Nurturing a Professional Development Ecosystem Julia Parra Holly Rae Bemis-Schurtz Susan D. Ceppi-Bussmann New Mexico State University RETA (Regional Educational Technology Assistance) Program Illustration by Sabine Deviche (ASU) http://askabiologist.asu.edu/research/ecosystems/index.html

Agenda Emerging Web 2.0 Toolset The Ecosystem as Model Nurturing a PD Ecosystem Assessing a PD Ecosystem Q & A

Emerging Web 2.0 Toolset

The Ecosystem as Model

Nurturing a PD Ecosystem

Assessing a PD Ecosystem

Q & A

Web 2.0 Tools Scoble’s Social Media Starfish http://www.flickr.com/photos/dbarefoot/1814873464/ Social Media Landscape http://www.fredcavazza.net/2008/06/09/social-media-landscape/ The Conversation Prism http://www.briansolis.com/2008/08/introducing-conversation-prism.html

Can’t see the forest for the trees… Retrieved on October 23, 2008 from http://travel.paintedstork.com/blog/2005/12/hiking-up-brahmagiri.html

Collaboration & Interaction Tools Content Creation & Dissemination Tools Learning & Content Management Tools Learning/Course Management System Webconferencing System VOIP Instant Messaging Tool Robust Wiki Blogs Micromedia Robust Wikis Voice Discussion Tools Multimedia Creation Tools Social Bookmarking Tools Content Sharing Tools Custom Search Tools Lifestreaming Tools Analytic Tools RSS Feed Aggregators Social Networks eLearning Ecosystem Tools

Learning/Course Management System

Webconferencing System

VOIP Instant Messaging Tool

Robust Wiki

Blogs

Micromedia

Robust Wikis

Voice Discussion Tools

Multimedia Creation Tools

Social Bookmarking Tools

Content Sharing Tools

Custom Search Tools

Lifestreaming Tools

Analytic Tools

RSS Feed Aggregators

Social Networks

Current Events & Trends Widgets & RSS Facilitation and Assessment Recomposers Producers Primary Consumers Ambient Consumers The Internet

Learner Responsibility Learner as Recomposer Learner as Producer Learner as Connector Learner as Lurker Relationship to Requirements

Learner Responsibility Learning & Content Management Tools Learner as Recomposer Learner as Producer Learner as Connector Learner as Lurker

Collaboration and Interaction Tools Learner as Recomposer Learner as Producer Learner as Connector Learner as Lurker

Content Creation and Dissemination Tools Learner as Recomposer Learner as Producer Learner as Connector Learner as Lurker

Learnstreaming Tools Learner as Recomposer Learner as Producer Learner as Connector Learner as Lurker

Learner Activity Touch Points Method Examples Nurturing Concepts Learner Assessment Lurking Browsing/Surfing Reading Socializing Custom Search Engines Shared RSS Feeds Social Networks Blogs Wikis Integrate presence of learning community in places where learners already spend their time. Provide places on web that are course related but not main course. Provide a community blog &/or wiki Add RSS feeds to course, blog, wiki Use of Group feature in popular social networks (Facebook, MySpace) Customized iGoogle Gadgets Post fun multimedia (Voki, Viddler, Animoto, Moblyng) Increasing Social Presence & Identity Utilizing Shared Resources & Knowledge Usually optional, not graded, not mandatory, low-risk participation. Difficult to assess individually, but visible as a group with site analysis tools like Lijit Sharing Reflecting Voting Social Bookmarking Lifestreaming Micromedia Tumbleblogs Polling and Surveying Tools Avatar Generators Facilitate ways for learners to share updates on what they are doing, seeing, reading, and thinking about. Status updating & microblogging Course tag on Delicious Use of simple poll widgets Avatar creation Increasing Communication & Interaction Increasing Social Presence & Identity Utilizing Shared Resources Usually optional, not graded, not mandatory, still pretty low-risk Poll/survey analysis Twitter Search Writing Editing Conferencing Blogs Wikis Instant Messaging Voice Conferencing Audio/Video sites Facilitate ways for learners to engage in conversations about what they are learning outside of the “classroom.” Communicate with them from outside the “classroom.” Shared resources and best practices on a PBWiki Learners meet on Skype to discuss projects and or assist peers Blogging (individually or communally) Instructor/Mentor meets individually with learners in Skype Instructor/Mentor sends Viddler messages to group Broadcasting events with Ustream Increasing Communication & Interaction Increasing Social Presence & Identity Utilizing & Contributing to Shared Resources & Knowledge at global level Learning about Knowledge Management Engaging in Collaborative Learning and Contribution Type of investment and “risk” starts to increase. Complexity, collaboration, Grading, mandatory, payment, artifacts, rubrics Peer assessment, mentor assessment Course Reqs Webconferencing Quizzes, Exams, Assessments Discussions Portfolios Building Models Course/Learning Magagement System Webconferencing System Blogs Wiki Provide an instructionally sound online learning environment. Provide activities and explorations for your learners to practice skills and demonstrate mastery of concepts Novice, intermediate and advanced levels of PD courses available Office hours facilitated by LMS chat tool Advanced use of discussion (debate, role-play, Voicethread, etc.) Learners attend/present at Webconferencing events Students create a blog, wiki, video, podcast, etc. Membership, Policies & Guidelines Communication & Interaction Individual & Shared Goals Social Presence & Identity Utilizing & Contributing to Shared Resources & Knowledge at class level Collaboration & Contribution These are highest risk methods. Grades, payment are at risk. Based on established criteria, rubrics, etc. Includes interventions and alternative paths

Lurking

Browsing/Surfing

Reading

Socializing

Custom Search Engines

Shared RSS Feeds

Social Networks

Blogs

Wikis

Integrate presence of learning community in places where learners already spend their time.

Provide places on web that are course related but not main course.

Provide a community blog &/or wiki

Add RSS feeds to course, blog, wiki

Use of Group feature in popular social networks (Facebook, MySpace)

Customized iGoogle Gadgets

Post fun multimedia (Voki, Viddler, Animoto, Moblyng)

Increasing Social Presence & Identity

Utilizing Shared Resources & Knowledge

Usually optional, not graded, not mandatory, low-risk participation.

Difficult to assess individually, but visible as a group with site analysis tools like Lijit

Sharing

Reflecting

Voting

Social Bookmarking

Lifestreaming

Micromedia

Tumbleblogs

Polling and Surveying Tools

Avatar Generators

Facilitate ways for learners to share updates on what they are doing, seeing, reading, and thinking about.

Status updating & microblogging

Course tag on Delicious

Use of simple poll widgets

Avatar creation

Increasing Communication & Interaction

Increasing Social Presence & Identity

Utilizing Shared Resources

Usually optional, not graded, not mandatory, still pretty low-risk

Poll/survey analysis

Twitter Search

Writing

Editing

Conferencing

Blogs

Wikis

Instant Messaging

Voice Conferencing

Audio/Video sites

Facilitate ways for learners to engage in conversations about what they are learning outside of the “classroom.”

Communicate with them from outside the “classroom.”

Shared resources and best practices on a PBWiki

Learners meet on Skype to discuss projects and or assist peers

Blogging (individually or communally)

Instructor/Mentor meets individually with learners in Skype

Instructor/Mentor sends Viddler messages to group

Broadcasting events with Ustream

Increasing Communication & Interaction

Increasing Social Presence & Identity

Utilizing & Contributing to Shared Resources & Knowledge at global level

Learning about Knowledge Management

Engaging in Collaborative Learning and Contribution

Type of investment and “risk” starts to increase. Complexity, collaboration,

Grading, mandatory, payment,

artifacts, rubrics

Peer assessment, mentor assessment

Course Reqs

Webconferencing

Quizzes, Exams, Assessments

Discussions

Portfolios

Building Models

Course/Learning Magagement System

Webconferencing System

Blogs

Wiki

Provide an instructionally sound online learning environment.

Provide activities and explorations for your learners to practice skills and demonstrate mastery of concepts

Novice, intermediate and advanced levels of PD courses available

Office hours facilitated by LMS chat tool

Advanced use of discussion (debate, role-play, Voicethread, etc.)

Learners attend/present at Webconferencing events

Students create a blog, wiki, video, podcast, etc.

Membership, Policies & Guidelines

Communication & Interaction

Individual & Shared Goals

Social Presence & Identity

Utilizing & Contributing to Shared Resources & Knowledge at class level

Collaboration & Contribution

These are highest risk methods. Grades, payment are at risk.

Based on established criteria, rubrics, etc.

Includes interventions and alternative paths

Evaluating the Ecosystem “ Traditional Methods” + Emerging Methods

“ Traditional Methods” + Emerging Methods

Evaluating the Ecosystem http://reta.nmsu.edu and http://reta-otl.pbwiki.com *tried and true **in practice ***completely experimental Method Measuring Example Tool Face to Face Evaluations* Satisfaction Comfort Level Areas for improvement Post Workshop Survey Consensogram Plus / Delta Survey Monkey Moodle Choice Chart Paper Program Evaluation* Change in self assessment on skills based on program goals Relevance of content and activities Accessibility and effectiveness of instructors/mentors Pre and Post Program Surveys Formative and Summative Course Evaluation Informal Course Feedback Survey Monkey Discussion Forum Webconferences Product Assessment** Quality as related to national and/or state standards Demonstration of skills based on program goals Rubrics Peer Reviews Skill Inventories Self Assessment of Practice Webconferences Wiki Survey Monkey Web Analytics** Activity of lurkers in the ecosystem Participation in course activities Number of visits Use of existing content Types of keywords queried Google Analytics Lijit Moodle (LCMS) Tracking Logs Customized Search Tools Lifestreaming & Social Networking*** Health of ‘whole learner’ Connections between learners Activity within the Web-2.0-isphere Awareness of learner stress, overload, burnout Stream of a learner’s updates, Bookmarks, Microblogs, Blogs, etc. Plaxo FriendFeed Linked In Facebook Data Mining*** Occurrences of individualized assistance Types of support offered Project tracking by tag or keyword Organizational email accounts copied on all correspondence from staff Learner or project profiles with a history of all updates related to project Gmail Highrise HQ Yammer

Satisfaction

Comfort Level

Areas for improvement

Post Workshop Survey

Consensogram

Plus / Delta

Survey Monkey

Moodle Choice

Chart Paper

Change in self assessment on skills based on program goals

Relevance of content and activities

Accessibility and effectiveness of instructors/mentors

Pre and Post Program Surveys

Formative and Summative Course Evaluation

Informal Course Feedback

Survey Monkey

Discussion Forum

Webconferences

Quality as related to national and/or state standards

Demonstration of skills based on program goals

Rubrics

Peer Reviews

Skill Inventories

Self Assessment of Practice

Webconferences

Wiki

Survey Monkey

Activity of lurkers in the ecosystem

Participation in course activities

Number of visits

Use of existing content

Types of keywords queried

Google Analytics

Lijit

Moodle (LCMS) Tracking Logs

Customized Search Tools

Health of ‘whole learner’

Connections between learners

Activity within the Web-2.0-isphere

Awareness of learner stress, overload, burnout

Stream of a learner’s updates, Bookmarks, Microblogs, Blogs, etc.

Plaxo

FriendFeed

Linked In

Facebook

Occurrences of individualized assistance

Types of support offered

Project tracking by tag or keyword

Organizational email accounts copied on all correspondence from staff

Learner or project profiles with a history of all updates related to project

Gmail

Highrise HQ

Yammer

Questions and Answers What are you doing to… Explore learning ecosystems? Explain them to your learners? Model practices involved in teaching and assessing across an ecosystem? Nurture healthy learning ecosystems?

What are you doing to…

Explore learning ecosystems?

Explain them to your learners?

Model practices involved in teaching and assessing across an ecosystem?

Nurture healthy learning ecosystems?

Related Resources http://reta-otl.pbwiki.com http://vss2008.wikispaces.com/nurturing http://reta.nmsu.edu http://webinars.nmsu.edu

Scoble’s Social Media Starfish http://www.flickr.com/photos/dbarefoot/1814873464/ Social Media Landscape http://www.fredcavazza.net/2008/06/09/social-media-landscape/

The Conversation Prism http://www.briansolis.com/2008/08/introducing-conversation-prism.html