ELICITATION TECHNIQUES David Nunan Ulatni: Rodesa O. Lajada
Elicit mulasawikipedia To bring or draw out (something latent); To arrive at (a truth, for example) by logic. To call forth, draw out, or provoke (a reaction, for example).
Elicitation A range of procedures for obtaining speech samples and other data subjects. Such procedures may range from the administration of standardized tests through to questionnaires and interviews
1.2 Question Wording Questions should not be complex and confusing, nor should they ask more than one thing at a time
Example from Cohen and Mannion (1985: 105- 107)
Would you prefer a short, non-award course (3,4, or 5 sessions) with part-day release (e.g. Wednesday afternoon) and one evening per week attendance with financial reimbursement for travel or a longer, non-award course (6,7, or 8 sessions) with full day release, or the whole course designed on part-time release without evening attendance?
(from an oral proficiency interview) Interviewer: Where is your mother? What does your mother do? Subject: She’s dead? Interviewer: Ah- she’s dead. Very good. (van Lier 1989: 499)
Factors to be considered The willingness of respondents to make critical statements The willingness of respondents to discuss certain personal topics, such as age, salary, or opinions on political and social issues The shared values which can be assumed, for example, the concept of freedom of the press The attitudes which can be assumed, for example, the commonly held belief among many educators in Western countries that classroom learning should be a source of enjoyment for the learner
Reminder: Questionnaires must be: -constructed -piloted -administered before collating and interpreting the responses
1.3 Interpreting Responses Example: selected extracts from a study Nunan was involved in
‘State three beliefs you have about language development that determine the way you teach.’
Key Word Analysis(generating categories from the statements made by the respondents) Immersion Learning by doing/ experiential Language across the curriculum Grammar, structure, correctness Oral/ written language relationships Creation of rich, positive environment Etc.
Table 7.4Teachers Beliefs Aboutthe Nature of Language and Learning
1.4 Quantifying Qualitative Data -It should transpire that the relatively more experienced teachers made significantly more references to principles of language learning. Hypothesis- as teachers increase their mastery of technical aspects of instruction and knowledge of language. Their teaching practices become less dependent on local environmental and affective factors
1.4 Quantifying Qualitative Data (alternative way) Lincoln and Guba (1985) Place each individual entry onto library index cards. Select the first file from pile and place it on one side. Select the second card and make a determination on intuitive grounds whether it is ‘look-alike’ or represents a new category. Continue on successive cards Cards which are not fully recognized should be placed into a miscellaneous pile. They should not be discarded but should be retained for later review.
The elicitation of data by one person from another person through person-to-person encounters
Degree of Formality 1. unstructured
Guided by the responses of the interviewee rather than the agenda of the researcher
The interviewer has a general idea of where he or she wants the interview go, and what should come out of it, but does not enter the interview with a list of predetermined questions
Degree of Formality *advantages -it gives the interviewee a degree of power and control over the course of the interview -it gives the interviewer a great deal of flexibility -it gives one privileged access to other people live’s 3.structured
The agenda is totally predetermined by the researcher, who works through a list of set questions in a predetermined order
Bias inherent in most research method 1. In terms of oral interview- asymmetrical relationship between the participants 2. In terms of content- biographical factors such as gender and ethnicity can affect the validity and reliability of the research (Briggs, 1986) 3. In linguistic term the asymmetry will be reflected in the actual language used (van Lier, 1989)
Practical suggestions for planning and conducting interviews(recommended by Cohen and Manion, 1985) Preparing the interview schedule Piloting Selection of subjects Elements of the interview -briefing and explanation -questioning
Practical suggestions about the actual conduct of the interview(suggested by Walker, 1985) Physical positioning of the interviewer and interviewee The researcher must also decide how to interview is going to be recorded: *note-taking *tape-recording
Table 7.5Strengths and Weaknesses ofTape-recording and Note-taking