Hospital	  Projects	  A	  participatory	  approach	  to	  Interaction	  Design	  CHOI	  Chi	  Kit,	  Jackson	  	  	  	  //...
//	  relatively	  an	  open	  brief	  	  //	  design	  opportunities	  for	  improving	  the	         medical	  services	 ...
“What are the Medical Services?”
//	  scouting	  visits	  to	  the	  hospital	  
//	  to	  meet	  professional	  health	  caregivers	  
//	  to	  understand	  the	  organization	  and	  daily	  operation	  	  
//	  to	  observe	  how	  patients	  and	  health	  caregivers	  are	  interacting	  in	  the	  hospital.	  	  	  
//	  Potential	  project	  areas	  have	  been	  identified	  
Medical experiencefor ethnic minorityJackson	  CHOI	  Chi	  Kit	  MDES	  Interaction	  Design	  
“What is in my mind”    A	  project	  for	  Ethnic	  Minority	  
Ethnic minorities are facing differentproblems such as languages, social,cultural and religious issues in hospital.
Ethnic minorities are facing differentproblems such as languages, social,cultural and religious issues in hospital.HK, eme...
Ethnic minorities are facing differentproblems such as languages, social,cultural and religious issues in hospital. Taboo,...
Preliminary	  Proposition	  •  It	  is	  a	  conflicts	  between	  different	  cultures	  •  Minority	  VS	  Majority	  =	  ...
Preliminary	  Proposition	  •  It	  is	  a	  conflicts	  between	  different	  cultures	  •  Minority	  VS	  Majority	  =	  ...
“Preconception is a hallucinogen        for designers!”    You	  seem	  to	  know	  what	  you	  actually	  don’t!	  
Research	  and	  analysis	  methodologies	  
Service	  Design	  	  //	  relevance	  //	  usability	  	  //	  desirability	  and	  	  //	  compassion	  	  	  are	  the	...
Service	  Design	  	                                                       }//	  relevance	                               ...
“not what we want to design for the projects but what is required for a reliable, effective and comforting          patien...
  	   	   	   %	   	  20of	  patient	  population	  
Ingredients	  of	  research	                     People	      Tasks	                  Trust	           insights	  
//	  we	  should	  encourage	  the	  participation	  and	  contribution	  of	  all	  stakeholders	  in	  the	  very	  earl...
Pa:ent	  family	                    Management	                          pa:ents	  Social	  workers	                      ...
they are real people, not data
By	  understanding	  the	  real	  problems	  and	   difficulties	  faced	  by	  the	  stakeholders…	  	  
By	  understanding	  the	  real	  problems	  and	         difficulties	  faced	  by	  the	  stakeholders,	  	  	  Insights	 ...
//	  interviews	  were	  conducted	  with	  stakeholders	  who	  had	  provided	  useful	  views	  and	  suggestions	  abo...
“the	  one	  thing	  that	  would	    make	  my	  job	  easier	  ,	  is	           more	  time”	  
“Without	  interpreter,	  they	  cannot	   explain	  themselves	  fully,	  have	   phobia,	  and	  prefer	  not	  go	  to	...
"I	  dont	  really	  understand	  those	  difficult	  medical	  terms.	  	   ~	  Pakistani	  boy	  	  	  
"Core	  informa,on	  is	  important	  for	  sickness,	  not-­‐so-­‐core	  info	  may	  influence	  the	  experience."	   ~	...
Healthcare	  Givers	  Said	  //	  Don’t	  show	  up	  in	  appointed	  date	  //	  Don’t	  understand	  medical	  instruct...
Difficulties	  	  //	  Ethnic	  minorities	  are	  facing	  various	  difficulties	  such	  as	  language,	  cultural,	  and	 ...
We know the people,research	           Ingredients	  of	   what about their                 task?                         ...
“What about Current Patient Journey?”            A	  project	  for	  Ethnic	  Minority	  
//	  To	  collect	  direct	  evidence	  of	  patients’	  medical	  experience,	  research	  methods	  like	  field	  observ...
Field	  Research	  	    Health	  Check	  seminar	  
Triage	  Station	  	    EM	  patients	  shadowing	  in	  patient	  journey	    12	  EM	  patients	  for	  10	  hours	    	...
Consultation	  Room	  	   EM	  patients	  shadowing	  in	  patient	  journey	   12	  EM	  patients	  for	  10	  hours	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	                           interpreters	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
?“What did I learn from these ?”
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  	   “Without	  interpreter,	  th...
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  à  Let	  the	  patient	  take	 ...
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  à  Let	  the	  patient	  take	 ...
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  à  Let	  the	  patient	  take	 ...
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  à  Let	  the	  patient	  take	 ...
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  à  Let	  the	  patient	  take	 ...
Insights	  	  à	  Build	  confidence	  for	  EM	  patients	  and	  let	  them	  express	  à  Let	  the	  patient	  take	 ...
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
//	  not	  to	  focus	  on	  solving	  the	  social	  and	  cultural	  conflicts	  between	  EM	  patients	  and	  hospital...
Patient	  Journey	  	  
Patient	  Journey	  	  
//	  not	  to	  highlight	  instructions	  warning	  patients	  the	  importance	  of	  medical	  treatment	  and	  exerci...
New	  Interaction	  Model	  
//	  not	  to	  redesign	  the	  visual	  forms	  of	  charts	  and	  files,	  and	  how	  they	  are	  displayed	  in	  di...
//	  Participatory	  design	  approach	  is	  adopted	  to	  actively	  involve	  stakeholders	  in	  the	  design	  proce...
//	  Co-­‐creation	  and	  evaluation	  workshops	  had	  been	  conducted	  with	  stakeholders	  who	  contributed	  a	 ...
Co-­‐design	  Workshops	  Doctors,	  nurse	  and	  management	  people	  involved	  
Content	  and	  task	  analysis	  
Evaluation	  Workshops	  
Doctor	  Device	  –	  information	  architecture	  	  
Doctor	  Device	  -­‐	  paper	  prototyping	  	  	  
Evaluation	  Workshops	  
//	  Project	  Schedule	  co-­‐design	  /	  evaluation	  workshops	  are	  continuous	  activities	  towards	  the	  final	...
Challenges and Reflections
food	              language	                                              taboo	                 communica:on	            ...
solve-­‐all-­‐problems?	  >>	  solve	  specific	  problems	  	  
social	  related	  project?	  >>	  	  interaction	  design	  project	  
With	  participatory	  approach	  	  //	  Can	  discover	  findings	  that	  secondary	  research	  cannot.	  //	  Can	  ob...
//	  C0-­‐design	  /	  evaluation	  workshops	  are	  one	  of	  the	  most	  important	  tools	  for	  generating	  and	 ...
//	  the	  communication	  barrier	  became	  not	  only	  the	  problem	  of	  ethnic	  minority	  group,	  but	  also	  ...
More	  patients	  should	  be	  involved	  in	  co-­‐design	  workshops,	  instead	  of	  just	  healthcare	  givers.	  
//	  forget	  about	  designing,	  	  //	  release	  our	  perception,	  	  	  //	  understand	  people	  and	  their	  re...
Thank you                                                               This	  presenta:on	  is	  consolidated	  with	  th...
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design

1,376

Published on

1 Comment
10 Likes
Statistics
Notes
No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,376
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
1
Likes
10
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "Hospital projects - a participatory approach to interaction design"

  1. 1. Hospital  Projects  A  participatory  approach  to  Interaction  Design  CHOI  Chi  Kit,  Jackson        //            ICID  Conference  2011          //          11.11.2011  
  2. 2. //  relatively  an  open  brief    //  design  opportunities  for  improving  the   medical  services  of  Pok  Oi  Hospital  
  3. 3. “What are the Medical Services?”
  4. 4. //  scouting  visits  to  the  hospital  
  5. 5. //  to  meet  professional  health  caregivers  
  6. 6. //  to  understand  the  organization  and  daily  operation    
  7. 7. //  to  observe  how  patients  and  health  caregivers  are  interacting  in  the  hospital.      
  8. 8. //  Potential  project  areas  have  been  identified  
  9. 9. Medical experiencefor ethnic minorityJackson  CHOI  Chi  Kit  MDES  Interaction  Design  
  10. 10. “What is in my mind” A  project  for  Ethnic  Minority  
  11. 11. Ethnic minorities are facing differentproblems such as languages, social,cultural and religious issues in hospital.
  12. 12. Ethnic minorities are facing differentproblems such as languages, social,cultural and religious issues in hospital.HK, emergency 急症Filipino, kagipitanPakistani, !"#$%&, UrduIndonesian, darurat Nepalese, Nepali
  13. 13. Ethnic minorities are facing differentproblems such as languages, social,cultural and religious issues in hospital. Taboo, food, customs, ideology (sex, body)Hinduism / NepaleseMuslims / IndonesianIslam / Pakistani
  14. 14. Preliminary  Proposition  •  It  is  a  conflicts  between  different  cultures  •  Minority  VS  Majority  =  Inferior  VS  superior  •  Discrimination  
  15. 15. Preliminary  Proposition  •  It  is  a  conflicts  between  different  cultures  •  Minority  VS  Majority  =  Inferior  VS  superior  •  Discrimination   BIG Problem is far too
  16. 16. “Preconception is a hallucinogen for designers!” You  seem  to  know  what  you  actually  don’t!  
  17. 17. Research  and  analysis  methodologies  
  18. 18. Service  Design    //  relevance  //  usability    //  desirability  and    //  compassion      are  the  keys  to  success;  all  of  these  criteria  are  user-­‐centered  
  19. 19. Service  Design     }//  relevance   customer  //  usability     behavior  //  desirability  and     emotional  //  compassion     values    are  the  keys  to  success;  all  of  those  criteria  are  user-­‐centered  that  lead  to  customer  behaviors  and  emotional  values.    
  20. 20. “not what we want to design for the projects but what is required for a reliable, effective and comforting patient journey.” behavior  +  emotion  
  21. 21.         %    20of  patient  population  
  22. 22. Ingredients  of  research   People   Tasks   Trust   insights  
  23. 23. //  we  should  encourage  the  participation  and  contribution  of  all  stakeholders  in  the  very  early  stage  of  development  
  24. 24. Pa:ent  family   Management   pa:ents  Social  workers   Healthcare  givers  
  25. 25. they are real people, not data
  26. 26. By  understanding  the  real  problems  and   difficulties  faced  by  the  stakeholders…    
  27. 27. By  understanding  the  real  problems  and   difficulties  faced  by  the  stakeholders,      Insights  and  solutions  will  emerge  automatically.  
  28. 28. //  interviews  were  conducted  with  stakeholders  who  had  provided  useful  views  and  suggestions  about  concerns  and  problems  from  different  perspectives.    
  29. 29. “the  one  thing  that  would   make  my  job  easier  ,  is   more  time”  
  30. 30. “Without  interpreter,  they  cannot   explain  themselves  fully,  have   phobia,  and  prefer  not  go  to  the   hospital."      ~  Ms.  Samaira  Rehmat,  SSCEM  
  31. 31. "I  dont  really  understand  those  difficult  medical  terms.     ~  Pakistani  boy      
  32. 32. "Core  informa,on  is  important  for  sickness,  not-­‐so-­‐core  info  may  influence  the  experience."   ~  Rita  Kong,  Manager,  Community  Health  Center    
  33. 33. Healthcare  Givers  Said  //  Don’t  show  up  in  appointed  date  //  Don’t  understand  medical  instructions  //  Forget  to  bring  medical  reports  //  May  use  identity  of  someone  else  just  to  save  money    Patients  Said  //  Why  I  need  to  wait  for  4  hours?  //  I  get  Panadol  for  all  illnesses  //  I  need  to  bring  along  my  kids  to  the  hospital  or  else  no  one  is  taking  care  of  them  //  Doctors  are  exaggerating  my  illness  //  Difficult  to  use  telephone  reservation  system  //  I  am  lost  in  hospital  
  34. 34. Difficulties    //  Ethnic  minorities  are  facing  various  difficulties  such  as  language,  cultural,  and  emotional  issues  in  medical  service  in  POH.      Being  ignored  Sense  of  helplessness  Stressed  and  lost    
  35. 35. We know the people,research   Ingredients  of   what about their task? People   Tasks   Trust   insights  
  36. 36. “What about Current Patient Journey?” A  project  for  Ethnic  Minority  
  37. 37. //  To  collect  direct  evidence  of  patients’  medical  experience,  research  methods  like  field  observation  and  shadowing  have  been  used  for  patients  in  different  departments  and  clinics.  
  38. 38. Field  Research     Health  Check  seminar  
  39. 39. Triage  Station     EM  patients  shadowing  in  patient  journey   12  EM  patients  for  10  hours      
  40. 40. Consultation  Room     EM  patients  shadowing  in  patient  journey   12  EM  patients  for  10  hours  
  41. 41. Patient  Journey    
  42. 42. Patient  Journey     interpreters  
  43. 43. Patient  Journey    
  44. 44. Patient  Journey    
  45. 45. Patient  Journey    
  46. 46. Patient  Journey    
  47. 47. Patient  Journey    
  48. 48. Patient  Journey    
  49. 49. Patient  Journey    
  50. 50. ?“What did I learn from these ?”
  51. 51. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express     “Without  interpreter,  they  cannot  explain   themselves  fully,  have  phobia,  and  prefer   not  go  to  the  hospital."       ~  Ms.  Samaira  Rehmat,  SSCEM  
  52. 52. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express  à  Let  the  patient  take  control  of  the  journey     “Doctor  and  nurse  tend  to  talk  to   interpreters  instead  of  to  EM  patient”   ~  from  observation  in  shadowing      
  53. 53. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express  à  Let  the  patient  take  control  of  the  journey  à  To  create  consistent  contact  point  for  adherence   "  One  patient  meets  many  people  in   various  stages  of  the  journey"      
  54. 54. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express  à  Let  the  patient  take  control  of  the  journey  à  To  create  consistent  contact  point  for  adherence  à  Prevent  inaccurate  translation     "I  dont  really  understand  those  difficult   medical  terms.  Sometimes  I  need  to  call   my  daddy  to  do  further  interpretation.”     ~  Pakistani  boy      
  55. 55. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express  à  Let  the  patient  take  control  of  the  journey  à  To  create  consistent  contact  point  for  adherence  à  Prevent  inaccurate  translation  à  Make  use  of  the  waiting  time     "  In  hospital  ,  is  always  waiting,  waiting.  I   have  brought  newspaper  to  kill  time."       ~  GURUNG,  Sujan  
  56. 56. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express  à  Let  the  patient  take  control  of  the  journey  à  To  create  consistent  contact  point  for  adherence  à  Prevent  inaccurate  translation  à  Make  use  of  the  waiting  time     Emotional Aspects "  In  hospital  ,  is  always  waiting,  waiting.  I   have  brought  newspaper  to  kill  time."       ~  GURUNG,  Sujan  
  57. 57. Insights    à  Build  confidence  for  EM  patients  and  let  them  express  à  Let  the  patient  take  control  of  the  journey  à  To  create  consistent  contact  point  for  adherence  à  Prevent  inaccurate  translation  à  Make  use  of  the  waiting  time     Technical Aspects "  In  hospital  ,  is  always  waiting,  waiting.  I   have  brought  newspaper  to  kill  time."       ~  GURUNG,  Sujan  
  58. 58. Patient  Journey    
  59. 59. Patient  Journey    
  60. 60. //  not  to  focus  on  solving  the  social  and  cultural  conflicts  between  EM  patients  and  hospital    //  but  to  empower  EM  patients  to  take  control  of  their  patient  journey  through  effective  communication  tools.  
  61. 61. Patient  Journey    
  62. 62. Patient  Journey    
  63. 63. //  not  to  highlight  instructions  warning  patients  the  importance  of  medical  treatment  and  exercise    //  but  to  engage  young  patients  to  support  each  other  as  a  community,  and  motivate  the  exercise  through  their  habits.  
  64. 64. New  Interaction  Model  
  65. 65. //  not  to  redesign  the  visual  forms  of  charts  and  files,  and  how  they  are  displayed  in  different  locations    //  but  to  develop  a  mechanism  of  transferring  and  translating  important  patient  information  for  clinics  to  wards,  from  doctor  to  nurse  to  technicians  effectively.  
  66. 66. //  Participatory  design  approach  is  adopted  to  actively  involve  stakeholders  in  the  design  process  ensuring  that  the  design  solutions  meet  their  needs  and  is  usable.  And  they  can  be  more  responsive  and  appropriate  to  the  users  cultural,  emotional,  and  physical  conditions.  
  67. 67. //  Co-­‐creation  and  evaluation  workshops  had  been  conducted  with  stakeholders  who  contributed  a  lot  to  the  relevancy  of  project  direction,  content  as  well  as  the  usability  of  design  solutions.      
  68. 68. Co-­‐design  Workshops  Doctors,  nurse  and  management  people  involved  
  69. 69. Content  and  task  analysis  
  70. 70. Evaluation  Workshops  
  71. 71. Doctor  Device  –  information  architecture    
  72. 72. Doctor  Device  -­‐  paper  prototyping      
  73. 73. Evaluation  Workshops  
  74. 74. //  Project  Schedule  co-­‐design  /  evaluation  workshops  are  continuous  activities  towards  the  final  stage  of  development  
  75. 75. Challenges and Reflections
  76. 76. food   language   taboo   communica:on   cultural   social   ideology   religion  discrimina:on   custom  
  77. 77. solve-­‐all-­‐problems?  >>  solve  specific  problems    
  78. 78. social  related  project?  >>    interaction  design  project  
  79. 79. With  participatory  approach    //  Can  discover  findings  that  secondary  research  cannot.  //  Can  observe  target  behavior  in  context  that  generate  relevant  insights  for  design  development.  //  Can  put  ourselves  in  the  shoes  of  stakeholders  
  80. 80. //  C0-­‐design  /  evaluation  workshops  are  one  of  the  most  important  tools  for  generating  and  evaluating  the  design  solutions  whether  they  can  actually  empower  the  users,  and  will  be  well  received.    
  81. 81. //  the  communication  barrier  became  not  only  the  problem  of  ethnic  minority  group,  but  also  the  problem  of  the  designer  too.      //  the  down  side  is  I  needed  to  rely  on  interpreters  for  translation,  whom  I  claimed  as  an  unreliable/indirect  source  of  information.  //  the  positive  side  of  it  was  that  I  could  put  myself  into  their  shoes  and  share  their  frustration  and  stress.  
  82. 82. More  patients  should  be  involved  in  co-­‐design  workshops,  instead  of  just  healthcare  givers.  
  83. 83. //  forget  about  designing,    //  release  our  perception,      //  understand  people  and  their  real  difficulties.      //  then  the  design  solutions  will  find  their  way  to  you.  
  84. 84. Thank you This  presenta:on  is  consolidated  with  the  project  materials    from  Charles  LAW,  Krupali  RAIYANI  and  Jackson  CHOI  

×