User Experience Vision, Strategy & Teams
UX Marathon 2009
14 October 2009
Susan J. Wolfe Managing Director
susan.wolfe@optimalexperience.com
www.optimalexperience.com
1
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 1

Today’s session
Part 1: Defining the UX strategy
– What is a UX strategy and how do you develop it
Scoping your strategy and creating a vision
– Obstacles and opportunities
Knowing your organization
Part 2: Implementing the vision
– Making the UX team successful
– Techniques and user-centered design
Some of today’s top methods and techniques
– Measuring the success
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 2

Sources
Multiple surveys of our colleagues about practices
and viewpoints
Usability Professionals’ Association survey
Previous workshops and presentations over the
years
And lots and lots of experience…
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 3

Usability vs. user experience
UI design Cross-functional
Deep Customer Knowledge
UX
Design
User-Centered
Methodology Design Generalists
Usability
Evaluation Experts
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 4

Why user experience?
Here’s Cat, a project manager and mother of 2
teenagers, answering emails using her Blackberry on
the NY subway.
She sees an email confirming an order she placed for
her daughter’s birthday, but it’s not going to arrive
in time.
When she gets out of the subway she calls the
company to cancel the order. The customer service
person helps her select something else,
guaranteeing it will arrive on time at no extra cost.
Cat feels…
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 5

Part 1: User Experience strategy
6
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 6

Optimal is the key word
Business goals User goals
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 7

Customer experience from all angles
Shops
Shop design
Customer facing
staff Shop staff
Purchase process
Ability to solve issue
Attitude and tone
Web
Sales staff Web visual treatment
Information architecture
Staff knowledge
Ease of use
Tone
Ability to deliver on
promise Products
Materials (doc, Brand promise
packaging etc.) Visual treatment
Visual treatment Packaging
Brand experience Use
Findability
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 8

Customer experience over time
Web Sales staff Shops
Materials (doc, Product(s)
packaging,
shipping etc.)
Customer facing
staff
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 9

The UX challenge
Web Sales staff Shops
How to keep the whole company focused on a
How to keep the whole company focused on a
consistent customer experience vision?
consistent customer experience vision?
Materials (doc, Product(s)
packaging,
shipping etc.)
Who owns the customer experience vision?
Who owns the customer experience vision?
Customer Facing
Staff
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 10

How to develop a UX strategy
Creating a vision and strategy to support it
11
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 11

Developing a UX strategy
Identify the organization’s business goals
Decide where to focus UX design: computer
systems, products, services and/or processes
Vision
Derive user experience goals
Research customer values, needs and context of
use
Align goals with customer research findings
Combine UX goals with UCD-derived data
Scope the strategy to be achievable
Strategy
Build a scalable strategy over time
Create a UX approach which supports the vision
and strategy
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 12

A UX strategy implements the vision
It addresses both what and how
Business goals / drivers
Product(s) Process
& Team
What and How
Who and When
Constraints
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 13

UX strategy model
What The UX vision
Why The business goal(s)
Who The cross-functional team members
When Schedule for:
- communications among team members
- presentations/updates to stakeholders
- when milestones will be reached
How Success metrics
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 14

Example
What Accessibility Consistency Usability
Why Government sales Sales demos License
Revenue renewals
Who Product team A Product team B Product team C
When Weekly team mtg Weekly team mtg TBD
Monthly senior manager Quarterly exec mtg
check-ins
How Checklist Education efforts 8-step process
Expert reviews Documentation Evaluation
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 15

Focus your UX design efforts
Don’t overextend your team. Make your efforts manageable.
Interactive Customer Facing Other
Experience Experience Experiences
Websites Tech support Packaging
Software products Customer service Instructions
Sales Store design
Training Order management
Billing
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 16

When the UX team owns the vision
Share techniques, resources and knowledge with other
groups in your organization.
Deep Customer Knowledge
Cross-Functional
User Experience
UI Design
Design
Techniques User-Centered
Design
Usability
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 17

The UX vision
Corporate goals
Corporate goals
& brand objectives
& brand objectives
Business Factors
Viability Costs
Costs
Reality checks along the way
Vision
Customer
Customer Opportunities
Opportunities
research
research Actionable Initiatives & skills
& skills
Design Applied Technology
Desirability Feasibility
Based on IDEO’s Innovation Engine.
www.ideo.com/images/media/DMI_IDEO_W02.pdf
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 18

Evolving a vision vs. strategy development
Your strategy can evolve, or it is the project
Evolving a vision Strategy project
Organic Fixed deadline
Vision
Each project provides Your research is
more ideas and feeds targeted at creating a
the vision. That vision vision and strategy
then informs the
strategy.
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 19

Developing a UX strategy
Discovery: Definition: Implementation:
What How and Who Review
Biz Factors
Company culture Translate goals into high level Planning
design goals (grids)
Business goals Development
Team set up
Scope Evaluation
Design research- proposed
UX goals Tracking
techniques
Customer needs and Revise
Customer needs
Design
expectations
Resources and tools
Opportunities
Establish clear deliverables
Constraints
Tech
Deliverable: detailed analysis Deliverable: shared
Deliverable: high level
of product space resources which embody the
findings document
vision
Strategy & Vision
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 20

What are business goals?
Business goals reflect the strategy of an
Business goals reflect the strategy of an
organization – how to accomplish the mission
organization – how to accomplish the mission
Goals should be:
Action oriented
Completed within a target time frame
Specific and well defined
Achievable, yet challenging
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 21

Example business goals
Specific goals from a previous client*
Provide customers with choice and develop
closer relationships with them
Generate domestic organic growth and
profitability
Generate efficiencies across personal insurance
lines of business
Maintain reputation and help customers and the
community better understand and reduce risk
* an insurance company in Australia
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 22

Support business goals
Better tech support
Improve Consistent user Rapidly find
productivity interface solution through
search
optimisation
reduce costs
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams

Derive goals and success metrics
Business Goals Issues Business UX Goals Success
Objectives Metrics
Reduce training • CSRs are often • Improve • Make UIs • Reduce
costs of in their first job customer consistent training time
customer service • Multiple apps satisfaction by with each from 5
reps (CSRs) with different helping novice other weeks to 2
UIs CSRs sound • Match the weeks
expert workflow • Increase
• High turnover
• Provide just-in- required by time to
time help sales proficiency
• Provide from 2
customer months to 1
centric month
information
• Provide
visible
prompts for
infrequently
used
functions
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 24

Experience matrix
Identify attributes for each area and check for alignment
Business Product Experience Best User Visual Customer Testing
Goals & Features Require- Practice1 Interface Design Service Plan and
Success Support- ments Acceptance
Metrics ing Goals Criteria
Build trust Not a lot Results offer Search Users can Easy to Users can Users find
and of ads all options results are find what scan the call and get what they
credibility easy to they are search help 10 are looking
for both Easy to Consumers under- looking for results hours per for within
potential contact gets what stand quickly day three logical
and help they expect Friendly, clicks
existing The offer is Consumers unin- Trust the
Minimize clear are timidat- outcome of
customers asking for confident in ing the service
Metric: personal their graphics request
1. majority data choices
of users
rate the
site as
trustworthy
2. Net
promoter
score
1Include competitors or companies who exemplify the goal
Derived from Donoghue: Built for Use
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 25

Experience definition
Articulate the overarching experience you want your customers
to have
Feel
Do
Think
Values
Action
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 26

Keep the UX vision simple
Skype – Internet phone to anywhere in the world for free
1. Make communicating with people around the world
easy and fun
2. Say hello or share a laugh with anyone, anywhere
Feel Easy, straightforward and fun, relaxed.
Do Use Skype for personal and business
Think This is the best way to connect to people
Values I like technology, I like saving money
Relax and talk
Action
Talk for a long time without interruption
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 27

The key: ongoing, deep research
Contextual / ethnographic studies
Share the resources & findings
Discussion forums
Web analytics Analyze existing
experience
Customer panels
Identify preferred
Personas customer experience
Stories
Align with business
Tech support data goals and drivers
Focus groups
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 28

Obstacles and opportunities
Know your organizational culture
29
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 29

The big stumbling blocks
UX teams and UX strategies fail when…
Wrong focus—no alignment to business goals
Being unaware of your corporate culture
Lack of communication
No champion or support
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 30

Know the culture of your organization
Business goals are not enough
‘Build it and they will come’ doesn’t apply here
Need to understand the culture and politics to
make UX team and vision accepted
Cultural analysis focuses on:
– Barriers
– Opportunities
– Myths
– Values
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 31

What is a “barrier”?
A barrier has the potential to prevent or
undermine the adoption of usability and UCD
Example:
Few UCD skills in organization:
– No existing systems development methodology
– Cannot apply UCD activities to development without
skilled people
– IT and Business are arguing over where the UX
team should live
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 32

What is an “opportunity”?
An opportunity offers a vehicle for pushing
through user experience initiatives
Example:
An organization has an initiative to reduce tech
support costs
– Better UI design of application can improve
usability
– Search optimisation can speed up call times
– Create better support self-service on the
organization’s website. The website is about to be
redesigned.
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 33

Identify myths and values
A myth is a belief held by your stakeholders
– UI design is subjective and cannot be measured or
engineered
– Users don’t need better interfaces, just better
training
A value is a belief that defines the culture
– Developers are rewarded for rescuing failing
projects
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 34

Case studies
Large government Medium software
agency company
Barriers Barriers
Perceived additional Two usability professionals
workload No development
Lack of UX expertise methodology
Old platforms and out of
date systems
Opportunities Opportunities
New systems development Executive champion
methodology Culture of collaboration
Increasing resources to Available funding
become more self-reliant
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 35

Explore culture of specific groups
Marketing Tech Support
Barriers Barriers
Research appears to be the Time spent learning
same technology, not customer
Threatened by UX taking service
credit for product success
Well established field
Opportunities Opportunities
Customer centered research Rewarded based on the
is current trend customer experience
Marketing can be more
effective
Tweak existing activities,
leverage existing research
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 36

Find a champion
CMO and CEO get it—the number 1 value
is customer success. Then product
managers feel the pressure to
understand the customer.
UX Manager, Software As Service company
As the company matures, more resources become available for
usability, but some prioritization is still needed. At the previous
stage, priorities were opportunistic; they must now be more
selective. Rather than chase easy wins, you must build
spectacular wins for usability to convince executives to move
the organization to the desired goal state.
Jakob Nielsen, Evangelizing Usability:
Change Your Strategy at the Halfway Point
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 37

Challenge: aligning the UX vision
Customer service
Tech support
Shops
Sales
Product design
Marketing
Branding
Legal
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 38

Part 2: Implementing the vision
39
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 39

A UX team implements the vision
Design a team that meets the needs within given constraints
Business goals / drivers
Product(s) Process
& Tea
What and How
Who and When
Constraints
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 40

Establishing your UX team
How the UX team fits into the organization
Working out the best structure
Knowing who’s involved in systems / product
development
What systems development method is used
Maintaining the team
Who owns the user experience vision?
Who owns the user experience vision?
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 41

And the survey said…
Location in the company Percentage Percentage
‘06 ‘08
IT / IS / Engineering 26 12
Product development 23 50
Dedicated infrastructure 16 2
Marketing 13 12
Dedicated business unit 10 4
R&D 6
Product management 3 1
Communications 3
Chief Technology Office 2
Consulting companies not included
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 42

One ideal world
Chief Experience
Officer (CXO)
Product Product
Marketing
Marketing Design
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 43

Models to structure your team
Five basic models:
– Consulting
– Distributed
– Review & Approve
– Educate & Administrate
– Hybrid
Project
Project Project
Project
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 44

And the survey said…
Model % ‘06 % ‘08
Consulting 34 31
Review & Approve 0 0
Educate & Administrate 0 0
Distributed 31 31
Hybrid 34 21
Split team (Research + UCD) - 5
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 45

Consulting and hybrid models
Focus Teams Other Models
Cisco / IDEO
Cross-functional team is Individual UX practitioners
assigned to high impact assigned to specific projects
projects Central design research team
Project manager Experience analysts
Generative researcher Ethnographers
UI architect Web analytics manager
Interaction designer Web technology strategist
Visual designer Design research lead
Industrial designer JavaScript Ninja
Developer
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 46

Characteristics for roles in UX teams
The anthropologist
The experimenter
The cross-pollinator
The hurdler
The collaborator
The director
The experience architect
The set designer
The caregiver
The story teller
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 47

Characteristics to seek out
Good communication skills: written and spoken
Facilitation and collaboration skills
Listening skills
Team oriented
Attention to detail
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 48

Desirable competencies and skills
Building relationships Influence and
consultation
Critical thinking and
decision making Negotiating ability
Dealing with End user research
ambiguity
Visual design
Organizational
awareness and agility UI prototyping
Focus on customers
The relative strengths required in any one person depend on the size of the team and how the roles
are carved out
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 49

Fitting into existing methods and processes
50
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 50

Several formal and informal methods
stakeholder interviews
usability testing field studies
focus groups
usability walkthroughs
affinity diagrams
expert review / heuristic
evaluation workflow diagrams
usability goals
scenarios
card sorting
paper mock-ups
collaborative design
The Hiser Element™
Cooper
UPA: Designing the User Experience
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 51

Fitting in with any development lifecycle
Business Factors
Viability
Requirements
analysis and
Vision
definition
Design Technology
Desirability Feasibility
System and
software
design
Implementation
and
unit testing
Integration
and
system testing
Analysis Design Evaluation
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 52

Today’s hot methodology: Agile
Agile Development
– Adaptive (vs predictive)
– Fast (2-6 week) iterations
– Small, co-located teams
– Experienced developers
– SCRUM – Project management method for Agile
Design Definition (Requirements and concept)
Iteration 1
Design
Iteration 2
Development Design
Iteration 3
Development Design
Development
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 53

User-centered design techniques
54
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 54

Which tools and techniques?
Largely determined by your scope
– Responsible for initiating the user interface design?
– Responsible for evaluating the user experience?
– Developing UX vision & strategy?
Highly influenced by when you get involved in the
project
– Need to fit in to any methodology
– Any involvement is better than none!
Somewhat dependent on your access to users and
stakeholders
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 55

User involvement
Steve Mulder
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 56

And the survey said…
Wireframes
Paper mockups
User interface specifications
Expert reviews
Use case scenarios
Informal usability testing
Functional prototypes
Formal usability testing
Field studies
Personas
Style guides
Stakeholder interviews
Activity scenarios
User surveys
Content audits
Focus groups
Card sorting
Design patterns
Mental model diagrams
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900
Number of occurrences (estimated)
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 57

St
ak Effectiveness of technique
eh
ol
de
1 = not effective, 5 = very effective
ri
n
Fo ter
0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
cu vie
s
U gr w s
se o
r u
F i su p s
el rv
d ey
st s
M u
e n E P e di e
ta xp rs s
l m er on
U od t re as
se e v
ca l di iew
a
Ac se gra s
tiv e sc m
ity n s
sc ario
C en s
Pa ar d ario
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams
pe so s
Effectiveness as sales tools
r m rti
Fu n
nc W ock g
Fo ti i u
rm ona refr ps
In al l p am
fo u
rm sa roto es
al bil ty
us ity pe
ab t e s
s
C ility tin
on t g
U t e es
nt tin
se
ri S t au d g
nt D
er es yle its
fa ig g
ce n ui
sp pa t d e
ec t e r
ific ns
at
io
ns
Selling to:
58
Management
Project teams

Effectiveness as sales tools
Most effective Least effective
Formal usability testing Mental model diagrams
Field studies Content audits
Functional prototypes Card sorting
UI specifications Focus groups
Design patterns
Styleguides
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 59

Measuring the customer experience
Net Promoter Score
– Percentage of customers who would recommend a company less
the percentage that would urge friends to stay away
Focus groups
– Opinions, collaborative thinking, idea generation
Customer panels
– Recruited group who work on pilot new products or designs
Online forums
– Collect feedback and ideas from customers
Usability testing
– Understand how users interact with your products/services
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 60

Measure against goals and success metrics
Guiding principles
– Helps answer the question: why are we doing this project?
– Keep it at a granular enough level by asking “why” until you agree upon
a specific, measurable, achievable goal
– Can measure both business success & technical success - but technical
success should be tied to a business benefit
– Aim for 2-5 metrics for every project, written in bullet point form
– When possible, tie to a business goal or product goal
Process for establishing metrics
– Define as part of initial project justification, before the project starts.
– Establish whether the metric adds anything to the project, and assess
whether it is critical enough to do so
– Assign ownership (eg. Business, Division, IT or Usability)
– Agree upon when to measure the success metric: during design, at roll-
out, ongoing
Ongoing measurement is the key…
Ongoing measurement is the key…
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 61

Final questions and thanks
62
UX Marathon 2009: UX Vision, Strategy & Teams 62