The Gentle Art of             Giving a PaperNOT TO BE CONFUSED WITH...                                  David L. Hildebran...
Tools and tips for giving effective talks:✴Class presentations✴Conference talks✴Professional talks             The Audience
Personal History  My public speaking past:• Docent at Washington arts organization• Occasional presentations in graduate s...
Later...• Academic conferences, national and    international                                            A•   Department c...
Memorial lectures:                             Howell Memorial                                Lecture                     ...
Hints and Tips:Lighting things Up
&Avoiding Disaster
Give a paper when youhave something to sayQ. When should one give a conference paper?A. When research and thinking are dev...
Context: the audience Who is your audience? Know the situation:• Audience background knowledge• Purpose of conference (aca...
MotivatingAudience isImportant: Substance   Style   Timing
Substance of Talk  A coherent work with a clear purpose  Make your paper a complete work:• a beginning, middle, and end.• ...
Transitions Matter: Don’tleave your audience behind  Ensure audience  can stay with the  thread• “Sheepdog  Sentences” can...
Sheepdog SentencesSheepdog sentences sum up before movingon: “So, my point has been X. Now let’s seehow Y follows/adds to ...
Style  A talk must be understood AURALLY:  your audience is listening not reading.• Monotone voices cause suicidal thought...
For listeners: Less is More  Listeners cannot retain large numbers of details  Less is More:• Cut material ruthlessly• Bui...
T it or Write it?       alkIf you can TALK a paper (using justbullet points but creating a coherentnarrative): great.Know ...
If you need to write/read ...  KISS: = Keep It Simple Stupid!• Use direct language, shorter  sentences• Insert directions ...
REPEAT KEY INSIGHTS:    Forecast --Tell -- Remind• Forecast what  you’re going to tell  them• Tell them• Remind (summarize...
Put Roadsignsin yourdraft
Using signs helps youmanage your performance
Talking Pretty•   Stand up to speak, do not sit.•   Move while talking if you can.•     Speak loud, speak clear.
Time & TimingRespect the assigned time limit.
Time yourself carefully when you practice.Get a good estimate for your reading speedMy self testing (which I use as a basi...
Concluding the TalkSignal that you’re DONE:“THANK YOU FOR LISTENING”Invite and Encourage discussion“I’M REALLY INTERESTED ...
Couple Last HintsPractice in front of others--then reviseBe enthusiastic and enjoy thelimelightDiscussion needs to be mana...
Handling Discussion1. Let the questioners finish speaking2. Answer questions directly and succinctly.
Discussion...3. Clarity is crucially important to theaudience.Re-stating each question:(a) makes sure everyone heard it(b)...
Discussion...  4. Always take the high road. Defend your  argument without being overly defensive• Being kind is always pa...
Thanks for listening
Sources1) “Giving a Conference Talk,” Mike Dahlin Universityof Texas at Austinwww.cs.utexas.edu/~dahlin/professional/goodT...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

The gentle art of giving a paper mhmss 2012

569
-1

Published on

A brief talk meant to help people giving academic papers present more effectively. Also applicable, I think, to class and business presenters.

Published in: Education, Technology
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
569
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
2
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • \n
  • 1. Lay out some hints and tips; 2. Spend most of our time in discussion; 3. Interrupt me as we go and we can also talk at end\n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • You are on display at a conference – benefits if you impress but consequences if you flop. \nAudience may include people deciding on grants, publications, hiring. They will form an impression.\nYour audience should leave being able to summarize the gist of your paper—at least it’s motivating topic\n\n
  • Knowing situation (audience, purpose) allows you gauge the best level of content and complexity to include\nYou want to provoke discussion so ask the right level questions!\n
  • \n
  • Asides: (a) what you’ve done elsewhere; (b) what you would do with more time; (c) how much more you know; \n Don’t skip pages or talk about last minute changes: e.g., “In this part of the paper I talk about topic X, but I'll have to skip it now because of time” \n DON’T EDIT: Confuses the audience by misdirecting their attention.\nUse of quotations. The audience wants to hear your ideas\n\n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • \n
  • The gentle art of giving a paper mhmss 2012

    1. 1. The Gentle Art of Giving a PaperNOT TO BE CONFUSED WITH... David L. Hildebrand Associate Professor Philosophy Department University of Colorado Denver
    2. 2. Tools and tips for giving effective talks:✴Class presentations✴Conference talks✴Professional talks The Audience
    3. 3. Personal History My public speaking past:• Docent at Washington arts organization• Occasional presentations in graduate seminars• First conference paper: 1995 (Driscoll Hotel, Austin, TX.5th year of graduate school)
    4. 4. Later...• Academic conferences, national and international A• Department colloquia At Helsinki, Finland, 2010 At Sorbonne, Paris, 2011 Reykjavik, Iceland, 2009
    5. 5. Memorial lectures: Howell Memorial Lecture Rhode Island College 2010Public talks: “Mixed Taste” lecture at Lab at Belmar, 2
    6. 6. Hints and Tips:Lighting things Up
    7. 7. &Avoiding Disaster
    8. 8. Give a paper when youhave something to sayQ. When should one give a conference paper?A. When research and thinking are developedenough for a sustained and coherentpresentation and fruitful discussion. It usually takes more than three weeks to prepare a good impromptu speech. – Mark Twain
    9. 9. Context: the audience Who is your audience? Know the situation:• Audience background knowledge• Purpose of conference (academic, public forum, invasion force, etc.)
    10. 10. MotivatingAudience isImportant: Substance Style Timing
    11. 11. Substance of Talk A coherent work with a clear purpose Make your paper a complete work:• a beginning, middle, and end.• Don’t let little asides get in the way• Don’t edit as you deliver• Minimize use of “Quotations” Create a clear narrative & Don’t step on it
    12. 12. Transitions Matter: Don’tleave your audience behind Ensure audience can stay with the thread• “Sheepdog Sentences” can keep the group
    13. 13. Sheepdog SentencesSheepdog sentences sum up before movingon: “So, my point has been X. Now let’s seehow Y follows/adds to X, etc.”A handout can help do these chores.
    14. 14. Style A talk must be understood AURALLY: your audience is listening not reading.• Monotone voices cause suicidal thoughts• Vary the volume and rhythm of your voice.• speak confidently but not quickly. The right word may be effective, but no word was ever as effective as a rightly timed pause — Mark Twain
    15. 15. For listeners: Less is More Listeners cannot retain large numbers of details Less is More:• Cut material ruthlessly• Build around one or two central concepts• Allow time for a conclusion
    16. 16. T it or Write it? alkIf you can TALK a paper (using justbullet points but creating a coherentnarrative): great.Know that this requires you to haveyour material down cold.
    17. 17. If you need to write/read ... KISS: = Keep It Simple Stupid!• Use direct language, shorter sentences• Insert directions to yourself—• “pause here”• “emphasize this point”• “make eye contact”
    18. 18. REPEAT KEY INSIGHTS: Forecast --Tell -- Remind• Forecast what you’re going to tell them• Tell them• Remind (summarize) what you’ve said
    19. 19. Put Roadsignsin yourdraft
    20. 20. Using signs helps youmanage your performance
    21. 21. Talking Pretty• Stand up to speak, do not sit.• Move while talking if you can.• Speak loud, speak clear.
    22. 22. Time & TimingRespect the assigned time limit.
    23. 23. Time yourself carefully when you practice.Get a good estimate for your reading speedMy self testing (which I use as a basis now):I read 142 words in a minute.That’s 1420 words in 10 minutesThat’s 2840 words in 20 minutes, etc.
    24. 24. Concluding the TalkSignal that you’re DONE:“THANK YOU FOR LISTENING”Invite and Encourage discussion“I’M REALLY INTERESTED TO HEAR YOURTHOUGHTS”
    25. 25. Couple Last HintsPractice in front of others--then reviseBe enthusiastic and enjoy thelimelightDiscussion needs to be managed
    26. 26. Handling Discussion1. Let the questioners finish speaking2. Answer questions directly and succinctly.
    27. 27. Discussion...3. Clarity is crucially important to theaudience.Re-stating each question:(a) makes sure everyone heard it(b) can change the tone or improve clarity,(c) give you a little extra time to thinkabout it
    28. 28. Discussion... 4. Always take the high road. Defend your argument without being overly defensive• Being kind is always paramount.• Lose your composure and that is all people will remember 5. Don’t read too much into the question. Answer it directly & let deeper things emerge.
    29. 29. Thanks for listening
    30. 30. Sources1) “Giving a Conference Talk,” Mike Dahlin Universityof Texas at Austinwww.cs.utexas.edu/~dahlin/professional/goodTalk.pdf2) “The Captive Audience; or Liberating Thoughtson Conference Papers,” Edward H. Friedman, ADFLBulletin, Vol. 27, No. 3, Spring 19963) “How to give an effective conference paper: Fivetips to impress your audience and get the most outof your presentation,” by Francine McKenziehttp://www.universityaffairs.ca/how-to-give-an-effective-conference-paper.aspx
    1. A particular slide catching your eye?

      Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

    ×