SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 44
Josh McHugh
CEO, Attention Span
Co-Founder, Fanatical
The Care and Feeding of
Social Media Superfans
FOR DISCUSSION
• What is a superfan?
• What superfans can do for you
• How to find them
• Building superfan communities
• Doing it wrong
• Superfan relationship upkeep
BACKGROUND
Proprietary audience intelligence
and development platform
Digital and audience development
agency
[STRATEGISTS]
[OPERATIVES ]
[ SOFTWARE ]
AGENCY CLIENTS
WHO ARE THESE “SUPERFANS”?
SUPERFANS AND INFLUENCERS ARE NOT THE SAME
• “Influencer outreach” often PR-focused blogger
campaign
• Enthusiasm is more important than historical influence
• Influence can be built in a short amount of time
PORTRAIT OF A SUPERFAN
• Lisa Stanforth
• Purdue 2007
• Production Coordinator
• Morning News Producer
• Raving Superfan
WHAT SUPERFANS CAN DO
FOR YOU
THE 20/90 RULE
• 20% of Twitter users generate 90% of activity
YOUR OWN MARKETING ARMY
TRUST
TRUST
• 92%trust recommendations from people they know
• 81%report being influenced by friends’ social media
posts
• 36%trust ads on social networks
• -24% in trust in traditional advertising since 2009
Trust acceleration
• The greatest perceptions of trust were reported by highly
identified ingroup fans describing fellow ingroup fans,
while the lowest levels of trust were found in the highly
identified fans’ descriptions of rival outgroup fans.
• Sports Fans, Identity and Socialization: Exploring the
Fandemonium, 2012
S.E.O.
CAMPAIGN RESURRECTION
HOW TO FIND THEM
WHAT TO LOOK FOR
• They’re already creating content for you
• They’re talking about you a lot
• They’re saying positive things about you
• They’re sharing your content
• They’re clicking your links
• They’re using your hashtags
WHERE TO LOOK
• Customer service wins
• Inbound traffic sources (Google Analytics, etc.)
• Review sites
• Yelp
• TripAdvisor
• Twitter lists
• Listmakers
PAST PERFORMANCE DOES NOT
INDICATE FUTURE SUCCESS
• General and even topic-specific influence scores can be
inversely useful in recruiting and developing superfans
Malcolm Gladwell:
Influence is predictive
Duncan Watts:
Influence is history
Those who participated Those who didn’t
Average Klout Score
37 39
TURNING FANS INTO FANATICS
HOW TO APPROACH
• Context, Context, Context
• An unsolicited message doesn’t have to be a cold call
FOCUS
• A community manager only has time to write and send
50-150 personalized messages/day – CHOOSE
WISELY
RECOGNIZE
• Most powerful motivator of superfans
• Retweets
• Shout-outs
• Post their content
MAKE IT A CAUSE
• Figure out what resonates with your budding superfans
and help them get behind the cause
HOW TO LOSE THEM
PROLONGING THE MAGIC
LET THE SUPERFANS DRIVE ONCE IN A WHILE
• Give them a say
• Sneak peeks
• Backchannel
• Unauthorized sites can be a good thing!
GOOD TIMES AND BAD
Going beyond the tweet
THERE ARE
SUPERFANS
, AND THEN
THERE’S
twitter.com/getFanatical

More Related Content

What's hot

Creating Drowning Awareness through Social Media
Creating Drowning Awareness through Social MediaCreating Drowning Awareness through Social Media
Creating Drowning Awareness through Social MediaSuncoastMeetings
 
Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...
Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...
Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...Toby Beresford
 
Measuring Success in a Digital World
Measuring Success in a Digital WorldMeasuring Success in a Digital World
Measuring Success in a Digital WorldAndy Kutcher
 
Social Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information Superhighway
Social Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information SuperhighwaySocial Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information Superhighway
Social Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information SuperhighwayNevada Division of Tourism
 
RISE Austin: Social Media Measurement
RISE Austin: Social Media MeasurementRISE Austin: Social Media Measurement
RISE Austin: Social Media MeasurementSocial Distillery
 
Social media turbo boost workshop
Social media turbo boost workshopSocial media turbo boost workshop
Social media turbo boost workshopNerida Gill
 
Marketing Your Tourism Business Online
Marketing Your Tourism Business OnlineMarketing Your Tourism Business Online
Marketing Your Tourism Business OnlineDream Local Digital
 
2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning
2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning
2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morningLisa Dickson
 
Social Media & Personal Branding 2
Social Media & Personal Branding 2Social Media & Personal Branding 2
Social Media & Personal Branding 2asuarea48
 
Still kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorses
Still kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorsesStill kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorses
Still kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorsesandrewfrankcommunications
 
IVAA Social Media Seminar
IVAA Social Media SeminarIVAA Social Media Seminar
IVAA Social Media SeminarNerida Gill
 
#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...
#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...
#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...Kelly Hungerford
 
What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?
What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?
What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?eiconnection
 
WeShareMedia Capabilities Deck
WeShareMedia Capabilities DeckWeShareMedia Capabilities Deck
WeShareMedia Capabilities DeckErnie Velas
 
The Power of Social media
The Power of Social mediaThe Power of Social media
The Power of Social mediaAmanda Harlin
 
Social Media Action Plan!
Social Media Action Plan!Social Media Action Plan!
Social Media Action Plan!Pepovski Darko
 
University of Central Missouri Guest Lecture
University of Central Missouri Guest LectureUniversity of Central Missouri Guest Lecture
University of Central Missouri Guest LectureLisa Qualls
 
Social Media & Linkages To Multiple Markets
Social Media & Linkages To Multiple MarketsSocial Media & Linkages To Multiple Markets
Social Media & Linkages To Multiple MarketsIntelegia Group
 

What's hot (20)

Creating Drowning Awareness through Social Media
Creating Drowning Awareness through Social MediaCreating Drowning Awareness through Social Media
Creating Drowning Awareness through Social Media
 
Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...
Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...
Leaderboards - the greatest game mechanic of them all - by leaderboarded at d...
 
Iaorc Conference
Iaorc ConferenceIaorc Conference
Iaorc Conference
 
Measuring Success in a Digital World
Measuring Success in a Digital WorldMeasuring Success in a Digital World
Measuring Success in a Digital World
 
Social Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information Superhighway
Social Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information SuperhighwaySocial Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information Superhighway
Social Media 101: Building Your Town's Onramp to the Information Superhighway
 
RISE Austin: Social Media Measurement
RISE Austin: Social Media MeasurementRISE Austin: Social Media Measurement
RISE Austin: Social Media Measurement
 
Social media turbo boost workshop
Social media turbo boost workshopSocial media turbo boost workshop
Social media turbo boost workshop
 
Marketing Your Tourism Business Online
Marketing Your Tourism Business OnlineMarketing Your Tourism Business Online
Marketing Your Tourism Business Online
 
2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning
2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning
2015 sw ohio leadership retreat morning
 
Social Media & Personal Branding 2
Social Media & Personal Branding 2Social Media & Personal Branding 2
Social Media & Personal Branding 2
 
WOW social media_marketing 101 (2008)
WOW social media_marketing 101 (2008)WOW social media_marketing 101 (2008)
WOW social media_marketing 101 (2008)
 
Still kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorses
Still kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorsesStill kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorses
Still kicking: The importance of media releases as storytelling workhorses
 
IVAA Social Media Seminar
IVAA Social Media SeminarIVAA Social Media Seminar
IVAA Social Media Seminar
 
#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...
#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...
#FusionMex Content Workshop: Content Marketing in Practice, Antwerp June 10, ...
 
What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?
What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?
What are some of the best practices when conducting a 360-degree assessment?
 
WeShareMedia Capabilities Deck
WeShareMedia Capabilities DeckWeShareMedia Capabilities Deck
WeShareMedia Capabilities Deck
 
The Power of Social media
The Power of Social mediaThe Power of Social media
The Power of Social media
 
Social Media Action Plan!
Social Media Action Plan!Social Media Action Plan!
Social Media Action Plan!
 
University of Central Missouri Guest Lecture
University of Central Missouri Guest LectureUniversity of Central Missouri Guest Lecture
University of Central Missouri Guest Lecture
 
Social Media & Linkages To Multiple Markets
Social Media & Linkages To Multiple MarketsSocial Media & Linkages To Multiple Markets
Social Media & Linkages To Multiple Markets
 

Similar to Internet Week New York: Superfans Presentation

Marketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media WorkshopMarketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media WorkshopDarryll Stinson
 
Marketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media WorkshopMarketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media WorkshopDarryll Stinson
 
Maximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community Engagement
Maximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community EngagementMaximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community Engagement
Maximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community Engagementlgdeaton
 
Best Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation Leaders
Best Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation LeadersBest Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation Leaders
Best Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation LeadersKDMC
 
Workshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOS
Workshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOSWorkshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOS
Workshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOSBeth Kanter
 
Content is the Fire, Social Media is the Gasoline
Content is the Fire, Social Media is the GasolineContent is the Fire, Social Media is the Gasoline
Content is the Fire, Social Media is the GasolineSarah Zink
 
Game Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media Impact
Game Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media ImpactGame Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media Impact
Game Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media ImpactMelinda Venable
 
5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact
5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact
5 Steps To Maximize Social Media ImpactResource Media
 
Networking online and offline
Networking online and offlineNetworking online and offline
Networking online and offlineDale Denham
 
#NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing
#NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing #NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing
#NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing Live And Social
 
MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]
MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]
MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]CanadaHelps / MyCharityConnects
 
Leading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected World
Leading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected WorldLeading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected World
Leading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected WorldBeth Kanter
 
Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)
Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)
Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)PR 20/20
 
Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media
Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media
Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media Marketing Nutz
 
How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In
How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In
How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In Pam Moore
 
Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...
Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...
Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...Earthsite
 
Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...
Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...
Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...Social Jack
 
Donorpath Webinar
Donorpath WebinarDonorpath Webinar
Donorpath WebinarBeth Kanter
 

Similar to Internet Week New York: Superfans Presentation (20)

Marketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media WorkshopMarketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media Workshop
 
Marketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media WorkshopMarketing & Social Media Workshop
Marketing & Social Media Workshop
 
Maximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community Engagement
Maximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community EngagementMaximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community Engagement
Maximizing Social Media for Nonprofits - Advanced Community Engagement
 
Best Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation Leaders
Best Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation LeadersBest Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation Leaders
Best Social Media and Networking Skills and Practices for Foundation Leaders
 
Workshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOS
Workshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOSWorkshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOS
Workshop at Helsinki University: Social Media and NGOS
 
Content is the Fire, Social Media is the Gasoline
Content is the Fire, Social Media is the GasolineContent is the Fire, Social Media is the Gasoline
Content is the Fire, Social Media is the Gasoline
 
Game Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media Impact
Game Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media ImpactGame Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media Impact
Game Changer: 5 Steps to Maximize Your Social Media Impact
 
5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact
5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact
5 Steps To Maximize Social Media Impact
 
Networking online and offline
Networking online and offlineNetworking online and offline
Networking online and offline
 
#NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing
#NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing #NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing
#NotForGeeks Introduction to Social Media Marketing
 
MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]
MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]
MyCharityConnects Peel - Social Media Planning [2010-11-18]
 
Leading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected World
Leading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected WorldLeading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected World
Leading on Social Platforms - Smarter Networking in a Connected World
 
Clip Jan 12
Clip Jan 12Clip Jan 12
Clip Jan 12
 
Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)
Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)
Social Media for Real Estate Agents (2011)
 
Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media
Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media
Social Network Prioritization - How to Prioritize Investment in Social Media
 
How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In
How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In
How to Prioritize Social Networks Your Business Should Invest In
 
Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...
Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...
Open Brands: How Social Media is Pushing Radical Transparency on Brand Manage...
 
5W’s of social media
5W’s of social media5W’s of social media
5W’s of social media
 
Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...
Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...
Digital Summit - Humanize Your Brand with Influencer Marketing from the Insid...
 
Donorpath Webinar
Donorpath WebinarDonorpath Webinar
Donorpath Webinar
 

Recently uploaded

Top 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO SEO Expert in USA - Macaw Digital
Top 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO  SEO Expert in USA - Macaw DigitalTop 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO  SEO Expert in USA - Macaw Digital
Top 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO SEO Expert in USA - Macaw Digitalmacawdigitalseo2023
 
Values Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdf
Values Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdfValues Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdf
Values Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdfSoftServe HRM
 
THE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECT
THE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECTTHE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECT
THE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECT17mos052
 
Dubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In DubaiDubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In Dubaikojalkojal131
 
Amplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing Services
Amplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing ServicesAmplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing Services
Amplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing ServicesNetqom Solutions
 
The--Fraud: Netflix Original Media Pitch
The--Fraud: Netflix Original Media PitchThe--Fraud: Netflix Original Media Pitch
The--Fraud: Netflix Original Media Pitch17mos052
 
Unveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the Stars
Unveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the StarsUnveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the Stars
Unveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the StarsSocioCosmos
 

Recently uploaded (7)

Top 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO SEO Expert in USA - Macaw Digital
Top 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO  SEO Expert in USA - Macaw DigitalTop 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO  SEO Expert in USA - Macaw Digital
Top 5 Ways To Use Reddit for SEO SEO Expert in USA - Macaw Digital
 
Values Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdf
Values Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdfValues Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdf
Values Newsletter teamwork section 2023.pdf
 
THE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECT
THE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECTTHE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECT
THE FRAUD NETFLIX ORIGINAL MEDIA PITCH PROJECT
 
Dubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In DubaiDubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In Dubai
Dubai Calls Girls Busty Babes O525547819 Call Girls In Dubai
 
Amplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing Services
Amplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing ServicesAmplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing Services
Amplify Your Brand with Our Tailored Social Media Marketing Services
 
The--Fraud: Netflix Original Media Pitch
The--Fraud: Netflix Original Media PitchThe--Fraud: Netflix Original Media Pitch
The--Fraud: Netflix Original Media Pitch
 
Unveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the Stars
Unveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the StarsUnveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the Stars
Unveiling SOCIO COSMOS: Where Socializing Meets the Stars
 

Internet Week New York: Superfans Presentation

Editor's Notes

  1. Red herring in the event description
  2. [video: unsolicited superfan reviews of web series episodes]
  3. http://socialcommercetoday.com/word-of-mouth-still-most-trusted-resource-says-nielsen-implications-for-social-commerce/ (Nielsen 2012)http://socialmediatoday.com/ritu-pant/1324011/social-influencers-digital-marketings-most-overlooked-and-misused-resource
  4. Examples of content created by superfans
  5. Silver Oak tour went to her town