Validating Identity Claims and Content Science Online London – August 22, 2009 Michael C. Habib, MSLS Product Manager, Collaboration Tools [email_address]

Identity Matrix About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me Matrix from ClaimID founders: http://claimid.com/

By Me, About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Facebook Home Page

By Me, Not About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Publications References Facebook Blog Home Page

Not By Me, About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Publications Citations References Facebook Blog Trackback Home Page

Not By Me, Not About Me About Me Not About Me By Me Not By Me LinkedIn Home Page Publications Citations References Facebook Blog Disambiguation Same Name Same Ideas Trackback

Disambiguation

Same Name

Same Ideas

Distributed Institutional - Authority Files Pros Human-edited Organizational responsibility Tight standards Validated by institution Cons Labor intensive, slow Which organization? Less flexible (Blogs, Comments…) Impersonal Opportunities Librarians - Institutional Repositories Publishers - Article Submission (EES) Funding Agencies - NIH, EU, etc.. LC Authority Files

Pros

Human-edited

Organizational responsibility

Tight standards

Validated by institution

Cons

Labor intensive, slow

Which organization?

Less flexible (Blogs, Comments…)

Impersonal

Opportunities

Librarians - Institutional Repositories

Publishers - Article Submission (EES)

Funding Agencies - NIH, EU, etc..

LC Authority Files

Distributed Author - ClaimID Pros Human-edited Individual responsibility Versatile Personal Cons Labor intensive, limited participation Loose standards, coverage Light validation Opportunities OpenID Professional Networks (LinkedIn, Xing, etc.)

Pros

Human-edited

Individual responsibility

Versatile

Personal

Cons

Labor intensive, limited participation

Loose standards, coverage

Light validation

Opportunities

OpenID

Professional Networks

(LinkedIn, Xing, etc.)

Aggregated Machine – Scopus Author ID Pros Automated Scales – Complete Validated by publications 99% precision, 95% recall Cons Impersonal 99% precision, 95% recall Opportunities Scopus Author ID http://www.scopus.com/search/form/authorFreeLookup.url

Pros

Automated

Scales – Complete

Validated by publications

99% precision, 95% recall

Cons

Impersonal

99% precision, 95% recall

Opportunities

Scopus Author ID

Aggregated Machine – Scopus Author ID Pros Automated Scales – Complete Validated by publications 99% precision, 95% recall Cons Impersonal 99% precision, 95% recall Opportunities Scopus Author ID http://www.scopus.com/search/form/authorFreeLookup.url + Distributed Author Control

Pros

Automated

Scales – Complete

Validated by publications

99% precision, 95% recall

Cons

Impersonal

99% precision, 95% recall

Opportunities

Scopus Author ID

Machine & Author – 2collab

Shared Responsibility Claim Validation Librarians Institutional Repositories Publishers Article Submission (EES) Funding Agencies NIH, EU, etc. A&I Databases Scopus Author ID User-Generated Content OpenID Professional Networks (LinkedIn, Xing, etc.) Content/Expertise Validation Librarians Institutional Affiliation Publishers Peer-Review Funding Agencies Awards A&I Databases Citations User-Generated Content Cross-Reference: A&I, Full-Text, Citation Count, etc. Peer-comments, etc

Claim Validation

Librarians

Institutional Repositories

Publishers

Article Submission (EES)

Funding Agencies

NIH, EU, etc.

A&I Databases

Scopus Author ID

User-Generated Content

OpenID

Professional Networks

(LinkedIn, Xing, etc.)

Content/Expertise Validation

Librarians

Institutional Affiliation

Publishers

Peer-Review

Funding Agencies

Awards

A&I Databases

Citations

User-Generated Content

Cross-Reference: A&I, Full-Text, Citation Count, etc.

Peer-comments, etc