ICAWC 2013 - Improving Dog Welfare Within a Difficult Community & How to Bring Municiplities Along With You - Urska Markelj

Uploaded on

ICAWC 2013 - Urska Markelj's presentation on Improving Dog Welfare Within a Difficult Community & How to Bring Municiplities Along With You

ICAWC 2013 - Urska Markelj's presentation on Improving Dog Welfare Within a Difficult Community & How to Bring Municiplities Along With You

More in: Lifestyle , Education
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads


Total Views
On Slideshare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds



Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

    No notes for slide


  • 1. Improving Dog Welfare Within a Difficult And Marginalised Community & How to Bring Municipalities Along With You Roma Settlements Urska Markelj SPA Pomurje
  • 2. Short presentation of Pomurje Society •Small NGO in NE Slovenia with a large Roma community in area (28 settlements) •Working WITH, not against Roma community with the help of DogsTrust
  • 3. Roma Settlements • History And Marginalisation: – Moved onto private land, built illegal settlements – Never tried to “fit in”, including no real respect for law; “ghetto” situation – Large cultural, linguistic differences from local residents • Different situations in different settlements, but all problematic.
  • 4. Roma Settlements – present day • Illegally built settlements, poverty, unemployment, poor education • Residents weary of any “outsiders”, often quite aggressive Photo: Jure Erzen
  • 5. Roma Settlements – present day • Linguistic differences (some unable to speak Slovene) • Very marginalised community, issues between Roma community, the rest of Pomurje residents and officials persist
  • 6. SPA Pomurje in Roma Settlements How it all started: • We received a report of neglected dog in Roma setlement • Found that ALL dogs lived in deplorable conditions • Veterinary service refused to enter the setlement; too dangerous • From first settlement followed the trail of puppies
  • 7. SPA Pomurje in Roma Settlements At the beginning • Mistrust (Settlements often avoided even by police and veterinary services), fear • Aggression (members threathened by axes, fireams, …)
  • 8. Work With Dogs in Settlements Beginning Settlements overwhelmed with intact dogs Example: Dobrovnik settlement (smallest): 3 houses, 18 dogs. (Today there are 3 spayed / neutered dogs) Brina
  • 9. Work With Dogs in Settlements Beginning • Puppies were given and traded amongst settlements and families Enja
  • 10. Work With Dogs in Settlements Beginning • Adult dogs in deplorable conditions
  • 11. Work With Dogs in Settlements Beginning • No support from authorities • If dogs would get culled (illegal today) or confiscated, new dogs would replace them in within days - no emotional attachments to animals; • If there was attachment, dogs would get hidden from authorities The situation called for a different approach Don
  • 12. Work Principles • Work with, not against residents, basically work with people • Going for the root cause • Treating residents with respect, without prejudice; try to see it from their perspective
  • 13. Work Principles • Following approach: “Not re-homing an animal, but changing its home – where applicable” • Essentially changing families.
  • 14. Work Principles • Gaining trust !!! Takes years! (many very sweet turkish coffees  ) • Individual approach for every family, according to their “weak spot”
  • 15. Work Principles • Making them accept their dogs in another, better way / raising the value of the dog • Grooming:
  • 16. Work Principles • Making them accept their dogs in another, better way / raising the value of the dog • Training
  • 17. Work Principles • Walks – strenthening of connection with dogs, dogs can be fun; walking clubs
  • 18. Work Principles • Presenting advantages of neutering – good for them • Fostering schemes • Enforcement only with very bad cases or when the majority of community have accepted the value of their dogs • Gathering donated leashes, collars, brushes, etc
  • 19. Work Principles • Children education (reaching parents through them )
  • 20. Work Principles • SPA P. never pays for microchipping and vaccination to make them understand the responsibility and costs involved with owning an animal • Kids have to do homework for collars and leashes if they have lost (traded) them – train the dog (video)
  • 21. • “Homework” video • http://youtu.be/Kwn9XHAjjyA • 16.7.2013 Domača naloga.MOV
  • 22. Some stats • Owerall about 70% of dogs spayed / neutered • There are several settlements that haven’t had any litter in last 3 years • There are few settlements (probably the first  ) that have ALL dogs microchipped, vaccinated and spayed / neutered (even we never dared hope for this)
  • 23. Municipalities • Based on results, SPA Pomurje started approaching municipalities (27 in the region), police and veterinary services First reaction: “One cannot work within Roma settlements” The authorities were VERY surprised something could actually be done
  • 24. Municipalities • Most were very hard to reach in the beginning • Approached already with results (gaining their attention by success) • Principle of approach: long-term lowering of municipal costs by prevention – municipalities are saving money by donating it to SPA Pomurje; making them understand the importance of prevention
  • 25. Municipalities • Often municipalities used argument that there is not even enough resources for “poor” people, definitely not for animals. – Lower costs due to prevention = more resources for people (municipalities are small). • Now some mayors have already gotten involved, visited settlements together with vet to explain the importance of microchipping and regular vaccination (an infected dog would endanger Roma children) • SPA Pomurje is using more succesfull municipalities as example in negotiations with other municipalities
  • 26. Municipalities • Few numbers – I.e. entire Pomurje region in 2010: 150.000€ of shelter costs; municipalities didn’t know precisely what are they paying for – 2012: 100.000€ – Costs are progressively lowering
  • 27. Municipalities – successes • Financial support (limited; poor small municipalities) Črenšovci municipality: “Tightening of belt – Budget adopted – The only approach is saving – 1.000€ for SPA of Pomurje” “with their activities they spared another 6.000€ of municipal money, as the Crensovci municipality’s shelter costs have lowered significantly”
  • 28. Municipalities – successes • Publishing of information in municipal publications • Donated offices for SPA of Pomurje (huge!  )
  • 29. Municipalities – successes • Co-financing of 3 staff • Presence of mayors in Roma settlements • Cooperation of municipal representatives in adopting new legislation • Cooperation between municipalities and other authorities (veterinary, police, …)
  • 30. Additional • Cooperation with the police • Cooperation with Veterinary service • “Radio Romic”
  • 31. Case Studies Kamenci settlement • Red dots: unspayed females 2009 • Pink dots: spayed females 2013
  • 32. Case Studies Suza
  • 33. Case Studies Suza • Owner calls us every day to report how Suza is, paid vet costs for his sister’s dog, …
  • 34. Case Studies “Sharpei” family • Owner’s plan: breeding and selling (monetary gain) • Loads of persuation + PATIENCE: Puppies rehomed (for free); 2 (now) spayed “Sharpei” remained with the family
  • 35. Case Studies Aika
  • 36. Case Studies Brina
  • 37. Case Studies Omica
  • 38. Case Studies Pika
  • 39. Thank you for attention Thank You, DogsTrust!