Danwei: a key to understanding social enterprise discourse and ambitions in China Revd Timothy Curtis Senior Lecturer in Social Entrepreneurship University of Northampton HEFCE/Unltd Ambassador for Social Entrepreneurship in Higher Education Project Manager, British Council Prime Minister’s Initiative Connect project Supported by
Philosophy Looking at social enterprise as a general response to inequity, exploitation and exclusion in the workplace Rather than a more narrow attempt to resolve specific social problems caused by the general conditions mentioned above Contrast European models of ‘economiesociale’ rather than American models. Should social enterprise be for the whole economy or just the tails of the normal probability curve
Unemployment in China An article published by the Chinese news agency Xinhua on 2 February 2004 reported that the number of new job seekers entering the labour market in China will be around 15 million people every year between 2003 and 2020. However, according to the article, only eight million jobs can be created annually, even if the economy maintains a growth rate of seven percent. Registered urban unemployment – 4.5% In the northern industrial areas, unemployment is at least as high as twenty percent. from 1997-2000 SOE jobs decreased by forty three million, and the private sector and non-state sector jobs increased by 16.5 million. The number of registered jobless people in cities is around eight million, and the total number of job seekers in urban areas is around twenty four million people At least 150 million rural Chinese make up the floating population
‘socialism with Chinese characteristics’ The actual control of assets and revenues by the danwei is so extensive that one might argue that the main form of property rights in China has long been "work unit ownership," rather than state ownership.
Special type of public In Chinese society, "public" (gong) is regarded as anything that is outside the private domain (si) of the individual or family. The state is not distinguished from the public: It is the public. However, the "minor public" of the danwei constituted a different kind of gong, which was in some ways at odds with the state, or "greater public."
Danwei -Work Unit tool of the state for organizing and controlling urban society allowed the Maoist state to monitor the political loyalty of its citizens limited the mobility of their employees. Without proper permission duly noted in their dossiers (dang'an), employees could only dream about a job transfer. constitute a "small society" (xiaoshehui) with little need for interunitexchanges.
Social Function of Danwei a horizontal "bundle of activities,“ secure jobs, affordable housing, inexpensive medical care, a range of subsidies for everything from transportation to nutrition, and generous retirement pensions Housing -Unlike in the Soviet Union, where urban housing was controlled by municipal governments, Chinese work units controlled 90 percent of urban public housing Despite recent changes in Chinese urban society, the Danweimay still be involved in matters of health, marriage, family, love relationships, studying abroad, etc. An individual belonged to a danwei, which was responsible for the political and social well-being of its members
Qiyedanwei or enterprise units. This category covers all units engaged in production or profit-making. According to one set of official figures, there were 316,875 units of this sort in 1990. 13 At the end of 1994, the enterprise units employed 113.7 million people. 14
Shiyedanwei, or nonproduction, nonprofit units. This designation includes scientific research institutes, educational institutions, as well as government- sanctioned social and professional organizations (e.g., the Consumer Rights Association), health services, cultural organizations, and athletic organizations. By official figures, as of 1995 there were more than 1.3 million units in this category. 15 This remains the largest of all three main types of units, employing more than 24 million people. 16 Before the fiscal reforms of the 1980s, the budgets of these units were allocated by the state ( Ministry of Finance). It has been shrinking because of the conversion of many shiyedanwei into self-supporting, profit-generating entities no longer dependent upon the state budget or subsidies.
Xingzhengdanwei or administrative units. In 1990, there were 253,587 such units. 18 At the end of 1994, 10 million people were employees of administrative units. 19 This category is often confused with shiyedanwei for an obvious reason: Administrative units are also nonproduction and nonprofit entities. Sometimes they are regarded as a subcategory of the shiyedanwei. But because administrative units have their own characteristics and involve state power, they should be treated as a separate type. Included under this rubric are government agencies, mass organizations (e.g., the Women's Federation, Communist Youth League, Federation of Trade Unions), and other organizations that receive regular budgets from the state.
Downsizing the danwei enterprises needing to make cuts in their workforce did so initially by getting rid of non-core or marginal employees, and then by persuading other, permanently employed workers to transfer to less secure forms of employment relationship with the work-unit. depended on the ability of local authorities to step in with basic social-security provision for former SOE workers who have lost their access to a wide range of welfare benefits along with their jobs. i.e. transfer of social security infrastructure out of the danwei to the state
Danwei were not perfect The state and enterprise institutions always distinguished between permanent, temporary and contract workers, between unionized and non-unionized labour, and sometimes between male and female workers or between older, more established employees and new, young entrants to the workforce, in an attempt to limit the proportion of the industrial workforce that was entitled to the most extensive welfare benefits and which enjoyed virtually unassailable security of employment for life the true ‘iron rice-bowl’ was only ever available to a minority of permanently employed, unionized state-sector workers at the biggest and most prosperous urban enterprises.
Unique features of ‘danwei’ for SE 1. Labour aspect --usually including the right to hire, fire, and arrange transfers to other units. A danwei controls the dossiers of its employees, which play a key role in personnel-related matters. Sometimes, however, even when a lower unit controls dossiers, important personnel decisions are made by its superior unit. 2. Spatial aspect (often in the form of a compound with living quarters physically separated from the outside by walls)--including residential housing, dining hall, health clinic, fleet of cars, and other basic service facilities. 4. Urban aspect. A rural commune or village was never regarded as a danwei. On the other hand, a state-owned industrial plant located in a rural area is considered a danwei. This reflects urban geographical notions of an urban cultural milieu even in rural areas (Pahl, 1965). Some danwei were so large that they constituted a city within a city (Li, 2005). 5. Social aspect. The danwei provides a ‘horizontal bundle’ of social infrastructure activities- health, education, employment, civil society- everything that pertains to ‘state’ provision in the west (and also in Soviet economies) were delivered in and through the danwei structure.
Conclusions? “The ‘little public’ of the danwei is a unique contribution to social enterprise theory” “The challenge to social enterprises and ethical, social purpose organizations, might be not just to focus on, and fix, one discrete social problem, but to be the unit through which all social infrastructure is delivered.”
Kowloon- total danwei!
References AIKEN, M. (2007) What is the role of social enterprise in finding, creating and maintaining employment for disadvantaged groups? , Cabinet Office: Office of the Third Sector. ANON (2008) Migrant workers in China. China Labour Bulletin. ARTHUR, L., KEENOY, T., CATO, M. S. & SMITH, R. (2006) Where is the ‘social’ in social enterprise? Third Annual Social Enterprise Conference June 22nd - 23rd 2006. London South Bank University. BJORKLUND, E. M. (1986) The Danwei: Socio-Spatial Characteristics of Work Units in China's Urban Society. Economic Geography, 62, 19-29 BRAY, D. (2005) Social space and governance in urban China: the danwei system from origin, Stanford, Calif, Stanford University Press. CURTIS, T. (2009a) The challenge of educating social entrepreneurs. Social Enterprise in the UK and China – A Comparative Perspective. Kettering, UK. CURTIS, T. (2009b) Educating Social Enterprise 社会企业教育. The International Symposium of Social Enterprise and Self-employment. Beijing, China. DEFOURNY, J. & NYSSENS, M. (2008 ) Social enterprise in Europe: recent trends and developments. Social Enterprise Journal, 4 202 - 228. HASSARD, J., MORRIS, J., SHEEHAN, J. & YUXIN, X. (2006) Downsizing the danwei: Chinese state-enterprise reform and the surplus labour question The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 17, 1441 - 1455. HE, S. & WU, F. (2009) China’s Emerging Neoliberal Urbanism: Perspectives from Urban Redevelopment. Antipode, 41, 282-304. HULGARD, L. (2008) Discourses of social entrepreneurship in the USA and Europe- variations of the same theme? 8th International Conference of ISTR. Barcelona. IRWIN., W. (2009) UK Case Study -英国经验, 'The motivations of social entrepreneurs to form social enterprises 'a study in the UK' 社会企业家创立社会企业的动因分析，来自英国的案例研究. The International Symposium of Social Enterprise and Self-employment. . Beijing, China. KENDALL, J. & KNAPP, M. (1995) A Loose and Baggy Monster. Boundaries, Definitions, and Typologies. IN SMITH, J. D., ROCHESTER, C. & HEDLEY, R. (Eds.) An Introduction to the Voluntary Sector. London, Routledge. KEPING, Y., BARTLETT, J., WEBB, M. & KAIJIE, D. (2008) Social Enterprise Overview: A UK and China Perspective. British Council. LEADBEATER, C. (1997) The Rise of the Social Entrepreneur, London, Demos. LEFEBVRE, H. (1984) The production of space, Oxford, Blackwell Publishing. LEUNG, A. S. (2002) Gender and career expeirence in mainland Chinese state-owned enterprises. Personnel Review, 31, 602-619. LI, L. & KLEINER, B. H. (2001) The legacy of 'Danwei' and job performance. Management Research News, 24, 57-66. LI, S.-M. (2005) From work-unit compounds to gated communities: housing inequality and residential segregation in transitional Beijing. IN MA, L. J. C. & WU, F. (Eds.) Restructuring the Chinese City: changing scoiety, economy and space. Abingdon, Oxon, Routledge. LÜ, X. & PERRY, E. J. (1997) Danwei: the changing Chinese workplace in historical and comparative perspective, London, ME Sharpe/Eastgate. MAWSON, A. (2008) The Social Entrepreneur: making communities work, London, Atlantic Books. NAUGHTON, B. (1997) Danwei: the economic foundations of a unique institution. IN LÜ, X. & PERRY, E. J. (Eds.) Danwei: the changing Chinese workplace in historical and comparative perspective. London, ME Sharpe/Eastgate. NICHOLLS, A. (2006) Introduction. IN NICHOLLS, A. (Ed.) Social entrepreneurship: new models of sustainable social change. oxford, Oxford University Press. NON-PROFIT INCUBATOR (2006) The general report of social enterprise in China: Executive Summary. British Council. PAHL, R. (1965) Urbs in rure: the metropolitan fringe in Hertfordshire. Geographical Papers 2. London, London School of Economics. RIDLEY-DUFF, R., BULL, M. & SEANOR, P. (forthcoming) Understanding Social Enterprise: Theory and Practice, London, Sage Publications. RIDLEY-DUFF, R. J. (2008) Social Enterprise as a Socially Rational Business. International Journal of Entrepreneurial Behaviour and Research, 14, 291-312. SEVIGNY, R., CHEN, S. & CHEN, E. Y. (2009) Personal experience of schizophrenia and the role of Danwei: A case study on 1990's Beijing. Cult Med Psychiatry, 33, 86-111. SHARPEN, C. (2006) Social enterprise under the microscope: Comparing and contrasting Green-Works and ReBoot. Social Enterprise Journal, 2, 101-113. SHEEHAN, J., MORRIS, J. & HASSARD, J. (2000) Redundancies in Chinese State Enterprises: A Research Report. Industrial Relations, 39, 486-501. SPRECKLEY, F. (1981) Social Audit - A Management Tool for Co-operative Working. Beechwood College. THOMPSON, P. & MCHUGH, D. (1995) Work organisations : a critical introduction, Basingstoke, Macmillan. WANG, D. & CHAI, Y. (2009) The jobs-housing relationship and commuting in Beijing, China: the legacy of Danwei. Journal of Transport Geography, 17, 30-38. XIE, Y., LAI, Q. & WU, X. (2009) Danwei and social inequality in contemporary urban China. Work and Organizationsin China Afterthirty Years of Transition. Bingley, UK, Emerald. YU, X. & ZHANG, Q. (2009) Development of social enterprises under China's market transition. 2nd EMES International Conference on Social Enterprise. Trento, Italy. ZHAO, M. (2006) Hybrid Grass-Root NGOs and Government-NGO Interaction: Implications for the Emergence of Social Enterprise in China. Third annual UK social enterprise research conference. London South Bank University.