• Save
Boase, J., & Kobayashi, T. (2012). Theoretical Implications of  Digital Trace Data: Insight From the Development of a  Mobile Smartphone Application. Presented at the Social Science and Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights symposium. March 12.
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×
 

Boase, J., & Kobayashi, T. (2012). Theoretical Implications of Digital Trace Data: Insight From the Development of a Mobile Smartphone Application. Presented at the Social Science and Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights symposium. March 12.

on

  • 279 views

This paper was presented at the Social Science and Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights symposium held at Oxford University on March 12, 2012. The symposium was organized by the Oxford ...

This paper was presented at the Social Science and Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights symposium held at Oxford University on March 12, 2012. The symposium was organized by the Oxford Internet Institute.

Statistics

Views

Total Views
279
Views on SlideShare
279
Embed Views
0

Actions

Likes
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0

0 Embeds 0

No embeds

Accessibility

Upload Details

Uploaded via as Apple Keynote

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Processing…
Post Comment
Edit your comment
  • \n
  • \n
  • Explain CS & IS role\nInterdisciplinary? \nYes: we work in different disciplines\nNo: each of us has training and publishes in venues of different disciplines \nLess scholars from different disciplines who collaborate\nMore we are both interdisciplinary scholars who are collaborating\n
  • \n
  • - NHK story\n
  • \n
  • Self-Report vs. Log Data: - self-report = mobile use \n- mobile use = frequency \n\nWhat’s wrong with self-report?- over under-reporting random = okay\n- over under-reporting non-random = not okay\n\nCan self-report be improved? - compensate/develop weights via demographics\n\n
  • Results: respondents tend to over-report\nDemographics: few associations -- difficult to compensate \nOver-reporting can have spurious affects: inflates correlation between mobile phone use & civic participation\nResults robust across Japan and the US\n
  • Collaboration with CS and IS \npermits a possible cumulating of knowledge \n
  • Mobile media multiplexity or - Multiplexity: texting + voice = maintain same ties?\na division of mobile media?- Division: texting = monadic clusters & voice = bridging\n\nDoes relational role predict - rational role via phone book\ninteraction?- predict to frequency & duration of interaction using relational role?\n\nHow rhythmic are ties?- predicting to regularity of contact OR predictability of contact\n- relational role & duration of contact may be predictors\n\n
  • Bonding/Bridging: - Sociology: Lin focuses on KNOWING people in diverse Occupation\n- Political science: Putnam: like mindedness & organizational engagement\n- Communication: Ellison & Lampe: self-report of interaction preference\n\nPre-condition of related outcomes: e.g. access to new information - must communicate to access\n
  • Yes: we want to build on existing scholarship\nNo: existing scholarship often includes cognition & behaviour\n
  • \n

Boase, J., & Kobayashi, T. (2012). Theoretical Implications of  Digital Trace Data: Insight From the Development of a  Mobile Smartphone Application. Presented at the Social Science and Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights symposium. March 12. Boase, J., & Kobayashi, T. (2012). Theoretical Implications of Digital Trace Data: Insight From the Development of a Mobile Smartphone Application. Presented at the Social Science and Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights symposium. March 12. Presentation Transcript

  • Theoretical Implications ofDigital Trace Data Insight From the Development of a Mobile Smartphone ApplicationJeffrey Boase, Ryerson University, CanadaTetsuro Kobayashi, National Institute of Informatics, JapanSocial Science And Digital Research: Interdisciplinary Insights SymposiumOxford Internet Institute, March 12th, 2012
  • Overview✤ Project Overview✤ Research Questions✤ Implications✤ Reflections and Insights✤ Conclusions
  • The Project✤ Android app✤ Anonymizes log data✤ Data is encrypted and uploaded✤ Onscreen surveys✤ Collaboration of... Computer & Info. Scientists Social Psychologist Communication Researcher
  • CommunicationExplorer✤ Panel participants ✤ 310 adults in Japan ✤ 232 adults in the USA✤ Log data General survey data Pop-up survey data
  • RelationshipImprover✤ Experimental design ✤ 100 adults in Japan ✤ 100 adults in the USA✤ Also free download in app store (NHK)✤ Interact with network graph✤ App suggests people to contact✤ Log & pop-up survey data
  • Phone Log Data
  • MethodologicalQuestionsSelf-Report vs. Log Data✤ What’s wrong with self-report?✤ Can self-report be improved?
  • ImmediateImplications✤ Literature analysis 40% mobile comm. journal publications use these self- report measures (Boase & Ling)✤ Internet researchers use similar self-report measures✤ Results: non-random error✤ Demographics only help identify over-reporting slightly
  • LargerImplications✤ Self-report measures are highly limiting✤ Advancement of empirical quantitative research implies more connection with IS & CS
  • TheoreticalQuestionsMobile CommunicationNetworks✤ Mobile media multiplexity or a division of mobile media?✤ How rhythmic are ties?✤ Are findings robust across Japan and the US?
  • ImmediateImplications✤ Bonding & bridging are commonly used concepts✤ But they are operationalized in a variety of ways✤ We are rethinking bonding & bridging in behavioural terms✤ Behaviour is a pre-condition of many outcomes
  • LargerImplications✤ But does it make sense to operationalize existing concepts using only behaviour?✤ Will theory focus more on behaviour as a result of this sort of digital research?
  • Conclusion✤ The project highlights the weakness of self-report✤ This project has led us to question and rethink core concepts in the social sciences in behavioural terms✤ How this is approach will be received by scholars remains to be seen