Developing higher-order thinking through blended problem-based learning Mr TONG, Edmond Tak Fai School of Nursing, Dr Paula Hodgson Education Development Centre, Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong SAR, China This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License .

Blended learning face-to-face mode online mode

face-to-face mode

Background Year 3 students of a four-year Bachelor of Science (Nursing) programme Class of 124 students Five groups were randomly formed 3 cases were reconstructed from real cases and each case was split into 3 parts. Case analysis: Face-to-face tutorials & online tasks ( 5% ): Based on each case, students posted topics, issues and hypotheses, peer group members were to post subsequent threaded discussions.

Year 3 students of a four-year Bachelor of Science (Nursing) programme

Class of 124 students

Five groups were randomly formed

3 cases were reconstructed from real cases and each case was split into 3 parts.

Case analysis: Face-to-face tutorials & online tasks ( 5% ):

Based on each case, students posted topics, issues and hypotheses, peer group members were to post subsequent threaded discussions.

Blended PBL

Bloom’s taxonomy Categories in the cognitive domain of Bloom's Taxonomy (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001) Source: http://edorigami.wikispaces.com/Bloom's+and+ICT+tools

4 categories of learning challenge Remember Understand Apply / Analyze Evaluate / Create

Results and findings Group participation (5 groups) Referencing sources (websites, books, and journals) Distribution of the four categories modified from Bloom’s taxonomy in online forum discussion

Group participation (5 groups)

Referencing sources (websites, books, and journals)

Distribution of the four categories modified from Bloom’s taxonomy in online forum discussion

Group participation N=124 Most active Least active

N=124

Online case discussion Discussion topics created by students of Sophie’s case Sophie may suffer from left tympanic bone facture (8 postings) The fluid in her left eye (2 postings) The initial management of head injury (17 postings) Brain death of Sophie (13 postings) The organ donation card (3 postings) Consequences of CSF leakage & Temporal bone fracture (1 posting) Assessing her level of consciousness in hospital (2 postings) Patient and Family Psychological Support (3 postings) Alcoholic Effects on the Brain (6 postings) Mechanical Ventilation (1 posting) Management on ventricular cartherter (6 postings) Craniectomy (3 postings) More information about Craniectomy (5 postings) Management of Increased ICP in Part 2 (28 postings) Shivering ??? (13 postings) The cause of vertigo (7 postings) Purpose for using steroid and side effects related to appearance (6 postings) …

Discussion topics created by students of Sophie’s case

Sophie may suffer from left tympanic bone facture (8 postings)

The fluid in her left eye (2 postings)

The initial management of head injury (17 postings)

Brain death of Sophie (13 postings)

The organ donation card (3 postings)

Consequences of CSF leakage & Temporal bone fracture (1 posting)

Assessing her level of consciousness in hospital (2 postings)

Patient and Family Psychological Support (3 postings)

Alcoholic Effects on the Brain (6 postings)

Mechanical Ventilation (1 posting)

Management on ventricular cartherter (6 postings)

Craniectomy (3 postings)

More information about Craniectomy (5 postings)

Management of Increased ICP in Part 2 (28 postings)

Shivering ??? (13 postings)

The cause of vertigo (7 postings)

Purpose for using steroid and side effects related to appearance (6 postings)

…

Supporting discussion with references

Referencing sources

Distribution of the four categories identified from student postings in 3 cases

Significantly different between cases “ Remember” were significantly different between cases, c2 (2, N = 559) = 28.0, p < .001 Similar findings were seen in the postings categorized as “Analyse/Apply” with c2 (2, N = 559) = 8.66, p < .013

“ Remember” were significantly different between cases, c2 (2, N = 559) = 28.0, p < .001

Similar findings were seen in the postings categorized as “Analyse/Apply” with c2 (2, N = 559) = 8.66, p < .013

Mapping top / low 10% students in examination with uses of referencing materials in online forum

Distribution of the 4 categories of top / low 10% students examination with student participation in online forum

Conclusion Nurturing supportive and open learning environment is essential Students were engaged in graded tasks Increased percentage of postings for three cases: S1 (31 percent) S2 (32 percent) S3 (37 percent) Improved quality of discussion gradually emerges An increase in the number of postings in ‘ apply and analyse’ in S2 and S3 A decrease in the number of postings in ‘ remember’ in S2 and S3 Continuing support from facilitator

Nurturing supportive and open learning environment is essential

Students were engaged in graded tasks

Increased percentage of postings for three cases:

S1 (31 percent)

S2 (32 percent)

S3 (37 percent)

Improved quality of discussion gradually emerges

An increase in the number of postings in

‘ apply and analyse’ in S2 and S3

A decrease in the number of postings in

‘ remember’ in S2 and S3

Continuing support from facilitator