Public-Private Partnershipsfor Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelJ. M. LUZAssociate Dean, Center for Development Manage...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    Outline           Key Questions           Contex...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    Key Questions           In the face of limited pu...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    Thesis           Private-Public Partnerships prov...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    The Context: Local Government           Range fro...
Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding  Some Issues in Local Governance  ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    A Response: Private-Public Partnerships       Par...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    Private-Public Partnerships: Framework      (Organ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level  Organizing Concepts                                 ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Organizing Concepts                                  ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelOrganizing Concepts                                  S...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelOrganizing Concepts                                  S...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    Modalities of Participation  To go beyond     mer...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    1.   Increase Revenues for Public Education       ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    1.   Increase Revenues for Public Education       ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    2.   Providing in-kind services to augment        ...
Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding    2.   Providing in-kind services...
Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding    2.   Providing in-kind services...
Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding    2.   Providing in-kind services...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    3.   Service contracting            Government As...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    3.   Service contracting            Proposals:   ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level    4.   Private spending for education (private      ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level   Example: Cost effectiveness of ESC (Education      ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level  If possible for Education, why not for      other se...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level   The Future: Opportunities       1.   Water         ...
Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level   The Future: Opportunities       The KEY: Proper Reg...
Public-Private Partnershipsfor Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelJ. M. LUZAssociate Dean, Center for Development Manage...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Mike luz on public private partnerships for good governance

914 views
805 views

Published on

Published in: Technology, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
914
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Mike luz on public private partnerships for good governance

  1. 1. Public-Private Partnershipsfor Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelJ. M. LUZAssociate Dean, Center for Development Management,Asian Institute of ManagementPanibagong Paraan for Good Government5 November 2009
  2. 2. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Outline  Key Questions  Context  Framework of Analysis  Modalities of Participation  Issues  The Future: Opportunities for Local Governments
  3. 3. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Key Questions  In the face of limited public resources, how to finance and provide for the growing demand (at the LGU level) for more infrastructure, services?  What options exist that could deliver infrastructure or services in a cost-effective manner?  How to finance and support the needed investment?
  4. 4. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Thesis  Private-Public Partnerships provide a variety of options  Options range from:  Increasing revenues from the private sector for needed investment  Providing in-kind services that augments Local Government  Service contracting  Private spending for identified infrastructure or service
  5. 5. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level The Context: Local Government  Range from First to Sixth Class  LGUs largely dependent on IRA as source of revenues  The lower the income class, the more dependent on IRA  Increasing share of LGU taxes…but never enough to cover demand for more services
  6. 6. Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding Some Issues in Local Governance  Devolution  service delivery  Health  Social welfare  Agriculture  Environment  More demand for local cost-sharing  Education (Local School Board, Special Education Fund)  Disasters  More competition for National Government resources  For share of projects  For timely release of IRA
  7. 7. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level A Response: Private-Public Partnerships  Partnerships are born out of a convergence of interests  To address growing needs or demands of constituent publics  Hypothesis: The Whole (e.g. Partnerships) > sum of the parts (e.g. Sectors’ contribution)  Traditional responses inadequate viz heightened demand or new need  Government not in a position to respond adequately  Markets not able to address needs
  8. 8. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Private-Public Partnerships: Framework (Organizing Concepts)  The ability of existing institutions (i.e. LGU) to address demand or need Versus  Degree of need or demand  What types of partnerships are needed?
  9. 9. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Organizing Concepts SUPPLY-SIDE Ability of institutions to deliver STRONG LIMITED DEMAND-SIDE I. Partnership as an II. Partnership Arrangement as a System Heightened Response Effective Demand III. Partnership to strengthen an IV. Partnership existing as a new New or Emerging institution Institution Need articulated Capacity Issues Capability Issues Can institution x deliver enough? Is Institution x able to deliver at all?
  10. 10. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Organizing Concepts SUPPLY-SIDE Ability of institutions to deliver STRONG LIMITED DEMAND-SIDE II. I. Partnership as Partnership an Arrangement Heightened as a System Effective Demand Response III. Partnership to strengthen an IV. Partnership existing as a new New or Emerging institution Institution Need articulated Capacity Issues Capability Issues Can institution x deliver enough? Is Institution x able to deliver at all?
  11. 11. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelOrganizing Concepts SUPPLY-SIDE Ability of institutions to deliver STRONG LIMITED DEMAND-SIDE I. Partnership as II. Partnership New or Heightened an Arrangement as a System Effective Demand Response III. Partnership to strengthen IV. Partnership an existing as a new New or Emerging Institution Need articulated institution Capacity Issues Capability Issues Can institution x deliver enough? Is Institution x able to deliver at all?
  12. 12. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelOrganizing Concepts SUPPLY-SIDE Ability of institutions to deliver STRONG LIMITED DEMAND-SIDE I. Partnership as II. Partnership New or Heightened an Arrangement as a System Effective Demand Response III. Partnership IV. to strengthen an existing Partnership New or Emerging institution as a new Need articulated Institution Capacity Issues Capability Issues Can institution x deliver enough? Is Institution x able to deliver at all?
  13. 13. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Modalities of Participation  To go beyond mere Government spending (Example: Basic Education)  Increasing revenues for public education (from Non- Government participation)  Providing in-kind services that augments Government spending in education  Service contracting  Increased private spending for education (private education)
  14. 14. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level 1. Increase Revenues for Public Education  Objective: Raise revenues for public education (beyond the national budget)  From Private Sector: Corporate philanthropy through “Adopt-a-School” mechanism  Tax incentives provided by law  From Local Governments: Special Education Fund  1% of real estate taxes collected by LGUs  Through Local School Boards (chaired by the Governor, Mayor)
  15. 15. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level 1. Increase Revenues for Public Education  Bold Ideas: Raise revenues for public education through market mechanisms  Education bond issue  Securitization of school building construction  Securitization of the voucher system
  16. 16. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level 2. Providing in-kind services to augment Government spending in education  Brigada Eskwela  National Schools Maintenance Week (May)  Community voluntarism  minor repair and maintenance of schools (preparatory to school opening)  2003 [2006]  12,533 public schools involved [29,215 schools)  832,000+ volunteer man-days [4.0 million m/days]  Total value of repairs = Estimated P392 Million [P2.0 Billion]
  17. 17. Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding 2. Providing in-kind services to augment Government spending in education  Textbook Count  National Textbook Delivery Program (June-November)  NGO involvement in monitoring deliveries of textbooks  In 2003  30,000+ deliveries (schools and district offices)  37 million textbooks
  18. 18. Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding 2. Providing in-kind services to augment Government spending in education  Textbook Count: Summary of Findings on Deficient Deliveries by Elementary Schools District (Quantity) Zone # Districts # with Delivery % Remarks Errors 3 552 78 14.13 Region VIII (74) 4 538 30 5.58 Region XII (10) 1 500 8 1.60 2 491 15 3.05 NCR (12); Pasig- San Juan (4/4) TOTAL 2,081 125 6.00
  19. 19. Public-Private Partnership in Basic Education Service Delivery:Provisioning and Funding 2. Providing in-kind services to augment Government spending in education  PTCA Involvement  Parent-Teacher-Community Associations  Local stakeholders  School feeding programs  Pay for school security, janitorial, utilities  “Adopt-a-School” Corporate Involvement  Corporate tie-ups for facilities improvement  Manila Electric Company  audit of electricals in schools  Manila Water Company  audit of school water systems
  20. 20. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level 3. Service contracting  Government Assistance to Teachers and Students in Private Education (GASTPE)  Voucher-type program  Shift enrolment from public high schools to private high schools  Education Service Contracting scheme (with a subsidy)  For 2004-2005:  325,000 students  1600 private high schools contracted  P1.5 Billion  Managed by the Fund for Assistance to Private Education (FAPE, NGO)
  21. 21. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level 3. Service contracting  Proposals:  Pre-school education service contracting (expansion of the pilot project)  ESC for Madaris Education (Madrasah schools) in Mindanao
  22. 22. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level 4. Private spending for education (private education)  Regulation of private schools  Standards  Consumer protection  As an alternative or option for parents  Possibilities for PPPS  Involvement of private educators in governance  Opening Departmental programs to private schools (teacher training, Educators’ Congress, professional associations)  Opening LSB funding for private education
  23. 23. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level Example: Cost effectiveness of ESC (Education Service Contracting) Scheme  Constructing (traditional DepED solution)…  For every 50 students = 1 classroom = P500,000  For every class = 1.25 teachers = P300,000/year  For every class = 5 subjects x 1 textbook x P75 x 50 = P18,750  For every 50 students = 50 desks x P1000 = P50,000  For every student = P250 in MOOE/year (average) = P12,500  Total = P833,750 start up + P312,500 recurring cost  …versus contracting (ESC)  P6000/year (SY 2009-2010) x 50 = P300,000
  24. 24. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level If possible for Education, why not for other services, needs? 1. Health: Private medical providers  school health as primary target (preventive)  Private hospitals/clinics + LGU health card 2. Garbage collection and recycling 3. Street maintenance (especially in town or city center, business district) by local businesses 4. Disaster response (Local business)  Preparedness (what other evacuation centers available?)  Mitigation (reduce risks)
  25. 25. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level The Future: Opportunities 1. Water  Manila: Assets owned by MWSS; water and sewerage services privatized to Manila Water and Maynilad  Privatize the management of the local water district (If regulated well, the town/city can realize greater efficiencies)  Not a private enterprise, but a public-private partnership 2. Garbage landfill sites  Collection  Disposal  Recycling (business opportunity ) 3. Electricity cooperative  Non-governmental, but many are run like government agencies
  26. 26. Public-Private Partnership for Good GovernanceLocal Government Level The Future: Opportunities The KEY: Proper Regulation  Standards + enforcement  Protection of constituents (from a monopoly)  Ensure a stable environment to operate as a partnership The DRIVER: Rules and regulations  Local chief executive is critical, but not the key to success  Partnerships must be sustainable over time (e.g. beyond 3 year terms)
  27. 27. Public-Private Partnershipsfor Good GovernanceLocal Government LevelJ. M. LUZAssociate Dean, Center for Development Management,Asian Institute of ManagementPanibagong Paraan for Good Government5 November 2009

×