What’s our stack:
process, technology, community
and ideas for the future of
ATIP
Data
&
Software

Government
&
Public Policy

Negotiation
&
Strategy
8
key points
1. new expectations
2. ATIP is technology dependent
3. stack = process
4. ideas
<1>
New Expectations
30 milliseconds
30 milliseconds
vs.
4 months
"The Net interprets
censorship as
damage and routes
around it."
“Citizens interprets
delay as damage..."
is ATIP the
solution, or the
problem?
<2>
ATIP is
technology
dependent
history
17
66
Sw
ed
en
19

66

66

17

-

-

Un

en

ed

ed

it

Sw

St
at
es
74

70

66

66

-

-

-

-

Un

No

ed

en

ay

it

ed

rw

Un

Sw

St
at
es

it
19
ed
77
St
19
at
Me
78
es
xi
(P
Fr co
ri...
74

70

66

66

-

-

-

-

Un

No

ed

en

ay

it

ed

rw

Un

Sw

St
at
es

it
19
ed
77
St
19
at
Me
78
es
xi
(P
Fr co
ri...
74

70

66

66

-

-

-

-

Un

No

ed

en

ay

it

ed

rw

Un

Sw

St
at
es

it
19
ed
77
St
19
at
Me
78
es
xi
(P
Fr co
ri...
why?
19
66
Un
it
ed
St
at
es
74

70

66

-

-

-

Un

No

ed

ay

it

rw

Un
St
at
es

it
19
ed
77
St
19
at
Me
78
es
xi
(P
Fr co
ri
an
19
va
ce
80
cy
A...
progressive coalitions
political/trust crisis
best practice
1960 Xerox 914 copier

74

70

66

-

-

-

US

No

ed

ay

it

rw

Un
St

at

es

(P
19
ri
77
va
cy
19
Me
78
Am
xi
en
dm
...
1968 -

1960 $1B in sales

*50-59 revenue = $12M

Xerox 914 copier

74

70

66

-

-

-

US

No

ed

ay

it

rw

Un
St

at...
1970 - $1.6B in sales
1969 - largest 100 companies
1968 - $1B in sales

1960 Xerox 914 copier

74

70

66

-

-

-

US

No...
1980 - $8B in sales ~60% market share

1970 - $1.6B in sales
1969 - largest 100 companies
1968 - $1B in sales

1960 Xerox ...
ATIP
is predicated
on the existence
of copiers
why it matters
<3>
technology
shapes
process
values driven
technology agnostic
values driven
technology agnostic
ATIP/FOIA
built on a set of
assumptions
ATIP/FOIA
built on a
stack
technology stack
commissioners
live
in a world of
process
ATIP PROCESS

DISTRIBUTION
POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT
INVESTIGATIONS

BLACK BOX
ATIP PROCESS

DISTRIBUTION
POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT
INVESTIGATIONS

BLACK BOX
software
software is process
control the
software
control the
process
influence the
software
influence the
process
ATIP PROCESS

DISTRIBUTION
POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT
INVESTIGATIONS

BLACK BOX

PROCUREMENT

Rules,
Processes
&
Cultur...
sometimes
comment
on this
ATIP PROCESS

report about
this
DISTRIBUTION
POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT
INVESTIGATIONS

BLACK...
auditing
books
to
spreadsheets
to
systems
auditing
books
to
spreadsheets
to
systems
auditing
books
to
spreadsheets
to
systems
<4>
ideas
1. help define
standards for
procurement
ATIP PROCESS

DISTRIBUTION
POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT
INVESTIGATIONS

BLACK BOX

PROCUREMENT

Rules,
Processes
&
Cultur...
understand our
assumptions
act
policies
standards
open data as
pre-approved
systems
why not for some
document creation
processes?
why not for some
document creation
processes?
procurement
buyandsell.gc.ca
2. Create your open
data on response
times
build power
64
3. open data
assess openness of
data
especially
regulatory data
Wonderful Case Study
•
•
•

2006-2012 spills
$4000
eventually 711 pages of
printed records ($262)
• months to convert
• ru...
3. there is an
opportunity for a
broader tent
not just government
not just reporters
hello!:
programmers/
developers
archivists
librarians
bloggers
CIOs
technologists
access

gov20
access

gov20

accountability

leverage
find common
interests
speed
reliability
persistence
accountability
leverage
accessibility
We need a new act
- eliminates the joke of access
summaries
-respects today’s expectations
of access
- compels government to rethink
how it ...
@daeaves
david@eaves.ca
www.eaves.ca

This work is copyrighted using Creative Commons
Attribution 2.5
You may share and re...
ATIP PROCESS

DISTRIBUTION
POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT

STORAGE/ARCHIVE

ARCHIVES
HARD DRIVES
EMAIL

INTERNAL USAGE

DOC...
ATIP PROCESS

STORAGE/ARCHIVE

INTERNAL USAGE

DOCUMENT CREATION

PROCUREMENT
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI

10,533 views
10,455 views

Published on

David Eaves Keynote from the Access & Privacy 2020 Conference in Vancouver, BC, October 2013

In this talk David talks about how technology has driven Right to Information movements in the past and how Open Government, Gov20 and others advocates should use apply those lesson to advocate for changes in the future.

Published in: Technology, Business
0 Comments
3 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total views
10,533
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
7,918
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
15
Comments
0
Likes
3
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of RTI

  1. 1. What’s our stack: process, technology, community and ideas for the future of ATIP
  2. 2. Data & Software Government & Public Policy Negotiation & Strategy
  3. 3. 8
  4. 4. key points 1. new expectations 2. ATIP is technology dependent 3. stack = process 4. ideas
  5. 5. <1> New Expectations
  6. 6. 30 milliseconds
  7. 7. 30 milliseconds vs. 4 months
  8. 8. "The Net interprets censorship as damage and routes around it."
  9. 9. “Citizens interprets delay as damage..."
  10. 10. is ATIP the solution, or the problem?
  11. 11. <2> ATIP is technology dependent
  12. 12. history
  13. 13. 17 66 Sw ed en
  14. 14. 19 66 66 17 - - Un en ed ed it Sw St at es
  15. 15. 74 70 66 66 - - - - Un No ed en ay it ed rw Un Sw St at es it 19 ed 77 St 19 at Me 78 es xi (P Fr co ri an va ce cy 19 19 19 17 Am en dm en ts )
  16. 16. 74 70 66 66 - - - - Un No ed en ay it ed rw Un Sw St at es it 19 ed 77 St 19 at Me 78 es xi (P Fr co ri an 19 va ce 80 cy Am Ne en th dm 19 er en 82 la ts nd ) s Ca na da , 19 Ne 85 w Ze De al nm an ar d k & Au st ra li a 19 19 19 17
  17. 17. 74 70 66 66 - - - - Un No ed en ay it ed rw Un Sw St at es it 19 ed 77 St 19 at Me 78 es xi (P Fr co ri an 19 va ce 80 cy Am Ne en th dm 19 er en 82 la ts nd ) s Ca na da , 19 Ne 85 w Ze De al 19 nm an 91 ar d k & 19 Au 93 Br st az ra il Be 19 li lg 98 a iu 19 m 98 Ir e So land 20 ut 00 h Ko re Un a it & ed Be Ki li ng ze do m 19 19 19 17
  18. 18. why?
  19. 19. 19 66 Un it ed St at es
  20. 20. 74 70 66 - - - Un No ed ay it rw Un St at es it 19 ed 77 St 19 at Me 78 es xi (P Fr co ri an 19 va ce 80 cy Am Ne en th dm 19 er en 82 la ts nd ) s Ca na da , 19 Ne 85 w Ze De al 19 nm an 91 ar d k & 19 Au 93 Br st az ra il Be 19 li lg 98 a iu 19 m 98 Ir e So land 20 ut 00 h Ko re Un a it & ed Be Ki li ng ze do m 19 19 19
  21. 21. progressive coalitions political/trust crisis best practice
  22. 22. 1960 Xerox 914 copier 74 70 66 - - - US No ed ay it rw Un St at es (P 19 ri 77 va cy 19 Me 78 Am xi en dm Fr co en an 19 ts ce 80 ) Ne th 19 er 82 la nd s Ca na da , 19 NZ 85 & Au De st 19 nm ra 91 ar li k 19 a 93 Br az Be il 19 lg 98 iu 19 m 98 - Ir e So land 20 ut 00 h Ko re Un a it & ed Be Ki li ng ze do m 19 19 19
  23. 23. 1968 - 1960 $1B in sales *50-59 revenue = $12M Xerox 914 copier 74 70 66 - - - US No ed ay it rw Un St at es (P 19 ri 77 va cy 19 Me 78 Am xi en dm Fr co en an 19 ts ce 80 ) Ne th 19 er 82 la nd s Ca na da , 19 NZ 85 & Au De st 19 nm ra 91 ar li k 19 a 93 Br az Be il 19 lg 98 iu 19 m 98 - Ir e So land 20 ut 00 h Ko re Un a it & ed Be Ki li ng ze do m 19 19 19
  24. 24. 1970 - $1.6B in sales 1969 - largest 100 companies 1968 - $1B in sales 1960 Xerox 914 copier 74 70 66 - - - US No ed ay it rw Un St at es (P 19 ri 77 va cy 19 Me 78 Am xi en dm Fr co en an 19 ts ce 80 ) Ne th 19 er 82 la nd s Ca na da , 19 NZ 85 & Au De st 19 nm ra 91 ar li k 19 a 93 Br az Be il 19 lg 98 iu 19 m 98 - Ir e So land 20 ut 00 h Ko re Un a it & ed Be Ki li ng ze do m 19 19 19
  25. 25. 1980 - $8B in sales ~60% market share 1970 - $1.6B in sales 1969 - largest 100 companies 1968 - $1B in sales 1960 Xerox 914 copier 74 70 66 - - - US No ed ay it rw Un St at es (P 19 ri 77 va cy 19 Me 78 Am xi en dm Fr co en an 19 ts ce 80 ) Ne th 19 er 82 la nd s Ca na da , 19 NZ 85 & Au De st 19 nm ra 91 ar li k 19 a 93 Br az Be il 19 lg 98 iu 19 m 98 - Ir e So land 20 ut 00 h Ko re Un a it & ed Be Ki li ng ze do m 19 19 19
  26. 26. ATIP is predicated on the existence of copiers
  27. 27. why it matters
  28. 28. <3> technology shapes process
  29. 29. values driven technology agnostic
  30. 30. values driven technology agnostic
  31. 31. ATIP/FOIA built on a set of assumptions
  32. 32. ATIP/FOIA built on a stack
  33. 33. technology stack
  34. 34. commissioners live in a world of process
  35. 35. ATIP PROCESS DISTRIBUTION POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT INVESTIGATIONS BLACK BOX
  36. 36. ATIP PROCESS DISTRIBUTION POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT INVESTIGATIONS BLACK BOX
  37. 37. software
  38. 38. software is process
  39. 39. control the software control the process
  40. 40. influence the software influence the process
  41. 41. ATIP PROCESS DISTRIBUTION POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT INVESTIGATIONS BLACK BOX PROCUREMENT Rules, Processes & Culture OPEN BY DEFAULT EASY TO ACCESS
  42. 42. sometimes comment on this ATIP PROCESS report about this DISTRIBUTION POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT INVESTIGATIONS BLACK BOX PROCUREMENT Rules, Processes & Culture OPEN BY DEFAULT EASY TO ACCESS write about this
  43. 43. auditing books to spreadsheets to systems
  44. 44. auditing books to spreadsheets to systems
  45. 45. auditing books to spreadsheets to systems
  46. 46. <4> ideas
  47. 47. 1. help define standards for procurement
  48. 48. ATIP PROCESS DISTRIBUTION POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT INVESTIGATIONS BLACK BOX PROCUREMENT Rules, Processes & Culture OPEN BY DEFAULT EASY TO ACCESS
  49. 49. understand our assumptions act policies standards
  50. 50. open data as pre-approved systems
  51. 51. why not for some document creation processes?
  52. 52. why not for some document creation processes? procurement buyandsell.gc.ca
  53. 53. 2. Create your open data on response times
  54. 54. build power
  55. 55. 64
  56. 56. 3. open data
  57. 57. assess openness of data especially regulatory data
  58. 58. Wonderful Case Study • • • 2006-2012 spills $4000 eventually 711 pages of printed records ($262) • months to convert • run around • Energy Resources Conservation Board ($367) • Alberta Township System not Lat/Long ($1000 to convert)
  59. 59. 3. there is an opportunity for a broader tent
  60. 60. not just government not just reporters
  61. 61. hello!: programmers/ developers archivists librarians bloggers CIOs technologists
  62. 62. access gov20
  63. 63. access gov20 accountability leverage
  64. 64. find common interests
  65. 65. speed reliability persistence accountability leverage accessibility
  66. 66. We need a new act
  67. 67. - eliminates the joke of access summaries -respects today’s expectations of access - compels government to rethink how it creates and manages documents and data - makes new assumptions about the stack it is on, and what the stack SHOULD be.
  68. 68. @daeaves david@eaves.ca www.eaves.ca This work is copyrighted using Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 You may share and remix this work on the condition that you attribute the work to its original author.
  69. 69. ATIP PROCESS DISTRIBUTION POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT STORAGE/ARCHIVE ARCHIVES HARD DRIVES EMAIL INTERNAL USAGE DOCUMENT CREATION PROCUREMENT POLITICAL/SECURITY ASSESSMENT
  70. 70. ATIP PROCESS STORAGE/ARCHIVE INTERNAL USAGE DOCUMENT CREATION PROCUREMENT

×