Interdisciplinary research theories & thoughts

  • 542 views
Uploaded on

An adaptation from a presentation by Jenny Delasalle and Richard Parker to the University of Warwick's Library management team in June 2010

An adaptation from a presentation by Jenny Delasalle and Richard Parker to the University of Warwick's Library management team in June 2010

More in: Technology , Education
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads

Views

Total Views
542
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0

Actions

Shares
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0

Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
    No notes for slide
  • Same stimuli = same results in physical sciences… not necessarily, in soc sci!
  • Come to the research with a bias from their own discipline…
  • Overcome suspicions and naivity through guided reading of each others’ literature. – Greaves & Grant

Transcript

  • 1. Interdisciplinary Research …their work …our support Jenny Delasalle & Richard Parker For Library EMT, 22 June 2010
  • 2. What’s it all about?
    • Interdisciplinary, multidisciplinary, cross-disciplinary, transdisciplinary, subdisciplinary, …*disciplinarity
    • Quantitative/Qualitative preferences.
    • What is a science? What makes a science? How wide is the divide?
    • Within the Social Sciences?
    • From Social Sciences to Natural Sciences? Physical Sciences
  • 3. Multidisciplinary research Problem information, techniques, perspective, terminology, concepts etc
  • 4. Interdisciplinary research Problem Shared language, Methodology
  • 5. Transdisciplinary research? Problem Framework: assumptions, theories & frames of analysis …
  • 6.
    • Problem
    A whole discipline Own teaching techniques, funding, administration and professional development. Hierarchies and specialisations within a discipline. sub sub
  • 7. More big words…
    • Ontology – What can we research?
    • Epistemology – What can be known about it?
    • Methodology – How can we find that out? (Strategic level)
    • Research Methods – techniques & procedures (Operational level)
    • Data Sources
    • ( http://www.politicsjournal.org/Articles/grix.pdf)
  • 8. Interdisciplinary teaching
    • Research-led teaching! Lead academics with skills/experience in both disciplines
    • Employers expect of our students that they can work across disciplinary boundaries
    • Module formats and assessment methods acceptable to all departments!
    • Packed curricula: enough in their own discipline!
    • Timetabling, deadlines, pre-requisites
  • 9. Limitations on/barriers to interdisciplinary research
    • Career advancement concerns: hierarchy
    • RAE/REF discipline-based panels
    • Suspicion regarding rigour of qualitative research
    • Lack of respect/confidence in each others’ findings. Value judgements.
    • Naïve expectations of the others’ contribution.
    • Must overcome mis-understandings… assumptions, methodology, vocabulary
    • (NB less distance might cause more assumptions!)
    • How to write joint publications:
      • “ tersely argued” in just a few pages vs discursive styles.
      • Standardising jargon of different disciplines.
    • “ Replacing one orthodoxy with another”
    • Loss of specialisation
  • 10. Academics’ needs
    • Learn from experts in other disciplines
    • Where to start in unfamiliar territory
    • Which methodology to follow
    • How the discipline is structured
    • Guided reading
    • Which methods to use? How to explore ideas?
    • What is happening/Who is doing interesting work in their field?
  • 11. Benefits of interdisciplinary co-operation
    • Methodological insights
    • Opening areas of interest
    • Developing common approaches
    • Fresh insights: a new perspective
    • Re-framing a problem
    • Enhance wider-world significance/impact of the research
    • Carve your own niche!
  • 12. Drivers for interdisciplinary research
    • Improve profile
    • Acquire new skills and contacts
    • Create international calibre
    • Collaborate with non-academic areas
    • Financial support – funders
  • 13. What has the library got?
    • AS team which crosses the disciplines.
    • Individuals who have crossed discipline.
    • New perspective to add when considering where to publish.
    • Contacts in/knowledge of individuals across departments.
    • Subscription databases to use for identifying collaborators.