At the end of November in 2013, Virginia State Senator Creigh Deeds told CNN that he was alive for just one reason: to work for change in mental health. After tragic events like the death of Deeds' son Guss, we wring our hands and assume nothing can be done. Utilizing technology and the lessons of air traffic control can help drive innovative solutions to improve both the effectiveness and safety of crisis systems.
Call Girls Service in Bommanahalli - 7001305949 with real photos and phone nu...
What Crisis Should Learn From Air Traffic Control
1. DAVID COVINGTON, LPC, MBA
How to Avoid Tragedies
and Near Misses
DAVID COVINGTON, LPC, MBA—
RECOVERY INNOVATIONS, INC.
http://davidwcovington.com
2. EXCELLENCE IN HEALTH INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Supported by Qualifacts, Inc.
Behavioral Health Link
Atlanta, GA
3. Wide Cracks in the Safety Net
At the end of November following the suicide of his
son “Guss,” Virginia Senator Creigh Deeds told CNN
that he was alive for a reason and that he would
work for change in mental health.
4. Polling Question #1
Virginia Tech, Columbine, Tucson, Aurora,
Newtown… We should do the following:
A. Double Mental Health System Capacity
B. Ban Assault Rifles Immediately
C. Dramatically Expand MH First Aid
D. Create Robust, Integrated Crisis Systems
E. All of the Above
F. None of the Above, as Tragedies Are
Unavoidable
6. If US airports
settled for a
99.9% success
rate for
commercial
flights, there
would be 300
unsafe take-offs
and/or landings…
per day!
7. Keeping Individuals from
Falling through the Cracks
Individuals walk out of an Emergency Department
“Against Medical Advice,” for example, and crisis
services shift their focus away to others.
9. A Safety Net Requires
Accountability
Every time there is a Columbine, Tucson or Sandy Hook,
we grieve… and we wring our hands and consider
whether there is a better way. It is time to raise the bar
and innovate with solutions that will drive a different
set of results.
10. Learning from Air Traffic
Control Safety
“Flight 93” chronicled the heroic passengers of a
hijacked plane. It also gave an up close view of the
way air traffic control works to ensure the safety of
nearly 30,000 commercial flights… per day!
11. Two Key Principles of Safety
Goal #1: always
know where the
aircraft is and
never lose
contact;
Goal #2; verify the
hand-off has
occurred and the
airplane is safely
in the hands of
another.
12. Without Air Traffic Control
Principles
Referrals are shotgun faxed to multiple facilities at once,
bogging down w/ paperwork when most will not admit
The first facility giving acceptance is where the individual
goes without regard to how far away from family supports
No accountability - no way to know if someone is stuck in
an ED unless the staff make noise (squeakiest gets grease)
No one knows how many are being sent home w/o care
Receiving facility staff may sift through all referrals, and
pick out the ones that will be easier in the milieu
13. Without Air Traffic Control
Principles (Continued)
Almost all individuals are sent to the ED for medical
clearance, even if not indicated. No accountability for
using the ED as a holding cell
Communication depends on numerous phone calls, faxes.
ED staff and crisis facility staff make and field numerous
phone calls about each case. If nurses at either facility are
busy, the other must wait for call backs. No time frames
are set for receiving facilities to give referral decisions
There is no transparency around the census for inpatient
Costly, invasive and time consuming medical tests are
often required unnecessarily
15. Modifying the Milbank Continuum
for Crisis Coordination
“Flight 93” chronicled the heroic passengers of a
hijacked plane. It also gave an up close view of the
way air traffic control works to ensure the safety of
nearly 30,000 commercial flights… per day!
Crisis Access, LLC has modified the Milbank
collaboration continuum (original citation Doherty,
1995) for the purposes of evaluating crisis system
community coordination and collaboration (see
table above).
16. A Level 5 Crisis System: Close
& Fully Integrated
In our model, the highest level requires shared
protocols for coordination and care management
that are “baked into” electronic processes, not
simply add-ons.
17. Polling Question #3
Which of the following elements are
required in a Level 5 Crisis System (select all
that apply):
A. Intensive Referral Tracking
B. 24/7 Scheduling
C. Crisis Bed Inventory Tools
D. High-tech Mobile Crisis Dispatch
E. Real-time Online Outcomes Dashboards
18. The Five Components of a
Level 5 Crisis System
For a crisis service system to provide Level 5 “Close
and Fully Integrated” care, it must implement an
integrated suite of software applications that
employ online, real-time, and 24/7:
Status
Disposition
for
Intensive
Referrals
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Shared Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
GPS-
enabled
Mobile
Crisis
Dispatch
Real-time
Perform-
ance
Outcomes
Dashboards
19. Polling Question #4
Without community based mobile crisis
services law enforcement and ERs will
hospitalize individuals:
A. The Same Amount as if Those Services
Were Available
B. Less Likely to Hospitalize
C. 2x More Likely
D. 3x More Likely
22. #1 – Intensive Referral Tracking
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
23. #2 – 24/7 Scheduling
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
24. #3 – Bed Inventory Census
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
25. #4 – High Tech Mobile Dispatch
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
26. #5 – Outcomes Dashboards
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
27. #1 – Intensive Referral Tracking
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
28. #2 – 24/7 Scheduling
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
29. #3 – Bed Inventory Census
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
30. #4 – High Tech Mobile Dispatch
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
31. #5 – Outcomes Dashboards
Level 5
Crisis
Intensive
Referral
Status
24/7
Outpatient
Scheduling
Bed
Inventory
Tracking
High-tech,
Mobile
Dispatch
Outcomes
Dashboards
32. Polling Question #5
What are the benefits of a Level 5 Crisis
System (select all that apply):
A. Reduce Burden on ERs/Law Enforcement
B. Actionable Intelligence for Funders
C. Improve Transparency/Efficiency of
Referral Process
D. Reduce Unnecessary Phone Calls, Faxes
E. Informed Clinical Decision-making
33. Contact Us
CEO & President
David.Covington@recoveryinnovations.org
Social Networking
http://davidwcovington.com
http://davidwcovington.com
Editor's Notes
Just a week earlier, his son “Guss” stabbed him 10 times and then ended his own life by suicide, an event that occurred the day following a mental health evaluation determined Guss needed more intensive services.
The answer is E, all of the above. Mental health advocates have called for the first three (see Ron Manderscheid’s letter, for example). F is the wrong answer. Handwringing will no longer cut it. We must create robust, integrated crisis systems, and policy makers are requiring and funding it in increasing numbers.
http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/01/07/newtown-shooting-mental-health-reform/1781145/
Mental health and crisis intervention services feel an obligation to keep pressing forward, with great need in front of them, and a feeling they have neither the time nor resources to look back.
The success of aviation safety is just not complicated.
Often it takes several hours to get a denial even if the facility does not have any beds available- unnecessarily prolonging a referral
The answer is D, 3x more likely. Scott (2000) and Hugo et al (2002) alongside data from the BHL Georgia Crisis & Access Line and mobile crisis response services suggest that diversion is 25% away from intrusive and costly higher end services without mobile crisis response, and 75% and higher with those services in place.