Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
0
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Whither Pakistan?
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.

×
Saving this for later? Get the SlideShare app to save on your phone or tablet. Read anywhere, anytime – even offline.
Text the download link to your phone
Standard text messaging rates apply

Whither Pakistan?

313

Published on

Nadeem Ul Haque …

Nadeem Ul Haque
12th August 2009, International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI)

Published in: Travel, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
313
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
9
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

Report content
Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. Whither Pakistan? Whither Pakistan? Swat, Buner, Gojra, Mukhtaaran mai,  Hina’s office murder‐‐‐‐a continuum‐
  • 2. Four failures Four failures • Failed state Failed state • Failed society • Failed policy il d li • Failed intellect • How? Who? Needs debate How?  Who?  Needs debate • But we do not even have forums for that?
  • 3. Failed state Failed state • Apologists will say cars run…… 1. State has no monopoly on violence 2. No property rights 2 No property rights – Qabza 3. No justice – G j Gojra – Hina etc • State is the biggest predator‐‐‐ serves elite‐‐rentseeking • Too many games played by the state – No one believes Masood dead No one believes Masood
  • 4. Failed society Failed society • Fragmentation – Clan, religion, tribe‐‐‐‐looking for the door • Newspapers full of despair • “Today failure is the most often heard  expression in Pakistan.” Roedad News aug 11 • “Pakistan is a dream turned sour, very few will  disagree.” Tayyab Siddiqui nation Aug 4
  • 5. Social capital: What ordinary folk  think‐‐‐98 immigrants Dubai? Percent Proud of being Pakistani 16 Pakistanis are at fault 72 Work together W k t th 22 No Trust 69 Faith in state 12 faith in leadership 7
  • 6. Failed Policies Failed Policies • Wunderkind PM croaked success Wunderkind PM croaked success • Musharaf “in line of fire” strutting about • All donor agencies congratulatory All donor agencies congratulatory – Some macro and a burst of growth • Governance Governance  • Justice system  • Democracy D • The world (donors) happy…..congratulatory
  • 7. Failed intellect Failed intellect • No thought leadership‐‐‐research thinking— No thought leadership research thinking systematically destroyed • No technocracy No local debates no local No technocracy‐‐‐No local debates …no local  visions • N No professionalism  ‐‐Bankers for  f i li B k f economists…Army officers for running  universities i ii • All policy made by donors—no responsibility   SAP, IPP FCD etc
  • 8. Social protection perfect Social protection‐‐‐perfect • Of the elite • Civil servant perks 14% of expenditures • Clubs, golf courses, polo elite education  subsidized • Subsidies‐‐‐PM and President travel 4b • Pi Prime land for rich and rich entertainment l df i h d i h t t i t • Poor condemned way out • Apartheid!?!?
  • 9. The poor The poor • Excluded c uded • Charity • No opportunity No opportunity • No space • “The regal manner in which the rulers have  p treated themselves at the tremendous expense  of the misery of the ruled is most depressing.”  The Nation
  • 10. Youth • 90m under 20 90m under 20 • No education • No skills No skills • No opportunity‐‐‐No hope • No space—not even public or community N t bli it • No intellectual guidance…no domestic  thought leadership th ht l d hi • Except Mosque and Moulvi
  • 11. What do you expect? What do you expect? • Will they not come? Will they not come? • Is John Perkins right? • But what is the objective? • Without a new approach….shudder
  • 12. What new approach What new approach • Build society Build society • Build state—ghani and Lockhart Alavi • Build community ild i • Let local intellect and debate lead –Ownership and local relevance O hi dl l l

×