Why the @#!% isn’t
WordPress a CMS?
John	
  Eckman	
  
ISITE	
  Design	
  	
  -­‐	
  h4p://www.isitedesign.com/	
  
CMS	
 ...
First, A Little Background
h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2010/03/is-­‐wordpress-­‐a-­‐cms/	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #w...
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
Say What?
h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2012/05/revisiFng-­‐wordpress-­‐as-­‐a-­‐cms-­‐again/	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
 ...
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
What’s a CMS?
“A	
  system	
  that	
  lets	
  you	
  apply	
  management	
  principles	
  to	
  web	
  
content.”	
  	
  	...
What would lead one to say
WordPress is NOT a CMS?
h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/narisa/97218748/	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPr...
WordPress is
like the leading
candidate in a
primary race:
everyone’s a
critic
h"p://knowyourmeme.com/memes/haters-­‐gonna...
Why would people say WordPress is just a
blog platform?
Because we keep telling them it is.
h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/tho...
@jeckman	
  	
  	
  
#WordPressCMS	
  
	
  #wcbos	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
What if WordPress.com and
WordPress.org had different
names?
h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/1935788259/in/photostr
@...
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbos	
  
Sometimes people use tools in
unexpected ways: edge cases
Edge cases can reveal limits in a
platform. Is CMS an edge case ...
What doesn’t WordPress do well?
•  MulFlingual	
  	
  
•  Publish	
  to	
  Remote	
  
Servers	
  
•  Extended,	
  Fine-­‐G...
Do open source projects reflect the
attitudes of their founders and
leaders?
h"p://schipulcon.com/photos/514/in/9/	
  
@je...
Dries vs. Matt
•  PhD	
  in	
  Computer	
  
Science	
  and	
  Engineering	
  
•  Founded	
  Drupal	
  project	
  
2000	
  ...
Acquia vs Automattic
•  VC	
  Funded	
  (aggressive	
  
growth	
  plan)	
  
•  Corporate	
  
Headquarters	
  in	
  
Burlin...
What does this suggest about Drupal
and WordPress as platforms?
•  Engineering	
  culture	
  
•  Steep	
  learning	
  curv...
What, if anything, should we do
about the state of WordPress as
a CMS?
@jeckman	
  	
  #WordPressCMS	
  #wcbosc	
  
Do we want more power,
and therefore accept more
complexity?
h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2012/02/build-­‐one-­‐to-­‐throw-­‐away...
“What the detractors and critics
of electric vehicles have been
saying for years, is true. The
electric vehicle is not for...
Should there be a fork of
WordPress focused
on CMS use cases?
A Distribution? Package?
Application? Downstream?
h"p://www....
How can we preserve WordPress’
existing advantages?
•  Focus	
  on	
  usability	
  and	
  user	
  experience	
  design	
  ...
This is a great time for exactly what
WordPress is best at
•  Shig	
  in	
  buying	
  power	
  from	
  IT	
  to	
  busines...
Closing Thoughts
•  WordPress	
  certainly	
  can	
  be	
  used	
  as	
  a	
  CMS:	
  
the	
  quesFon	
  is	
  ulFmately	
...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Why the heck isnt word press a cms

3,501

Published on

Talk from Word

Published in: Technology
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
3,501
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
7
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
6
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Managing Director, Boston for ISITE Design – digital agency for brands who differentiate on customer experience. Significant design and implementation work on many platforms, including Sitecore, Ektron, Drupal, Adobe CQ, etc. Blogger / Mythbuster for the CMS Myth – focus on the core myths that derail CMS projects. Open Parenthesis, TwitterWordPress plugins: WPBook, WPBook-Lite, WPGPlus, Hello Dalai WordCamp Boston 2010, 2011, 2012 organizer and volunteerAlso work significantly with Drupal – including speaking at DrupalCamps
  • Dirk Shaw – SVP Social @ Ogilvy west, Irina Guseva – Real Story GroupScott Liewehr – Digital Clarity Group
  • Phil Sturgeon – PyroCMSTony White – ArsLogica, ex Gilbane and Yankee Group - http://www.cmsexpo.net/speakers/1-100-Tony_WhiteDavid Skarjune – Content Strategist http://www.linkedin.com/in/davidskarjune Luis Hernandez - http://www.523design.com/
  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/narisa/97218748/Haters Gonna Hate (prominence)WordPress is “just a blog” (brand, origin)WordPress is a “simple” CMS (there are limits)
  • http://forums.allkpop.com/threads/post-your-favorite-haters-gonna-hate-pic.6471/http://wordpress.org/news/2011/08/state-of-the-word/
  • When people say WordPress is not a CMS, they really mean it’s too simple, or not Enterprise enough, or too close to being “just” a blog platform. The logic seems to be that because WP began as a blog platform, and is used by many as a blog platform, that it cannot have become more than just a blog platform. This is known as the “nothing ever changes” thesis. http://www.flickr.com/photos/thomashawk/4595386436/
  • Why would people say WP is just a blog?Because we keep telling them that. “A better way to blog”WordPress.com home page
  • “the open source blogging software available at WordPress.org”WordPress.com about page
  • “WordPress is web software you can use to create a beautiful website or blog.” WordPress.org
  • To be fair, WordPress.com VIP does
  • Finally, at the bottom of the Why WordPress VIP page, we get a reference to WordPress as a Content Management SystemIt’s almost as though there’s a desire NOT to have WordPress and Content Management ever associated with each other.
  • What would it be like if when WordPress.com launched, it took a different name than the underlying platform?http://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/1935788259/in/photostream/
  • “Drupal is an open source content management platform powering millions of websites and applications.”“Use Drupal to build everything from personal blogs to enterprise applications.”
  • Drupal Gardens – powered by the Drupal Platform
  • http://www.flickr.com/photos/bikeportland/7422629250/in/photostream/Fulll story here: http://bikeportland.org/2012/06/28/with-six-kids-and-no-car-this-mom-does-it-all-by-bike-73731Emily Finch, six kids, no car – does it all by bike
  • Note that it isn’t that your couldn’t do any of these things with WP, but would you want to? Would you be the edge case?See Spark Distribution in Drupal for In-Context Editing and next-gen author experience: http://drupal.org/project/spark
  • http://schipulcon.com/photos/514/in/9/
  • Dries’ thesis?: “Profiling Techniques for Performance Analysis and Optimization of Java Applications”Drupal starts as a hacker project by an undergrad comp sci major to be able to exchange messages with his roomates. WP starts as a fork of B2 focused on simplicity and better user experience for the content creator. Matt’s profile on d.o lists “simplicity” as an interest
  • Acquia (self-declared) wants to be to Drupal what RedHat was to Linux – enterprise validation. http://www.flickr.com/photos/pgoyette/1276986086/in/photostream/
  • Of course these are broad brush generalizations – there is a design 4 drupal camp in Boston focused on UX, and there is a very strong developer community in the WordPress world – see Buddy Press, MU and networks, enterprise sites, ecommerce – all the things some of the folks in this camp are involved in. Tweets from:http://www.commonplaces.com/inspiring-conversation/team-posts/drupal-7-vs-wordpress-3-battle-new-features-0Photo: http://www.flickr.com/photos/andrewl04/3163980834/
  • Photo: see http://www.cmsmyth.com/2012/02/build-one-to-throw-away/ for story of its origin
  • Ed BegelyJr in Who Killed the Electric Car"What the detractors and critics of electric vehicles have been saying for years, is true. The electric vehicle is not for everybody; given the limited range it can only meet the needs of 90% of the population.“Photo: http://www.filmaluation.com/who-killed-the-electric-car.html
  • Forks: http://www.flickr.com/photos/jonathancohen/5396179251/Drupal Distributions: http://drupal.org/project/distributionsInstall WordPress, and you get a blog – complete with first post and comment. You have to change home page and make pages to do more CMS oriented stuff. Install Drupal, you get very little – not even blog is turned on by default. Distributions help with this . http://interconnectit.com/724/wordpress-distributions-are-the-future/
  • Photo:http://www.flickr.com/photos/r_a_z_e/498818720/
  • http://blog.schipul.com/drupal-and-wordpress-at-schipulcon-one-stage-one-open-source-love/
  • Why the heck isnt word press a cms

    1. 1. Why the @#!% isn’t WordPress a CMS? John  Eckman   ISITE  Design    -­‐  h4p://www.isitedesign.com/   CMS  Myth  -­‐  h4p://www.cmsmyth.com/   Blog  -­‐  h4p://www.openparenthesis.org/ Github:  h4p://github.com/jeckman   Twi4er  -­‐  @jeckman  
    2. 2. First, A Little Background h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2010/03/is-­‐wordpress-­‐a-­‐cms/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    3. 3. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    4. 4. Say What? h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2012/05/revisiFng-­‐wordpress-­‐as-­‐a-­‐cms-­‐again/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    5. 5. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    6. 6. What’s a CMS? “A  system  that  lets  you  apply  management  principles  to  web   content.”       (real  story  group)     A  content  management  system  (CMS)  is  a  system  providing  a   collecFon  of  procedures  used  to  manage  work  flow  in  a   collaboraFve  environment.  These  procedures  can  be  manual   or  computer-­‐based.  The  procedures  are  designed  to  do  the   following:   •  Allow  for  a  large  number  of  people  to  contribute  to  and   share  stored  data   •  Control  access  to  data,  based  on  user  roles  (defining   which  informaFon  users  or  user  groups  can  view,  edit,   publish,  etc.)   •  Aid  in  easy  storage  and  retrieval  of  data   •  Reduce  repeFFve  duplicate  input   •  Improve  the  ease  of  report  wriFng   •  Improve  communicaFon  between  users   (wikipedia  on  CMS)   h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/5403098626/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    7. 7. What would lead one to say WordPress is NOT a CMS? h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/narisa/97218748/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    8. 8. WordPress is like the leading candidate in a primary race: everyone’s a critic h"p://knowyourmeme.com/memes/haters-­‐gonna-­‐hate/photos   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    9. 9. Why would people say WordPress is just a blog platform? Because we keep telling them it is. h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/thomashawk/4595386436/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    10. 10. @jeckman       #WordPressCMS    #wcbos  
    11. 11. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    12. 12. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    13. 13. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    14. 14. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    15. 15. What if WordPress.com and WordPress.org had different names? h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/quinnanya/1935788259/in/photostr @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    16. 16. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    17. 17. @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    18. 18. Sometimes people use tools in unexpected ways: edge cases Edge cases can reveal limits in a platform. Is CMS an edge case for WordPress? h"p://bikeportland.org/2012/06/28/with-­‐six-­‐kids-­‐and-­‐no-­‐car-­‐ this-­‐mom-­‐does-­‐it-­‐all-­‐by-­‐bike-­‐73731   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    19. 19. What doesn’t WordPress do well? •  MulFlingual     •  Publish  to  Remote   Servers   •  Extended,  Fine-­‐Grained   User  Permissions   •  Content  TargeFng  /   Dynamic   PersonalizaFon   •  In-­‐Context  EdiFng   •  Custom  ApplicaFons   with  High  User   InteracFon   •  Complex  Workflow   •  Versioning  across   complex  asset  types   •  EdiFons  /  Content   Bundles     •  Digital  Asset   Management  at  Scale   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    20. 20. Do open source projects reflect the attitudes of their founders and leaders? h"p://schipulcon.com/photos/514/in/9/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    21. 21. Dries vs. Matt •  PhD  in  Computer   Science  and  Engineering   •  Founded  Drupal  project   2000   •  Founded  Acquia  2008,   as  CTO   •  Coding,  Technology,   Photography   •  Studied  PoliFcal  Science   at  University  of  Houston     (leg  to  join  CNET)   •  Started  WordPress  in   2003,  founded   Automaic  and   WordPress.com  2005   •  Jazz,  Photography,   Simplicity   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    22. 22. Acquia vs Automattic •  VC  Funded  (aggressive   growth  plan)   •  Corporate   Headquarters  in   Burlington  MA  with   some  distributed   employees   •  Focus:  “Your  enterprise   guide  to  Drupal”   •  VC  funded,  though   slower  growth  plan  (?)   •  All  virtual  /  Distributed   •  Small  office  in  SF  (now   closed?)   •  Focus:  “we  are   passionate  about   making  the  web  a   be"er  place”     h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/pgoye"e/1276986086/in/photostream/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbos  
    23. 23. What does this suggest about Drupal and WordPress as platforms? •  Engineering  culture   •  Steep  learning  curve,   but  very  powerful  once   learned   •  Design  /  Content   culture   •  Simple  learning  curve   but  arguably  less   powerful  /  flexible   h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/andrewl04/3163980834/   h"p://www.commonplaces.com/inspiring-­‐conversaFon/team-­‐posts/drupal-­‐7-­‐vs-­‐ wordpress-­‐3-­‐ba"le-­‐new-­‐features-­‐0  
    24. 24. What, if anything, should we do about the state of WordPress as a CMS? @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbosc  
    25. 25. Do we want more power, and therefore accept more complexity? h"p://www.cmsmyth.com/2012/02/build-­‐one-­‐to-­‐throw-­‐away/     @jeckman       #WordPressCMS     #wcbos  
    26. 26. “What the detractors and critics of electric vehicles have been saying for years, is true. The electric vehicle is not for everybody; given the limited range it can only meet the needs of 90% of the population.“ h"p://www.filmaluaFon.com/who-­‐killed-­‐the-­‐electric-­‐car.html   @jeckman       #WordPressCMS     #wcbos  
    27. 27. Should there be a fork of WordPress focused on CMS use cases? A Distribution? Package? Application? Downstream? h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/jonathancohen/5396179251/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbosc  
    28. 28. How can we preserve WordPress’ existing advantages? •  Focus  on  usability  and  user  experience  design   for  the  content  author  /  site  admin   •  Ease  of  installaFon  and  Fme  to  “live  site”   experience   •  Broad  availability  of  themes  and  plugins   •  Community  (including  WordCamps!)   •  WordPress.com  as  a  massive  scale  ongoing   tesFng  plaoorm  for  new  concepts   h"p://www.flickr.com/photos/r_a_z_e/498818720/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbosc  
    29. 29. This is a great time for exactly what WordPress is best at •  Shig  in  buying  power  from  IT  to  business   owner   •  Renewed  interest  in  and  focus  on  content   strategy   •  Focused  small  iniFaFves  rather  than  large   enterprise  roll  outs   •  Focus  on  design,  usability,  and  content  impact    
    30. 30. Closing Thoughts •  WordPress  certainly  can  be  used  as  a  CMS:   the  quesFon  is  ulFmately  whether  this  is  an   edge  case  or  the  core  direcFon  of  the  project.     •  In  trying  to  grow  WordPress  as  a  CMS:   – We  won’t  win  by  trash  talking  other  plaoorms   – Power  is  shiging  from  IT  buyer  to  markeFng/ business  buyer   – Don’t  fall  for  the  technology  selecFon  myth   – Don’t  compete  on  feature  checklists   – The  “S”  in  CMS  should  be  strategy   h"p://blog.schipul.com/drupal-­‐and-­‐wordpress-­‐at-­‐schipulcon-­‐one-­‐stage-­‐one-­‐open-­‐source-­‐love/   @jeckman    #WordPressCMS  #wcbosc  
    1. A particular slide catching your eye?

      Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

    ×