Gene Therapy - Problems and Challenges Alison M. Beaney Regional Quality Assurance Specialist North-East and Yorkshire Helapet Aseptic Study Day 2008

Alison M. Beaney

Regional Quality Assurance Specialist

North-East and Yorkshire

Gene Therapy Background to Gene Therapy Potential Benefits Perceived Hazards and Risks Regulations Implications for Pharmacy Aseptic Units Future?

Background to Gene Therapy

Potential Benefits

Perceived Hazards and Risks

Regulations

Implications for Pharmacy Aseptic Units

Future?

Gene Therapy Definition The deliberate introduction of genetic material into human somatic cells for therapeutic, prophylactic or diagnostic purposes Addition of EXTRA genes Aim is to cure disease (or at least help the patient) First introduction of gene-modified cells into a patient was in 1989 First gene therapy product approved for market in 2004 Still very experimental and early in its development

Definition

The deliberate introduction of genetic material into human somatic cells for therapeutic, prophylactic or diagnostic purposes

Addition of EXTRA genes

Aim is to cure disease (or at least help the patient)

First introduction of gene-modified cells into a patient was in 1989

First gene therapy product approved for market in 2004

Still very experimental and early in its development

PTQA April 2008

Gene Therapy Vectors Vectors deliver genes to cells Therapeutic gene (Transgene) Therapeutic protein Vector for efficient gene delivery Transcription Translation

Vectors deliver genes to cells

Types of Gene Therapy Vectors Non-viral vectors Naked DNA Liposomes/DNA Polymer/DNA complex (polyplex) Liposome/Polymer/DNA (lipopolyplex) Viral vectors DNA viruses Adenovirus Herpes Simplex Virus RNA viruses Retrovirus

Non-viral vectors

Naked DNA

Liposomes/DNA

Polymer/DNA complex (polyplex)

Liposome/Polymer/DNA (lipopolyplex)

Viral vectors

DNA viruses

Adenovirus

Herpes Simplex Virus

RNA viruses

Retrovirus

Gene Therapy Strategies Gene Replacement Replace ‘faulty’ genes with normal genes Corrects inherited genetic errors Provides a missing function Monogenic diseases e.g. cystic fibrosis, haemophilia, X-SCID Gene Addition Delivers genes to provide a new function Polygenic diseases e.g. cancer

Gene Replacement

Replace ‘faulty’ genes with normal genes

Corrects inherited genetic errors

Provides a missing function

Monogenic diseases e.g. cystic fibrosis, haemophilia, X-SCID

Gene Addition

Delivers genes to provide a new function

Polygenic diseases e.g. cancer

Were trying to make a mouse contraceptive vaccine for pest control Used modified mousepox virus as vehicle for transporting antibodies into mice Inserted gene to create ↑ IL-4 (interleukin 4) to boost production Surprise !! totally suppressed the "cell-mediated response“ which combats viral infection Mousepox 100% lethal 2001

Were trying to make a mouse contraceptive vaccine for pest control

Used modified mousepox virus as vehicle for transporting antibodies into mice

Inserted gene to create ↑ IL-4 (interleukin 4) to boost production

Surprise !!

totally suppressed the "cell-mediated response“ which combats viral infection

Mousepox 100% lethal

December 19, 2007 Boy gets leukaemia after gene treatment to cure ‘bubble baby syndrome’ 3 year-old with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID) - immune system fails to develop Treated with genetically modified virus to correct the faulty DNA that causes X-SCID Inserting the replacement DNA activated another gene that promotes cancer Now an acknowledged risk of gene therapy Also seen in 4 / 11 patients in a French trial One has died while 3 are in remission Retrovirus vector

December 19, 2007

Boy gets leukaemia after gene treatment to cure ‘bubble baby syndrome’

3 year-old with X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (X-SCID) - immune system fails to develop

Treated with genetically modified virus to correct the faulty DNA that causes X-SCID

Inserting the replacement DNA activated another gene that promotes cancer

Now an acknowledged risk of gene therapy

Also seen in 4 / 11 patients in a French trial One has died while 3 are in remission

Regulations governing the handling of gene therapy vectors No additional regulations governing the handling of Non-Infectious vectors Non-viral & Non-bacterial Viral vectors are Genetically Modified Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs)

No additional regulations governing the handling of Non-Infectious vectors

Non-viral & Non-bacterial

Viral vectors are Genetically Modified

Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs)

Genetic Modification Genetic modification is officially defined as ‘the alteration of genetic material (DNA or RNA) of an organism by means that could not occur naturally through mating and/or recombination’ A guide to Genetically modified organisms (Contained Use) Regulations 2000. Health and Safety Executive

Genetic modification is officially defined as ‘the alteration of genetic material (DNA or RNA) of an organism by means that could not occur naturally through mating and/or recombination’

A guide to Genetically modified organisms (Contained Use) Regulations 2000. Health and Safety Executive

Regulations governing the handling of gene therapy viral vectors Two sets of Regulations: GMO (Contained Use) Regs 2000, HSE All possible barriers (physical, biological or chemical) are in place to limit contact of the GMOs with humans and the environment GMO (Deliberate Release) Regs 2002 , DEFRA All appropriate measures are taken to avoid damage to the environment from the escape or release from human control of GMOs aimed at laboratories (difficult to interpret clinically) no reference to product or patient safety

Two sets of Regulations:

GMO (Contained Use) Regs 2000, HSE

All possible barriers (physical, biological or chemical) are in place to limit contact of the GMOs with humans and the environment

GMO (Deliberate Release) Regs 2002 , DEFRA

All appropriate measures are taken to avoid damage to the environment from the escape or release from human control of GMOs

aimed at laboratories (difficult to interpret clinically)

no reference to product or patient safety

Additional Regulations that apply to Gene Therapy Clinical Trials Protection of the Patient Gene Therapy Advisory Committee (GTAC) Established 1993, Department of Health UK national research ethics committee (REC) for gene therapy Ethical acceptability for human gene therapy Scientific merits Potential benefits and risks Patient flagging and long term monitoring Advice to UK health Ministers on developments in gene therapy research Applies to ALL GENE THERAPY CLINICAL TRIALS using viral and non-viral vectors

Protection of the Patient

Gene Therapy Advisory Committee (GTAC)

Established 1993, Department of Health

UK national research ethics committee (REC) for gene therapy

Ethical acceptability for human gene therapy

Scientific merits

Potential benefits and risks

Patient flagging and long term monitoring

Advice to UK health Ministers on developments in gene therapy research

Applies to ALL GENE THERAPY CLINICAL TRIALS using viral and non-viral vectors

Containment Levels for GMOs Containment Measures Required Isolatable Lab Suite Microbiological Safety Cabinet Gloves Protective Clothing Class 1 Level 1 NO NO NO YES Requires first use of premises notification to HSE Class 2 Level 2 NO Risk Assessment R/A R/A YES Minimum requirement for any human blood or clinical samples. Requires HSE notification Class 3 Level 3 YES YES YES YES + Footwear Requires HSE notification Class 4 Level 4 YES YES YES YES Complete change of clothing and footwear on entry and exit Requires HSE notification

Guidelines on Handling GMOs in Pharmacy QA of Aseptic Preparation Services (4th Ed n. ) Appendix 6 Gene Therapy Scientific Advisory Committee on Genetic Modification (SACGM), Part 6, Guidance on the use of genetically modified micro-organisms in a clinical setting European Association of Hospital Pharmacists (EAHP) Guidance on the Pharmacy Handling of Gene Medicines Rules and Guidance for Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Distributors 2007 – No Specific Guidance

QA of Aseptic Preparation Services (4th Ed n. ) Appendix 6 Gene Therapy

Scientific Advisory Committee on Genetic Modification (SACGM), Part 6, Guidance on the use of genetically modified micro-organisms in a clinical setting

European Association of Hospital Pharmacists (EAHP) Guidance on the Pharmacy Handling of Gene Medicines

Rules and Guidance for Pharmaceutical Manufacturers and Distributors 2007 – No Specific Guidance

APPENDIX 6 - GENE THERAPY Facilities Documentation Labelling Training Aseptic processing Cleaning Storage Transport Waste Disposal Spillage

Facilities

Documentation

Labelling

Training

Aseptic processing

Cleaning

Storage

Transport

Waste Disposal

Spillage

Facilities Gene therapy should not be manipulated in clinical areas Basic Principles - Containment - Knowledge / understanding / skill - Validated procedures Persons handling the product should be masked and gloved All disposable equipment and materials used for prep & admin - handled as biohazardous Dedicated facilities required -ve pressure isolators or Class II BSC +ve pressure room or lobby Containment level > 2

Gene therapy should not be manipulated in clinical areas

Basic Principles - Containment - Knowledge / understanding / skill - Validated procedures

Persons handling the product should be masked and gloved

All disposable equipment and materials used for prep & admin - handled as biohazardous

Dedicated facilities required

-ve pressure isolators or Class II BSC

+ve pressure room or lobby

Containment level > 2

Clean room suite designed to provide protection to the cleanroom

Aseptic Manipulation Doses Calculation / dilutions / multiple dilutions Needle stick injury risk Units Particle Units/ml (PU/ml) Plaque Forming Units/ml (PFU/ml) Infectious particle Units/ml (IU/ml) Gene Transfer Units/ml (GTU/ml) Stability Container compatibilities - Plastic/glass adhesion Expiry date - Time to administration from thawing

Doses

Calculation / dilutions / multiple dilutions

Needle stick injury risk

Units

Particle Units/ml (PU/ml)

Plaque Forming Units/ml (PFU/ml)

Infectious particle Units/ml (IU/ml)

Gene Transfer Units/ml (GTU/ml)

Stability

Container compatibilities - Plastic/glass adhesion

Expiry date - Time to administration from thawing

Decontamination Cleaning Virucidal detergents (validated against GT vectors) Cleaning Validation Specific Detection methods needed for viruses that are virus specific and highly sensitive Waste Disposal On site validated autoclave for re-usable equipment Inactivation on-site for Class 3 vectors Validated autoclave Incineration Disinfectant treatment

Cleaning

Virucidal detergents (validated against GT vectors)

Cleaning Validation

Specific Detection methods needed for viruses that are virus specific and highly sensitive

Waste Disposal

On site validated autoclave for re-usable equipment

Inactivation on-site for Class 3 vectors

Validated autoclave

Incineration

Disinfectant treatment

Spillage Specific to GT vector Spillage kit Contents ( gloves, masks, aprons, goggles, disposable shoe covers, virucidal detergents, absorbent material, disposable forceps & biohazard incineration bag) Positioned in all GT handling areas Notification to HSE Accidental Exposure

Spillage

Specific to GT vector

Spillage kit

Contents ( gloves, masks, aprons, goggles, disposable shoe covers, virucidal detergents, absorbent material, disposable forceps & biohazard incineration bag)

Positioned in all GT handling areas

Notification to HSE

SOPs needed Safe handling & protection Storage Operators (Not pregnant, breastfeeding or immunosuppressed) Training Facilities Spillage, contamination & needle stick Waste disposal, cleaning and transport

Safe handling & protection

Storage

Operators (Not pregnant, breastfeeding or immunosuppressed)

Training

Facilities

Spillage, contamination & needle stick

Waste disposal, cleaning and transport

Risk Assessment Assess each product individually Cytolytic viruses Non-cytolytic viruses Replication competent Replication deficient Class I, II or III

Assess each product individually

Cytolytic viruses

Non-cytolytic viruses

Replication competent

Replication deficient

Class I, II or III

What will the Future bring? Dedicated facilities Automation? The first gene medicine in Europe could be licensed in 2008 Licensed closed-system gene therapy products Use of gene therapy as an adjunct to standard therapy e.g. Radiotherapy & Chemotherapy Vector development e.g. Targeted vectors (viral & non-viral) Bacterial vectors

Dedicated facilities

Automation?

The first gene medicine in Europe could be licensed in 2008

Licensed closed-system gene therapy products

Use of gene therapy as an adjunct to standard therapy e.g. Radiotherapy & Chemotherapy

Vector development e.g.

Targeted vectors (viral & non-viral)

Bacterial vectors

Additional Information Gene Therapy Advisory Committee (GTAC) http://www. advisorybodies . doh . gov . uk /genetics/ gtac /index. htm Gene therapy trials worldwide. Provided by the Journal of gene medicine http://82.182.180.141/trials/index.html A guide to Genetically modified organisms (Contained Use) regulations 2000. Health and Safety Executive Genetically Modified Organism (Deliberate Release) Regulations 2002 [GMO(DR)]. Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2002/uksi_20022443_en.pdf Quality Assurance of Aseptic Preparation Services Fourth Edition. A.M. Beaney. Pharmaceutical Press 2006. Appendix 6. Gene Therapy. EU Clinical Trials Directive. http://www. wctn .org. uk /downloads/EU_Directive/Directive. pdf Implications of gene therapy for hospital pharmacists. Simpson.J, Stoner. N. www.pjonline.com/pdf/articles/ pj_20030726_ genetherapy .pdf

Gene Therapy Advisory Committee (GTAC) http://www. advisorybodies . doh . gov . uk /genetics/ gtac /index. htm

Gene therapy trials worldwide. Provided by the Journal of gene medicine http://82.182.180.141/trials/index.html

A guide to Genetically modified organisms (Contained Use) regulations 2000. Health and Safety Executive

Genetically Modified Organism (Deliberate Release) Regulations 2002 [GMO(DR)]. Department for the Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA) http://www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2002/uksi_20022443_en.pdf

Quality Assurance of Aseptic Preparation Services Fourth Edition. A.M. Beaney. Pharmaceutical Press 2006. Appendix 6. Gene Therapy.

EU Clinical Trials Directive. http://www. wctn .org. uk /downloads/EU_Directive/Directive. pdf

Implications of gene therapy for hospital pharmacists. Simpson.J, Stoner. N. www.pjonline.com/pdf/articles/ pj_20030726_ genetherapy .pdf

Additional Information Cancer gene therapy: from science to clinical trials . Searle. P.F, Spiers. I, Simpson. J, James. J.D. Drug Delivery Systems and Sciences 2002, 2 (1), 5-13. Standards for gene therapy clinical trials based on pro-active risk assessment in a London NHS Teaching Hospital Trust. Bamford, K.B., Wood, S., Shaw, R.J. QJM 2005, 98, 75-86. www. qjmed . oupjournals .org Progress in Gene Therapy – are hospital pharmacies the next barrier? Simpson, J. Hospital Pharmacist , 2006 , 13 (8), 266 http://www. pjonline .com/ pdf /hp/200609/hp_200609_comment. pdf Cancer Biotherapy. An Introductory guide. Young, A. Rowett, L. Kerr, D. Oxford University Press 2006 Scientific Advisory Committee on Genetic Modification (SACGM), Part 6, Guidance on the use of genetically modified microorganisms in a clinical setting. http://www. hse . gov . uk / biosafety / gmo / acgm / acgmcomp /part6. pdf European Association of Hospital Pharmacists (EAHP) Guidance on the Pharmacy Handling of Gene Medicines. http://www. ejhp . eu /

Cancer gene therapy: from science to clinical trials . Searle. P.F, Spiers. I, Simpson. J, James. J.D. Drug Delivery Systems and Sciences 2002, 2 (1), 5-13.

Standards for gene therapy clinical trials based on pro-active risk assessment in a London NHS Teaching Hospital Trust. Bamford, K.B., Wood, S., Shaw, R.J. QJM 2005, 98, 75-86. www. qjmed . oupjournals .org

Progress in Gene Therapy – are hospital pharmacies the next barrier? Simpson, J. Hospital Pharmacist , 2006 , 13 (8), 266 http://www. pjonline .com/ pdf /hp/200609/hp_200609_comment. pdf

Cancer Biotherapy. An Introductory guide. Young, A. Rowett, L. Kerr, D. Oxford University Press 2006

Scientific Advisory Committee on Genetic Modification (SACGM), Part 6, Guidance on the use of genetically modified microorganisms in a clinical setting. http://www. hse . gov . uk / biosafety / gmo / acgm / acgmcomp /part6. pdf

European Association of Hospital Pharmacists (EAHP) Guidance on the Pharmacy Handling of Gene Medicines. http://www. ejhp . eu /