Signing And Speaking Ch. 5
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Signing And Speaking Ch. 5






Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



0 Embeds 0

No embeds



Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

Signing And Speaking Ch. 5 Signing And Speaking Ch. 5 Presentation Transcript

  • Signing and Speaking William C. Stokoe Competitors, Alternatives, or Incompatibles? Jacqueline Hurst
  • Introduction
    • Language origins – we should not assume that language was only spoken and heard
    • Sign languages are true languages
    • Different cultures use a combination of signed and spoken language
    • Language is necessary for humanity but the crucial feature is not vocal
  • What are Neanderthals?
    • An extinct human species or subspecies
    • (Homo neanderthalensis and Homo sapiens neanderthalensis)
    • They lived during the late Pleistocene Epoch throughout most of Europe and parts of Asia and northern Africa and are associated with Middle Paleolithic tools
    View slide
  • Neanderthal Culture
    • Evidence shows that they buried their dead and put artifacts into their graves
    • Implies a culture that includes some notions of life after death
    View slide
  • Lieberman (1972, 1975)
    • Suggested that Neanderthals lacked the physiology for speech
    • But still possessed a fully human culture complete with language
    • … How is this possible?
  • Opponents of Lieberman:
    • Evidence of Neanderthal culture implies a human culture
    • Such a culture requires language
    • Therefore Neanderthal man could speak and understand
    • Lieberman’s conclusions must be false
  • But It Is Possible!
    • Neanderthals had other human attributes like bipedalism, human hands with unpongid thumb placement, convergent binocular vision, and human faces
    • Spoken language is not the only form of human language
  • Other Ways of Communicating
    • Facial expressions – thanks to binocular vision
    • Body language
    • Hand gestures – thanks to bipedalism, hand are free
  • Sign Language of Aboriginal Australia (1988)
    • Adam Kendon
    • Primary sign languages
    • Alternate sign languages
    • Shows that signing and speaking are not incompatible
  • Primary Sign Language
    • Used mostly by persons whose hearing acuity makes it impossible for them to acquire true spoken language competence
  • Alternate Sign Language
    • Use is determined by culture instead of physical necessity
    • Can be used as speech is used, for normal conversation
  • Examples
    • Australian Aborigines
      • Requires signing to be substituted for speaking under certain circumstances.
    • Warramungu/Walpari women
    • Signing is the preferred form of communication for prolonged conversations
    • Yucatans
      • Communicate with hearing and deaf fluently in sign language
      • Teenagers use both sign and speak in everyday discourse
  • Conclusion
    • Signing and speaking are and always were compatible
    • To assume vocal language is ethnocentric
    • Signing is more likely than speaking to have been the means by which language was first transmitted and acquired