COUNTER usage statistics: Measuring the benefits of the big dealsPresentation Transcript
COUNTER usage statistics:Measuring the benefits of the big deals Angela Conyers Evidence Base, Research & Evaluation Birmingham City University
Working with usage statistics2004-5NESLi2 analysis of usage statistics (JISC)2006-9Analysing Publisher Deals (Evidence Base)2008Assessing the value of the NESLi2 deals (JISC)2008-9Usage Statistics Portal Scoping Study (JISC)2010 -JUSP - Journal Usage Statistics Portal (JISC)
What do libraries want fromusage data?• Be sure it is right• Ready access for reporting• How well titles in a deal are being used: – High use, nil and low use• Usage by subject area• Analyse trends over time• Evidence of value for money
JUSP Purpose and benefits • Single point of access to usage data from multiple publishers • No need to visit separate publisher sites to download usage statistics • Usage comparison across publishers and years • Establishing value for money http://www.flickr.com/photos/wallyg/418328695/
A collaborative project
138 UK highereducation andresearch councillibraries are in JUSP http://www.flickr.com/photos/ellf/3910635234/
18 publishers Nature Publishing Group American Association for the Oxford University Press Advancement of Science Project MUSE American Institute of Physics Royal Society of Chemistry Annual Reviews SAGE BioOne Springer British Medical Journal Taylor & Francis Publishing Group Wiley-Blackwell Edinburgh University Press 3 intermediaries Elsevier Ebsco EJS Emerald Publishing Technology Future Medicine (ingentaconnect) Institute of Physics Swets
COUNTER usage reportsJR1• Journal Report 1: Number of Successful Full-Text Article Requests by Month and JournalJR1a• Journal Report 1a: Number of Successful Full-Text Article Requests from an Archive by Month and Journal / http://www.flickr.com/photos/bionicteaching 2920562020/
• Standardized Usage Statistics Harvesting Initiative (SUSHI)• M2M way of gathering statistics• Replaces the user- mediated collection of usage reports• 12 JUSP SUSHI clients available• SUSHI server to gather data from JUSP http://www.flickr.com/photos/ragingwire/3395161474/
Making sure it is right• Data is quality checked• Full usage reports are given: – JR1 and JR1a usage reports from publishers – Addition of usage from intermediaries/gateways – Separation of JR1A archive use from use of current deal
Adding value to the JR1• Titles with the highest use from one publisher or all publishers in JUSP• Titles in various usage ranges, from nil and low to very high• Search facility – title or ISSN or keyword• Trends over time (2009- )• Comparing usage of different publishers• Assisting with the SCONUL return
HelpingAdding value to JUSP a deal to judge the value ofJUSP enhancements: • Adding subscribed or core titles • What titles are in the deal?
Adding subscribed or core titles Adding subscribed or core titles• How much are the subscribed titles being used?• How much are other titles in the deal being used?• Does usage show that the deal offers better value than individual subscribed titles?
What titles are in the deal? What titles are in the deal?Accounting for nil usage• Does the JR1 report contain titles that are not available in the collection the library subscribes to?• Does the JR1 report contain titles that are no longer part of the current deal e.g. name changes, publisher changes?
How many titles are in the deal?Project Muse JR1 for 2011 for a library with theBasic Research Collection– Titles in the Premium Collection in the JR1 498 Titles in the Basic Research Collection 206 Titles in the JR1 not available to the Library 29259% of titles in the JR1 are not in the library’sdeal and will show nil use.
JUSP enhancements• Usage patterns of subscribed or core titles• Identification of titles in the deal or collection within the JR1 report• Adding more publishers
Measuring costsCost per download • All titles • Subscribed titles • Non-subscribed titlesCost per title • All titles in the JR1 • All titles in the deal/collection taken • Subscribed titles • Non-subscribed titles