Breakout 3: Author identity – Creating a new kind of reputation online Duncan Hull, Geoffrey Bilder, Michael Habib, Reynold Guida

Validating Identity Claims and Content Science Online London – August 22, 2009 Michael C. Habib, MSLS Product Manager, Collaboration Tools [email_address]

Identity Matrix About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me Matrix from ClaimID founders: http://claimid.com/

By Me, About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Facebook Home Page

By Me, Not About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Publications References Facebook Blog Home Page

Not By Me, About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Publications Citations References Facebook Blog Trackback Home Page

Not By Me, Not About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Home Page Publications Citations References Facebook Blog
Disambiguation
Same Name
Same Ideas
Trackback

Distributed Institutional - Authority Files
Pros
Human-edited
Organizational responsibility
Tight standards
Validated by institution
Cons
Labor intensive, slow
Which organization?
Less flexible (Blogs, Comments…)
Impersonal
Opportunities
Librarians - Institutional Repositories
Publishers - Article Submission (EES)
Funding Agencies - NIH, EU, etc..
LC Authority Files

Distributed Author - ClaimID
Pros
Human-edited
Individual responsibility
Versatile
Personal
Cons
Labor intensive, limited participation
Loose standards, coverage
Light validation
Opportunities
OpenID
Professional Networks
(LinkedIn, Xing, etc.)

Aggregated Machine – Scopus Author ID
Pros
Automated
Scales – Complete
Validated by publications
99% precision, 95% recall
Cons
Impersonal
Opportunities
Scopus Author ID
http://www.scopus.com/search/form/authorFreeLookup.url

Aggregated Machine – Scopus Author ID
Pros
Automated
Scales – Complete
Validated by publications
Cons
Impersonal
Opportunities
Scopus Author ID
http://www.scopus.com/search/form/authorFreeLookup.url + Distributed Author Control

Machine & Author – 2collab

Shared Responsibility
Claim Validation
Librarians
Institutional Repositories
Publishers
Article Submission (EES)
Funding Agencies
NIH, EU, etc.
A&I Databases
Scopus Author ID
User-Generated Content
OpenID
Professional Networks
(LinkedIn, Xing, etc.)
Content/Expertise Validation
Librarians
Institutional Affiliation
Publishers
Peer-Review
Funding Agencies
Awards
A&I Databases
Citations
User-Generated Content
Cross-Reference: A&I, Full-Text, Citation Count, etc.
Peer-comments, etc

Breakout 3: Author identity – Creating a new kind of reputation online Duncan Hull, Geoffrey Bilder, Michael Habib, Reynold Guida

by Michael Habib on Aug 24, 2009

Accessibility

Categories

Tags

Upload Details

Usage Rights

2 Embeds 91

Statistics

Breakout 3: Author identity – Creating a new kind of reputation online Duncan Hull, Geoffrey Bilder, Michael Habib, Reynold Guida — Presentation Transcript

http://mchabib.com	89
http://www.slideshare.net	2