Treating mastitis: Balancing cure, money,
welfare and resistance
Henk Hogeveen
With input from Wilma Steeneveld and Claudi...
My paper gives latest results from literature
But ...session on analytics:
The modern dairy farm has at its fingertips an ...
My presentation

 Balancing treatments
 Analytics of lactational treatment
 Example of published results
 Analytics of...
Important in treatment decisions

 Cure
 Much knowledge
available

 Keywords “Cure rate”
and “mastitis”

 11 scientifi...
There is more than cure rates: Welfare

 Clinical mastitis gives pain (e.g., Kemp et al. 2008 VetRec)
 Behaviour is also...
Antibiotic resistance

 Heavily in discussion
 Resistance of mastitis pathogens
● Self-interest
● No increase seen

(Hog...
Economics

 A farm is a business
 Self interest
 Costs of antibiotics vs benefits of higher cure rates or
better preven...
Difficult task of herd manager

 There is:
● Cure rate (welfare)
● Money
● Antibiotic resistance

 Should be balanced
Not much knowledge on balancing

 11 scientific papers in
2013

 One with economics
(related to
transmission);

Down et ...
My presentation

 Balancing treatments
 Analytics of lactational treatment
 Example of published results
 Analytics of...
Lactational treatment

 Much knowledge available on cure, e.g., reviews
● Barkema et al. 2006 JDairySci
● Roberson, 2012 ...
Straightforward spreadsheet

Two scenarios
Straightforward spreadsheet

Cure rates
(input)
Straightforward spreadsheet

Calculation of
proportion of
cured cows
Straightforward spreadsheet
What if
animals do
not cure?

We have not
really thought
that out very
well
Farm specific
Role...
Let’s add economics
Proportion of
proportion
Let’s add economics
But we are
missing input
Let’s add economics
That depends
on cure and
lactation
stage
Let’s add economics
Formula for
the average
nr of days

We are
missing some
price levels
Let’s add economics

Let’s make
final
calculations
Let’s add economics
And finally, what are the costs?
What’s the point

 Specific situation -> no papers available
 Creation of a tool is not too difficult
 Input needed
● P...
My presentation

 Balancing treatments
 Analytics of lactational treatment
 Example of published results
 Analytics of...
Treatment of clinical mastitis
 Causal pathogen

● Streptococci (40%), S. aureus (30%), E. coli
(30%)

 Parity
 Day in ...
Defined treatments
 3-day intramammary antibiotic treatment (IMM3)
 5-day intramammary antibiotic treatment (IMM5)
 3-d...
Simulating follow-up of treatment
Treatment
CM1

No bact. cure,
clin. cure

Bact. + clin.
cure

End
lactation

No bact. cu...
Cow-specific cure
 Probability of bacteriological cure (%) defined
● for heifers, SCC<200, <60 DIM, no CM before, not
sys...
Average costs ($US)
IMM3

IMM5

IMM3_S

IMM5_S

Culling

Overall

245

270

275

295

766

Daily milk
production (kg)
<20
...
Least cost frontiers
High cure cow
E. coli cow
Average cow
S. aureus cow
Low cure cow

100

IMM3
IMM5
IMM3_S
IMM3_N_S
IMM5...
My presentation

 Balancing treatments
 Analytics of lactational treatment
 Example of published results
 Analytics of...
The ongoing debate on dry-cow therapy

 Dry-cow therapy has two uses
● Curative
● Preventive

 “We” do not want preventi...
Probabilities
depend on
risk group

Very basic
input

Costs with
and without
DCT
Probabilities from: Scherpenzeel et al., ...
Average costs drying-off per cow

Costs per cow
We’re also interested in amount of AB

Daily doses

Totals
Let’s optimize (linear programming)
Minimize total
costs of mastitis

By the numbers
of treated cows

Under constraints:
- Nr of cows equal
- Less AB than thr...
The constraint
What’s the point

 Literature never fits the individual farmer’s situation
 Probabilities can be based on farmers on dat...
My presentation

 Balancing treatments
 Analytics of lactational treatment
 Example of published results
 Analytics of...
Automatic milking

 On-line mastitis monitoring (Electrical conductivity,
colour, SCC)

 Great possibilities for therapy...
Study on farmer’s handing of alerts

 7 farmers, student checked all alerts
● 60 % of alerts false positive
● 3.5 % of al...
Options

1. Maintain the “old” paradigm of treating clinical mastitis
cases hold in automatic milking

….. and educate our...
My presentation

 Balancing treatments
 Analytics of lactational treatment
 Example of published results
 Analytics of...
I did not present all knowledge

 There is more knowledge out there
 Mostly economics
 Welfare ≈ cure rate
 On-farm cu...
On-farm analyses

 Use straightforward calculation tools
 Use farm-specific input
● Price levels
● Incidences
● Cure rat...
Thank you for your attention

@henkhogeveen
animal-health-management.blogspot.com

On-line courses on
Veterinary Economics...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Balancing antibiotic treatment with regard to mastitis

946

Published on

These are the sildes of a presentation I gave at the NMC Annual Meeting, held in Fort Worth Texas on January 27, 2014. I was asked to tell something on the economics of mastitis treatment. I broadened that to balancing. Economics is about optimization, but nowadays in antibiotic treatment in animals factors such as animal welfare and a reduction in the use of antibiotics play also a role. The farmer and the veterinary advisor have to balance this. The presentation aims at setting up spreadsheet to support decision making

Published in: Business, Technology
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
946
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
3
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
30
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "Balancing antibiotic treatment with regard to mastitis"

  1. 1. Treating mastitis: Balancing cure, money, welfare and resistance Henk Hogeveen With input from Wilma Steeneveld and Claudia Kamphuis
  2. 2. My paper gives latest results from literature But ...session on analytics: The modern dairy farm has at its fingertips an endless array of data. When managed properly, these data can be used to create a competitive advantage. This session will explore the potential of analytical approaches to managing mastitis through the use of on-farm records, decision support for mastitis treatment, and statistical processing of information. My presentation will have an emphasis on analytics, not on results
  3. 3. My presentation  Balancing treatments  Analytics of lactational treatment  Example of published results  Analytics of dry-cow therapy (optimization)  New possibilities with automatic milking  Concluding remarks
  4. 4. Important in treatment decisions  Cure  Much knowledge available  Keywords “Cure rate” and “mastitis”  11 scientific papers in 2013
  5. 5. There is more than cure rates: Welfare  Clinical mastitis gives pain (e.g., Kemp et al. 2008 VetRec)  Behaviour is also affected (Medrano-Galarza et al., 2012 JDairySci)  So: Better cure is better welfare
  6. 6. Antibiotic resistance  Heavily in discussion  Resistance of mastitis pathogens ● Self-interest ● No increase seen (Hogan, IDF-factsheet)  Antibiotic resistance in humans ● Externality ● Dairy cattle has very minor contribution ● In the Netherlands (self) regulations (Oliver et al., 2011)
  7. 7. Economics  A farm is a business  Self interest  Costs of antibiotics vs benefits of higher cure rates or better prevention
  8. 8. Difficult task of herd manager  There is: ● Cure rate (welfare) ● Money ● Antibiotic resistance  Should be balanced
  9. 9. Not much knowledge on balancing  11 scientific papers in 2013  One with economics (related to transmission); Down et al., JDairySci
  10. 10. My presentation  Balancing treatments  Analytics of lactational treatment  Example of published results  Analytics of dry-cow therapy (optimization)  New possibilities with automatic milking  Concluding remarks
  11. 11. Lactational treatment  Much knowledge available on cure, e.g., reviews ● Barkema et al. 2006 JDairySci ● Roberson, 2012 VetClinFoodAnim ● Roy and Keefe, 2012 VetClinFoodAnim ● Suojala et al. 2013 JVetPharmTherap  Some papers on economics ● Steeneveld et al., 2011 JDairySci ● Halasa et al., 2012 JDairySci ● Down et al., 2013 JDairySci  These are averages  Make your own calculations
  12. 12. Straightforward spreadsheet Two scenarios
  13. 13. Straightforward spreadsheet Cure rates (input)
  14. 14. Straightforward spreadsheet Calculation of proportion of cured cows
  15. 15. Straightforward spreadsheet What if animals do not cure? We have not really thought that out very well Farm specific Role of advisor
  16. 16. Let’s add economics Proportion of proportion
  17. 17. Let’s add economics But we are missing input
  18. 18. Let’s add economics That depends on cure and lactation stage
  19. 19. Let’s add economics Formula for the average nr of days We are missing some price levels
  20. 20. Let’s add economics Let’s make final calculations
  21. 21. Let’s add economics
  22. 22. And finally, what are the costs?
  23. 23. What’s the point  Specific situation -> no papers available  Creation of a tool is not too difficult  Input needed ● Price levels – farmers know these ● Specific situation of the cow – farmers know these ● Cure rates – this is a problem  Cure rates might be available from farm records ● Large farms ● Available data  Evaluate previous assumptions
  24. 24. My presentation  Balancing treatments  Analytics of lactational treatment  Example of published results  Analytics of dry-cow therapy (optimization)  New possibilities with automatic milking  Concluding remarks
  25. 25. Treatment of clinical mastitis  Causal pathogen ● Streptococci (40%), S. aureus (30%), E. coli (30%)  Parity  Day in milk  Calving interval  Most recent SCC-value  Repeated CM case yes/no  Systematically ill yes/no  305-day milk production All stochastic ● Wood curve to determine daily milk production at moment CM and remaining milk production during lactation Steeneveld et al., 2011, JDairySci
  26. 26. Defined treatments  3-day intramammary antibiotic treatment (IMM3)  5-day intramammary antibiotic treatment (IMM5)  3-day intramammary antibiotic treatment + systemic antibiotic treatment (IMM3_S)  5-day intramammary antibiotic treatment + systemic antibiotic treatment (IMM5_S)  Immediately culling
  27. 27. Simulating follow-up of treatment Treatment CM1 No bact. cure, clin. cure Bact. + clin. cure End lactation No bact. cure, no clin. cure Culling No bact. cure, clin. cure Culling End lactation Treatment CM2 Extended treatment Bact. + clin. cure End lactation Culling No bact. cure, no clin. cure Dying End lactation etc. Dry-off quarter Culling
  28. 28. Cow-specific cure  Probability of bacteriological cure (%) defined ● for heifers, SCC<200, <60 DIM, no CM before, not systematically ill IMM3 Streptococci S. aureus E. coli IMM5 IMM3_S IMM5_S 70 40 80 80 60 85 80 60 85 90 70 95 Defined effects of cow factors • Older cow: 10% • SCC 200-500: 10% • SCC >500: 20% • >60 DIM: • Repeated case: • Systematically ill: 10% 20% 20%
  29. 29. Average costs ($US) IMM3 IMM5 IMM3_S IMM5_S Culling Overall 245 270 275 295 766 Daily milk production (kg) <20 20-25 25-30 30-35 35-40 >40 158 189 200 216 253 307 174 206 223 238 279 326 192 216 230 244 284 332 207 230 255 266 301 351 478 578 569 577 732 1,026 Causal pathogen Streptococci S. aureus E. coli 216 283 253 238 296 284 238 296 284 266 318 310 758 749 789 Original calculations in €; € 1 = $US 1.37
  30. 30. Least cost frontiers High cure cow E. coli cow Average cow S. aureus cow Low cure cow 100 IMM3 IMM5 IMM3_S IMM3_N_S IMM5_S 90 Probability of cure (%) 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 130 150 170 190 210 Total costs (€) 230 250 270 290
  31. 31. My presentation  Balancing treatments  Analytics of lactational treatment  Example of published results  Analytics of dry-cow therapy (optimization)  New possibilities with automatic milking  Concluding remarks
  32. 32. The ongoing debate on dry-cow therapy  Dry-cow therapy has two uses ● Curative ● Preventive  “We” do not want preventive use of antibiotics (anymore)  Which cows to dry-off with antibiotics?  Let’s create another spreadsheet ● Basically the same as the previous one
  33. 33. Probabilities depend on risk group Very basic input Costs with and without DCT Probabilities from: Scherpenzeel et al., 2014, in preparation
  34. 34. Average costs drying-off per cow Costs per cow
  35. 35. We’re also interested in amount of AB Daily doses Totals
  36. 36. Let’s optimize (linear programming)
  37. 37. Minimize total costs of mastitis By the numbers of treated cows Under constraints: - Nr of cows equal - Less AB than threshold
  38. 38. The constraint
  39. 39. What’s the point  Literature never fits the individual farmer’s situation  Probabilities can be based on farmers on data  Quite straightforward economic modelling  Evaluate previous assumptions
  40. 40. My presentation  Balancing treatments  Analytics of lactational treatment  Example of published results  Analytics of dry-cow therapy (optimization)  New possibilities with automatic milking  Concluding remarks
  41. 41. Automatic milking  On-line mastitis monitoring (Electrical conductivity, colour, SCC)  Great possibilities for therapy evaluation  But ….. Sensitivity & specificity of mastitis detection  Farmer’s confirmation is needed ● Time consuming ● Mostly negative ● Not the nicest of work  3.5 % of alerts are checked
  42. 42. Study on farmer’s handing of alerts  7 farmers, student checked all alerts ● 60 % of alerts false positive ● 3.5 % of alerts is checked by farmers ● checked alerts are often clinical cases ● 74 % of clinical cases is missed  How bad is this?
  43. 43. Options 1. Maintain the “old” paradigm of treating clinical mastitis cases hold in automatic milking ….. and educate our farmers better to check ….. or have better sensors (less false positives) 2. Use the daily sensor measurements differently -> detect acute severe mastitis, for mild mastitis look at chronicity, use on-farm culturing before treatment  Lot’s of questions, no answers (yet)
  44. 44. My presentation  Balancing treatments  Analytics of lactational treatment  Example of published results  Analytics of dry-cow therapy (optimization)  New possibilities with automatic milking  Concluding remarks
  45. 45. I did not present all knowledge  There is more knowledge out there  Mostly economics  Welfare ≈ cure rate  On-farm culture systems ● Lago et al., 2011, JDairySci ● Cameron et al., 2013, PrevVetMed ● Pinzón-Sánchez et al., 2011 JDairySci (Economics)  Use of antibiotics only through dry cow therapy
  46. 46. On-farm analyses  Use straightforward calculation tools  Use farm-specific input ● Price levels ● Incidences ● Cure rates  Use those farm data!!!  Operational use should be automated  There is a future for tailor-made treatment decisions  PS Example models and ppt are available
  47. 47. Thank you for your attention @henkhogeveen animal-health-management.blogspot.com On-line courses on Veterinary Economics on: www.elevatehealth.eu
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×