZHGWRWDNH]DNDK$VK6KDIL$KPDGDQGDO%XNKDULUHODWHIURP-XEDLULEQ0XWLPZKRVDLG$WWKHEDWWOHRI.KDLEDUWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFH VHW DVLGH WKH VKDUH RI WKH UHODWLYHV RI WKH IDPLOLHV RI%DQX+DVKLPDQG%DQXDO0XWWDOLEDQGOHIW RXW WKH VKDUHV RI %DQX 1DZIDO DQG %DQX $EG 6KDPV , DQG 8WKPDQ LEQ $IIDQ FDPH WR WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGVDLGWRKLP20HVVHQJHURI$OODKRQRWGHQ%DQX+DVKLP WKH JUDFH RI WKHLU SRVLWLRQ EHFDXVH $OODK SODFHG RX DPRQJ WKHP +RZ DERXW RXU EURWKHUV%DQX DO0XWWDOLE" <RX JDYH WKHP DQG OHIW XV RXW" ,VQW RXU UHODWLRQVKLS RQH DQG WKH VDPH" 7KH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQVZHUHG,DQG%DQXDO0XWWDOLEDUHQRWWREHVHSDUDWHGHLWKHUGXULQJMDKLOLDK RU ,VODP :H DQG WKH DUH RQH 7KHQ KH MRLQHG KLV ILQJHUV >LQ GHPRQVWUDWLQJ WKH FORVHUHODWLRQVKLS@ 5HDVRQ GLFWDWHV WKDW RQH VKRXOG QRW GLIIHUHQWLDWH EHWZHHQ WKHP WKH WZR IDPLOLHV
  • 240.  LQDQPDWWHURIODZEHFDXVHWKHDUHRQHDFFRUGLQJWRWKHVDLQJRIWKH3URSKHW,WLVHYLGHQWWKDWWKHDUH WKH IDPLO RI 0XKDPPDG DQG WKHUHIRUH VDGDTDW DUH IRUELGGHQWRWKHP$EX+DQLIDKKROGVWKDWWKHIDPLORI%DQXDO0XWWDOLEPDWDNHIURP]DNDK%RWK WKHVHUHSRUWVDUHUHODWHGE$KPDG-XVWDVWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHPDGHFKDULWXQODZIXOIRUWKHIDPLORI%DQX+DVKLPKHDOVRPDGHLWXQODZIXOIRUWKHLUSURWHJHV PDZOD
  • 241. $EX5DILDSURWHJHRIWKH3URSKHWVDLGWKDWWKHODWWHU DSSRLQWHG D PDQ IURP WKH IDPLO RI %DQX 0DNK]XP WR FROOHFW VDGDTDW 7KLV PDQ VDLGWR$EX5DIL$FFRPSDQPHVRWKDWRXPDJHWVRPHRILW+HVDLG1RXQWLO,PHHWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDQGDVNKLP+HOHIWDQGDVNHGKLP7KH3URSKHWDQVZHUHG6DGDTDKLVQRWODZIXOIRUXVDQGWKHSURWHJHVRIDFHUWDLQWULEHDUHOLNH>WKHPHPEHUVRIWKHWULEH@WKHPVHOYHV$KPDG$EXDZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KLUHODWHGLW7KHODWWHUJUDGHVLWJRRG KDVVDQ
  • 242. DQGVRXQG VDKLK
  • 243. :KHWKHU QRQREOLJDWRU FKDULW WDWDZZX
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 248.  DQG KLGGHQ ZHDOWK LH WUDGH JRRGV JROGVLOYHU DQG WUHDVXUH
  •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
  •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
  • 251. :DLOLEQ+DMDUUHSRUWHG,KHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDDIWHUDPDQKDGDVNHGKLPKLVRSLQLRQRIRXUOHDGHUVZKRGHQWKHLUULJKW>RIFROOHFWLQJDQGGLVWULEXWLQJWKH]DNDK@/LVWHQ DQG REH IRU LQGHHG WKH KDYH WKHLU UHVSRQVLELOLW DQG RX KDYH RXUV  7KLV LV UHODWHG E0XVOLP&RPPHQWLQJRQWKHVXEMHFWDVK6KDXNNDQLVDVWKDWWKHKDGLWKFLWHGLQWKLVVHFWLRQDUHXVHGEPDQVFKRODUVWRMXVWLIWKHSHUPLVVLELOLWRIWUDQVIHUULQJERWKNLQGVRI]DNDKWRXQMXVWUXOHUV7KLVDSSOLHVWRUXOHUVRI0XVOLPVLQWKHZRUOGRI,VODP DUDO,VODP
  •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
  • 253. WRUHWXUQWR0DNNDKDIWHUWKHKDGOHIWLWDVLPPLJUDQWV,WLVUHODWHGE$EGXOODKLEQ8PDUWKDW2QFH8PDUJDYHDZDDKRUVHIRUWKHFDXVHRI$OODKDVVDGDTDK/DWHUKHVDZLWIRUVDOHDQGZDQWHGWREXLW+HDVNHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHLIKHFRXOGGRVR7KH0HVVHQJHUDQVZHUHGRQRWEXEDFNZKDWRXJDYHLQVDGDTDK7KLVLVUHODWHGEDO%XNKDUL0XVOLP$EXDZXGDQGDQ1DVDL$Q1DZDZLVDVLWLVDSXULILQJSURKLELWLRQQRWRQHRIXQODZIXOQHVV,WLVXQVXLWDEOH PDNUXK
  •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
  •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
  • 256. $VIRUWKHLQGLYLGXDO ZKR LV QRW VHHNLQJ NQRZOHGJH ]DNDK LV QRW SHUPLVVLEOH IRU KLP LI KH LV DEOH WR HDUQ KLVOLYLQJ HYHQ WKRXJK KH UHVLGHV DW D VFKRRO $Q1DZDZL VDV $V IRU RQH ZKR LV HQJDJHG LQVXSHUHURJDWRUZRUVKLS QDZDILO
  •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
  • 258. ELWVSDHU/LNHZLVHLIDQLQGLYLGXDOWUXVWLQJODVVLJQVVRPHPRQHWRDSHUVRQWRNHHSDQGDWWKHWLPHRI]DNDKKHDVNVWKHDVVLJQHHWRNHHSWKHDPRXQWLQOLHXRIKLV]DNDKLWZLOOEHYDOLG7KH MXULVWV KRZHYHU DJUHH WKDW LI D SHUVRQ SDV ]DNDK WR DQRWKHU ZKR RZHV KLP PRQH DQG WKHQUHFHLYHVLWEDFNWRUHGHHPKLVORDQWRKLPWKHREOLJDWLRQWRSD]DNDKZLOOQRWEHGLVFKDUJHG,WLVDOVRLQYDOLGIRUDSHUVRQWRDFFHSW]DNDKRQWKHFRQGLWLRQWKDWKHZLOOSDLWEDFNWRWKHOHQGHU WKH]DNDKSDHU
  •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
  •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
  • 261. XQOHVVLWLVIRUQHHGUHODWLYHVDQGVHUYHVWKHWLHVRIEORRGRUZKHQWKHQHHGVRIDJURXSRI0XVOLPVDUHPRUHSUHVVLQJWKDQWKRVHRIWKHORFDOVZKHQLWLVWLHGWRWKHJHQHUDOLQWHUHVWVRIWKH0XVOLPVZKHQLWLVVRXJKWIURPDFRXQWUDWZDUDJDLQVW WKH 0XVOLPV WR WKH ODQG RI ,VODP ZKHQ LW LV LQWHQGHG IRU D VFKRODU RU ZKHQ ]DNDK LV SDLGEHIRUHWKHFRPSOHWLRQRIWKHKDZO,QWKRVHFDVHVWUDQVIHUULQJ]DNDKLVQRWGLVOLNHG PDNUXK
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 265. 0DDQLEQ<D]LGUHSRUWV0IDWKHUVHWDVLGHDIHZGLQDUVIRUVDGDTDKDQGJDYHWKHPWRDPDQLQWKHPRVTXH , ZHQW DQG WRRN WKHP DQG EURXJKW WKHP EDFN WR P IDWKHU +H VDLG % $OODK :KDW KDYHRXGRQH",FRQVXOWHGWKH3URSKHWXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDERXWLW7KH3URSKHWREVHUYHG2<D]LGIRU RX LV ZKDW RX LQWHQGHG DQG 2 0DDQ IRU RX LV ZKDW RX KDYH WDNHQ  7KLV LV UHODWHG E$KPDGDQGDO%XNKDUL7KHPHDQLQJRIWKLVKDGLWKLVWKDWVDGDTDKLVVXSHUHURJDWRU QDIO
  • 266. KRZHYHUWKH ZRUG PD PHDQLQJ ZKDW
  • 267.  LQ ODND UQD QDZDWD IRU RX LV ZKDW RX LQWHQGHG
  •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
  • 269.  JDYH ]DNDK
  •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
  • 271. WRRWKHUSHRSOH$KPDGVDV WKDWWKHUHDUHWZRRSLQLRQVFRQFHPLQJRQHSDLQJ]DNDKWRDSHUVRQZKRPKHWKRXJKWZDVSRRUDQGODWHUOHDPHGZDVULFK7KHILUVWFRQWHQGVLWZRXOGEHFRQVLGHUHG SDLG ZKLOH WKH VHFRQG VDV WKDW LW ZRXOG QRW EH :KHQ LW EHFRPHV NQRZQ WKDW RQH ZKRUHFHLYHG ]DNDK LV D VODYH DQ XQEHOLHYHU D +DVKLPLWH D SHUVRQ IURP WKH 3URSKHWV IDPLO
  • 272.  RU DQLQHOLJLEOH UHODWLYH RIWKH]DNDKSDHUWKHQRQHKDVQRWGLVFKDUJHGRQHVREOLJDWLRQWKHUHDVRQEHLQJWKDWLWLVGLIILFXOWWRNQRZZKRLVULFKDQGZKRLVSRRU7KHLJQRUDQWPDQWKLQNVWKDWVLQFHWKH>ZKRGRQRWDVNIRU@DUHPRGHVWWKHDUHIUHHIURPZDQW>DO%DTDUDK@)LTKLVFORVXUHRI6DGDTDK,WLVSHPPLVVLEOHIRUWKHSHUVRQJLYLQJVDGDTDKWRGLVFORVHKLVVDGDTDKZKHWKHULWLVRIDQREOLJDWRURUVXSHUHURJDWRUWSH QDILODK
  •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
  • 274. LVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 276. ULFHFRUQRUVLPLODULWHPVFRQVLGHUHGDVEDVLFIRRGV TXW
  • 277. $EX+DQLIDKPDGHLWSHUPLVVLEOHWRVHWDVLGHDVD]DNDWXOILWUDQHTXLYDOHQWYDOXHDQGDOVRVDLGWKDWLIWKHSDHUSDVLQZKHDWRQHKDOIRIDVDZRXOGEH VXIILFLHQW $EX 6DLG DO.KXGUL UHSRUWHG :H XVHG WR JLYH RQ EHKDOI RI HYHU FKLOG ROG SHUVRQIUHHPDQ DQG VODYH GXULQJ WKH OLIHWLPH RI WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH RQH VD RIIRRGRURQHVDRIGULHGFRWWDJHFKHHVHRURQHVDRIEDUOHRURQHVDRIGDWHVRURQHVDRIUDLVLQVDV]DNDW XOILWU :H FRQWLQXHG WR GR VR XQWLO 0XDZLDK FDPH WR XV WR SHUIRUP SLOJULPDJH KDMM
  • 278.  RU DPLQRUSLOJULPDJH XPUDK
  •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
  • 280. DQG0DOLN LQRQHRIKLVUHSRUWV
  • 281. DUHRIWKHRSLQLRQWKDWLWLVGXHDWWKHVXQVHWRIWKHQLJKWRIEUHDNLQJWKHIDVWIRUWKLVLVZKHQWKHIDVWRI5DPDGDQ HQGV $EX +DQLIDK DO/DWK DVK6KDIL LQ KLV RULJLQDO RSLQLRQ
  •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
  • 283. PDLQWDLQWKDWLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRSDLWRQORQHRUWZRGDVLQDGYDQFH7KHIRXQGHUVRIWKHIRXUDFFHSWHG,VODPLFOHJDOVFKRROVDJUHHWKDW]DNDWXOILWULVQRWQXOOLILHGVLPSOEQRWSDLQJLWRQLWVGXHGDWH,IVXFKLVWKHFDVHLWEHFRPHVDGHEWRQWKHRQHUHVSRQVLEOHIRULWXQWLOLWLVSDLG7KHDOVRDJUHHWKDWLWLVQRWSHUPLVVLEOHWRGHODLWXQWLOWKHGDRILGEXW,EQ6LULQDQGDQLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 285.  WKDW WKH ZHDOWKEHVWRZXSRQWKHSRRUUDWKHULWLVDGXH KDTT
  • 286. WKDW$OODKHQWUXVWHGLQWKHKDQGVRIWKHULFKWRGHOLYHUWRWKHSRRUDQGGLVWULEXWHDPRQJWKHGHVHUYLQJ7KXVWKHHPLQHQWWUXWKDERXWZHDOWKDQGSURSHUWLVHVWDEOLVKHGWKDW LV ZHDOWK LV QRW H[FOXVLYHO IRU WKH ULFK EXW IRU ERWK WKH ULFK DQG WKH SRRU 7KLVEHFRPHV REYLRXV EHFDXVH RI $OODKV MXGJPHQW FRQFHUQLQJ WKH GLVWULEXWLRQ RI ERRW ID
  •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
  •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
  • 289. DQGLVHQMRLQHGOLNHWKHSUHVFULEHG]DNDK:KHQHYHU WKH H[LJHQF FDOOV IRU LW VDGDTDK RWKHU WKDQ ]DNDK LV JLYHQ 7KDW FRXOG EH EHIRUH WKHFRPSOHWLRQ RI WKH HDU KDZO
  • 290.  RU DIWHU WKH SDPHQW RI ]DNDK 7KH FRQWULEXWLRQ LV QRW EDVHG RQ DVSHFLILF DPRXQW RI QLVDE EXW RQ WKH DELOLW WR JLYH 7KXV LI VRPHRQH SRVVHVVHV RQO DORDIRIEUHDGDQGVHHVDSHUVRQZKRLVPRUHKDUGSUHVVHGWKDQKLPVHOIKHVKRXOGJLYHLWWRWKDWSHUVRQ7KHKDUGSUHVVHG SHUVRQ LV QRW WKH RQO RQH ZKR KDV D ULJKW WR EH VDWLVILHG EXW $OODK KDV DOVR RUGHUHG WKHEHOLHYHUVWRJLYHQRQSUHVFULEHGVDGDTDWWRWKHIROORZLQJNLQRUSKDQVQHHGZDIDUHUVEHJJDUVDQGVODYHV)LTK.LQ ]KDZLDO4XUED
  •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
  • 292. UHFLSLHQWVRIVDGDTDK,QWKHFDVHRIRUSKDQVZKRVHJXDUGLDQVKDYHGLHGWKHLUVXSSRUWDQGXSEULQJLQJGHSHQGVRQZHDOWKDQGZHOOWRGR0XVOLPVVRWKDWWKHZLOOQRWEHFRPHDSUREOHPWRWKHPVHOYHVRURWKHUSHRSOH)LTKE7KH1HHG ZDOPDVDNLQ
  • 293. UHFLSLHQWVRIVDGDTDK%HFDXVHWKHDUHXQDEOHWRHDUQHQRXJKWRPDLQWDLQWKHPVHOYHVDQGKDYHEHFRPHFRQWHQWHGZLWKWKHOLWWOHWKHKDYHDQGDEVWDLQIURPEHJJLQJLWLVQHFHVVDUIRUWKHZHOOWRGRWRKHOSWKHP)LTK:DIDUHUH ZDEQLVDELO
  • 294. UHFLSLHQWVRIVDGDTDK,Q WKH FDVH RI WKH ZDIDUHU FXW RII IURP IDPLO DQG UHODWLYHV DV LI WUDYHOLQJ ZHUH KLV KRXVHKROGFRQVLGHUDWLRQ UHTXLUHV NLQGQHVV IRU KLP DV ZHOO 7KXV WR VPSDWKL]H ZLWK KLP DQG KHOS KLP LQ KLVWUDYHOV LV ZLWKLQ WKH PHDQLQJ RI ,VODPLF ODZ DQ HQFRXUDJHPHQW ZKLFK LQYLWHV RQH WR MRXUQHWKURXJKRXWWKHHDUWK)LTKD%HJJDUV ZDVVDLOLQ
  • 295. UHFLSLHQWVRIVDGDTDK,QWKHFDVHRIEHJJDUVIRUFHGWRDVNSHRSOHIRUWKHLUQHHGVWKHVKRXOGEHKHOSHG$SHUVRQPDDOVRDVN IRU KHOS LQ RUGHU WR UHGUHVV DQRWKHUV QHHG +RZHYHU WKH VKDULDK GRHV QRW DSSURYH RI EHJJLQJH[FHSWXQGHUGLUHFLUFXPVWDQFHV(YHQWKHQRQHVKRXOGQRWWUHVSDVVOLPLWV)LTKE6ODYHV ZDILDUULTDE
  • 296. UHFLSLHQWVRIVDGDTDK7KH OLEHUDWLRQ RI VODYHV LQFOXGHV EXLQJ DQG VHWWLQJ WKHP IUHH KHOSLQJ FRQWUDFWHG VODYHV DOPXNDWDEXQ
  • 297. SDRIIWKHLUGHEWVDQGKHOSLQJFDSWLYHVEXWKHLUZDRXWRIFDSWLYLW%HQFRXUDJLQJSHRSOH WR VSHQG RXW RI WKHLU ZHDOWK RQ VODYHV WKH VKDUL DK ZDQWV WR HPDQFLSDWH WKH ODWWHU 6WLOO DVLPSRUWDQW DV WKH HPDQFLSDWLRQ RI VODYHV LV LQ WHUPV RI SULRULWLHV LW LV SODFHG DW WKH HQG DIWHU WKHRUSKDQVWKHQHHGWKHZDIDUHUDQGWKHEHJJDUWKHUHDVRQEHLQJWKDWWKHIRUPHUIDOOXQGHUWKHQHHGIRUSUHVHUYLQJOLIH ZKLFKKDVDKLJKHUYDOXH
  • 298. ZKLOHWKHODWWHUIDOOVXQGHUWKHULJKWWRIUHHGRP DOHVVHUYDOXHWKDQOLIH
  • 299. )LTKF6DGDTDKRWKHUWKHQ=DNDWLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 300. 7KHOHJLWLPDFRIJLYLQJVDGDTDKRWKHUWKDQWKDWRI]DNDKLVQRWUHVWULFWHGEDWLPHOLPLWRUGHILQLWHQLVDE7KHDPRXQWGHVLJQDWHGIRUH[SHQGLWXUHQHHGQRWEHDFHUWDLQSHUFHQWDJH IRUH[DPSOHDWLWKHDRQHTXDUWHU WLWKH RU D RQHWHQWK WLWKH
  • 301.  ,W LV DQ RSHQHQGHG PDWWHU WKDW LV OHIW WR WKH EHQHILFHQFHJHQHURVLW DQG FRQGLWLRQ RI WKH RQH ZKR JLYHV 7KH SURWHFWLRQ RI D UHYHUHG PXKWDUDP
  • 302.  PDQ IURPGHVWUXFWLRQ DQG KDUP LV DQ REOLJDWLRQ XSRQ ZKRHYHU FDQ KHOS KLP EXW PRUH WKDQ WKDW LW LV OHIWXQTXDQWLILHG3HRSOHRYHUORRNPRVWRIWKHSXEOLFULJKWVZKLFKWKH4XUDQVXSSRUWVIRUWKHVHULJKWVVHHNWRHVWDEOLVKDQ KRQRUDEOH DQG MXVW VRFLDO OLIH 3HRSOH VSHQG RQO D VPDO, DPRXQW RQ WKH QHHG DQG HYHQ OHVV IRUEHJJDUVEHFDXVHWKHDUHFRQVLGHUHGWKHOHDVWGHVHUYLQJQRZDGDV7KLVLVGXHWRWKHIDFWWKDWEHJJDUVKDYHPDGHEHJJLQJDSURIHVVLRQ KLUIDK
  • 303. HYHQ WKRXJKPRVWRIWKHPDUHZHOOWRGR,EQ+D]PVDV,WLVHQMRLQHGXSRQWKHULFKRIHYHUFRXQWUWRVXSSRUWWKHLUSRRUDQGWKHUXOHUKDVWKHDXWKRULWWRIRUFHWKHPWRGRVR7KLVLVFDOOHGIRUZKHQWKHSUHa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
  • 304. 7KLVLVFRQVLGHUHGWREHWKHPRVWDXWKHQWLFUHSRUW$OLVDLG$OODKWKH([DOWHG2QHKDVSODFHGDGXHXSRQWKHSURSHUWLHVRIWKHULFKWRPHHWWKHQHHGVRIWKHSRRU7KXVLIWKHSRRUJRKXQJURUQDNHGRUVWUXJJOHEHFDXVHRIWKHQHJOHFWRIWKHULFKWKHQ$OODKZLOOKROGWKHP>WKHULFK@DFFRXQWDEOHRQWKHDRI-XGJPHQWDQGZLOOSXQLVKWKHP,EQ 8PDU LV UHSRUWHG WR KDYH VDLG 7KHUH LV D GXH RQ RXU SURSHUW RWKHU WKDQ ]DNDK ,W LV UHODWHGIURP $LVKDK WKH PRWKHU RI WKH EHOLHYHUV
  • 305.  DO+DVDQ LEQ $OL ,EQ 8PDU WKDW DOO RI WKHP UHSOLHG WRWKRVH ZKR KDG DVNHG WKHP ,I RX DUH DVNHG IRU KHOS LQ FDVHV RI EORRG PRQH KHDY GHEW RUGHVSHUDWHSRYHUWWKHQLWLVDPXVWIRURXWRJLYHWKHPIURPRXUKROGLQJVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 306. ,WZDVDFFXUDWHOUHSRUWHGE$EX8EDLGDKLEQDO-DUUDKDQGFRPSDQLRQVWKDW RQFH
  •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
  • 308.  ZLOO EH LPSRVHG XSRQ WKHNLOOHU,IWKHSURSHUWKROGHUZKRSUHYHQWVKLPIURPUHFHLYLQJKLVGXHLVNLOOHG WKHQPDKHKDYHWKHFXUVHRI$OODKXSRQKLPEHFDXVHKHZLWKKHOGDULJKW KDTT
  •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
  •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
  • 311. 2QHVFKLOGUHQIDPLODQGUHODWLYHVKDYHSUHFHGHQFHRYHURWKHUV,WLVQRWSHUPLVVLEOHWRJLYHVDGDTDKWRDVWUDQJHUZKHQRXDQGRXUGHSHQGHQWVDUHLQQHHGRILW,WLVUHODWHGIURP-DELUWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KHQRQHRIRXLVSRRUKHVWDUWVZLWKKLPVHOI,IDQWKLQJLVOHIWKHVSHQGVLWRQKLVGHSHQGHQWV,IDQWKLQJLV VWLOOOHIW
  •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
  • 313.  2 P /RUG 2 P /RUG +LV IRRG ZDVXQODZIXO KLV GULQN ZDV XQODZIXO KLV FORWKLQJ ZDV XQODZIXO DQG ZKDW KH KDG SURYLGHG WR VXVWDLQKLPVHOIZLWKZDVDOVRXQODZIXO+RZFRXOGKLVLQYRFDWLRQEHDFFHSWHG"7KLVLVUHODWHGE0XVOLP$OVR,IRQHJLYHVDGDWHERXJKWIURPKRQHVWOHDUQHGPRQH DQG$OODKDFFHSWVRQOJRRG
  • 314. $OODKDFFHSWV LW LQ +LV ULJKW KDQG DQG HQODUJHV >LWV UHZDUGV@ IRU LWV RZQHU DV RQH UHDUV KLV IRDO
  •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
  •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
  • 317. SHDFH =XEDLU LV D ZHOORII PDQ $ PDQ LQ QHHG DSSURDFKHG PH DQG , JDYH KLP VDGDTDK IURP PKXVEDQGV KRXVHKROG ZLWKRXW KLV SHUPLVVLRQ 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG*LYHZKDWRXDUHLQWKHKDELWRIJLYLQJRIZKDWLVVPDOODQGGRQRWVWRUHSURSHUWDZDIRU$OODKVKDOOZLWKKROGKLVEOHVVLQJVIURPRX7KLVLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDO%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP)LTKE3HUPLVVLELOLWRI*LYLQJ6DGDTDKRI$OO2QHV3URSHUW)RURQHZKRLVILWDQGFDSDEOHRIHDUQLQJKLVOLYLQJJLYLQJVDGDTDKRIDOOKLVSURSHUWLVSHUPLVVLEOH8PDUUHSRUWV7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHLQVWUXFWHGXVWRJLYHVDGDTDKDQGLWDSSOLHG WR P SURSHUW , VDLG 7RGD , VKDOO EHWWHU $EX %DNU , KDYH QHYHU EHWWHUHG KLP 7KHQ ,EURXJKWKDOIPSURSHUW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHVDLG:KDWGLGRXOHDYHIRURXUIDPLO",VDLG$QDPRXQWOLNHWKLV$EX%DNUFDPHZLWKDOOKLVSURSHUWDQGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDVNHG:KDWGLGRXOHDYHIRURXUIDPLO"+HVDLG,KDYHOHIW$OODKDQG +LV 0HVVHQJHU XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH IRU WKHP 7KHQ , VDLG , VKDOO QHYHU EHWWHU RX LQDQWKLQJ7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EXDZXGDQGDW7LUPL]KL7KHODWWHUJUDGHVLWDXWKHQWLF)LTK*LYLQJDOORIRQHVSURSHUWLQVDGDTDK7KH MXULVWV VD WKDW JLYLQJ DOO RI RQHV SURSHUW LQ VDGDTDK LV SHUPLVVLEOH SURYLGHG WKH GRQRU LV ILWHDUQLQJ DQG VWHDGIDVW QRW LQ GHEW QRU KDV GHSHQGHQWV IRU ZKRP DGHTXDWH VXSSRUW IURP KLP LVREOLJDWRU,IKHGRHVQRWIXOILOWKHVHFRQGLWLRQVWKHQKLVDFWLRQLVPDNUXK-DELUQDUUDWHG:KLOHZHZHUHZLWKWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHDPDQFDPHZLWKZKDWZDVOLNHDQHJJRIJROG+HVDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK,REWDLQHGWKLVIURPEXULHGWUHDVXUHVRWDNHLW,WLVVDGDTDK DQG,GRQRWSRVVHVVDQWKLQJRWKHUWKDQLW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHWXUQHGDZDIURPKLPDQGKH>WKHPDQ@WKHQDSSURDFKHGKLPIURPWKHGLUHFWLRQRIKLVOHIWVLGH 7KH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH WKHQ WXUQHG DZD IURP KLP DJDLQ DQG KHDSSURDFKHGKLPIURPEHKLQG7KHQWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKXSRQZKRPEHSHDFHWRRNLWDQGWKUHZLWDW KLP ,I LW KDG KLW KLP LW ZRXOG KDYH LQMXUHG KLP 7KHQ KH VDLG 2QH RI RX FRPHV ZLWK DOO KLVSURSHUWWRPDNHVDGDTDKWKHQDIWHU>JLYLQJDOOKHKDG@KHVLWV>EWKHURDG@EHJJLQJIURPWKHSHRSOH6DGDTDKLVJLYHQEWKHRQHZKRLVULFK7KLVLVUHODWHGE$EXDZXGDQG+DNLP7KHODWWHUVDLG,WLVDXWKHQWLFDFFRUGLQJWRWKHVWLSXODWLRQRI0XVOLP,QLWVWUDQVFULSWLRQLV0XKDPPDGLEQ,VKDT)LTKD*LYLQJ6DGDTDKWRWKH=KLPPLDQGWKH6ROGLHU2QH FDQ JLYH VDGDTDK WR WKH ]KLPPL DQG WKH VROGLHU DQG RQH LV UHZDUGHG IRU WKDW $OODK SUDLVHG DJURXS RI SHRSOH IRU WKLV
  •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
  • 319.  $KPDG DQG 0XVOLP UHODWH WKDW WKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODKXSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG :KHQ D SHUVRQ GLHV >WKH EHQHILW@ RI KLV GHHGV HQGV H[FHSW WKUHH DLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 321. $V6LDP JHQHUDOO PHDQV WR DEVWDLQ IURP VRPHWKLQJ )RU H[DPSOH D YHUVH LQ WKH 4XUDQ VDV ,KDYHYRZHGWRWKH0HUFLIXOWRDEVWDLQWKDWLVIURPVSHDNLQJ:KDWLVPHDQWKHUHLVDEVWDLQLQJIURPIRRGGULQNDQGVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVHIURPGDZQXQWLOVXQVHWZLWKWKHH[SOLFLWLQWHQWLRQRIGRLQJVR IRUWKHVDNHRI$OODK
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 326. )LTK6LJKWLQJRIWKH&UHVFHQWERQH3HUVRQ7KH VFKRODUV RI ILTK DJUHH WKDW LI RQO RQH SHUVRQ VHHV WKH QHZ PRRQKHLVWRIDVW$WDGLIIHUVDQGVDVWKDWKHLVQRWWRIDVWXQWLOVRPHRQHHOVHDOVRVLJKWVWKHQHZPRRQZLWKKLP7KHFRUUHFWSRVLWLRQLVWKDWKHLVWREUHDNWKHIDVWDVDVK6KDILDQG$EX7KDXUKDYHUXOHG7KH3URSKHWKDVEDVHGWKHIDVWDQGLWVEUHDNLQJRQWKHVLJKWLQJRIWKHPRRQ2QHVRZQVLJKWLVHQRXJKIRUKLPDQGWKHUHLVQRQHHGIRUDQRWKHUSHUVRQVVLJKWLQJ)LTKD7KH(VVHQWLDO(OHPHQWVRIWKH)DVW7KH IDVW KDV WZR HVVHQWLDO HOHPHQWV OLWHUDOO SLOODUV
  •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
  • 328. 7KLVLVUHODWHGE$KPDGDQ1DVDLDW7LUPL]KL$EXDZXGDQG,EQ0DMDK,EQ.KX]DLPDKDQG,EQ+LEEDQKDYHFODVVLILHGLWDVVDKLK7KHLQWHQWLRQLVYDOLGGXULQJDQSDUWRIWKHQLJKW,WQHHGQRWEHVSRNHQDVLWLVLQUHDOLWDQDFWRIWKHKHDUWZKLFKGRHVQRWLQYROYHWKHWRQJXH,WZLOOEHIXOILOOHGERQHVLQWHQWLRQWRIDVWRXWRIREHGLHQFHWR$OODKDQGIRUVHHNLQJ+LVSOHDVXUH,I RQH HDWV RQHV SUHGDZQ PHDO VDKRRU
  •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
  •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
  • 331. :HVKDOOGLVFXVVHDFKJURXSLQPRUHGHWDLO)LTKD(VVHQWLDOHOHPHQWVRIIDVWLQJWKHIDVWRIWKHLQVDQH)DVWLQJ LV QRW REOLJDWRU IRU WKH LQVDQH EHFDXVH RI WKHLU LQDELOLW WR XQGHUVWDQG ZKDW WKHDUHGRLQJ$OL UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VDLG 7KH SHQ LV UDLVHG IRU WKUHH JURXSV >RILVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 335. EDEWKHPXVWSDWKHUDQVRPDQGPDNHXSWKHGDVODWHU,IWKHIHDURQOIRUWKHPVHOYHVRUIRUWKHPVHOYHVDQGWKHEDEWKHQWKHDUHRQOWRPDNHXSWKHPLVVHGGDVDWDODWHUGDWH)LTK0DNLQJXSWKH0LVVHGDVRI)DVWLQJ,W LV DOORZHG IRU WKRVH ZKR DUH QRW FKURQLFDOO
  •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
  •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
  • 338. $EX+DQLIDKDVK6KDILDQG0DOLNDUHRIWKHRSLQLRQWKDWLIRQHKDVWKHDELOLWWRIDVWLWLVEHWWHUIRUKLPWRGRVRDQGLIRQHGRHVQRWKDYHWKHDELOLWWRIDVWLWLVEHWWHUIRUKLPWREUHDNWKHIDVW$KPDGVDLGWKDWLWLVEHVWWREUHDNWKHIDVW8PDULEQ$EGXOD]L]VDV7KHEHVWRIWKHWZRDFWVLVWKHHDVLHURIWKHWZR,ILWLVHDVLHUIRURQHWRIDVWWKDQWRPDNHXSWKHGDODWHURQWKHQLQKLVFDVHWRIDVWLVEHWWHULVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  • 339. $VK6KDXNDQLKDVFRQFOXGHGWKDWLILWLVGLIILFXOWIRUDQLQGLYLGXDOWRIDVWRUWRUHMHFWWKHFRQFHVVLRQWKHQ LW LV EHVW IRU KLP QRW WR IDVW ZKLOH WUDYHOLQJ
  • 340.  6LPLODUO LI RQH IHDUV WKDW RQHV IDVWLQJ GXULQJWUDYHOZLOOORRNOLNHVKRZLQJRIIWKHQLQWKLVFDVHEUHDNLQJWKHIDVWZRXOGEHSUHIHUUHG,IRQHLVQRWIDFHGZLWKVXFKFRQGLWLRQVWKHQIDVWLQJZRXOGEHSUHIHUUHG,I D WUDYHOHU PDNHV WKH LQWHQWLRQ WRIDVW
  •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
  • 342. ,WLVQRWSHUPLVVLEOHWRIDVWGXULQJWKHWKUHHGDVIROORZLQJWKH,GDO$]KD$EX+XUDLUDKUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK XSRQ ZKRP EH SHDFH VHQW $EGXOODK LEQ +X]KDTDK WR DQQRXQFH DW 0LQD<RXDUHQRWWRIDVWWKHVHGDV7KHDUHGDVRIHDWLQJDQGGULQNLQJDQGUHPHPEHULQJ$OODK7KLVLVUHODWHGE$KPDGZLWKDJRRGFKDLQLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 351. $QGKHVDLG,WLVOLNHIDVWLQJWKHZKROHHDU7KLVLVUHODWHGEDQ1DVDLDQGE,EQ+LEEDQZKRFDOOHGLWVDKLK,W LV UHODWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW ZRXOG IDVW RQ 6DWXUGD 6XQGD DQG 0RQGD RI RQH PRQWK DQG RQ7XHVGD :HGQHVGD DQG 7KXUVGD RI WKH QH[W PRQWK +H ZRXOG DOVR IDVW IRU WKUHH GDV DW WKHEHJLQQLQJRIWKHPRQWKRURQWKHILUVW7KXUVGDDQGWKHQH[WWZR0RQGDVRIWKHPRQWK)LTKE)DVWLQJRQHGDDQGQRWIDVWLQJWKHQH[WLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  • 353. )LTKE)DVWLQJWKHWLPHIRUWKHSUHGDZQPHDO7KHWLPHIRUWKHSUHGDZQPHDOLVEHWZHHQWKHPLGGOHRIWKHQLJKWDQGGDZQ,WLVFRQVLGHUHGEHVWWRGHOD LW WKDW LV DV FORVH WR GDZQ D SRVVLEOH
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 358. ,IGXULQJWKHEDWKVRPHZDWHULVVZDOORZHGXQLQWHQWLRQDOOWKHIDVWLVVWLOOYDOLG)LTK)DVWLQJDSSOLQJNRKORUHHGURSVRUDQWKLQJHOVHWRWKHHHV7KHVHDFWVDUHDOOSHUPLVVLEOHHYHQLIVRPHWDVWHIURPLWILQGVLWVZDWRWKHWKURDWDVWKHHHVDUHQRWDSDVVDJHZDWRWKHVWRPDFK$QDVUHSRUWHGWKDWKHZRXOGDSSONRKOZKLOHKHZDVIDVWLQJ7KLVLVWKHRSLQLRQRIWKH6KDILDK,EQDO0XQ]KLUUHFRUGVWKHVDPHRSLQLRQIURP$WDDO+DVVDQDQ1DNKDLDO$XaDL $EX +DQLIDK $EX 7KDXU DQG DZXG ,W LV UHODWHG IURP WKH IROORZLQJ FRPSDQLRQV ,EQ8PDU$QDVDQG,EQ$EX$XID$FFRUGLQJWRDW7LUPL]KLQRWKLQJDXWKHQWLFKDVEHHQUHODWHGIURPWKH3URSKHWFRQFHUQLQJWKLVTXHVWLRQ)LTKD)DVWLQJNLVVLQJIRURQHZKRKDVWKHDELOLWWRFRQWUROKLPVHOILVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 361.  /DTLW LEQ 6DEUD UHSRUWHG WKDW WKH 3URSKHW VDLG([DJJHUDWHZKHQULQVLQJRXUQRVHXQOHVVRXDUHIDVWLQJ7KLVLVUHODWHGEDQ1DVDL$EXDZXGDW7LUPL]KLDQG,EQ0DMDK$W7LUPL]KLFDOOHGLWKDVVDQVDKLK6FKRODUV GLVOLNH XVLQJ QRVH GURSV WKDWLVDSSOLQJPHGLFLQHWKURXJKWKHQRVH
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 365. DWWKDWWLPHKHVKRXOGLPPHGLDWHOVWRS,IKHGRHVVRKLVIDVWZLOOVWLOOEHYDOLG ,I KH FRQWLQXHV LQ WKHVH DFWLRQV DW WKDW WLPH KH ZLOO KDYH EURNHQ KLV IDVW $O%XNKDUL DQG0XVOLPUHFRUGIURP$LVKDKWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG%LODOPDNHVWKHFDOOWRSUDHUZKLOHLWLVVWLOOQLJKWWKHUHIRUHHDWDQGGULQNXQWLO,EQ8PP0DNWXPPDNHVWKHFDOOWRSUDHU)LTKD,WLVSHUPLVVLEOHIRUWKHIDVWLQJSHUVRQWREHVH[XDOOGHILOHGLQWKHPRUQLQJ WKDWLVDSHUVRQLVQRWUHTXLUHGWRSHUIRUPJKXVOEHIRUHIDMU
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 369. $O+DIL]KGLIIHUV7KLVLVQRWFRUUHFW,WZDVMXVWRQHHYHQWDQGWKHSDUWV DUHDOOXQLWHG6RWKHFUX[RIWKHPDWWHULVWKDWWKHUHZDVQRWPRUHWKDQRQHHYHQW6RPHFRPELQHWKHUHSRUWVDQGVDWKDWIROORZLQJWKHRUGHULVSUHIHUUHGEXWWKDWRQHPDFKRRVH2WKHUVVDWKHRSSRVLWH:KRHYHUKDVVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH ZLWKKLVZLIH
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 375. SHUIRUPHGHOVHZKHUHZKZRXOG$OODKH[FOXVLYHOGLVDOORZFRPLQJWRRQHVZLIHGXULQJLWLNDI7KHDQVZHULVWKDWVLQFHVXFKDQDFWZRXOGQXOOLILWLNDI QRPDWWHUZKHUHLWLVSHIRUPHG
  •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
  •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
  •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
  • 379. TXLFNHQHGWKHLUSDFH
  •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
  • 381. LWLNDIIRULWLVDQLOOHJDOWRXFKUHJDUGOHVVRIZKHWKHU WKHSHUVRQLQYROYHGHMDFXODWHVRUQRW)URPDVK6KDIaLWKHUHDUHWZRUHSRUWVWKDWFRUUHVSRQGWRWKHWZRSUHFHGLQJRSLQLRQV,EQ5XVKGH[SODLQVWKDW7KHUHDVRQIRUWKHLUGLIIHUHQFHVRIRSLQLRQLV>WKH IDFW
  •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
  • 383. $EX6DLGUHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWSHUIRUPHGLWLNDIXQGHUD7XUNLVKWHQWZKLFKKDGVRPHWKLQJRYHULWVRSHQLQJV)LTKD0DNLQJD9RZWR3HUIRUP,WLNDILQD6SHFLILF0RVTXH,IVRPHRQHPDNHVDYRZWRSHUIRUPLWLNDILQWKH0DVMLGDO+DUDP LQ0DNNDK
  • 384. WKH3URSKHWV0RVTXH LQ0DGLQDK
  • 385. RULQWKH$TVD0RVTXH LQ-HUXVDOHP
  • 386. KHLVWRIXOILOOKLVYRZDVWKH3URSKHWVDLG2QHVKRXOG QRW XQGHUWDNH MRXUQHV H[FHSW WR WKUHH PRVTXHV WKH 0DVMLG DO+DUDP WKH $TVD PRVTXH RUWKLVPRVTXH,IVRPHRQHYRZVWRSHUIRUPLWLNDILQDQRWKHUPRVTXHLWLVQRWREOLJDWRURQKLPWRIXOILOOLWDQGKHPDSHUIRUPWKDWLWLNDILQDQPRVTXHIRU$OODKGLGQRWVSHFLIDQSDUWLFXODUSODFHIRU+LVZRUVKLSDQG WKHUH LV QR VXSHULRULW RI RQH PRVTXH RYHU DQRWKHU ZLWK WKH H[FHSWLRQ RI WKH WKUHH PRVTXHVPHQWLRQHGHDUOLHU
  • 387. ,WKDVEHHQFRQILUPHGWKDWWKH3URSKHWVDLG$SUDHULQPPRVTXHLVVXSHULRUWRRQH WKRXVDQG SUDHUV LQ DQ RWKHU PRVTXH EXW WKH 0DVMLG DO+DUDP DQG D SUDHU LQ WKDW PRVTXH LVVXSHULRUWRDSUDHULQPPRVTXHERQHKXQGUHGSUDHUVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP 
  •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
  •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
  • 390. UHZDUGHG$QDVQDUUDWHV,KHDUGWKH3URSKHWSHDFHEHXSRQKLPVDLQJ$OODKVDV:KHQ,DIIOLFWDVHUYDQWRIPLQHZLWKUHVSHFWWRKLVWZRPRVWEHORYHGWKLQJV PHDQLQJKLVHHV
  • 391. DQGKHHQGXUHVLWSDWLHQWO,JUDQWKLPSDUDGLVHLQUHWXUQ$WDLEQ5DEDKUHODWHGWKDWKHKHDUG,EQ$EEDVVD6KDOO,VKRZRXDZRPDQRI3DUDGLVH",VDLG<HVLQGHHG+HVDLG$EODFNZRPDQFDPHWRWKH3URSKHWSHDFHEHXSRQKLPDQGVDLG,VXIIHUIURPHSLOHSWLFILWVDQGEHFDXVHRIWKHVH DWWLPHV
  • 392. PERGEHFRPHVXQFRYHUHG:RXOGRXLQYRNH$OODK WKH ([DOWHG 2QH WR FXUH PH RI WKLV GLVHDVH"  7KH 3URSKHW SHDFH EH XSRQ KLP VDLG ,I RXZLVKRXFDQEHSDWLHQWDQGRXZLOODWWDLQ3DUDGLVH IRUWKLVVXIIHULQJ
  • 393. %XWLIRXSUHIHU,ZLOOSUDWR $OODK WKH ([DOWHG WR FXUH RX RI LW" 7KH ZRPDQ VDLG , ZLOO EH SDWLHQW WKHQ DGGHG , EHFRPHXQFRYHUHG ZKHQ , KDYH ILWV
  • 394.  VR LQYRNH $OODK IRU PH WKDW , GR QRW EHFRPH XQFRYHUHG  6R WKH3URSKHWSHDFHEHXSRQKLPSUDHGIRUKHU)LTK7R&RPSODLQRI2QHV,OOQHVV,WLVSHUPLWWHGIRUDSDWLHQWWRFRPSODLQRIKLVSDLQDQGLOOQHVVWRDSKVLFLDQRUDIULHQGSURYLGHGKHGRHV QRW GR VR WR H[SUHVV KLV RU KHU DQJHU RU LPSDWLHQFH ,W ZDV PHQWLRQHG HDUOLHU WKDW WKH 3URSKHWSHDFHEHXSRQKLPVDLG0IHYHULVDVVHYHUHDVWKDWRIDQWZRRIRX2QFH$LVKDFRPSODLQHGWRWKH 0HVVHQJHU RI $OODK SHDFH EH XSRQ KLP DERXW KHU KHDGDFKH ODPHQWLQJ 2 P KHDG +HUHWRUWHG1DUDWKHU ,VKRXOGVD
  • 395. 2PKHDG/LNHZLVHLWLVUHSRUWHGWKDW$EGXOODKLEQ$O=XEDLUDVNHGKLVDLOLQJPRWKHU$VPDELQW$EL%DNU+RZDUHRXIHHOLQJQRZ"6KHUHSOLHG,DPLQSDLQ$SDWLHQWVKRXOGWKDQNDQGSUDLVH$OODKEHIRUHWDONLQJDERXWKLVGLVWUHVVDQGFRPSODLQW,EQ 0DVXG VDLG ,I RQH WKDQNV $OODK EHIRUH FRPSODLQLQJ DERXW KLV SDLQ RU GLVHDVH WKHQ LW LV QRWFRQVLGHUHGLPSDWLHQFH,QGHHGWRUHIHURQHVFRPSODLQWWR$OODKLVTXLWHODZIXO-DFRE WKHSURSKHW
  • 396. VDLG , FRPSODLQ RI P GLVWUDFWLRQ DQG DQJXLVK RQO WR $OODK 7KH 3URSKHW 0XKDPPDG SHDFH EHXSRQKLPKLPVHOISUDHG2$OODKWR<RX,FRPSODLQRIPZHDNQHVVLVODPPHVVDJHFRP