2. Objectives
Be familiar with the definition of Psychology /
Counselling
To understand the “Scientific Method”
Understand why Psychology is a science and
evidence based practice for counselling
Be familiar with the historical roots of Psychology &
Counselling
Understand the different research methods used by
psychologists
3. What is Psychology?
Psychology comes from the root words psyche, or
mind, and logos, or study
Psychology is defined as the ‘scientific study of
behavior and mental processes’.
4. What is Counselling?
McLeod (2003, p6)defines it as “Counselling is a
purposeful private conversation arising from the
intention of one person to reflect on and resolve a
problem in living, and the willingness of another
person to assist in that endeavour.”
5. Why is Psychology a Science?
Psychology is an objective and
systematic study of how people
behave and think.
Its goals are to describe, explain,
predict, and control behavior and
mental processes.
7. Historical Origins of ψ from
Philosophy
Rene Descartes
Beliefs
Rationalist: True knowledge comes through reasoning
Nativist: Heredity provides individuals with inborn
knowledge and abilities and we use this to reason
We are to doubt everything – that’s the only way we
can be certain about anything
I think, therefore I am.
9. Historical Origins of ψ from
Philosophy
John Locke
Saw the mind as receptive and passive, with its main
goal as sensing and perceiving
Tabula rasa – we are born as a blank slate, everything
we know is learned
This is in direct contrast to the rationalist Descartes
11. Psychology Becomes More
Scientific
Hermann Helmholtz
He was a mechanist – he believed that everything can
be understood with basic physical and chemical
principles
He pushed for the need to test and demonstrate things.
13. Psychology Becomes More
Scientific
Gustav Fechner
Psychophysics – he pushed to investigate the
relationship between the physical world and our
conscious psychological world
He thought it possible to measure the perceived as well
as the physical intensities of sensory stimuli and to
determine a mathematical relationship
Just noticeable difference (JND) approach
15. The Father of Psychology
Wilhelm Wundt
1st ψ lab (1879)
University of Leipzig, Germany
Focus on consciousness
Find basic elements of conscious processes
Discover how elements (sensations and feelings) are
connected
Specify laws of connection
Introspection
Self-observation: ‘seeing’ mental processes in immediate
experience
16. The First Schools of ψ
Structuralism
Lots of work on sensation & perception and breaking
those down into minute detail
Three basic mental elements
Images, feelings & sensations
Titchner
Found 43,000 elements associated with sensory experiences
30,000 associated with visual
11,000 associated with auditory
4 associated with taste (was correct with this one)
17. The First Schools of ψ
Functionalism
Focus on adaptation
Applying Darwin’s theory of natural selection to mental
processes
William James
Stream of consciousness
Consciousness is personal/selective, continuous (can’t be ‘cut
up’ for analysis), and constantly changing
Structuralism was foolish to search for common elements to all
minds
18. The First Schools of ψ
Behaviorism
Focus on observable behavior
J. B. Watson
Felt that the main goal of psychology should be the
prediction and control of behavior
Stimulus-response theory
We respond to stimuli with our behavior, not thoughts
Pavlov’s dog studies
Reinforcement for behavior
If our behavior produces rewarding consequences, then we
will do it again
19. Subsequent Schools of ψ
Gestalt psychology
Wholes vs. multiple individual elements
You shouldn’t dissect an experience into separate
elements to discover truths – instead, look at the
‘whole’
20. Subsequent Schools of ψ
Freud’s Psychodynamic Theory
Conscious vs. unconscious conflicts
Unconscious: motivations and memories of which we are
not aware
Mental illness arises from being overwhelmed by which of
these is ‘in control’
Psychoanalysis as therapy: tell me about your
childhood….
21. Western History of Psychology
Early dates
Greek philosophers: Studied the nature of the mind, the
(Socrates, Plato,
soul, the body, and human
Aristotle)
experience
17th Century
Rene Descartes
Nativist View:
some ideas are innate
John Locke
Empiricist View:
Knowledge is acquired through
experiences & interactions with the
world
1869
Sir Francis Galton of
England
Studied individual differences> dev’t of
intelligence tests
1879
Wilhelm Wundt
Father of Psychology
Established the first psychological
laboratory (Germany @ Leipzig Univ. )
Research: senses (vision), attention,
emotion and memory
22. History continues…
1883
Granville Stanley First American to finish doctoral studies
Hall
in psychology
Established the 1st psychological
laboratory (US @ John Hopkins Univ)
Founded the 1st American Journal of
psychology
1888
James McKeen
Cattell
1st psychology professor in the US
19th Century
Titchener
Structuralism:
Specified mental structures & analyzed the
basic elements of mental life.
Introspection: the examination of one’s own
emotional states & mental processes.
William James
Functionalism:
Functions of the mind & behavior to adapt
to the environment
23. 1920’s
John B. Watson
Ivan Pavlov
B.F. Skinner
Behaviorism:
Only observable behavior should be
studied
Classical Conditioning
Operant Conditioning
1912
Max Wertheimer
Gestalt Psychology:
“Gestalt” means form or configuration
“the whole is greater than the sum of its
parts”
20th Century
Sigmund Freud
Psychoanalysis:
Human behavior is deeply influenced by
unconscious thoughts, impulses, & desires
(sex & aggression)
Recent dev’ts
Herbert Simon
Views humans as information processing
systems
Modern Linguistics: study of how mental
structures are required to comprehend &
speak a language
Neuropsychology:
studies the relationship between
neurobiological events & mental processes
Noam Chomsky
24.
25. Perspectives in Psychology and
counselling
Psychodynamic Approach
Behavioral Approach
Cognitive Approach
Biological or Behavioral Neuroscience Approach
The Phenomenological or Humanistic Approach
The Sociocultural Approach
The Evolutionary Psychology Approach
Systemic approach
26. Psychodynamic Approach
Developed by Sigmund Freud
States that “much of our behavior
stems from unconscious
processes, conflict between
biological instincts & society’s
demands, and early family
experiences.
Basis for the therapeutic approach
called psychoanalysis
27. Behavioral Approach
John B. Watson: father of Behaviorism
Behaviors are activities of people or other organisms
that can be observed by others.
States that “when we attempt to understand an
event, we need to look at the observable behaviors
& their environmental determinants”.
Little Albert experiment.
28. Cognitive Approach
Concerned with mental processes, such as
perceiving, remembering, reasoning, deciding, and
problem solving.
States that “Only by studying mental processes can
we fully understand what people do.”
29. Biological Approach
Concerned with how the brain and nervous system
underlie behavior & mental processes.
Attempts to relate behavior to electrical and
chemical events taking place inside the body
The Nervous System (brain) and the Endocrine
System are studied to determine the biological
causes of behavior.
30. Phenomenological or Humanistic Approach
Focuses on the subjective and personal
experience of events (Individual
Phenomenology) , and on the need for
personal growth.
Concerned with describing the inner life
and experiences of individuals, rather
than developing theories or predicting
behaviors.
31. Sociocultural
Approach
Studies the ways by which social and cultural
environments influence behavior
A person’s cultural context should be considered in
order to understand behavior.
Focuses on comparing behaviors across countries
as well as across cultures within a country.
32. The Evolutionary Psychology
Emphasizes the importance of adaptation,
reproduction, and survival of the fittest in explaining
behavior.
Focuses on the conditions that allow people to fail or
survive.
33. Systemic approaches
These focus on the feedback loops within the family
system that cause “double bind” or “catch 22”
situations that cause the presenting problems.
The solution is the problem focus
The Structures (Munichian) or feedback loops
(Milan) cause the issues.
34. Research Methods of Psychology
Experimental Method
Quasi-experimental Method
Correlational Method
The Naturalistic Observation Method
The Survey Method
Standardized Tests
Case Studies
Archival Research
35. Experimental Method
The main objective of an experiment is
to discover the effect of an independent
variable (IV) on a dependent variable
(DV).
IV: variable to be manipulated;
independent of what the participant
does
DV: variable being measured; depends
on the IV
Ex. Effect of Music on Memory
37. Correlational Method
The objective of this method is to determine whether
two or more variables are associated or related to
each other.
The variables are first measured, after which a
correlational analysis or technique (e.g. Pearson r) is
conducted to determine the relationship.
38. The Naturalistic Observation Method
Involves observing the phenomenon of interest as it
occurs naturally.
Ex. Observing primates in their natural environment,
systematically observing the behavior of newborn
babies, and observing couple’s public display of
affection (PDA) in the school campus.
39. The Survey Method
Employs either a written questionnaire or an
interview schedule.
Ex. Political opinions, sexual attitudes, or product
preferences
Allows us to gather data about experiences,
feelings, thoughts, and motives that are hard to
observe directly.
40. Standardized Tests
Respondents are required to answer a series of
questions and their responses scored to reflect
something about their persons. A respondent’s score
is compared with those of the others who took the
same test.
Ex. Otis Test, Stanford-Binet Test (IQ)
Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI)
Indigenous Tests: Panukat ng Pagkataong Pilipino
(PPP), Panukat ng Ugali at Pagkatao (PUP)
41. Case Studies
Descriptive record of an
individual’s experiences or
behavior, or both, as kept by
an observer.
The main objective is to
obtain a case history of the
person being studied.
42. Archival Research
Written records (i.e. public and private
documents), statistical archives, and physical
traces of human beings are systematically studied
in lieu of actual behaviors.
Exs. Diaries, letters, paintings, books, poems,
newspaper or magazine articles, movies, and
speeches.
43. Conclusion: Is psychology
Scientific?
A range of objective approaches are used
Variables are controlled
Observation leads induction and deduction
Theories are tested against real world
Practice is evidence based on observation
“Common factors” evidence base to
counselling.
44. Readings For Seminar
1. Glassman, W & Hadad, M.(2009)
Approaches to psychology (5th edition).
Chap 1
2. McLeod J. (2009) An Introduction to
Counselling. Chap 1& 2
3. Dryden et al (2000) Counselling in the
United Kingdom past, present and future
45. Advanced reading
1.
Feltham, C (2010) Critical Thinking in
Counselling
and Psychotherapy. Chap 54
2. Map of the history of psychology:
http://webspace.ship.edu/cgboer/1900s.ht
ml
3. Feltham (2010) chap 54 Is counselling
scientific?
Editor's Notes
Quick history of his life: a Frenchman, brilliant (top of his class), after graduation he gambled a lot and engaged in debauchery. He then joined the army but preferred isolation to hanging out with others – he didn’t trust them. He believed that ‘my truth is better than their truth.’ He left the army, got interested in geometry and wanted to apply the rules of geometry to aspects of life with regards to axioms (those self-evident truths) and theorems (logical connections between two axioms). From his work, developed a doubting perspective – we are to doubt everything. How do I know this is blue? Can I trust my perception?
I think, therefore I am. He was left with only a doubting mind.
In his work, ‘An Essay Concerning Human Understanding’ he put forth the belief that the mind is receptive and passive. It’s main goals are to sense and perceive the external world. He believed that we develop all knowledge from the observation of things in the external world. Thus, we are born in a state of ‘tabula rasa’, with a brain that is a blank slate and has no prior knowledge. This is in direct contrast to the Rationalists (and Descartes). Locke saw morons and smart people and wondered what made the dumb people. If we have all this innate knowledge and reasoning skills, how are people dumb? Children aren’t born with innate reasoning, it is something they learn.
Hermann contributed the first major attempt to bring psychology into the laboratory – in the past, psychology had been a domain where really smart people sit around and think and talk and think and talk…not a lot of science going on.
Johannes Muller was Hermann’s teacher. Muller believed in ‘vitalism’ – that every living organism has a life force that cannot be measured. Muller thought that nerve impulses traveled at a ‘near infinite’ speed, propelled by the ‘life force’. Hermann respectfully disagreed.
Helmholtz was a mechanist – he believed that everything could be understood with basic physical and chemical principles. There is no mystical life force – everything is measurable. For example, the amount of muscular energy and heat generated by a frog is a function of the amount of oxidation of food the frog has consumed.
So you can see that the movement to measure things is coming into view. Helmholtz is arguing that we can’t say there is this infinite energy out there, we need to test and demonstrate things. Muller was a ‘mystical forces’ guy and Helmholtz said no, we need to measure everything.
Fechner was a founder of the psychophysics movement – he thought we should investigate the relationship between the physical world and our conscious psychological world. I highlight the word ‘conscious’ here because we’ll get to the ‘unconcscious’ later…these theorists so far in history haven’t even conceived of the ‘unconscious’.
For example: a candle in a lit room is perceived differently than a candle in a dark room (ask students what is perceived differently). Or a pin dropped in a quiet room is perceived differently than a pin dropped in a loud room.
Fechner thought that it was possible to measure the perceived as well as the physical intensities of sensory stimuli and to determine a mathematical relationship between them. This is what we do now only now we call it construct validity.
Fechner realized that we couldn’t put a yardstick inside someone’ head so instead of worrying about measuring absolute differences, he focused on measuring relative differences. To do this, he developed the ‘just noticeable difference’ approach. So you place two stimuli next to each other and ask – Which is brighter? Which weighs more? We’ll see later in class that the difference of low intensity stimuli is much smaller than the change in large intensity stimuli (Weber). So if I piled three textbooks in (get volunteer)’s arms and then added one more, would (name) notice? YEP! But if I piled twenty textbooks in (name)’s arms and then added one more, would (name) notice? NOPE!
What you should notice from all this is a strong movement from the field into the lab.
And now we come to what most historians consider the founding of psychology! Wilhelm Wundt and the magical year of 1879. Prior to this, though, Wundt had had a varied career in medicine (working with Robert Bunsen of Bunsen burner fame), physiology (working with Hermann Helmholtz and Johannes Muller) and got interested in vision and perceptions of space.
Several of his discoveries are important to his psychological emphasis: auditory and visual stimuli are not experience simultaneously (separate acts of attention are required) and that there is a central attentional process that others had ignored (they had focused on the motor nerves that carry messages to the brain rather than the brain itself).
His work focused on consciousness. Thus, he determined that it takes about 1/10 of a second to shift one’s attention from the sound of a bell (auditory stimuli) to the position of a pendulum (visual stimuli). This led Wundt to believe that we had a voluntary control process for mental events (I.e., selective attention).
So now that we have psychology officially ‘founded’, we have ‘schools’ of psychology – because as is the case with most everything in the world, there were different opinions regarding what psychology was and how it should be studied.
Structuralism involves defining the ‘structure’ of the objects of study BEFORE we study it’s function. To do this, self-reflective introspection was utilized. Thus, people were to examine conscious experience in terms of its elements of sensation and feeling. Tichner had highly trained individuals reduce all of the mental contents into its most basic elements, while being totally devoid of imposing meaning of those views. He had participants define something (for example, an image). The experimenter would then work to break these images down into the most minute details…describing different patches of light, color, shape, intensities, duration, etc. From this, they understood that there are processes associated with intensities, lights, color, etc.
William James is considered the ‘Father of American Psychology’. He was from an intellectual and wealthy family (his brother is Henry James – a very famous American author). He studied at Harvard in chemistry, then studied with Agassiz, who totally disagreed with Darwin. He later split with Agassiz and sided with Darwin. He is known as a great teacher and wrote an extremely influential volume ‘The Principles of Psychology’ that, while it is somewhat difficult to read, is still very useful.
James focused on Functionalism – he studied how the conscious mind helps us to adapt to the changing environment. He was a proponent of the ‘Stream of Consciousness’ method and felt that you couldn’t look at it in discrete chunks as Titchner had done. Like the ancient Greeks, he thought that one could never experience the same thing twice – every new experience is colored by the old and framed by past experiences (think about hearing the same song multiple times). He also studied habit and talked about how after enough repetitions, behaviors become hard-wired and difficult to change.
From the ‘stream of consciousness’ perspective, psychology then took a completely different turn in the form of behaviorism. The most influential psychologists in this are include Watson and Skinner. Watson especially is considered one of the most influential people in the history of psychology – because of this guy, thousands of studies were done using his methods for over 30 years (between the 1930s and 1960s). Watson disagreed with structuralism and functionalism and didn’t feel that the mind was the most appropriate object of study. He felt that behavior wasa the ‘correct’ thing to study.
Growing up, Watson was a trouble-maker, did poorly in school, and arrested at one point for firing his gun within city limits. He went to school and in grad school he studied under John Dewey, who was a functionalist…but he thought that introspection was a waste of time. Other faculty at the University of Chicago did research on animals, which he liked. His dissertation was on the complexity of rats’ behavior and the amount of myelin sheaths around their necral fibers (that will make more sense when we start talking about the brain later on in the semester). Here you started to see his interest in behavior begin.
What finally developed was a theory that the main goal of psychology should be the prediction and control of behavior – he preferred the concrete versus the theoretical. He felt that introspection had no intrinsic value. He also denied the traditional view of distinction between humans and animals. Therefore, all of his studies on rats can generalize to humans….which for what he is studying was a valid conclusion. We’ll see throughout the semester that there are some areas of psychology that are specific to humans.
Watson focused exclusively on the rewards and punishments we have experienced in the past. He bragged about the power of rewards and punishments in the following statement: “give me a dozen healthy infants, well formed, and my own specified world to bring them up in and I’ll guarantee to take any one at random and train him to become any type of specialist I might select--doctor, lawyer, artist, merchant, chief and yes, even beggarman and thief, regardless of his talents...abilities...and race of his ancestors.” Optimistic, but surely overstated, because our genetic background is important too.
By the way, Watson took this objective approach even into his personal life. His advice for childrearing: “Never hug and kiss them, never let them sit on your lap. If you must, kiss them once on the forehead when they say goodnight. Shake hands with them in the morning....In a week’s time you will find how easy it is to be perfectly objective with your child and at the same time kindly...” No wonder many have hated the behaviorist tradition. Two of his four kids tried to kill themselves as adults!
So far we’ve seen schools really have a period of dominance all to themselves. Now we’ll start seeing that schools of thought start developing simultaneously – some of which are still around, and some of which have faded through the years. The Gestalt perspective is really best phrased as ‘the whole is greater than the sum of the parts’. The main philosophy is that you shouldn’t dissect an experience into separate elements to discover the truth but instead, look at the whole of the experience. They felt that dividing mental experiences up into elements isn’t meaningful: we do not see patches of color but instead, we see people, cars, trees, etc.
The focus here is really perception. For example, Max Wertheimer’s Phi phenomenon: you can create an illusion that a light is moving from one location to another by flashing lights on and off at a certain rate.
We then move into one of the most controversial domains of psychology – Freud’s psychodynamic theory. I should point out that while Freud was the originator of this domain, he was by no means the only psychologist who held to these beliefs. A number of people worked with him throughout the years and who then started their own psychodynamic departments.
Freud was born in the now Czech Republic and moved to Vienna when was 4. He stayed there until the Nazis forced him to move to London in 1938, just before his death. He was one of 8 children (his mom was 20 years younger than his dad), and had several half-brothers as well. He was a good student and studied medicine, specifically localizing brain injuries. He set up private practice and realized that he couldn’t make a living studying ‘normal’ neurological cases so he expanded his practice to treat ‘hysterical’ patients. No one else would treat these patients, but he took it very seriously.
From his work with these hysterical patients, his psychodynamic approach began to take shape. His basic model involves the conflict between one’s conscious and unconscious in terms of which one is controlling thought and behavior. He focused a lot on motivations – mostly those involving sex and aggression. He felt that most mental illness evolved because the conscious part wanted to address the problem the patient was having while the unconscious feared the pain and didn’t want to do it.
Later theories involved free association – where everything the patient says has meaning and dream analysis. Both of these haven’t necessarily stood the test of time but the conscious/unconscious framework is still utilized in some aspects of psychology today.