Quality Control of Conferences


Published on

A recent decree by the Medical Council of India has made it mandatory for Indian doctors to attend conferences and get credit points to renew their licence to practice.
There is hence a mad rush to attend all conferences.
But the MCI would do well to evaluate conferences that they are forcing us to attend.

Published in: Health & Medicine, Business
  • Doctors have to accumulate 6 credit points a year for the last 5 years till 2012 for a 5 year renewal of our Licence. We were made aware of this rule only this year. So, you can well imagine the mad scramble to attend accredited Conferences. But the quality of conferences needs improvement to be meaningful.
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here
  • I believe all doctors registered with Maharashtra Medical Council need to accumulate 10 credit hours (CMEs and Conferences) by March 2012. And there are just not enough quality conferences being held. Therefore, attending just about ANY conference has become necessary!
    Are you sure you want to  Yes  No
    Your message goes here
No Downloads
Total views
On SlideShare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Quality Control of Conferences

  1. 1. March 29, 2011<br />Quality control of Conferences<br />By- Dr. Swati allahabadia<br />'Whatever you do, do it well.'<br />This is the principle I and my friends were taught-by parents, grand parents and teachers.The recent Common wealth games sadly brought to the notice of India and the world that Indians believe problems will sort themselves out. And embarrassed a young nation with shabby construction and toilets. And corruption and poor hygiene standards.<br />The west used to laugh at Japanese goods, till the Japanese took care of quality-in their cars electronics and everything. <br />In the movie 127 hrs, the hero uses a Chinese knife to cut stone and then curses it for being Chinese and regrets leaving his Swiss knife at home-as if the Swiss knife would cut the boulder! Western nations never miss an opportunity to criticise Chinese goods.India escapes this criticism because we don't make that many finished goods.But the quality of what we produce, would even make the Chinese laugh.<br />A recent decree by the Medical Council of India has made it mandatory for Indian doctors to attend conferences and get credit points to renew their licence to practice.There is hence a mad rush to attend all conferences.<br />But the MCI would do well to evaluate conferences that they are forcing us to attend.Most speakers are chosen from among the elected committee members of the body organising the conferences or their friends. The topic the speaker speaks on is sometimes not of their core competency, or a field where the speaker has researched. Occasionally, the entire talk is downloaded from the Net or books or Journals or prepared by the company whose product the speaker uses. As a result the audience gets no information about the actual practical issues in a topic or can well read up the topic themselves without attending the conference! Most speakers have a set of prepared subjects that they keep repeating all the time. So we hear the same things at various conferences for years on the end. The same thing is seen with panel discussions/workshops/debates-tremendous repetition of inconsequential data.To all the Presidents and managing committee members of various medical organisations-past, present and future, may I offer the following suggestions to make the conference worth our while when we leave our patients, families and leisure to come and listen to you? <br />1. Choose the topics  and the sub topics for the conference well-let it be approved by atleast 2 more members so as to be relevant and practical to an average gynaecologist while highlighting newer fields and problem areas.e.g High Intensity Focussed Ultrasound with MRI guidance. Pelvic floor repair. The latest in Ovulation Induction.<br />2. Get Surgeons, Physicians, Anaesthetists, Urologists, Embryologists-all the people from allied fields to talk and let this be followed up by a talk by a Gynaecologist who has extensive experience in the same field. e.g. Cholecystectomy/ Appendectomy/  Multi drug resistant TB/ Malaria in pregnancy<br />3. Instead of saving up money for the organisation, spend it to get good international speakers who are actually doing path breaking research in their fields. Members fees come from their tax-they won't mind paying a bit more. Pharma companies are more than happy to help. Organise for more people instead of closing limited registrations.<br />4. For all the time and energy spent by managing committee members, don't give them meaningless lectures but let them get extra credit points for organising a conference. They can also be given preference for a lecture if they are doing work in the area.<br />5. Invite talks from all ordinary gynaecologists-let them present the jist of their talk beforehand and let it be approved by the managing committee before the person is given the opportunity e.g. removal of large fibroids through a minilaparotomy incision using a tonsillar knife to core out the fibroid.<br />6. Have a feedback form for the audience-speakers who get very adverse comments should not be repeated. e.g. a speaker who showed several different incisions for a caesarean section but had no explanation for choosing those incisions. Overseas speakers who are incomprehensible. Speakers who quote fake statistics, exceed their time and repeat their talk too often.<br />7. Introducing some standards like ISO 9000 towards conferences will help improve the level of the conferences.  In today's information age where all lead journals are available at the click of a button, conferences will be relevant only if they highlight actual work and practical problems faced.<br />Conferences are for the benefit of the audience and not for the speakers or organisers.<br />Author: Dr. Swati Allahabadia<br />About: Dr. Swati Allahabadia is a Consultant Gynaecologist practicing in Mumbai since the last 19 years. She has wide ranging experience in every aspect of Gynaecology having worked in the Family planning area for two years, as Lecturer and then Associate Professor at the Sion Hospital-a teaching Hospital in Mumbai. She currently practices at: Rotunda Hospital, Brach Candy Hospital and Wadia Hospital. She has a website from website for doctors<br />Contact: www.gyno4u.com, swatiallahbadia@gmail.com <br />Blog: http://saadharanaari.blogspot.com/<br />