Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
ETIS09 - Black Swans and White Elephants - Presentation
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.

×
Saving this for later? Get the SlideShare app to save on your phone or tablet. Read anywhere, anytime – even offline.
Text the download link to your phone
Standard text messaging rates apply

ETIS09 - Black Swans and White Elephants - Presentation

504
views

Published on

Published in: Technology, Business

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
504
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
8
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

Report content
Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. Black Swans & White Elephants Return On Investment In Business Intelligence David M Walker Data Management & WarehousingETIS ‒ Istanbul ‒ Oct 09
  • 2. !"#$%&(&)&*"+#,"&#!  -."%/(%,0&1","0+$%"$+"2#("*03$0#"#4""516"&17(/0& 6&*"+#,"&#(%#(1(,.0%"#4""516"&17(/0&$,8"%(/ 269"%"&#6&*"+#,"&#+:;(1031$30#"!<)=#4"8"&">#?%"#$%&@(/ 0&6&*"+#,"&#6+26*62"287#4"1(+#(/#4"6&*"+#,"&#A#4" %"+$3#6+"B.%"++"20+0."%1"&#0C"(%0%0#6(:!  ;4"%"#$%&(&6&*"+#,"&#/(%,$30D !"#$%$&()*$+,-.$#*/012.0*2$3$4-12$-+$#*/012.0*25$ 4-12$-+$#*/012.0*2$!  !"#$%&(&6&*"+#,"&#6+0*"%7.(.$30%,"#%618"10$+"(/6#+ *"%+0#636#70&2+6,.3616#7:;40#6+=6/0&6&*"+#,"&#2("+&(#40*" 0.(+6#6*"!<)=(%6/#4"%"0%"(#4"%(..(%#$&6#6"+E6#4046C4"% !<)=#4"&#4"6&*"+#,"&#+4($32&(#8"$&2"%#0F"&:
  • 3. G(E4"%"0%"#4"!<)H"#%61+I!  J3"0%37*03$6&CK)6+&(#0&"B01#+16"&1"0&2(/#"&1(,"+2(E& #(,6&2+"#:J(,.0%6&CK)#(01(33"C""2$10#6(&D)#,078" "B."&+6*"0&2#6,"L1(&+$,6&C=8$##4"%"0%",0&73"++ #0&C683"8"&">#+=36F"6&1%"0+"2"0%&6&C.(E"%0&2(*"%033 6,.%(*"2M$036#7(/36/"=E46141(,"7"0%+30#"%:!  )#N+&(#"0+7#(."%+$02"+(,"(&"#(C(#(1(33"C"80+"2(&0 .$%"37>&0&1603(%&$,8"%+C0,"=0&2#4"+0,"#46&CC("+/(% K):O($P$+#40*"#(8"36"*"#40#K)6+08+(3$#"37"++"&#603/(%7($ 0+0&(%C0&6Q0#6(&#(6&*"+#=#40##46+6+0/$&20,"&#031(%" 1(,."#"&17#40#7($40*"#(40*": K633R(+#,0&&=S61"T%"+62"&#U-&037+#=V0%#&"%=H0%14WXXY
  • 4. Z40#6+V((2K)I!  V((2K)6+#4"/$+6(&(/#4"%6C4#6&/(%,0#6(&=#4"%6C4##6,"= #4"%6C4#/(%,0#=0&2#4"%6C4#4$,0&0&2[(%+7+#",%"+($%1"+: )/E"E6+4#(6,.%(*"K)=E"0+F#4"+"M$"+#6(&+D !  (8$+6&"++$+"%+40*"#4"6&/(%,0#6(&&""2"2=E4"&#4"7&""26#= #(,0F"2"16+6(&+I !  (#4(+"."(.3"40*"#4""B."%#6+"=#%06&6&C0&2,6&2+"##($+" #40#6&/(%,0#6(&6&#4"8"+#E07/(%#4"C((2(/#4"(%C0&6Q0#6(&I !  -%"#4"72(6&C#4"6%P(88"##"%8"10$+"(/#4"6&/(%,0#6(&8"6&C 2"36*"%"2I !  R(E,$14269"%"&1"2("+#40#6&/(%,0#6(&,0F"#(#4",I (%(#47H633"%=K)H"#%61+=]"8WXX^!  ;4"8"+#0..%(014#("*03$0#6&C0K)+(3$#6(&6+0#"14&6103 %"*6"E1(,86&"2E6#408$+6&"++$+"%."%1".#6(&+$%*"7
  • 5. T%(.(+6#6(&!  _((%C0&6+0#6(&40+"*"%2"36*"%"2#4"!<)(%6C6&0337 .%(,6+"2D !  ;4"8$+6&"++40+,(*"2(&6&#4"#6,"6##0F"+#(2"*"3(. #4"?(%6C6&03@+(3$#6(&,"0&6&C#40##4"*03$"40+26,6&6+4"2 !  ;4"86CC"+#C06&+0&23(++"+40*"1(,"/%(,K301FGE0&+ 0&2&(#.30&&"2"*"&#+ !  ;4"86CC"+#1(+#+40*"1(,"/%(,Z46#"`3".40&#+0&2#4" /063$%"#(%"1(C&6+"E4"%"#4"1(+#+0%"4622"&!  G(,"?,06&37#4(+"46C4371(,,6##"2#(K)@40*"/0% "B1""2"2#4".%(,6+"2!<)8$#,(+#/063#(0146"*"6# !  `*"&6/#4"2"*"3(.,"&#1(+#+0%"(&8$2C"##4"(&LC(6&C <T`a1(+#+0%"4622"&0&2/0%($#LE"6C4#4"#4"8"&">#
  • 6. K301FGE0&+!  R6C4L6,.01#=40%2L#(L.%"261#=0&2%0%""*"&#+8"7(&2#4"%"03, (/&(%,03"B."1#0#6(&+!  ;4"#"%,K301FGE0&1(,"+/%(,#4"bc#41"&#$%7`$%(."0& 0++$,.#6(&#40#N-33+E0&+0%"E46#"N:)&#40#1(&#"B#=08301F +E0&E0+0+7,8(3(/+(,"#46&C#40#E0+6,.(++683"(%1($32 &(#"B6+#:)&#4"bY#4J"&#$%7=#4"26+1(*"%7(/8301F+E0&+6& Z"+#"%&-$+#%0360,"#0,(%.4(+"2#4"#"%,#(1(&&(#"#40#0 ."%1"6*"26,.(++68636#7,0701#$03371(,"#(.0++:
  • 7. K301FGE0&+D T%(2$1#H0+#"%0#0!  0#0Z0%"4($+"%"M$6%","&#+2"36*"%"2!  0#0Z0%"4($+"0&037+6+62"&#6>"+&(,0&0C","&#(/.%(2$1# ,0+#"%20#00&2&(.%(2$1#,0+#"%36+#!  T%(P"1#%6+F%06+"20&2"+1030#"2#("B"1$#6*"3"*"3!  K)T%(P"1#.(+#.(&"20&2+#09%"L#0+F"2#(2">&"0&22"36*"% J(%.(%0#"T%(2$1#HH!  ),.3","&#+`!T80+"2HH+(3$#6(&0&2%"2$1"+.%(2$1# 10#03(C$"87^Xd!  6%"1#3709"1#+1(%.(%0#"8(##(,36&"!  !"+#0%#+K)T%(P"1#+6B,(&#4+30#"%E6#4,0++6*"376,.%(*"2 20#0M$036#70&220#06&#"C%0#6(&
  • 8. K301FGE0&+D ]6&0&1603!".(%#6&C!  ;"31(6&(#J(,8((,1(&+6+#"&#37(*"%+#0#"+"0%&6&C+0&2 +$8+1%68"%C%(E#4#(8((+#+40%".%61"!  0#0Z0%"4($+".%(P"1#62"&#6>"+6++$"0&2.%(2$1"+0+"#(/ 1(%%"1#&$,8"%+!  K$+6&"++%"/$+"+#(02P$+#+#0#$#(%7%".(%#6&C0+#4"740*"8""& $+6&C#4"e`B1"3f&$,8"%+=6#E($328"",80%%0++6&C#(%"+#0#" #4">C$%"+0&2#4"&"E(&"+0%"P$+##((269"%"&#!  K$+6&"++1(330.+"+0&26+#0F"&(*"%=&0#6(&03&"E+.0."%+ %".(%##40#e6&#"%&03+7+#",+f402#4"1(%%"1#>C$%"+!  ;4"/063$%"#($+"%"0320#0E0+46C436C4#"2870$26#(%+0+0 +6C&6>10&#/01#(%6&#4".((%2"16+6(&+,02"87,0&0C","&#
  • 9. K301FGE0&+D ;4"G03"+,0&]%0$2!  G$..36"%(/1(&/"1#6(&0%7#(0,0P(%+$."%,0%F"#1406&!  ]6%+#!"3"0+"(/0#0Z0%"4($+"!  J`<E0+$&L40..7E6#4#4"&$,8"%+/%(,#4"&"E+7+#", !  R"F&"E#40##4"+$."%,0%F"#E0+#4"6%86CC"+#1$+#(,"%!  );2"/"&2"2#4"0#0Z0%"4($+" !  `*"%730+#3(026&C+#".0&2#%0&+/(%,0#6(&4028""&#"+#"2U14"1F"2!  -G03"+,0&f+1(,,6++6(&2($83"2/(%#4">%+#M$0%#"%(&&"E 011($&#+8"/(%"2%(..6&C#(+#0&20%2%0#"6&+$8+"M$"&#M$0%#"%+!  ;4"G03"+,0&%"+.(&+683"/(%#4"+$."%,0%F"#1406&1%"0#"20&"E 1$+#(,"%"014M$0%#"%!  J(%.(%0#"%"*"&$"+09"1#"2"&($C4/(%0&"B140&C">36&C
  • 10. K301FGE0&+D `B#"%&03J(330.+"!  G$22"&,0%F"#1(330.+"!  H0&71$+#(,"%++$22"&37140&C".%(>3" !  g((F6&C/(%*03$"h3(E"%+."&2!  K"T%(L01#6*" !  -&(..(%#$&6#7#(2",(&+#%0#"#4"#%$"*03$"(/K) !  ?)#,6C4#+0*"7($%P(8#((i@
  • 11. Z46#"`3".40&#+!  -E46#""3".40&#6+0*03$083".(++"++6(&(/E46146#+(E&"% 10&&(#26+.(+"0&2E4(+"1(+#?.0%#61$30%371(+#(/$.F"".@6+ ($#(/.%(.(%#6(&#(6#+$+"/$3&"++:!  ;4"#"%,2"%6*"+/%(,#4"+01%"2E46#""3".40&#+F".#87 G($#4"0+#-+60&%$3"%+:;(.(++"++0E46#""3".40&#E0+?0&2 +#6336+@%"C0%2"20+0+6C&#40##4",(&0%14E0+%$36&CE6#4 P$+#61"0&2.(E"%=0&2#40##4"F6&C2(,E0+83"++"2E6#4 ."01"0&2.%(+."%6#7:;4"0&6,03+E"%"1(&+62"%"2+01%"20&2 30E+.%(#"1#"2#4",/%(,308($%=%"1"6*6&C0C6/#(/0E46#" "3".40&#/%(,0,(&0%14E0+8(#4083"++6&C0&201$%+"D0 83"++6&C8"10$+"#4"0&6,03E0++01%"20&20+6C&(/#4" ,(&0%14N+/0*($%=0&201$%+"8"10$+"#4"0&6,03402#(8" F".#0&21($32&(#8".$##(.%01#6103$+"#((9+"##4"1(+#(/ ,06&#06&6&C6#:
  • 12. Z46#"`3".40&#+ J(&*"&#6(&(*"%J(&>C$%0#6(&!  K0&FE6#4"B6+#6&C20#0E0%"4($+"!  `B#"&+6(&#(+$..(%#K030&1"2G1(%"10%2!  Z0&#"2#($+"0269"%"&#20#0,(2"336&C#"14&6M$"6&#4"+0,"20#0 E0%"4($+"/(%#4"&"E"3","&#+!  j$+#6>"20+0,0&0C","&#2"16+6(&8"10$+"kE"10&f#09(%2#(%"L 2"*"3(.#4"(32,(2"38$#E"E0&##4"8"+##"14&6M$"/(%#4"&"E.0%#+l!  !"+$3#0&#,(2"31($32+6,.37&(#8"$+"2!  e<&!063+f !  S03$"+k!OL(&f#%"."0#7($%+"3/lUkJ(&*"&#6(&(*"%1(&>C$%0#6(&l !  m+""0141(,.(&"&#6&01(&+6+#"&#E07 !  -62+m&2"%+#0&26&C0&2!"2$1"+H06&#"&0&1" !  m+""0141(,.(&"&#/(%#4".$%.(+"6#E0+6&#"&2"2
  • 13. Z46#"`3".40&#+D _(#"*03$0#6&C#"14&(3(C7!  G"1(&2V"&"%0#6(&0#0Z0%"4($+"K$632 !  `B6+#6&C.30#/(%,,0P(%!KHG !  !"1(,,"&2"2+(3$#6(&DJ(,.(&"&#6+"20%146#"1#$%"E6#446C4 ."%/(%,0&1"20#080+""&C6&"0&2+6,.3"`;g0%146#"1#$%" 2"*"3(."287+,0336&4($+"#"0, !  J4(+"&+(3$#6(&D`B6+#6&C!KHG*"&2(%E6#4#6C4#371($.3"2`;g #((3/%(,0269"%"&#*"&2(%0&2,0P(%G)2(6&C2"*"3(.,"&#(& +6#"hk8"10$+"#40#f+#4"E07E"2(6#4"%"0&2,0&0C","&# E(&f#1(&+62"%0&7#46&C"3+"l !  J$%%"&#6++$"+D !  J(&+62"%"2#((1(+#370&26+8"6&C2"36*"%"230#" !  -3%"02740*6&C#(%"*6"E#"14&(3(C714(61"+8"10$+"(/ ."%/(%,0&1"6++$"+8"/(%"%(33L($#1(,.3"#" !  G)40+3"/##0F6&C033#4"F&(E3"2C"E6#4#4",
  • 14. Z46#"`3".40&#+D H0F6&C0&`;gZ46#"`3".40&#!  `B6+#6&C20#0E0%"4($+"6&."%+(&03>&0&1"1(,.0&7E6#40 `;g3(028$63#/%(,Gng+1%6.#+0&20+4"33+1%6.#0&2#6C4# 1(&#%(3*60GS_6&.%(2$1#6(&/(%o7"0%+!  _"E);6%"1#(%1(,,6++6(&+%"*6"E87*"&2(%#40# %"1(,,"&2+#4"*"&2(%+`;g#((3/(%mGpqXXr!  G6BH(&#4+=qJ(&+$3#0&#+smGpb:tr."%207 ?0#(#03+."&2umGpvXXr@30#"%w !  -33`;g1(&*"%#"2 !  !$&+WXd+3(E"% !  <#4"%K)2"*"3(.,"&#+2"307"2E463+#140&C"+,02"!  "","2;<<`aT`_G)S`#(%"*"%#801F !  `*"&#$0337%"*"%#"2801FbW,(&#4+30#"%E4"&*"&2(%M$(#"2/(% $.C%02"#(+7+#",
  • 15. Z46#"`3".40&#+D K%"0F6&C0&`;gZ46#"`3".40&#!  )&#"%01#6*"H"2601(%.(%0#6(&,(*"+/%(,#%026#6(&03!KHG#( 1(,,(26#70..360&1"#"14&(3(C7!  0#0S(3$,"+2($836&C"*"%7+6B,(&#4+!  )&#"%&03!"*6"E !  `;g#((3+10&f#40&23"3(02 !  `;g"B."%#+#(("B."&+6*"/(%3(&C#"%,"&C0C","&#+ !  Gng+1%6.#+10&8"2"*"3(."287,(%"%"+($%1"+ !  Gng+1%6.#+033(E,(%"E(%F#(8"2(&"6&#4"0..360&1" !  Gng+1%6.#+033(E,(%"0C63"0..%(014 !  Gng+1%6.#+033(E#6C4#"%140&C",0&0C","&#!  _"E0%146#"1#$%"1(,.(&"&#6+"2=1(,,(26#780+"2E6#4+6,.3" +1%6.#"&C6&"%"2$1"+1(+#+87^Xd0&26&1%"0+"2.%(2$1#6*6#787 bXXd
  • 16. Z46#"`3".40&#+D ;4"<T`a#%0.!  K)T%(P"1#+1(,,0&24"0236&"J-T`a8$2C"#>C$%"+!  K)T%(P"1#+0%"E62"37.$83616+"22$%6&C2"*"3(.,"&#!  H(+#(/#4",(&"76++."&#6&<T`a !  )#1(,"+/%(,m+"%G$..(%#=;%06&6&C=J40&C"+0&2 <."%0#6(&03G$..(%# !  )#6+&(%,0337WBLoB0&2(/#"&tB,(%"#40&#4"1(+#(/#4" 8$632(*"%#4"36/"#6,"(/#4"+7+#", !  )#6+4622"&h+.%"02(*"%,$3#6.3"8$2C"#+6&+$140E07#40# 6#6+40%2#("*03$0#"0&2(/#"&6C&(%"2!  -&701#6(&?"+."160337#01#610301#6(&+@6&#4"8$632[#"+# +#0C"#40#E633%"+$3#6&6&1%"0+"2<T`a6+2"0237#(!<)
  • 17. Z46#"`3".40&#+ ;4"_"E!".(%#6&C;((3!  0#0Z0%"4($+"G"1(&2V"&"%0#6(&K$632 !  _"E.%(P"1#h&"E6&#"%/01"1(&1".# !  J$%%"&#+7+#",$+"%+E"%"e$&L40..7fE6#4#4""B6+#6&C#((3 !  ;4"%"036#7E0+30%C"376++$"+E6#4#4"20#0,(2"30&220#0 M$036#7(/#4"1$%%"&#+7+#", !  !".301"2E6#40&"M$6*03"&#%".(%#6&C#((3!  ;4"1(+# !  !"#%06&6&C(/(*"%WXXX+#09 !  ]063$%"#(2"L1(,,6++6(&(32%".(%#6&C#((3 !  tXd#((,0&7361"&1"+8($C4#/(%#4"&"E#((3 !  m+"%26++0#6+/01#6(&E6#4#4"?&"E@%".(%#6&C#((3
  • 18. Z46#"`3".40&#+D !".(%#6&C;((3T"&"#%0#6(&!  K$+6&"++6&#"336C"&1"*"&2(%+ !  _6C"3T"&2+"(/K)G$%*"7 36F"#(#03F$.0WX[YX+.36#D +4(E+P$+#(*"%Y."%1"&#(/ ",.3(7""+0%"01#$0337$+6&C (&37WX."%1"&#(/$+"%+0%" K)#((3+: 01#$03371(&+$,6&CK) #"14&(3(C6"+A#4"%",06&6&C !  `*"&6&6&2$+#%6"+#40#40*" YX."%1"&#0%" 0CC%"++6*"3702(.#"2K)#((3+ ?":C:=E4(3"+03"=80&F6&C=0&2 26+"&/%0&146+"2: %"#063@=$+0C"80%"37"B1""2+ bb."%1"&#:!  !"0+(&+ !  G"1$%6#736,6#0#6(&+ !  R0%2E0%"1(+# !  0#00*06308636#7 !  G3(EM$"%7."%/(%,0&1" !  G(/#E0%"1(+# !  )&#"%&03.(36#61+0&2 !  G(/#E0%"E0+#((40%2#( ?,(%".%"16+"37@6&#"%&03 $+" .(E"%+#%$CC3"+ !  m+"%+10308636#7
  • 19. Z46#"`3".40&#+D _(##"+#6&C#4"2"36*"%7!  -&72"36*"%740++#0C"+ !  !"M$6%","&#+[-&037+6+["+6C&[K$632[;"+#[".3(7"#1:!  `*"%7+#0C"10&40*"#"+#+0++(160#"2E6#46# !  !"M$6%","&#+DH6&2`B."%6,"&#H"#4(2 !  -&037+6+DJ%(++L14"1F6&CE6#4(#4"%+($%1"+ !  "+6C&D-3C(%6#4,61J4"1F+ !  K$632Dm&6#;"+#+[K($&20%7J4"1F6&C !  ;"+#6&CDG7+#",;"+#+[)&#"C%0#6(&;"+#!  ;"+#"0%370&2(/#"& !  ]6B6&C+(,"#46&Cb+#0C"30#"%xWB,(%""B."&+6*" !  ]6B6&C+(,"#46&CW+#0C"+30#"%xqB,(%""B."&+6*"="#1:!  H0&7,(%"+,033#"+#+."%/(%,"2"0%37E633+0*"4$C"0,($&#+(/#6,"0&2,(&"7 !  R0*"#(40&23"+4(%##"%,+36..0C"+ !  )/7($40*"&f#C(##6,"#(#"+##4"&7($0%".30&&6&C#(+."&2<T`a!  H0++6*"$+"%."%1".#6(&6,.01#0+6&/(%,0#6(&6+%6C4#>%+##6,"
  • 20. Z46#"`3".40&#+ V0%80C")&DDV0%80C"<$#e<&#E((110+6(&+)40*"8""&0+F"2yT%07=H%:K0880C"=6/7($.$#6&#(#4",0146&"E%(&C >C$%"+=E633#4"%6C4#0&+E"%+1(,"($#Iyw)0,&(#083"%6C4#37#(0..%"4"&2#4"F6&2(/ 1(&/$+6(&(/62"0+#40#1($32.%(*(F"+$140M$"+#6(&:fhJ40%3"+K0880C"bc^bLbYcb!  0#0n$036#76+,(%"1%6#6103#40&"*"%!  -/063$%"#(022%"++0#0n$036#70#"*"%7+#0C"E63303E07+ 3"02#(0226#6(&031(+#+!  T30&/(%7($%K).%(P"1##(+.6&(9!"#$%&(/20#0M$036#7 .%(P"1#+0&21(&#6&$"#(2(+(#4%($C4($#6#+36/"!  0#0n$036#76++$"+2%6*"$+"%+0E07E461426%"1#37 6&1%"0+"+1(+#(/(E&"%+46.0&2%"2$1"+!<)
  • 21. Z46#"`3".40&#+D "L1(,,6++6(&i!  0#0Z0%"4($+"J(,.(&"&#"36*"%"2 !  "L1(,,6++6(&#4".%"*6($+%".(%#6&C+7+#", !  _<L!`-ggOL;m!_);<]]i!  )/6#6+3"/#(&D !  )#1(+#+,(&"7#(%$&?0&26#6+0336&*6+683"<T`a@ !  m+"%+E6331(,.0%"%"+$3#+0&226+#%$+##4"&"E+7+#","*"& 6/6#10&8".%(*"2#(8",(%"1(%%"1##40&#4"(32+7+#", !  m+"%+E6331(&#6&$"#($+"#4"(32(&"8"10$+"6#6+/0,6360% 0&2&(L(&"36F"+140&C" !  m+"%+#40#2(&(#,6C%0#"8$#40*"8""&#%06&"2(&#4"&"E +7+#",E63340*"#(8"%"L#%06&"2E4"&#4"7+#0%##($+"6#
  • 22. ;4"G(3$#6(&!  ;4".%(.(+6#6(&+$CC"+#+#40#2(6&CK)40+&(#2"36*"%"2 #4""B."1#"2!<)/(%,(+#(%C0&6+0#6(&+:!  ("+#46+,"0&#40#(%C0&6+0#6(&++4($32+#(.2"*"3(.6&C K)+(3$#6(&+I!  J0#"C(%610337_<hK)+4($328"4$C"37E(%#4E463"!  K$#%",",8"%7($10&(&37+$11""26/D !  O($%(%C0&6+0#6(&/$337",8%01"+K$+6&"++)&#"336C"&1" !  O($"B."1#0&2",8%01"K301FGE0&+ !  O($0*(620&2,6#6C0#"Z46#"`3".40&#+ !  O($,0F"7($%(E&3$1F
  • 23. R(E#(8"3$1F7!  g$1F7."(.3"/%"M$"&#3740.."&$.(&140&1"(..(%#$&6#6"+ !  ;4"%"0%".(+6#6*"8301F+E0&+6&"*"%7(%C0&6Q0#6(&=6#6+P$+#0,0##"%(/62"&#6/76&C #4",0+#4"7(11$%!  g$1F7."(.3"36+#"&#(#4"6%4$&14"+ !  H",8"%+(/7($%#"0,E63340*"6&+6C4#+8"7(&2#4"6%%",6#80+"2(&#4"6% "B."%6"&1"=62"&#6/7#4"+"."(.3"0&2"B.3(6##4"6%6&+6C4#+!  g$1F7."(.3"."%+"*"%"6&#4"/01"(//063$%" !  `*"%7.%(P"1#E633/01"+"#L801F+L.30&/(%#4",!  g$1F7."(.3"40*"#4"08636#7#(#$%&8023$1F6&#(C((2/(%#$&" !  `*"%7.%(P"1#E633/01"+"#L801F+L",8%01"#4",0+0&(..(%#$&6#70&2140&C"7($% .%(P"1#[%",6#0&2%"+"#7($%C(03+ K0+"2(&E(%F87T%(/:!6140%2Z6+",0&=m&6*"%+6#7(/R"%#/(%2+46%"=WXXo
  • 24. ),.%(*6&C!<)!  K301F+E0&+?40&23"2.(+6#6*"37@(&&)*$+,6&1%"0+" V06&/%(,6&*"+#,"&#!  Z46#""3".40&#+?"36,6&0#"2@&)-%)./(%0+,%"2$1"#4" J(+#(/#4")&*"+#,"&#!  Z40#"*"%#4"J-T`a6&*"+#,"&#(/#4".%(P"1# #4"<T`aE6338"+6C&6>10&#37,(%"h2"+6C&/(%#46+
  • 25. Black Swans & White Elephants Return On Investment In Business IntelligenceTHANK YOU
  • 26. Black Swans & White Elephants Return On Investment In Business IntelligenceBI Environment BenchmarkOctober 2009
  • 27. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  ("+7($%(%C0&6+0#6(&40*"#4"08636#7#( !  !"1(C&6+"K301FGE0&+I !  -*(62K$6326&CZ46#"`3".40&#+I!  ;4"K"&14,0%F3((F+0##4"F"7+#(+$11"++ !  ;"14&(3(C7[!"+($%1"+[H"#4(2+[T%"261#6(&+!  -++"++E4"#4"%7($10&,""#-gg(/#4"/(33(E6&C !  )/7($10&f#,""#0&6#",6#6+1(+#6&C7($,(&"7 !  (&f#6C&(%"0+#0#","&#P$+#8"10$+"7($2(&f#0C%""E6#46#
  • 28. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  ;"31(`&*6%(&,"&# !  H$+#R0*"+ !  bXH#(qXH+$8+1%68"%+ !  !`-g1(,,6#,"&#/%(, !  H(863"(%]6B"2 `B"1$#6*";"0,#( K$+6&"++)&#"336C"&1" !  Z62".(%#/(36((/S-G !  T%(2$1#6(&=;"+#U !  0#0#%051($#+#%6..6&C "*"3(.,"&# C%(E#46&*(61"+"%*61"+ `&*6%(&,"&# !  V0,"140&C6&C2"*61"+ !  J(,.(&"&#6+"2 -%146#"1#$%" !  czWqG$..(%# !  H6&:c7"0%36/"+.0&
  • 29. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  R0%2E0%"U0#080+"1(,86&"2 !  T073"++#40&mGpWXr."%;"%087#"(/m+"%0#0z!  `;gU0#0n$036#7;((3+ !  T073"++#40&mGpbXXr/(%#4".%(2$1#361"&1"+!  !".(%#6&C;((3+ !  T073"++#40&mGpbX."%+"0#/(%#4".%(2$1#361"&1"+ !  !"2$1"361"&1"1($&#87tXd(%6&1%"0+"$+"%#0F"$.87tXd !  S"&2(%+1306,361"&1"+(/0%($&2WXd(/(%C0&6+0#6(&+ !  eK)G$%*"7f%"+"0%14+4(E+#40#02(.#6(&6+#7.610337cLYd zH(&0+4!"+"0%14K"&14,0%F]6C$%"
  • 30. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  T%(C%0,H0&0C","&# !  !".(%#6&C`&*6%(&,"&# !  T%(P"1#H0&0C"% !  ;"0,g"02"% !  ;"14&6103-%146#"1# !  oLq];`/(%O"0%b !  WLo];`0/#"%E0%2+!  K$+6&"++-&037+#+ !  ;"0,g"02"% !  `;g"*"3(."%+ !  oLq];`z/(%O"0%b !  ;"0,g"02"% !  WLo];`0/#"%E0%2+ !  oLq];`!  K-[G7+-2,6&G$..(%# !  ;"+#;"0, !  ;"0,g"02"% !  ;"0,g"02"% !  bLW];` !  WLo];` -1(,,6#,"&#(/8"#E""&bc0&2Wq."(.3"/(%c7"0%+i z];`x]$33;6,"`M$6*03"&#
  • 31. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  G$11"++/$30#0Z0%"4($+"[K$+6&"++)&#"336C"&1".%(P"1#+ E63340*"D !  -C63"T%(P"1#H0&0C","&#H"#4(2+ !  !6C62J40&C"J(&#%(3 !  "#063"2;0+F[!6+F[)++$";%01F6&C !  Z"33">&"2J(,.(&"&#6+"2-%146#"1#$%" !  ;4"08636#7#(+E0.*"&2(%+M$61F370&2"0+637 !  `0141(,.(&"&#.%(*626&C08301F8(B+"%*61" !  (&f#",8"2/$&1#6(&036#76&#4"E%(&C.301" !  ":C:0#06&7($%`;g#((3
  • 32. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  G40%"2<."&(1$,"&#H0&0C","&#G7+#",!  "#063"2`B1".#6(&!".(%#6&C/(%,"#020#0 !  g(02;6,"+[n$"%7;6,"+[0#0n$036#7[Gg-!  cX[oX+.36#(/6&#"%&03%"+($%1"+#("B#"%&03%"+($%1"+!  ]6B"21(+#%"+($%1"+ !  ;4"%"+($%1"+2"+1%68"2E633,0&0C"0+,033"&*6%(&,"&#0&2 E63303+(8"083"#(1(."E6#40,$1486CC"%(&"E6#4($#140&C" !  ;((/"E%"+($%1"+E(&f#8"083"#(,""#2",0&2 !  ;((,0&7%"+($%1"+E(&f#8"083"#(1(,,$&610#"
  • 33. !<);0%C"#`&*6%(&,"&# K"&14,0%Fh<1#(8"%WXX^!  ;46&C+#(E0#14 !  )&*"+#6&1(,.(&"&#6+0#6(&_<Zh6#10&&(#E06# !  `B."1#H0.!"2$1"#"14&(3(C7#(8",$14,(%"6,.(%#0&# !  <."&G($%1"#"14&(3(C6"+#(40*"+$8+#0&#603,0%F"#+40%" !  -&"EC"&"%0#6(&(/E62"L+103"3(EL1(+#6&/(%,0#6(&2".3(7,"&# ,"140&6+,+E6330.."0% !  H(%"e<&!063+f*"&2(%+E4(40*""&2#("&2,"#4(2(3(C7!  <*"%#4"&"B#W7"0%+ !  0#0*(3$,"+#(C($.87WXXd !  p[;8#(2%(.87tXd !  n$"%7+.""2E6338"ubXXB/0+#"%#40&+#0&20%2!KHG !  ctd(/#4"&"E*"&2(%+#(26+0.."0%
  • 34. Black Swans & White Elephants Return On Investment In Business IntelligenceBI Environment Benchmark Thank You

×