SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 23
Download to read offline
Marine Polymer Techs v. Hemcon Can arguments alone give rise to intervening rights? Jeff B. Vockrodt Hunton & Williams LLP February 2012
Federal Circuit goes  en banc   ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Federal Circuit goes  en banc
Marine Polymer:  The Patent ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The District Court
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The District Court
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The District Court
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The Reexamination
[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The Reexamination
[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The Reexamination
[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer:  The Reexamination
Marine Polymer: the Federal Circuit ,[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],Marine Polymer: the Federal Circuit
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer: the Federal Circuit
Marine Polymer: Recap Patent Owner  Argument Prior art  correct post - reexam construction REEXAM Prior Art  ? correct pre - reexam construction district court construction accused product accused product
[object Object],Marine Polymer: the Federal Circuit
[object Object],Marine Polymer: the Federal Circuit
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer: the Federal Circuit
Marine Polymer:  Judge Lourie Dissent ,[object Object],[object Object]
Marine Polymer: Judge Lourie Dissent ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Marine Polymer: Typical Prosecution Disclaimer Patent Owner  Argument Prior art  correct post - reexam construction REEXAM Prior Art  ? district court construction accused product accused product
Marine Polymer: Expanded Intervening Rights Patent Owner  Argument Prior art  correct post - reexam construction REEXAM Prior Art  ? district court construction accused product accused product
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Marine Polymer: What can Patent Owners Do?

More Related Content

Similar to Marine Polymer v. Hemcon

Patents That Cannot Be Infringed
Patents That Cannot Be InfringedPatents That Cannot Be Infringed
Patents That Cannot Be Infringedblewisbell
 
Are My Patents Still Valid
Are My Patents Still ValidAre My Patents Still Valid
Are My Patents Still Validinsightc5
 
Umg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks Inc
Umg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks IncUmg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks Inc
Umg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks IncJoe Gratz
 
Year In Review (Nov. 29)
Year In Review (Nov. 29)Year In Review (Nov. 29)
Year In Review (Nov. 29)bradsugarman
 
European and US Patent Law
European and US Patent LawEuropean and US Patent Law
European and US Patent LawIP Dome
 
5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions
5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions
5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctionsmsstephanielord
 
Doctrine of equivalents
Doctrine of equivalentsDoctrine of equivalents
Doctrine of equivalentsraokavi
 
Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...
Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...
Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...Marcellus Drilling News
 
Keeping the sharks at bay
Keeping the sharks at bayKeeping the sharks at bay
Keeping the sharks at bayJane Lambert
 
Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?
Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?
Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?enthu_rajan
 
Recent Trends in Oil & Gas Litigation
Recent Trends in Oil & Gas LitigationRecent Trends in Oil & Gas Litigation
Recent Trends in Oil & Gas LitigationJackson Walker LLP
 
Patents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman Issues
Patents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman IssuesPatents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman Issues
Patents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman IssuesKirby Drake
 
Patent amendment before the Federal Court in Australia
Patent amendment before the Federal Court in AustraliaPatent amendment before the Federal Court in Australia
Patent amendment before the Federal Court in AustraliaWayne Condon
 
Post-Grant Practice Primer
Post-Grant Practice PrimerPost-Grant Practice Primer
Post-Grant Practice Primerkblaurence
 
Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 Newsletter
Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 NewsletterAdam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 Newsletter
Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 NewsletterAdam Leitman Bailey
 
KJO Representative Matters
KJO Representative MattersKJO Representative Matters
KJO Representative MattersKevin O'Shea
 

Similar to Marine Polymer v. Hemcon (20)

Cardiac Pacemakers
Cardiac PacemakersCardiac Pacemakers
Cardiac Pacemakers
 
Patents That Cannot Be Infringed
Patents That Cannot Be InfringedPatents That Cannot Be Infringed
Patents That Cannot Be Infringed
 
Are My Patents Still Valid
Are My Patents Still ValidAre My Patents Still Valid
Are My Patents Still Valid
 
Test for determining infringement of patents
Test for determining infringement of patentsTest for determining infringement of patents
Test for determining infringement of patents
 
Umg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks Inc
Umg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks IncUmg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks Inc
Umg Recordings Inc V Veoh Networks Inc
 
Year In Review (Nov. 29)
Year In Review (Nov. 29)Year In Review (Nov. 29)
Year In Review (Nov. 29)
 
Recent Developments in Hatch-Waxman Law
Recent Developments in Hatch-Waxman LawRecent Developments in Hatch-Waxman Law
Recent Developments in Hatch-Waxman Law
 
European and US Patent Law
European and US Patent LawEuropean and US Patent Law
European and US Patent Law
 
5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions
5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions
5 a law and ethics discharge of contract, remedies and injunctions
 
Doctrine of equivalents
Doctrine of equivalentsDoctrine of equivalents
Doctrine of equivalents
 
Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...
Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...
Delaware Riverkeeper Legal Primer on Becoming an Intervenor in the PennEast P...
 
[2015] SGSTB 5
[2015] SGSTB 5[2015] SGSTB 5
[2015] SGSTB 5
 
Keeping the sharks at bay
Keeping the sharks at bayKeeping the sharks at bay
Keeping the sharks at bay
 
Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?
Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?
Are Reverse Payment Settlements on Reverse Gear?
 
Recent Trends in Oil & Gas Litigation
Recent Trends in Oil & Gas LitigationRecent Trends in Oil & Gas Litigation
Recent Trends in Oil & Gas Litigation
 
Patents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman Issues
Patents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman IssuesPatents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman Issues
Patents, Competition, Antitrust and Generic Drugs: Resolving Hatch-Waxman Issues
 
Patent amendment before the Federal Court in Australia
Patent amendment before the Federal Court in AustraliaPatent amendment before the Federal Court in Australia
Patent amendment before the Federal Court in Australia
 
Post-Grant Practice Primer
Post-Grant Practice PrimerPost-Grant Practice Primer
Post-Grant Practice Primer
 
Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 Newsletter
Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 NewsletterAdam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 Newsletter
Adam Leitman Bailey, P.C. Winter 2018 Newsletter
 
KJO Representative Matters
KJO Representative MattersKJO Representative Matters
KJO Representative Matters
 

Marine Polymer v. Hemcon

  • 1. Marine Polymer Techs v. Hemcon Can arguments alone give rise to intervening rights? Jeff B. Vockrodt Hunton & Williams LLP February 2012
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15. Marine Polymer: Recap Patent Owner Argument Prior art correct post - reexam construction REEXAM Prior Art ? correct pre - reexam construction district court construction accused product accused product
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21. Marine Polymer: Typical Prosecution Disclaimer Patent Owner Argument Prior art correct post - reexam construction REEXAM Prior Art ? district court construction accused product accused product
  • 22. Marine Polymer: Expanded Intervening Rights Patent Owner Argument Prior art correct post - reexam construction REEXAM Prior Art ? district court construction accused product accused product
  • 23.