Economic Theory testing
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Like this? Share it with your network


Economic Theory testing






Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



1 Embed 5 5


Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

Economic Theory testing Presentation Transcript

  • 1. Keynesians vs monetarists A Granger Causality match Guy Lion April 2006 Hey Keynes, your [Tax] Cuts are no uppercut. Milton, where is your [Money] Velocity? I am Clive Granger who decides Causality
  • 2. Introduction
    • We will use Granger causality to referee a match in economic theory between Keynesians and monetarists.
    • Both claim their respective tools are best to manage GDP.
    • We will test which tools better “Granger cause” quarterly GDP changes.
  • 3. Keynesian economics
    • John Maynard Keynes (1883 – 1946) stated that a counter-cyclical fiscal policy was effective in managing the business cycle.
    • This means running a Budget Deficit when the economy is decelerating. And, running a Budget Surplus when economy is accelerating.
    • Keynes suggested government (net) spending affected aggregate demand without affecting price (inflation).
  • 4. Monetarism
    • Milton Friedman (1912 - ) stated the Money Supply has a direct impact on economic growth and inflation.
    • Milton relied on Irving Fisher’s (1867–1947) Quantity Theory: MV = PQ or
    • Money Supply x Velocity of Money = Price x Quantity.
    • The best way to manage the economy is to target a conservative Money Supply growth and stick to it. This way, you control inflation.
  • 5. Keynesians vs Monetarists fighting stands
    • Keynesians do not believe monetary variables (M1, M2, M3) affect macroeconomic variables (GDP, CPI). This may be due to change in Velocity of Money being a countervailing force to change in Money Supply. Thus, for them “money does not matter.”
    • For monetarists, fiscal policies are not effective because interest rate is a countervailing force to fiscal stimulus (the “crowding out” theory). And, because of the Quantity Theory [MV = PQ] Money Supply does have a direct impact on macroeconomic variables (GDP, CPI). Thus, for them “money is everything.”
  • 6. A Budget Deficit proxy variable
    • Budget Deficit data is annual. That’s a problem.
    • As an alternative we looked at Treasury levels from one quarter to the next.
    • Disaggregate Interest refinancing from Deficit financing as shown below.
  • 7. Granger Causality review
    • Develop a Base case autoregressive model using dependent variable and its lagged values as independent variable.
    • Develop a Test case model by adding a second lagged independent variable you want to test.
    • Calculate the square of the residual errors for the two models and run a t test (unpaired) to check if the residuals are significantly lower when you add tested second variable. [We will run the non-parametric Mann-Whitney test to observe P value differences].
    • Redo steps 1 through 3, but reverse the direction. By comparing the tests significance or P value, you can see if A Granger causes B more than B Granger causes A.
    We will skip step 4 because we are not interested on whether GDP impacts fiscal or monetary policies, but on whether fiscal or monetary policies have a greater impact on GDP.
  • 8. Selecting the lagged variable for GDP Data source: quarterly data since second quarter 1959 to 3d quarter 2005. Source: BEA (GDP), Flow of Funds (Treasury -> Deficit Financing), Federal Reserve (M2).
  • 9. Granger Causality GDP Output P values for both test models are too high. In the Mann-Whitney test, the Milton model is going in the wrong direction. The avg. rank went up. That’s bad.
  • 10. Keynes vs Milton slugfest
  • 11. Conclusion [Milton to Granger] I feel tired right now. Keynes wins by Granger causing decision.