30th Efma Convention:
Leadership in retail finance
13 p.m. & 14 March 2008 - Paris
Bertrand Lavayssière
Managing Director, Global Financial Services
Capgemini
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
1
Press conference
Amsterdam, March 12th 2008
Introducing…
Patrick DESMARES, Secretary General, European Financial Management & Marketing
Association (EFMA)
Bertrand LAVAYSSIERE, Managing Director, Global Financial services, Capgemini
Felix POTVLIEGE, Head Strategy & Business, Development of Retail Banking, ING Group
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
3
Agenda
Presentation of the World Retail Banking Report
Pricing Indexes – Key Findings
Organic Growth in Domestic Markets – Key Findings
Questions & Answers
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
4
The World Retail Banking Report (WRBR) aims to Highlight the Trends in
the Retail Banking Industry on a Global Scale
Figure 1.3 Average Local Profile Prices
Annual prices of core banking services by geographic area and usage pattern, 2008 (€)
Index of prices for product and
250 €
Pricing
197 €
200 € Very Active User price
Active User price
Less Active User price
services based on their 150 €
100 €
101 €
136 €
104 €
122 €
indexes
79 €
frequencies of use, and updated
75 € 74 € 70 €
52 €
50 €
45 € 49 €
31 € 35 €
22 €
0€
yearly
Europe Eurozone Europe Non-eurozone North America Asia-Pacific Average
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
FINALPRICE_FIGURES WRBR08 V1.12.PPT 4
Figure 2.3 Domestic Retail Banking: Growth of Revenue vs. Costs for
“Organic Growth in Domestic
Selected Banks, 2002-2006 (%)
0,2
Revenue
growth
CAGR 02-06 (1)
2008
Bank of America
Markets” 0,15
0,1
La Caixa
Sumitomo Mitsui
KBC
HBOS
Wachovia
The spotlight is based on case
Banques Pop
CBA CM-CIC RBS
ANZ Caja Madrid
Spotlight
ING Wells Fargo
Banca Intesa BBVA Dexia BNPP
Santander
0,05 ABN AMRO HVB
Citigroup SocGen Crédit Agricole
Mizuho Barclays Nordea Caisse d'Epargne
studies, quantitative analysis
UniCredit Banca Sanpaolo
Rabobank
Fortis
Westpac
LCL
0
Dresdner Bank
Deutsche Bank
Resona
Operating
and interviews with 52 banks
cost
growth
-0,05 CAGR 02-06(1)
-0,15 -0,1 -0,05 0 0,05 0,1 0,15
Sources : Capgemini analysis, 2008 , and bank annual reports.
Note: CIR before impairment losses.
(1) CAGR calculation using 2007 currencies.
FINALSPOTLIGHT_FIGURESV7.
5
2.PPT
Overview based on Macro economic indicators (2006)
Macro economic indicators (2006)
•• GDP at current prices and PPP :: 229 billion Billion
€ 34 Billion
GDP at current prices and PPP 229 billionHRK •• Banking staff: 24000 19 096
Croatia Dashboard WRBR2008
Retail banking environment
Retail banking environment
Regulatory Organisations supervisory institutions
macroeconomic data and on
€ 34 HRK Banking staff: 24000 19 096
Croatian Agency f or
Inhabitants :4.44 million
•• Population ::: 4.44 million
Population
Inhabitants 4.41 million
4.41 million •• Number of branches: 1114
Number of branches: 1114 1 118
1 118 Croatian National Superv ision of Croatian Competi tion Financial Agency Croatian Chamber of
Economy (HGK) -
•• GDP per head ::51560 HRK
GDP per head 51560 HRK € 7 638
€ 7 638 •• Number of ATM: 2307
Number ofATMs: 2307
ATMs:
ATM: 2 649
2 649 Bank (H NB) Financial Serv ices Agency ( AZ TN) (FINA)
Financial Department
(HA NF A)
)
Economic growth rate :in GDP: n/a
Importanceof Banking
•• Importancegrowthrate :in GDP: n/a
Economic of Banking 4.8%
4.8% •• Households savings ratio ::1.9%
Households savings ratio 1.9% 2.0%
2.0%
•• Economic growth rate :indicator ::
Consumer confidence :indicator
Economic growth rate 4.3%
Consumer confidence 4.3% -22
-22 •• Inflation rate :: 3.3%
Inflation rate 3.3% 3.2%
3.2% • Central bank, • Supervi si on of banks, • Respon sibl e for
respon sible for overall pension and • Supervi si on of • Advisory body on poli cy
•• Unemployment rate :: indicator ::-26
Consumer confidence indicator -26
Unemployment rate
Consumer confidence 12.0%
12.0% •• Interest rate for consumer credit: 12% 9.5%
Interest rate for consumer credit: 12% 9.5% competition control
domestic payments and developments within
stabi lity of financi al investment funds,
•• Unemployment rate :: 12.7%
Consumer Price rate 12.7%
Consumer PriceIndex:
Unemployment Index: 3.2%
3.2% •• Interest rate for residential mortgage: 5%5.5%
Interest rate for residential mortgage: 5%5.5% system insurance companies, system (cleari ng and the banking industry
RT GS) • Data selecti on and
•• Interest rate on long term bonds:
Interest rate on long term bonds: 4.1%
4.1% • Control of all banking brokerage house s
• Respon si bl e for Central processing from card
activities
Account Register management fi eld
Taxation of xx on
Taxation of xx on
capital gains
capital gains
Dashboards
RETAIL BANKING MARKET
analyses of local evolutions in
Type and size of Players
Type and size of Players Products
Products Trends
Trends
Regulatory Changes
Regulatory Changes
Regul atory
In December 2006, HNB announced further tightening of regulation s.
In December 2006, HNB announced further ti ghteni ng of regulation s.
In December announced tightening of regul ati ons.
Effective from January 2007, the growth of the banks’ loan portfolios iss
’
Effecti ve from January 2007, the growth of the banks l oan portfolios i
from January banks’
restricted to 12 percent per annum. Any excess of the growth rat e must be
rest ricted to12 percent per annum.Any excess of the growth rat mustbe
rest ri cted 12 percent per Any the rate be
followed by mandatory purchase of llow-yielding HNB billls innthe amount of
followed by mandatory purchase of ow-yielding HNB bil s i the amount of
foll owed low-yi elding HNB bills the amount of
50% of the excess placement .
50% of the excess pl acement
50% of the excess placement.
Competition envi ronment
Competition environment
environment
• •Major Banks inn private foreign ownershipp have retained their dominant
MajorBanks i pri vate foreign ownership have retai ned their dominant
Banks forei gn ownershi have retai ned their dominant
positi ons in all business segments
posi tions i n all businesssegments
positions in all segments
• Increase of capi tal carried out, sharp competition and slowing ddownof the
•Increaseof capital carried out, sharp competititionand sl owing down of the
of capital carried out, sharp competi on and slowing own of the
net income growth showed the effects, Banks´ ROAE decrea sed to 12%
net i ncome growth showed the effects, Banks´ ROAE decrea sed to 12%
net showed effects, Banks´ ROAE to 12%
or 9%.
or9%.
9%.
• •Banks conti nue to compete with new products and services showinng
Banks continue to compete with new products and servi ces showi g
Banks continue to compete with products and services g
raise in fee income and income from other servi ces such a sscredi t tcards,
rai se in fee i incomeand income from other services such a credi cards,
raise in fee ncome and income from other services such cards,
investment banki ng.
i nvestment banking.
investment banking.
In meanwhile, two main sourcesof fundsfor Banks´ growth were more
• •In meanwhil e, two mai n sources of funds for Banks´ growth were more
In meanwhile, main of for Banks´ more
barely avail abl e: forei gn funds become more expensive due to HNB
barel y available: foreign funds become more expensi ve due to HNB
barely available: foreign funds become more expensive to
the retail banking sector
restricti ons and domestic funds (cliient deposi ts) were channeled into
rest rictions and domestic funds (cl ent deposits) were channel ed into
rest ri ctions domestic funds (client deposits) channeled i nto
investment funds and stock mar ket.
i nvestment funds and stockmarket.
investment funds mar ket.
• •Latest acquisitions: Hungarian OT P Group (Nova Banka ) end of 2005;
Latest acqui si tions: Hungarian OT P Group (Nova Banka end of 2005;
Hungari an Group (Nova Banka) end of 2005;
Soci éétéGé né rale (Spli tska Banka) iin 2006; Bayri sche Landesbank (Hypo
Soci té Générale (Splitska Banka) n 2006; Bayrische Landesbank (Hypo
é rale Splitska ) in 2006; Bayrische Landesbank
Alpe Adria Bank Group) iin 2007.
Al pe Adria Bank Group) n 2007.
Alpe Adria Bank Group) in 2007.
Customerss
Customer s
Customer
• •Customerssare becoming more demandi ng in terms of product offerings . .
Customer s are becoming more demanding in termsof productoffer ngs
Customer are becoming more demanding of i
offerings
• •At the end of 2006 IPO of INA iintroduced the signifi cant number of small
Atthe end of 2006 IPO of INA ntroduced the significant number of small
the end 2006 IPO of introduced the si gnificant number of
individual investors at the money market. T his moved the small private
i ndi vidual investors at the money market. T his moved the small pri vate
individual i nvestors market. hi s moved the small rivate
investors into different dimensi on, from non ririsky savings to taking certain
sky savi ngs
i nvestors i nto di fferentdi mension, from nonrisky savings to ta ki ng certain
investors into dimension, taking certain
ririsk for investments such aas securities (followed by IPO of HT iin Sep
risk for i nvestments such ass securiti es (foll owed by IPO of HT in Sep
sk for investments such (fol lowed by IPO Sep
Credit activities: In 2006 Banks granted credits to a total amount of EUR 25.6bn (both in HRK and in foreign
2007)
2007)
2007)
currency); 23.6% increase compared with the previous year. • •Loans to retail customers remain a key business, but most Banks have
Loans to retail customers remain a key business, but most Banks have
Loans to retail remain key business, but Banks
started to target SME busi nesse ssassan untapped revenue segment.
started totarget SMEbusinesse s aas an untapped revenue segment.
target businesse an untapped revenue segment.
Deposits: Ban ks we re very active in deposi ts collection. T otal deposi ts increased to EUR 27.5bn or 18.2%.
Product T rends
Product T rends
Product rends
New technologies, credit and debit card transactions: Croati an banks continue to invest in technology • •Most Banks offer cc redi tsin domestic HRK and EUR/CHF (value claause);
Most Banks offer credits in domesti c HRK and EUR/CH F (val ue cl use);
Most Banks offer redits in domestic and EUR/CHF
Consumer loans have become hi ghl y popular among the customers.
Consumer l oans havebecome highly popular among the customers.
become highly popular among customers.
development i n order to increase the number and quality of financial products and services.
• •Payments servi ce sssti ll l represent the highest revenues for core banking
Agenda
Presentation of the World Retail Banking Report
Pricing Indexes – Key Findings
Organic Growth in Domestic Markets – Key Findings
Questions & Answers
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
6
World Retail Banking Report – Price Index Key Messages Summarized
Prices vary significantly across the globe while consumers pay an average of €70 a year for banking
services
Influencing consumers seems to have been the main driver of banks’ pricing strategies from 2006 to
2008
Banks cut the price of sales influencers
Banks acted on prices of behaviour influencers according to their costs
Banks kept prices unchanged for unseen services
Prices were stable in Europe
European prices remained stable with a small 0.8% price increase across both the eurozone and non
eurozone
With the advent of SEPA, prices of pan-European payments have stabilised in the eurozone, and
(excluding Ireland) even decreased faster in Europe eurozone than in the rest of the world
Prices rose in North America (+5.7%) and dropped in Asia-Pacific (-11.1%)
North America’s price rose the most—averaging 5.7%—resulting primarily from higher prices for
payments and cash utilisation; its price had declined during the three previous years due to fierce
competition on account management fees.
Asia-Pacific’s price fell by 11.1% this year, essentially because of intensified competition in Australia and
India, particularly in payments and account management.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
7
While consumers pay an average of €70 a year for banking services,
prices vary significantly across the regions of the globe
Average Local Profile Price (€)
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
8
While consumers pay an average of €70 a year for banking services,
prices vary significantly across the 26 studied countries
450
400
350 278
Very Active User Price
300 243
215 Active User Price
210 Less Active User Price
250
167 185 159
132
200
105
116 119 112 98 122 113
114 95
150 117 124
85 99 72
123 90 60
95 85 84 59 74 95
100 86 82 70 72
70 68 54 30
72 34 45
64 66 61 52 34 35
50 58
47 54 43 54 33 17
42 41 39 42 59 12
32 33 36 8 17
24 19 1 18
13 5
0
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
9
Influencing consumers seems to have been the main driver of banks’
pricing strategies from 2006 to 2008
BEHAVIOUR INFLUENCERS,
more costly ( -0,9%)
1,9% 2%
BEHAVIOUR INFLUENCERS,
Less costly ( -0,2%) UNSEEN SERVICES ( 0%)
1,1% -1,2%
0,9%
SALES
INFLUENCERS ( -0,8%)
0,3% 0,4%
0,2%
0% -1,3% -1% -2,3% -0,6% 0% -0,5% -0,3%-0,4% 0,1%
-1,6%
Internal Transfer
Direct Debit
External Transfer
Document Search
Cash Deposit at
ATM
banks’ ATM network
Withdrawal at other
Banker’s draft
Current Account
Cheque
Cheque Stop
Withdrawal at desk
Standing Order
Cash deposit at desk
banks’ ATM
Withdrawal at
Online Banking
Debit Card
Credit Card
Debit Card Stop
Call
Centre
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
10
Prices were Stable in Europe Eurozone with a 0.8% (€0.6) rise only for
local active users
Sources of Fees for Core Banking in Europe Eurozone (%)
Product and Service Price Variations vs.
Last Year for the Local Active User in Europe Eurozone (€)
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
11
With the advent of SEPA, prices of pan-European payments have
stabilised in the eurozone
Price of Pan-European Payments Means for the Local Active Profile (€)
Average Eurozone*
€38 vs. €41 in 2007
Average Rest of the World
€33 vs. €34 in 2007
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
*Note: For methodological reason one country has been taken off
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
12
Prices were Stable in Europe Non-eurozone with a 0.8% rise (€0.6) only
for local active users
Sources of Fees for Core Banking Services in Europe Non-eurozone (%)
Product and Service Price Variations vs.
Last Year for the Local Active User in Europe
Non-Eurozone (€)
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
13
Prices evolutions over the last three years do not show resilient policies at work
Country A Country C
18%
13% 12% 15%
5 6 2 3 4 5 7 9
5% 4% 4%
1% 1% 3% 3%
0% -1% 0% 0% -4% -4% -8% 0,2%
-1% -0% -1%
-1% -2% -3% -2% -1% -1%
-3% -4% -3% -4% -3% -4%
1 2 3 4 -7% -5%
-8%
-10% 1 6 8
-13% -14%
-17%
-22%
-25% -25%
29%
Country B -44% Country D
1 37%
16% 16%
27% 2 3 4 25%
16% 11%
14% 12% 13% 14%12%
7% 9 10 7% 5%
3% 4%
0% -2% 0% 0% 1% 0% -5% -2% 0,2% 0% 0% 0,2% 0% 0%
0% 0% 0%
13% 0% -2%
0% -5% -5% -2%
-11% -10% -11% 13
-18% -17%
-26% 11 1 2 3 4 5
5 6 7 -28%
-38%
8
-53%
-57% -60%
12 Var. 06/05
-83% Var. 07/06
Var. 08/07
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
14
World Retail Banking Report – Price Index Key Messages Summarized
Prices vary significantly across the globe while consumers pay an average of €70 a year for banking
services
Influencing consumers seems to have been the main driver of banks’ pricing strategies from 2006 to
2008
Banks cut the price of sales influencers
Banks acted on prices of behaviour influencers according to their costs
Banks kept prices unchanged for unseen services
Prices were stable in Europe
European prices remained stable with a small 0.8% price increase across both the eurozone and non
eurozone
With the advent of SEPA, prices of pan-European payments have stabilised in the eurozone, and
(excluding Ireland) even decreased faster in Europe eurozone than in the rest of the world
Prices rose in North America (+5.7%) and dropped in Asia-Pacific (-11.1%)
North America’s price rose the most—averaging 5.7%—resulting primarily from higher prices for
payments and cash utilization; its price had declined during the three previous years due to fierce
competition on account management fees.
Asia-Pacific’s price fell by 11.1% this year, essentially because of intensified competition in Australia and
India, particularly in payments and account management.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
15
Agenda
Presentation of the World Retail Banking Report
Pricing Indexes – Key Findings
Organic Growth in Domestic Markets – Key Findings
Questions & Answers
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
16
WRBR 2008 spotlight theme
2004 2005 2006 2007
Pricing in a Increasing Share of Wallet The Rise of Remote Transforming Operating
Global Market from High-Potential Clients Channels: Building a New Models in Retail Banking
in Mature Markets Client Relationship Model
The sub-prime crisis and forecast economic slow down has highlighted the
importance of growth in mature countries. We decided therefore to focus our
2008 analysis on :
Organic Growth in Domestic Markets
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
17
World Retail Banking Report – Spotlight Key Messages Summarized
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations over the last 5 years, steadily
growing their revenue faster than their costs
Four pillars have supported their efforts to achieve profitable organic growth in their domestic markets
1. Combining fast time to market, innovation, and local client intimacy
2. Full multi-channel integration and optimisation
3. Increasing sales productivity through dynamic branch management
4. Leveraging a multi-brand portfolio to create attractive value propositions for each market segment.
Most banks however rely on these pillars to support very similar strategies: namely to build trust
relationship with their clients in order to sell them a large number of financial products.
We believe that tougher regulations, more flexible technology, more demanding clients and new
competitors will radically change retail banking
We simulated the effect of these structural changes on retail banking in 8 major European markets
Banks could lose 36% of their projected net income (and more than 50% in certain markets) within 10
years
To cope with this new environment, successful banks can use three distribution strategies to grow
beyond the traditional retail banking business models
“Better sell”, to better fit diverse clients’ needs
“Larger offer”, extending the offering to non-financial products and services
“Indirect business”, selling through other distributors
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
18
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
15%
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
10%
5%
0%
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
19
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
15%
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
10%
5%
0%
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
20
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
USA Bank Of
America
+ Japan
15%
Wachovia
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
Sumitomo
Mitsui
10%
Wells Fargo
5%
Citigroup
Mizuho
0%
Resona
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
21
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
+ Italy Bank Of
America
+ Spain
La Caixa
15%
Wachovia
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
Sumitomo
Mitsui
10%
Caja Madrid
Banca BBVA Wells Fargo
Intesa Santander
5%
Citigroup
Sanpaolo
Mizuho Unicredit
0%
Deutsche Resona Dresdner
Bank
Bank
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
22
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
+ Germany Bank Of
America
+ France
La Caixa
15%
Wachovia
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
Sumitomo
Mitsui Banques Populaires
10%
CM-CIC
Caja Madrid
Banca BBVA BNPP Wells Fargo
Intesa Santander
5% HVB
Citigroup SocGen Crédit Caisses
Sanpaolo Agricole d’Epargne
Mizuho Unicredit
LCL
0%
Deutsche Resona Dresdner
Bank
Bank
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
23
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
+ Netherlands Bank Of
America
+ UK
La Caixa
15%
Wachovia
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
HBOS
Sumitomo
Mitsui Banques Populaires
10%
CM-CIC RBS
Caja Madrid
ING
Banca Wells Fargo
ABN BBVA BNPP
Intesa AMRO Santander
5% HVB Dexia
Citigroup SocGen Crédit Caisses
Barclays
Sanpaolo Agricole d’Epargne
Mizuho Unicredit
Rabobank
LCL
0%
Deutsche Resona Dresdner
Bank
Bank
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
24
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations
over the last 5 years
20%
+ Belgium Bank Of
America
+ Australia
La Caixa
15%
KBC Wachovia
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
HBOS
Sumitomo
Mitsui Banques Populaires
10%
CBA CM-CIC ANZ RBS
Caja Madrid
ING
Banca Wells Fargo
ABN BBVA BNPP
Intesa AMRO Santander
5% HVB Dexia
Citigroup SocGen Crédit Caisses
Barclays
Sanpaolo Agricole d’Epargne
Mizuho Unicredit
Rabobank
LCL
Fortis Westpac
0%
Deutsche Resona Dresdner
Bank
Bank
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
25
4 best performers on their domestic markets have been identified
20%
Bank Of
America
La Caixa
15%
KBC Wachovia
Revenue Growth CAGR 02-06
HBOS
Sumitomo
Mitsui Banques Populaires
10%
CBA CM-CIC ANZ RBS
Caja Madrid
ING
Banca Wells Fargo
ABN BBVA BNPP
Intesa AMRO Santander
5% HVB Dexia
Citigroup SocGen Crédit Caisses
Barclays Nordea
Sanpaolo Agricole d’Epargne
Mizuho Unicredit
Rabobank
LCL
Fortis Westpac
0%
Deutsche Resona Dresdner
Bank
Bank
- 5%
-15% -10% - 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
Operating Costs Growth CAGR 02-06
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
26
Pillar 1: Fast time to market, innovation and local client intimacy
Crédit Mutuel - CIC in France
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
27
Pillar 2: Ensuring full multi-channel integration and optimisation:
ING in the Netherlands
Source: CBS (Dutch market) and company data (Postbank).
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
28
Pillar 3: Increasing sales productivity through dynamic branch
management
La Caixa in Spain
Source: La Caixa annual report, 2006.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
29
Pillar 4: Leveraging a multi-brand portfolio to create
attractive value propositions for each market segment
HBOS in UK
Source: Presentation at HBOS Retail Investors' Seminar, 2003.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
30
Conjectural and structural changes in the market are putting banks
revenue at risk and compelling them to adapt their strategies
Conjectural changes:
No longer financial market bubble
No longer real estate bubble More competitive
markets
Slow economic growth in mature countries
Harmonised national
Structural changes: environments
Down pressures on
More constraining regulations prices
High leverage technologies Market saturation to
traditional value
New customers’ behavior propositions
(risk averse, delegators…)
New entrants
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
31
Simulation of the effect of this competitive pressure :
Banks could loose 36% of NBI before 2017
90 000
- 30%
80 000 + 32%
70 000
- 50%
60 000
- 57% - 54%
50 000
A
40 000
global
- 55% - 17% 36%
30 000
drop
20 000
- 55%
10 000
NBI 2017F
Prices
harmonization impact
0
Interest rate
Belgium France Germany Italy Netherlands Nordic Spain UK margin impact
Source: Capgemini analysis, 2008.
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
32
Identification of three distribution strategies to go beyond the most
rewarding traditional model
BETTER SELL
LARGER
OFFER
BUSINESS
INDIRECT
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
33
Identification of three distribution strategies to go beyond the most
rewarding traditional model
Financial Advisor for Taking care of the customer’s HSBC Premier
Mass Affluent Customer financial life as a financial advisor
BETTER SELL
Specialised service provider to a USAA
Community Bank specific community
The most economic without Société Générale
Discount Bank minimising security or quality Boursorama
LARGER
OFFER
BUSINESS
INDIRECT
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
34
Identification of three distribution strategies to go beyond the most
rewarding traditional model
Financial Advisor for Taking care of the customer’s HSBC Premier
Mass Affluent Customer financial life as a financial advisor
BETTER SELL
Specialised service provider to a USAA
Community Bank specific community
The most economic without Société Générale
Discount Bank minimising security or quality Boursorama
LARGER
OFFER
One-stop shopping for Deutsche Bank
Trust Operator customers, including all kinds
Q110 branches
of personal or family services
BUSINESS
INDIRECT
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
35
Identification of three distribution strategies to go beyond the most
rewarding traditional model
Financial Advisor for Taking care of the customer’s HSBC Premier
Mass Affluent Customer financial life as a financial advisor
BETTER SELL
Specialised service provider to a USAA
Community Bank specific community
The most economic without Société Générale
Discount Bank minimising security or quality Boursorama
LARGER
OFFER
One-stop shopping for Deutsche Bank
Trust Operator customers, including all kinds
Q110 branches
of personal or family services
Easy access and time saving
BUSINESS
of highly automated operations
INDIRECT
Open Source Bank through the Internet,
Zopa
The best products on the market,
General Broker and independent advisory Virgin Money
Services to fit clients’ needs
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
36
Banker rated models according to their perceived likeliness and impact
Most likely to appear Most impacting
before 2010 for the retail banking industry
Trust Discount
Operator Bank Open
Discount
General Bank General Source
Broker 1 Broker 1
2 2
3 3
The future will be likely a combination of several models
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
37
The next challenge for retail bankers: re-assembling the building blocks
to support a new retail banking business model of their own
Lar
g er O
New s
nship rif ffer
Relatio ta
e
Model t iv
olu
Ev ne
l
Low an n
C
Stru osts ich o
ctur ult grati
M te
e Flexi In
Prod ble
uctio
n
New Branc New Banking
Innov ds h
ation ran gy
B te Model
a
Str
ic
lt u r e We om l
Job Cu b2 on e
SO .0 et Ec Mod
A
Clients &
Co
communitie mp
s ete
nc
ies
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
38
World Retail Banking Report – Spotlight Key Messages Summarized
Leading banks have well performed on their retail domestic operations over the last 5 years, steadily
growing their revenue faster than their costs
Four pillars have supported their efforts to achieve profitable organic growth in their domestic markets
1. Combining fast time to market, innovation, and local client intimacy
2. Full multi-channel integration and optimisation
3. Increasing sales productivity through dynamic branch management
4. Leveraging a multi-brand portfolio to create attractive value propositions for each market segment.
Most banks however rely on these pillars to support very similar strategies: namely to build trust
relationship with their clients in order to sell them a large number of financial products.
We believe that tougher regulations, more flexible technology, more demanding clients and new
competitors will radically change retail banking
We simulated the effect of these structural changes on retail banking in 8 major European markets
Banks could lose 36% of their projected net income (and more than 50% in certain markets) within 10
years
To cope with this new environment, successful banks can use three distribution strategies to grow
beyond the traditional retail banking business models
“Better sell”, to better fit diverse clients’ needs
“Larger offer”, extending the offering to non-financial products and services
“Indirect business”, selling through other distributors
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
39
Agenda
Presentation of the World Retail Banking Report
Pricing Indexes – Key Findings
Organic Growth in Domestic Markets – Key Findings
Questions & Answers
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
40
Agenda
Presentation of the World Retail Banking Report
Pricing Indexes – Key Findings
Organic Growth in Domestic Markets – Key Findings
Questions & Answers
WRBR08_ CONVENTION_EFMA_ENGLISH
41
0 comments
Post a comment